@@Mangela_Erkel We are downhill. "Made in Germany" is history. The new Germans don't know about history, especially our own. Schools got really bad. Teachers have to follow standards and care more for fancy pedagogy than to TEACH children! Just one generation and we are f***ed up completely!
What you should take from this, most medium quality tools are more than strong enough if used as intended. Don't waste money on expensive tools, spend it on buying the right tool for the job.
Eh depends. If you're a tradesman you want tools that will last you through years of abuse and also have quirks that make your job a little easier. Yeah I could buy cheap wire strippers that get the job done and will last a long time but they suck the entire time I use them and make life just a little more difficult than it has to be every single time because they don't have a snug fit around the wire. Or even something as simple as a cheap temperature probe, it takes forever to get to the current temperature and when it finally gets there I wonder if I can even trust it. Compare that to a nice Fieldpiece dual temperature sensor that is nearly instant and very accurate. Better tools are definitely worth the extra money if you use them often.
@@jdthesexpert05 I totaly agree with you. And also even for homework I prefer better tools. My father has collected some really good tools, same like his father and he gave it to me. Now I collect good quality tools too and I will gave them to my son. Average quality tools are for average skilled guys which more likely call profesional on the job then do it by their own.
@@StoneInMySandal He is correct though. Unless you routinely abuse a wrench on rusty worn bolts with a huge extension, buying a premium one is a waste of money. The medium quality (cheap but brand name) tools at my job have lasted over 20 years with no signs of wear.
The shape of the open-end wrench (Maulschlüssel in my Language) from the Milwaukee one gives it more grip compared to the rest. Thats an advantage, that makes the comparison not really fair. The others had practically the same shape. Beside that, after it boiled down to Germany vs. USA, Würth was close second to a far heavier, more than 3times more expensive Wrench. Personally, i would choose the Würth Wrench. If they add the open-end from milwaukee, it would probably be even closer. Also i have to say....there are some flaws in the comparability, since the wrenches had different angles and pressure-points while being pressed, which affects the applied forces.
It’s not an advantage that’s just a good design, so it’s unfair, because it was a comparison and better designing is a big point, for deciding which one’s the best.
@@Ichbins_Tim_04 watch the Video again. Compare how many contact areas the wrenches have. The US wrench has far more contact and that gives it more Grip compared to the Rest. You may call it Design, but this Design gives it an Advantage. And yes....that makes it unfair.
Question is, if the forces here are relevant to real life? If not I would also take the cheaper and lighter German version, especially if you think about carrying a larger set.
@@djbeste the max forces? most likely no. But these are Tools for all kinds of craftsman. Sooner or later, someone will use them for Tasks, that they are not meant for. So durability is important. A good Toolset can last for Decades, if treated well.
@@rapidrrobert4333 True, however there are times when it's better to have the wrench rather than the fastener fail! That's why it's always a good idea to keep some cheap, disposable tools around!
@@chiefdenis Simply not true. If you use them to make a living you don't want to run to the store halfway through a suspension replacement. But I do agree for a hobbyist.
price comparison is unfair, becasue thanks to communist regime, no real environmental standart control, concentration camp labor and more, china can always be cheaper at same quality if needed.
While price is probably indicative, I'd pay more attention to the geometry there. The Milwaukee wrench has an entirely different one compared to the other contemporary ones.
You're absolutely right. The thing is that, once you start very clearly displaying the country this "stuff" comes from, you're obviously going to make people angry. Especially when you choose to compare very cheap "stuff" with another "stuff" that's way more expensive than the rest (and happens to be American, of course). I'm pretty sure there wouldn't have been half as many angry comments if the country those wrenches were made in hadn't been mentioned.
No matter where it came from or how good it was made, an open - end wrench is only good for just so much. Even the best possible quality is going to fail somewhere.
To be fair to this creator, I've seen goofballs on TH-cam do things like buy ludicrously rare video games just for the sake of deliberately destroying them to make fans of those games upset. At least we get some insight into the [possibly lost] material science behind the things deliberately destroyed on this channel, even if plenty are also here because big hydraulic smash good.
@@AdhamMGhaly you people acting like he broke some 1820 original painting, but the wrench he broke can be purchase between 10-20 dollar on ebay, also at leats one museum already have those in stock in chattanooga.
@@alm4142 xD what 10-20 dollar lol, u can find tools like this or even double or triple older for 5$ or so, there are thousands of tools like this ones everywhere around the world. And to be honest those are not old tools, just rusted metal. which has less than 100 years for sure.
If you feel bad for inanimate wrenches... just chucks of metal in a certain shape... how do you get by during the day? Do you feel bad when people have bad hair days? Or anything related to humans?
Milwaukee’s v groove open end and fastener grooves definitely helped it grip to the Allen key better, a little unfair to the other wrenches but shows how it helps transmit more force
The Milwaukee is not comparable to the other wrenches because it is a higher tier model, they have better wrenches from those other countries as well. Taking the cheapest foreign made and comparing it to not the cheapest American made is not a fair comparison of the countries steal and design, still a good video.
@@lawrencelazaro8400 I mean, not really. Milwaukee is known for a lot of good tools, but in the trades they're not especially highly regarded for their box wrenches. If this was a Snap-On or something then I would agree, but anything you can just go buy off the shelf in Home Depot is not what I'd describe as "higher tier." Clearly they've engineered a good wrench though, for the price.
@@anssi2267 Absolutely agree. it's not just the fancy stuff like v-groove jaws, either. The Milwaukee also had the tightest tolerances for any of the "17mm" wrenches. This wasn't a contest of steel quality or national pride, but it does show that an intelligently designed and accurately manufactured tool will do better than the others
You see how the cheap Würth wrench did, now take a serious german brand like Hazet or Wera. As the germans say: "If you want good quality tools you have to spend some money, but if you want to inherit tools to your grandkids you take Hazet".
As an American I am gratified to see the US brands win hands down but... honestly I expected the German one to win so to know that it was a cheap brand... the contest may have been rigged honestly. So... ya... I'd love to see a rematch vs higher quality tools between the US and Germany.
@@rlt422 Its not a cheap brand, its just a good value commercial tool line. Stuff thats actually used in production because its affordable and solid. The Milwaukee wrench was almost 3x the price and comes from a "luxury" premium line of products. Arguably unecessarily strong for normal use but impressive nonetheless.
@@ilikeships9333 ok but consider no mechanic is going to apply that much force on a hand tool unless they put a 6 foot bar on the end of it and gorilla the thing and before that ever happens they're just going to reach for the impact driver. For $4 the german tool is good enough and a way better value
Your video was interesting as always. However, torque plays a major role in this comparison. Thus, you would always have to choose the same distance to the head. In addition, the tool can do nothing if the construction fails.
I believe the distance from the allen wrench used to the pressure point of the press never changed, so the torque on the jaws should have been the same
@@johnsonpaul1914 It's possible that he tried to maintain the same distance, but it's still highly prone to error. Even being off by a few millimeters would have a significant effect on the results, and the way the press encounters different contact points with the wrench as it pushes down due to the wrench's shape pretty much guarantees that this won't be very accurate. It's still interesting though; not crapping on the video, just suggesting a better method.
If you're a professional tradesman that uses the tools 15-20 times a day the better quality is a good investment. If you're a home repairman that uses the tools 15-20 times over the 30-40 years you own them, maybe not so much.
@@robertorobertes7630 have you ever wondered how they do that? Send products half way around the world and sell it for less than it could be made in your own home town? Again, imagine all the resources consumed through that entire process. Somebody's getting the shaft. There and here. In more ways than one. This whole money thing has gotten way out of control.
You wont bend or break a 17mm Allen key from a name-brand manufacturer with hand tools. Go take a look how large 17mm actually is - 16mm is the same size as 5/8"
@@austinjohnson8900 - yeah, 17mm hardened steel (not tungsten carbide, that would shatter). The properly engineered hex keys are incredible things - I remember the original Hex Keys and Fasteners were termed "Unbrako" (brand name) which still exists today. My dad engineered large printing presses that used them for high-stress applications, and it was amazing how long a helper bar you could put on one. They act almost like a spring, and feel very strange when you really lean on one - at a certain point they actually twist rather than snap or strip to socket. I think that the Torsional Yield on a 5/8" (smaller than 17mm) Unbrako wrench is approximately 900 ft/lb of torque, but I may have the equation/conversions wrong.
@@hetrodoxly1203 Milwaukee tools are 100% made in the US since 1924... They are manufactured in Greenwood MS, Jackson MS, and Mukwonago WI... They just opened a new plant in West Bend WI. I think you are confused about them being bought out by Techtronic Industries...
when you keep in mind that Würth in Germany is considered to be reasonably well but they are more of an enthusiast toolmaker and if you want the real pro stuff you buy Hazet or Gedore then they did pretty well.
Or Stahlwille. I never considered Würth to be serious quality, it's barely above the stuff you get in any normal home depot. It's just a widespread and easy option for small craftsman businesses. Gedore, my company only ever bought the cheap stuff, so I got a bit of a bad bias here. Is it really on the same level as the others?
Iv been turning wrenches for a living for over 35 years and know from experience who's stuff is better than others but have always wanted to do a measured head to head test. Thanks for checking of a bucket 🤠 list Mark.
@@blackdogleg Würth is a chromium-vanadium alloy with only less material in it. With practical use, this has no drawbacks. No one will break it by hand. Milwaukee looks good. It looks like they worked hard a lot to make an even better tool, so I think it was a completely fair win.
Yes exactly. But, it also teaches that you need to spend money according to the tasks. For example, it makes no sense to spend more than 0.3 bucks if you cannot apply more than 75 kg of force, moreover, in many cases, this will not be needed - you will already break the thread by 50 kg.
