Less cumbersome and easier to aim and fire with the .30 carbine round than a 30 06 Better fire control and less wasted ammo than a grease gun or Thompson In case you could not tell these men were not trained infantry so the carbine was an excellent choice
nah the other guys where just not real soldiers lol, one of them old af too^^ if real soldiers wouldve been there kid wouldve been smoked by a nade before the soldiers wouldve even knew they just naded a kiddo^^
WW2 was brutal. Tons of kids were fighting at the end but the Soviets were slaughtering them. They didn't care. The Soviets saw what the Germans did to their people and were hellbent on revenge.
The M-1 carbine was magazine fed and lacked the distinctive “ ping” given off by the far more famous M-1 garand. It held 15 rounds of .30 carbine. .30 carbine is essentially a supercharged handgun sized load. Bullet weight of 110g mimics the weight of a .38 special but with 3 times the powder charge. Todays 5.56 or .233 in the AR-15 is meant to mimic this round in ballistic performance
Esse filme é simplesmente maravilhoso. Eu tenho ele em DVD. Ainda bem que existem pessoas no mundo que prezam a identidade, a história e tudo o mais que está contido na cultura de todos os povos. Muito obrigado.
That didn’t look like a Mauser the kid was using. What kind of rifle was that? The only bolt action rifles I know of in that time with a extended magazine were the Lee Enfield and the Mosin Nagant.
It was late in the war. By the time hitler jugend and the volksturm was deployed they pretty much had to give them any weapon they could find. Even captured soviet/allied weapons.
It's either a Gewehr M95 or an 1889 Mauser. We don't get a great look at the rifle, and there are a few differences between either rifle I've seen, but the overall designs and profile is a close match for either one. I'd personally say M95 is the closest with the profile of the magazine.
He fires 5 rounds, then reloads at 0.54. He then fires 19 rounds, which would be consistent with a 30 round box magazine... but there's only a 15 round magazine in the gun (plus you could maybe assume one still in the chamber). It's not the most egregious example of Hollywood ammo counting, but yeah, he does fire more shots than he appears to actually have loaded. ;)
@@davebalaam I don't think anyone really had 30rd M1 box magazines until Korea. There were probably a very small number of them in circulation at the very end of World War II but I doubt a Rear Echelon guy like these "Monuments Men" would have them lol.
@@tinman3586 Yup. Didn't know they weren't common until Korea (I just went off Wikipedia). As I said, you can see the magazine (most clearly at 1.08) is only a 15-round mag.
Never going to watch it, don't really care either way. But the uniform the kid is wearing looks off. I'm no expert, but wouldn't he just be in civilian clothes OR in a basic grey Wehrmacht kit?
I have got this movie DVD of John Goodman Matt and Matt Damon in The Monuments Men I am dedicating this movie DVD to my old school friends who are both sisters and I hope to see them both again very soon to Chris and Hester from Billyxxx
Honestly, pretty accurate. There were child soldiers during the Battle of Berlin, and Hitler Youth were usually where said child soldiers came from. And a gun from a child can kill just as well as from an adult, so…yeah. Nice little scene.
"i dont think these people that has chosen to watch a gun fight scene from ww2 in a movie would be okay with a couple of no no words, death? ok, no no words? how blastomous" someone somewhere when deciding to mute this with the worst mute noise known to mankind
You gotta love TH-cam's sensibilities. It's ok for us to see someone prepare to shoot a child but we can't hear the word "shit". Fury has the same treatment. Our eyes can see people being blown limb-from-limb but heaven forbid our ears hear the word "fuck".
Bleeping the swearing, why, WHY is that still a thing ffs. Anyone dislike swearing while watching a movie about the Second World War needs to get there damn head checked
It's not a Garand but a M1 Carbine. And it's definitely a huge step tactically speaking. There are archives of the Germans speaking about how their men were way more effective with the STG44 than with the Kar98 because they could keep firing while moving, instead of having to stop, "unshoulder" their rifle, cycle the bolt manually and shoulder it again.
Yeah semi auto is big step up to bolt action. Here he is using M1 carbine. Would honestly be good gun for the time for urban combat. Way better than the full power bolt actions generally used. Garand also is maybe the best general issue rifle of the war.
Soviet, American, Italian, French, British any seasoned soldier would shoot the kid take the rifle look for weapons, ammunition food, maps, negotiables, clean dry underwear, socks, undershirts, boots. Nothing has changed in warzones since Genghis Khan except the technology.
