ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2024
- Protests over Jallikattu, the bull-taming sport, were a way for people to "vent their discontent", actor Kamal Haasan told NDTV today, as he joined a league of celebrities appealing for calm on a day the demonstrations, hailed for their discipline and order so far, turned violent in Tamil Nadu. A supporter of the traditional contest, a ban on which was nixed by the state assembly today, Mr Haasan also said that the uprising showed that courts were not infallible and should strive to regulate but not ban things.
Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/vi...
Download the NDTV news app: play.google.co...
Don't ban it at all...regulate it, thats fine. it's not only Tamils , its Indias culture!
Kal Gandikota Dude. what are you smoking?
Well said Sir 👍👍👍💝 As a Tamizhan You made US proud Sir 👏👏👍💝
Few months before nidi was saying killing cow and eating beef is freedom to chose what to eat, but now saying playing with bull is animal cruelty. Why this double standard Nidi Razadan?
mr kamal aways use to say "i know only cinema" but he is the one who always rise voice against bad things. GOOD INDIAN.
You are great Mr.Kamal...Heritage, Tradition should continues with some regulations if needed. We never gonna give up. No one have the right to ban our 5000 years heritage. Period.
Aandavar for reason ... கமல்ஹாசன் அப்டினா படத்துல மட்டும் வீரவசனம் பேசிட்டு, கிளைமேக்ஸ்ல சொத்து எழுதி குடுத்துட்டு, அரசியல்வியாதிக்கு எதிரா பேசிட்டு Twitter ல பிஜேபி க்கு ஜால்ரா போடுறவனு நினைச்சியா? நிஜத்துல
எங்கேயும் எந்த சூழ்நிலையிலும் மக்களுக்கு சப்போர்ட் பண்றவர் #கமல்ஹாசன்டா...
King Kamal is the best. Long Live the Pride of Indian Cinema. We support Kamal.
he is not believe in God... because he realised the god...watch Anne sivam
Bro athu Anbe Sivam
100/ NO ONE CAN BAN ANY THING, JUST CONTROL ,THANKS FOR COMMEND KAMAL SIR ?
Kal Gandikota IT SEEMS THAT YOU TAKE PRIDE IN UR WRITING ABILITY.THIRUVALLUVAR CONDENSED PRICELESS WISDOM IN 1 & 3/4th lines. SHORTER U SAY WITH THE ESSENCE OF WISDOM IN EVERY WORD IN IT...APPRECIATION.
U INSTEAD TRY TO TAKE EVERYONE FOR A RIDE..ZAMBIA NICARAGUA PAPUA GUINEA..WHAT IS THIS ? STOP DOING THIS..
First of the all, law should be taken in spirit and letter and in our country the spirit of the law is never taken into consideration it is almost always taken literally like the idiots in three idiots movie who mug up the subject.if the jallikattu is seen with spirit of the law, then no court would have banned it just regulated it.
Next,yes in a democracy freedom of expression is the most important so what he says is correct most of the time except in special cases where the larger public gets unnecessarily affected and this is not the case in Jallikattu.
kamal is always bold & correct.
Don't ban it regulate it. Kamal hassan what a quote should go in books forever
Very well said Mr. Haasan
Excellent Sir....well spoke👍🏽
I thank to Kamal sir behalf of Tamil people
It's not sentiment, it's cultural.
I'm a great fan of Kamal ji..must respected individual in my eyes..but I just feel he could've elaborated more on the real intensity of the situation rather than being so haphazard about it..he seems more interested in showing off his American accent rather than reflecting his actual mindset about it,well he does seem very intense in his tweets ahout this uproar..
kamal is always grt..
My Humble Request to all Protesters/Leaders of Jallikattu Movement:
Vanakkam! I admire everybody for coming forward to protect and cherish this ancient Indian tradition of Jallikattu(Bull Hugging/Stopping/Sorting). Many thanks to India’s News media for coverage of this movement. It helps ordinary people like us understand and empathize/feel connected to brave Tamil Youth who are eager with passion and valor like Jallikattu bulls. I am glad India’s Central Government, Tamil Nadu State Government and all Political Parties are in support of JalliKattu. I am happy that even celebrities and business people of TN, AP, Telangana are also in support of Jallikattu.
I apologize in advance for expressing anything inconvenient, incorrect and wrong due to limitations in my time and my understanding. I am not a UNO Expert, IFS/IAS/IPS guru, lawyer, police, politician, judge, researcher, defense strategist, JNU professor, PITAnewala, or a media professional... I beg audience/readers too submit their comments and utilize various Social media on how to best resolve these types of injustices/oppression/ridicule/discrimination standing by your side to maintain peace in Jallikattu movement.
