I honestly hate that song. I agree with Lu, I'd honestly put it in mid but I likely am just biased. Objectively it is likely just a decent song and not as bad as I think it is so good probably fits well.
They are eminem haters pretending to be his fans. They are trashing his new albums since no one will care if they trash old eminem. In this video, they pretend to fight when one says good and other bad, and ultimately puts the song below great.
yall are fucking stupid maybe watch their other videos and they consistently consider eminem a top 10 rapper and consider his early albums the best in the genre
I never understood why the argument "he's done this before" is used as a way to discredit him. Yes, I know he already did, that's why I like it and why I want to keep listening
We are the core audience. They are essentially high end listeners. So we grade music probably on a 50-100% where anything under 50% is garbage. They rate things 85-100%. So that’s why the scaling feels off. While we can enjoy a 70% quality song and feel like it’s one of his best they listen and are disappointed. And it’s like everything about a song needs to be in that range for them.
It didn't even make sense when they were talking about Mockingbird either because When I'm gone was after that, then they said When I'm Gone was off of the Eminem Show.
I'm not english native speaker, so how do you that he's saying "I can't be your superman" instead of "I can be your superman" if the pronounce is exactly the same?
@@Preá1000I hear “can’t” instead of “can” I’m not sure why tho. Also could be because of the context of the verses makes your brain automatically hear can’t
"Lose yourself came out when he wasn't dropping his best albums but he was at the peak of his popularity".... came out in 2002 (same year of the Eminem Show)
I know right? What were they thinking? Eminem recorded LOSE YOURSELF while he was still working on TES DURING 8MILE WHICH HE HAD THE 🌎 BY THE BALLS AT THAT TIME
The Houdini disrespect is crazy Also bruh...Mockingbird came out before When I'm Gone. Mockingbird was on Encore in 2004, When I'm Gone didn't come out until 2005 when he dropped Curtain Call: The Hits
@@louis-nz8ce yes, but it also had a couple new songs, those being FACK and When I'm Gone. When I'm Gone did not release prior to Curtain Call, it is not on The Eminem Show or ANY other Eminem album or project. It wasn't even recorded until 2004. Edit: a quick Google search would do you wonders btw en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_I%27m_Gone_(Eminem_song)
It's weird, it gets criticism for people wanting a different kind of song from them. Most people wanted a gritty song but they apparantly clicked on a crazy song
@@nusretabi7222 it's not a bad song, it's just nowhere near his best. It's worse than literally every song on his first three albums imo, still doesn't mean it's bad, those songs are just so good. And then the concept is sweet but the chorus makes it corny. He's done the same concept far better and far less cliche in songs like hailies song and castle/arose. Also the whole song for me is shrouded by the rest of the unbearable songs on the same album. Plus tiktok has ruined it and now it lives in this wierd little world where everyone loves it and considers it amazing even though the verses are not his best performance and its praise only comes from the catchiness of the chorus, which is only so catchy because it (lazily) relies on a nursery rhyme melody most people are already familiar with. Without the psychological trick of using a widely spread melody to convey comfort and a listenable chorus, it wouldn't Recieve anywhere near the praise it does atm
That song literally gives me nursery kid song vibes it doesn't come off comical or edgy like without me or real slim Shady. It comes off cringe by a 50 year old sum Em who outta touch with everyone it's try hard and corny doesn't seem organic. The video was dope though
@02Raul434 literally gave a whole valid explanation on why it's ass and Stans stay saying we are hating on New Em. Bro he can rap and still a good rapper but he hasn't made a good fucking song in ages. I mean bro be honest who tf is bumping houdini their Car literally when he raps it sounds like sound coco melon Anthem like wtf🤣 I can dead ass picture a whole bunch of cocomelon babies dancing in a daycare to this fucking song like what grown man listening to that shit. He so damn cringe it was funny before cause he was younger and it was more organic but dude tryna recapture his past it's never gonna happen just evolve or fuck off the industry.
you didn't have headlights here????? it is easily an A tier for me personally its S tier the song was soo fucking good i cried few times listening to it
Videos like this show how crazy Eminems catalog is. Two really knowledgeable rap enthusiasts can still find controversy on his records. And then little old me having a completely different view point further still on a few of the records you guys liked or disliked. Just shows why his popularity is so vast, he's got an entire catalog to listen to for every type of listener.