@Tin Man Goodmen character wouldn't of been able to run across the clearance, the carbine fires faster and has more rounds in it making it a better weapon for suppression.... i.e. fire and maneuver the foundation for modern combat. Suppressing an enemy is far more important when it's come to moving. Thus the person who can fire the most shots without reloading is the suppressor while other move forward so they are in position to make the best of the few shot they have. You don't know military tactics , I wouldn't want a bolt action being responsible for the pinning/suppressing fire as you have 5 shots and about 2 sec between shots Thus if the bolt action tries to suppress another bolt action, it doesn't work out too well since the enemy is feel to engage due to the slow rate of fire being used for suppression....
I mean really there is an argument to be made that an M1 Carbine would be a better close quarters weapon due to its lighter weight, shorter barrel, higher magazine capacity and ability to follow up shots more quickly. I assume the French guy is using a SMLE No4, which is able to hold ten rounds. There also was the "Mad Minute" shooting style with the SMLE that at least doubles the fire rate of the rifle at the sacrifice of accuracy, which is what you'd want when laying down suppressive fire. Really the difference between the two weapons is small enough that it comes down to who actually is willing to close with the enemy. Which is what we see here.
Lee Enfield is different though It's a very suppressive Bolt Action rifle depending on the users due to how smoothly they can operate it for rapid fire They can fire and cycle so quickly that the enemies thought it was a Semi auto or MG if they fired in group
maybe he comes from the starship trooper universe XD his old sergeant was killed so he got promoted on the spot until the captain dies or find something better for him XD
The amount of shitty bleeps edited into this clip by Binge are just awfull! You can even tell the editor probably doesnt even speak a single word in German as nearly an entire line spoken in German gets bleeped out. (Around the 2:00 mark). The movie is great, but this clip was ruined.
@@haydentenno6773 I am an honorable citizen of the most important country in the world, the light above all lights, the pinnacle or freedom, peace, harmless science, and vegetable pizzas.
I would say this is about the only shooting action you'll get from the whole film but, its nice to see the No.4 in action on a Hollywood movie.
I prefer the №1 Mk3.
Wish we had more of these two, amazing comedic duo
No! We need an Asian and a black guy as duo! White only is rhasis!
@@cashewnuttel9054 Havent you heard of Eddie Murphy?
@@cashewnuttel9054 Have you not seen Rush Hour? 🤣
Glory to Ukraine!
Unfortunately John Belushi was gone
good thing there's extremely loud beeps to cover up the swearing so we can't hear the rest of what he says
Bleeping the entire tirade kind of adds to the comedy, I feel.
Has nothing to do with them lmao. Its so the channel doesnt get demonetized @steiner554
@steiner554. Yeah, Swearing, nudity and sex are taboo in the U.S but violence is not. Talk about messed up values.
@steiner554 Americans love swearing. What? lmao.
John Goodman's M1 Carbine would have been better suited to the close quarters combat inside the building.
@@Horsemanray LOL touche
the carbine is also more suitable for covering fire.
True, but it also provided better cover fire than a bolt-action rifle would. That rifle wasn't the best choice for urban work.
EXACTLY
Less cumbersome and easier to aim and fire with the .30 carbine round than a 30 06
Better fire control and less wasted ammo than a grease gun or Thompson
In case you could not tell these men were not trained infantry so the carbine was an excellent choice
Mr Brown was so annoyed with Paddington Bear that he joined the armed forces.
That kid has a hell of a aim
nah the other guys where just not real soldiers lol, one of them old af too^^ if real soldiers wouldve been there kid wouldve been smoked by a nade before the soldiers wouldve even knew they just naded a kiddo^^
there was a similar scene in the old war movie "The Bridge at Remagen" - but there the US-soldier shot the boy. the kid used a MP-40.
WW2 was brutal. Tons of kids were fighting at the end but the Soviets were slaughtering them. They didn't care. The Soviets saw what the Germans did to their people and were hellbent on revenge.
These two actors performed in a film that won the Best Picture Oscar, "The Artist" (2011).
You can hear goodman reload with a distinctive click at around second 55.
I love the sound of a reload, just makes any movie wholesome.