Now that the protests are turning violent causing injuries to people and destruction/burning of private and public vehicles, I humbly request/beg everybody to please kindly restrain their frustrations/anger and not vandalize others’ properties & vehicles (private/public, that are expensive and needed for common people)). Imagine you were at a festive gathering and a fight broke out between family members...everyone at the gathering are watching. Doesn't it generate awkward feelings? Then how much more damage these damages (of people/police & properties) could cause to the reputation/respect of Tamil Nadu and India among comity of nations? As a match-stick sets forest trees on fire and char them and those amongst them and around them, I urge everyone(including yourself) not to be frustrated, to be humble, compassionate yet cautious, wise and impartial in their judgments.
May be its time to take rest and revisit this movement when the need arises. I understand that Jallikattu is an age-old tradition to sort Indian-born bulls with best gene pool, best milk and preserve them too and not just a sport. Wonder why not use modern veterinarian techniques to do the same? In my view, may be the stayed order could be lifted with rules and regulations. And Criminal charges be levied on only those people who are abusing bulls just like Justice is served against only those men who abuse women. Banning Jallikattu in India is like banning marriage because some spouses beat/abuse/kill their wives (and husbands).
Sometimes we tend to think the members of our communities, religions, castes, tribes, languages, gender (including LGBT), towns, states, countries etc. are like us. Like us, they have same principles, ethics and morals. However for most of the time, for Indian borns, it looks like not the case. For instance, most of the time, I trust all Indians share their burdens, problems and discuss/consult each other. However, when incidents (violent protests/vandalism) like these happen, my trust, unity, empathy and compassion towards fellow Indians wears down. If you have as much faith in Murugan/Your Gods & Goddesses/Allah as I much as I do, I’m sure you’ll agree with me at least before him/her. Therefore, may be its time to take rest and revisit this movement when the need arises.
And I tell you the truth, I eat cattle flesh (cooked of course) with same sacrosanctity and respect as those who eat the flesh of Jesus Christ every weekend (communion) at a Church……And keep praising God for making me so superior to those bovines I eat! I keep praising God for making those who eat them superior to Indians in wealth, power, technologies, weapons and luxuries. I also praise God for blessing the beef eaters that just 8 of them hold half of the world’s wealth. I also praise God for blessing those beef eaters not only in Hollywood but also in Hindi Film Industry…I also praise God for how lucky they are all that they get to shake hands with Hon’ble elected representatives of India (MPs & MLAs) including Hon’ble PM of India…..and when those beef-eaters die, everyone including Hon’ble PM of India stands up and pays respects including standing silent for few minutes in public conferences. THEREFORE, LET ME GIVE CONFIDENCE TO EVERYBODY THAT I AM NOT WORRIED ABOUT BOVINES, I AM ONLY WORRIED ABOUT MY POOR TAMIL BROTHERS GETTING INJURED, SUFFERING LIFE-LONG TRAUMA AND WORSE DEAD DUE TO THIS EXTREME SPORT OF BULL HUGGING/STOPPING!
Personally I think the main reason for popularity of JalliKattu sport in Tamil Nadu may be due to poverty of Tamil Youth so much so that they are not able to buy expensive equipments required for similar bull sports (of USA/Spain/Portugal/Australia/France/Canada/South America etc.) or Olympic sports or any other extreme adventurous sports like those in Developed nations (USA, France, Europe, UK, Japan, South Korea, Japan etc.) (Mother State of Sri Sundar Pichaiji, the CEO of Google! Wonder what he is doing for youth of his Home State besides his own children regarding sports?)
Not depending on anybody(billionaire, celebrity or politician), let us all pray together and wish that in Tamil Nadu there are also more sports competitions like Wrestling, Judo, Swimming, throws etc. and many more that are all adventurous/manly/extreme. Then the state players could as well be sent to compete at National level and at international levels. And some news mentioned Kungfu/karate, fencing/sword-fights originated in Tamil Nadu….How about sports like that?
That said I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, caste, last name, race, tribe, language, region, nationality, gender (women including LGBT) etc.
I beg all privileged (including you) travel around India and the world. I wish they not only enjoy their trips & take pictures/videos and “experience foods, nature, imaraten/buildings, shopping foreign mall, finding/giving/getting spouses, honey-moon, enjoying music, wine, dance, night-life, and cultures” but also advise/teach their fellow human-beings their experiences/wisdom (old & new) for progress, peace, harmony and prosperity of not only the entire world but also of India. (Given a chance, like you, they are also keen, highly adaptive and always refine themselves!)
We are able to watch the news and write comments/replies here though we live few thousand miles away in different time-zones because we all have high-speed internet connection. What about those in TN (India) who do not have electricity and internet and whose voices are not heard like theirs and ours? (Especially those living in small towns and villages?) Hence let us accelerate on ‘war footing’ two most important infrastructure projects, Electricity and Internet proliferation to mitigate ignorance and reduce ‘information gap’ strengthening ties between all “human beings”(Manavatha Vadi/Insaaniyat) on earth and make the world one big global village (Vasudaiva Kutumbakam).