@@suprematiccube7072 but on other end the strongest will last longer in the long run if you are in a trade where you are using them constantly. better steel it will just wear less " same with knives and so on" But if you are avg Joe who uses them only when needed, then cheaper tools probably a good idea. :)
The better mindset is "Will I need to use this tool a lot or on multiple occasions?" If yes, then splurge on the better tool. If you're just using it every once in a while, and the tool sits in a toolbox for months, then there's no problem at all with going to a no name cheap tool.
Exactly. Look at 4:13 how the display suddenly jumps from 75 to 95 (+27%) when the contact point goes from the eyelet on the right to the stem (?) on the left
The American 1920s wrench should not be a contestant, it was never designed for that, it was only designed for opening and closing valves. Unfair comparison as it was constructed of cast iron. the rest of the comparison is a great representation. You truly get what you pay for. Cheap is good for "In a pinch" use. But know the quality of what you're buying. I'd say for a good representation next, step up to the next level of Wrenches same size, but mid-quality. The Cheap quality we know will fail faster. Even China has better quality, Comparing it to USA built is almost unfair. That said, was there any question about what was going to fail and what was going to exceed expectations? GREAT Video AGAIN!!! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
chooseng the right 'size' tool for the job is most important. In any trade. For instance, you wouldn't use an old fasion ignition wrench set to remove the lugs from your wheel. Sometimes you can go underkilt & get away with it. But the right tool for the right job always worked best for me. The cheap version tools probably belong next to the sewing kit
That 1920s wrench is an International Harvester. I have the exact one, but the stamping is still visible. They were given out with every tractor/implement as a universal "the only wrench you'll need" to work on their equipment.
TH-cam suggested me this video from absolutely nowhere and guess what, I watched it for absolutely no reason. 😅🙈 I discovered a fact that I was more keen to see what happened next for certain country's make. So, good job makers of the video. You labelled the tools by Country than by material. You know what can keep your viewers glued to your video. 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Damn good endorsement for Milwaukee wrenches after all that abuse you put it through you still have a perfectly good working wrench at the end. Always had good luck with Milwaukee tools
Virtually always worth the price. You'll have the same tools decades from now if they're made by Milwaukee. Every time I buy something from someone else, there is a point where it gets put to the test and I just go right back to the old solid lineup I know will hold up.
Stahlwille have one of the best tools for brake lines, springs and other great tools. But standard quality about wrench in Germany is still Hazet or Gedore. Is like about pliers, Hazet, Gedore or stahlwille didn't make pliers like Knipex and all other didn't make wrench tools like Hazet or Gedore. At the end is the quality from KS tools, bgs and so stuff good quality at this segment, but not standard at Germany
Milwaukee is considered a top end brand in North America but I am surprised they used it because over here, whether you're working on a little locomotive next to the Panama canal or a front end loader up in Prudhoe Bay, all mechanics day dream about having a full set of tools from Snap-On but then they curse about how much they cost and instead opt to feed their family instead of their tool addiction.
Thank you so much for the Video. It is so hypnotising to watch. I can not STOP... 👍👍👍 TH-cam is full of content where things are being build and created in an orderly way and people show off what they have got as well as what they have build and what effort they have put into it. Priding them selves. I am sick of it. It is great to see instead things being systematically distroyed and demolished in an orderly way and that to great success!!! KEEP ON GOING!!!... 👍👍👍
Some of the craziest wrenches I ever encountered were some weird old rather cheap open end wrenches made in India from some exotic India alloy. I used one trying to break a nut loose and it was all I had that fit so I was going way beyond all torque range but it broke one of the jaws and it sounded like a gun when it broke and I never found the jaw piece. Pure violence.
An normal 17mm hex headed bolt has ~10mm shaft diameter and will probably not withstand ~250Nm (five time the force that is recommended on 8.8 stainless steel quality) and about 100 kg at .25 m distance.
If you multiply 20 million jigawatts that's what you get .See what I'm saying. Just use quantum physics and you'll get the correct answer. Wait a minute. what were we talking about ?
Yep. If such a bolt did not go at gravity force of 100 KG at 0.25m (1000 Newtons force, 250Nm torque) you better do something other than forcing it further. Too much torque may shear the bolt head or worse, squeeze shear the board between the bolt and nuts. I'm civil engineer. Too much specs on one place makes no sense as others would be the weak spot. (If you are using bolts not on steel structures but machines, they usually have torque requirements which you SHALL obey)
My dad was a mechanic/machinist. He taught me to buy the best you can afford, and when you really need it, it will work. I have good wrenches thatI purchased in the eighties, and they are still like new. Never let me down. This is just more proof of that.
Thanks for pointing that out, as an American tradesman I wouldn't have known that. But to be honest I guessed it from the price that it wasn't a genuine- apples to apples - comparison and a little more of a- apple to crabapple - comparison. Milwaukee is a a top end brand here in North America and considering the region's history and demographics it would've been more fun to see our Germans competing against your Germans on a level playing field price-wise : )
Even the Zebra tools are not manufactured by Würth. They just buy the tools from various high quality manufacturers like Facom from France and brand them with Würth Zebra. The Red Line is sometimes even imported from China. Don't get me wrong. The Würth Zebra tools are very high quality professional tools but not necessarily a german made tool. Stahlwille, Gedore or Hazet would be the brands to go with for a test like this.
Many people would consider “ snap-on” tools to be the best. But that may be marketing because Milwaukee makes great tools! But I each brand has their fan boys. There are also several other brands that come close. But I would love to see a high end versus high end video, across all makes and all countries. So long as the quality of the tool is there!
Back in my auto mechanic days I would by cheap wrenches on sale for making specialty tools for hard to get places. I'd bend then and grind them so they would fit where I needed them. No matter how little I paid for them I never broke on unless I was beating the crap out of it with a great big hammer.
This, real life experience. Kudos, we do the same with tools in my workshop in Argentina (more related to trucks, farm machines and general metal works).
It seems like every wrench was strong enough to resist plastic deformation until after its open end lost its grip. I don't know what more you need than that. I'd say they're all good enough except the one whose box end snapped.
Crazy, the Milwaukee tool didn’t look like it started yielding at all. The hex stock started to visibly deflect in torsion. I bet that tool could have pushed back a lot harder than it did in the shot if the setup had been more ridgid
naja... mit Würth wurde ja ein Schlüssel eingekauft, der bei Facom bzw. einem seiner Untermarken hergestellt wurde. Hat also so viel "Germany" drin wie "USA" in den Milwaukee-Akkuschraubern. Interessant wäre es erst dann geworden, wenn Hazet / Gedore / Stahlwille im Vergleich gewesen wäre. Aber so ist es halt immer mit diesen "Tests/Vergleichen"
Because torque was applied on the side, not from the bottom as the others tools. You Can not trust this test, maybe Milwaukee its weaker, he should repeat the test using the same torque in the same spot in all of them
Yeah, because this testing setup has a major flaw. The hex key is not correctly fixated. You can see it multiple times, not only at the Milwaukee, that the hex key jumps out of the clamp.
Great video, although as a tools lover it's just break my heart to see the tools get destroyed. Also, can I have a request to have different country's tools comparison but relatively equal price? 🤔 Just want to know which product has best cost efficient. Thanks
As far as I know the one from Germany was very low quality. Some of the best German ones are from Bosch, Brüder Mannesmann and BGS which are in a similar price range as the US brand shown in this video.
@@mercedesking6800 Brüder Mannesmann is the cheapest shit you can buy and mostly far east imports. What about Stahlwille, Hazet etc real made in Germany brands
and the distance between where the tool connec tot eh nut/bolt to where teh press press touch teh tool have to be teh same on all case, if not then teh torque that each tool put on the bolt/nut will be different.
Milwaukee is not produced in USA. Most of their spanners are made by Toptul in Taiwan. Wurth is also a rebrand of different companies. Some spanners and ratchets are made in Taiwan, some sockets are made in Japan by Koken. I even have some old Wurth spanners that are made by Facom.
@@Rimrock300 I disagree. In these cases what you pay is the brand. You can buy spanners from Toptul for lower price. Same design, same quality and specs. The reason why Milwaukee is more expensive is because it is a well known brand, while Toptul is barely known and people question its quality. So for them to sell any spanners, they need to go with lower price.
@@Rimrock300 Actually, historically that wasn't the case. And I would say it's still true to a smaller degree today, that certain countries are happy with wider tolerances when they manufacture their tools. It's a cost savings measure, and countries that produce cheap tools can't be bothered with tighter tolerances. Also in decades past, China produced tools with inferior steels and cheaper alloys. That's largely gone today, but still worrying.
@@aquarius5264 quality over quantity. Pay your workers a decent wage and using superior quality steel cost more money. Buy 5 cheap wrenches that will eventually break or one that could last a lifetime.
@@NoRdIcRaGe Kommt drauf an. Habe hier einen Gedore Rollgabelschlüssel (der schon alleine wegen des Preises) nicht überzeugt (zu viel Spiel). Es soll aber durchaus noch gute Gedore Produkte geben. Ich persönlich bevorzuge trotzdem Hazet und Stahlwille.
Würth is a german retailer that is often using companies like Facom to produce. My favorite german wrench companies are Hazet and Stahlwille. We have a complete Hazet metric set at home and we never destroyed one (even with abuse). Before you destroy the tool, you will destroy the bolt. Greetings from germany.
Milwaukee is a product from a different price level. Among the German products, it will find many much better than the tested basic Wurth. Like Gedore, Hazet, Stahlwille, Matador and more.
Not really. You can't find a United States wrench for more than 10 bucks. Our tools are just more expensive. It doesn't matter where they come from. You'd have to import tools and while it might cost you five bucks in Germany, It could cost you $50 in the United States
Look at the kg counts. Are you really going to put like 80+ kg on a 17 mm wrench (for 10 mm bolts)? The bolts would normally break sooner than your tools.
Nice to know tool quality has improved since we learned to fly and go to the moon. For me I avoid the ultra cheap and the ultra pricey and look for something with a lifetime warranty. I do buy some Harbor Freight tools when its for a one time job.
