The real question is why the capacity was increased when there was no support of distribution. It was clear that old government made lot of Under table money through kickbacks by increasing capacities.
Thanks you very much Dr sb, I loved it when you said at 9:10 "2 takay bhe nahe bachaen gay" I think it's time when we stop saying takka as we are lowest
I live in the UK for 15 years, not even once faced load shedding. Because the national grid has the capacity to provide the whole country because of continuous investment by private and government entities
Thanks for explaining such a complicated economic issue in simple words. Lets hope your recommendation for renegotiating the agreements with the IPPs is taken consideration. Otherwise the masses are on the verge of revolt. On the other hand the IPPs should also realize the thininning of eonomic situation of the state. If the state remains economically stable then their investment would be of some worth In case of chaos and anarchy they wont be able to get a penny. Lets hope the sanity prevail on both sides and the poor consumers are given relief.
Also solar, but all that happens where true freedom exists. Here, the crown of gothas still rules. Have you ever seen old pictures of Quaid e azam meeting the Brits with their generals ? If yes see the uniforms and badges, same as what your generals strut around. They serve their masters who are masters of divide deprive and dominate. After all, a society with extra time and money might want to pay close attention to Quran. So....keep em busy.
Very informative. Dr. Taimur you mentioned the IPP policy of 1994 but did we not double down after 2013? This is important as 1- The old 1994 plants were mostly small around 150MW 2 - Oil and coal prices in the following 8 years were low enough 3 - my understanding is the capacity payment on those projects will be very small now 4- The projects from 2013 are much bigger and were signed when oil price was over $100/bbl vs below $30 in 1994. So it was a much bigger mistake.
An excellent point. There are many details of this sort that I had to skip to keep the length as short as possible. Had to cut down the slides I had to as few as possible to make it easy for people to understand.
@@Taimur_Laal I would request you to kindly make a long form version with comprehensive details, please also educate us how these decisions, specifically the ones made form 2013 onwards, might includes aspects of private gain for some. I understand that you have a particular style and refrain from taking names but you must eductate the populace of how many forms of corruption there are, this can be done without taking any names.
Sir also please add the total number and names of owners of these IPPs and the reasons behind these kinds of decisions. And is there no one to question these kinds of decisions?
very well explained. 1.I suggest, when you speak of a year, mention which govt. it was. 2. How Nanyang IPPs set up by politicians. Why must they be paid dollar prices? 3. How many local companies set up IPP. Why must they be paid dollar equivalents? 4. Increasing transmission line is a must. We should see this as defence of Pakistan. Defence budget should be utilized. 5. Quaid-e-Azam started Pakistan with 7 ministries. It is ridiculous a caretaker needs 22. Cabinets and others should work for Pakistan, not for grabbing privilege and perks.
Thank you for all the information. It was objective and to the point. One small request. If you could share the sources of your information via links in the description, it would be very helpful.
@TaimurRahman1975, can you please invite Shabbar Zaidi for an interview? I have seen him do TV and Internet interviews and I think, he wants to get a message across but I don't think people interviewing him didn't know the right questions and weren't able to do justice.
should do a further talk on the a) addition of various non-electric related taxes on electric bills including income tax? b) Impact of these high bills on the budget of poor/MC people & future implications of civil unrest, crime etc
Jab tak President, Prime Minister, Governors, Speaker National Assembly, Deputy Speaker, Senate Chairman, Deputy Chairman Senate, Ministers, Judges, Generals, WAPDA Officers, MNAs, MPAs, Senators, Commissioner, DC, AC, Principal Secretary, Secretaries, Chief Secretaries, Military Secretary, Election Commissioner, or bureaucrats, saray retired govt officers ke muft bijli, petrol or gas band nahi kiye jaatay tab tak protest kartay raho. Zaalim hukumat na manzoor. Ye begrt ab petrol mehnga bhi karege pehli tareekh ko. Sugar mehngi alag kar rahay hain. Aata mehnga. Chawal mehngay. Laant zaalim Boot chaat or IMF ke ghulam govt pe.