The modern India(world) is faced with many grave challenges like poverty, malnutrition, pollution, corruption, dirty politics, mental diseases, extortions, riots, suicides, parasitic economies, prostitutes/concubines & their cuckolding, religiously-enforced-no-choice pregnancies, teen-pregnancies/marriages, divorces, gender inequalities(including LGBT), misguided proselytizations/religious terrorism, human trafficking, visa slavery, adverse climate changes and Global warming. Let us all humbly meditate and introspect
“Do we, even now in 21st century, fight amongst ourselves and try tearing our Mother India apart and watch vultures devouring it or we now vow to stitch her wounds, nurture her, heal and strengthen her to stand up for Peace once again and shine, brighter than ever, as the Beacon of Hope for jobless, sick, vanchith, peedith, Sochith,kuchilith, dabhe, divyang jan, naree and upaekshith around the world?”
JAI JAWAN! JAI KISAN! JAI VIGYAN! JAAGO NOWJAWAN!
STANDUP INDIA! STARTUP INDIA!
Once again, please kindly forgive me if I said anything incorrect and wrong or hurt anyone’s feelings! I am not an expert or respected but only a common Indian citizen (a looser begging for Justice and Unity). Also due to time constraints, please kindly forgive my Indlish mistakes too! I will correct my Indlish mistakes as time permits!
Satyameva Jayathe!
Kal Gandikota
Note: I am not paid to comment and not seeking favors. I made this comment so I get replies from fellow viewers to educate myself. I am not affiliated with any political party, religion, caste, tribe, gender, media, NGO, Government institution, business, nationality etc. Hence if anyone uses this comment for making their decisions, I am not responsible for any failures incurred. Before my voice is suppressed like it happened several times, copy to
1. All Political Parties of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
2. Tribes of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
3. NGOs(including religious missionaries) of the world
4. Newspapers of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
6. Translators of all languages of the universe
7. All sapient beings of the universe
8. All sentient beings of the universe
HI, Namashkar. Who said you there is no electricity . and Internet in TN? From which UTOPIA are you??
Kal Gandikota do all cities, homes and villages in ur state have Internet and 24 hours electricity ?
Dear Sir/Madam (Gayathri Sundareshwar), In the state and the country, I live in right now Yes. I admire you coming forward and expressing your views. With comments, replies and discussion is how problems, big or small should be dealt with in a civilized manner, isn’t it? Hence, this reply to what you wrote (Copying here just in case it gets deleted):
“Kal Gandikota do all cities, homes and villages in ur state have Internet and 24 hours electricity ?”
Just around 15 households with internet access is too low for India. Just hope mobile internet access is not included to count this 15 percent. Let’s pray and hope more households in India(TN) get internet. If only many households (including those of fishermen) had internet, they’d have all known the environmental effects of 20 tonnes of crude in sea along the coast line. Any idea, how many indigenous species in sea are going to disappear? If everybody had internet, they’d have all known. Now only few know, research and understand the effects. Now I beg all privileged (elected representatives, business magnets, star celebrities including yourself if possible) to travel around India and the world. I wish they not only enjoy their trips & take pictures/videos and “experience foods, nature, imaraten/buildings, shopping foreign mall, finding/giving/getting spouses, honey-moon, enjoying music, wine, dance, night-life, and cultures” but also advise/teach their fellow human-beings their experiences/wisdom (old & new) for progress, peace, harmony and prosperity of not only the entire world but also of India. (Given a chance, like you, they are also keen, highly adaptive and always refine themselves!)
Fourth Industrial Revolution must take place in India as much as it happens elsewhere in the world. However, I’m afraid many in India appear to have become blind to the fact that law-abiding Indian Tax-payers have also become marginalized in India(less than 3%). 97% of those who do not pay taxes are deciding the Indian Governments(local, state and center). Whose John Galt anyway? I apologize for expressing anything inconvenient, incorrect and wrong due to limitations in my time and my understandings. I am open to criticisms, suggestions, corrections and feedback. I am not a law-maker (politician), lawyer, police, judge, religious preacher, researcher, World bank/IMF executive, UNO Expert, PETAnewala, IFS/IAS/IPS officer, defense strategist, diplomat, a Nobel-Prize winning professor or a media professional. I wholeheartedly felt it is my duty as a human being to submit this humble reply and my thoughts on this matter based on my life’s experiences. I ask everybody in India (world):
1. Deep down in your heart, would you be willing to accept anything less for your services, for your taxes without being afraid in the villages, towns, cities, states or countries where you live in right now?
2. Deep down in your heart, would you be willing to accept anything less in the future of your children and grandchildren and their grand-children and so on…deep down in your heart?
If your answer to the above two questions is “No to yourself” but “Yes to others”…then please realize we are all rocking the same boat and we will all drown one day….
