I pray a company who appreciates their content creators buys TH-cam. There is literally no excuse for the way they are treating their creators. A really excellent video as usual!
VirginiaGirl 66 APPRECIATE... you're asking for a bit much. It's ALL ABOUT dollars and cents to conglomerate corporations. ALWAYS HAS... ALWAYS SHALL BE. Just a sad fact my good and NO DOUBT honest friend. PEACE AND PROSPERITY TO YOU!
TH-cam couldn't even be what it is today without creators like you. This is my favorite channel and I absolutely love the originality you bring to your videos.
I don't understand YT's decision to demonetise your work. I see a lot of channels are full of so much rubbish and here you are presenting very tastefully prepared historical work, and they decide against it. I just want to say that I'm glad I found your work and I'm loving the content of such sad stories that are compiled with a great amount of respect from you.
They have pornography on TH-cam. Why are they upset with these dramas?I get dinged for nothing URL because of my religious opinion.You get cited for literature.What's up with these people ???
Oddie, you are the only creator whose work I intentionally watch multiple times. I’m always struck by the fact that people, their motivations and weaknesses, have not changed in the passage of time. Only the surroundings and instruments give a clue to the time frame of the story. Thank you again for not leaving us without access, we know you don’t have to post here and we’re eternally grateful for your man of the people persona. Oh, the holiday videos are fascinating in and of themselves, but they’re also a day with the oddities, our favorite people. More please!
Well that is indeed a great compliment my friend, and very much appreciated. Yes human nature has not changed much at all, we would like to think that we have evolved, and indeed our quality of life and social laws has come along way, at least here in the west, but emotionally we are still the same creatures. New video coming very soon!
The well narrated tale kept my interest piqued throughout its entire course. The poor girl did not deserve her cruel death by a cold and calculating murderer.
*After asking for a review after the video was demonetised immediately, and the review being rejected, I wrote to TH-cam asking for an internal review, and to scroll through my subscribers comments to understand how ridiculous their decision was to demonetise it in the first place....it worked! Thank you my dear friends :)* I have also started a new channel on Vimeo - which at the moment I'm using to slowly post videos that YT have demonetised, as some of the newer subscribers may not have seen them, because YT doesn't recommend as much...or not at all. vimeo.com/o101879728obsoleteoddity I'm going to be posting on TH-cam selected previously locked Patreon videos that are approximately 1.5 (one and a half) years old. This is one of them. Many, many thanks to my patrons on Patreon for enabling me to keep going - bless you all! Some of the topics discussed on the 'blah blah' towards the end of video, because of the upload date, may no longer be relevant. Later videos are more graphic in content, and will most certainly be demonetised by TH-cam; nevertheless, thanks to my loyal Patreon patrons, I will eventually post them here too despite TH-cam's advertiser friendly policy. Link to my Patreon page and other sites under the description :)
I watch a few channels like this and they spell out instead of saying certain words as i think theyve said certain words can get videos demonetised, like murder and other crime related words (samantha M , Stephanie harlowe are the ones i watch whho spell out certain words instead of sayong them ?)
There are people on youtube live streaming who use very raw language and routinely drop F bombs yet their channels are fully monetized. What is going on here? Oddie, Is the decision to demonetize actually made after review by a human being or is it done after some sort of algorithmic audit or review? I do not believe that the word "brothel" Or the mention of a woman who was a prostitute in the 1800s would be enough or should be enough to demonetized any channel. I have my suspicions though that perhaps if they're using some sort of search where looking for specific keywords on which to base demonetization that this might be the clue and could be based on Helen's last name.
ObsoleteOddity I fail to understand why TH-cam demonetizes works like this, while allowing a number of channels to post sexualized footage of underage girls under the pretence of them being models...with followings comprised almost exclusively of fully grown men. It makes no sense at all, but we have your back Oddie. We will not allow your tasteful work to be denied its worth. 🖤🇨🇦
So...she chose the life of a prostitute because it was easy money, and then she took up with a bad dude who told her that he was bad (all the while still turning tricks), and then she tried to extort something from him and wound up dead...and we're somehow expected to view that as tragic? Did I miss something here?
One of my favourite parts of your stories are the embellishments in the pictures, such as gaslights, butterflies, flames in ceiling lights and other added items. Always narrated well.
Knocked this one out of the ballpark yet again! Attention to detail especially in the narrative is very important for someone like me who well can’t see the pretty pictures. Wonderful narration as always. And I’m sure the video is very beautifully done. Thanks so much for all the work you put into it. Very sad story unfortunately. Look forward to the next one. Take care, take it easy and be safe everyone
@@AHarshman08 I love Oddie's voice too; he's an excellent narrator, and a keen student of history. I'm going to become a patron, his work deserves my support!
I feel for this young lady. I wish early on that someone would have been so enthralled with her that he would have married her and provided her with a better life. As for the demonetization. Don’t think for a minute that TH-cam is the ultimate arbiter of appreciation for your work. I and other subscribers like myself appreciate the time and work you take to bring these works to us. Please keep it up, and enjoy your weekend... .
I absolutely love your videos, there is nothing wrong with them at all. I’m in my seventies and believe me when I tell you that if there was anything inappropriate with them I would not be watching them. They are honest, well presented, and have interesting graphics done with the best of taste and a very clean concept. Perhaps you are just too intelligent in your presentation that intimidates the owners or whoever runs TH-cam. I will continue watching your videos and supporting you 100%.
