ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2022
- The Bhuttos are amongst a few hundred feudal families, mostly large landowners, that have dominated politics and business in Pakistan since its creation in 1947. In the eyes of the west, Pakistan’s Benazir Bhutto was a beacon of democracy and a staunch foe of Muslim extremism, but at home, the slain opposition leader was a controversial figure, mired in allegations of corruption and accused of acquiring wealth, worth over 1.5 billion dollars.
Help keep VICE News’ fearless reporting free for millions by making a one time or ongoing contribution here. - vice.com/contribute
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE-News
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Tumblr: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
#VICENews #News
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 62 | คู่เอก "มงคลแก้ว vs อีที"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q7QuSUtUN94/mqdefault.jpg)
My grandmother remembered when she came into power twice. She told me that she did nothing for women. Instead she made corruption mainstream in Pakistan. Her only achievement according to my grandmother was bring Cable/Satellite TV.
💯
The main problem in asia is worship of personalities hailing from big families until this changes and we have leaders from grass root nothing can change.
Don't make it whole Asia's problem. There may be few instances but there are countries like india, Singapore that dont follow this.
China doesn’t have this big family problem, current India too doesn’t have this problem. So it’s not a asia problem but a Pakistan problem. Former pm Imran Khan doesn’t belong to a big family so why did you kick him out
Thats changing now. Look at how much support IK has. Next election is easily his unless they manage to jail him or remove him by other means
As usual a Pakistani thinks whole world is as illiterate as they are :). Pakistan is worse than Sri lanka. They are selling there daughters to China to make money but news is being suppressed.
@@palboy3565 even india does not have this problem now..
This isn't even 'casual' corruption. This is 'making my great, great, great, great, great, great, great, grandchildren' billionaires level corruption.
Some people really have no shame.
What's so jarring is that the first time I heard about Mrs Bhutto was through a BBC podcast on 'great figures' in history and they were so glowing and almost sickly. But I bought into it hard *sigh* 😔
She did what they all do at least she added some positive reform ideas to mainstream politics as she did it... I'm not saying it's ok just that it seems to be the norm in these places and honestly in the west to a lesser degree but they are no less selfish and doing wealth gaining from their political career
Same.
Peasants are born to provide for their betters. It is the greatest honor.
This country is a mess
Story could be told without the weird, pandering slow motion shots of the reporter walking up stairs...
Reporters who still realise that it's actually about the story and not them is a very rare breed.
Especially on VICE
Something for the month
Go film your own video
Triggered
It was great of VICE to get Atom Araullo aboard the team. I may have some bias for famous Filipino figures in journalism, I just love seeing Filipino representation in VICE.
So basically you want it to be gayer....great😂
This is why I love Vice--the willingness to tell the story of mass corruption when every other news outlet is busy telling the same narrative.
Correction:
@0:55 - Shah Nawaz Bhutto was not Prime Minister of Sindh (there was no PM on Sindh). He was however the Dewan of Junagadh for a very short time.
How do you knownthis info
@@a2u650 i learnt in history of class 8th India.
@@elenagomez4508 why tf you learning about Pakistan in Indian history lesson
@@Haris-qo1hx Pakistan was part of India before its formation
@@omkarc28 and so was mars according to you “people” lmao
Her son came back to steal more
Whilst the majority lived in filth and misery...these guys were playing polo
...
What sort of humans are these..
I hate corruption, that country could be great but too much scum exists in the govt
Me too! Especially in our country! Why isn’t Vice focused on the mounting corp and political corruption in the US?
I'm Pakistani and this video is really well presented. I'd like to point out that unfortunately, we as a nation have failed and are 'corrupt' individually and while its easy to blame the government and leadership, we repudiate reforms and objective policies that shape each one of us.
Illiteracy and paucity of quality education is still the biggest issue we face today and it'd now require at least decades of work by honest and loyal politicians to make us stand on our feet again!
May Allah guide us all! Amen.
