as an asian who couldn’t understand english that much, your way of explaining and present heidegger’s the question concerning technology really helps me alot ! thank you for making this!
I came here to begin to prep out for a college policy debate tournament in which I am participating. I appreciate the introduction to Heideggers's essay. Thank you so much!
This is the 2nd time I used your video for my class. This really helped my students in understanding Heidegger's thoughts on technology. Thank you for making it understandable and fun to watch!
@@jannabutay2868 can you give an example of a technology that are not merely instrumental but that have a strong influence on how people see the world.
Hari Thank for this modern style practical presentation of Heidegger, making the profound philosophers analysis done many years ago, very relevant today. Important with such presentation because it makes clear that it is not enough to see and feel the problematic effects of technology - there is a need to deeper, namely, to solve this problem we have to change our conception of truth, where Being is just seen as Bestand - standing resource. People consume nature and each other as well. I did an exam on Heidegger 40 years ago and it is inspiring to see that people of today discover and appreciate this very profound thinker. I am sure Heidegger also is pleased, as another of his worries was the end of deep thinking/philosophy in European culture, where in hybris one thinks science and technology has made philosophy irrelevant and therefore reduced to mere history of ideas. Interestingly enough Heidegger brings up the same fundamental questions that is asked in Vedanta philosophy of India.
Great presentation, gets right to the heart of what he was saying, without getting weighed down by the context of what others ma have been saying. Technology is our life now, but we need to be as aware as ever how we live that life.
Technology is just one way of poesis - revealing truth. But it has basically become the only one, leading to robot life, impersonalism and aleniation, leaving less and less space for beauty, love and the sweet taste of personal interaction. Love becomes reduced to sex exploitation. That is also an effect of the technological poesis.
@@shanashana8027 Yes, when technology or any material activity is connected to a higher purpose, it is not just instrumental to get a material result but supports the higher purpose and has therefore a broader impact on the world. The perspective of modern science and technology is not objective, although they claim - it is just one perspective, that of seeing the world as a mere resource for control and exploitation. Heidegger pointed out the need of a holistic perspective, and that is also the perspective of ancient Vedas of India.
Greater than the danger of the atom bomb for humanity today is the essence of technology. The essential feature of technology is to reveal the real in the mode of ordering as `always-for-use': to make anything and everything available at the push of a button. I see in the essence of technology that man is under a power that challenges him and opposite which he is no longer free. Health, youth and freedom are the best blessings of life.
In the digital age it could be argued that people have become the "standing-reserve" of information. Bernard Stiegler talks of Algorithmic Governmentality which is the governance of desires and expectations, this is primarily accomplished through mining of individuals online data. So to that extent, humans have become a "standing-reserve" of information for the digital economy.
Very good video. Heidegger explained like this more often would make for easy scholarship. I believe I disagree with quite a swathe of Heidegger. We're not precisely special as humans; I wouldn't be surprised at all if nature saw itself as standing reserve. And assuming this, for technology not to challenge (as though the challenging and bringing-forth are somehow discretely distinct; not even fuzzily distinct) would somehow make technology unnatural, which isn't at all the case, seeing as it is from our nature, and it's own nature viz. Aristotle's four causes. There's a few modicums in Heidegger though that seem useful. For example, economics could be defined as the set of processes which predicate over the standing frame. Though, I would personally invert the definition to have the standing frame be defined. But it does allow us to distinguish the way we individually see things poetically to the way "man" sees things "enframing" (so we can actually limit his thesis to make it more plausible).
Can you give me an art piece besides Chalice depicting science and technology and identify the 4 causes(causality) thankss its for our presentation I hope you can help us😊😊😊
Yawn! I say use it up and throw it away. We will always find a way out and a way to have more. Humanity is invincible. The more we create overwhelming challenges the more we overcome obstacles that limit our owning this universe. Carry on... and don't worry so much.
Thank God for Standing Reserve! Enframing is the unconcealment of Dasien!! Proof that Heidegger's criticism of the challenge of the standing reserve as a type of Romanticism. Bring on the Free Relationship to technology! Let's use technology to help us with technology. Hey Siri!
We store energy??? What makes you think this in unnatural? Was he form other universe, because storing energy is something all living creatures do. How do you think a water eagle see the river? As source of food or as some romantic picture? Why I see big hypocrisy and double standards.
That windmill logic, if we can call it logic, is something so incredibly silly, it is on the lower level than middle age science. lol But thx for the video anyway. Ayn Rand was right. Industrial primitivism is one of the biggest things stopping people form enjoying happines and postmodern philosophy is making people stupid.
There is no need to be negative. Clearly, you don't understand Heidegger's philosophy. By the way, he's not a postmodern philosopher, he's contemporary and an existentialist. Thanks for trying, but you're wrong, and not just about this comment, but on all your comments on this video.
Greater than the danger of the atom bomb for humanity today is the essence of technology. The essential feature of technology is to reveal the real in the mode of ordering as `always-for-use': to make anything and everything available at the push of a button. I see in the essence of technology that man is under a power that challenges him and opposite which he is no longer free. Health, youth and freedom are the best blessings of life.
as an asian who couldn’t understand english that much, your way of explaining and present heidegger’s the question concerning technology really helps me alot ! thank you for making this!