What is wrong with TH-cam? There is nothing offensive about this video. I found it interesting and I love the animation. You always do such amazing work. Research is brilliant. Two thumbs up for you and 100 thumbs down for TH-cam
Jonah Goldgerg wrote a book called Liberal Facism. If you had read it you could've accurately predicted their response to anything that even faintly offends their false morality.
@@nenesimone It's nothing to do with the content, adults watch adult themes, and adults are consumers and buy products; it's absolutely insulting to our intelligence for YT to try and make us believe that advertisers don't want to place their products with popular videos. Just watch the plethora of ads on absolutely horrific horror films on cable networks. Yes cable networks don't like the competition from indie film-makers.
A story worth telling. My heart goes out for her. Thank you for delivering this tragic event with complete upscaled class. You grabbed and held my attention throughout.
Oh, they certainly do.. and if you didn't start off lower class, they take and take so that's where you stay. A.K.A. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer. It's gotten nothing but worse and more ridiculous and petty.. (kind of like demonetization on You Tube) When Good is Evil and Evil is Good, that's when the Lord is gonna come and collect the good who believe in him. The good who've suffered mercilessly on Earth as did Christ himself. He will take the good who've suffered and finally they will have eternal peace ✝️😊♥️🙏✝️
@Cheryl Lynne I don't know about the other states but in Pennsylvania, which is supposed to favor mothers,the double standard, at least in my experience where children and youth are involved is unbelievable. For example, I have ADHD, so yeah, you'll notice I'm a little off but realize if you really listen, I'm intuitive and more intelligent than may come across at first, but because I have ADHD according to c&y, makes me an unfit mother.. but it's just okay for our son's dad to not take care of his diabetes and be found and have to go to the er with a blood sugar of 14! Near death. If I mess up. I'm irresponsible. But what is it for say our nonverbal autistic son has no idea what wth is going on when his dad is just passed out on the floor. We're not together. But damn. When I'm awake, I'm awake and he's fed with clean clothes and attended to.. total double standard!!
How sad that even in death, they didn't leave her with her dignity. And the murderer got to live out his life in luxury and comfort. Thank you for this video. Very well done and entertaining, as always.
@@juliecasey3283 it is too bad, .. that stupid, ridiculous cheap ending of the young girl's life .. sex is sex, .. and if two want to agree to the bed without rules, .. so be it. However, .. there is true love with all the happiness that two can make, .. and no-one can replace such joy .. the trust between two, ... not based on molding gifts,.. or gold to be remelted by some pawn shop.
Here in Nevada, we have the case of Mademoiselle Julia Bulette. He murderer was hanged and it was witnessed by Mark Twain. Love your work, the older history, the way you establish the tale and are able to keep it up throughout the video. Screw YT! LOL
One of the absolutely best channels on TH-cam! THIS channel is what TH-cam is supposed to be about! I am so disgusted by the unwarranted demonitization of some of your best creators - and simultaneously allowing so much garbage! Do your job TH-cam!
Wonderful video as always Oddy. Can't help but feel sorry for the women living in those times, there didn't seem like there were many options for them.
Your videos are always the highlight of my days. Thank you for all your hard work. I know putting together a great quality video (like they ALL are) isn’t easy, but we all enjoy and appreciate all the hard work you put into making these. Again, thank you.
Intrigue at its finest!. I agree that times have not changed much. To this day important letters or testimony is not allowed in court. I will never understand why. Thank you for creating this. The sailing ship was breathtaking
They are demonetizing all sorts of videos...most shockingly and surprising is how many videos talking about any sort of history are included and they have stated their intentions to do as such.
Anna Sloan yes. They say anything involving or discussing war, natural disasters, religion, etc. So basically everything that isn’t a “make your own slime” video.
It’s perhaps has already been said, your channel and work always leaves the viewer entertained and knowledgeable about the oddities of history. Thanks.
This was an amazing story, so sad but not uncommon for the time. Still today women murdered who work in the sex trade are often overlooked or demonized because of their occupation. It's sad that Mr. Robinson got away with murder. You did a wonderful job with this piece!
Oddly enough, men who work manual labor are treated the same way when they're killed by old useless equipment and safety tools. Is a damn shame really. Those boss who are too cheap to keep their workers safe are murderers.
It is nearly impossible to investigate prostitutes' murder cases because they meet complete stranger on a daily bases .... almost all murder cases carried by a stranger are impossible to crack and unless the stranger murderer is a serial killer, they are impossible to catch. saying that theses cases and the women involved are demonized or overlooked is not true.
Absolutely riveting as usual. I like your choice of stories and the pictures you include are very entertaining. Thank you for providing captivating bits of History.
How did I miss this one?! The graphics are gorgeous. One can tell you worked very hard on this. Thank you so much! The man got away with murder, very cunning indeed. Nice hearing about old cases and how everything worked back then. Bravo!
Beautiful work my friend. Have you made one about Gypsy Rose? She was a burlesque dancer. I think during the depression era. Back when women just didn't do that. My 85 yr old nana snuck in to watch her as a child. Very famous self made woman. Just an idea. Hoping everyone has a blessed weekend!!
David Whitman Character Actor --Yes, she was a very funny and entertaining talk show hostess. She had a son by a well known movie mogul, who didn't know he existed until after Gypsy Rose Lee died. Father and son were thrilled and delighted to meet.