Glad to see someone from Pakistan who has a hold on reality, most I came across blame everything on India, hope things change and everyone in Pakistan thinks like you brother
@@anup7604 f***ING pakistan won't develop and clear its own mess till eternity 😂😂😂😂
@@anup7604 this is the most f***ed country in the world,it is bound to be doomed forever 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@anup7604 if Pakistan was a colony of the United States,then things would have been much better
@@anup7604 when USA changed Japan after ww2 by colonising it,same could be done for Pakistan,if people of Pakistan propagate and strive to their utmost for democracy,opting for foreigners who are much better than the local cruel, corrupt dictators and politicians .
Try the Rajapaksha clan of Sri Lanka for the next “big steal” episode
You are underestimated our corrupt leaders 😛. They are more corrupt than your's.😝😝😝
Her party is fully 200% corrupted now her son is exterior minister
Note to the editor: We need more footage of the narrator walking and still shots of statues, please.
Thank you for these article pieces
What about the role of the army in all this? While corruption exists in the civil government - I wonder what the relationship is like between the government and army.
So sad . Pakistan needs someone to empower women without resorting to corruption for once..
Rn they'd be lucky if they avoid total economic collapse.
@@sympathiser_of_Germans_in_40s word
we have lot of women empowerment but gender does'nt matter , we just wan good non corrupt prime minister, but have only 3 parties to vote
Since yesterday was the anniversary of the nepali royal massacre,I think a video looking at it and the mystery surrounding it would be great and revitalize questions surrounding it.
Benazir was a very sick woman. Not the saint that most people make her out to be.
I think her legacy and story would make a fascinating musical: Benazir!
Don't cry for me, Pakistan!
My family was close friends with hers before we cut ties due to political differences (over Karachi). We've lived in Dubai for over 40 years and visited them at least twice in the 90s. I can confidently say that $1.5 billion is a nearly negligible fraction of what they actually plundered from Pakistan. At first, I didn't think she deserved to die the way she did, but after seeing the deprived state of interior Sindh on a trip there a few years ago, I changed my mind.
If this comment of yours is true I thank you for your info. Do you still visit Pakistan time to time?
Pakistani expat in Dubai living comfortably? Your family must have been involved in some level of corruption to be able to achieve that.
A pakistaní politican being corrupt?!?!?!??!
Next thing you know vice will have a new story about the sun rising
A female politician before America had one. Remind me again what America is doing about school shootings?
Only $1.5 billion? By Pakistani standards, that's not much. The Bhuttos were too lazy to steal even more.
There's a great law and order criminal intent episode on these real life public figures. I just saw it 2 days ago..
We are fed up with these bhutto and sharif names….
Now our last hope is IMRAN KHAN
I think I saw this doc. a month ago.
Is it de ja vu?
The real joke here is "Democratcially Elected"
There can be no true democracy in a theocracy, religion simply wouldn't allow it and is too arrogant and fascistic by nature to allow the people to choose their own representatives. It's Islam that does for Pakistan.
The vice is one of the best news channels out there which gives an unbiased opinion.
Wasn't this posted not too long ago. I remember watching this and seeing him walk around this garden
Yep on vice asia
@@_rtx_ thanks! I thought i was crazy when I couldn't find the upload lol
@@kbar11 where
Every country has an army but pakistan army has a country
Has this been re uploaded?
yea i definitely saw it in the past but watched it again cos it didn't have the viewed bar on it
#SMBB defined empowerment as right to be independent;to educated;to have choices in life.
Pakistan needs a new constitution.
Hmmm...
Pakistan is corrupt to the bone,and so poverished
How’s that possible when the army is breathing down our necks
She was assasinated on the day of my flight. I still cant believe i got to the airport with all the tire burnings going on
Great journalism
i am disappointed in this video, it lacks the understanding about the politics of pakistan and what role army plays in it. he is saying her govt has dismissed but saying always for corruption..poor and shoddy journalism
Her government was dismissed by the President not the Army Chief.
Regardless of why her government was dismissed, she was a corrupt politician
this is why imran khan is a legend hes been telling us for 20 years
Pakistan beat the united states to an important civil rights point. WHAT??? How did they become more open minded than us.
They have grape pilot and children who would sacrifice their life for Pakistan so ofcourse they can beat USA.
USA terrorists
Believe or not that's what they've believed🌚🌝
In terrorism**.