Progress and Prosperity Always...Where there is no progress and prosperity there is no Peace or Love...I wish economic and Social modernization (includes women empowerment) is fueled by Non-farming occupations (with a ban on mining as much as possible. Only timely exploitation of natural resources may be permitted). India's biggest mistake since India’s Independence was striving to fuel growth by agriculture & mining (and their exports), roads, highways and seaports even after 70 years of Independence. This resulted in unorganized sectors of services with poor/illiterate/frustrated farmers & migrant workers in India (and even illegal immigration of Indians around the world) even after 70 years of India’s Independence.
Education, Entrepreneurship, Electricity, Connectivity and social modernization must be facilitated/encouraged especially in all poorer regions and poorer sections/communities. The poor must be encouraged to take up jobs or do businesses in Non-farming professions (with a delay/ban on mining as much as possible to protect their habitats/regions/cities/rivers/seas). Connectivity includes Modern Communication Systems like Satellite, Mobile phones, internet etc. besides print news media, roads, water-ways and railways. Education is not just being literate in English Language, marrying a foreigner or taking up a different religion but an overall Education aimed at building one’s own character, families, communities, cities/towns/villages and if given a chance the entire nation.
(It is much easier to teach people basic literacy, entrepreneurship, cashless transactions and open their bank accounts on earth than teaching them a foreign religion and making them believe they got an account in Heavens and a wireless connection to God with a lengthy prayer and scriptures full of umpteen verses. Since most of them are illiterate, Governments and NGOs (including religious missionaries) may also start adult schools (just one hour evenings/4 hours weekends) for basic literacy, entrepreneurship.)
We are able to watch the news and write comments/replies here though we live few thousand miles away in different time-zones because we all have high-speed internet connection. What about those in TN (India) who do not have electricity and internet and whose voices are not heard like theirs and ours? (Especially those living in small towns and villages?) Hence let us accelerate on ‘war footing’ two most important infrastructure projects, Electricity and Internet proliferation to mitigate ignorance and reduce ‘information gap’ strengthening ties between all “human beings”(Manavatha Vadi/Insaaniyat) on earth and make the world one big global village (Vasudaiva Kutumbakam). Those who cannot travel around the world may still edify themselves and make friends with people in India (and around the planet) via internet right from their own homes/facilities.
Also I pray and wish a day dawns when one don’t need pay high tuition fees or travel across India (to institutes like JNU, Hyderabad university, IIT, IIM, AIIMS, AMU etc.) or elsewhere in the world (like Ukraine, USA, Australia etc.) to study if one has no money to study sciences, medicine, business, law, politics, technologies, acting, cinema, sociology, psychology, philosophy, religion etc. Just a computer and internet connection will do. (It is possible to reduce the costs of education by a good mix of online classes & necessary in-person classroom lectures and labs.) Also, Girl-children who are under several restrictions by their traditional-parents could get educated from their own homes under supervision of their traditional parents.
The modern India (world) is faced with many grave challenges like poverty, malnutrition, pollution, corruption, dirty politics, mental diseases, extortions, riots, suicides, parasitic economies, prostitutes/concubines & their cuckolding, mental diseases, religiously-enforced-no-choice pregnancies, teen-pregnancies/marriages, divorces, gender inequalities(including LGBT), misguided proselytizations/religious terrorism, adverse climate changes and Global warming. Let us all humbly meditate and introspect
“Do we, even now in 21st century, fight amongst ourselves and try tearing our Mother India apart and watch vultures devouring it or we now vow to stitch her wounds, nurture her, heal and strengthen her to stand up for Peace once again and shine, brighter than ever, as the Beacon of Hope for jobless, sick, vanchith, peedith, Sochith,kuchilith, dabhe, divyang jan, naree and upaekshith around the world?”
JAI JAWAN! JAI KISAN! JAI VIGYAN! JAAGO NOWJAWAN!
“Do we, even now in 21st century, fight amongst ourselves and make children(especially girls) of Mother India cry or we now vow to, at least, wipe their tears properly with shame and dignity, let alone keep swearing again and again that we are gonna strive to protect them and make their lives better only if we have lots of funds?”
STANDUP INDIA! STARTUP INDIA!
Please kindly forgive me if I said anything incorrect and wrong or hurt anyone’s feelings! I am not an expert or respected but only a common Indian citizen (begging for Justice & Unity not for money). Also due to time constraints, please kindly forgive my Indlish mistakes too! I will correct my Indlish mistakes as time permits!
Satyameva Jayathe!
Kal Gandikota
Note: I am not paid to comment and not seeking favors. I made this comment so I get replies from fellow viewers to educate myself. I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, media, NGO, business or any Government institution. Hence, if anyone uses this comment for making their decisions, I am not responsible for any failures incurred. Before my voice is suppressed like it happened at iChaat Café, 1208 E Arques Ave, Sunnyvale, CA, 94085, USA copy to
1. All Political Parties of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
2. Tribes of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
3. NGOs(including religious missionaries) of the world
4. Newspapers of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
6. Translators of all languages of the universe
7. All sapient beings of the universe
8. All sentient beings of the universe
Your comment is baseless. I study in London,LSE (from Chennai).