I've got a Quinn ratchet set from Harbor Freight that stays under the seat in my truck. Good enough for occasional use and if I lose it, it was cheap enough not to hurt my feelings ;) I've got impact sockets from HF that I've been using for years with no complaints whatsoever.
I have a few thoughts on this enjoyable video: BTW I paid $169 for a set of 30 Milwaukee Wrenches 15 Metric, 15 SAE six months ago. I upgraded from a cheap Chinese set not for the box ends which were sufficient even on my cheap set, but for the open ends. That's the end that separates the higher quality wrenches from the cheaper ones. A 17mm bolt head only needs about 50 lb-ft of torque... This is roughly 90lbs (41 kg) applied at 6 3/4 inches* But no one wants the wrench to come close to failure while doing a normal job, so let's throw in a factor of 2 and say that any wrench that manages twice that value: 82 kg, should get a pass. I think the video is great and I do consider my Milwaukee Wrenches to be about five times sexier than the old 22 piece for $27 Chinese set that I bought at O'Reilly Auto...but this test was very hard on the wrenches and, again, any that made 82+ kg might deserve some respect. *Length measurements from my 17mm Milwaukee Combination Wrench. (From the center of the open end to the opposite size marking. I don't believe the distance from press to hex is changing, the contact point changes some, changing the lever arm, and the angle of the wrenches changes, but I think they are all close to horizontal when it matters.
I’m not sure the Milwaukee wrench exactly failed in the first test. Rather it was strong enough to pull the bar stock out of your jig… which couldn’t have been too easy. Of course, I’m an American and I might be a bit biased… but hey. 😉🤣 For whatever reason I LOVE watching these. There’s something sort of relaxing about it, which is strange because of all things - why would watching destructive testing be relaxing?! LOL
i dont think this comparisson says anything, in order to have a fair comparison you'd need to use tools of the same weight (so you have tools of similar mass) and the same lenght (so you apply similar torque to them using this method) lastly similar prices so that they have similar quality it was fun to watch tho!
@@AndrewHadi07 im pretty sure the point of a comparisson like this is to compare the quality of the craftmanship of tools in different countries, and to have a good comparisson you gotta have similar tools if price/performance was the point then you'd still need similar tools, because i can compare a plastic toy wrench to a steel one and it would work just as well as a comparisson with your criteria
Wera is a hyped company that is producing in Czech republic. I prefer Hazet and Stahlwille for wrenches. Nevertheless I have roughly 200 Wera Bits here (Toolcheck+, Bitcheck Impactor/Universal/Wood...) and I am happy with their durability.
I think those wrenches would be similar to the American Milwaukee wrench. he wouldn't find the limit of quality wrenches like that, but, he would find the limit of how well the vice was clamped to the press table. (how about that hex key!!!)
Japanese wrenches are some of the best fit wise as well as quality for metric!! Still using the same one my dad was using in 2004 when he got his tundra. And the tundra is now mine dont use any other set of wrenches
If you are putting this level of force on your wrench you are superman. Any of these will do the job for me. I have a breaker bar and impact sockets for 100 plus ft lbs torque.... I'm never really going to get enough leverage on my wrenches to break them. I will buy Milwaukee from now on though
You MAY need to use such a torque to loose a rusty bolt. Also striking the end of wrench with a hammer would apply a huge amount of spike torque to the bolt. Whether you should or worth do such an action is another question.
@@Arltratlo if germans really cared about quality they would make cars that dont leak oil and dont have electrical issues on its first drive from the dealership
@@sixunity1171 There were times (70s-90s) where german cars were really top notch. Suddenly the car companies in germany like VW, BMW, Audi, Mercedes and so on decided to stop producing in such a high quality level. Instead they've built in weakspots so they earn money from repairing in their workshops or people buying new cars because their old cannot be repaired economically. This happens all over the world and has to do with market systems, because if the market is satisfied you cannot sell your product anymore, no matter how good it is. In your case you seemed to have a bad dealer, because usually the cars are designed to weaken after a couple years or miles driven.
very cool concept, but the linear force is not that we're using, in fact, the arme is followig the tool, and the resulting force is angular. and, the thin oxide coat must be cleaned before test ;) Congratulation for the good job, material resistance must be compare again, but we can the see they are not egal in quality ! (sorry for my poor english, I'm french, haha)
Thing is though a lot of Russia's stuff was made in other parts of the USSR. Not Russia itself. It's Ukraine, Poland, etc who had the facilities and skills.
@@BlatentlyFakeName "lot of Russia's stuff was made in other parts of the USS" nope also poland is never part of ussr this is also nonsense, the Russians have the most skill, resources and capabilities. Any thing the Poles have always yielded to us in everything, and everything that the Ukraine invented by the Bolsheviks had, which never existed before 1922, it had only thanks to us
@@dropanukeonusaagain6606 They don't have much skill of their own. Not much of their stuff was actually made in Russia. The electrical components come from Japan and Korea, the hardware from Ukraine. Even the Moskva (now on special underwater operations) was made in Ukraine.
8:11 😱🤔 parece que esa es la buena. 13:26 🤔 parece buena opción. Serían buenos más vídeos poniendo a prueba la resistencia de otras herramientas u objetos de seguridad y uso cotidiano.
@@santiagoelsantos645 concuerdo, esos pequeños milímetros de diferencia, pueden hacer que una herramienta pueda ejercer mejor su trabajo, incluso diría que no a todas las herramientas se les ejercicio el mismo problema, a la más vieja y con forma extraña prácticamente estaba ejercicio un gran torque pero el oxido también debilita la fuerza del material (además no se sabe de si procedía de una buena fabricación o solo era de las chafas de ese tiempo)
You cannot possibly compare a Milwaukee wrench with a common german wrench, it's like comparing McDonalds with a Michelin star restaurant. At least try a Hazet/Knipex/Hera/Stahlwille wrench...
Milwaukee tools aren't anywhere near top end tools in the US; they're a lower to mid-level big box store brand. If you are talking true high end professional tools, you'd be looking at Snap-On, MAC, Cornwell or Matco. Hazet and Stahlwille would probably slide somewhere between Milwaukee and the brands like Snap-On.
LOL calling Milwaukee tools high end, they're considered consumer grade. No professional would use them unless they were starting out and couldn't afford something better.
Milwaukee tools are not considered premium by anyone in the US. Milwaukee is just a cheap common brand, we don’t really have any thing sold for cheaper here in the states. If I wanted a 4 dollar wrench, I would have to buy from a Chinese website.
Aquí en Francia es lo que siempre compro porque son garantizadas "de por vida". Nunca me han fallado pero tampoco he puesto mis llaves bajo tanta presión. Hay que ver
The distance between the hex key and the press plunger was equal in each comparison. Pay attention, maybe you will understand what everyone else can see.
Here's what I got from this video: - 1.2$ Chinese wrench versus 14$ American wrench (10x more expensive). That's literally like comparing a 20,000$ Kia with a 200,000$ Lamborghini (10x times more expensive). You better hope the expensive stuff is better. - 187 gram American wrench against against 118 gram Chinese wrench and 119 gram German wrench. That is, more than 50% heavier; or 50% more steel used in the tool. Of course the heavier tool will perform better; that's why they use gigantic Caterpillar 6090 FS Excavators in the mining industry instead of tiny Bobcat E10s. So, no, the American wrench is not better engineered than the other wrenches; it's just bigger. - You could get 40 "no name" wrenches (0.3$) for the price of one American wrench (14$)... and leave the store with change. Those are tools designed for DIYers, who are unlikely to use those wrenches on a daily basis; let alone apply the amount of force that was necessary to break those wrenches as shown in the video. And if you're a professional, you're definitely not going to buy Milwaukee or Wurth. In other words, the American wrench is way overpriced for what it's designed for; and the "no name" wrench would do the job it was designed for in 99% of the cases. It pains to say this, but, all in all, the Chinese wrench has the best value for money considering the use 99% of customers will have for that wrench. In conclusion, after watching this video, I'd personally buy either the "no name" wrench or the Wurth wrench (just because I don't want to support the Chinese or Russian economy).
The open end test wasn't really fair since the Milwaukee one had "teeth" and the rest were smooth....but the closed end test was fair all around and showed the quality of the Milwaukee wrench.
@@namastelana5586 You can find a wrench of the same quality for cheaper. All you get with the price of these big name tools is another CEO with a yacht
Interesting video. But I don’t know what job I’ll need to put the wrench strength to it’s full potential. So far I have stay with the reasonable priced. It works every time. My consideration is always the one will not rust easily, which the cheapest tends to be the worst.
The Milwaukee tool might have gotten the highest values in those test but let's not forget a few important aspects here. No person would effectively produce that high numbers so probably any of the wrenches are good to go. Further, the Milwaukee was the only one with a proper nominal size and basically any tool failed at that point cause they lost grip. Regarding the weight, probably a few tools would have outperformed the Milwaukee one as well. And most of the price tag on the American one is probably the polishing and engraving on the tool. it's still just a basic wrench using more material and made shiny.
Have you ensured prior to testing them that the distance between the press and the mounting point for the wrench is always the same? If there's a difference in the distance, there will be a difference in the leverage.
The only problem I have with this is that "USA" tool is just a cheap Taiwanese manufactured knock off of an actual US made Snap-On flank drive wrench.... Not exactly saying it's a bad wrench for the money but it kind of defeats the purpose of comparing tools by country if it's "American" in brand name only. It would have been a more fair comparison to see an actual US made tool here.
Snap-on in not US made either it is also a import tool just like 95% of what the US sales. as stated from snap-on them self. Only certain Snap-On tools are still made in the USA. Most hand tools are still made in their facilities in Milwaukee and other U.S. manufacturing locations, but products like their cordless power drill kit are made in China, among other countries. More details below.