@@lucasjones5397 Carbine charging slide
The M-1 carbine was magazine fed and lacked the distinctive “ ping” given off by the far more famous M-1 garand. It held 15 rounds of .30 carbine. .30 carbine is essentially a supercharged handgun sized load. Bullet weight of 110g mimics the weight of a .38 special but with 3 times the powder charge. Todays 5.56 or .233 in the AR-15 is meant to mimic this round in ballistic performance
@@matthewcaughey8898 he said click not ping
2:02 I just love hearing a long beep in a video
-Said no one ever.
Actually, I laughed.
A quick count has Goodman firing 21 times without re-loading: no wonder the Reich fell.
My 30 carb held 30 rounds
@@upandaljm Not with the short mag he's using :)
@ that's the same size nah mine uses, still 30 rounds.
@@ryan-uu9lj I'd swear that's a 15 rounder, but whatever.
He's basically the allied counterpart to Sgt. Schultz.
If this was the movie Fury brad Pitt would have put a round of white phosphorus in the building.
American soldier : "Maybe we keep this to ourselves. French soldier : I think that's best.
Lol, funny. 😂
Thumbs down for bleeping out "merde" - and I usually never take time to explain my thumbs down...
Maybe the us version as usual for snowflakes ...
Yep, there is cursing and there is cursing. Here, there was a lot of unnecessary bleeping.
Esse filme é simplesmente maravilhoso. Eu tenho ele em DVD. Ainda bem que existem pessoas no mundo que prezam a identidade, a história e tudo o mais que está contido na cultura de todos os povos. Muito obrigado.
I agree there are too few in the world today that care about culture and our history as people.
My God, this beeping is terrible. Can't we just stop this nonsense?
If you haven't seen Madonna and Child in Bruges, be prepared to be moved to tears, even if you aren't religious.
Fun fact: this was the lowest-budget episode in season 8 of Roseanne.
Ah, I would have thought this was Walter Sobchak Sr., who also has a son that went to war in Vietnam.
Thought It Was From Monuments Men
I love that little carbine. Not really the roll it was designed for, but still a fun design
That didn’t look like a Mauser the kid was using. What kind of rifle was that? The only bolt action rifles I know of in that time with a extended magazine were the Lee Enfield and the Mosin Nagant.
looks like a steyr straight pull rifle m95
It was late in the war. By the time hitler jugend and the volksturm was deployed they pretty much had to give them any weapon they could find. Even captured soviet/allied weapons.
It's either a Gewehr M95 or an 1889 Mauser. We don't get a great look at the rifle, and there are a few differences between either rifle I've seen, but the overall designs and profile is a close match for either one. I'd personally say M95 is the closest with the profile of the magazine.
they converted carcanos and gave them to the volksturm. Theres some videos about it on youtube.
K98 was a bolt action
Such an underrated film.
Hermosa película. Gracias
Man that censor bleep really fucking ruined this scene. Nice job
Great movie.
The "NIEN NIEN, NIEN" poor kid.
LOL, M1 carbine that never runs out of ammo!
If you listen really carefully you hear him reload
He fires 5 rounds, then reloads at 0.54. He then fires 19 rounds, which would be consistent with a 30 round box magazine... but there's only a 15 round magazine in the gun (plus you could maybe assume one still in the chamber). It's not the most egregious example of Hollywood ammo counting, but yeah, he does fire more shots than he appears to actually have loaded. ;)
@@davebalaam I don't think anyone really had 30rd M1 box magazines until Korea. There were probably a very small number of them in circulation at the very end of World War II but I doubt a Rear Echelon guy like these "Monuments Men" would have them lol.
@@tinman3586 Yup. Didn't know they weren't common until Korea (I just went off Wikipedia). As I said, you can see the magazine (most clearly at 1.08) is only a 15-round mag.
15 or 30 round detachable box magazine
I'll pencil this one in--the understated facetious drama of the storyline in juxtaposition to the reality is refreshing
I think I meant the term, "satire"😁
My God... people seem to either idolise the film, or have a distilled hatred for it and/or Clooney being in it...
I think that some people who hate the film never even watched it
Clooney must have loved this era. Fing Nazi
Never going to watch it, don't really care either way. But the uniform the kid is wearing looks off. I'm no expert, but wouldn't he just be in civilian clothes OR in a basic grey Wehrmacht kit?