Heidegger is like a freaking riddle.
Thanks so much!
I came here to begin to prep out for a college policy debate tournament in which I am participating. I appreciate the introduction to Heideggers's essay. Thank you so much!
Robbie Nikont I hope this worked out for you! :)
I’ve read bits and pieces of Heidegger’s take on humans and technology but you’ve made it simpler to understand. Thank you!
Wonderful! and how timely - I'm happy to discover Heidegger from many counselors! Thanks.
Best explanation I have seen so far. Thank you!
I love it, thank you for your creativity that helps me understand such hard readings from him. All the best!
This is the best video I have seen so far on Heidegger, apart from the ones on Then&Now channel. Where can I get more of these from?
ur intro hit me hard like being smack by a sledgehammer
This was so incredibly helpful, THANK YOU!
Excellent video! Congratulations of a heideggerian from Brazil!
A wonderfully clear and engaging explanation of Heidegger's question - well done, and thank you.
This was wonderfully made, thank you so much!
This is the 2nd time I used your video for my class. This really helped my students in understanding Heidegger's thoughts on technology. Thank you for making it understandable and fun to watch!
can you give an example of a technology that are not merely instrumental
but that have a strong influence on how people see the world.
Very well done! Thank you.
I seldom comment on YT videos, but I appreciated this a lot. Helped my brain. Thanks
The best explanation that I found. Thank you.
I am making a reflection paper about this topic and all I can say is sir Martin is really confusing lol
hahaha totally agree!
Same hahaha
@@jannabutay2868 can you give an example of a technology that are not merely instrumental
but that have a strong influence on how people see the world.
Thank you so much!!! i love this video and the way you explain this hard aticle
Hari
Thank for this modern style practical presentation of Heidegger, making the profound philosophers analysis done many years ago, very relevant today. Important with such presentation because it makes clear that it is not enough to see and feel the problematic effects of technology - there is a need to deeper, namely, to solve this problem we have to change our conception of truth, where Being is just seen as Bestand - standing resource. People consume nature and each other as well.
I did an exam on Heidegger 40 years ago and it is inspiring to see that people of today discover and appreciate this very profound thinker. I am sure Heidegger also is pleased, as another of his worries was the end of deep thinking/philosophy in European culture, where in hybris one thinks science and technology has made philosophy irrelevant and therefore reduced to mere history of ideas.
Interestingly enough Heidegger brings up the same fundamental questions that is asked in Vedanta philosophy of India.
Great presentation, gets right to the heart of what he was saying, without getting weighed down by the context of what others ma have been saying. Technology is our life now, but we need to be as aware as ever how we live that life.
Thank you for this!
It was so gooood! Excellent video!
Thank you for being amazing haha this was so helpful!
You are incredibly smart!!! Thank you!!!
Amazing and very Interesting video, i have ever seen in relation to philosophy, especially when it comes to Heidegger.
You are an angel for real.. Tmr is my exam and I have some hopes now... Thankyou so much!!!!
Technology is just one way of poesis - revealing truth. But it has basically become the only one, leading to robot life, impersonalism and aleniation, leaving less and less space for beauty, love and the sweet taste of personal interaction. Love becomes reduced to sex exploitation. That is also an effect of the technological poesis.
can you give an example of a technology that are not merely instrumental
but that have a strong influence on how people see the world.
@@shanashana8027 Yes, when technology or any material activity is connected to a higher purpose, it is not just instrumental to get a material result but supports the higher purpose and has therefore a broader impact on the world. The perspective of modern science and technology is not objective, although they claim - it is just one perspective, that of seeing the world as a mere resource for control and exploitation.
Heidegger pointed out the need of a holistic perspective, and that is also the perspective of ancient Vedas of India.
Thanks for your fabulous presentation
Marie Cambe, couldn't help but see elements of McLuhan in this.
THANK YOU!!!!!
Very nice explanation of the text. Thank you
Thank you ❤️
That's very understandable and that time quite accurate to Haidegger's theory... Thanks for upload!
Any example of technologies not merely instrumental ( or means ti an en), but that have a strong influence on how people see the world?
Spectacular presentation.
Very helpful indeed
Heidegger's pov of technology was kinda deep to understand, however, thanks for this vid. Deserves a BIG THUMBS UP!
Thanks
thanks for this
Great video 👍
I cannot thank you enough for this, this is so good, just made everything so much more approachable I'm crying 😭😭😭
Greater than the danger of the atom bomb for humanity today is the essence of technology.
The essential feature of technology is
to reveal the real
in the mode of ordering
as `always-for-use':
to make anything and everything available
at the push of a button.
I see in the essence of technology
that man is under a power
that challenges him
and opposite which
he is no longer free.
Health, youth and freedom
are the best blessings of life.
Please add bookmark to that video dividing by parts
are all the quotes from Heidegger essay ??
nice explanation thanks
Bring back your channel!
I made my whole day a lot easier for making reflection paper :) Thanks !
How can we understand information as a "standing-reserve?" Can information be viewed as a resource in the same way that we view coal or petroleum?