@@caleb4828 Could you not decipher the sentence? I explicitly articulated that it's not merely about Eminem. Are you even literate in English? If not, desist from commenting to me. It appears you likely lack a Ph.D. or may not have even completed an undergraduate program. To have the audacity to voice an opinion, one should minimally have graduated from a top 50 university worldwide. Rather than indulging in video consumption or commenting, you should prioritize intellectual pursuits. Why do English speakers exhibit such a deplorable neglect of their academic endeavors? Your profound ignorance, lack of sophistication and abysmal educational background are utterly infuriating. I'm thoroughly exasperated by individuals of your ilk. If you aspire to engage in meaningful discourse, dedicate yourself to scholarly pursuits.
@@caleb4828it’s his energy. He seems too cocky and arrogant. Will say really harsh things as if he’s infallible, and get facts surrounding these takes wrong a lot. Like he said here in an angry tone that mockingbird had already been done before on when I’m gone When I’m gone came after movkibird Then they said when I’m gone was on the Eminem show Just a mess
@@Nico-iv3wr not saying that they trash but even if i wanna listen to Eminem I won’t be doing those. They’re messy and irrelevant even in his catalog, but not bad albums imo.
@@mahkamsaeed IDK, I think MMLP2 is much more forgettable than Relapse and Recovery. Not technically or production wise, just conceptually and storytelling wise. The whole concept about Relapse and Recovery was him falling back into addiction and then recovering, but MMLP2? And dying his hair blonde again? It really didn't sound anything like the original MMLP, so why even call it like that? I think at that moment, for the 1st time in his career, he just didn't know the concept, idea and backstory to his own album, he just didn't know which pattern to go through. Even if there are some great tracks on it of course
Bro, if you don't like Not Afraid, that is your problem. It is one of his best songs that has a lot of replay value and it doesn't have almost 2 billion views on You Tube by accident.
Dude u Stans are cringe I personally like the song and it's a classic but not everyone has to like what you like he gave his opinion and I respect someone who stands by it and is truthful rather than following the crowd and falling into peer pressure. U can't force someone to like something.
You guys are trippin man. MTBMB both sides is amazing. The beats, the hooks and em spitting str8 🔥 thru out. Sure, just like every album, there are some clunkers, but overall that album is great
Nah they keeping it a stack and I agree with nearly every take if this was a rap tier list u can make an argument for every song to be at least good or above. But as songs u know to play for enjoyment that guy has a shit load of bad songs that I would never play and honestly the ratio of good to bad songs gets worst and worst as his career goes on
Idk I prefer crack a bottle due to the hook, like he’s saying. It’s a good song overall. Verses in lead up are awesome. It’s mostly just the chorus. Obviously, not afraid was a deeper song
You guys are worse hip-hop fans Because how are you guys can put Houdini and Godzilla & the monster on mid they should have been in good list I ranked you guys 0/10 f. I.y I use to respect you guys but now two of ya’ll are falling off
Fantano and NFR shouldn't react to an eminem thing, the amount of bad takes is impressive, the hate in thier eyes is so clear, berzerk is a bad song, really!
@@Python-xs2iv shut up dude pls with those same answers of y'all, im sick of you, he just put some classic songs as mid do y'all listen from that place you are thinking now?
Houdini is straight ass, but it's literally just fan service "remember when i made better music" even down to the music video. So, if you're a stan i get why you like it
I know you guys needed a good mix of old and new songs. Should definetly go through Eminem’s first three albums and rank every song. You guys missed Brain damage, guilty consequence, If I had, 97 Bonnie and Clyde, As the world turns, Rock Bottom, Who knew, Drug Ballard, Kill you, Criminal and so many classic songs.
Not afraid that low is criminal, there's a brilliant triple on top of a quadruple entendre on top of a homophone You said you was king you lied through your teeth For that fuck your feelings Instead of getting crowned you getting capped The holes in the story of the lying king can be compared to the holes or cavities in one's teeth making him need a dental crown or cap to fill thus fuck your Feelings can be heard as fuck your fillings giving us the homophone Crowned 1 - headwear as the king wears a crown 2 - a dental crown in one's teeth 3 - crowned is a slang for getting punched Now capped Is the quadruple entendre 1- just like a crown it's headwear 2 - a dental cap 3- since crowning someone (punching them) isn't a severe enough punishment they get shot (capped) 4- cap in terms of lies bringing the line "you lied through your teeth" to a close
"I can't be your superman." He's telling that ho off, Ant. Do you have ears? And Love Game is one of the most fun and hilarious songs of Eminem's career. It's so underrated.