I totally agree and endorse the comment made here by Dr. Rahman from Canada He rightly said: “Mashallah Zabardast Tajziya aur Tabsara ! Taimur saab we are willing to give you 5 minutes 5000 times, but to get any real outcome, please ask the men in green uniform to give you 5 minutes. If you are able to satisfy Pindi Boys in 5 minutes, I will vote your for Next Nobel Prize.”” Sir ji please let us know if you succeed in convincing the real owners of Pakistan, which is not Awaam but the Men in Green from Pindi Abpara. Pakistan Paindabad
With respect..who ever you are…..can u convince establishment….tum jaisay log awam ko bolnay say Bhi mana kartay hain….ur thinking is exactly same as so-called pindi boyz, shame on ur thinking…doob kay mar jao
If IPP agreements are signed for Capacity and not actual consumption then Pakistanis should find who signed such agreements. Such signatories should be punished immidiately as these sound clear cases of putting money into someone's pocket. Pakistani people will be paying for such money for generations.
Dr. The private investment brought in for building power generation capacity is exactly like when the east india company raised private funds from britain to build rail in india which was guaranteed by tax money collected in india. Such high subsidies with a high possibility of increasing even further and increase in price of dollars will fuel massive inflation in addition to the currently already prevailing high inflation. Gov. will have to increase subsidies to reign in civil unrest high prices will cause.
@@Taimur_Laal Thanks for you reply Dr. Taimur. Sir, I have a question regarding CPEC and its economic purpose for China. The question arose because of 2 factors-population spread in china and shipping cost. I really want to know the answer to this question as it is biting me. I don't have Twitter blue can I contact you via Facebook or email or any other method Please reply sir🙏
Well when colonies were fighting to ge freedom the Pakistanis were busy doing nothing. Jinhha too was fighting to carve a country for him as parasite. If Pakistanis didn’t do right thing when it was possible to create something good. What hope is there today? Pakistanis never tough for freedom. So you never earned it. Enjoy!
@@nacpatil jinnah just created the necessary conditions. There are a lot of things which happened since then which has resulted in the situation today. I mentioned my assumptions and Dr. Taimur agress. @TaimurRahman1975 Few more things I think will happen in near future. There will be massive outflow of capital (of the rich) from Pakistan due toh increased cost of living and security problems. And there will be uptick in terror recruitment and terrorism due to poverty. Anyways who knows the future I am just an observer.
@@PP-jf3tp Situation today is obvious conclusion of what Jinhha sowed and masses wanted! Jinhha simply created a nice hot bed for all the feudals to take over and exploit the system. With leadership vaccum strogest playes which was army took over. Why this happened: because Jinhha's vision was not about what to do in future. It was short sited with two nation theory that we can't live together. What that not living together means was not thought over. If he had larger objectives, then he wouldn't be giving carrot to everyone including feudals and elites. One of the features of his carrot to elites was we will not distribute landlords land to poor which congress wanted to do.
ماشاءاللہ ❤ پاکستان مدینہ کی ریاست ہے اور مدینہ کی ریاست میں فیکٹریاں کارخانے بجلی پانی گیس انٹرنیٹ موبائل موجود نہیں تھی ہمیں بھی پاکستان مدینہ کی ریاست میں یہ چیزیں نہیں چاہیے یہ سب کافر کی ایجاد ہے
Banana republic. I salute people like you who persevere. I say run and leave and save yourself. The best thing that can happen is a complete rest of the country.
Then why if generation is above 41K MW then why transmission is only till 22K MW?? When this would be too resolved alongwith continuous hike in price of electricity
Please mention name of person, companies and woners of those private firms to hom subsidiaries have been granted. Who can cancel those bands , contracts ECT in the best interest of people.