@@failatthis5169 As stated from snap-on them self? "Snap-On CEO says ’80% of what we sell off the trucks here in America’ is made in the U.S." The vast majority of what Snap-on sells is made here in the US including the wrench's in question which is what is relevant. While I am aware there are a few items made outside the US, the same would apply to them. It's not reasonable to call it an "American" tool when there's nothing American about it but a brand name.
@@andybilakshow260 I would debate that. Marketing wizards like to throw terms like that around to make you feel better about it but what does it really mean? I work in an industry that does contract manufacturing and typically the way the process works is the customer has a set of design requirements. Each set to include what sizes, company logo, costs, size, finish, packaging ect. The manufacturer reads these requirements and drafts a proposed blueprint as for how they intend to meet those requirements. The key here is manufacturer is the one doing the real engineering. They are determining the materials and processes that will be used in the final product. Not to mention, they are the ones actually doing the manufacturing. A great design is meaningless if they are not manufactured to spec. The point, is 99% of the output result is determined by the skill of the manufacturer.
I think, German made good quality for an affordable price.
Cause we dont have time to find the spare Tool, we are germans. One Tool for one purpose for a lifetime. ;)
@@Mangela_Erkel We are downhill. "Made in Germany" is history. The new Germans don't know about history, especially our own. Schools got really bad. Teachers have to follow standards and care more for fancy pedagogy than to TEACH children! Just one generation and we are f***ed up completely!
Rusia
@@muesique true Story bro. "Mit denen gewinnt man kein krieg"
@@Mangela_Erkel ;) leider. Aber es gibt noch ein paar Perlen. Wird ein schwerer Neuanfang. Aber das gute läßt sich nicht ausrotten!
What you should take from this, most medium quality tools are more than strong enough if used as intended. Don't waste money on expensive tools, spend it on buying the right tool for the job.
If shear strength was the only quality criteria of a tool you’d be correct.
Eh depends. If you're a tradesman you want tools that will last you through years of abuse and also have quirks that make your job a little easier. Yeah I could buy cheap wire strippers that get the job done and will last a long time but they suck the entire time I use them and make life just a little more difficult than it has to be every single time because they don't have a snug fit around the wire. Or even something as simple as a cheap temperature probe, it takes forever to get to the current temperature and when it finally gets there I wonder if I can even trust it. Compare that to a nice Fieldpiece dual temperature sensor that is nearly instant and very accurate. Better tools are definitely worth the extra money if you use them often.
Isn't the mantra "Buy cheap once."
@@jdthesexpert05 I totaly agree with you. And also even for homework I prefer better tools. My father has collected some really good tools, same like his father and he gave it to me. Now I collect good quality tools too and I will gave them to my son. Average quality tools are for average skilled guys which more likely call profesional on the job then do it by their own.
@@StoneInMySandal He is correct though. Unless you routinely abuse a wrench on rusty worn bolts with a huge extension, buying a premium one is a waste of money. The medium quality (cheap but brand name) tools at my job have lasted over 20 years with no signs of wear.
Millwauke did great it didnt open up even with this high load. But a better fair competion would be Stahlwille,Gedore or Hazet
The Milwaukee open end also has teeth and the others were just smooth. Not a fair comparison in that test.
I would have used a Snapon spanner for the USA test
@@bonza167 Snapon is overpriced garbage
Milwaukee is made in China now anyways.
It seems to be made from a different alloy as well judged by the appearance and weight.
The shape of the open-end wrench (Maulschlüssel in my Language) from the Milwaukee one gives it more grip compared to the rest. Thats an advantage, that makes the comparison not really fair. The others had practically the same shape.
Beside that, after it boiled down to Germany vs. USA, Würth was close second to a far heavier, more than 3times more expensive Wrench. Personally, i would choose the Würth Wrench.
If they add the open-end from milwaukee, it would probably be even closer.
Also i have to say....there are some flaws in the comparability, since the wrenches had different angles and pressure-points while being pressed, which affects the applied forces.
It’s not an advantage that’s just a good design, so it’s unfair, because it was a comparison and better designing is a big point, for deciding which one’s the best.
@@Ichbins_Tim_04 watch the Video again. Compare how many contact areas the wrenches have.
The US wrench has far more contact and that gives it more Grip compared to the Rest.
You may call it Design, but this Design gives it an Advantage.
And yes....that makes it unfair.
Question is, if the forces here are relevant to real life? If not I would also take the cheaper and lighter German version, especially if you think about carrying a larger set.
@@djbeste the max forces? most likely no.
But these are Tools for all kinds of craftsman. Sooner or later, someone will use them for Tasks, that they are not meant for. So durability is important. A good Toolset can last for Decades, if treated well.
Milwaukee Chines owned for nearly 20 years and made in China. WÜRTH CHINA make their spanners.
I love how the Allen key/vise failed before the Milwaukee did. Yea... They're expensive but it's for a reason.
You have to break a few cheap tools before you understand why buying the best can really save a lot of frustration. This applies to EVERYTHING.
@@rapidrrobert4333 True, however there are times when it's better to have the wrench rather than the fastener fail! That's why it's always a good idea to keep some cheap, disposable tools around!
No one needs a wrench that strong for that much
@@chiefdenis Simply not true. If you use them to make a living you don't want to run to the store halfway through a suspension replacement. But I do agree for a hobbyist.
@@chiefdenis $14 isn't even that much. Mac Tools is around $25 and Snap On is $50 for one wrench.
I'd like to have a comparison between a Milwaukee wrench and a german Hazet or Gedore wrench. These are more of a competitor based on the price
Actually, it’s pronounced “mill-e-wah-que” which is Algonquin for “the good land”. (Alice Cooper)
But in this case it is the channel owner who would not have a comparison...
Stahlwille
price comparison is unfair, becasue thanks to communist regime, no real environmental standart control, concentration camp labor and more, china can always be cheaper at same quality if needed.
While price is probably indicative, I'd pay more attention to the geometry there. The Milwaukee wrench has an entirely different one compared to the other contemporary ones.
It seems like some people here are forgetting this is a "let's put stuff in a hydraulic press" channel, and not a "wrench review channel".
@Check my about page link can’t sorry I’m blind
You're absolutely right. The thing is that, once you start very clearly displaying the country this "stuff" comes from, you're obviously going to make people angry. Especially when you choose to compare very cheap "stuff" with another "stuff" that's way more expensive than the rest (and happens to be American, of course).
I'm pretty sure there wouldn't have been half as many angry comments if the country those wrenches were made in hadn't been mentioned.
@@johnjohnson6090 why we should care about angry people though? I will refer this video to see which wrench i want 😂
@@dx7255 Because... that's what the initial comment was about... And I was merely replying to his comment.
No matter where it came from or how good it was made, an open - end wrench is only good for just so much. Even the best possible quality is going to fail somewhere.
Feels sad watching old tools be deliberately destroyed, even if they had not been used in decades or ever.
To be fair to this creator, I've seen goofballs on TH-cam do things like buy ludicrously rare video games just for the sake of deliberately destroying them to make fans of those games upset. At least we get some insight into the [possibly lost] material science behind the things deliberately destroyed on this channel, even if plenty are also here because big hydraulic smash good.
Totally agree. Some of those belong to museums.
@@AdhamMGhaly you people acting like he broke some 1820 original painting, but the wrench he broke can be purchase between 10-20 dollar on ebay, also at leats one museum already have those in stock in chattanooga.
@@alm4142 xD what 10-20 dollar lol, u can find tools like this or even double or triple older for 5$ or so, there are thousands of tools like this ones everywhere around the world. And to be honest those are not old tools, just rusted metal. which has less than 100 years for sure.
If you feel bad for inanimate wrenches... just chucks of metal in a certain shape... how do you get by during the day? Do you feel bad when people have bad hair days? Or anything related to humans?
Milwaukee’s v groove open end and fastener grooves definitely helped it grip to the Allen key better, a little unfair to the other wrenches but shows how it helps transmit more force
I do not see it as unfair. Better design = better result.
The Milwaukee is not comparable to the other wrenches because it is a higher tier model, they have better wrenches from those other countries as well. Taking the cheapest foreign made and comparing it to not the cheapest American made is not a fair comparison of the countries steal and design, still a good video.
@@lawrencelazaro8400 I mean, not really. Milwaukee is known for a lot of good tools, but in the trades they're not especially highly regarded for their box wrenches. If this was a Snap-On or something then I would agree, but anything you can just go buy off the shelf in Home Depot is not what I'd describe as "higher tier." Clearly they've engineered a good wrench though, for the price.
@@anssi2267 Absolutely agree. it's not just the fancy stuff like v-groove jaws, either. The Milwaukee also had the tightest tolerances for any of the "17mm" wrenches. This wasn't a contest of steel quality or national pride, but it does show that an intelligently designed and accurately manufactured tool will do better than the others
@@lawrencelazaro8400 I would not consider that a higher tier model really, it is decidedly average
You see how the cheap Würth wrench did, now take a serious german brand like Hazet or Wera.
As the germans say: "If you want good quality tools you have to spend some money, but if you want to inherit tools to your grandkids you take Hazet".
Its Würth Red Line which is the cheap bulk line of products. I dont think Würth makes a premium line because they are not in that market.
As an American I am gratified to see the US brands win hands down but... honestly I expected the German one to win so to know that it was a cheap brand... the contest may have been rigged honestly. So... ya... I'd love to see a rematch vs higher quality tools between the US and Germany.
@@rlt422 really wasn't a fair comparison for any other country, comparing a high end american wrench to cheap foreign budget wrenches
@@rlt422 Its not a cheap brand, its just a good value commercial tool line. Stuff thats actually used in production because its affordable and solid.
