Malta is only your stepping stone to reach another success more than them. They are afraid of you that is why they eliminated you. You are not loser in the eyes of many viewer. We the Pilipino are very proud of you. Go lang ng go kabayan!
Honestly the winner of this show is no match to mamaclay that is what we called cooking show is not new for all the Filipino competitors in singing contest in other country
Auditioning in the UK singing talent search is not an option either. We don't want a repeat of the 4th impact for not getting what they truly deserve in the contest despite blowing the british' audience minds with their exceptional singing prowess.
Votes are just nothing, the prize is just lost after it is spent---it is the authenticity and honesty that counts in the long run. It doesn't matter how many of them blocked you on purpose, God is bigger than them all. He can close one door but can open more doors of opportunity for you Ms. Mayi. My apology if I tend to argue with those who kept on putting two of you down as my nature is what is black should be black and what is white should be white. I did not emphatize with you because you are my kababayan but because your giftedness is simply and obviously undeniable in every performance you showed on that stage. Whatever happened behind the scenes---God will still hold them accountable. Keep on shining through HIM and for HIM, He is giving you much greater break in your music career soon in His amazing ways❤9
The rules are followed from the beginning, they could not have allowed the non-Maltese applicant from the start. They've ruined someone's dream. Who is the chef of this contest?
Her and Sean was invited to join..nonetheless ang laki ng mali nila to eliminate her sa semi finals...klato tuloy ang cooking show nila.. kung ginawa lang sana nila na maging runner up si Mamaclay matabonan pa sana pagiging racist ng ibang Maltese 😂
Same thing that happened to 4th impact remember? They were the best among everyone but they got eliminated and placed 5th. Same issue because they weren’t british so why let them win. But the producers took them far because of the hype the show was getting all over the wold. Same as mamaclay. Xfactor Malta experienced the hype after people started watching because of Mamaclay and when it was time for finale they took her out because they dont want to see a non -maltese winner. Also, i remember rose fontances from xfactor israel, she won but she wasnt a citizen and after she won she had so much problem with the authority.
It's not surprising that Rose Mariel is eliminated simply because she's not born and raised in Malta simply because producers favor of Maltese a national who can represent X Factor Malta well.
It really đspends on how the locals view foreigners when it comes to talent search. It’s either they adore you or don’t like you. Just like the case of Janice Phương, a Filipina band singer who won Vietnam idol 2016 (if I’m not mistaken about the year) , but she did not sustain her popularity after she won, because she gained weight, and her invitations were getting less and less. She still work as a band singer, abd getting few invitations here and there.
filipino nga naman walang natatalo nadadaya lang. let's face it, in her last performance she struggled a lot so justified yung pagkakaeliminate sa kanya. im a filipino but im not a blind fanatic
I’m a Filipino but not gonna lie, her voice is not really marketable. Doesn’t matter if you have high range cos nowadays people are looking for something different. She’s talented but her live show performances were really underwhelming compared to her auditions. I was extremely disappointed watching them cos she was pitchy most of the time, and singing and screaming exaggerated notes which were not necessary. But anyways, just be proud of how far she’s gone.
Ginagamit lang nila talent ng Pinoy show para mag ingay sa social media dahil Philippines Ang madaming mahilig sa social media or manood online kapag sinali nila Pinoy sa competition lalago Ang views nila.
Just feel bad , that the some remaining contestants do not even have the right to be there. A lot of disgusting singers still in the competition, they just say good infront of the camera but deep in there heart they areRACISTS
oki lang yan, ganun din naman tayo pag dating dito sa mga contest sa pinas eh hanggat maaari purong pinoy gusto natin. Pag nalaman ntn na half half eh medyo tagilid satin tulad ni Jessica Reynoso. Pero tignan mo naman cya ngyon ang female member ng black eyed peas.
@ronron3749 kahit na si Bella Santiago (xfactor Romania) o di kaya'y Cyrus Villanueva (XFactor Australia) ang sumali dito, ganon din yong mangyayari sa kanila kasi locally contextualized yong XFactor show dito sa Malta.
@@neilnorcio291 i am not referring to whatever she said. It's about those people who can't just accept she was eliminated without saying this and that 🙄
no bitterness, it's Malta's decision. remember it is their right to remain native contestants. keep auditioning... UK, Romania, and US x factors are waiting for you.
From the start they should complained and discuss about this kind of rules,well life is always unfair….they only used her for the views and to invite people to make their show be talk about…
its gotta be nationality thats why she got eliminated . No matter how good Mamaclay was but for them she was not . I know SHE WAS THE BEST SINGER compare to any other contestant .
Magaling nman sya kqso hindi bagy sa boses nya ung pinipili nya ,sana may natutunan sya jan mas madami pwd nyang pang audation.......sa totoo lng di ga sya nanalo sa tawag ng tanghalan eh khit weekly lng mens may kulang pa tlga sa knya pero magaling nanya may kulan lng tlga..
