Reality of Pro Kannada Protest | Karnataka | HIndi | Open Letter
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 พ.ค. 2023
- This video is a detailed deep-dive into the language debate that are currently ongoing in different states of Bharat. We have seen people fight on social media as well as on the street because of the language issue. Lets understand the history, reasons and repurcussion of this issue. Do watch and share!
🔥 Subscribe for more videos!
INSTAGRAM ► / openletteryt
TWITTER ► / openletteryt
FACEBOOK ► / openletteryt
Music: uppbeat.io/?referral=an-wkrvy
#Hindi #Kannada #LanguageDebate #India #OpenLetter
Ye topic kafi serious aur important hai, aapko video kaisa laga zarur batana ❤👇
1 kosh me 3.2 kilometres hota hai
Bhaiya ji aapki mother tounge kya hai?
Agar 5 year time leke bhi language nahi sikege toh ho log ko kya bolne padega???
There are hindi people who stay here for more than 10 years still they don't speak in our languages.
Its call ethnocentrism topic
Yah ek achha topic jo sare log ko samjna chaiye
ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರು ❤ like madrappa✅✅
Creator of the video conveniently forgot that Hindi is made compulsory in non-Hindi speaking states too!
@@aikyabharatha288 Jai shree ram. Bro Hindi and other languages are compulsory. Before 1960 there no hindi as official language.by article 343 made hindi as official and 22 languages also. Hindi is not compulsory language. Bhai mojhe Hindi ata hai tere se achcha .I'm from Karnataka.
That's why south states are erudite than north states😅😂
@@sumithkare9536, Hindi compulsory is ok, state language compulsory is not ok? Double standards? Let people decide what language they want to speak.
1 of the worst ppl
ಯಾವುದು ಊರು ನಿಮ್ದು
I’m from Mangalore Karnataka , I’m belong to Konkani speaking community so i talk konkani with relatives and family , Tulu is the language of our area so i talk tulu amongst villagers and friends. Kannada is state language so I speak Kannada to people who are from different parts of the state . Hindi is language of national politics so i also know Hindi . English is for education and news . So i speak 5 different language and I’m proud of my country 🇮🇳
👍👍
I speak the universal language of heart ❤️😂
@@staymotivated374 dhak dhak Dhak dhak
But of course… nobody values the language of heart 😐
@Ankith Mallya Same from my side. We, Konkani especially GSB people can adapt any language and settle with no issue without losing our mother tongue.
As a bengali, staying many months in mysore and bangaluru for work, I have sarted loving the culture of karnataka, so started to learn Kannada and believe me guys, when kannada people hear a north indain atleast trying to speak to them in their local language, they become very helpful , very sweet. the least I can say to my fellow north indians , this is just a language atleast learn the basic, they dont ask you to be a poet or philosopher in kannada language. Jai Hind .. Jai bharat...
Apreciated.... Kannadave sathya kannadave nithya... Jai karnataka
This is the difference between a person trying to learn a southern language in the south and a southern person trying to learn Hindi in the north. In the north, one can easily get laughed at. I had such experiences even though I speak fluent Hindi now. My bitter experience has made me not to speak Hindi to Hindi speakers and use only English. I act ignorant and it serves them well too!
yeah, they expect everyone to know hindi@@greenhopper29
Yes very true ❤❤❤we appreciate your efforts ❤😊
❤❤this is what everyone wanted. Language is our culture not just a communication tool.
As a kannadiga i can say here in Bengaluru many people know more than 3 languages including hindi. But the fact is we are trying our best to communicate with the outsiders and expect the same from them. This is not only on the streets but even in some government offices and banks where some people from north indiacome to work and speak only in hindi, just imagine any person in their land struggling to communicate with outsider who doesn't know the local language, that's a big headache and they even refuse to learn kannada and tell us back to learn hindi. Ok just imagine any of us kannadigas or tamilians or any person from South Indian going and imposing anybody in North India to learn any of the southern languages will they accept...??? We r just trying to save our language from hindi imposition.After begging for so many years now we have become rude.
Most of them know Hindi and English. If they need to communicate with Kannada people, they can do so in English - what's the problem? Learning a new language is not that simple. If I am working in Bengaluru, I don't know for how long I will be there; maybe I have to shift to another state.
Secondly, Hindi is not the official mother tongue for all North Indians. You guys have to understand this basic thing. We have our own regional languages like Marwari, Gujarati, Marathi, Bengali, Awadhi, Malwi, Punjabi, etc. Hindi is just like English in India - the language of communication. We have our own regional languages.
@@ayushrajput7154See I live in Bangalore and I don't think I need to learn Hindi to communicate daily to earn my livelihood because Bangalore is an IT hub anyway ..
"If they need to communicate with Kannada people, they can do so in English - what's the problem" The problem is they refuse to speak in English(and most of them can't even speak English properly). Secondly English works only in Urban areas. If you go to work in Rural areas you have to learn the local language.
"Hindi is not the official mother tongue for all North Indians" more than 40 North indian languages are considered as Hindi just to artificially increase the number of hindi speakers. Many North Indian languages are in Endangered state due to influence of Hindi.
Finally, what North Indians speak is not hindi. It is Urdu. Calling Urdu as Hindi for political reasons doesn't make it Hindi. Check any conversations of Indian and pakistani TH-camrs. They speak the same language that is Urdu...
@@ayushrajput7154
"We r just trying to save our language from hindi imposition" The central Gov is already replacing words of Kannada language with words of persian origin used in Urdu/Hindi by using money and influence. Just carefully watch news channels, astrologers, pop gurus, youtubers etc... they are slowly replacing one word at a time. for example :Hudukṭa becomes Talash, Bhuddhivanṭa becomes Akhalmand, Adhbuta becomes Kamāl, Jote becomes sath. they are trying to make it a fashion statement.
Also replacing kannada words with equivalent Urdu pronunciations Ex: Rāma become Rām, Bhārata becomes Bhārat and so on...
We must be aware of these criminals..
Cool, then you are second Tamil Nadu in the making.
I am staying in Bengaluru from last 10 years, I don't feel they force to us to learn. They just want to respect their language also. I learn kannada . It's sweet language
simple,ashte🙂
@@qandf5984 🙏🏽,No such difference b/w us brother ❤️ and let's respect all the languages of our Country,Just respect 🙏🏽🙏🏽
❤
Also we need UP people to learn few non hindi languages like Kannada and Marathi.
Now many ppl are visiting UP so tbere should not be langauage issue. Kannada and Marathi are ancient languages
Then what do you think about those people who posted the videos for getting harassed? Just because you didn't get harassed doesn't mean others also didn't get harassed. Learn to respect others experience.
As a Bengali I love to speak Hindi but if anyone imposed me to must speak Hindi. Then I never speak Hindi and this is thinking of maximum non hindi community. Love you all 🇮🇳
So many north indian already says it you don't know Hindi then you are not India get lose from hindustan they disrespect our mother tongues and try to impose language of munghol on us
Exactly same here.
I can speak hindi much better that hindi speakers. But totally no if it is imposed.