Not Afraid is a super hit Ant , how can u act like such a rap expert and say those dumb things. All my friends think ur a joke as an analyst so u can go on with ur role
I know as someone who has Eminem as pfp i'm not allowed to talk because everybody would say I'm a Stan but I would have put Houdini in Good or MAYBE in Great bcs it gave flashbacks on Without Me. And the lines are also good. But the list overall is good!
Houdini was straight cheeks bro. The hook was awful, the production was weird and unoriginal, the bars were corny af and not clever at all. It has absolutely 0 replay value. And the entire point of the song was to just be nostalgia bait.
@@fl1nt001 if you think the song is good. You might have you're head up yo ahh. Expand you're music taste brother. This isn't a good song. Falling for nostalgia bait. Which is the only quality taken from this song and it'll get old fast
@@UZI-hb3cu yeah, because each time he’s tried to evolve and be experimental, he’s been lambasted for it. So what else can he do besides nostalgia bait? His 3 album run is pretty much what he’s most remembered fondly for
Facts, I’m not the biggest fan of the hook looking back now but when I was a kid I loved the hook , and I think it fits the song well Personally though after registering to the verses I think these are some of the best verses Eminem ever wrote
Ya'll honestly sleep on soldier from eminem show. That track has some of his greatest lyricism across all his albums. The energy he puts into his flow is absolutely bonkers too
@@Andy-td8eo Eminem show is honestly his best album. Light listeners of em will say MMLP, but after like 100 listens in each album, Eminem show really fcking sticks out
Superman: "put anthrax on a tampax and slap you till you can't stand"
Ant: "arguably his best romantic attempt"
😂😂
Haha. Even the chorus is tongue in cheek/sarcastic, not romantic
You cant seriously think these 2 even listen to eminem
I’m just here to say this “Tobey” single is horrible 😂
@@Jay410S nah its a banger
Why was the Crack A Bottle discussion so heated. The tension was crazy
let your body waddle rn bro
Lu was buggin on that one tho, 50's flow was smooth and there was definitely energy on the song
Time stamp pls
I honestly hate that song. I agree with Lu, I'd honestly put it in mid but I likely am just biased. Objectively it is likely just a decent song and not as bad as I think it is so good probably fits well.
Because it’s not a good song lol.
Lu roasting Ant for Crack a Bottle take, and Ant roasting Lu for Not Afraid take is the energy i wanted from this video 😂
"never released officially" "don't care" lmaoo these guys are fuckin hilarious
These are clowns 🤣🤣.. they just follow what haters say. 🤣🤣
They are eminem haters pretending to be his fans. They are trashing his new albums since no one will care if they trash old eminem. In this video, they pretend to fight when one says good and other bad, and ultimately puts the song below great.
yall are fucking stupid maybe watch their other videos and they consistently consider eminem a top 10 rapper and consider his early albums the best in the genre
@@EM_Tusharyour profile pic says it all 😂
@@SportsFan-pt9jwyall Eminem fanboys can’t take criticism of him. The only fan base I see that acts like this. 😂😂😂
I never understood why the argument "he's done this before" is used as a way to discredit him. Yes, I know he already did, that's why I like it and why I want to keep listening
It's the most stupid argument and it can be said to any artist ig they use it when they don't want to give credit lol
"I want the old slim shady"
*Gets the old slim shady*
"Its mid hes done it before"
*gets something new*
"This isnt slim shady"
Rinse and repeat
We are the core audience. They are essentially high end listeners. So we grade music probably on a 50-100% where anything under 50% is garbage. They rate things 85-100%. So that’s why the scaling feels off. While we can enjoy a 70% quality song and feel like it’s one of his best they listen and are disappointed. And it’s like everything about a song needs to be in that range for them.
but but when travis scott kanye or whoever does the same shit again and again is all good
It didn't even make sense when they were talking about Mockingbird either because When I'm gone was after that, then they said When I'm Gone was off of the Eminem Show.
You know that on Superman, is the opposite of what you saying, he says " I can't be your Superman"
Exactly
I'm not english native speaker, so how do you that he's saying "I can't be your superman" instead of "I can be your superman" if the pronounce is exactly the same?
@@Preá1000the pronunciation isn’t the exact same but yeah sometimes it’s hard to tell which one people are saying
@@Luka_MK but in this song specifically you hear "can't" instead of "can"?
@@Preá1000I hear “can’t” instead of “can” I’m not sure why tho. Also could be because of the context of the verses makes your brain automatically hear can’t
Ant has the recovery cut 💀
His barber’s the biggest hater, not Kendrick.