Diyan sa Pinas, expected yon kasi bumabaha ang mga talents dyan... Paki.watch nga muli ng kanyang performance at ikompara sa mga katunggali niya dito bago ka magkomento
All semi finalists were truly outstanding .I do not agree she was eliminated because she was not Maltese .Someone had to be eliminated .I personally agree with the results .Good luck for all who are in the finals .
@jogauci4876, Someone whose talent obviously surpassed all others on that stage is a bIG threat so she needs to be eliminated whether you agree or not. If Mamaclay, did not perform and outshone all the rest like what happened to Sean due to his bronchitis which affected his vocals, it would have been reasonable ground but she has had surpassed them all and got the standing ovation and claps from the crowd. Since, the show has made headlines on the newspapers, the management should simply and clearly specify that the show is only for local talents and not for foreign ones, this way, it would keep its credibility and transparency.
I think she did some mistakes in her rendition. There are some parts that she didn't hit the right notes like in sustaining the high note sort of like off key and her low notes are not that good in terms of control and her placements need arr not quite impressive. She really put herself to the limit that is why she struggle in the hiigher note that is needed in her version.
@@claireobeja8094I'm also Filipino and of course I want her to be in finals but on the technical side you know what I'm talking about.She is a great singer her rendition is not perfect coz she went way beyond expectation of trying to make it her own but her rendition is not that perfect for me. The Judges are very very critical when it comes to mistakes. It's like it is better to do simple song but wih great rendition rather that a powerful voice like pushing to hard but with some mistakes like off key notes in singing a song.
@@marlondenoyo4900 I viewed her and the rest performed on that stage and saw the diference. It is huge between her and the rest. I am a Filipino married to Maltese here and Mamaclay performed against the locals here and not against Filipino talents back home who could perform way way better than her and the island's singers here with all honesty.
@@claireobeja8094if you see it that way then I guess it's the judges fault and the people of malta who have the power to change the result. But everyone has their own opinion, Xfactor malta has their own criteria in doing that show and it is the judges decision to control the show of who they want to win or not.
@@marlondenoyo4900 the judges did not judge the sing off round when they used to do that at that round. Ruling was changed and so the Judgment was thrown to the public televoters who as expected would choose kinship and friendship here rather than allows an obvious foreign talent to get to the finals---that is it.
controversy aside, maybe it's also the song choice. "Bang Bang" is an overly-used overrated song that Pinoys frequently perform. compared to the songs the other four finalists sang in the show-down. maybe, JUST maybe and it might still not change the outcome, but if Rose had picked a different song more popular in Europe, or with Maltans
They should not allowed any nationality to join if it is like that. She is the best of all the contestant i must say.. She deserve to win.
Malta is only your stepping stone to reach another success more than them. They are afraid of you that is why they eliminated you. You are not loser in the eyes of many viewer. We the Pilipino are very proud of you. Go lang ng go kabayan!
Honestly the winner of this show is no match to mamaclay that is what we called cooking show is not new for all the Filipino competitors in singing contest in other country
You’re the winner for us Mamaclay. You have a pure heart and talent, bless you always!
So sad 😢 Mamaclay you’re the best. You’ll be alright
It was really shocking to note that she was out..
Malta is a small stage .you can audition to US or UK .
No it's not about the stage TALENT and deserving is a must
@@MarianoOpanda-hg3td echoserang palaka
Correct
Auditioning in the UK singing talent search is not an option either. We don't want a repeat of the 4th impact for not getting what they truly deserve in the contest despite blowing the british' audience minds with their exceptional singing prowess.
let the audience lift up you from downfall, hindi kawalan yang the voice malta. Walang akong kilalang taga malta na sikat na singer
Votes are just nothing, the prize is just lost after it is spent---it is the authenticity and honesty that counts in the long run. It doesn't matter how many of them blocked you on purpose, God is bigger than them all. He can close one door but can open more doors of opportunity for you Ms. Mayi. My apology if I tend to argue with those who kept on putting two of you down as my nature is what is black should be black and what is white should be white. I did not emphatize with you because you are my kababayan but because your giftedness is simply and obviously undeniable in every performance you showed on that stage. Whatever happened behind the scenes---God will still hold them accountable. Keep on shining through HIM and for HIM, He is giving you much greater break in your music career soon in His amazing ways❤9
if they allow you to go to the finals, their plans may be compromised. it looks like they already have someone to win in mind.
The rules are followed from the beginning, they could not have allowed the non-Maltese applicant from the start. They've ruined someone's dream. Who is the chef of this contest?
Her and Sean was invited to join..nonetheless ang laki ng mali nila to eliminate her sa semi finals...klato tuloy ang cooking show nila.. kung ginawa lang sana nila na maging runner up si Mamaclay matabonan pa sana pagiging racist ng ibang Maltese 😂
Wasn't this supposed to have been X-FACTOR MALTA?