Same thought. I'm an Assamese and studied Hindi till class tenth. But I will never speak Hindi, if imposed on me.
@@malabikabarua1163 Can you explain how hindi is imposed on you?
@@Aditya_Pro i said "if"... And i mean it too 'if" ever.
I’m a teluguite living in Karnataka, I don’t agree with just telling local language being imposed on the outsiders, it all started when the union government started imposing Hindi on locals, secondly I disagree with locals forcing other to learn language complete, from what I have seen it is mostly the outsiders don’t respect the language, people and customs, which over time has piled up and caused an outburst, most Bangaloreans do speak atleast 2-3 languages and all they expect from my experience is us putting a small effort to learn few words, and they start helping us, and one more thing is Bangalore development started with the kingdom of Mysore, when the Wodeyars started progressive measures 100 years earlier which started reaping benefits 6-8 decades later, but the outsiders telling locals that Bangalore developed because of them forgetting that the very reason they have come is the successive governments and people have put more efforts to get investments and also I have seen in my office once we have a North Indian boss he tends to hire only North Indians and don’t encourage people from other parts of the country. Finally both the parties have few faults it’s better both the parties learn from their mistakes.
FR
Your understanding/knldge about kannadigas and bengaluru is grt❤ #wodeyars❤
Exactly this is what I want to tell
Same in my company, a tamilian focuses more on tamilians/Telugu
Finally someone told truth about origin of bangalore's progress or development.
I am from Rajasthan & an ExMuslim, I started loving every Indian language when got to know about its influence on its people & strong influence on great nation Bharat, So please respect every Indian language ❤
Bro no need to say that you are a exmuslim that's you choice but I k wo what you want😡
Im a Bengali from Jharkhand. I was travelling by train and my co passenger was a Manipuri Army soldier. The only reason i had the best conversation and one of the most pleasing journey of my life was because we both knew Hindi. So screw this petty linguistic divide. Language connects. Let it remain that way
Problem is central government's promotion of (only) hindi and sanskrit language
@@rajashashankgutta4334 more than 60 percent india knows hindi , why would the central govt. promote a language only 1 state speaks? this is coming from a malayali so dont give me that north india crap
@@hardworkistheway നന്നായി സഹോദരാ
@hard work is the way see bro, hindi is a derived language, it has been derived from many North indian languages, unlike dravidian derived. Back then government used hindi to unite us. It didn't work well everywhere. Take Punjab and haryana, haryana is a state now because Punjab didn't like schools teaching hindi instead of Punjab (even in a Punjab majority place). Now ppl (north) only speak hindi is cuz, others speak, ppl who speak their mother tongue (non hindi, north Indians) can understand them (cuz hindi is derived from it), so as they speak with more hindi ppl, they too picked up hindi. But we never caught on that train, when someone speaks in hindi, we'd be like "ahhhhhh?" And that's it.
Both of you should've been able to communicate in Bengali rather because of cultural similarities between the said cultures. You've been imposed by Hindi in a way as you think its more preferable than your own language
I have lived in Bangalore, I have seen both sides of the issue. .Issue doesn't come when they don't know how to speak(locals accept the fact), it comes when they refuse to learn it even after working and staying in the city for long. Especially when PPL use statements like "If you don't speak Hindi, why are you staying in India" and "If you don't speak Kannada, y r u in Karnataka"
Finally someone speaking sensibly. We don't have a problem when someone doesn't know how to speak Kannada but if they have stayed here for a long time and refuse to learn even few general sentences to use in everyday life it angers the local people. I mean we learn Hindi and try to make your visit as comfortable as possible in Karnataka, it's only respectable that you also learn local language. Tbh if someone tries to speak even a few words in Kannada, the locals get really happy and they go out of their way to help you. I don't support people who are harassing those who don't know local language but I can totally understand why they are harassing. I've also come across a lot of north Indians have a superiority feeling and insulting the local language and the cuisine.
we cannot learn a language just after shifting to a city. and if you are so proud of the language keep it to yourself don't just mock someone like a dump.
I agree with you, a friend of mine from Delhi said this to an another friend of mine(who doesn't speak Hindi).
@@nikhilbaitha4886 Bhai bhasha padhna hein ya nhi padhai ye aapki icxha hein lekin doosre bhaashaon ko neej dikha k bolna galat h na .Aap hi socho!
@@nikhilbaitha4886 Get comfortable with the local language, if you are going to live there for more than 6 months. The rule is majority wins. So when a non-Hindi guy goes to Delhi/Noida, he has to speak in Hindi, but if a Hindi guy goes to another state, he expects everyone should know Hindi. This will not work.
I'm Tamizhan studied English,Can understand Malayalam,Kannada,Tulu and Telugu.There is no need for other languages.
I am Tamil living in Tamil Nadu but I learnt Hindi out of my own interest (can write Hindi fluently and speak to an extent). No one compelled me to learn Hindi. Learning languages become beautiful when it is not imposed upon us.
@@N5coolyou can learn all Dravidian languages bro we don’t need to learn Hindi you know who is contributing more to our country if we get our own nation then you would go starving mate
@@SachinKumar-pi2xx Kerala is bankrupt, Karnataka is on the verge of bankruptcy, Andhra is inching closer to bankruptcy and you are thinking about making southern 🇮🇳 the next 🇧🇩 (🇧🇩 is still a least developed country for your information).
@@N5coolkerala is not bankrupt as they are richest indians abroad. South poor because mugal soldiers kids in delhi looting us
@@N5coolWhat? Bangaldesh is developed?😂. I agree it has a higher gdp oer capita, but it's still a 3rd world country just like ours?
Southern states and Maharashtra are still the bread earners of India. Like it or not. The tax return we get from central is a joke
I have been living in Bangalore for the last 13 years. Though I couldn't speak kannada i have progressed to the extent of understanding it and hopefully one day i will overcome my shyness and fear of making mistakes and start speaking kannada. The larger problem people often do not understand is the demographic shift happening in Bangalore which will be resented by the localites naturally. Imagine delhi being overpopulated by tamilians or malayalis and insist on local delhiites to speak in tamil or Malayalam.
What i feel is that kannadigas don't mind if you don't learn kannada. What makes them irriated is the insistence of north indians to converse in hindi . If you speak in English you dont face issues is what i have experienced so far.....
Im sorry to say this, because of people like you only this kind of incidents are happening.. you have been living here from past 13years and dont know kannada this show how much you respect local culture..this outburst are happening because outsider disrespect local culture like this, understand the main cause
@@dhavaljaina5923 why do you guys demand respect? It is something people feel out of themselves. How does it matter if others don't respect your culture. Ses you guys want others to respect you, a sign of having inferior feeling
@@prasanth123cet see you have been here from past 13years, still you haven't learnt it. Does this looks like we demand respect? Do you know how long 13years is this shows you don't care about the culture here. And more than 50% Bengaluru population is non-natives if everyone starts ignoring local culture like you means. How will the culture survive? Please answer this.
Learning kannada makes you inferior? this is the mentality of non-natives.
Giving respect to local culture, adding value to echo system where we live, where we eat makes you inferior?