تحریک اس بات کی چلائیں یار کہ پٹواری کی تنخواہ چالیس ہزار اور اس کا گھر دو کروڑ روپے کا، تحصیلداروں کی تنخواہ اسی ہزار اور گاڑی چالیس لاکھ کی، گھر چار کروڑ کا۔ یہ لوگ پھر اوپر اے سی اور ڈی سی کو بھتے دیتے ہیں۔ اور قبضہ گروپوں اور جوئے کے اڈوں سے روزانہ کروڑوں کی وصولی ڈالتے ہیں۔ ان کے خلاف عدالت جائیں تو 20 سال فیصلے نہیں آتے۔ الٹا یہ لوگ مفت بجلی، مفت گیس، مفت پٹرول بلکہ دس کنال کا مفت گھر حکومت سے لیتے ہیں۔ الٹا عوام کے دو ٹکے کا کام نہیں کرتے۔
Full support for govt to increase the electricity bill and gas petroleum diesel❤❤❤, and full support to awam for not paying these bills🤗, full support to both
۱۹۹۰ میں سوویت روس ٹوٹ گیا تھا اور امریکہ کا مقصد پورا ہوگیا تھا۔ انہوں نے ساری دنیا بشمول پاکستان کے سوفٹ قرضے بند کردیے تھے اور ہمین کہا گیا کہ آپ اب کمرشل بینکوں سے قرضے لیں۔ ساتھ ہی ساتھ واپڈا کی نجکاری کا پلان شروع ہوا اور PPIB کی تشکیل ھوئی۔
The real question is why the capacity was increased when there was no support of distribution. It was clear that old government made lot of Under table money through kickbacks by increasing capacities.
بہت شکریہ آگاہی کا ڈاکٹر تیمور
Meny ye video deer se dekhi or kam ilmi ki wja se dost se debate hara...i wont deley even a day for the next video❤❤❤❤
To the point explanation of recent issue. You are doing much better job than many of News Channels.
Thanks Dr Taimoor.
All your programs are objective and revealing the deep rooted contradictions
Can U explain those contradictions
They are called "circular debt" simply put.@@faizahmad6826
Thanks you very much Dr sb, I loved it when you said at 9:10 "2 takay bhe nahe bachaen gay" I think it's time when we stop saying takka as we are lowest
عمدہ تجویز
Dr Taimur Sahib, your videos are very informative on this critical subject. Your analysis are realistic, full of wisdom and true.
I live in the UK for 15 years, not even once faced load shedding. Because the national grid has the capacity to provide the whole country because of continuous investment by private and government entities
An eye-opening analysis, I think we people should take strict actions against the govt to initiate self sufficient steps.
We can't do anything except protesting like idiots... That's the end of the story
Thank you very much Taimur Sb., as always you have come up with data and solutions. thanks again.
The best thing is that you have given the solutions and not just blatantly criticized everything.
Basically we are paying the price of kickbacks for giving such sweet heart deals to IPPs
Thank you for being another person who provides clarity in the time of question. To whom one needs to question.
Sir hatts off to you for spreading such a valuable information
Thanks for explaining such a complicated economic issue in simple words. Lets hope your recommendation for renegotiating the agreements with the IPPs is taken consideration. Otherwise the masses are on the verge of revolt. On the other hand the IPPs should also realize the thininning of eonomic situation of the state. If the state remains economically stable then their investment would be of some worth In case of chaos and anarchy they wont be able to get a penny. Lets hope the sanity prevail on both sides and the poor consumers are given relief.
Very good analysis, you should be advisor to the Government, wish it accepted the advises of educated people like you ❤️🤲🏻
he wont be able to retain the position. Will soon be removed as an obstacle to the mafia
Yes it's called wishful thinking or as desis know it as "khiali palao"
Video is well presented with proper facts and figures.
Excellent
Quite apt analysis and suggestions. Much appreciated Dr.Taimur for weighing in.
Karachi has a favourable location for cheap generation of wind energy but optimization is the last thing I expect from Pakistani policy makers.
Also solar, but all that happens where true freedom exists. Here, the crown of gothas still rules. Have you ever seen old pictures of Quaid e azam meeting the Brits with their generals ? If yes see the uniforms and badges, same as what your generals strut around. They serve their masters who are masters of divide deprive and dominate. After all, a society with extra time and money might want to pay close attention to Quran. So....keep em busy.
