The ones I agree with the most: Feathertail:She was one of the most kind cats I’ve ever read about in the series,Her and Crowfeather were one of my favorite ships and I was depressed when she passed,She would’ve been a kind and caring mother and would’ve always been there for her kits,She also saved the Tribe and her friends from Sharptooth! Bristlefrost:She was really kind,Even though her and RootSpring didn’t have kits it would’ve been amazing if they did,It hurt my heart when she died from saving ShadowSight from Ashfur and I just wished she would’ve survived and had kits. Sunstar:He cared so much about Moonflower and he was heart broken when she chose Stormtail and had Bluestar and Snowfur,He would’ve loved his kits and he would’ve loved Moonflower and he would also be a loyal father and mate.It killed me when he died- Ravenpaw,And Barley:Yes,Just yes! They would’ve been great parents and I wanted to see that and it also killed me when he died-.Same with Barley! Brambleberry:She was always there for Crookedstar,She was basically his second mom and she loved him more than his own mother did.She would’ve been a great mom. Thrushpelt:He was an amazing fake father to Mosskit,Stonefur and Mistystar and he would’ve been an amazing mate to Bkuestar as well if they had their own kits.He is own of my favorites for his kindness to Bluestar.❤
I was so happy when I saw thrushpelt as 1st- he's my favorite character and he deserved to be bluestar's mate. he was so amazing to mosskit, mistykit, and stonekit.
Silverstream would have been a good mother. She knew what it was like to grow up without one, so if she hadn't died in kitting, I believe she would have protected Stormfur and Feathertail more than any other queen in the nursery. And this may sound a bit strange, but hear me out. I believe Scourge would have been a great father. He'd protect and play with his kits and any other kits so their kithood didn't up like his.
I definitely agree with Silverstream, but not Scourge. I’m pretty sure he was the one who made the rule that kits couldn’t stay with their parents or siblings past a certain age.
@Claires_everyday_life That’s all true, but I don’t think he’d be a good parent at all still lol. He hates kits, and was fully willing to kill Violet, even ordering her siblings to kill her themselves. True he’s Firestars brother but none of them ever knew it, and I doubt he’d care since he hated his other siblings.
Scrouge probably would be trying to teach them to be tough and scary, and he would most likely be harsh on them so they weren’t bullied like he was when he was a kit.
Fr though! Shadowstar is the only founder, who physically cannot have descendants XD Moon Shadow died, as did two of his kits, as kits, then Sun Shadow died without, (as far as we know) having any descendants. I can get behind this list, especially Thrushpelt, I think that everyone can agree with Thrushpelt..
I did think of something, but since we have no canon evidence, I'm not so sure it should count. But, I guess it's possible that her's and Moon Shadow's parents had siblings, maybe they had kits, who maybe have descendents. But then again, I don't think cousins really count as "descendants" as much as just relatives, but, at least it's something, I guess? I choose to accept this as my canon, because the thought that she has no family is depressing... poor girl
I think it sounds a little bit cringe but i think MapleShade would have been a very good mother to her kits. I know she did very bad things, but because she was betrayed by every cat who loved, she wouldnt done that to her kits, because she knows how much it hurts. I think just because she was a little bit possesive and she loved maybe too much, i think she would have protect her kits with the price of her life, because they would have been the only ones who loved her. I think she was a good cat in her heart, but it happened so many bad things to her. She didnt deserve this
Okay, gonna start with BristleFrost!!!! -So at the moment I haven’t finished The Broken Code, but she sounds like she’d have been a great mother. Yes I spoiled her death for myself. Alr making our way up the family, FeatherTail! -She and CrowFeather would’ve been amazing. Seriously, her death was unfair. And, does anyone else believe she should get a super edition or at least novella called, ‘FeatherTail’s Love’? SilverStream! -FeatherTail’s mother, if SilverStream had survived her birthing she would’ve been an amazing mother, and I wish the Erin’s had had her live. She was the first major love interest connected by a main character (GrayStripe) I think she did the first major rescue scene (the river), and was one of the first major deaths. Alr! SilverStream’s mother, WillowBreeze! -I pity CrookedStar- who doesn’t? His mother neglected him after he broke his jaw, and then died. His father moved early to the elders den, and I’m pretty sure died soon after. Her last words (I checked this) were, -‘SilverKit.’ WillowBreeze relaxed against him, her cheek resting on his. ‘They are lovely names.’ Her breathing eased. Curling herself around her kits, she rested her nose on her paws and closed her eyes.- So yeah, I think she’d have been a wonderful mother. Okay, Bright Stream AND Storm. I wish Bright Stream had survived, because if she had, maybe Clear Sky wouldn’t have gone insane. And after Storm died, maybe he wouldn’t have rejected his son. Can I say smthn? Pls don’t judge. I. Hate. Clear Sky. After everything he’s done, how can anyone like him? I’ll admit, I haven’t finished Dotc, but from what I hear he just gets all the girls and then goes crazy. Idk why, he bothers me. If Bright Stream had survived, he would’ve been a good father though.