@@sstivala2138 tell that to the Production team so that they will stop inviting non-Maltese Talent 😀
@@sstivala2138Someone should told Destiny that when she went to Factor UK.
@@thetruth9494 it was BGT not X factor
In every shows specially talent search. They always put a Filipino coz Filipino viewers are big and they always use that in there advantage.
THATS IT!!!
It's obvious, the show is X Factor Malta so they will choose their people
You're a threat to them. Your success is in your hands. Go, shine girl!
Same thing that happened to 4th impact remember? They were the best among everyone but they got eliminated and placed 5th. Same issue because they weren’t british so why let them win. But the producers took them far because of the hype the show was getting all over the wold. Same as mamaclay. Xfactor Malta experienced the hype after people started watching because of Mamaclay and when it was time for finale they took her out because they dont want to see a non
-maltese winner. Also, i remember rose fontances from xfactor israel, she won but she wasnt a citizen and after she won she had so much problem with the authority.
Even MP
It's not surprising that Rose Mariel is eliminated simply because she's not born and raised in Malta simply because producers favor of Maltese a national who can represent X Factor Malta well.
Wasn't her coach the show's producer too?
SO WHY NOT TAKE ALL FROM MALTA SO MANY SINGERS OVER THERE WHY THEY ACCEPT FROM OUTSIDE EVEN SO GOOD.....FOR VIEWSSS
It really đspends on how the locals view foreigners when it comes to talent search. It’s either they adore you or don’t like you. Just like the case of Janice Phương, a Filipina band singer who won Vietnam idol 2016 (if I’m not mistaken about the year) , but she did not sustain her popularity after she won, because she gained weight, and her invitations were getting less and less. She still work as a band singer, abd getting few invitations here and there.
She's a blessing from above!!
filipino nga naman walang natatalo nadadaya lang. let's face it, in her last performance she struggled a lot so justified yung pagkakaeliminate sa kanya. im a filipino but im not a blind fanatic
You are the best!
I’m a Filipino but not gonna lie, her voice is not really marketable. Doesn’t matter if you have high range cos nowadays people are looking for something different. She’s talented but her live show performances were really underwhelming compared to her auditions. I was extremely disappointed watching them cos she was pitchy most of the time, and singing and screaming exaggerated notes which were not necessary. But anyways, just be proud of how far she’s gone.
Ginagamit lang nila talent ng Pinoy show para mag ingay sa social media dahil Philippines Ang madaming mahilig sa social media or manood online kapag sinali nila Pinoy sa competition lalago Ang views nila.
Please come here in the US. You will definitely make it
The truth is Simon Cowell pressured them to eliminate her because she's from the Philippines.
They should not accept other nationality to join the contest if they want their own home grown talent to win the singing contest.
They made the wrong decision.Its their loss not yours...Another door will open for you..I was surprised they had this contest in Malta...
ur still the one
Go go go
God knows .....😊😊😊😊😊
Mamaclay .. deserve to win because.. audition to semi live show give 1000% performance
Just feel bad , that the some remaining contestants do not even have the right to be there. A lot of disgusting singers still in the competition, they just say good infront of the camera but deep in there heart they areRACISTS
Why all this people commenting didn't vote to her then?
They just dont want to give the prize yo a filipina, its a big insult for them being a residence of malta, pero kabayan you're the best
oki lang yan, ganun din naman tayo pag dating dito sa mga contest sa pinas eh hanggat maaari purong pinoy gusto natin. Pag nalaman ntn na half half eh medyo tagilid satin tulad ni Jessica Reynoso. Pero tignan mo naman cya ngyon ang female member ng black eyed peas.
Si Morisette Amon, Charice Pempengco at Daren Espanto nanalo ba? Purong pinoy din sila
@ronron3749 kahit na si Bella Santiago (xfactor Romania) o di kaya'y Cyrus Villanueva (XFactor Australia) ang sumali dito, ganon din yong mangyayari sa kanila kasi locally contextualized yong XFactor show dito sa Malta.
Acceptance is the key! Stop the bitterness.
Where’s the bitterness on her statement? 🤔
@@neilnorcio291 i am not referring to whatever she said. It's about those people who can't just accept she was eliminated without saying this and that 🙄
❤
Only mamaclay can hit a high notes ang she have a unique voice of all the contestant,,its very clear they let tha maltese win..
no bitterness, it's Malta's decision.
remember it is their right to remain native contestants.
keep auditioning... UK, Romania, and US x factors are waiting for you.
She is not bitter, most here are for popularity sake.
From the start they should complained and discuss about this kind of rules,well life is always unfair….they only used her for the views and to invite people to make their show be talk about…
S A D !