As the Goat Yuno Miles said: FIRE YOU BARBER FIRE YOUR BARBER
@@Kanyewestbiggestfan123bro how do u have all this time to comment around Damn. Wish i had that Much free time
@@Mindonicon I’m on break rn and these videos drop at the perfect time
ahahahaha
11:58 Lu’s laugh started a heated argument about Crack A Bottle. 😭😭
Can't believe they didn't even mention Psycho when talking about 50/Em collabs. That's their best together imo
@@dojo_ Cause 50 cent's the main man on that with Em featured on it
@@ASR-ashso was Patiently Waiting.
4:39 “renting like the rent is due”😭
Today is the 1st too.... I felt that shit. 💔
Tbf when you’re a renter the rent will indeed be so 😅
Landlords when THEIR rent is due
You when a hip hop video is uploaded
Bone thugz n harmony 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
“That’s an Awfully hot coffee pot”🤯🔥🔥
Should I drop it on Donald Trump
Should I pour it on Donald trump probably not
are we still acting like that aint a hard bar?
@@chrisanthony408 probably not that’s all I got til I come up with another plot
@@chrisanthony408the bar is straight cheeks bro 😭
How is Gnat “one of the worse Eminem songs ever”
Plus the AUDACITY to say the beat switches were trash. Y’all WILLING 🤣
Fr tho, the second Gnat beat is a vibe lol. They sleeping on that song
Gnats the best song of side b
@@justasportsboy7776 naahhh its Killer. Tone deaf was funmy at first but got annoying. But Higher Discompulated, Killer. Those are the 3 best ones!
@@kallesoininen557 come to think of it I think Zeus is the best song on side b if em made a full album of songs like that I think he’d have a classic
Those fuckers are hating
You’re conversation about Superman is wild, you got the entire song wrong 😂😂
I slap you of that barstool, there goes another lawsuit, leave handprints all across you.... it's one of his most romantic songs
@@sitvisjes he’s talking about saving her bro you just don’t get it
@@kleatise52I don't think you get my comment but that''s allright
@@kleatise52”Him rapping from the perspective of Mariah Carey”
@@sitvisjes I was just messing around too haha
"Lose yourself came out when he wasn't dropping his best albums but he was at the peak of his popularity".... came out in 2002 (same year of the Eminem Show)
Eminem Show is one of his best albums so what are we talking about here ?
@@benjaminmartinez1638 ant said that
I know right? What were they thinking? Eminem recorded LOSE YOURSELF while he was still working on TES DURING 8MILE WHICH HE HAD THE 🌎 BY THE BALLS AT THAT TIME
Yea I was like wtf?
yeah instantly disregard their opinions once he said that
The "Crack a bottle" disagreement was one of the funniest moments of their entire career 😂😂😂
Interesting choice to put Fack in perfect but I respect it 👍
This comment section is slowly turning into fantano’s comment section
Where? I don’t see fack on their tier list..
Comedy
@@GaminTricksYou must have missed it.
@@Kanyewestbiggestfan123every single music TH-camr is like that now, it just be like that 🤷🏾♂️
The Houdini disrespect is crazy
Also bruh...Mockingbird came out before When I'm Gone. Mockingbird was on Encore in 2004, When I'm Gone didn't come out until 2005 when he dropped Curtain Call: The Hits
Curtain call is just a compilation album of his previous hits - including When I'm Gone
@@louis-nz8ce yes, but it also had a couple new songs, those being FACK and When I'm Gone. When I'm Gone did not release prior to Curtain Call, it is not on The Eminem Show or ANY other Eminem album or project. It wasn't even recorded until 2004.
Edit: a quick Google search would do you wonders btw en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_I%27m_Gone_(Eminem_song)
@@louis-nz8ceno there were 3 original songs on the album and that was one of them
Houdini is legit a great track!
Fax. Lu is crazy for calling it mid
Love Game is under appreciated in my opinion. Em and Kendrick went off on this track verse by verse. One of my personal favorites.
The PRODUCTION though 🤡🎸
@@retrogressive8245its good bro
Top 5 on mmlp 2
@@mahkamsaeed could even say top 3 on mmlp2
It's weird, it gets criticism for people wanting a different kind of song from them. Most people wanted a gritty song but they apparantly clicked on a crazy song
Bro he literally says he *CAN’T* be her Superman do y’all even listen to the lyrics?
stg sometimes they’ll misinterpret the message of a track and make an entire new song out of it lol
He wouldn't have made a list like that if he had listened to and understood the lyrics.