The Milwaukee wrench was almost 3x the price and comes from a "luxury" premium line of products. Arguably unecessarily strong for normal use but impressive nonetheless.
i was hoping to see some stahlwille tools. since thats the only competition for hazet
Hydraulic press: imma destroy these wrenches
Milwaukee wrench: imma destroy this hydraulic press
that was really impressive to me, a wrench guy
They call them Milwaukee Beast for a reason.
It does cost 14 dollars but sure seems to be worth it for a mechanic.
@@ilikeships9333 ok but consider no mechanic is going to apply that much force on a hand tool unless they put a 6 foot bar on the end of it and gorilla the thing and before that ever happens they're just going to reach for the impact driver. For $4 the german tool is good enough and a way better value
@@lufusol true tbh I don’t think any mechanic would need a bolt to be that tight
Your video was interesting as always. However, torque plays a major role in this comparison. Thus, you would always have to choose the same distance to the head. In addition, the tool can do nothing if the construction fails.
Was thinking the same thing. The torque is the important thing to measure here, not the downward force on an arbitrary point along the handle.
this is a video of a Russian blogger, and this dude stole it
I believe the distance from the allen wrench used to the pressure point of the press never changed, so the torque on the jaws should have been the same
@@johnsonpaul1914 It's possible that he tried to maintain the same distance, but it's still highly prone to error. Even being off by a few millimeters would have a significant effect on the results, and the way the press encounters different contact points with the wrench as it pushes down due to the wrench's shape pretty much guarantees that this won't be very accurate. It's still interesting though; not crapping on the video, just suggesting a better method.
@@jrd603 did you watch to the end?
If you're a professional tradesman that uses the tools 15-20 times a day the better quality is a good investment. If you're a home repairman that uses the tools 15-20 times over the 30-40 years you own them, maybe not so much.
@DrGrandpa with that price? No, thanks, Russia is the best.
Im too poor to buy cheap tools..
10 món hàng của Nga sẽ bóp chết 1 món hàng của Mỹ
@@robertorobertes7630 have you ever wondered how they do that?
Send products half way around the world and sell it for less than it could be made in your own home town? Again, imagine all the resources consumed through that entire process. Somebody's getting the shaft. There and here. In more ways than one. This whole money thing has gotten way out of control.
@@mortenfaurbyegellert9564 hang in there. Help is around the corner.
the real MVP here is that Allen key that survived massive torsion loads.
i've seen them permanently twist or even break with hand loads.
You wont bend or break a 17mm Allen key from a name-brand manufacturer with hand tools. Go take a look how large 17mm actually is - 16mm is the same size as 5/8"
That allan was massive tho, solid brick a tungsten. Shit wouldn't bend if you told it's kids were diein .absolute unit
@@austinjohnson8900 - yeah, 17mm hardened steel (not tungsten carbide, that would shatter).
The properly engineered hex keys are incredible things - I remember the original Hex Keys and Fasteners were termed "Unbrako" (brand name) which still exists today. My dad engineered large printing presses that used them for high-stress applications, and it was amazing how long a helper bar you could put on one. They act almost like a spring, and feel very strange when you really lean on one - at a certain point they actually twist rather than snap or strip to socket.
I think that the Torsional Yield on a 5/8" (smaller than 17mm) Unbrako wrench is approximately 900 ft/lb of torque, but I may have the equation/conversions wrong.
@@johncoops6897 my bröther in christ I'm making an joke now *LAUGH PEASANT*
That Milwaukee is basically the phrase "if I'm going down I'm taking you with me" in the form of a wrench.
But... It didn't go down! Lol
The vice broke before the wrench did.
Milwaukee Chines owned for nearly 20 years and made in China.
@@hetrodoxly1203 Milwaukee tools are 100% made in the US since 1924... They are manufactured in Greenwood MS, Jackson MS, and Mukwonago WI... They just opened a new plant in West Bend WI.
I think you are confused about them being bought out by Techtronic Industries...
@@hetrodoxly1203 Are you talking about the Milwaukee store-brand for Harbor Freight?
Because that's a completely different company.
If I have a 100 ton hydraulic press in my garage I WILL DO THIS AT HOME. Go Milwaukee. Broke the test fixture both times and was still usable.
I also have 200 ton press in corner of living room and will try this when I get home from shopping
th-cam.com/channels/K_icgfhiCxlQuYVPW6teMg.html
It also costs considerably more than any of the other wrenches
@@tonyrichard2705 I have a 300 ton press in my bedroom closet. I'll try it too.
snapon vs mac vs matco vs cornwell
Do it and post I dare you. Double dog dare.
*waiting patiently*
when you keep in mind that Würth in Germany is considered to be reasonably well but they are more of an enthusiast toolmaker and if you want the real pro stuff you buy Hazet or Gedore then they did pretty well.
Or Stahlwille. I never considered Würth to be serious quality, it's barely above the stuff you get in any normal home depot. It's just a widespread and easy option for small craftsman businesses.
Gedore, my company only ever bought the cheap stuff, so I got a bit of a bad bias here. Is it really on the same level as the others?
Same can be said for Milwaukee. It’s not a MatCo or SnapOn. This test is fair considering Milwaukee is a box store tool brand.
@@McKay1108 Stahlwille for sure, but I would also throw in Facom
Wurth tools not manufactured in Germany.
Iv been turning wrenches for a living for over 35 years and know from experience who's stuff is better than others but have always wanted to do a measured head to head test. Thanks for checking of a bucket 🤠 list Mark.
Good old American
Absolutely gut wrenching to see those old tools get crushed.
Pun intended
Not only are the Milwaukee’s tools strong but they have a beautiful finish on them also.
It is a different process. Milwaukee wrench is Chromium... not a fair comparison.
@@Oberkommando 😂 Exactly
@@blackdogleg Würth is a chromium-vanadium alloy with only less material in it. With practical use, this has no drawbacks. No one will break it by hand. Milwaukee looks good. It looks like they worked hard a lot to make an even better tool, so I think it was a completely fair win.
@@lacikeri3102 yes Milwaukee is very good. I wonder where Grey or Snapon would fit in this.
@@Oberkommando thats low budged wrenches the high quality one cost 200$+
That is the definition of “get what you pay for”
Nice on the older wrenches 👍🏽
Yes exactly. But, it also teaches that you need to spend money according to the tasks. For example, it makes no sense to spend more than 0.3 bucks if you cannot apply more than 75 kg of force, moreover, in many cases, this will not be needed - you will already break the thread by 50 kg.
@@suprematiccube7072 but on other end the strongest will last longer in the long run if you are in a trade where you are using them constantly. better steel it will just wear less " same with knives and so on" But if you are avg Joe who uses them only when needed, then cheaper tools probably a good idea. :)
China product get best cost performance
@@kakaxifx4913 Assuming the china product doesn't contain a playhouse wrench or photograph of wrench or plastic wrench or... Well, you get the idea.
The better mindset is
"Will I need to use this tool a lot or on multiple occasions?"
If yes, then splurge on the better tool.
If you're just using it every once in a while, and the tool sits in a toolbox for months, then there's no problem at all with going to a no name cheap tool.
Sometimes this channel is the best jump scare. Things will be going smooth for most things then out of no where, something goes boom
Американският ключ е много по-здрав от това, което се показва! Браво, добър клип!
I am amazed that almost no one talks about the torque distance changing which makes the kg of force almost meaningless
That's a ridiculous statement considering how close the length is between the various wrenches
Bullshit. Torque and physics is conspiracy
@@skipdegraff6547 Try saying that after trying to use your weight on a wrench to loosen a tight nut without even a small extender 😉.
I noticed it myself, but this isn’t exactly a real scientific experiment, it’s entertainment.
Exactly. Look at 4:13 how the display suddenly jumps from 75 to 95 (+27%) when the contact point goes from the eyelet on the right to the stem (?) on the left
The American 1920s wrench should not be a contestant, it was never designed for that, it was only designed for opening and closing valves. Unfair comparison as it was constructed of cast iron.
the rest of the comparison is a great representation. You truly get what you pay for. Cheap is good for "In a pinch" use. But know the quality of what you're buying. I'd say for a good representation next, step up to the next level of Wrenches same size, but mid-quality. The Cheap quality we know will fail faster. Even China has better quality, Comparing it to USA built is almost unfair.
That said, was there any question about what was going to fail and what was going to exceed expectations?
GREAT Video AGAIN!!! 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
also waste of history in my opinion. i would just throw into cocacola and recover it :) and keep is as new just for fun.
yeah seeing the old girl break hurt...
No wrenches were American made, Milwaukee wrenches are Not made in America despite the Milwaukee USA tag
@@joe3USA he was talking about the cast iron pipe valve wrench...
Combo wrenches are the one tool a mechanic shouldn’t scrimp on, as they have proved here today. A rounded nut is a huge pita.
Agreed but I’d also say definitely get some knipex pliers just in case
I wish I had me some scrimps and some cocktail sauce lmao
@@novachannel1981 lololol you gotta try that scrimp scampi
You need it when you need it
chooseng the right 'size' tool for the job is most important. In any trade. For instance, you wouldn't use an old fasion ignition wrench set to remove the lugs from your wheel.
Sometimes you can go underkilt & get away with it. But the right tool for the right job always worked best for me. The cheap version tools probably belong next to the sewing kit
That 1920s wrench is an International Harvester. I have the exact one, but the stamping is still visible. They were given out with every tractor/implement as a universal "the only wrench you'll need" to work on their equipment.
At about 9:50 you can actually see the stress energy physically causing some of the oxide layer to shear off
Thats cool asf
🤤
@@THUNDERCAT37c ayo
With the German ring spanner, the clamping of the hexagon also failed. The ring spanner could otherwise have been further stressed.
As a German I can't stand that you chose such a cheap wrench to represent Germany
None represented America at all, Milwaukee wrenches are not made in America
If that is true it’s not fair.
@Saul Murray there is always one
@Saul Murray Gedore or Stahlwille.
@Saul Murray I have Wera screw drivers and they are sweet. But prefer Klein USA.