What kind of non sense you are talking?
@@dhavaljaina5923 I may live for 50 years without learning the language of the place. It is absolutely my choice to learn or not to learn. Nobody can force me to do it as it is my fundamental right as an Indian citizen. I neither respect nor disrespect kannada or kannadigas. They are just like other Indians in any other part of the country and doesn't command special status or respect.
If you read my first message, you will understand that I have been trying to learn it just out of my own wish and not out of persuasion which should be the case for anyone. If I could manage without learning it what is your problem? I am not forcing anyone to communicate with me in my language. Neither anyone have the authority to force me to learn their language as long as I remain the citizen of india.
Being proud of one' s language and culture is good. Forcing it on others is not going to work and only make your own face look uglier....
Ps. This will be my last message. I have no more time to fight with some stranger through TH-cam...
@@prasanth123cet am i disrespecting you or am i scolding you for anything? Why do you guys think we will force someone to give respect or like now you think i started fighting with you.. Even you are stranger to me.. See because of this audacity and ignorance conflicts are happening... Will allow any German, French people to live in India without learning hindi or English for long years?
Im talking about sentiments you talking about law.. fine in Karnataka law mandates 60% kannada signage, are you guys following it? NOOO, atleast give respect to the law, forgot about culture. You guys opt for sentiments and law only if it suits you
People from Karnataka were very patient with outsiders, but having stayed here for years and still don't learn the language, how do you feel when Hindi speaking people put locals down. Has happened with me and is happening in my apartment in Bangalore
Very high superiority and entitled feeling many Hindi speakers have
@@sas2061same goes for southern indian states also .
@@sas2061 u know only 2 languages, we have to deal with 4. Why u want us more headache to learn one more.
@@joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 That is the thing bro...like half of the nation is connected by one language from east to West and North but for South everybody wants everyone to learn their own particular language ... 🙄
So what? there is no mandate that everyone should learn every state language, everyone will speak the language they want, what you are talking about is arrogance
I'm a south indian who lives in Chhattisgarh so I speak Telugu with my relatives from South and know the native language of chhattisgarhi from where i Live , Hindi because it's widely and most spoken language in India and English thanks to Education.
And I'm definitely proud of it.
Fuck barriers let's get United Together.
Please don't say South Indian it feels like different entity like people from north indian can't call themselves north indian becoz Kashmir and up are poles apart I think it might be true for state in Southern
Rajput? South Indian?
@@stylequotient4921 okk , i get your point but how you gonna denote the southern region of India without mentioning the word "South India" ?
Please Enlighten me.🙏
@@Rahul_Rao_001 you can use your state name !!
@@Rahul_Rao_001 use your individual identity like telugu kannada tamil punjabi gujrati like that
South Indian learning Hindi but North Indian not try to learn south indian language
😂o , you learning gujurati, Marathi, bhojpuri, maithili, asami, udia, it's it's 😡
@@MANOJSINGH-gg3ml thodha side dengey
@@MANOJSINGH-gg3ml madda guduvu vachi . erripukaa
@@MANOJSINGH-gg3ml learn English not hindi
I am from Bengaluru we have huge respect for our gujju, marwadi and Bihari brothers who learn kannada and speak like a local within few months.
That is never possible.. So chill... Keep fighting nothing will change.. Nobody has time to learn a new lang within few months.. It takes almost 5 yrs min
@@riteshvizz9786 🤣🤣come out of your cave kid they are not learning to read and write and become professors😂 5 Yrs lol. Maybe you will take 5 Yrs.My friend just spent 3 months in Delhi now he can speak hindi like a local Delhi guy.If you communicate daily with locals anything is possible.
@@riteshvizz9786 it depends on person to person. As to their learning abilities and interest.
We don't need your respect. Who are you? I've spent 7 years of my life in Bangalore and left it last month I'm proud of my languages Bhojpuri and Hindi and I never let any Kannadiga impose their language on me. A colleague of mine once did but I abused him in my traditional Bhojpuri style and from the next day he would look down and walk away from me 😂😂😂
I am a gujarati and I'm very proud that here people do not mistreat somebody just because they don't know how to speak Gujarati. And we never give this dumb argument that "if you have been living for long in gujarat then you must learn and speak ".. Absolute bullshit.. this false pride of language and region is nothing. If a kannada speaker and a Gujarati speaker go abroad both are yelled racist names like "headshaker" and "chicken curry"😤😤 nobody gives a shit about any language we all are Indians.
Yes thats what i love about gujaratis. I am a bengali having my hometown in gujarat now, although I can read and understand gujarati very well, but I still cant speak it fluently, but gujarati people are very chill and they easily communicate in hindi also. Most people from cities know hindi too, so there is no problem in communication.
😁Jai shree Krishna Gujju brother
@Souven Tudu u filthy tribal
@Souven Tudu tell me one thing, didn't you learn anything from the video? and no one is saying you to learn hindi brother/sister, you have created a Resistance for Hindi in your mind yourself I don't know under which circumstances, and this Hindi belt thing is kinda weird! we as Indians should respect each other cultures and language and shouldn't be offensive about it! I am from Bihar residing in Delhi, and have immense respect for kannada, malyalam, tamil etc. culture and traditions, but that doesn't mean anyone is superior to another, LOVE SHOULD BE MUTUAL, AND WHEN WE LOVE, WE LEARN TO RESPECT! I hope I am clear about my msg, spreading out love!😃
@@karanpandit5033 bhai rehne de. Ye chutiya same comment har jaga paste kar raha hai.
As a Bengali I believe Hindi is not just a language. It's a connection way that connect India. Few month ago I visited meghalaya. All tourist and locals are in conversation with each other in hindi. Although it's not anyone's mother tongue but all communicate with each other by broken Hindi in their way. That boosts me a lot. It's my incredible India
inhe kaun smjaye bhai ,
❤❤
You will lose your language and your culture like Maithili in Bihar. Goodluck.
@@engineeredarmy1152 if people our moving on let them forget no problem
At the End -: Language is used for communication... Just communicate with whichever language you want
@@engineeredarmy1152 no ,all hindi speaker here speak bengali . mere nanaji toh bas bengali newspaper padhte hai . even i can read bengali .koi culture lose nahi horha .instead its increasing .
Misleading title. Change it to: 'Why is this mughal era language called hindi, with no real history being forced on all Indians'
you are so right. They are prioritising some language with the history of 600 yrs old with the languages which has the history of 3000 yrs.
Because they are mugsl kids
@@keralanaturelover196With the same logic you are African kid's right?😂
@@vibhav____7791 COME KERALA and see. TAMILS ARE WORLD CEOS anot look like africans. GO AND SEE YOUR PRESIDENT. WHERE IS SHE FROM? JHARKAND?????
@@vibhav____7791 Africans not ruled kerala. Kerala Muslims mixed with arabs
Like Hindi, people from north should also give equal importance to other languages like TAMIL, TELUGU, MALLYALUM, KANNADA, MARATHI etc as well.
As they are the part of our culture and Tamil & Telugu are one of the oldest languages.