The Not Afraid hate from Ant is insane😭🙏
I respect it I hate that song
@@shrimpscampin L.
@@shrimpscampindo you actually HATE it or do you just dislike it
@@agapanthus2024Corny ass song 🤣
That song is dope imo
Mockingbird not being in at least amazing is crazy 💀
Mockingbird is so unbelievably overrated
yes I was soo suprised for me Perfect one of the best songs of EM
@@oscartsintas I thought everyone loves the song
@@nusretabi7222 it's not a bad song, it's just nowhere near his best. It's worse than literally every song on his first three albums imo, still doesn't mean it's bad, those songs are just so good. And then the concept is sweet but the chorus makes it corny. He's done the same concept far better and far less cliche in songs like hailies song and castle/arose. Also the whole song for me is shrouded by the rest of the unbearable songs on the same album. Plus tiktok has ruined it and now it lives in this wierd little world where everyone loves it and considers it amazing even though the verses are not his best performance and its praise only comes from the catchiness of the chorus, which is only so catchy because it (lazily) relies on a nursery rhyme melody most people are already familiar with. Without the psychological trick of using a widely spread melody to convey comfort and a listenable chorus, it wouldn't Recieve anywhere near the praise it does atm
@@oscartsintas Cool 👍, still should be in amazing
i will never get the mtbmb hate. ever. so many bangers. so many bars. lyrical skill at an all time high.
The lyrics go over their heads and they don’t admire his lyricism and evolution to the mc he has become
Shit is not good bro
Lyrical skill doesn't mean anything when it's not used well. Not to mention the production wasn't the best.
i love mtbmb, it has some bad songs and bad choruses, but idk how, i love it
The production was literally the best part@@mandem2362
houdini is actually good tho😭😭
No
Hell nah
Not really
It was a nice throwback and the verses were above average, its good
No it’s not
L take on Berzerk
Giving Houdini mid is just hating.
that song is garbage
Mid asf
That song literally gives me nursery kid song vibes it doesn't come off comical or edgy like without me or real slim Shady. It comes off cringe by a 50 year old sum Em who outta touch with everyone it's try hard and corny doesn't seem organic. The video was dope though
@@KnowledgeNation-vj2jk just sounds like someone who likes to follow the trend of “new Em sucks” and hates on the newer music even if it’s good.
@02Raul434 literally gave a whole valid explanation on why it's ass and Stans stay saying we are hating on New Em. Bro he can rap and still a good rapper but he hasn't made a good fucking song in ages. I mean bro be honest who tf is bumping houdini their Car literally when he raps it sounds like sound coco melon Anthem like wtf🤣 I can dead ass picture a whole bunch of cocomelon babies dancing in a daycare to this fucking song like what grown man listening to that shit. He so damn cringe it was funny before cause he was younger and it was more organic but dude tryna recapture his past it's never gonna happen just evolve or fuck off the industry.
When I’m gone is not on the Eminem show either wtf do y’all even listen to Eminem??
"How lenient are we gonna be today, Ant?"
Damn, Lu woke up and chose violence. Love it.
You fellas do not get to cook ever again. We're ordering take out if I even get the hint y'all are coming over.
Lmao
Can't believe you put Fack in perfect
Do you understand jokes 😭
Fack is eminems best song wym?
Kim as "Great" is a travesty. That's a perfect song, the content matter doesn't affect its quality.
“Content matter” isn’t a term! It’s “subject matter”! They drive me crazy when they say that. lol
relapse is peak
hell yeah, peak garbage
@@mxderate B.F.B, Medicine ball, Must be the ganja, 3am, deja vu, beautiful, stay wide awake
hell yeah, peak garbage. i second the motion
I agree. I don't understand some of the hate. It's one of his best Albums
@@mxderateStay Wide Awake’s second verse is a top 10 rap verse of all time. But sure, it’s peak garbage.
40:35 @NFR out of context
I didn’t agree with all of the rankings but solid list. Great vid
21:28 "I'm not gonna fucking repeat myself" Nah ts got wayy too heated😭😭
you didn't have headlights here????? it is easily an A tier for me personally its S tier the song was soo fucking good i cried few times listening to it
Ant take on not afraid was atrocious fr
Videos like this show how crazy Eminems catalog is. Two really knowledgeable rap enthusiasts can still find controversy on his records. And then little old me having a completely different view point further still on a few of the records you guys liked or disliked. Just shows why his popularity is so vast, he's got an entire catalog to listen to for every type of listener.