I LOVE your videos, and you have the perfect voice for it. Don't stress about the videos too much, whenever they're up, you can bet we'll be here. Thanks for the wonderful work, stay safe Oddy!
What a story,wow,and you always make us feel like we are actually there with all the characters. No Justice was ever found for poor Helen, in life or death. Looking forward to more stories 🤗
This was heart wrenching to hear. Like, she got murdered having to live how she lived. Then she didn't have peace and decency. They dig her up, then autopsy her and then reduced her to a skeleton to be hung and gawked at. 😔If a soul ever had a reason to haunt the shit outta someone. It's her. How sad indeed😔No justice is there at all even remotely. So so sad.
I’m sorry I didn’t see this sooner. I took a history class about three years ago, and we covered this story in detail. I was fascinated and looked for videos about it, but there were only two at the time, one of which was terrible. I bought a book about her and she’s one of my favorite crime stories. Good job on the video, keep up the good work.
"Life and death of a courtesan"... It's a sad story for this young woman. I would like to thank you a lot ObsoleteOddity for the incredible talent to tell a story and for your beautiful video artwork ! I'm a French man and I never knew this story. But thank you very much for your work and for sharing it. Regards.
You are bringing back radio narration of mystery's of history...Great name for your work, it was very classy and without bias, cold hard facts...Radio's greatest comback, thank you this was a treat!
Have missed you horribly..... So happy and excited to see the video And as usual very good info and the reading was delightful in your voice Thumbs up as usual Please keep up the good work for us who can not afford patreon.
Oh man! Yes I have been gone a long time and it's wonderful to see here you again. Helen Jewett is on my family tree. I knew it the first time I saw her name!
I think you always do a fantastic job of researching and presenting the stories in a elegant an factual and interesting true presentation.I thank you.Im using my son's phone so this comment comes under his name.Please continue your lovely work.
Being a courtesan was never the safest choice f career. For a young women, (anymore than it is today). She appeared to have both beauty and intellect, although threatening a client is never the wisest course of action. Clearly, she was a celebrated beauty or her murder would not have been such a publicized event. I suspect the blandishments of fine gowns and gentlemen callers of social standing struck her as preferable to the hard work and low wages of servants at the time. It was all a rather sad story, but by no means an uncommon end for women in her profession, although those employed in the finer brothels had a stronger measure of protection. Thank you for bringing us another peek into history, enlivened by your clever animations. I hope you and your Beloved are enjoying your sojourn in the Black Forest and France. Wishing you light and love along the way.🖤🇨🇦
Thank you for your very kind feedback Tamarra. :) We have now returned from the Black Forest and France - check out my 'community' section here (one of the sub-headers on my TH-cam home page,) ...and you will see and read my latest post about some very interesting future uploads regarding our road trip! Love and light along the path xx
Depending on your class it was never really a choice. Even women with “legitimate” work during low seasons made ends meet by temporarily selling their bodies. Jack the Ripper killed women who had multiple jobs along with occasional prostitution.
Tamarra James did you just shame a fucking woman who couldnt have voted or owned property for choosing to do so on her back instead of on her feet for hours on end with high likelihood of sexual exploitation regardless? Fucking gross, dude.
TH-cam stop being stupid and use common sense when making decisions, and if your over worked and there's just not enough workers, who have the time to go over these videos properly, and in a fair manner then please higher more ppl!!! Don't just don't demonize creators!!! TH-cam, isn't that why we have the choice to watch ADULT CONTENT?!
I woke up this morning saw a notification from you tube. Ohh a new oddity story. Watched it with my first coffee. What a great way to start the day. Msde me sad and angry to think may girls from 3rd world countries still go through the same. And he didn't even pay for his crime. Such an unfair world. Thanks again for narrating stories so brilliantly.
Excellent video! I was especially taken by the cat that wandered through the bedroom. It is such touches that make the viewer feel they are transported to the time and place, involved in the action.
You put alot of effort into these videos for us. Between listening to the story and seeing the story come alive with the sounds animation is brilliant. .
I really like the tasteful, sometimes invisible use of audio effects. The water effect and the crowd in this story were nearly invisible, but perfect and establishing the mood. The score as well. Really well done stories, I'm so glad I found this channel.
I think your videos are awesome! I think you take the time and effort to get them accurate and very enjoyable!I hope you keep making videos on the history we do not know! Thank you and God Bless you
Thanks for another interesting story, dear friend Oddie. Your voice is very calm and soothing. You Tube is very bias. Your stories are clean, not messy, or overtly gory, or bloody , you do not use filthy languages, or swear words. Oddie, you narrate true stories and bring them to interested audience like me. We can't get enough of your beautiful voice. No one tells stories, or bring them to life like you. Thanks again for being you, my favourite story teller. 😀😀 I do not think much has changed for poor young women looking to make a living . There are many evil men and women out there who are waiting and ready to take advantage of gullible young people who are lonely and looking for a jobs. Sad world we are living in .
As a subscriber for a year or more, I must say good quality has become supreme, with your output! This has been created with such attention to production value, that I am greatly impressed - although I was initially, when I subscribed. I appreciated, even then, the level of output! Beautifully presented.
I just found your channel a couple days ago and am in love with your content.!! Your research is very thorough and your videos are the best. TH-cam should be praising creators like you, you make TH-cam what it is.!!!!