Ok but if we say it is mandatory for you to know haryanvi and Rajasthani and pahadi language are you agree with this
@@mushaidkhan9258 Muslims should be loyal to their religion not to their states or language
Marathi came from Sanskrit not from tamil
In Bangalore if we speak little kannada also people are Happy and appreciated...i live here since 5 years and peoples are very humble..
Some people won't do that much that's these many problems
This is the difference between north and south.
You should be ashamed of being a Rajput chi! Rajputs never bow down but you did
Dear every Bharatiya, always remember," Together we stand, divided we fall". Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@@greater5677well for sanatan people, india is the only country. Indic religions are the native ones and the rest are foreign. We indians need to get united irrespective of anything which has a tendency to divide but remember this is mutual. If my counterpart isn't willing to mutualise the understanding between us neither i am gonna do it, it's tiresome. And this is the case in my country, when one party wills to do that other stands to the ground.
@hinduvta Ram-terrorist lmao and you are promoting harmony with your name
I can't the irony 😂
@Papi Dey what's funny about that?
@Papi Dey are you serious??please stop with this linguistic divide created by Mamata Banerjee and do hell with your slogans like "joy Bangla"...I take pride of my language (Bangla)...but I am part of Hindustan/Bharat..so I will always be loyal to that idea of nation.
@Papi Dey jai hind🇮🇳 only
Our kannada language 5000 year old,why we forget our language and talk Hindi 😢
Maximum age of kannada language is 1500 years.Every South Indian language is mixture of Sanskrit and Tamil.I just give you a right information not about say you talk hindi.yes Hindi is not our national language
Dear what about Sanskrit and Prakrut language.
@@subashmala92 If lord Rama exits then which language he used to speak sapad or oota.
@@subashmala92 Dear study deeply not 1000 and 2000 Prakrut language is oldest language no body created this language it was present in nature while human was created.
@subashmala92 bla bla we have 1500 year old novel gadya😂.
1800 yrs old stone inscription.
Language is atleast 2500 yrs old and might have originated 3000 yrs back
I'm an Odia. But I'm staying in Kolkata since 3 to 4 years. I have learnt bengali which is also a sweet language alike Odia. I love India not a single state.
Talk about Bangalore.
Thank u, i am A Bengali. ❤️
I'm from Chapra, Bihar and born and brought up in Kolkata, West Bengal. My parents speak in bhojpuri, siblings speak in hindi, teachers speak in English and friends speak in Bangla. Also few friends are Assamese and few are maithili and I listen to Punjabi music so I have learnt almost five to seven languages in 20 years of my life and another reason for that is my father was an army officer. I know it's quite different to learn and manage so many languages at time along with studies but then thats the beauty of India 💚🤍🧡🇮🇳
Bangla bojhen?
I live in jharkhand and same. Just instead of bhojpuri make it magahi.
@@atrijaghosh7418 I know you didn't ask me but mostly yes:) I think Kolkata(WB) Bengali is a little different from here though.
@@atrijaghosh7418keno, gaalagal debe, chaddi bole nijer mota buddhi dekhabe?
@@atrijaghosh7418 haa khub bhalo kore 😊
I'm a kannadiga!
I don't agree when my own kannadigas say "if ur living in Karnataka learn kannada"
I'd rather choose to agree when we say "try to learn basic kannada so as to be able to contact with local people!" This would sound more positive and better way to say it !
You are correct, my friend. As a fellow Kannadiga, I feel some random instances are blown out of proportion. We take pride in Kannada, and at the same time, learning multiple languages helps in complete development. I recommend non kannadiga people living in Karnataka to make an effort to learn Kannada and Kannadigas must encourage that positively. And we too must make an effort to learn hindi and other regional languages spoken around us.
Basic kannada ಕಲೀರಿ ಅನ್ನೋದನ್ನ ಒಪ್ಕೊತಿನಿ
ಆದ್ರೆ ಅವ್ರು ಅದನ್ನ ಕಲಿಯೊಲ್ಲ , ಮತ್ತೆ ಕನ್ನಡ ಬಾಷೆ ಕೀಳಾಗಿ treat ಮಾಡ್ತಾರೆ ಅದುಕ್ಕೆ ನಾವು ಕನ್ನಡ ಕಲಿರಿ ಇಲ್ಲ ಅಂದ್ರೆ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಿಂದ ಹೋಗಿ ಅನ್ನೋದು💛♥️
@@TheNameisRamesh ನಿಮ್ಮ ಮಾತು ನಿಜ. ಆದರೆ ಇದನ್ನು ಸರಿಪಡಿಸುವ ಹೊಣೆ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರದು. ಅವರು ಕನ್ನಡ ಕಲಿಯಲು ಪ್ರೇರಣೆ ಕೊಡಬೇಕು. ನಾವು adjust ಮಾಡಿಕೊಂಡು ಅವರ ಭಾಷೆಯಲ್ಲಿ ಮಾತಾಡ್ತೀವಿ.
Ur a hindi gulam
@@adarshactivity not at all !
Why does north people who stays in karnataka for a long time wont even try to understand or learn the local language? Why is it that we kannadigas only have to learn hindi here in our city? We have learnt hindi and is it wrong for us to expect North Indians to try and learn kannda
I am a Bengali and I have seen many non Bengali people comes to our state for tourism, buisness and other purpose. I find most of them communicating in Hindi with us and our Bengali people cooperate with them very well even if somebody doesn't know Hindi tries to speak it. But when we go to any Hindi speaking state and if we can't speak Hindi if we tries to communicate with Bengali very less no. Of Hindi speaking people who know Bengali cooperate with us but most of them don't cooperate with us and also they say that Hindi is our national language(according to them not in reality)so you must know Hindi. Also when a non Bengali people in our state tries to speak bangla we feel happy and if he makes some mistakes we tries to correct it but in a Hindi speaking state if we can't speak Hindi properly and mix our local language with Hindi they make fun of our language and a very best example of that is that Vivek Bindra's video where he openly makes fun of Bengali dialects. Every language have different dialects but making fun of them seems very bad and it hurts those people who speak that language. So I think cooperation should be from both parties if one party does not co-operate says Hindi is national language (which is actually not) and other party only co operate then it's seems unbalanced. So every language speakers should co-operate with the other otherwise there will be a linguistic inequality in the country.
Vivek bindra didn't made fun of bengali ..he is actually right
@@Anjani-tk9xs He is I think in the whole video was partially right because in middle of that video for 8-9 minutes he talked about those statistics of different aspects in that time band he was right. But in the starting of the video he made fun of Bengali pronunciation and I am saying about that thing in my comment that a person has no right to mock any language pronunciation like this. Apart from that he also said Bengalis are mamma's boy so what's wrong with that we respect our parents and we respect their decision and there is nothing wrong with obeying our parents. He also says about our food habits that he went to a Bengali hotel and wanted veg but they gave him fish. Do you think any hotel exist in Bengal like this what he meant to say that Bengali have no sense to differentiate veg and non veg. He says Bengali have very less knowledge of economics but there are two Bengali noble laureate who are from Bengal. He said about Bengalis Durga Puja without knowing it has inscribed in UNESCO World Heritage. He says many bad things about Bengalis culture, Language, People, Food Habits. I think if had not said all these and have only talked about the datas and statistics I would have liked his video but somewhere I think in the process of describing Bengal's downfall he have blamed Bengali culture, language, people, food habits etc. Yes Bengal is in very poor condition today but that's only because of the politicians of Bengal not because of the common people not because of the language food habits culture. Whatever Vivek Bindra said in his video about our culture, language is totally against the constitution.