@@madb36474 Bro is swallowing Eminem's man fluids
Berzerk might be the most overhated Eminem song of all time tbh
top 3 song on the mmlp2
If u don't fw that sound ur gonna hate that song it's for a niche people which I'm not a part of it's ass😂
Recently Lou sounds a lot like Fantano. It's not just about Em; he's been spitting out tons of weird takes, especially lately.
You mean he doesn’t glaze Eminem so he’s weird?
@@caleb4828 Could you not decipher the sentence? I explicitly articulated that it's not merely about Eminem. Are you even literate in English? If not, desist from commenting to me. It appears you likely lack a Ph.D. or may not have even completed an undergraduate program. To have the audacity to voice an opinion, one should minimally have graduated from a top 50 university worldwide. Rather than indulging in video consumption or commenting, you should prioritize intellectual pursuits. Why do English speakers exhibit such a deplorable neglect of their academic endeavors? Your profound ignorance, lack of sophistication and abysmal educational background are utterly infuriating. I'm thoroughly exasperated by individuals of your ilk. If you aspire to engage in meaningful discourse, dedicate yourself to scholarly pursuits.
@@caleb4828it’s his energy. He seems too cocky and arrogant. Will say really harsh things as if he’s infallible, and get facts surrounding these takes wrong a lot.
Like he said here in an angry tone that mockingbird had already been done before on when I’m gone
When I’m gone came after movkibird
Then they said when I’m gone was on the Eminem show
Just a mess
Nah lu is better than ant, not afraid is an amazing song
Not Afraid is definitely one of his most iconic tho you can’t lie 😂😂😂
Why do they underrate MMLP2 so much? it wasn’t amazing but it has a lot of great tracks.
Best album after that first 3 album
@@mahkamsaeedI used to think this way too, but now that I look back both Relapse and Recovery are better imo
@@Nico-iv3wr not saying that they trash but even if i wanna listen to Eminem I won’t be doing those. They’re messy and irrelevant even in his catalog, but not bad albums imo.
@@mahkamsaeed IDK, I think MMLP2 is much more forgettable than Relapse and Recovery. Not technically or production wise, just conceptually and storytelling wise. The whole concept about Relapse and Recovery was him falling back into addiction and then recovering, but MMLP2? And dying his hair blonde again? It really didn't sound anything like the original MMLP, so why even call it like that? I think at that moment, for the 1st time in his career, he just didn't know the concept, idea and backstory to his own album, he just didn't know which pattern to go through. Even if there are some great tracks on it of course
I listen to Venom🙋♂️ ,it gets you hype it is a energertic song and is fun to listen to
Barsbarsbarsbarsbarsbarsbarsbars
Bro, if you don't like Not Afraid, that is your problem. It is one of his best songs that has a lot of replay value and it doesn't have almost 2 billion views on You Tube by accident.
Dude u Stans are cringe I personally like the song and it's a classic but not everyone has to like what you like he gave his opinion and I respect someone who stands by it and is truthful rather than following the crowd and falling into peer pressure. U can't force someone to like something.
You guys are trippin man. MTBMB both sides is amazing. The beats, the hooks and em spitting str8 🔥 thru out. Sure, just like every album, there are some clunkers, but overall that album is great
That album is fucking ass😂
@@KnowledgeNation-vj2jk so is your breath weirdo
Godzilla at Mid is absolutely wild HOTTEST TAKE EVER
I wouldve put it at good or great.
Nah they keeping it a stack and I agree with nearly every take if this was a rap tier list u can make an argument for every song to be at least good or above. But as songs u know to play for enjoyment that guy has a shit load of bad songs that I would never play and honestly the ratio of good to bad songs gets worst and worst as his career goes on
There's no fucking way "crack a bottle" is better than "not afraid" bro
100% mate not afraid aged horribly all I see it as is that mc Burberry parody song “I’m not a maid”
Idk I prefer crack a bottle due to the hook, like he’s saying. It’s a good song overall. Verses in lead up are awesome. It’s mostly just the chorus. Obviously, not afraid was a deeper song
@@BrooksOrlando fair enough i guess.
My personal favorite Eminem song is bump heads, just love the disses and overall energy the song brings
Same
The hate on 2010-now Em is crazy
They don’t like Em post 2010 it’s blatantly obvious lol
They still had 6 songs in good or better. But it's no secret his first 3 albums were his best.
It really isn’t good tho
Yeah bc he’s absolute dog ass rn
@@apretrogaming1041who does lmao he became so ass
When I'm gone is always going to be my favorite Eminem song.