I really appreciate that Anna, thank you so much for your lovely feedback - so glad you’re enjoying my content! Unfortunately TH-cam doesn’t seem to value my content.
I pray a company who appreciates their content creators buys TH-cam. There is literally no excuse for the way they are treating their creators. A really excellent video as usual!
Thank you for your very kind feedback my friend. :)
Or a new company forces competition.
Agree completely.
VirginiaGirl 66 APPRECIATE... you're asking for a bit much. It's ALL ABOUT dollars and cents to conglomerate corporations. ALWAYS HAS... ALWAYS SHALL BE. Just a sad fact my good and NO DOUBT honest friend. PEACE AND PROSPERITY TO YOU!
TH-cam couldn't even be what it is today without creators like you. This is my favorite channel and I absolutely love the originality you bring to your videos.
Thank you very much for your very kind feedback Rachel - much appreciated :)
One of my absolute favorites on TH-cam
I don't understand YT's decision to demonetise your work.
I see a lot of channels are full of so much rubbish and here you are presenting very tastefully prepared historical work, and they decide against it.
I just want to say that I'm glad I found your work and I'm loving the content of such sad stories that are compiled with a great amount of respect from you.
That's very kind of you Claudia, thank you.
I don’t understand either. His content is so well done and interesting. So much rubbish out there. I agree with you.
Like best history teacher ever , this Chanel I can’t live without
They have pornography on TH-cam. Why are they upset with these dramas?I get dinged for nothing URL because of my religious opinion.You get cited for literature.What's up with these people ???
She was a call girl.😆😆😆
Oddie, you are the only creator whose work I intentionally watch multiple times. I’m always struck by the fact that people, their motivations and weaknesses, have not changed in the passage of time. Only the surroundings and instruments give a clue to the time frame of the story. Thank you again for not leaving us without access, we know you don’t have to post here and we’re eternally grateful for your man of the people persona. Oh, the holiday videos are fascinating in and of themselves, but they’re also a day with the oddities, our favorite people. More please!
Well that is indeed a great compliment my friend, and very much appreciated.
Yes human nature has not changed much at all, we would like to think that we have evolved, and indeed our quality of life and social laws has come along way, at least here in the west, but emotionally we are still the same creatures.
New video coming very soon!
True
The well narrated tale kept my interest piqued throughout its entire course. The poor girl did not deserve her cruel death by a cold and calculating murderer.
Thanks for your very kind feedback Michael, much appreciated :)
*After asking for a review after the video was demonetised immediately, and the review being rejected, I wrote to TH-cam asking for an internal review, and to scroll through my subscribers comments to understand how ridiculous their decision was to demonetise it in the first place....it worked! Thank you my dear friends :)*
I have also started a new channel on Vimeo - which at the moment I'm using to slowly post videos that YT have demonetised, as some of the newer subscribers may not have seen them, because YT doesn't recommend as much...or not at all.
vimeo.com/o101879728obsoleteoddity
I'm going to be posting on TH-cam selected previously locked Patreon videos that are approximately 1.5 (one and a half) years old. This is one of them.
Many, many thanks to my patrons on Patreon for enabling me to keep going - bless you all!
Some of the topics discussed on the 'blah blah' towards the end of video, because of the upload date, may no longer be relevant. Later videos are more graphic in content, and will most certainly be demonetised by TH-cam; nevertheless, thanks to my loyal Patreon patrons, I will eventually post them here too despite TH-cam's advertiser friendly policy. Link to my Patreon page and other sites under the description :)
I will check the link out! ☻ when is your next contest?
Hello my dear friend. I have missed you, I need to catch up on the vids. I have been out on med leave. xoxo Kat.
I watch a few channels like this and they spell out instead of saying certain words as i think theyve said certain words can get videos demonetised, like murder and other crime related words (samantha M , Stephanie harlowe are the ones i watch whho spell out certain words instead of sayong them ?)
There are people on youtube live streaming who use very raw language and routinely drop F bombs yet their channels are fully monetized. What is going on here? Oddie, Is the decision to demonetize actually made after review by a human being or is it done after some sort of algorithmic audit or review? I do not believe that the word "brothel" Or the mention of a woman who was a prostitute in the 1800s would be enough or should be enough to demonetized any channel. I have my suspicions though that perhaps if they're using some sort of search where looking for specific keywords on which to base demonetization that this might be the clue and could be based on Helen's last name.
ObsoleteOddity I fail to understand why TH-cam demonetizes works like this, while allowing a number of channels to post sexualized footage of underage girls under the pretence of them being models...with followings comprised almost exclusively of fully grown men. It makes no sense at all, but we have your back Oddie. We will not allow your tasteful work to be denied its worth. 🖤🇨🇦
I feel for poor Helen. And the fact that he got away with it and went on to live a trouble free, prosperous life makes it so much worse.
So...she chose the life of a prostitute because it was easy money, and then she took up with a bad dude who told her that he was bad (all the while still turning tricks), and then she tried to extort something from him and wound up dead...and we're somehow expected to view that as tragic? Did I miss something here?
chokkan7 fuck off. Victim blaming is ugly.
@@shariwelch8760 Except when the victim is to blame.
crowe bobby She wasn’t to blame. No one deserves to be axed to death and set on fire, you asshole.
@@MrCrowebobby she was murdered , the murderer is the one to blame
Another beautifully told tale of sorrow. Well done.