I have seen this sport several times and the people who owns this bulls. This people don't torment the animals rather they build the bull by providing them the best and healthy food, I would compare it with owning a Racing Motor sport Crew.They give best of everything as they want there bull to win. Well the difference is Motor Sport is owned by Billionaires . But , This people who owns this bulls struggle for a meal a day, But they make sure the bull gets best of every thing. The bull is like a brother to them its Family.( How would you expect them to be cruel to there own family ?). Well about the sport it not like 100 people are gonna jump on the cow rather Its only one person has to Hug the bull For 15 Meters which bull wins is the best bull so its the highest paid bread . This sport has been for more than 3000 years you can not Ban a sport rather regulate it, Well It already under control by the state government, Its Governed by IAS. Speaking of culture up here in London If you buy a house your not allowed to Paint are modify the exterior of your own house, Its because they want to be conservative about there culture, In a city Like London who are developed and modern they spent a lot to stay conservative, why not a country like India? We are running towards Modern culture Which is good,But that doesn't mean we have to forget Who we are.
Well, I will put this in a simpler way There is huge Business behind this Ban. India is Number 1 in Diary farming, What if companies take over this business. We are buying Milk for 50 Rupees now, If its take over by Corporate They would sell it for 200 Rupees. In this case What if all the bulls are dead eventually the cows will die as well.
So corporates will show up giving us Diary products for much higher price.
So think about it. Its about our country.
Regards
SharanRaj
don't understand why the north news keep repeating 'Tamil sentiment'??? It's Tamil pride and dignity, if you don't have one, it's just too bad,. So, don't complain when us the Tamil have them!
Talking about law here! Men created it and now arguing on it! Do not interfere in a traditional practice in the name of law which has never been stable for the past thousands of years! Do a research on the loops in laws where people are using those loops to escape from the crime that they have commited! Apply these laws in something which is really important rather than applying it in unnecessary things! Vaalghe Tamil Nadu! Vaalghe India! Jai Hind!!!!!
Thanks sir for explaining to National media who doesnt know abt Jallikattu #Banpeta
Every word and statement he made sense in every manner
It's a Indian pride not only for Tamil nadu #BanPETA save our culture. 😕😕😕
kamal ji you may start one entertainment show in tamil tvs... it's rocks and God wish you wealth and bless you wealth & prosperity... I am great fan of your way of justifying social acts.. and educate the people of Indias to reflect Indian old culture and rich life in India culture and ancient trends and also try to educate the people to findout local Indian products are more quality and not toxic... why should Indians follow the foreign trends.. is insane... kindly made our India better and great
Kamal sir exceptional chat
Well done KamalHasan!
North Indians are born for cow's and vegetables 😂😂😂😂
i support jallikattu not only coz it's our tradition but I support bcoz if we let go of our tradition now later on they will band more of our tradition.. and we can't just say yes for everything
The man have guts. Believe him.
Good point made here Regulate the traffic.
Well said Kamal Hassan.
Real hero..he is legend..
How do you regulate this? I'm guessing you simply wrestle cows but not too hard, without acknowledging that putting them in that position to begin with is what's cruel.
really sad decission by the Court.
kamal is true. ......... true is kamal. .......
super sir 👍👏👏
Ban lion killing any animal. Ban driving as many people die. Ban eating vegetables as they are also life, science has proved it now. Oh also when you breathe, every-time millions of bacteria die. Ban breathing. I would suggest you do that first and then ask other to do. 😇
Sati should not have been banned.That was also age old custom in Rajesthan.
Elephants carry tons of logs in Kerala and Karnataka's forest areas. We can see them carrying those big trees (logs) & doesn't that cruel PETA? Well PETA is more worried only about the Bulls in TN!!!!
Common??? NDTV does not know why this is linked to our price?? Please!!
yup lift all bans cos india is unable to enforce it
and lets put dat resources in proper cause
very soon going against to law citing tradition will become a norm.
Nobody noticed he is speaking american !!!! thats sarcasm...
you no what this media over all bullshirt ...
you have to think 1st from last 4000 year it's happening in Tamil Nadu...and the are celebrating this festival.
what you no about bull .....
this not specifically for Hindus only this festival for all Tamil people
I really hate my Indian media by the way
A young wife has lost her 40 yr old husband who was going to temple this month. A bull from nowhere came & gored him to death because Jallikkattu was held somewhere in that village. Did you or any of your film fraternity come on the road to ask for justice & compensation for her ? Oh that is not a popular thing to do, is it ? In "Indian", when someone says, "ஏழை வாழ்ந்தால் என்ன செத்தா என்னையா", you take your knife & kill him. Good acting. Claps. First care for Tamilian's life.