TH-cam suggested me this video from absolutely nowhere and guess what, I watched it for absolutely no reason. 😅🙈
I discovered a fact that I was more keen to see what happened next for certain country's make. So, good job makers of the video. You labelled the tools by Country than by material. You know what can keep your viewers glued to your video. 👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Thank you for this video. I have many Milwaukee tools. I never know how strong they are. I am very impressed.
th-cam.com/channels/K_icgfhiCxlQuYVPW6teMg.html
Damn good endorsement for Milwaukee wrenches after all that abuse you put it through you still have a perfectly good working wrench at the end. Always had good luck with Milwaukee tools
But i can't remember pushing on a wrench with a force that's over 300 kgs.
Virtually always worth the price. You'll have the same tools decades from now if they're made by Milwaukee. Every time I buy something from someone else, there is a point where it gets put to the test and I just go right back to the old solid lineup I know will hold up.
I heard the teeth wear out on the open end
Snap on...?!!!
@@85square whyle Milwaukee have theets and Smalltalk inner size they are the best on holding.
For Germany is the standard brand Gedore or Hazet. The Milwaukee looks pretty hi-tech :)
Stahlwille I am a joke to you?
Stahlwille have one of the best tools for brake lines, springs and other great tools. But standard quality about wrench in Germany is still Hazet or Gedore. Is like about pliers, Hazet, Gedore or stahlwille didn't make pliers like Knipex and all other didn't make wrench tools like Hazet or Gedore. At the end is the quality from KS tools, bgs and so stuff good quality at this segment, but not standard at Germany
Stehwill
Milwaukee is considered a top end brand in North America but I am surprised they used it because over here, whether you're working on a little locomotive next to the Panama canal or a front end loader up in Prudhoe Bay, all mechanics day dream about having a full set of tools from Snap-On but then they curse about how much they cost and instead opt to feed their family instead of their tool addiction.
@@randomperson8695 yeah, at the end chart all a lot of money.. the Milwaukee Max Bite 144 chart at Germany 100€ for 15pc / Hazet 170€ for 15pc
Thank you so much for the Video. It is so hypnotising to watch. I can not STOP... 👍👍👍
TH-cam is full of content where things are being build and created in an orderly way and people show off what they have got as well as what they have build and what effort they have put into it. Priding them selves. I am sick of it.
It is great to see instead things being systematically distroyed and demolished in an orderly way and that to great success!!!
KEEP ON GOING!!!... 👍👍👍
Some of the craziest wrenches I ever encountered were some weird old rather cheap open end wrenches made in India from some exotic India alloy.
I used one trying to break a nut loose and it was all I had that fit so I was going way beyond all torque range but it broke one of the jaws and it sounded like a gun when it broke and I never found the jaw piece.
Pure violence.
violence in mech. love it.
It sounds like just a cheap wrench. Breaking under any condition isn't at all a sign of quality
Tools come und different classes and price points in each country. A comparison of top of the line manufactures across the line would be interesting.
Exacto! Esa seria una comparacion mas justa.
Exactly, you should see how ridiculously overpriced Strap-On tools are in Australia.
Agree, but Milwaukee is not top of the line in the US.
@@ChickenShmicken I think none in this test were.you are right
@@ChickenShmicken 所谓来自中国的那个工具，在中国甚至经常被当作一次性工具使用，质量非常差价格非常低廉。我不知道为什么要进行这种不用进行就知道结果的测试。
An normal 17mm hex headed bolt has ~10mm shaft diameter and will probably not withstand ~250Nm (five time the force that is recommended on 8.8 stainless steel quality) and about 100 kg at .25 m distance.
Exactly
If you multiply 20 million jigawatts that's what you get .See what I'm saying.
Just use quantum physics and you'll get the correct answer. Wait a minute. what were we talking about ?
Yep. If such a bolt did not go at gravity force of 100 KG at 0.25m (1000 Newtons force, 250Nm torque) you better do something other than forcing it further. Too much torque may shear the bolt head or worse, squeeze shear the board between the bolt and nuts.
I'm civil engineer. Too much specs on one place makes no sense as others would be the weak spot.
(If you are using bolts not on steel structures but machines, they usually have torque requirements which you SHALL obey)
My dad was a mechanic/machinist. He taught me to buy the best you can afford, and when you really need it, it will work. I have good wrenches thatI purchased in the eighties, and they are still like new. Never let me down. This is just more proof of that.
The würth is the RED line the cheap version of würth tools you have to test the zebra tools from würth
Thanks for pointing that out, as an American tradesman I wouldn't have known that. But to be honest I guessed it from the price that it wasn't a genuine- apples to apples - comparison and a little more of a- apple to crabapple - comparison. Milwaukee is a a top end brand here in North America and considering the region's history and demographics it would've been more fun to see our Germans competing against your Germans on a level playing field price-wise : )
@@randomperson8695 right
Even the Zebra tools are not manufactured by Würth. They just buy the tools from various high quality manufacturers like Facom from France and brand them with Würth Zebra. The Red Line is sometimes even imported from China.
Don't get me wrong. The Würth Zebra tools are very high quality professional tools but not necessarily a german made tool.
Stahlwille, Gedore or Hazet would be the brands to go with for a test like this.
Many people would consider “ snap-on” tools to be the best. But that may be marketing because Milwaukee makes great tools! But I each brand has their fan boys. There are also several other brands that come close. But I would love to see a high end versus high end video, across all makes and all countries. So long as the quality of the tool is there!
@@coytheboy snap-on s are actually good. maybe a bit overpriced but still good.
Back in my auto mechanic days I would by cheap wrenches on sale for making specialty tools for hard to get places. I'd bend then and grind them so they would fit where I needed them. No matter how little I paid for them I never broke on unless I was beating the crap out of it with a great big hammer.
th-cam.com/channels/K_icgfhiCxlQuYVPW6teMg.html
This, real life experience. Kudos, we do the same with tools in my workshop in Argentina (more related to trucks, farm machines and general metal works).
Yessir! Got a few still
It seems like every wrench was strong enough to resist plastic deformation until after its open end lost its grip. I don't know what more you need than that. I'd say they're all good enough except the one whose box end snapped.
Yup, I couldn't apply more than 50kg force, so...
Can be nice try closed wrenches next time.
"I don't know what more you need than that" longevity?
Crazy, the Milwaukee tool didn’t look like it started yielding at all. The hex stock started to visibly deflect in torsion. I bet that tool could have pushed back a lot harder than it did in the shot if the setup had been more ridgid
naja... mit Würth wurde ja ein Schlüssel eingekauft, der bei Facom bzw. einem seiner Untermarken hergestellt wurde. Hat also so viel "Germany" drin wie "USA" in den Milwaukee-Akkuschraubern. Interessant wäre es erst dann geworden, wenn Hazet / Gedore / Stahlwille im Vergleich gewesen wäre. Aber so ist es halt immer mit diesen "Tests/Vergleichen"
No wrenches were American made, Milwaukee wrenches are Not made in America despite the Milwaukee USA tag
da stimme ich die zu. Next Test with Stahlwille/Gedore or Hazet Wrenches
Gotta love that Milwaukee wrench didn't really bend or break, it instead broke the setup both times lol
It was a beast
Because torque was applied on the side, not from the bottom as the others tools. You Can not trust this test, maybe Milwaukee its weaker, he should repeat the test using the same torque in the same spot in all of them
Yeah, because this testing setup has a major flaw. The hex key is not correctly fixated. You can see it multiple times, not only at the Milwaukee, that the hex key jumps out of the clamp.
Because it had a different style with "teeth" in there to grip it, all the others were smooth from the inside so they slipped easier as you saw
Would that make you spend $14 as oppsed to....whatever else ?
That 1920 wrench is what I found, just a week ago, here in my shed. Hidden in an old rusty toolbox.
th-cam.com/channels/K_icgfhiCxlQuYVPW6teMg.html
Great video, although as a tools lover it's just break my heart to see the tools get destroyed.
Also, can I have a request to have different country's tools comparison but relatively equal price? 🤔 Just want to know which product has best cost efficient. Thanks
Milwaukee is maybe the best brand of tools in the USA, or at least pretty high up there overall, but are those the other countries best?
As far as I know the one from Germany was very low quality. Some of the best German ones are from Bosch, Brüder Mannesmann and BGS which are in a similar price range as the US brand shown in this video.
Don’t forget hazet
Beta, Facom, Snap-on, Würth (not the red line).
@@mercedesking6800 Brüder Mannesmann is the cheapest shit you can buy and mostly far east imports. What about Stahlwille, Hazet etc real made in Germany brands
Milwaukee is run of the mill
A 4$ tool vs a 14$ is really fair
and the distance between where the tool connec tot eh nut/bolt to where teh press press touch teh tool have to be teh same on all case, if not then teh torque that each tool put on the bolt/nut will be different.
@@yia01 yep thats a major flaw in this test
True but it's more the made in test though, hard to find a made in USA less in 14.
Take a 14$ German was a 20$ us
The German will win. Würth is not really the yellow from the egg
cheaper tools are better sometimes, look at milwaukee power tools vs snap on
Milwaukee is not produced in USA.
Most of their spanners are made by Toptul in Taiwan.
Wurth is also a rebrand of different companies.
Some spanners and ratchets are made in Taiwan, some sockets are made in Japan by Koken.
I even have some old Wurth spanners that are made by Facom.
Yeah, but would you really want him to test a snap on, wrench? Same performance for 5x the price.
Doesn't matter what country, what matters is fabrication after what spec's and design.
@@Rimrock300 I disagree.
In these cases what you pay is the brand.
You can buy spanners from Toptul for lower price.
Same design, same quality and specs.
The reason why Milwaukee is more expensive is because it is a well known brand, while Toptul is barely known and people question its quality.
So for them to sell any spanners, they need to go with lower price.