@@againsttheleftandright4065 it's a mix of Hitler youth and random boys clothes
@@GrasshopperKelly
Interesting. I've never seen a full black combat kit except for panzer leaders.
Fat John Goodman is definitely a real war hero.
lol, that Carbine looks like a toy when John Goodman holds it
It did look like the Erma EM1 (a german made .22lr trainer rifle for the M1) when he held it... :D
James Granger = William Garin
Richard Campbell = Baloo
Claire Simone = Galadriel
Walter Garfield = James P. Sullivan
I have got this movie DVD of
John Goodman Matt
and Matt Damon in
The Monuments Men
I am dedicating this movie DVD to my old school friends who are both sisters and I hope to see them both again very soon to Chris and Hester from Billyxxx
Honestly, pretty accurate. There were child soldiers during the Battle of Berlin, and Hitler Youth were usually where said child soldiers came from. And a gun from a child can kill just as well as from an adult, so…yeah. Nice little scene.
Actually the Hitler Youth were among the most fanatical Nazis, willing to fight to the death rather than surrender.
Did ya have to bleep out him saying Merde
GOD those censor bleeps are obnoxious.
"i dont think these people that has chosen to watch a gun fight scene from ww2 in a movie would be okay with a couple of no no words, death? ok, no no words? how blastomous" someone somewhere when deciding to mute this with the worst mute noise known to mankind
British soldiers at war. "I say, good fellow, sit and have a drink, why don't you? Spot of cognac, wot wot?"
Stupid censorship…🙄
I find it hilarious lmao
Je dis merde à la censure
It's totally unneeded
I love the part where he said "beeeep"
You gotta love TH-cam's sensibilities. It's ok for us to see someone prepare to shoot a child but we can't hear the word "shit". Fury has the same treatment. Our eyes can see people being blown limb-from-limb but heaven forbid our ears hear the word "fuck".
"We train young men to drop fire on people. But their commanders won't allow them to write 'fuck' on their airplanes because it's obscene."
Wow.... US army and British Army👍💪
A french in free french army with uk uniform
How many bullets were in Goodman's gun? He didn't have a banana clip or a drum.
He has a modified M1 protagonist garant, it only runs out of ammo for dramatic reasons.
it was an m1 carbine with a 15 round detachable box magazine chambered in caliber .30 carbine.
your welcome
This beep Sound is so annoying
Have a book about the monument men I took it from 5th grad cause it caught my interest but now it’s been sitting their for 2 years
Really? They bleeped him saying merde?
Who knew James P. Sullivan was in ww2
Yep
the voices are so funny,,,😲
A bruh moment.
Rip to people using headphones (loud beep)
The Name?
wow never saw the movie but right before the reveal i thought what if it was a child ..
Bleeping the swearing, why, WHY is that still a thing ffs. Anyone dislike swearing while watching a movie about the Second World War needs to get there damn head checked
Wtf is this shit, all those " bip bip "? Damn censorship is ruining this scene
"MAichelangelo"... lol
Amzing!😀
0:17 makes no sense...."you have a family" so he is saying you be the distraction cause you have a family ?
You're not very bright are you?
How can you used a kid as human shield
John Goodmans character must have gained weight after basic.
I am conviced, the Garand makes a huge difference to any bolt action.
For sure ask any Allied soldier who had a Lee-Enfield
It's not a Garand but a M1 Carbine. And it's definitely a huge step tactically speaking. There are archives of the Germans speaking about how their men were way more effective with the STG44 than with the Kar98 because they could keep firing while moving, instead of having to stop, "unshoulder" their rifle, cycle the bolt manually and shoulder it again.
Yeah semi auto is big step up to bolt action. Here he is using M1 carbine. Would honestly be good gun for the time for urban combat. Way better than the full power bolt actions generally used. Garand also is maybe the best general issue rifle of the war.
This is TH-cam. Stop beeping swear words in war movies.
Ridicolous.
God that is the most annoying censer beep in the world.
i only graduated high school because of this movie
Really bleeping out the audio screw this channel
Man, to be led off by the ear. Harsh.
Why bleep the words?
ruined the scene.
Good lad
Why is it there so many fucking bleeps are there ?
Its actually called Fire and Movement.
Bounding overwatch.
It's also called "war sucks"
Had to downvote due to the ridiculous censorship. Makes it unbearable to watch.
70 year olds cast as soldiers. Good to see Hollywood staying consistent.