You film stars are there only because you see it as a good opportune moment to steal the thunder from those students & get a piece of action for yourselves. When 144 farmers committed suicide in the last 3 months because the TN Govt failed to give them compensation for the unprecedented double drought of the year, where were you all & where were your Tamil feelings bro ?
You say these deaths can be prevented if proper regulation is done. In the new regulatory act, the path of the bull should not be blocked. How are the common tamilians going to temples or elsewhere safe in that case ?
You are insane and funny. Bus accident nadakkuthu... Bus ah ban pannidalama???? Aunty konjam yosinga... engyo onnu nadakaratha eduthu pesakodathu
LionMeatSnackEater You have become a laughing stock of this country by this kind of stupid & insensitive comparisons. In this age people cannot live without vehicles which is a well known fact. Comparing Jallikattu to essential services is the most idiotic thing which goes on only in TN. By the way has anybody bothered to find out the young widow who lost her husband who was going to the temple unaware of Jallikattu ? Have you ever fought for a compensation & justice for her or sat on dharna for the TN Govt to give compensation to the farmers who are committing suicide ? Have tamilians lost any iota of sympathy & compassion for fellow beings ? Is tamilians lives so cheap ? In your fever to enjoy a sport of this nature you are trampling over the basic rights of ordinary tamilians to 'live'. Thaatha konjam moolaya use pannunga, enna ?
@Latha Baradwaj The answer to your question lies in your comment itself. Had the young woman been made aware that Jallikattu was going on and where, she would've taken a different path right? Why are you not advocating for the Jallikattu route to be made popular so these unfortunate incidents don't happen? Just a thought.
R Harish There is no jallikattu route. People going to temple to pray peacefully cannot share the route of jallikattu. Keep it far away from ordinary people who carry on their business.
Okay, point taken that there is no definitive route. How about ordinary people being cautious enough to avoid going out on the Jallikattu day if they wish no bodily harm?
i agree ,,dont ban but regulate..
Regulation in India? As if there is not enough corruption? Either make it totally legal or ban it.
And why biriyani and automobile accidents are thrown into this issue? In what way one bad thing justifies the other? The issue is purely on animal cruelty and any discussions and solutions should be based on that only. Everything is relative as the word "humane" is up to the interpretation of the people.
As a PETA volunteer, let me straighten some things here.
First, PETA has been against ALL animal "sports" where animals are abused. it includes Rodeo of US , Bull sport of Spain etc. So no double standard.
Second, the argument "what about this country/state doing that" is not logical defence of animal abuse in jallikattu . Its possbile to oppose this everywhere. But if someone opposes one while supports other, then they are pushing their agenda, not animal rights. PETA is NOT that, i assure u.
Third, struggle in every country depends on how open and free that country is. PETA has maximum demonstrations in US *because* it is free country which allows protest. So is India. It doesn't mean India is most cruel place for animals. If you say , why don't PETA protest against bakrid in Saudi arabia, that's simply not possible. Not because PETA supports it, but cuz that country has no freedom at all. Or people may threaten violence against protestors in name of culture etc. We should be thankful that doesnt happen in India (till now).
VIVEK D i m glad that u spoke for peta but it would be better if peta and others concentrate on real issues that are of more concern and less bothering conspiracies.
Aandavar for reason
with due respect kamal sir, its very dumb to compare elephant processions in kerala with jalikkettu and its not been done in the name of religion, its part of kerala culture as well
Rationalist for a Reason.
mr hassan lol ffs just call him kamal or kamalhassan
Mr. kamal sir...right... justified... the truth .... but there is su swamy .... wrong way of talk... they have to escape some issue ... they using some tricks.... nhrc .... what they are going to justify ..let us c
News reader - U have any traditional much more tamil????
Don't ban rape! Just regulate it!
Rape is different from it mf venna😂
Mr Hassan, it is possible to criticise jallikattu and also other "traditions" where animals are abused/killed. You can criticise double standards of people opposing jallikattu but not the idea that animals shouldn't be abused
Plz enlighten me oh PETA supporter wat to do wid these bulls once they lose their purpose. Don't giv me crappy answer like they r bttr off slaughtering than been "hurt" in Jallikattu. As a PETA member, out of d 500 bulls tht participate every year can u give me proof tht atleast 100 bulls have been abused in d way u ppl projected it in SC? So if majority of bulls r treated like gods and there is abuse for a few bulls, shud'nt u ppl b going after the owners or d violators rather than d sport. All they had to do was perform a day and live d rest of the year like a King. The only training they give is swimming for their legs to b strong. Other than tht they don't even plough fields as they r too rugged for it. So now tell me u blame d farmer who take a bull to jallikattu for 1 day. What do u call d same farmer who treats it like his child for the rest of d year
Vivek: Buddy , the proof of burden is on you to prove to the court that u r not violating the law i.e. prevention to cruelty act. Not the other way round. PETA has won the case by convincing court that the sport in itself amounts to animal abuse. I am no authority on whether jallikattu is cruel to animals or not. I am assuming it is because SC has said so. And my argument is on that presumption. If what u say is correct, nobody would have problem with the sport. But u failed to convince the court about it. Its another matter if u think court is biased.