One of my favourite parts of your stories are the embellishments in the pictures, such as gaslights, butterflies, flames in ceiling lights and other added items. Always narrated well.
I really appreciate such positive feedback - thank you very much :)
and the kitty cat........
Knocked this one out of the ballpark yet again! Attention to detail especially in the narrative is very important for someone like me who well can’t see the pretty pictures. Wonderful narration as always. And I’m sure the video is very beautifully done. Thanks so much for all the work you put into it. Very sad story unfortunately. Look forward to the next one. Take care, take it easy and be safe everyone
I really appreciate your positive feedback - thank you very much :)
So many things to do today! Is that a new ObsoleteOddity video? Everything can wait, (pours a cup of coffee).🍪☕
I said Oddie has a new video and my two year old daughter demanded that we sit down and watch it. She loves his voice. Now I get to enjoy my Chai tea.
@@AHarshman08 I love Oddie's voice too; he's an excellent narrator, and a keen student of history. I'm going to become a patron, his work deserves my support!
100%agree👍😎
Gr8 idea 😊☕🍪
I love how detailed and in-depth your videos are.
I feel for this young lady. I wish early on that someone would have been so enthralled with her that he would have married her and provided her with a better life.
As for the demonetization. Don’t think for a minute that TH-cam is the ultimate arbiter of appreciation for your work. I and other subscribers like myself appreciate the time and work you take to bring these works to us. Please keep it up, and enjoy your weekend... .
Thank you for your very kind feedback my friend. :)
Hello Oddie. Your video work has improved. I like the small cat or dog walking across a still frame...ha ha
Thanks for the entertainment.
Ya. Well, you know what they say, you can’t turn a hoe into a housewife ☺️
I reported the insane person’s comments
What happened to my kind, heartfelt thread? Mr. Oddity deserves better than this...
It was read like an adult horror bedtime story.... well done....I’m safe under my blanket now ... good night
I absolutely love your videos, there is nothing wrong with them at all. I’m in my seventies and believe me when I tell you that if there was anything inappropriate with them I would not be watching them. They are honest, well presented, and have interesting graphics done with the best of taste and a very clean concept. Perhaps you are just too intelligent in your presentation that intimidates the owners or whoever runs TH-cam. I will continue watching your videos and supporting you 100%.
Thank you very much for your kind feedback and support Barbara - much appreciated.
Affirmative and well stated!
What is wrong with TH-cam? There is nothing offensive about this video. I found it interesting and I love the animation. You always do such amazing work. Research is brilliant. Two thumbs up for you and 100 thumbs down for TH-cam
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Mary - much appreciated.
Jonah Goldgerg wrote a book called Liberal Facism. If you had read it you could've accurately predicted their response to anything that even faintly offends their false morality.
Obviously it was the advertisers. They want family friendly content. Treating the internet like it is TV or something.
@@nenesimone It's nothing to do with the content, adults watch adult themes, and adults are consumers and buy products; it's absolutely insulting to our intelligence for YT to try and make us believe that advertisers don't want to place their products with popular videos. Just watch the plethora of ads on absolutely horrific horror films on cable networks. Yes cable networks don't like the competition from indie film-makers.
Maybe all youtubers should pull an area 51 and just not open yt for a week or 2.
I watch your videos as soon as I see them available. Thanks so much.
Glad you enjoyed it my friend, thanks for watching - cheers!
Love the kitty cat walking across the screen. It's little touches like that which make your videos really fun to watch.
I love how some of his pictures are made to blink! it's like....What? How are they doing that?!!
I loved that scene, too! 😺
A story worth telling. My heart goes out for her. Thank you for delivering this tragic event with complete upscaled class. You grabbed and held my attention throughout.
Thanks for your very kind feedback Amy - very much appreciated :)
Like being at the theatre, magical. A very gifted storyteller.
Thank you so much for reaching out with your kind feedback 😊
Shame that courts today still treat the difference in social class the same as they did 200 years ago.
@Toni Sumblin yes but it's more like an oligarchy.
Oh, they certainly do.. and if you didn't start off lower class, they take and take so that's where you stay. A.K.A. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer. It's gotten nothing but worse and more ridiculous and petty.. (kind of like demonetization on You Tube) When Good is Evil and Evil is Good, that's when the Lord is gonna come and collect the good who believe in him. The good who've suffered mercilessly on Earth as did Christ himself. He will take the good who've suffered and finally they will have eternal peace ✝️😊♥️🙏✝️
@Cheryl Lynne I don't know about the other states but in Pennsylvania, which is supposed to favor mothers,the double standard, at least in my experience where children and youth are involved is unbelievable. For example, I have ADHD, so yeah, you'll notice I'm a little off but realize if you really listen, I'm intuitive and more intelligent than may come across at first, but because I have ADHD according to c&y, makes me an unfit mother.. but it's just okay for our son's dad to not take care of his diabetes and be found and have to go to the er with a blood sugar of 14! Near death. If I mess up. I'm irresponsible. But what is it for say our nonverbal autistic son has no idea what wth is going on when his dad is just passed out on the floor. We're not together. But damn. When I'm awake, I'm awake and he's fed with clean clothes and attended to.. total double standard!!
@Cheryl Lynne 😅😅😅😅😅
Yup and men get way longer sentences than women somehow. Pretty shame!
