It's often more a peaking mic thing than realism, BUT: Some of the sound and texture would be nice in WT. It is missing this feeling of getting hit by a wall of compressed air that the recorded sounds capture, as it is literally what is happening.
i wish they did more about sound design bcoz there's many weapons using the same sound effect while having a different gun and that feels generic, there's also stuff that isnt added into the game like ringing, deafness, the buzzing of projectiles passing nearby, the sound coming after an explosion depending on distance, echo on cities or inside buildings and so on
The right person i need as a realistic sound modder alot of modder make a cool mod and seem to forget that the gun need to be loud af like Robz realism mod they make a great mod for MoWAS2 i get deaf from it LOL M109 whistle is too cool imagine that one jagdpanther video tho💀🔊🔊🔊
the microphone capping out does not sound good in most cases. You just took some real recordings of questionable quality to put over the animation. Im mean...obviously there are limitations to what you can do, but with a bit of sound design you could mitigate the compression/clipping issues. But I suspect it would sound like the game sound again xD More interesting than the actual firing, would be the sound down range. Something most vehicle based games tend to forget: You would still get a supersonic crack, followed by the thunder of the gun. Warthunder is a bit weak in that regard.
I wouldn't say these are more realistic since most of the sounds are recorded with a phone or other audio capture device. So this isn't what the acctually sound like to the human ear. I think the war thunder ones are much closer to reality
It give you that immersive feeling to it ,because the reload sound is loop clean edited sound and it sound kinda suck sometime ,this is why camera record give you that more realistic feeling
@@FRFFW no it doesnt really, his point that its unrealistic. It's true because audio devices have a maximum decibel limit, pitch, ect ect, depending on the environment too, so the quality varies and in most cases are compressed as hell before uploading as well. WT sounds are kinda too clean, they got the pitch and stuff right just make more variations (ie a bit hollower sometimes, ect) and loop randomly the different sound effects. Oh and give them more punch
i cant speak to large caliber guns, but for MGs and rifles i can personally say that they sound way closer to the recorded sounds than what most media portrays. Everything in warthunder seems to have a dull thud for its sound profile, even though in reality it's more sharp and violent until you get far enough away from the sound or it's masked in some way.
Wt menu music jumpscare
I was expecting earrape
Some were a bit loud in my opinion, just wanted to make sure that nobody was listening with the highest volume :)
It's often more a peaking mic thing than realism, BUT: Some of the sound and texture would be nice in WT. It is missing this feeling of getting hit by a wall of compressed air that the recorded sounds capture, as it is literally what is happening.
i wish they did more about sound design bcoz there's many weapons using the same sound effect while having a different gun and that feels generic, there's also stuff that isnt added into the game like ringing, deafness, the buzzing of projectiles passing nearby, the sound coming after an explosion depending on distance, echo on cities or inside buildings and so on
Ok, this is actually alot better then most of the original sounds, I'd love seeing you do more!
They are not realistic, the just use bad microphone. But it will be cool to get this as sound mod.
The right person i need as a realistic sound modder alot of modder make a cool mod and seem to forget that the gun need to be loud af like Robz realism mod they make a great mod for MoWAS2 i get deaf from it LOL
M109 whistle is too cool
imagine that one jagdpanther video tho💀🔊🔊🔊
the microphone capping out does not sound good in most cases.
You just took some real recordings of questionable quality to put over the animation.
Im mean...obviously there are limitations to what you can do, but with a bit of sound design you could mitigate the compression/clipping issues. But I suspect it would sound like the game sound again xD
More interesting than the actual firing, would be the sound down range.
Something most vehicle based games tend to forget:
You would still get a supersonic crack, followed by the thunder of the gun. Warthunder is a bit weak in that regard.
very awesome video, id like this in the game
need mg42 please on a 10 hour loop, it helps me sleep
erm, MG-34
too much delay between the round being fired and the audio. very unpleasant, perhaps it can be fixed.
I wish I could have this because it’s actually very good
Thanks :)
Impressive indeed, tho I have a mod with realistic sounds. They have similar but with less of an echo compared to yours
I wouldn't say these are more realistic since most of the sounds are recorded with a phone or other audio capture device. So this isn't what the acctually sound like to the human ear. I think the war thunder ones are much closer to reality
It give you that immersive feeling to it ,because the reload sound is loop clean edited sound and it sound kinda suck sometime ,this is why camera record give you that more realistic feeling
@@FRFFW no it doesnt really, his point that its unrealistic. It's true because audio devices have a maximum decibel limit, pitch, ect ect, depending on the environment too, so the quality varies and in most cases are compressed as hell before uploading as well. WT sounds are kinda too clean, they got the pitch and stuff right just make more variations (ie a bit hollower sometimes, ect) and loop randomly the different sound effects. Oh and give them more punch
@@aax960 yeah like the old german MG34 sound
i cant speak to large caliber guns, but for MGs and rifles i can personally say that they sound way closer to the recorded sounds than what most media portrays. Everything in warthunder seems to have a dull thud for its sound profile, even though in reality it's more sharp and violent until you get far enough away from the sound or it's masked in some way.
NAGYEREJŰ ROBBANÓSZER BETÖLTVE
Támadjuk meg a D pontot! 🗣️🗣️
@@szilarderdelyi1529SOHA! 🔥
@@u238productionsvédjük meg a D pontot
this is good
am in need of ear penetrating gun sounds
Nein Nein es is 8,8cm flugabwehrkanone 37 Selbstfallerfette auf 18tonnen zugkraftwagen
can you send me the link to these
Its not real, all are edited videos
@@LeonXD111noooooooo
any download link?
I edited the sounds in myself, no link.
@@Breadnator8gaijin must see your edit
What's mod
No mod, edited sounds in myself.
@Breadnator8 Cool
How did you make this?
Took the audio out of clips which involved the firing of the specific gun, then edited it over the sound in WT.
What Mod Link ?
No mod, edited sounds in myself.