And no, I don't support slaughtering and don't even eat meat. But come on , we know what happens to the bulls in this country. It is not for nothing that india is largest beef exporter.
I'd rather say euthanasia is WAYYY better than slaughtering. Animal dies in peace and without pain.
Look here Jallikattu was a matter that was isolated to just 2 districts of TN. But tnx to PETA, the majority of ppl who knew Jallikattu as only a part of our culture, came to know abt its rules and breeding ideology and they truly believe where as the rest of India continues to despise us. But I'd say a big Thank You to PETA for uniting TN. Now Jallikattu will have more fame and control and support than ever b4. I don't know whether u know how much it costs to stand a case in SC. I'll openly say PETA targeted Jallikattu bcoz it was not much backed unlike rich men sport like horse racing where crorepatis can shell out cash. Sorry to say but unlike PETA the Jallikattu community in TN doesnt have the "magic" money to contest in SC. And yeah of course PETA is good at presentations and SC had to abide by the laws tht was stated. I'd say PETA won just bcoz of gud presentation skills. And just becoz u were able to project a mistake in Jallikattu as the whole sport itself and if u consider it as fair, then u r supporting all those fraud rich ppl who made money out of the poor by saying tht d fraud was smart and d poor was dumb. Euthanasia is killing when the animal cannot be saved. Slaughtering is done to kill and get good meat. And when farmers have an option to save bulls from slaughtering thru Jallikattu where is the problem here.Slaughtering and euthanasia are therefore entirely different. So ur comparison is utterly, sorry, senseless.
Kamal is just an actor not a representative of tamil culture ! So don't belive his thoughts or ideas strongly. Know the culture first , live in it ! Then only you will know what is tamil culture
what is medai first do we have proper news of question and answer we talk as if we talk any one as question and answer is that healthy or do we have stuff to prepare good homework
first media where theat u collect which kind of analysis u make when u ask questions none of media never showed single person of peta
we talk lot of things i happen search so many websites all that but none of visual active members of all state ,
lot of country the people carry a talk of freedom and make presentation in their degrees persued over all what this country plans each one y dont u regulate and make with funding will be done by our side
so from there they come forward about raping , mesturation cycle , periods
and it goes to the leve afforestation , banning a livily hood sports
not to gain this much profit from trees
but we c most wooden houses wooden flooring mostly 200 percent execute in other countries
we c hardly at resorts we dont have wooden flooring hardly very few
so banning to grow and banning to cut which country formed , where to take food do u question which food i should take
the story of egg itself still we dont understand and innvoation of allopathy business
and what is about siddha medicine y it is not so constructive as strength and immunity in tamilnadu we have where somewhere in corner
it is a shame roots stil evident to support so many cases of immunity
and govt hospital exapansion govt siddha expansion as district wider perspective we stilll hunt for books and private clincs as choice fate of india is because privatisation
what as govt will learn
it is highly shaming every indian employment exchange still people decades of waitning without any facts and figures should not bla bla bla on that
kindly dont over judge the nation is going as the percentage of job this much percentage is highly false information to project how the loan is projected to get a sanctioned same way
to fund from other country to fund for other montery fund all that make and made every country has its own demerits
a scheme and polices it is suitable to 100 members or 1lakh member that's it it does not feed to entire country it a scheme if that takes correct figures it is not at all possible
we dont have proper map to regulation or regulators as and when politcan word of mouth as talk that is what infused as laaw this is what teaching so for schools to education if u ask tommrow
even the stome wil made saying yesterday born today is GOD and GODESS is that what we understand as spirtuality or politcan
no way different tommrow thier wax or stone statue is GOD as party itself a great learning curve
fate of indians what as we understand as district labour law or state or central law forced to c circus often
India now bad conditions .
Rich people believe money , go behind money
not think INDIA.