@@kaustavdhara5625
I am Marathi and from Maharashtra. In my college, there was a non-Marathi guy. Most Marathi people can speak Hindi, so I asked the non-Marathi guy why he didn't learn Marathi. He replied that he felt that Marathi was a lower language or a chapri language. I felt bad, but I didn't say anything to him.
@@Anjani-tk9xs exactly Vivek Bindra is a Chad
@@stfo4260 this is the problem bro literally hindi destroy other language because of hindi of odia children don't know odia
To all my indian brothers , compassion is the only key to this problem .🙏Jai hind 🇮🇳
That's true brother. Jai Hind.
Bro Hindi Hindu Hindustan Hind ye sab foreign Wale ko bharat ko dekhne ki najariya hai humara nahi Hind Hindi Hindu Hindustan Arabic parsi turkey logo ka word hai bo use karte the humara dharm sanatan dharm not hindu Desh Bharat desh not hindustan or India
Lol.. easy said than done!
@@bojackhorsingaroundtrue
@@bojackhorsingaround can always TRY .
Some people think that speaking hindi is more patriotic than local language
Hindi sounds good...
It gives u space to experiment
Also it has the power to absorb different words of different languages and accents with in !
Not really. Speaking Hindi doesn't make u patriotic
@@Your_real_dadnorth induans do believe that.
@@drg598 which is the problem with it. People fear that their language and identity will be engulfed and absorbed into the bigger hindi language.
@@Attitudezero884 not everyone though! I am north Indian but I prefer malay over hindi ❤ no hate it's just my opinion
Nicely covered half topic . Let me tell you another half part of the story 😅
How about people staying in Bangalore for more than 20-30 years and still not knowing the Kannada language.
Funny thing is 2 neighbours in our apartment, both from North India scolding the local watchman to communicate with them in either Hindi or English as they don’t understand Kannada .
This is when we get irritated .
Shameless people.
Imagine the same being done by South Indians in Delhi 😅 It would be a national news
Acceptance > Compulsion
Language isn't just a mode of communication, it is strongly close to our culture & a matter of pride for us.
Harmony comes with acceptance. I come from Jharkhand but if I start to live in Karanataka/Telangana, it's my duty to accept their culture & learn there language as well. It helps us to evolve.
However, unfortunately many Hindi speakers don't feel that way. I have seen many who are working in South for several years but didn't even try to learn the local language. At the same time, they expect every non-hindi speaker to learn Hindi.
language has huge influence in everything from education to culture. Kannada is the identity of karnataka people
I was talking about my colleague in Hindi when I joined the company as a fresher.
The manager told us that Hindi is a language for bus conductors and auto drivers.
I am from odisha. My first language is Odia. That doesn't mean I will be rude to non-Odia people or force them to change their identity.
Average idli behavior
You should have said then why aren't you speaking in Hindi?
@@aexp.9539
If he really said that's wrong
Average Paan parag behaviour is much worse than that😂
yehi iss maamlo me odisha better lga mujhe. I am a bihari living in odisha. Odia bhi classical language hain people take pride in their language but they speak hindi as they understand it's important for the country to have a common language and see, I am having zero problems living here. and neither did their culture diluted which tamils are more concerned about
@@Swastikanothookcross bro Odia people are also Hardcore with their beliefs but in general are pretty chill.
I am from Bangalore, Imagine if kannada or Tamil is made compulsory language in India. You start hating these languages. The same will be the feeling of people if Hindi is forcefully imposed on us. In south India we had no contact of Hindi until independence. Please note that Hindi is not a pure Indian language. It is a mixture of Arabic, Persian and some Indian languages. It does not even has its own script. Script is borrowed from Sanskrit. Instead of having common language. I suggest to work on common script for all indian languages, so that all languages blend gradually and new common language is formed naturally.
Bro formal Hindi is not Arabic or anything ..Hindi is just for connecting states ...who told you not to talk to in kannada in Karnataka but you can't talk kannada in Delhi because people don't know...and no one in India is Hindi speaker every states has it's own language but still only North Indian understand how Hindi is important to connect with other states but not with south because south live in ego..but why you learn English ..English is not even Indian language English speaker looted you , raped women , make you vulnerable etc still you love English than Hindi ..bro even Hindi speaker didn't do anything to anyone...but still you south people love to talk in English and feel modern 😂😂there is difference between modern and western...a begger in uk also speak English but he is not modern ...😂😂😂
Yes right
The central Gov is already replacing words of Kannada language with words of persian origin used in Urdu/Hindi by using money and influence. Just carefully watch news channels, astrologers, pop gurus, youtubers etc... they are slowly replacing one word at a time. for example :Hudukṭa becomes Talash, Bhuddhivanṭa becomes Akhalmand, Adhbuta becomes Kamāl, Jote becomes sath. they are trying to make it a fashion statement.
Also replacing kannada words with equivalent Urdu pronunciations Ex: Rāma become Rām, Bhārata becomes Bhārat and so on...
We must be aware of these criminals..
Majority of hindi words are from sanskrit they have been corrupted by bollywood into urdu
Yes bro true just make kannada or Tamil national language make idli sambhar dosa national language and any other dish will not be allowed to eat..funny without logic Hindi is not Indian language Hindi is Hindustan and Hindustan is Hindi kannada or Tamil is just Sri Lankan language
I moved to Sweden for twenty years ago and learned the language first. It was easy to live here. So i think learning a new language is fun and important
Kannada is most important in karnataka
😂
I lived in Karnataka for 5 years and I proudly say it on your face that I have showed m.. finger to Kannad language my mother tongue is Hindi and I won't speak any other languages so do whatever you want
@@explorewithaShreya614shameless people want to stay in karnataka without giving respect to local language
@@HumanRider-ys6ldur mom shd feel ashamed of giving birth to such a hopeless child like u
@@HumanRider-ys6ld then tell us where do you live😂😂. You say it proudly
You said about reactance, kanadaigas in Bengaluru didn't not force Kannada on north Indians, but after IT revolution many young north Indians immigrated to Bengaluru who kind of resisted to learn Kannada Even though they're living here for more than 5 yrs, and many times in front of my eyes they have insulted Kannada and treated them as inferior language, mainly by young people, the old north Indians who are older than 50 yrs they are wise, they respect the indigenous culture and language
First of all you should learn the difference between inferior language and joke. And then also you shouldn't forgot indian govt set up tech organizations and tech institutions when bengaluru had nothing, anyone didn't say objection on it, they have right to come and work and talk in their language, at last if you want to stop migration in you city then stop propoganda about you city that your city is world class, many people trap in that propoganda and come to live there
@@soumyadeepchowdhury3585
Historically , south Indians had a gripe with Hindi,the tamils hated both hindi and sanskrit and wanted to create their Identity based on Tamil/tamizh language and it's antiquity , the telugu ,malayali,kannadiga, wanted sanskrit to be the national language, as this will aid them to understand their scriptures better and believed in the classical antiquity and prestige of sanskrit, along with their mother tongues. But the central govt , Congress party decided to go with pragmatism and chose Hindi because most people spoke(not read or write) it.