How sad that even in death, they didn't leave her with her dignity. And the murderer got to live out his life in luxury and comfort. Thank you for this video. Very well done and entertaining, as always.
Da Blonde thanks for telling us the ending of the story
@@juliecasey3283 it is too bad, .. that stupid, ridiculous cheap ending of the young girl's life .. sex is sex, .. and if two want to agree to the bed without rules, .. so be it. However, .. there is true love with all the happiness that two can make, .. and no-one can replace such joy .. the trust between two, ... not based on molding gifts,.. or gold to be remelted by some pawn shop.
Da Blonde just like Marilyn Monroe
Even today with DNA the rich get richer, the poor get prison.
Here in Nevada, we have the case of Mademoiselle Julia Bulette. He murderer was hanged and it was witnessed by Mark Twain. Love your work, the older history, the way you establish the tale and are able to keep it up throughout the video. Screw YT! LOL
Was she the one from Virginia City?
One of the absolutely best channels on TH-cam!
THIS channel is what TH-cam is supposed to be about!
I am so disgusted by the unwarranted demonitization of some of your best creators - and simultaneously allowing so much garbage!
Do your job TH-cam!
TH-cam allow people to steal
Others videos so they have no morals at all anything good they bitch about
This story is beautifully told. It’s the first time I’ve come across your channel...you’ve got yourself another fan!
Many thanks for your very kind feedback my friend - Much appreciated :)
Great job Oddie!! Loved it! Viewers, go to his Patreon, the videos are even better!! TH-cam is unfair! Oddie is AMAZING!!
Thank you very much for your kind feedback and support Charity - much appreciated.
This is the first time I watch absolute oddity.
This is my first experience and I have to say... I love it! 🙂👍💯
Cristina Mata Same!! 😊
God..what a sad and horrible story..she was defiled in death as well as in life...great job as always Oddy..your voice is so soothing..💝🎈
Very poignant and sad rendition. You have talent and a heart for the situation. God bless you sir.
Thanks for your very kind feedback Lynn - much appreciated 😊
How sad. Thank you for another beautiful story..
Wonderful video as always Oddy. Can't help but feel sorry for the women living in those times, there didn't seem like there were many options for them.
Your videos are always the highlight of my days. Thank you for all your hard work. I know putting together a great quality video (like they ALL are) isn’t easy, but we all enjoy and appreciate all the hard work you put into making these. Again, thank you.
Thank you for your very kind feedback my friend. :)
Intrigue at its finest!. I agree that times have not changed much. To this day important letters or testimony is not allowed in court. I will never understand why. Thank you for creating this. The sailing ship was breathtaking
The story is interesting but the production and art effects are wonderful!
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Sophia - much appreciated.
Still love your work, Oddie! Thank you for continuing to make these!
I appreciate that. Thank you :)
Wonderful storytelling you have a wonderful voice love all your work
It must be offensive to TH-cam that you are putting intelligent informative content on TH-cam
That is the only thing that makes sense!!
Thats what i think...anything to do to dumb us down...take away knowledge and decide what to put in its place.
They are demonetizing all sorts of videos...most shockingly and surprising is how many videos talking about any sort of history are included and they have stated their intentions to do as such.
@@bethyame3 omg then it starts...keep your books.
Anna Sloan yes. They say anything involving or discussing war, natural disasters, religion, etc. So basically everything that isn’t a “make your own slime” video.
It’s perhaps has already been said, your channel and work always leaves the viewer entertained and knowledgeable about the oddities of history. Thanks.
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Terrence - much appreciated.
This story would make one heck of a movie. Thank-you for a most interesting, but sadly forgotten, bit of history.
TOTAL AWESOMENESS to hear from you. I've viewed all your videos on TH-cam. Keep them coming. God bless
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Bonnie - much appreciated.
This was an amazing story, so sad but not uncommon for the time. Still today women murdered who work in the sex trade are often overlooked or demonized because of their occupation. It's sad that Mr. Robinson got away with murder. You did a wonderful job with this piece!
Oddly enough, men who work manual labor are treated the same way when they're killed by old useless equipment and safety tools. Is a damn shame really. Those boss who are too cheap to keep their workers safe are murderers.
@QTee I have done extensive research with Tiffany FitzHenry and sex slaves are very much a world wide epidemic. You can fact check me.
It is nearly impossible to investigate prostitutes' murder cases because they meet complete stranger on a daily bases .... almost all murder cases carried by a stranger are impossible to crack and unless the stranger murderer is a serial killer, they are impossible to catch.
saying that theses cases and the women involved are demonized or overlooked is not true.
Another rattling tale! Thanks, Oddie. Sorry that YT demonetised it without obvious reason.
I've looked forward to your update. Thanks for the video!
Thank you for your kind feedback my friend - Much appreciated!
Absolutely riveting as usual. I like your choice of stories and the pictures you include are very entertaining. Thank you for providing captivating bits of History.
Thank you very much!
How did I miss this one?! The graphics are gorgeous. One can tell you worked very hard on this. Thank you so much! The man got away with murder, very cunning indeed. Nice hearing about old cases and how everything worked back then. Bravo!
Very glad you enjoyed it Joyce, thank you so much for your positive feedback.
Beautiful work my friend.
Have you made one about Gypsy Rose? She was a burlesque dancer. I think during the depression era. Back when women just didn't do that. My 85 yr old nana snuck in to watch her as a child. Very famous self made woman. Just an idea.