Very well explained, Taimur Sb
You are doing great work sir.
Appreciate it Taimur sahib,, very well explained.
well explained. thanks
Thanks for this informative video.
Thank you for making such short video yet very comprehensive and informative. Please keep doing such work.
Very informative. Dr. Taimur you mentioned the IPP policy of 1994 but did we not double down after 2013? This is important as 1- The old 1994 plants were mostly small around 150MW 2 - Oil and coal prices in the following 8 years were low enough 3 - my understanding is the capacity payment on those projects will be very small now 4- The projects from 2013 are much bigger and were signed when oil price was over $100/bbl vs below $30 in 1994. So it was a much bigger mistake.
An excellent point. There are many details of this sort that I had to skip to keep the length as short as possible. Had to cut down the slides I had to as few as possible to make it easy for people to understand.
Doc next video ma poora such bolo
@@Taimur_Laal I would request you to kindly make a long form version with comprehensive details, please also educate us how these decisions, specifically the ones made form 2013 onwards, might includes aspects of private gain for some. I understand that you have a particular style and refrain from taking names but you must eductate the populace of how many forms of corruption there are, this can be done without taking any names.
It is very important topic. We need even a shorter version also for a layman/labour class in urdu text.
Thanks
Sir also please add the total number and names of owners of these IPPs and the reasons behind these kinds of decisions. And is there no one to question these kinds of decisions?
You just have opened our minds sir ❤ i love it.
Thanks for sharing this
Very well explained sir!
Thank you for this insight!
Renegotiating will be even more expensive. Those sovereign guarantees are ironclad. That was the whole purpose.
Thank you for educating us sir
Absolutely Correct. Thank you for rational analysis.
Great job sir
very well explained.
1.I suggest, when you speak of a year, mention which govt. it was.
2. How Nanyang IPPs set up by politicians. Why must they be paid dollar prices?
3. How many local companies set up IPP. Why must they be paid dollar equivalents?
4. Increasing transmission line is a must. We should see this as defence of Pakistan. Defence budget should be utilized.
5. Quaid-e-Azam started Pakistan with 7 ministries. It is ridiculous a caretaker needs 22.
Cabinets and others should work for Pakistan, not for grabbing privilege and perks.
Thank you for all the information. It was objective and to the point. One small request. If you could share the sources of your information via links in the description, it would be very helpful.
Informative video❤
Great sir
I really impress
Very informative sir.
My mentor.
Extraordinary information.
Thanks Dr sb
"John Perkins" the economic hitman was absolutely right Spot ON "bullseye"...!!! 😮😢
outstanding explanation....
Beautiful explain
Greatly explained
The only positive (news) in this video is how comprehensive, fact-based and well explained the information is
Sir ji tusi great hu ❤
Good job keep it up
good analysis
Nicely explained 👌
Islamic republic of Pakistan is on path to achieve greatness when it comes to performing worst economic output
great job !!
@TaimurRahman1975, can you please invite Shabbar Zaidi for an interview?
I have seen him do TV and Internet interviews and I think, he wants to get a message across but I don't think people interviewing him didn't know the right questions and weren't able to do justice.
should do a further talk on the a) addition of various non-electric related taxes on electric bills including income tax? b) Impact of these high bills on the budget of poor/MC people & future implications of civil unrest, crime etc
Jab tak President, Prime Minister, Governors, Speaker National Assembly, Deputy Speaker, Senate Chairman, Deputy Chairman Senate, Ministers, Judges, Generals, WAPDA Officers, MNAs, MPAs, Senators, Commissioner, DC, AC, Principal Secretary, Secretaries, Chief Secretaries, Military Secretary, Election Commissioner, or bureaucrats, saray retired govt officers ke muft bijli, petrol or gas band nahi kiye jaatay tab tak protest kartay raho. Zaalim hukumat na manzoor. Ye begrt ab petrol mehnga bhi karege pehli tareekh ko. Sugar mehngi alag kar rahay hain. Aata mehnga. Chawal mehngay. Laant zaalim Boot chaat or IMF ke ghulam govt pe.