They forget to add that word.
They helped and provided shelter to Taliban throughout the 20 years America was there, they played double games while taking billions from america, pakistan is the one who really beat America more than the Taliban did
Audio engineer, give me a bit more low end on the narrators voice. He sounds unnaturally thin.
What people call corruption here is literally legal in almost everywhere in the world, except for the money laundering thing. And even that is done by far more people per country abroad.
We have made a stupid problem an existential problem.
Her husband had her done to get the party and seat ...... Everyone knows that.
After Bhutto a the nation converted into banana nation😂
Why suddenly international media is interested in benazir bhutto?
Is this a repost ? Feel like I’ve seen this video already …
8:42 - Pakistan has never been a middle-income country. The only way it can become one is to massively decrease its birthrate. All countries that have very high birthrates are very poor. A very high birthrate ensures that a country will be & remain very poor.
Agree not just not Pakistan but Nigeria as well
It’s the opposite. Lower birth rates follow development.
@@TooSmalley Source.
Uh i think it rather comes up to how well they can educate the kids guys
@@ALotOfCancer it's a very well known fact.
Since when did Atom Araullo joined vice news!!!??? That’s dope!!!!
Oh God a corrupt politician, same old thing greed, greed n more greed when ur peeps r poor as hell 😳
So basically like every other Pakistani PM, except that Benazir was a woman? Cuz let's be quite frank, these corruption charges and what not have been on every single PM I can remember.
How come the Pakistani Army holds so much power, but has never once faced any corruption charges or abuse of power or many other things?
Hahaha a very good question! I hope people can answer your question in the comments!
It's since the independence army (the establishment) they select who becomes PM
@@ajmalik5693 Indeed, But not to forget people like ayub who did many good things for our country...!
@@ajmalik5693 and also that first time it was civilians who called on army to control anti qaddiani protests and handed the govt...
@@ajmalik5693 imran khan wasn't a selected PM , he was the only pm who came into power on the sheer amount of votes he got. No high ranking official wanted him cause he is uncorruptable and uncontrollable, and that is why they allowed this current imported goverment to be installed in PK
pakistani american and just visited iran for vacation....no women stared or bothered, no kids in uk us whose dad is in govt. clean
Sometimes I feel like Pakistan shold never have been made...my grandfather refused rishwat and yet the haramkhor got to the top anyways
I am glad to hear that this country did have a female leader... at one point... so sad for the controversy surrounding her life.
They are also one the first countries out three in the world to recognize third gender on their passport. Land of contrasts for sure.
@@aidasa3791 It is because of the high number of transvestites/transgenders.
@@haadikhan9729 many are probably just gay but since homosexuality is less accepted than transgenderism….
She was also the oldest child of a previous prime minister of a country where nepostism is very widespread. If she had a different last name, zero chance that she would have been elected.
Controversies???!!! Everyone in pakistan knows her party PPP was corrupt and probably she was too...
Be it Gandhi in India or Bhuttos in Pak ...or any other families controlling countries ....all are same
My dad had a picure with her, never understood the assasination till many years later.
Yeah she was corrupt her self too dats why they got rid of her
Yeah she was corrupt her self too dats why they got rid of her
Glad to see Atom Araullo in Vice News 😊
so, she's almost like the Pakistani version of margaret thatcher... it all makes sense lmao
What about 100 trillion dollars went missing before 9/11 o.O
this dude loves the camera
I really like this journalist
00:58 a legacy built on these men backs.
Is this what inspired that episode of Law and order: criminal intent ...
Thank you vice!!!!!!! I am a pakistani and i dunno y we are soooo brainwashed to always think she was some super great politician. Just because she unfortunately was assassinated in a terror attack, it doesn't mean everything else was fine. .
Her son is now FM
8:52 except IMRAN KHAN! He is the most loyal, most honest person, politician, leader! In the world and in the time to come.