The ones I agree with the most:
Feathertail:She was one of the most kind cats I’ve ever read about in the series,Her and Crowfeather were one of my favorite ships and I was depressed when she passed,She would’ve been a kind and caring mother and would’ve always been there for her kits,She also saved the Tribe and her friends from Sharptooth!
Bristlefrost:She was really kind,Even though her and RootSpring didn’t have kits it would’ve been amazing if they did,It hurt my heart when she died from saving ShadowSight from Ashfur and I just wished she would’ve survived and had kits.
Sunstar:He cared so much about Moonflower and he was heart broken when she chose Stormtail and had Bluestar and Snowfur,He would’ve loved his kits and he would’ve loved Moonflower and he would also be a loyal father and mate.It killed me when he died-
Ravenpaw,And Barley:Yes,Just yes! They would’ve been great parents and I wanted to see that and it also killed me when he died-.Same with Barley!
Brambleberry:She was always there for Crookedstar,She was basically his second mom and she loved him more than his own mother did.She would’ve been a great mom.
Thrushpelt:He was an amazing fake father to Mosskit,Stonefur and Mistystar and he would’ve been an amazing mate to Bkuestar as well if they had their own kits.He is own of my favorites for his kindness to Bluestar.❤
Brambleberry would be ✨amazing✨ at parenting! She was basically Crookedkit's mom
My feelings exactly
Yes it made me cry
OMG UR EVERYWHERE I just clicked a random video and HERE U ARE!
@@LillieFish HEHEHEHEHHEH
POOKIE FOUND IN THE WILD 👹 @@PebbleTheSeaWing
thrushpelt was such a good father figure to mosskit, stonefur and mistystar ♥️
Alderheart was a great father figure to Twig(kit)branch while she didn’t know Hawkwing.
I feel like TwigBranch had forgotten Alderheart’s kindness in all her time. Alderheart did it deserve to be forgotten, he would be an amazing parent.
@@powerflower3405 Fr
I personally think Ravenpaw and Barley are more like father and son, Barley being the father figure since he took in Ravenpaw
I feel like honeyfern would be an awesome parent as well
Yeah,since she literally saved a kit
I was so happy when I saw thrushpelt as 1st- he's my favorite character and he deserved to be bluestar's mate. he was so amazing to mosskit, mistykit, and stonekit.
Silverstream would have been a good mother. She knew what it was like to grow up without one, so if she hadn't died in kitting, I believe she would have protected Stormfur and Feathertail more than any other queen in the nursery. And this may sound a bit strange, but hear me out. I believe Scourge would have been a great father. He'd protect and play with his kits and any other kits so their kithood didn't up like his.
Actually that’s true I agree with you
Yes
I definitely agree with Silverstream, but not Scourge. I’m pretty sure he was the one who made the rule that kits couldn’t stay with their parents or siblings past a certain age.
@Claires_everyday_life That’s all true, but I don’t think he’d be a good parent at all still lol. He hates kits, and was fully willing to kill Violet, even ordering her siblings to kill her themselves. True he’s Firestars brother but none of them ever knew it, and I doubt he’d care since he hated his other siblings.
Scrouge probably would be trying to teach them to be tough and scary, and he would most likely be harsh on them so they weren’t bullied like he was when he was a kit.
When I saw Brambleberry’s and Thrushpelt’s names, I thought I was going to cry. They deserved to be parents
Willowshine, Silverstream, Cloudpelt, Briarlight and Honeyfern would make great parents too
Cloudpelt wanted to be a parent his entire life 😢
Fr though! Shadowstar is the only founder, who physically cannot have descendants XD Moon Shadow died, as did two of his kits, as kits, then Sun Shadow died without, (as far as we know) having any descendants. I can get behind this list, especially Thrushpelt, I think that everyone can agree with Thrushpelt..