THAT'S OKAY, MAMACLAY YOU WILL GET ANOTHER CHANCE.
THE WINNER IS NOT ALWAYS THE BEST!
(LOOK AT JENNIFER HUDSON)
She was the best one
Good for you. Best singer there but politics again. God loves you.
Malta is not after talent i will not click nor see this compitition.
My volume bosses niya at pitch pero hindi control masyado
😢😢😢😢😢
its gotta be nationality thats why she got eliminated . No matter how good Mamaclay was but for them she was not . I know SHE WAS THE BEST SINGER compare to any other contestant .
Magaling nman sya kqso hindi bagy sa boses nya ung pinipili nya ,sana may natutunan sya jan mas madami pwd nyang pang audation.......sa totoo lng di ga sya nanalo sa tawag ng tanghalan eh khit weekly lng mens may kulang pa tlga sa knya pero magaling nanya may kulan lng tlga..
3 times siyang pumiyok daw diyan,wrong choice ang kinanta niya,sayang ang galing pa Naman niya,well congratulations parin SA knya...
Diyan sa Pinas, expected yon kasi bumabaha ang mga talents dyan... Paki.watch nga muli ng kanyang performance at ikompara sa mga katunggali niya dito bago ka magkomento
@@genelyndagaleacruz6371 tama po
she use for more views and subscribers
Such competition is a business. It could use someone else's views to generate income and make such show more controversial and known worldwide.
Well I must judges were deaf and blind..Such horrible talent competition...
shame on you MALTA X FACTOR.
All semi finalists were truly outstanding .I do not agree she was eliminated because she was not Maltese .Someone had to be eliminated .I personally agree with the results .Good luck for all who are in the finals .
@jogauci4876, Someone whose talent obviously surpassed all others on that stage is a bIG threat so she needs to be eliminated whether you agree or not. If Mamaclay, did not perform and outshone all the rest like what happened to Sean due to his bronchitis which affected his vocals, it would have been reasonable ground but she has had surpassed them all and got the standing ovation and claps from the crowd. Since, the show has made headlines on the newspapers, the management should simply and clearly specify that the show is only for local talents and not for foreign ones, this way, it would keep its credibility and transparency.
I think she did some mistakes in her rendition. There are some parts that she didn't hit the right notes like in sustaining the high note sort of like off key and her low notes are not that good in terms of control and her placements need arr not quite impressive. She really put herself to the limit that is why she struggle in the hiigher note that is needed in her version.
The rest did theirs in mediocrity while Mamaclay outshone the rest of them on stage---you were just blind to see it and too bitter to admit it.
@@claireobeja8094I'm also Filipino and of course I want her to be in finals but on the technical side you know what I'm talking about.She is a great singer her rendition is not perfect coz she went way beyond expectation of trying to make it her own but her rendition is not that perfect for me. The Judges are very very critical when it comes to mistakes. It's like it is better to do simple song but wih great rendition rather that a powerful voice like pushing to hard but with some mistakes like off key notes in singing a song.
@@marlondenoyo4900 I viewed her and the rest performed on that stage and saw the diference. It is huge between her and the rest. I am a Filipino married to Maltese here and Mamaclay performed against the locals here and not against Filipino talents back home who could perform way way better than her and the island's singers here with all honesty.
@@claireobeja8094if you see it that way then I guess it's the judges fault and the people of malta who have the power to change the result. But everyone has their own opinion, Xfactor malta has their own criteria in doing that show and it is the judges decision to control the show of who they want to win or not.
@@marlondenoyo4900 the judges did not judge the sing off round when they used to do that at that round. Ruling was changed and so the Judgment was thrown to the public televoters who as expected would choose kinship and friendship here rather than allows an obvious foreign talent to get to the finals---that is it.
worst show ever
You try X factor 🇺🇸
controversy aside, maybe it's also the song choice. "Bang Bang" is an overly-used overrated song that Pinoys frequently perform. compared to the songs the other four finalists sang in the show-down. maybe, JUST maybe and it might still not change the outcome, but if Rose had picked a different song more popular in Europe, or with Maltans
Maltas Group not allowed to win from other countries..❤️❤️❤️❤️
They just used other nationality for views and likes for their page. Anyways congrats mamaclay.
Rechard aquillina cant even hit a high notes,,its crazyy he win the xfactor malta..they robbed mamaclay xfactor malta
Her performance is not enough in this round
Fake show
Good for you! Rules are rules.
TRY MO SA AUSTRALIA OR ROMANIA...
Di naman siya na kanta puro sigae ginagawa niya
i am happy she is out BECAUSE SHE DESERVES IT...but i am not happy with the others as well.... unTALENTED TALENTS
Judges sucks
Para nmn kc syang baboy n kinakatay pag highnotes na..
You called the Biased decisions or racial discrimination against foreigners try her luck to win but malta is racists..