Super :-)
what is our extranal minster carried as a talk it is state intrest or milk is not the immunity be it flesh eaters or meat eaters we consume and drink dont u c anything a consumption slowly showing a biggest bad sign as price and bad sign as inflation rise in price
as 500 ml milkpockets cost is so big a delhi people can argue is cheap or any welathiest state is that so
it is shame to understand how for we been
what as state cooperative animal and agriculture farming - how for private how for outsider private comes as royality as patent what is going on
how that a coke carried a milk as distribution
coke and pepsi should go out and we need strong autonomy rules in each state and central
we dont c as simple the invaders outside come and occupy and they deciding factor what people should eat
cheeck out indian broiler and egg how much we look as potential
a study of allopathy related to disease alilments calcium and all that
what kind of sports to be carried encourage milk kusthi kabbadi some thing as men and women
and we dont bother nothing as welfare of people as immunity just what for amul milk what for panner bavu baji
all that made of milk bread to confentionary sweets
so much lethargy of shaming a state
it is mandatory and made it compuslory to revist each coperative farming methods usage and counts of their business as govt and private how for we need proper debate we need to c who are agriculture minsteer in each state and work carried what is land coverage and animal farming each
and each state a district and group of places in district a big forum should be just like every month on month so that only we can make it process and bfing to best economic price and exports good variety we dont c nothing
all that some x and y fooliosh bastard talking as peta what lot of invaders coming already occupied as sleepr cell ffrom each party who knows
we need to bring sollid regulation that is what
indian district group of places froming a district dont have labour laws i, central and state all that police station business to be expanded are they are law makers are business makers it is to c
watchman to any thing they been used what for labour law state law what is human rights what is it shaming
it is some state u point it up shame it reflect whole nation a pm this much lethargy declaring ordiance when some one is absecnt a major decison maker and firm decider of carryhing it is loss
a bjp to make business it is clearlyh evident shown openly this is what politcs
🤴🙏
regulate word is that strictly highly hidden be it any law enforced as central or state or labour law
prior to that do we proper understanding about what as complaints register how for we bear saying some one x carried the issue as ban or y made this comment
we dont even receive message who are peta first ,how many member work in us as member and each country who are members
carried how many meber of india carry animal advisory way of protection directly indirectly as protection and peta forms of other country invaders who just get fund rolling by x or y top most people poweful in busienss zone of politcs with coproprate funds or to find a new way devalue the country markett
we still dont understand like jailkattu when a milk is questioned and taken away some one x or y as useless and u get to feed as the life with injected as frozen egg to reproduce all that to fool indain people
already indian health cases - is highly detroiationg more than indian life style and physcial fitness and people in lesser age get lot of disorders complication invariably
so it is first step be it coke to pepsi and their energy drinks and their milk business , now a days lot of sports highly the tradition is slowly made to deviate and made to focus as couach potato move as work jobs to brains
we c as opportunity invariably we been accepting as slave as sports whatever other country rules and regulation it is shaming
indian needed proper state to state universal protection to enter in to market or to protect our politan or board should document major things plants , foods
now broiler chicken flesh do u like as if as hotel mixed with all masala it looks good over all we are not eating healthy stuff
now we are chaning to prepare ourself from making masalas to even making kitchen receipes powder each resident started making market is flooded which is orginal and duplicate
still we c agricutlure this much loss how each company making of powder masalas how that possible even question arises how this much milk private companies are there where thy get , what are the
we still so blank what for we cannot coin any one what is healthy stuff
a milk consumption each family a 500ml for 2 member reached to 3 to four member do u feel inflation or shame on business done in each cooperative farming highest corruption carried we say what for media news paper identifying when something rong y dont with a proper technican y dont make each sectors of state district farming document in media as a big task work instead
we eat broiler chicken as heart attack alilment and what is going on generic drug is not there
what is india doing looting indian health and business hand over to x and y outsiders
a population as a district we dont get sufficent milk with cheapest price what for fooling gst or tax forming too fool as british tax
a ,milk pocket should be any form should be price not more than 10 , it is not same as delhi ecnonomy at kanayakumari
it is not same price as fish in kanyakumari as ecnomy as in delhi
all that food hotels price is too much as food
I Support jallikattu bt don't support anti national act n osama bin laden
Typical whataboutery here. Find any other reason to justify jallikattu Mr Hassan, but culture and tradition can't be one. Also, as a PETA volunteer, I request you to please look at what PETA does and stand for. There is no double standard.
"Spanish bullfighting! The Spanish does it!"
"But...but..people die in football!"
"I love biriyani btw."
- Another actor with a dumb logic
you need more time to understand what he said,,, it's not dumb logic...!!!!!!
Kishore Shanmugam
You need to understand reality.
@@edhominem6804 do u know anything about jallikattu?
Hominem what you about Tamil culture? Pls shut.
We all have first ban you Nidhi
Jallikattu is to be stop by all mean, heshould be the bull instead a poor animal let people who run after the bull run behind this crazy man he is a cruel beast and not a human in all at all I like comment more on this but I keep quite. Thank yu.
Do u what is the rules of jallikattu first learn and the oppose the real name is yereu tazhavuthal which means hugging the hump of the bull for three jumps that's it he is the winner
If there's a victim involved in a tradition or culture then it's best to dump that into to trash. Traditional and cultures were invented by us, so as all the evil deeds we have done in the past centuries. PETA is not American but it's an organisation with people from different parts of the world. PETA shares the same ancient principle "Ahimsa", which Indians today have forgotten and ignored.
really sad decission by the Court.
super sir 👍👏👏