Next up: Harrison Ford in Romeo and Juliet.
Fuck the censorship
2:01
Does anyone know what language he is speaking?
It's French, he is French, but there's almost no way to tell with the stupid censorship.
He's saying shit in French
Canadian
@@stretchedout6600 the actor is definitely French
This was one of the worst movies I’ve ever seen at a cinema.
The scene - mediocre. The beeping - WTF? Are americans this immature?
i love goodman but hes too old for this role its ridiculous putting old ass men in war movies as soldiers
Stop with these annoying beeeep ... This the part of the movie, for god sake !!!!!!!!
Give him to the soviets
Truly fiction, in real life the kid would have been shot on the spot.
I can only wonder how the encounter with the kid would turn out if it was with the Soviets instead, i don't want to imagine that.
@@Juggernogger64 US soldiers would have shot him without a doubt. In war nobody cares and must not care about age of the enemy.
Soviet, American, Italian, French, British any seasoned soldier would shoot the kid take the rifle look for weapons, ammunition food, maps, negotiables, clean dry underwear, socks, undershirts, boots. Nothing has changed in warzones since Genghis Khan except the technology.
@@Juggernogger64 And why is that? Because they are evil? Christ propaganda has rotted you people's brains.
@@Juggernogger64 yeah, imagine bombing vietnamese kids with napalm, truly bad people
Mr Grantham saves art
why would they send children to italy?
hm all i heard was bleeeeeeep
fucking censure!!
@Tin Man Goodmen character wouldn't of been able to run across the clearance, the carbine fires faster and has more rounds in it making it a better weapon for suppression.... i.e. fire and maneuver the foundation for modern combat. Suppressing an enemy is far more important when it's come to moving. Thus the person who can fire the most shots without reloading is the suppressor while other move forward so they are in position to make the best of the few shot they have.
You don't know military tactics , I wouldn't want a bolt action being responsible for the pinning/suppressing fire as you have 5 shots and about 2 sec between shots
Thus if the bolt action tries to suppress another bolt action, it doesn't work out too well since the enemy is feel to engage due to the slow rate of fire being used for suppression....
I mean really there is an argument to be made that an M1 Carbine would be a better close quarters weapon due to its lighter weight, shorter barrel, higher magazine capacity and ability to follow up shots more quickly. I assume the French guy is using a SMLE No4, which is able to hold ten rounds. There also was the "Mad Minute" shooting style with the SMLE that at least doubles the fire rate of the rifle at the sacrifice of accuracy, which is what you'd want when laying down suppressive fire.
Really the difference between the two weapons is small enough that it comes down to who actually is willing to close with the enemy. Which is what we see here.
@@lordofspearton8643 i.e. Goodman character not making that run lol
Lee Enfield is different though
It's a very suppressive Bolt Action rifle depending on the users due to how smoothly they can operate it for rapid fire
They can fire and cycle so quickly that the enemies thought it was a Semi auto or MG if they fired in group
Bip means m.erde means s.hit
ive never shot anyone before!
meanwhile has the rank of sergeant xd
Probably a lot of majors, colonels, and generals who never shot anyone.
maybe he comes from the starship trooper universe XD
his old sergeant was killed so he got promoted on the spot until the captain dies or find something better for him XD
The amount of shitty bleeps edited into this clip by Binge are just awfull! You can even tell the editor probably doesnt even speak a single word in German as nearly an entire line spoken in German gets bleeped out. (Around the 2:00 mark). The movie is great, but this clip was ruined.
The line was in French. Jean Dujardin is playing a frenchman and "merde" is french for shit.
bruh
Bald omg bald
Bip...blabla...bip...blabla...bip
...it's ridiculous
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEP
What were that swear word? M***e?
"Shit" in French
Was für ein Mist!!!
Aweful movie
What a ridiculous film.
Seriously an awful movie
Is the guy ,as an ally, using a Kar 98?
Which guy ? Which ally ?
Are you the center of the universe ? Can you reach my words on top of your high puffed smoky ivory siege ?
this is a lee enfield rifle the french soldier is using
@@PierreLucSex who are you ?
@@haydentenno6773 I am an honorable citizen of the most important country in the world, the light above all lights, the pinnacle or freedom, peace, harmless science, and vegetable pizzas.
A 14 year old pulling the trigger is the same as a 30 year old.