Hoping everyone has a blessed weekend!!
@Shirley Bailey didn't know that dear ty I'll look that up
Gypsy Rose Lee had a talk show for a while in the 1960's
David Whitman Character Actor --Yes, she was a very funny and entertaining talk show hostess.
She had a son by a well known movie mogul, who didn't know he existed until after Gypsy Rose Lee died.
Father and son were thrilled and delighted to meet.
@@mistydawn2717 i
Another excellent narrated piece, Oddie! What a sad ending...it shows just how unfair life can be sometimes :(
BUTTERFLIES! I love your vignettes
how are you today Oddie
Love the way these stories are told . A lot of research has gone into each and everyone . I’m totally hooked !
Thanks for your very kind feedback Jeanette, I appreciate it :)
I LOVE your videos, and you have the perfect voice for it. Don't stress about the videos too much, whenever they're up, you can bet we'll be here. Thanks for the wonderful work, stay safe Oddy!
Thank you very much for your kind feedback my friend, much appreciated :)
My, how little has changed.
Thank you for shedding light onto this story; your time spent is very much appreciated
What a story,wow,and you always make us feel like we are actually there with all the characters.
No Justice was ever found for poor Helen, in life or death.
Looking forward to more stories 🤗
How creepy of them to describe her corpse like that.
It was super creepy and slightly suspicious
J M O But it's like something Edgar Allan Poe would've written.
Especially after they committed the ultimate disrespect by robbing her grave.
Almost as creepy as demonetizing this excellently produced video!
Lilith I know it creeped me out
This was heart wrenching to hear. Like, she got murdered having to live how she lived. Then she didn't have peace and decency. They dig her up, then autopsy her and then reduced her to a skeleton to be hung and gawked at. 😔If a soul ever had a reason to haunt the shit outta someone. It's her. How sad indeed😔No justice is there at all even remotely. So so sad.
I’m sorry I didn’t see this sooner. I took a history class about three years ago, and we covered this story in detail. I was fascinated and looked for videos about it, but there were only two at the time, one of which was terrible. I bought a book about her and she’s one of my favorite crime stories. Good job on the video, keep up the good work.
Thanks for your very kind feedback - much appreciated :)
"Life and death of a courtesan"... It's a sad story for this young woman. I would like to thank you a lot ObsoleteOddity for the incredible talent to tell a story and for your beautiful video artwork ! I'm a French man and I never knew this story. But thank you very much for your work and for sharing it. Regards.
Thank you very much for your kind feedback my friend - much appreciated.
Dear Oddie, as always an empathetic,well researched and spellbinding video...Thank you.
Hello Oddie always love to see your posts
You are bringing back radio narration of mystery's of history...Great name for your work, it was very classy and without bias, cold hard facts...Radio's greatest comback, thank you this was a treat!
Many thanks for your very kind feedback Matlyn - Much appreciated :)
You bring such gentle grace to those whose sad stories you share with us. On their behalf, I thank you.
Thanks for your very kind feedback Mizera - much appreciated :)
Thanks for great video:) you really put lots of work into these videos, thanks:)
Thank you so much my friend!
Lovely feedback and very encouraging - bless you :)
Have missed you horribly..... So happy and excited to see the video
And as usual very good info and the reading was delightful in your voice
Thumbs up as usual
Please keep up the good work for us who can not afford patreon.
Oh how I have missed these stories!!! 💞
Sorry to hear about TH-cam. Don't know why they keep taking funds away from wonderful work!!
Your videos are not only educational but soothing. Thank you for putting your time and effort into the videos
Glad you like them! Thanks for your very kind feedback Christina, much appreciated :)
I really love the graphics and of course the stories..I always find myself still saying why.
Wow thats just crazy. My wife introduced me to your videos and ive been hooked ever since.
Oh man! Yes I have been gone a long time and it's wonderful to see here you again. Helen Jewett is on my family tree. I knew it the first time I saw her name!
Fine story telling and visuals. Looking foward to the next one. Thank you!
New sub here just for your integrity stated on an ealier vid about not buying subs & comments. Love your work.
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Dana - much appreciated.
I think you always do a fantastic job of researching and presenting the stories in a elegant an factual and interesting true presentation.I thank you.Im using my son's phone so this comment comes under his name.Please continue your lovely work.
Thanks for your very kind feedback my friend - much appreciated :)
Thank you, Oddie! Great video and excellent story telling.
Being a courtesan was never the safest choice f career. For a young women, (anymore than it is today). She appeared to have both beauty and intellect, although threatening a client is never the wisest course of action. Clearly, she was a celebrated beauty or her murder would not have been such a publicized event.
I suspect the blandishments of fine gowns and gentlemen callers of social standing struck her as preferable to the hard work and low wages of servants at the time. It was all a rather sad story, but by no means an uncommon end
for women in her profession, although those employed in the finer brothels had a stronger measure of protection.
Thank you for bringing us another peek into history, enlivened by your clever animations.
I hope you and your Beloved are enjoying your sojourn in the Black Forest and France. Wishing you light and love along the way.🖤🇨🇦
Thank you for your very kind feedback Tamarra. :)
We have now returned from the Black Forest and France - check out my 'community' section here (one of the sub-headers on my TH-cam home page,) ...and you will see and read my latest post about some very interesting future uploads regarding our road trip!
