the only thing IL-2 missed is track noise (notice how WT's tracks make a lot of creaking noises when the tank is moving) and the MG sound, but otherwise it holds up really well and is even better in many aspects
WT arcadifies suspension so much for a lot of vehicles, though I can't fault Gaijin too much in this case as both for gameplay reasons and historical accuracy it would be very difficult getting such niche details correctly for hundreds of vehicles. IL-2 wins the comparison for me
The models in WT is more realistic Il 2 look like a toy model or the tank just came out of the production line and never seen action ,wt has great attention to details Some rust, faded paint, scuffs and dents I love ear thunder
The Panther in IL-2 also has its fair share of paint peeling off and dirt, giving it a more realistic appearance, considering that tanks spent more time driving than actually engaging in battle. In my opinion, it’s too excessive in War Thunder. The dents, especially on the sideskirts and frontal guards, make it look as if it was ripped off a destroyed tank and reused.
@@stfuiknowbetter4474 Not necessarily. IL2 has hundreds of weathered community skins to download on its body and tracks, and very importantly, historical skins, historically detailed in proportions and best modeled tanks and damage physics and model, not only fictional or "for fun" as in WT. Those do look like toys.
that's bullshit, I can only speak for the German Army, but the germans maintained there tanks properly, even between their tasks/missionen on in the frontline. No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.
@@SturmPanzer43Brummbar The idler wheel (rear wheel) is sitting more behind the other wheel in IL2. For WT, it's more away from it with the whole wheel exposed. I'm pretty sure that's the early design version in IL2 while WT has the late panther d design (for tracks/wheels)
I got il 2 while the big discount was up and also got the tank crew dlc and when I saw what the soviets got compared to what the Germans Had I was like nah germany is op but it turned out tanks like the panther and elephant are actually pretty fragile especially when you fight ai since they have this weird Aimbot that allows them to hit extremly presise small weak spots on tanks like being able to accurately hit the panthers drivers view port and the front amor plate machine gunners port like I said extremly accurately in 4 to 5 shots or even less.
WT : you can play for the entire day in headphone at 100%vol IL2 : Getting deaf after firing 20 round at 100%vol WoT realistic with arcade mechanicsm WT is only realistic but not on the simulator level IL2 Simulator
T(h)ank you, finally somebody who knows, what he talk about. I hate those "wAr ThUnDEr loOkEd mORe REaliSTic bECaUSe iT'S WAr tImE" comments. Because when a tank is on the frontline, that doesn't mean, that they didn't maintained or repair their vehicles between their missions and from the german army I know, the did it properly. No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.
in my opinion, the exterior for il2's panther looks better than war thunders
Yes, it's newer
@@xWizardxRF But IL2 is locked in first person, you like never see your exterior when playing
@@everyonehastalent4309 What, no? You have full control in third person view??
I'm war thunder it's more of like, the tank is what you found or been I'm the war, In il2 it's just out of the factory or something
True but itnseems 'factory fresh'
il2 reminds me of classic war thunder
the tanks felt more real back then
yes
Very good indeed, I like Il-2 mainly for showing the inside of the tanks, in the next video it could be Ferdinand or Stug iii please
Can't wait to see your TC2 comparison vids ;)
TC2 👀👀👀
I wish war thunders vehicles were up to this detail because il-2 looks amazing side by side
Thats gonna be hard to do considering war thunder is more on gameplays than the actual vehicles
Incredible as always
the only thing IL-2 missed is track noise (notice how WT's tracks make a lot of creaking noises when the tank is moving) and the MG sound, but otherwise it holds up really well and is even better in many aspects
I would also like you to make a video about
"Tiger 2". Thanks for the interesting video))
Please make the next one with a soviet tnak like the kv1 or the t34
Yeah, I'll probably do the T-34 next.
But don't worry, I'll eventually get through all the tanks!
Modelled interiors got me sold
3:32 the engine sounds so good
Only see the riding physics… IL2 all the way.
WT arcadifies suspension so much for a lot of vehicles, though I can't fault Gaijin too much in this case as both for gameplay reasons and historical accuracy it would be very difficult getting such niche details correctly for hundreds of vehicles. IL-2 wins the comparison for me
Great video!