I totally agree and endorse the comment made here by Dr. Rahman from Canada He rightly said: “Mashallah Zabardast Tajziya aur Tabsara ! Taimur saab we are willing to give you 5 minutes 5000 times, but to get any real outcome, please ask the men in green uniform to give you 5 minutes. If you are able to satisfy Pindi Boys in 5 minutes, I will vote your for Next Nobel Prize.””
Sir ji please let us know if you succeed in convincing the real owners of Pakistan, which is not Awaam but the Men in Green from Pindi Abpara.
Pakistan Paindabad
With respect..who ever you are…..can u convince establishment….tum jaisay log awam ko bolnay say Bhi mana kartay hain….ur thinking is exactly same as so-called pindi boyz, shame on ur thinking…doob kay mar jao
Im from karnataka state of india.. We literally have 200 units free electricity for everyone but wr don't usenthat much we use 180 units maximum😂
Sir, waiting for the longer version.
Thanks for explaining
Great video but this can only happen in Pakistan alas
great analysis
سنا ہے اگلے سال کا انتظار نہیں کرنا پڑے گا، اگلے مہینے ہی فی یونٹ قیمت دوگنی ہو رہی ہے
Privatisation is never ever in favour in general Public 2:14
Keep up the good work!
Very nice analysis
I have watched your all philosophy lectures sir
Please make these kind of more videos Thanks
Major imported coal and RLNG based power plants were built by PMLN in 2013-2014. Because of that we are suffering heavily
It is very hard information but it's reality.
6:15 to 6:18 ...
What a shot 🤣
بہت اچھا وڈیو، لیکن یہ بتانا “بھول” گئے کہ ۱۹۹۳ میں حکومت کس کی تھی اور Ipp والا کارنامہ کس کا تھا۔
There has been no light in my village for many years.
Sir issi tarah aik video dollar rate and fuel prices par bhi bana dein..
Thanks
If IPP agreements are signed for Capacity and not actual consumption then Pakistanis should find who signed such agreements. Such signatories should be punished immidiately as these sound clear cases of putting money into someone's pocket. Pakistani people will be paying for such money for generations.
V good analysis
آنکھیں کھول دینے والے حالات
Dr. The private investment brought in for building power generation capacity is exactly like when the east india company raised private funds from britain to build rail in india which was guaranteed by tax money collected in india.
Such high subsidies with a high possibility of increasing even further and increase in price of dollars will fuel massive inflation in addition to the currently already prevailing high inflation. Gov. will have to increase subsidies to reign in civil unrest high prices will cause.
Absolutely right. Well said.
@@Taimur_Laal
Thanks for you reply Dr. Taimur.
Sir, I have a question regarding CPEC and its economic purpose for China. The question arose because of 2 factors-population spread in china and shipping cost.
I really want to know the answer to this question as it is biting me.
I don't have Twitter blue can I contact you via Facebook or email or any other method
Please reply sir🙏
Well when colonies were fighting to ge freedom the Pakistanis were busy doing nothing. Jinhha too was fighting to carve a country for him as parasite. If Pakistanis didn’t do right thing when it was possible to create something good. What hope is there today? Pakistanis never tough for freedom. So you never earned it. Enjoy!
@@nacpatil jinnah just created the necessary conditions. There are a lot of things which happened since then which has resulted in the situation today.
I mentioned my assumptions and Dr. Taimur agress.
@TaimurRahman1975
Few more things I think will happen in near future.
There will be massive outflow of capital (of the rich) from Pakistan due toh increased cost of living and security problems. And there will be uptick in terror recruitment and terrorism due to poverty.
Anyways who knows the future I am just an observer.
@@PP-jf3tp
Situation today is obvious conclusion of what Jinhha sowed and masses wanted!