I did think of something, but since we have no canon evidence, I'm not so sure it should count. But, I guess it's possible that her's and Moon Shadow's parents had siblings, maybe they had kits, who maybe have descendents. But then again, I don't think cousins really count as "descendants" as much as just relatives, but, at least it's something, I guess? I choose to accept this as my canon, because the thought that she has no family is depressing... poor girl
Love that Ravenpaw and Barley are in the same spot!
Ooo this is a really good list. Video Idea: if it's possible can you do medicine cats who would have made amazing warriors?
@@ChilliesAreFire I'll consider it :)
@@fuzeblitz6326yeees please it would be so interesting
Yoo i first! Love ur vids❤ and i definitely agree
I think it sounds a little bit cringe but i think MapleShade would have been a very good mother to her kits. I know she did very bad things, but because she was betrayed by every cat who loved, she wouldnt done that to her kits, because she knows how much it hurts. I think just because she was a little bit possesive and she loved maybe too much, i think she would have protect her kits with the price of her life, because they would have been the only ones who loved her. I think she was a good cat in her heart, but it happened so many bad things to her. She didnt deserve this
I think foxleap and rose petal too also hazletail and toad step
Also .mouse whisker
I agree but I would add willowbreeze, willowshine, brightsky, Cinderpelt, spottedleaf, longtail, Swiftpaw, briarlight
Amazing edit! I love it!!♥️ But where is PebbleShine??
Oh I forgot about her!
I love brambleberry❤️
She was a way better mother to crookedkit than rainflower ever was
Honeyfern would be an amazing parent. She died pregnant but she was so sweet she even sacrificed her life for Brairkit
Bristlefrose should have been higher but absolutely brambleberry she was practically crookedstars mother!
This is so true ❤
Can you do a top 50 most unqiue colour or Look warroir cat please
Yup! That video was already an idea I had and might be in the making soon :)
Where is spottedleaf?
When it mentioned Bristlefrost I almost cried, I miss her sm
Okay, gonna start with
BristleFrost!!!! -So at the moment I haven’t finished The Broken Code, but she sounds like she’d have been a great mother. Yes I spoiled her death for myself.
Alr making our way up the family,
FeatherTail! -She and CrowFeather would’ve been amazing. Seriously, her death was unfair. And, does anyone else believe she should get a super edition or at least novella called, ‘FeatherTail’s Love’?
SilverStream! -FeatherTail’s mother, if SilverStream had survived her birthing she would’ve been an amazing mother, and I wish the Erin’s had had her live. She was the first major love interest connected by a main character (GrayStripe) I think she did the first major rescue scene (the river), and was one of the first major deaths.
Alr! SilverStream’s mother, WillowBreeze! -I pity CrookedStar- who doesn’t? His mother neglected him after he broke his jaw, and then died. His father moved early to the elders den, and I’m pretty sure died soon after. Her last words (I checked this) were,
-‘SilverKit.’ WillowBreeze relaxed against him, her cheek resting on his. ‘They are lovely names.’ Her breathing eased. Curling herself around her kits, she rested her nose on her paws and closed her eyes.-
So yeah, I think she’d have been a wonderful mother.
Okay, Bright Stream AND Storm. I wish Bright Stream had survived, because if she had, maybe Clear Sky wouldn’t have gone insane. And after Storm died, maybe he wouldn’t have rejected his son.
Can I say smthn? Pls don’t judge.
I.
Hate.
Clear Sky.
After everything he’s done, how can anyone like him? I’ll admit, I haven’t finished Dotc, but from what I hear he just gets all the girls and then goes crazy. Idk why, he bothers me. If Bright Stream had survived, he would’ve been a good father though.
Bristlefrost😢❤
Love this FuZe!
I was screaming Thrushpelt when I got the notification 😭
I think Willowpelt would have been a good mother too
Sorry, I meant Willowshine
I agree with Feathertail Ravenpaw and Barley!
Didn’t Micah have kits with Moth Flight?
@@Carolinasigma yes but he never got the chance to father their kits before he died
@@fuzeblitz6326 That sucks, I’m sorry for Moth Flight :(
@@Carolinasigma I'm not..
@@tigerpeltofwindclan8431 Bro’s a savage 💀
@@tigerpeltofwindclan8431I found her a little annoying.
I thought tallstar did have kids
Nope he never took a mate or had kits because his heart always belonged to Jake
bro mothwing would be a terrible mother, look how she treats her apprentices, absolutely not
Frostpaw, Willowshine or Podlight?
@@Sandstorm89483 all