IL-2 really needs to improve the mg sound from the outside. But besides that they win in every other category
War thunder is a great reallistic game, IL-2 is a great simulator, they’re different but both are great in their category
In my opinion, I prefer war thunder. But IL-2 it's really great tho, and way more customizable
The models in WT is more realistic
Il 2 look like a toy model or the tank just came out of the production line and never seen action ,wt has great attention to details
Some rust, faded paint, scuffs and dents
I love ear thunder
The Panther in IL-2 also has its fair share of paint peeling off and dirt, giving it a more realistic appearance, considering that tanks spent more time driving than actually engaging in battle.
In my opinion, it’s too excessive in War Thunder. The dents, especially on the sideskirts and frontal guards, make it look as if it was ripped off a destroyed tank and reused.
@@stfuiknowbetter4474 Not necessarily. IL2 has hundreds of weathered community skins to download on its body and tracks, and very importantly, historical skins, historically detailed in proportions and best modeled tanks and damage physics and model, not only fictional or "for fun" as in WT. Those do look like toys.
that's bullshit, I can only speak for the German Army, but the germans maintained there tanks properly, even between their tasks/missionen on in the frontline. No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.
bro!i very love you video!😍
0:42 Why is angle of the track so high in the right compared to the left?
Different track tension I guess
@@SturmPanzer43Brummbar The idler wheel (rear wheel) is sitting more behind the other wheel in IL2. For WT, it's more away from it with the whole wheel exposed. I'm pretty sure that's the early design version in IL2 while WT has the late panther d design (for tracks/wheels)
think of war thunder was like il 2 what a game it would be love love love
Love the video!
0:39 and can someone tell me what that big thing is sitting in the middle in IL2?
Additional Air intake for engine and/or antenna holder for commander panther.
@@rolandhunter Thanks!
@@zeller2030 You're welcome!
You should compair the games to call to arms
is this the Clash at Prokhorovka DLC
Yes
I got il 2 while the big discount was up and also got the tank crew dlc and when I saw what the soviets got compared to what the Germans Had I was like nah germany is op but it turned out tanks like the panther and elephant are actually pretty fragile especially when you fight ai since they have this weird Aimbot that allows them to hit extremly presise small weak spots on tanks like being able to accurately hit the panthers drivers view port and the front amor plate machine gunners port like I said extremly accurately in 4 to 5 shots or even less.
problem with WT is how crappy BR is. like maus facing modern tanks etc.. they do everything they can, to make you pay for the grind
I mean its balance. There is a reason some vics are so high or low in BR. Alternatively try playing ground sim.
@@BlackWolf9988 Ground sim still has all the unrealistic teams and brs, it's no different other than locking you in zoom mode and removing name tags
After reaching BR 5.3, grinding further has no sense.
You do know that making tanks play against their contemporaries would be stupid right?
WT : you can play for the entire day in headphone at 100%vol
IL2 : Getting deaf after firing 20 round at 100%vol
WoT realistic with arcade mechanicsm
WT is only realistic but not on the simulator level
IL2 Simulator
Should i buy this game ?
Вартандер который мы потеряли
Il-2 Better for me
seems like im pretty early here!
But does il-2 have 2000 vehicles? something to keep in mind
This video compares the Panther model between both games, nothing more. It is not a "which game is better" video
@nickkyboy99 Yes i know but when you have that many vehicles its hard to make them all super high quality so its good to keep in mind like i said
War Thunder doesn't need 2000 vehicles but those who run the business DO need them FOR US to keep spending MONEY on it!
@@Rostyar What businesses need money to function😱
Oh! You're such a genius!
how to play ıl2?
war thunder for good art direction
il2 for good sound design
What's the point of removing sideskirts? Was that a thing?
It was probably taken off while in very muddy or snowy terrain
or not enough sideskirt to distribute to every tanker due to shortages ? idk i'm just asking
It was not standart for panthers they addes those later becouse without side skirts at rifles could penetrate the side
Side skirts were a later addition to the panther because soviet anti tank rifles kept penetrating the sides of the tank.
In tank details, I prefer war thunder, but the texture of IL-2 is much better
What do you prefer for the tank details in WT ?? lol
Shitthunder
War Thunder dont have love for Tanks look at their Models looks like the Tanks are sitting in dirt for 30 years even at 100% Cammo
T(h)ank you, finally somebody who knows, what he talk about. I hate those "wAr ThUnDEr loOkEd mORe REaliSTic bECaUSe iT'S WAr tImE" comments.
Because when a tank is on the frontline, that doesn't mean, that they didn't maintained or repair their vehicles between their missions and from the german army I know, the did it properly.
No german tank looked that worn as in War Thunder.