Did you know about the love / hate relationship between Tamil/telugu, Tamil / kannada?
Did you know the first state to form on the basis of the language is Andra pradesh? , Because we bifurcated the Madras state due to Tamil imposition. The Tamil hate Hindi imposition because they were also guilty of imposing their own language and culture ,ideology on other south Indian , and believe me the Tamil love their language ,there can be no better chauvinist than a Tamil chauvinist. The Hindi ones you can find now and then are cute by comparison.we south Indian did not let one language be imposed over the other and kept our distinctive classical status in check.
But why can't you learn Hindi for unity of India? If not,what is the common language of the south I can't learn all four languages(Tamil,telugu, kannada and Malayalam)?
You are correct, Hindi is a pragmatic solution for a national language, had it not shot in the leg but also letting english be the other option. Today Hindi and English are the official languages of india.
Ideally it should have been Sanskrit. Many agreed with sanskrit for nationalism and religious Hinduism reasons ,but pragmatism had to come in between,chose Hindi and guess what today the same pragmatism is a hurdle for Hindi to be a National language. Because pragmatically english is a better language to learn, instant respectability,better opportunity,heck the increasingly medium of schooling and job enviornment is english.so hmmm 🤔 🤷.
Same pragmatism that gave opportunity for Hindi to be a National language killed it in the end,i am sorry 😔.
The unofficial common language of south India is english.heck ,you can look me in the eyes and say, arrey sun be ,chyawanprash rang ke chutiye,main Naa Tamil sikhungi, Naa telugu, nahi kannada aur malyalam sikhungi, if you don't know Hindi and can't be bothered, you better talk to me in English, i can't be bother to learn four different languages. i would totally respect that.you go girl, and rise up for your truth. That is the reality, give this reasoning to south indian and see if he can't refute that.no he can't. It's the truth.
Have a nice day.pranam🙏
@@soumyadeepchowdhury3585 what you're trying convey and what I am telling is totally different, you're talking about propaganda and politics, I am telling about person to person interaction, you're giving points in national level, and I am telling about personal issues between immigrants and local people
@@soumyadeepchowdhury3585 if Bangalore gets industrialized then we will for sure welcome it, Yes others have right to come here and work and speak in their language I am not denying it, and neither we nor Karnataka govt tell Bengaluru is world class city, infact who have lived in Bengaluru for more than a year tell it's hell. In my comment I have mentioned about few young north Indians ( not all, very few) give hate comment on Kannada, politicians use this incident for them and emotionally triger the local people, I or majority of South Indian people have no hatred towards north Indians or hindi and majority of us like sanskrit, but continuous replay of incidents and politicians speech against n. India kind of makes us feel as if both are different countries and both are enemies
@@kgiplmdrf9488 bro I am completely accepted your comments
Untill Hindians give equal respect to all Indian languages, unity in diversity will always be on paper.
Northies must understand saying BHARAT MAATAAR JOY in Bangla instead of BHARAT MATA KI JAI in Hindi doesn't make me less patriotic.
Support to all language warriors from Bengal ❤
I happily say that, when you throw out Communism,understand the threat of Islam and stop loving football.
@@gauravk6114 Dear Chomu, I'm a Right winger not a communist. I don't belong to Andhbhakt fraction of BJP voter voter base. I belong to the right wing intellectual fraction & an active BJP member in my state.
@@Indianoamericanorussiano first of all we are indian not hindian so mind your language 😏😏😏
We don't hate Hindi language, dude we hate the pressure implementation of the language, that's all we all love Hindi as well as our mother tongue,but get real central government always ensures to put some pressure to accept Hindi
The very fact that he did this video in hindi though he expected south indians to see it is unbelievable ignorance especially by north people that everyone should speak hindi , HE DIDN'T EVEN KEEP CAPTIONS. 😂
Everyone speak Hindi
Hindi is indian language and official language
You have a point. This TH-camr is an ignoramus and lives in his world of Aaloo Paratha and Sub Standard Bollywood Movies.
I have no problem with other languages, but from childhood my parents speaks Hindi, and recently shifted to south of india , very sweet people but also I have come across some locals who showed aggregation because I was speaking in Hindi so i moved away from there , because i didn't want to make a seen. But yes I have experienced the pain .
English is acceptable but not Hindi
man sorry but, ig this is the thing, south indians dont really care what language ppl speak, we might not even care if ppl spoke hindi with each other, same with english. but south indians started to not like hindi
Can I ask you something? Why can't you learn native language if you shifted to there. Does you will allowe to speak to you in my native language in your state?
So according to you.
Locals should start learning a new language(hindi) bcz migrants like you to feel comfirt?
@@santhoshv3028it's simple , learning a new language needs a lots of time and dedication which most of the people don't have
@@lathalibin no, if I go to gujarat I will not learn gujarati by giving it a specific time, it's obvious that with time I will automatically learn gujarati but giving it specific time will be a waste cz I can communicate with them in hindi, everyone know hindi there. This is beauty of North India, ever state has it's own language but everyone learn hindi as second language to communicate with each other, and south Indians, 5 states, 5 languages, and no one agrees to make a common link language, that's language politics.
Being from uttarakhand i have grown up listening and sometime speaking Garhwali language ..not just the language but the culture and rituals attached to it is in my blood from incept but we do speak Hindi but never let it as a barrier for our communication and the
*struggle for communication is real* .#
😭areyy mai vi garhwali aur mera naam vi sanskriti 😭😭😭 .
@@defnurmom wow ..twining 😂❤️
@@sanskritinautiyal 😭😭 mai bss rawat hu
@@defnurmom oh wow
@@sanskritinautiyal ji
As maharashtrian , we accept every people Hindi , Gujarati , South Indians , and we don't have a problem with " if they don't know Marathi " until they say " Yaha Marathi nahi chalti "
truth hurts? Mumbai majority are Hindi speakers
Bhau aplya ya swabhava mulech he lok khup majlet ata Mumbai madhe nahi tar Nagpur madhe pan hach hal zala ahe
Ani yevdach nahi baher che lok aplya la ghati mantat
@@himanshunikode5832 even amaravati madhe pn khup hot aahet aata
I feel that when a non native tries to accept and adapt to the the local cultures, it is always appreciated. I have lived in many different states in India, most of which are non Hindi speaking states. I have tried to my best to learn the local languages and i would often speak it wrong, but the locals have always appreciated it and found it amusing then they themselves spoke in Hindi to include me. Of course there are bad apples everywhere but respect and tolerance towards other cultures and languages are important.