Ant decided to try to make is hair like Eminem’s for the episode
Ant
@@skipper6-9 my fault I changed it now
You guys are worse hip-hop fans
Because how are you guys can put Houdini and Godzilla & the monster on mid they should have been in good list I ranked you guys 0/10 f. I.y I use to respect you guys but now two of ya’ll are falling off
we dont need this vid bruh ur priorities are basically old em: put in amazing/perfect, new em: good/mid/bad
I was thinking the same thing haha. I wish I had checked the comments before I wasted half an hour on this
Finally people understand the greatness of Fack
Man, I'm reminded of the importance of "it's not what you say, but how you say it " everytime lyrics are read out of context.
underrated comment
Can’t wait to see these rankings, I’ll definitely show my brother since he’s a huge Eminem fan. Keep up the great content NFR! 💯🔥❤
Fantano and NFR shouldn't react to an eminem thing, the amount of bad takes is impressive, the hate in thier eyes is so clear, berzerk is a bad song, really!
You need to get a grip and stop worshipping has been rappers.
@@Python-xs2iv shut up dude pls with those same answers of y'all, im sick of you, he just put some classic songs as mid do y'all listen from that place you are thinking now?
@@SamirAmiri_01 I bet you only listen to Eminem and are ignorant to hip hop as a whole.
@@Python-xs2iv nas, big l, kurupt, rakim, redman, beasty biys, ice t, method man, public enemy, biggie, 2pac, llcool j, andre, mf doom......
@@SamirAmiri_01 How long it take you to google all those guys?
If you asked 12 year old me about Not Afraid I woulda said it's perfect, but now I think it's just good
I'm convinced that they have the WORST takes on Eminem I've ever seen in my life
i agree with a lot of these
Can’t wait to see these rankings, I’ll definitely show my brother since he’s a huge Eminem fan. Keep up the great content NFR! 💯🔥❤️
The Houdini hate is crazy
no it's not that song ain't allat and i'm glad that they acknowledged it. this is also coming from an em fan
The hook was the only thing that was mid to me. Everything else about the song was good
Song is horrid
Saying Houdini mid??
No fckin wayyyy
Should have been great.
Yup, they are just full of shit sometimes ngl
i would say good but definitely not mid
It's good, n9t mid though
Their Gnat take was insane to me. “One of the worse Eminem songs” thats WILD 🤣
@@ropao6310 how can we take someone seriously who said MMLP 2 was mid
Crack A Bottle over Not Afraid is genuinely an atrocious take
Nah not really they're both great songs
So agree
They are both great
Venom gets played in stadiums, I think that's why it has so many streams
Houdini is not mid
It's bad
@@Илья-д8д7в and you are?
@@Илья-д8д7вNope it's good.
Houdini is straight ass, but it's literally just fan service "remember when i made better music" even down to the music video. So, if you're a stan i get why you like it
@@Илья-д8д7в You must have high standards to think that was "bad"
Not afraid is a great song, we made you is a mid/good song, mockingbird is perfect, and when I’m gone is amazing.
Role model as number one is based, always been my favorite eminem song
Beat on that song is so dope. Could have that on repeat for hours
I know you guys needed a good mix of old and new songs. Should definetly go through Eminem’s first three albums and rank every song. You guys missed Brain damage, guilty consequence, If I had, 97 Bonnie and Clyde, As the world turns, Rock Bottom, Who knew, Drug Ballard, Kill you, Criminal and so many classic songs.
Beautiful not being in Perfect says enough about how much ur opinions on Eminem doesnt matter
The singing sucks on that song. It should be in Good at highest
Has some corny lines
@@peggytheveteran4968 deja vu is so much better
They are literally massive Eminem glazers 😭
@@peggytheveteran4968 cap go fap and its about a message which goes well with the verses and instrumental
Yoo the Not Afraid argument had me dying
kim not on S+
immediately lost all credibility
Not afraid that low is criminal, there's a brilliant triple on top of a quadruple entendre on top of a homophone
You said you was king
you lied through your teeth
For that fuck your feelings
Instead of getting crowned you getting capped
The holes in the story of the lying king can be compared to the holes or cavities in one's teeth making him need a dental crown or cap to fill thus fuck your Feelings can be heard as fuck your fillings giving us the homophone
Crowned
1 - headwear as the king wears a crown
2 - a dental crown in one's teeth
3 - crowned is a slang for getting punched
Now capped Is the quadruple entendre
1- just like a crown it's headwear
2 - a dental cap
3- since crowning someone (punching them) isn't a severe enough punishment they get shot (capped)
4- cap in terms of lies bringing the line "you lied through your teeth" to a close
"So will the real slim shady please stand up"🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥
Cringe
"I can't be your superman." He's telling that ho off, Ant. Do you have ears? And Love Game is one of the most fun and hilarious songs of Eminem's career. It's so underrated.