Love and light along the path xx
According to statistics, neither was getting married, lol.
funwithFred Good point, most things weren’t that good for women back then.🖤🇨🇦
Depending on your class it was never really a choice. Even women with “legitimate” work during low seasons made ends meet by temporarily selling their bodies. Jack the Ripper killed women who had multiple jobs along with occasional prostitution.
Tamarra James did you just shame a fucking woman who couldnt have voted or owned property for choosing to do so on her back instead of on her feet for hours on end with high likelihood of sexual exploitation regardless? Fucking gross, dude.
Thank you for your story time once again. Dont change a thing in how you present your stories its unique
Fun and intetesting
You have a beautiful voice telling the story of Helen
Thanks for the very kind feedback Sarah, much appreciated :)
Good story. Poor dear. Thank you for this!!
Glad you enjoyed it 😊
I love your stories, you should write some screenplays. These are movies I would go see in the theatre. Great story telling.
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Nina - much appreciated.
I love the stories so much, yesterday I was off and ended up watching 5 hours of your stories! Keep them coming ❤️
Love it when you gift us these gems 💎💗
Excellently told - such a sad tale of life.....I am utterly upset it got demonetized. This is so well done. Poor Helen- Rest In Peace. 💫💚🙏🏼👼🏼
Your stories are the BEST produced on You Tube, very well investigated and documented
That’s a great compliment Jenn, I really appreciated - thank you 🙏
The affects on the still photos are fantastic
TH-cam stop being stupid and use common sense when making decisions, and if your over worked and there's just not enough workers, who have the time to go over these videos properly, and in a fair manner then please higher more ppl!!! Don't just don't demonize creators!!! TH-cam, isn't that why we have the choice to watch ADULT CONTENT?!
Thank you very much for your kind feedback my friend - much appreciated.
@@ObsoleteOddity Great video congratulations
Excellent video
I woke up this morning saw a notification from you tube. Ohh a new oddity story. Watched it with my first coffee. What a great way to start the day.
Msde me sad and angry to think may girls from 3rd world countries still go through the same. And he didn't even pay for his crime. Such an unfair world.
Thanks again for narrating stories so brilliantly.
Thank you very much for your very kind feedback Ann - much appreciated :)
You are an amazing narrator\storyteller. Always enjoy your channel. Mickey and Sharon!
Love the mesmerizing voice of the narrator
Excellent video! I was especially taken by the cat that wandered through the bedroom. It is such touches that make the viewer feel they are transported to the time and place, involved in the action.
Thank you very much!
I enjoyed watching your video. You did an awesome job on it. Loved the history on it.
What a great video and well done narration. Shame on TH-cam for finding anything wrong with this piece of work
Thank you very much for your very kind feedback Cheryl - much appreciated :)
You put alot of effort into these videos for us. Between listening to the story and seeing the story come alive with the sounds animation is brilliant. .
Thank you so much! 😊
Sad story, great video. Love the photos with animations added. There was little justice back then just as there is little today.
Glad you enjoyed it
Awesome work as usual Sir...🖒💯
I really like the tasteful, sometimes invisible use of audio effects. The water effect and the crowd in this story were nearly invisible, but perfect and establishing the mood. The score as well. Really well done stories, I'm so glad I found this channel.
Thank you very much!
I think your videos are awesome! I think you take the time and effort to get them accurate and very enjoyable!I hope you keep making videos on the history we do not know! Thank you and God Bless you
Thanks for your very kind feedback Krista - much appreciated :)
Thanks for another interesting story, dear friend Oddie.
Your voice is very calm and soothing.
You Tube is very bias. Your stories are clean, not messy, or overtly gory, or bloody , you do not use filthy languages, or swear words. Oddie, you narrate true stories and bring them to interested audience like me. We can't get enough of your beautiful voice.
No one tells stories, or bring them to life like you.
Thanks again for being you, my favourite story teller. 😀😀
I do not think much has changed for poor young women looking to make a living . There are many evil men and women out there who are waiting and ready to take advantage of gullible young people who are lonely and looking for a jobs.
Sad world we are living in .
Thanks for your really great feedback Patricia, a truly wonderful compliment - much appreciated :)
As a subscriber for a year or more, I must say good quality has become supreme, with your output! This has been created with such attention to production value, that I am greatly impressed - although I was initially, when I subscribed. I appreciated, even then, the level of output! Beautifully presented.
Experience for viewers, has grown exponentially!
Thank you very much for your kind feedback Peter - much appreciated.
I just found your channel a couple days ago and am in love with your content.!! Your research is very thorough and your videos are the best. TH-cam should be praising creators like you, you make TH-cam what it is.!!!!
I really appreciate that Anna, thank you so much for your lovely feedback - so glad you’re enjoying my content!
Unfortunately TH-cam doesn’t seem to value my content.
Tragic tale beautifully told as always - you just keep getting better and better ❤
Thank you very much for your very kind feedback Tracy - much appreciated :)
Your videos are definitely *high quality,* original and well narrated.
That's very kind of you :)
Idk why I'm fascinated by old brothels. I lived in the French Quarter and you still feel those old vibes.
Not only do I love your stories, but I also love your illustrations and animations. Your voice is very soothing too.
Such wonderful feedback makes the time and effort well worthwhile.Bless you for that
Best regards
Oddie
I absolutely loved this episode! This is history that we need to hear about!
Much appreciated, thank you kindly!
Tubes of You don't want history.