@@Rimrock300 Actually, historically that wasn't the case. And I would say it's still true to a smaller degree today, that certain countries are happy with wider tolerances when they manufacture their tools. It's a cost savings measure, and countries that produce cheap tools can't be bothered with tighter tolerances. Also in decades past, China produced tools with inferior steels and cheaper alloys. That's largely gone today, but still worrying.
"Do not try this at home"
Ah damn it, i was really looking forward to use my massive press on some random tools !
Impressive, invincible Milwaukee. And the measurement doesn't even count since it destroyed the whole setup but not the tool. Twice.
And surprisingly the most accurate at a metric standard
It had advantage of little grooves in the open end that caught in the hex bit to prevent slipping allowing it to rotate the hex bit off the vise
@@donm6578 not only strong but design improvement, god bless America!
i mean of course, it's a 14 dollar wrench and most of the other ones were around 1-2 dollars
@@aquarius5264 quality over quantity. Pay your workers a decent wage and using superior quality steel cost more money.
Buy 5 cheap wrenches that will eventually break or one that could last a lifetime.
Instead of WÜRTH, a specialist in fastening technology, used a tool from GEDOR, the specialist for hand tools in Germany, for the next test.
Gedore ist auch nicht mehr das was es Mal war, wurde aufgekauft.
Yes, we also use Gedore at our BMW garage.
@@NoRdIcRaGe Kommt drauf an. Habe hier einen Gedore Rollgabelschlüssel (der schon alleine wegen des Preises) nicht überzeugt (zu viel Spiel). Es soll aber durchaus noch gute Gedore Produkte geben. Ich persönlich bevorzuge trotzdem Hazet und Stahlwille.
Knarren hab ich egal ob gedore oder alle alle schon kaputt bekommen. Schlüssel dagegen nicht egal wie fest was war
@@NoRdIcRaGe ich habe noch einen Schlüsselsatz von meinem Großvater 😆
Würth is a german retailer that is often using companies like Facom to produce. My favorite german wrench companies are Hazet and Stahlwille. We have a complete Hazet metric set at home and we never destroyed one (even with abuse). Before you destroy the tool, you will destroy the bolt. Greetings from germany.
Thank you for including my product in this video
The jaws are a lot more important than the handle, because you can always sleeve a steel pipe over that wrench to multiply your torque.
I was born in "no name". This country is quite alright.
So you're a "Nonamian"?
"no name" is equivalent to generic: generic is without a brand name, without certification and of very low quality.
@@anthonyreed3682 - and the material used is called "Nonamium".
@Esphaeras Praestans - don't forget the Nonamwomen !!
@@anthonyreed3682 Dude, I came to comment exactly that. Why you win? xD
Milwaukee is a product from a different price level. Among the German products, it will find many much better than the tested basic Wurth. Like Gedore, Hazet, Stahlwille, Matador and more.
No wrenches were American made, Milwaukee wrenches are Not made in America despite the Milwaukee USA tag
Not really. You can't find a United States wrench for more than 10 bucks. Our tools are just more expensive. It doesn't matter where they come from. You'd have to import tools and while it might cost you five bucks in Germany, It could cost you $50 in the United States
this pretty much sums up the old addage of 'buy cheap, buy twice' pricier hardware usually costs more for a damn good reason!
I actually have several of those 1920’s wrenches. Back when nuts & bolts had square heads.
No risk of rounding stuff off with those...at least no normally realistic chance
I wish you could expand the experiment by including some well-known italian wrenches such as:
- USAG
- BETA
- PASTORINO.
Watching the jaws of those cheap wrenches expanded is making me want to upgrade my wrenches a bit.
Look at the kg counts. Are you really going to put like 80+ kg on a 17 mm wrench (for 10 mm bolts)? The bolts would normally break sooner than your tools.
I like how even the close-in camera couldn't catch the moment when the allen wrench took off.
There one frame, _completely_ gone the next.
Nice to know tool quality has improved since we learned to fly and go to the moon. For me I avoid the ultra cheap and the ultra pricey and look for something with a lifetime warranty. I do buy some Harbor Freight tools when its for a one time job.
All Harbor Freight hand tools have a lifetime warranty.
@@RockandrollNegro ha. Haha.
I've got a Quinn ratchet set from Harbor Freight that stays under the seat in my truck. Good enough for occasional use and if I lose it, it was cheap enough not to hurt my feelings ;) I've got impact sockets from HF that I've been using for years with no complaints whatsoever.
Love the new line of Milwaukee hand tools, the wrenches have the same open end design as the wright wrenches, they give very good grip on bolts.
Chinese garbage made by Ryobi
I have a few thoughts on this enjoyable video:
BTW I paid $169 for a set of 30 Milwaukee Wrenches 15 Metric, 15 SAE six months ago.
I upgraded from a cheap Chinese set not for the box ends which were sufficient even on my cheap set, but for the open ends. That's the end that separates the higher quality wrenches from the cheaper ones.
A 17mm bolt head only needs about 50 lb-ft of torque...
This is roughly 90lbs (41 kg) applied at 6 3/4 inches*
But no one wants the wrench to come close to failure while doing a normal job, so let's throw in a factor of 2 and say that any wrench that manages twice that value: 82 kg, should get a pass.
I think the video is great and I do consider my Milwaukee Wrenches to be about five times sexier than the old 22 piece for $27 Chinese set that I bought at O'Reilly Auto...but this test was very hard on the wrenches and, again, any that made 82+ kg might deserve some respect.
*Length measurements from my 17mm Milwaukee Combination Wrench. (From the center of the open end to the opposite size marking. I don't believe the distance from press to hex is changing, the contact point changes some, changing the lever arm, and the angle of the wrenches changes, but I think they are all close to horizontal when it matters.
I’m not sure the Milwaukee wrench exactly failed in the first test. Rather it was strong enough to pull the bar stock out of your jig… which couldn’t have been too easy. Of course, I’m an American and I might be a bit biased… but hey. 😉🤣
For whatever reason I LOVE watching these. There’s something sort of relaxing about it, which is strange because of all things - why would watching destructive testing be relaxing?! LOL
i dont think this comparisson says anything, in order to have a fair comparison you'd need to use tools of the same weight (so you have tools of similar mass) and the same lenght (so you apply similar torque to them using this method) lastly similar prices so that they have similar quality
it was fun to watch tho!
Wrenches are made of different materials meaning no matter what you get they will never be the same weight
@@tom051 yeah i dont expect them to he the same weight down to the decimals, same for the other measurements, just similar
The only usefull metrics are price to performance .
@@AndrewHadi07 im pretty sure the point of a comparisson like this is to compare the quality of the craftmanship of tools in different countries, and to have a good comparisson you gotta have similar tools
if price/performance was the point then you'd still need similar tools, because i can compare a plastic toy wrench to a steel one and it would work just as well as a comparisson with your criteria
@Repent or you will likewise perish. no, shut up
Nobody knows where the Würth wrench comes from. It would be interesting to see some quality german wrenches like Stahlwille or Wera
Wera is a hyped company that is producing in Czech republic. I prefer Hazet and Stahlwille for wrenches. Nevertheless I have roughly 200 Wera Bits here (Toolcheck+, Bitcheck Impactor/Universal/Wood...) and I am happy with their durability.
Hazet!
They don't produce themselves, might be from any company worldwide.
I prefer Stahlwille and Gedore.
I think those wrenches would be similar to the American Milwaukee wrench. he wouldn't find the limit of quality wrenches like that, but, he would find the limit of how well the vice was clamped to the press table. (how about that hex key!!!)
We have FACOM tools too and must surely be between Milwaukee and Wurth. They have a similar quality
Facom are made in Taiwan. They also sell them as Sidchrome here in Australia and either match or Mac in the USA
@@joebelichio6974 the facom tools you find in France are made in France. The old one are simply indestructibles. Impossible to worn it.
Japanese wrenches are some of the best fit wise as well as quality for metric!! Still using the same one my dad was using in 2004 when he got his tundra. And the tundra is now mine dont use any other set of wrenches
I really like the finish of KSK wrenches. Too bad they aren't made anymore.
If you are putting this level of force on your wrench you are superman. Any of these will do the job for me. I have a breaker bar and impact sockets for 100 plus ft lbs torque.... I'm never really going to get enough leverage on my wrenches to break them. I will buy Milwaukee from now on though
You MAY need to use such a torque to loose a rusty bolt. Also striking the end of wrench with a hammer would apply a huge amount of spike torque to the bolt.
Whether you should or worth do such an action is another question.
Friend: "Oh hey man! Do you have a wrench that I could borrow?"
Me: "Sure, I've got one over here." *Grabs the 1920 wrench*
Friend:
What a pointless comment by Centauri 🙄
For the most part , I think they would all be satisfactory for the average home mechanic
not for a German one, quality matters!
@@Arltratlo if germans really cared about quality they would make cars that dont leak oil and dont have electrical issues on its first drive from the dealership
@@sixunity1171 There were times (70s-90s) where german cars were really top notch. Suddenly the car companies in germany like VW, BMW, Audi, Mercedes and so on decided to stop producing in such a high quality level. Instead they've built in weakspots so they earn money from repairing in their workshops or people buying new cars because their old cannot be repaired economically.
This happens all over the world and has to do with market systems, because if the market is satisfied you cannot sell your product anymore, no matter how good it is.
In your case you seemed to have a bad dealer, because usually the cars are designed to weaken after a couple years or miles driven.
@@sixunity1171 dont buy a German car made in USA, its your own fault...lol
@@Arltratlo why would german cars sold in europe be made in USA? makes no sense
very cool concept, but the linear force is not that we're using, in fact, the arme is followig the tool, and the resulting force is angular.
and, the thin oxide coat must be cleaned before test ;)
Congratulation for the good job, material resistance must be compare again, but we can the see they are not egal in quality !