Moral of the story plese🤗
In my village (Chhattisgarh) a sadhu came from Maharashtra.
He was talking with some villager in hindi but villager were responding in Chhattisgarhi both were understanding each other very well 😂😂😂😂
As I live in Maharashtra I started talking to him in Marathi and baba was surprised then I told that I lives in Nagpur.
If the same Sadhu comes here and start speaking in Hindi, then he will learn a lesson definitely. We are never exposed to Hindi and we don't want to.
@@GirishAdesh'here' means where?
@@Aratiii06 Karnataka.
@@GirishAdesh that is extremity. You can talk to him in sign language. No other lesson is required. Afterall, he is only a sadhu - a non violent spiritual person. What is the need to teach him a lesson? He is beyond all these small differences, isn't it? Will he force you to speak in any other language?
@@Aratiii06 I'm not asking or forcing him to speak my language.. he should pronounce a state's name as it is.. the same way Gujarat cannot be written or pronounced like Gujarata, Delhi as Dell, Uttar Pardesh as Uttara Pradesha. And it's definitely not a extremity.
Knowing additional language is always an advantage and adapting to the need of the situation is added bonus . Am fluent in my tribal dialects , nagamese (a Creole) and English. Can speak hindi and understand assamese and slight Bengali. So in a day you can be conversing in any languages and switching the languages to adapt to different speakers . It's fun.
I'm a maharashtrian,i know that 'आम्ही मराठीची बोलु कौतुके,परी अमृतातेही पैजा जिंके' but even then i love most of languages in india! Especially Sanskrit....its like life to me!
And i strongly believe that every language has its own sweetness and importance!
भाषा खासकर संवाद के लिये ज्यादा बनी है , वादविवाद के लिये कम!❤
Being a multilinguastic person is a good concept!❤❤❤
Everyone should communicate in Morse Code 😂😂
Bahut mehnat lagegi.
@@maitreyajambhulkar isiliye toh 😂
@@maitreyajambhulkar mehnat lagegi toh jhagada hi khatam 😂
But far simple then Sanskrit (jk)
Excellent Suggestion
Kannada is being spoken from centuries in karanataka, suddenly what is this force to learn Hindi?
As human being if I am being forced I won't learn anything. Only love can change peoples mind. Because of loving friends and neighbors, I learnt Hindi.
brother we are not forcing you to learn hindi but please dont misbehave with someone just because he/she speaks different language
@@snowleopard3925 many Hindi speaking people have also misbehaved with me, I did not create a language war because of it neither recorded and uploaded video in internet. If you don't know about kannadiga please stay out of this conversation.
English is the unofficial common language in south india.
Don't learn any south language .instead ask us (south Indian) to speak in English.
Today due to the job market and medium of education in English, it is a more pragmatic language than hindi.
As a human being who can speak and communicate in English, I don't want to be forced to learn kannada keeping my hectic schedule aside. If the ego of kannadigas is so big then I will stay here for more decades and I'll never learn your language. If you don't want hindi to be forced then don't force your local crap on us too....
@@snowleopard3925 speak english when down in south india. No one will respond to you in hindi in bangalore, because majoirty of them, includng me, dont know to speak hindi.
I grew up in Mumbai and being a Tuluva spoke in Tulu at home but was communicating in hindi outside the home. I also learnt to speak in Marathi and gujrati a little.
After my college learnt fluent English as well.
So now at least i know 3 languages fluently. And since last few years i have been living in Bengaluru and know a few words in Kannada too.
And i feel that Kannadiga folks are generally open minded but also expect you to be open minded and when it comes to language have a just expectation that you at least try to speak in Kannada.
If you simply brush it off thinking you don't want to put time and efforts on it..maybe you can refer the research paper which says that learning a new language has many benefits for the mind.😊
Dani encha ullar
Nina famili mangalord aa?
If North Indians can work in Bengaluru they have to speak at least basic Kannada.
People must understand that there's a huge difference between doing a task by loving it and doing the same task under pressure would give us a contradictory result .
Very true
You would learn German if you wanted to Work/Study in Germany.
@@engineeredarmy1152 Germany don't have that much toxic behaviour like France so we can easily communicate with with them in English, also when you live in foreign country you have to learn their language and pls don't compare this by Indian states you have to speak this and that fuck that. Come out of that behaviour as soon as possible, otherwise you wil be another example of politically misguided bigots 🤡🤡. Hope you understood this heavy dose thks a lot
@@engineeredarmy1152 Would you learn German if Adolf told you to?
@@engineeredarmy1152 many indians would learn a foregin language if they are going to work in foregin countries but they dont want to learn their own countries language
This video exactly shows the opinion of a Hindi speaking person about speaking Hindi in non Hindi speaking States without properly understanding the reality.
We kannadigas are not imposing our language on any outsiders. But we are imposed by hindi speaking people to talk in hindi. We love our language, expect same love & respect from others.
Good informative video 👍 Main problem is that most people are least bother to learn other languages - If you are at least 10th pass person, you can easily learn atleast 10 Kannada words in atleast 10 days - show some interest instead of giving reasons not to learn e.g. Maadi (Do), Kodi (Give), Yenu (What), Beku (Want), Beda (Do not want)..
BTW - I am a Kannadiga - spent my childhood among Marathis in Mumbai and in my SSC (English medium 😊) 1991 batch, I was School topper in Marathi, 4th in Hindi and 9th in English. Kannada I could only speak then but eventually self learnt to read & write Kannada within 48 hours. So it is all about interest, respect and skill - Kannada has almost similar alphabets like Hindi/Marathi 👍
Now I am learning Tulu, Telugu and then German and Spanish. My experience to share - Trust me if you converse atleast few Spanish words in USA with Mexican people they will help you like brothers. So learn new language to explore new world instead of complaining 👍
many world in marathi and kanada has same meaning.
ekada, anna, shighra somany
7 years ago my father shift to Gujarat and now I am able to speak influent Gujarati
15 years ago, a Hindi speaking guy shifted to Bangalore. He has still not learnt basic Kannada.
@@Aratiii06OMG
I have no answer for you
In that time period I can learn 3,4 languages more😂😂
I'm a Kannadiga from Bengaluru, this is the 1st time you did not see the other side of the story where there is chaos going on in some parts of Bengaluru from some hindi speaking people, which you can find in youtube itself.
Let me give you one example
Bengaluru has 16-17% Tamilians and they speak in Kannada, but problem is with Hindi speaking people who says Hindi is national language.
Its not about language, its about the interest which they have to learn and adopt in a different city, which we kannadigas and maybe other south indian people expect
Is it wrong ?
Yes it's wrong, they will learn if they feel the need for it
I think people in the south are doing the same thing north indians would do if they spoke to them in a South Indian language
Learning a second Language shouldn't make u forget your mother language but if you forget it, we can't help you, i mean who forgets their mother language. 😅.
@@aspirant9845 isn't it exactly what northies expect if you were in a North Indian city.?
@@aspirant9845 how good is saying a south indian to mandatorily lean hindi just because they are comming here for job...?
It's you who have to learn a south indian language
Not us ...!