The biggest issue in Pakistan is there is no separation of religion and country. Old school mentalities and money hungry corruption who do less for country but more for there own benefits
We can thank her father for that. Zia Ul Haq gets all the hate but really it was her father who started Islamatizaion of Pakistan. Her father wanted to make Pakistan into a Socialist republic but he needed the Mullahs to get his reforms through. Zia Up Haq who was unpopular at the time, decided to continue Bhutto work without Socialism.
omg not you memorizing a whole Wikipedia article
It's because she's a woman and in both countries🇮🇳 India and Pakistan🇵🇰 the law , police , society , Media always focuses and will focus on The Men indulged in crimes, corruption, murders and all that but when women take the charge whether it's Benazir , Mariyam Nawaz or any other powerful female . Every watchful eye suddenly turns into a blind eye as if it doesn't understand.
The thing you'll hear from everyone is "hamare ghar me bhi maye behne hai"
"Khatoon hai mai baat nai karunga" and so the list goes on
It's our men who need protection from the instruments of state which are always used against the Male figure but not the women .
Look at how well Indra Gandhi has been white washed.
Please do one for Nehru Dynasty that's still in power
Didn't know modi was a member of the Nehru dynasty
Modi is part of the Nehru dynasty? I thought BJP supporters defame nehru?
They are still powerful but not in power. There is a difference between those two things.
😂😂😂 Soon nehru dynasty will be in museums fking traitors
Nice video. But do you lift?
Didn't expect atom araullo here 😅
Sad the hardworking poor r paying for this …God Bless the people.
Her father was a legend
WAKE UP
So she was really a career politician
How are they re-elected again and again?
These leaders try and stop literacy through out the country. If society became literate, it would be the end of them.
I'm from Pakistan it's almost like 70s newyork.. but even worse there are garbage and trash everywhere
There’s garbage and trash everywhere in New York. All that you see on TV is fake about America akhi/ukhti. I’m an american muslim and not only is there garbage and trash everywhere in New York, but rodents and poor people peeing and pooping on the street and gang members shooting people. Also people who want to hurt you for being Muslim…. No where is better for a muslim than a muslim country. I wish my parents stayed in their homeland
Shame on them and on thier son, who is dying to come back in politics to loot more like his parents.
atom araullo on vice 👏
Y do u show this guy walking
Zulfi was not the first democratically elected leader. Sheikh Mujib was. Zulfi couldn’t take that, which led the creation of independent Bangladesh. 3M+ bengalis died because of the Bhuttos
Philippines is waving
What about sheikh hasina?
She came later, and she's a de facto dictator who jails her opposition.
@SenorSol what do you expect the bangaldeshi army assassinated her entire family completely wiped them out.
OLD VIDEO
Good post
In Pakistan, blasphemy is considered to be one of the worst crimes.
I'm from Pakistan, yes that's true. But I don't get this law. Like where does the Quran call for the death for blasphemy? 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@theycallmeflipper4515 they found it somewhere to justify, maybe twisted words
@@advaitk1908 what does BLA have to do with Islam? That's more of a Marxist movement than anything...
@@officialballisticfox8111 how about TTP?
@@advaitk1908 you're clearly an Indian who watches WION... 😅
She was corrupt.
Go Atom! Rise Philippines!!!
but that assassinated woman is too pitty! Killing with out due process is horrible
Next episode on "Gandy dynasty of India" and "Rajapakshe dynasty of Sri Lanka "
Is that Atom Araullo?
😏 Oh.
Thought, this was a different kind of story, at last, for once.
😔
This is why I’m subbed, thank u
She was a great leader nonetheless, it's important to mention that corruption is an integral part to a leader's position of ruling a nation. Every world leader to a varying degree is corrupt
I am not sure what's the point here; do you actually believe that you can apply power with having financial means? Don't you think that Pakistan is living an inside war since decades now? How do you make things better if you have any cash to keep key people of power under your influence? You cannot ask for batter place on one side and cut all your means to get to your goals at the same time.
Allegedly tells it all
As we
Nice
Nasa vise news din pala si atom..
Wow! Atom Araullo!
appointed his own husband as minister, interesting. no wonder the corruption allegation emerged
I'm honestly asking if anyone knows the answer to this has Irfan Khan or his family ever been looked into with regards to their tax returns .....
Imran Khan even?
Damn are they also Indian my mama was Indian couldn't tell me any more than that
Sleeping with the enemy!👀..Corrupt af!