Great... again! movie and music lover... I'd say for the t'shirt! yeah!. I think you'll have to start again once you finish, to add lots of other interesting movies, as people said here: 'Un chien andalou' should also be present!! Anyway, keep the good work, is very interesting.
@@alexbaba3000 I got 30/30 with a special mention 😍😂 Still remember it because the Professor gave me lots of compliments, I was very happy :) Thank you!!
@@Silviia23Sanders that's awesome! I just watched the Movie today for the first time and found this video afterwards. Then I saw your comment and just had to know how it went 😄
I'm glad the Kinok's philosophy didn't fly. Although the film itself is interesting, the complete rejection of narrative as bourgeois luxury is not only something not socialist (which is all about the narrative of revolution and change), but so exclusive as to be bourgeois itself. "Only our educated version of cinema is truly socialist" is exclusionary.
it didn't fly because the revolution, of which art was a part, was missed. narrative art has nothing to do with revolution and change. Soviet Realism, the aesthetic demands of a Stalinist state was completely reactionary compared to modernism that arranged against representation and narration. There's a good argument that all realism is regressive. Communism is not about adapting to the masses but about them overcoming themselves. A satisfaction and applause to how people are is essentially a fear of what they *could* be. Don't take art at face-value. That art which idealised the proletariat hoped they would never escape that identity; that bourgeois or avant-garde art which through form appeals to the world to come speaks to the proletarian liquidating itself: the real movement of communism
You spoke some truth, but they were wrong because the absolute truth doesnt exists, Objectivity is only a word in the dictionary that cant be achieved. You cant capture the reality as a own, because reality is what we perceive along our algorithms and mechanical attributes, and that is why pluralism is the truth.
Cinema was quite young at that and these kind of experiments were vital so that it could grow. That's why this movie has such an importance in cinematic history. The same experiment is the need of hour in today's cinema, as it has deteriorated
I don’t think this is a complete rejection, I think this is a concept piece. If it were a complete rejection it would still have gone somewhere outside of the meta commentary.
+Nick Woodward Hi Nick! I have not stopped! Someone quit unexpectedly at my real life job so I have been working double time. There is a new video in the works right now!
You don't have to thank anyone, we have to thank you for this amazing job you've been doing for us, Thank you so much.
the most timeless movie ever...i watched this movie with michael nyman's soundtrack and my feelings were beyond words
I just watched this film in class. Such a great watch.
Thanks a lot for making this videos. It's truly a pleasure to see them.
I had a feeling you'd explore either this or 'Un Chien Andalou'.
Great job. You definitely deserve those 2,000 subs and more!
Your videos are always a pleasure!
Good job brother. It helped me for my ppt presentation
There's a great 4k restoration with amazing music by Cinematic Orchestra
Wonderful work, thank you so much for sharing, making your work accessible, and making cinema more accessible at the same time
You did hell of a job, young man. Cheers!
Fabulous video!
I have the Cinematic Orchestra version on disk. Very interesting.
nice. i was hoping you would do this or an andalucian dog
It was amazing👍 thankyou
thanks for helping me write my paper
very well done! congrats!
Great... again! movie and music lover... I'd say for the t'shirt! yeah!. I think you'll have to start again once you finish, to add lots of other interesting movies, as people said here: 'Un chien andalou' should also be present!! Anyway, keep the good work, is very interesting.
This is a really good explanation! I hope it will help me get a good grade in my exam tomorrow 😊
Which grade did you get?
@@alexbaba3000 I got 30/30 with a special mention 😍😂 Still remember it because the Professor gave me lots of compliments, I was very happy :) Thank you!!
@@Silviia23Sanders that's awesome! I just watched the Movie today for the first time and found this video afterwards. Then I saw your comment and just had to know how it went 😄
What subject did you take an exam on?
I'm glad the Kinok's philosophy didn't fly. Although the film itself is interesting, the complete rejection of narrative as bourgeois luxury is not only something not socialist (which is all about the narrative of revolution and change), but so exclusive as to be bourgeois itself. "Only our educated version of cinema is truly socialist" is exclusionary.
it didn't fly because the revolution, of which art was a part, was missed. narrative art has nothing to do with revolution and change. Soviet Realism, the aesthetic demands of a Stalinist state was completely reactionary compared to modernism that arranged against representation and narration. There's a good argument that all realism is regressive. Communism is not about adapting to the masses but about them overcoming themselves. A satisfaction and applause to how people are is essentially a fear of what they *could* be. Don't take art at face-value. That art which idealised the proletariat hoped they would never escape that identity; that bourgeois or avant-garde art which through form appeals to the world to come speaks to the proletarian liquidating itself: the real movement of communism
You spoke some truth, but they were wrong because the absolute truth doesnt exists, Objectivity is only a word in the dictionary that cant be achieved. You cant capture the reality as a own, because reality is what we perceive along our algorithms and mechanical attributes, and that is why pluralism is the truth.
also funny no dislike to this point anyway ...XDDD
Cinema was quite young at that and these kind of experiments were vital so that it could grow. That's why this movie has such an importance in cinematic history. The same experiment is the need of hour in today's cinema, as it has deteriorated
I don’t think this is a complete rejection, I think this is a concept piece. If it were a complete rejection it would still have gone somewhere outside of the meta commentary.
Dd you stop making videos? I'd be heartbroken.
+Nick Woodward Hi Nick! I have not stopped! Someone quit unexpectedly at my real life job so I have been working double time. There is a new video in the works right now!
Just saw the new one, already excited for the next. Glad to have ya back!
well now he has :'(
Love your videos
Hi from México
Anyone from Valencia?
The director Dziga Vertov covers one day in the life of three UKRAINIAN cities: Kyiv, Kharkiv and Odesa.
just thought id let u know if u hadn't found out in 6 years, its pronounced -Ser-gay not Ser-jey ;) great video very informative thanks
0:23 not "russian city"! it was filmed in Ukraine!
they should be referred as "Soviet" at that time, but people on the West usually replaced Soviet with Russian.
... Without a story?
My favorite Sociology film
This full colorized movie: th-cam.com/video/UO_ofltIoeQ/w-d-xo.html