In the digital age it could be argued that people have become the "standing-reserve" of information. Bernard Stiegler talks of Algorithmic Governmentality which is the governance of desires and expectations, this is primarily accomplished through mining of individuals online data. So to that extent, humans have become a "standing-reserve" of information for the digital economy.
What three concepts remain unclear or difficult for you to understand? #STS
Please answer this charss
I am greatful I didn't put my earphones. That intro extremely shocked me
and i am wearing my headphones
Savage 😂🤣
great video hope see my classmates here
Very good video. Heidegger explained like this more often would make for easy scholarship. I believe I disagree with quite a swathe of Heidegger. We're not precisely special as humans; I wouldn't be surprised at all if nature saw itself as standing reserve. And assuming this, for technology not to challenge (as though the challenging and bringing-forth are somehow discretely distinct; not even fuzzily distinct) would somehow make technology unnatural, which isn't at all the case, seeing as it is from our nature, and it's own nature viz. Aristotle's four causes. There's a few modicums in Heidegger though that seem useful. For example, economics could be defined as the set of processes which predicate over the standing frame. Though, I would personally invert the definition to have the standing frame be defined. But it does allow us to distinguish the way we individually see things poetically to the way "man" sees things "enframing" (so we can actually limit his thesis to make it more plausible).
A good example of how technology can reduce simplicity
Huge help c:
7 years ago:
Makes two videos total.
Stays at 520 subscribers.
Gets 132k views.
Refuses to elaborate.
Leaves.
*Can You Feel My Heart begins playing*
لو تترجم هذه المحاضرة القيمه شكرا لكم
it was really helpful
Can you give me an art piece besides Chalice depicting science and technology and identify the 4 causes(causality) thankss its for our presentation I hope you can help us😊😊😊
👍👍
i miss watching wall.e
Sa sobrang complicated ng buhay ni Heidegger pati ako dinadamay
Great presentation.
Why did you stop doing this videos?
I'm pretty sure they were her personal presentations that she just happened to put on TH-cam.
Watching for the exam tomorrow. So tired of reading 30-page essay 😑
I see a carolinian😂
🤧 wako kasabot pucha🤧😢
7:44
You make the best videos omg please be my best friend.
e0w po code 3019 wazzap mga paa
Si mam lang malakas
Always selling Hollywood, your dream, but not mine.
ouch my ear
Hi Jaynard
naiiyak ako, naka limang nood na ako pero di ko parin maintindihan huhuhuhhu. anyway, tenks parin beh sa pag effort na mag explain :>
sir kung makikita mo po ito, jk lang hehe may reaction na po akoo
welcome daw be
ate pakopya AHAHHAHAHHAHA
Bs ENTREP 2 b mag ingay....shout out edzel
Yawn!
I say use it up and throw it away. We will always find a way out and a way to have more. Humanity is invincible. The more we create overwhelming challenges the more we overcome obstacles that limit our owning this universe. Carry on... and don't worry so much.
PCU STUDENTS LANG SAKALAM
do you want to know more about philosophy come and take a look at my database
ayan,, STS pa HAHAHAHAHHA
NIce, but it should not go in high gear...
LNU normalista SHARAWTS!
the sound effects r annoying af tho
Thank God for Standing Reserve! Enframing is the unconcealment of Dasien!! Proof that Heidegger's criticism of the challenge of the standing reserve as a type of Romanticism. Bring on the Free Relationship to technology! Let's use technology to help us with technology. Hey Siri!
The sound effects hurt my ear.
@0:43 ear rape
have some respect, he's President now, it should be "President Trump's toupee"
Lmao
Cross-reference Kaczynski's take on technology if you really want your mind blown... "Industrial Society and its Future"
Nice video and lisp tho sry
I can't understand the things that you are saying when you are speaking too fast! and i also hate those other sounds that you are adding!
We store energy??? What makes you think this in unnatural? Was he form other universe, because storing energy is something all living creatures do. How do you think a water eagle see the river? As source of food or as some romantic picture? Why I see big hypocrisy and double standards.
That windmill logic, if we can call it logic, is something so incredibly silly, it is on the lower level than middle age science. lol But thx for the video anyway. Ayn Rand was right. Industrial primitivism is one of the biggest things stopping people form enjoying happines and postmodern philosophy is making people stupid.
There is no need to be negative. Clearly, you don't understand Heidegger's philosophy. By the way, he's not a postmodern philosopher, he's contemporary and an existentialist. Thanks for trying, but you're wrong, and not just about this comment, but on all your comments on this video.
Thanks for showing why Heidegger has no use in philosophy. He offers no clarity to concepts.
Heidegger can’t be dumbed down, honey. Try again.
Wow. What an annoying accent! Didn't make it past the first minute.
Greater than the danger of the atom bomb for humanity today is the essence of technology.
The essential feature of technology is
to reveal the real
in the mode of ordering
as `always-for-use':
to make anything and everything available
at the push of a button.
I see in the essence of technology
that man is under a power
that challenges him
and opposite which
he is no longer free.
Health, youth and freedom
are the best blessings of life.