(sorry for my poor english, I'm french, haha)
Those Soviet tools were quit good, seems like the saying "They dont make em like they used to" also applies to Soviet stuff.
except for their tanks :D
@@ernestoescobar5446
For their time, they were quite good, they were some of the first to use ERA, composite armor and APFSDS.
Thing is though a lot of Russia's stuff was made in other parts of the USSR. Not Russia itself. It's Ukraine, Poland, etc who had the facilities and skills.
@@BlatentlyFakeName
"lot of Russia's stuff was made in other parts of the USS" nope also poland is never part of ussr
this is also nonsense, the Russians have the most skill, resources and capabilities. Any thing the Poles have always yielded to us in everything, and everything that the Ukraine invented by the Bolsheviks had, which never existed before 1922, it had only thanks to us
@@dropanukeonusaagain6606 They don't have much skill of their own. Not much of their stuff was actually made in Russia. The electrical components come from Japan and Korea, the hardware from Ukraine. Even the Moskva (now on special underwater operations) was made in Ukraine.
Was interesting to see the kind of failure, a brittle failure is way worse than a ductile one, can really get someone hurt
8:11 😱🤔 parece que esa es la buena.
13:26 🤔 parece buena opción.
Serían buenos más vídeos poniendo a prueba la resistencia de otras herramientas u objetos de seguridad y uso cotidiano.
Pero si son distinto torque, fijate que el único que encaja bien, casualmente es la norteamericana. El resto no es para ese tipo de tuerca.
@@santiagoelsantos645 es verdad, es como comparar peras con manzanas
@@santiagoelsantos645 concuerdo, esos pequeños milímetros de diferencia, pueden hacer que una herramienta pueda ejercer mejor su trabajo, incluso diría que no a todas las herramientas se les ejercicio el mismo problema, a la más vieja y con forma extraña prácticamente estaba ejercicio un gran torque pero el oxido también debilita la fuerza del material (además no se sabe de si procedía de una buena fabricación o solo era de las chafas de ese tiempo)
The best industry in the world is America. Well done. I am from Iran and I love America's industry and power
" How strong was that allen key " 😉 Time to do some work on the allen key, Very interesting. GOOD WORK SON !!!!!
Way stronger than it needs to be. You'll strip the bolt long before you even start to feel the wrench bending in your hand.
Muito boa essa demostração de potencia das chaves. Parabéns.
2 brs no meio de gringos
3
You cannot possibly compare a Milwaukee wrench with a common german wrench, it's like comparing McDonalds with a Michelin star restaurant. At least try a Hazet/Knipex/Hera/Stahlwille wrench...
Würth is pretty good. We use so much Würth tools at our workshop
Würth is awesome. But here we See the Red Line. Zebra Line would perform a Lot better
Milwaukee tools aren't anywhere near top end tools in the US; they're a lower to mid-level big box store brand. If you are talking true high end professional tools, you'd be looking at Snap-On, MAC, Cornwell or Matco. Hazet and Stahlwille would probably slide somewhere between Milwaukee and the brands like Snap-On.
LOL calling Milwaukee tools high end, they're considered consumer grade. No professional would use them unless they were starting out and couldn't afford something better.
Milwaukee tools are not considered premium by anyone in the US. Milwaukee is just a cheap common brand, we don’t really have any thing sold for cheaper here in the states. If I wanted a 4 dollar wrench, I would have to buy from a Chinese website.
I appreciated the cutouts on the mouth on the Milwaukee. Small design feature that made for better contact
La marca francesa FACOM es mi preferida. Estaria bien verla en esta prueba contra la impresionante Milwaukee.Saludos
Aquí en Francia es lo que siempre compro porque son garantizadas "de por vida". Nunca me han fallado pero tampoco he puesto mis llaves bajo tanta presión. Hay que ver
would be really interested in seeing a torque sensor on the hex in addition to the load on the wrench :)
th-cam.com/channels/K_icgfhiCxlQuYVPW6teMg.html
Great video! I'd love to see how the expensive American and Geman brands, like Snap-on and Stahlwille, compare with these results.
it's likely all made in China, good comparison though...
Stahlwille kicks A$$
"Milwaukee was pretty awesome".
It performed very well but it was also by far the heaviest of the modern wrenches, so not really a fair comparison.
and the most expensive by atleast 3x, upwards of 12x in price, this video was blatantly skewed and was not a fair comparison in the slightest
It is not entirely fair, the further out on the key you press, the less force is required.
Everyone holds on the same position
@@SecretPesch No.
The distance between the hex key and the press plunger was equal in each comparison. Pay attention, maybe you will understand what everyone else can see.
12:35 not really and the Hex key sliped out of the wrench...
@@chiprock804 exactly.
at the beginning you prepared the key from the Czech company Vorel. why didn't you test him?
Here's what I got from this video:
- 1.2$ Chinese wrench versus 14$ American wrench (10x more expensive). That's literally like comparing a 20,000$ Kia with a 200,000$ Lamborghini (10x times more expensive). You better hope the expensive stuff is better.
- 187 gram American wrench against against 118 gram Chinese wrench and 119 gram German wrench. That is, more than 50% heavier; or 50% more steel used in the tool. Of course the heavier tool will perform better; that's why they use gigantic Caterpillar 6090 FS Excavators in the mining industry instead of tiny Bobcat E10s. So, no, the American wrench is not better engineered than the other wrenches; it's just bigger.
- You could get 40 "no name" wrenches (0.3$) for the price of one American wrench (14$)... and leave the store with change. Those are tools designed for DIYers, who are unlikely to use those wrenches on a daily basis; let alone apply the amount of force that was necessary to break those wrenches as shown in the video. And if you're a professional, you're definitely not going to buy Milwaukee or Wurth. In other words, the American wrench is way overpriced for what it's designed for; and the "no name" wrench would do the job it was designed for in 99% of the cases. It pains to say this, but, all in all, the Chinese wrench has the best value for money considering the use 99% of customers will have for that wrench.
In conclusion, after watching this video, I'd personally buy either the "no name" wrench or the Wurth wrench (just because I don't want to support the Chinese or Russian economy).
The "no nome" wrench is also from China. Lol
We'd better make sure too that the US wrench is not a Chinese one with US label. Lol
Ty, always wondered how the performance of various wrenches. Im 66, broke and twisted many a import. They are recycled as ship anchors.
I would like to see Milwaukee vs Gedore in a test like this.
The open end test wasn't really fair since the Milwaukee one had "teeth" and the rest were smooth....but the closed end test was fair all around and showed the quality of the Milwaukee wrench.
“You get what you pay for.” All of the bigger and better tool manufacturers have added the teeth for that reason
The Milwaukee got pressed closer to the screw. This makes a huge difference in the strength that is applicated- the real is lower than 2130N
This is why teeth are important.
Teeth make tough!
@@namastelana5586 You can find a wrench of the same quality for cheaper.
All you get with the price of these big name tools is another CEO with a yacht
Interesting video. But I don’t know what job I’ll need to put the wrench strength to it’s full potential. So far I have stay with the reasonable priced. It works every time. My consideration is always the one will not rust easily, which the cheapest tends to be the worst.
The Milwaukee tool might have gotten the highest values in those test but let's not forget a few important aspects here. No person would effectively produce that high numbers so probably any of the wrenches are good to go. Further, the Milwaukee was the only one with a proper nominal size and basically any tool failed at that point cause they lost grip. Regarding the weight, probably a few tools would have outperformed the Milwaukee one as well. And most of the price tag on the American one is probably the polishing and engraving on the tool. it's still just a basic wrench using more material and made shiny.
Hopefully we can see the testing of similar price spanners from different regions and maybe some pleasant surprises
所以中国和台湾那事儿你不打算说说？
Have you ensured prior to testing them that the distance between the press and the mounting point for the wrench is always the same? If there's a difference in the distance, there will be a difference in the leverage.
I don’t believe it matters all that much considering Milwaukee was subject to far more force than the others and had no faults unlike all the rest.
From p/p perspective: the best one is the German one
Excelente vídeo! Quase todas as minhas ferramentas são Gedore, duram uma vida!!!
The only problem I have with this is that "USA" tool is just a cheap Taiwanese manufactured knock off of an actual US made Snap-On flank drive wrench.... Not exactly saying it's a bad wrench for the money but it kind of defeats the purpose of comparing tools by country if it's "American" in brand name only. It would have been a more fair comparison to see an actual US made tool here.
Whats more is, no matter the country of origin, the product is produced as 'buyer' specifications.
Snap-on in not US made either it is also a import tool just like 95% of what the US sales. as stated from snap-on them self. Only certain Snap-On tools are still made in the USA. Most hand tools are still made in their facilities in Milwaukee and other U.S. manufacturing locations, but products like their cordless power drill kit are made in China, among other countries. More details below.
@@failatthis5169 As stated from snap-on them self? "Snap-On CEO says ’80% of what we sell off the trucks here in America’ is made in the U.S." The vast majority of what Snap-on sells is made here in the US including the wrench's in question which is what is relevant. While I am aware there are a few items made outside the US, the same would apply to them. It's not reasonable to call it an "American" tool when there's nothing American about it but a brand name.
@@andybilakshow260 I would debate that. Marketing wizards like to throw terms like that around to make you feel better about it but what does it really mean? I work in an industry that does contract manufacturing and typically the way the process works is the customer has a set of design requirements. Each set to include what sizes, company logo, costs, size, finish, packaging ect. The manufacturer reads these requirements and drafts a proposed blueprint as for how they intend to meet those requirements. The key here is manufacturer is the one doing the real engineering. They are determining the materials and processes that will be used in the final product. Not to mention, they are the ones actually doing the manufacturing. A great design is meaningless if they are not manufactured to spec. The point, is 99% of the output result is determined by the skill of the manufacturer.
@@richardtomaszewski3569 just saying paper work is and can always be falsified doesn't matter what company they all do it.. anyway have fun sir