Houdini is Great or Amazing
Recency bias😂
Cant believe you missed ‘criminal’ off this list.
Nfr on a generational run this year
The “crack a bottle” segment had my dying😂😭
clowns 🤡
Not Afraid is a super hit Ant , how can u act like such a rap expert and say those dumb things. All my friends think ur a joke as an analyst so u can go on with ur role
Superman and Bezerk lowkey "Perfect"
Bro I love berserk
Ahhhh my favorite love song Superman
I love how they didnt say a word and put stan in perfect
I know as someone who has Eminem as pfp i'm not allowed to talk because everybody would say I'm a Stan but I would have put Houdini in Good or MAYBE in Great bcs it gave flashbacks on Without Me. And the lines are also good. But the list overall is good!
Houdini was straight cheeks bro. The hook was awful, the production was weird and unoriginal, the bars were corny af and not clever at all. It has absolutely 0 replay value. And the entire point of the song was to just be nostalgia bait.
@@UZI-hb3cu3/10 rage bait
@@fl1nt001 if you think the song is good. You might have you're head up yo ahh. Expand you're music taste brother. This isn't a good song. Falling for nostalgia bait. Which is the only quality taken from this song and it'll get old fast
@@UZI-hb3cu ok bro 😂, my music taste is expanded enough
@@UZI-hb3cu yeah, because each time he’s tried to evolve and be experimental, he’s been lambasted for it. So what else can he do besides nostalgia bait? His 3 album run is pretty much what he’s most remembered fondly for
18:57 ant’s haircut is getting to him. Not afraid 100% belongs in great
ANTS HEAD LOOKING LIKE A PING PONG BALL 🔥🔥🔥🗣🗣🗣
L
saying that castle and crack a bottle are better than not afraid is a crime and an insult to eminem
W take by Lou on not afraid . The hook is really good, it’s a well written song.
Facts, I’m not the biggest fan of the hook looking back now but when I was a kid I loved the hook , and I think it fits the song well
Personally though after registering to the verses I think these are some of the best verses Eminem ever wrote
With these guys you truly get the two types of eminem fans.
Not affraid is EASILY a better song than crack a bottle. I like crack a bottle but its overrated.
Disagree with a couple of the low ranks but can’t be mad. Enjoyed watching you guys dissect. Hopefully a part 2 on the way! As he has so many songs
Ya'll honestly sleep on soldier from eminem show. That track has some of his greatest lyricism across all his albums. The energy he puts into his flow is absolutely bonkers too
Square Dance too
@@Andy-td8eo Eminem show is honestly his best album. Light listeners of em will say MMLP, but after like 100 listens in each album, Eminem show really fcking sticks out
@@demohunto3 Hard agree. TES is his best work.
I commented the same thing. Shows they don’t know his music like they say. Also not having 8 mile as perfect is wack.
Everything's "arguably" here. Not a bad list, but not a great one either.
Also, Mockingbird and Lose Yourself should've had different album covers
Not having mockingbird in perfect is a crime against humanity
Fall was a mid????
No grippy is crazy
Grippy isn’t an Eminem song
@@FowlerTheScouser-xh4epno grippy is crazy
@@FowlerTheScouser-xh4ep no grippy is crazy
Copy paste in his catalog? 😂😂 but y’all take back shots to yeat and carti and all that mumble shit y’all are goofy lol
Thank you! COMPLETELY agree!
Lose Yourself was released at a time where em wasnt releasing the best studio albums????
What was Ant on about
Fun fact, he dropped the song a day before he released the soundtrack, and that soundtrack outsold and blocked Christina Aguilera's sophomore album
@@Andy-td8eoWho gives a shit?
never let these guys rate anything again
The bias to older em songs is wild man
Older em=prime em
Don’t necessarily disagree, but people act like he drops trash nowadays and that’s just not true
I’m also just now hearing them saying When I’m Gone was off of the Eminem Show and I just can’t believe it
New Eminem sucks, can you blame them?
@@Python-xs2iv no he don't
Ant is wrong abt Not Afraid and Lu is wrong abt We Made You