Jinhha simply created a nice hot bed for all the feudals to take over and exploit the system. With leadership vaccum strogest playes which was army took over.
Why this happened: because Jinhha's vision was not about what to do in future. It was short sited with two nation theory that we can't live together. What that not living together means was not thought over.
If he had larger objectives, then he wouldn't be giving carrot to everyone including feudals and elites. One of the features of his carrot to elites was we will not distribute landlords land to poor which congress wanted to do.
Sir pura energy crisis py video bna dy
ماشاءاللہ ❤ پاکستان مدینہ کی ریاست ہے اور مدینہ کی ریاست میں فیکٹریاں کارخانے بجلی پانی گیس انٹرنیٹ موبائل موجود نہیں تھی ہمیں بھی پاکستان مدینہ کی ریاست میں یہ چیزیں نہیں چاہیے یہ سب کافر کی ایجاد ہے
We have to change the entire system, policies, government, laws and everything 😭 huge reforms needed
thanks
Dr sb please provide advice for hydrogen system as discussed.
Excellent Explanation by Dr Taimur Rahman. In short the cost of 'barq e tajalli' is also included in the damned consumers' bills!
Banana republic. I salute people like you who persevere. I say run and leave and save yourself. The best thing that can happen is a complete rest of the country.
Then why if generation is above 41K MW then why transmission is only till 22K MW?? When this would be too resolved alongwith continuous hike in price of electricity
Crupt Wapda ne kicks back le kr bijli mehngi kr di
Incompetent governance has been the issue.
Please mention name of person, companies and woners of those private firms to hom subsidiaries have been granted.
Who can cancel those bands , contracts ECT in the best interest of people.
جناب کوئی منظم تحریک چلائیں یہی وقت ہے
Agree 100 % Agree ... ☆☆♡♡☆☆
تحریک اس بات کی چلائیں یار کہ پٹواری کی تنخواہ چالیس ہزار اور اس کا گھر دو کروڑ روپے کا، تحصیلداروں کی تنخواہ اسی ہزار اور گاڑی چالیس لاکھ کی، گھر چار کروڑ کا۔
یہ لوگ پھر اوپر اے سی اور ڈی سی کو بھتے دیتے ہیں۔ اور قبضہ گروپوں اور جوئے کے اڈوں سے روزانہ کروڑوں کی وصولی ڈالتے ہیں۔
ان کے خلاف عدالت جائیں تو 20 سال فیصلے نہیں آتے۔
الٹا یہ لوگ مفت بجلی، مفت گیس، مفت پٹرول بلکہ دس کنال کا مفت گھر حکومت سے لیتے ہیں۔
الٹا عوام کے دو ٹکے کا کام نہیں کرتے۔
Corrupted system ( people in general)will bear consequences
Sir please make a comprehensive video on Power sector reforms.
and yah mohida kitnay time kay liay hay ?
Full support for govt to increase the electricity bill and gas petroleum diesel❤❤❤, and full support to awam for not paying these bills🤗, full support to both
۱۹۹۰ میں سوویت روس ٹوٹ گیا تھا اور امریکہ کا مقصد پورا ہوگیا تھا۔ انہوں نے ساری دنیا بشمول پاکستان کے سوفٹ قرضے بند کردیے تھے اور ہمین کہا گیا کہ آپ اب کمرشل بینکوں سے قرضے لیں۔ ساتھ ہی ساتھ واپڈا کی نجکاری کا پلان شروع ہوا اور PPIB کی تشکیل ھوئی۔
سر اپ کی بات بالکل بجا ہے تو پھر یہ سوال پیدا ہوتا ہے کہ گزشتہ سالوں میں جو بجلی کی خوفناک حد تک لوڈ شیڈنگ ہوتی رہی ہے اس کا کیا جواز رہا ہے۔۔۔
People should be strong enough to kick out corrupt people from power or else a great danger is ahead.
In short: Mulk is full LUL.
Excellent analysis on current energy crisis in our country.Kindly make a video on National Energy Policy(2013-18) with its analysis.