I hv no problem, we shud learn as many.but Some native Hindi speakers have spoiled the image of Hindi speaking people.
It's Not about not learning a language but just respecting people's culture and language
TO ALL HINDI SPEAKERS:
Hindi is a very beautiful language but so are other indian languages.
You are not superior to us and neither are we to you.
One thing you have to realise is that the moment you stay in a non Hindi speaking region for a long time, do learn the local language.
And the thing is no one mocks you even if you speak it with an Hindi accent which is not the case with us. I have been mocked by hindi speakers for my accent despite having fluency in hindi.
I also feel that many Hindi speakers are racists
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz u are right
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz really?? How about kannada dadagiri .
@@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz So are many punjabi speakers, tamil speakers, kannada speakers, bengali speakers, etc. Every group has a few bad apples.
Hame superiority complex nahi h tumhe hhhh
English language Janne ka
There is nothing to "like" Hindi...it's not good to push any language on state and culture...India is a multi cultural and multi linguistic nation. There isn't any national language as such.
Dont impose to learn Hindi , but start promoting Sanskrit , it will be accepted by every state because its almost mother of all languages in Bharat 🎉❤
I respect all regional languages and culture from bottom of my heart. But friends, why hatred towards Hindi speakers? When we happily accept English as a language (Which actually was imposed and is a symbol of past slavery) why not a more or an equal respect towards Hindi speakers too? Hindi is a language which has an Indian soil origin. Who's mother tongue is Hindi? I guess all regions have there own languages, it's just that Hindi is a common communication medium. Though I respect your opinions. Please come over this, we have a lot of issues to be solved. Jai Hind, Vande Mataram!
It’s difficult to learn than a south indian languages all north belt languages are similar but imposing the other way around when you are not moving from home state is also bad. It should be optional for people not a mandate
Simple reason, it gives unfair advantage to hindi speaking folks especially in accessing central services.
@@avinashnandyala nobody is Imposing is still an Optional languages
Mostly people from North West and eastern India 🇮🇳 people fight against Britishers a lot so it's in our blood we can't speak English with our own people
@@rajashashankgutta4334 the same way English gives advantage to the west. People don't question that?
@@proshort7423western institutions dominate our world in almost every major field. Ofcourse they gonna set their instructions in their preferred language.
I just want to clear my stance here. I am from odisha. And yes if someone is visiting odisha for touristing or traveling purposes then you don't have to learn odia. But if you are going to stay in odisha for job and business then learning local language would be beneficial for you more in the long run. Still i am fluent in hindi , english know a little bit of bengali and currently learning kannada. It's about your own benefit.
If some outsider is planning to live there for long period of time, he/she will eventually learn basic odia only and only if Odias don't pressurise them to learn it.
People decide themselves whether they want the benefit of learning a different language or not. It becomes a problem when people are forced to learn the language just because they are working at a particular place. Will they learn a new language every time they change jobs??
Absolutely we odia people didn't impose our language to anyone even though our language is a classical language as old as other languages. Most Odia people comfortable with hindi speaking and people from cities comfortable with both hindi and english.
Hindi should ban from odisha because Hindi killed odia language in odisha
Yes It will be beneficial but it should not be mandatory because everyone is not as smart as you who can learn multiple learn easily ..yahan english nahi seekh pa rakhe Jo bachpan se pad rahe school odisa, Bengali , or koi language kaise sikhenge kyu aam insan ki life ko or jada horrible bana Rahi h govt waise hi Aaj kal ke time mi waise hi paresan h insan
Iam from Delhi I live Bangalore since 5 years. People here don't force us or see down when we talk in our native language but they will appreciate or help if we try to learn their language and culture. It's our duty to respect the language culture and People where we are gaining from. We are not moguls or Britishers to impose our language or culture to other states. Let us be not stupids
A Bengali here....When I was studying in Delhi I had to share my room with a Bengali guy and a Bihari guy initially I had no problem speaking Hindi but when I used to talk with my Bengali guy in our language that Bihari guy used to get agitated and repeatedly told us "Yeh Bangladesh nhi hai Bengali bolna hai to Bangladesh chala jao yha rehna hai to sirf Hindi hi bolna padega" and this the reason why I hate speaking Hindi nowadays and yes I support these Kannadiga nationalists too these Hindi speakers are forcing their language on us which must be stopped.
I'm a Kanndiga speaking completely in Hindi staying in Punjab for the last 2 years, typing this very comment in English watching a japaneese anime.
I believe it's not all and always about patriotism, yes it's really important, but if your goal is long term, you would be automatically willing to learn multiple languages. It's not about who's right or who's wrong, it's about all the amazing quality people and content that now gets unlocked because you know those languages.
I'm now able to work with multiple brilliant people by speaking in hindi and strive to improve India as a whole.
Many of my friends have recommended me some of the most brilliant channels I've come across on TH-cam which are in hindi and unfortunately not in Kannada. It's more about accepting the amazing culture present in India and respect and atleast try to learn a little bit of the place you're living in, which in and of itself is a great experience.
I'm grateful for all the amazing Indians out there whom I'm able to meet and grow together with.
Thank you.
You moved to their land. you learned their language. you assimilated. that is good. that is how it should be. but do north indians reciprocate the same thing? nope. some do but most don't. The concept of national language is moronic. for thousands of years, our civilization has co-existed without any "national" language. "Hindi connects us all" is just north indian propaganda. Don't get me wrong. I ain't anti-hindi. I'm from the telugu land. we learn hindi in our schools here but it's so useless for us, we might as well scrap hindi from our syllabus and invest that money into something a lot more productive stuff like CS, financial studies or sports.
you wanna move to my land? cool, speak my language and assimilate but still hold on to your native culture. simple as that. most north indians do not understand this simple rule. especially the migrant workers who move to the south.
@@sarakamnani6328 yeah yeah keep saying that to yourself. First of all South Indian speak rudely to North Indians and force their language on North Indians, i am from Bihar but learnt Tamil when I lived in Andaman and Nicobar for 3 years, it wasn't necessary to learn Tamil because most of the people there were from Kerala, west Bengal and Tamil Nadu but still Tamil interested me the most. If you tell someone to learn a language because you are living in their state then it's rude, people will learn it by themselves if they feel the need it's not about respect or disrespect the main problem of you guys is your ego and superiority complex, throw it away and accept the outsiders first with open arms and help them learn rather than insulting them.
@@sarakamnani6328 Sure, it did hurt a lot when people asked me what state Karnataka is in and not knowing the beauty and the amazing culture we got down in south, but I wouldn't go as far as saying learning Hindi was useless, more like opened up more doors. Sure, most don't reciprocate as much as us, but it is what they are missing out and probably because most aren't open minded as I see here, just like a frog in a well ,and I won't lie saying its alright they don't speak the local language when down there. But, the central imposing Hindi and state imposing Kannada is where things get complicated for an average person. The individual is the one who should decide themselves respect and try to learn and enjoy and assimilate the process as you said. More individuals need to understand this that language is being used by the politics and they need to think for themselves, only then the country will progress in all places.
@@Shubham-hk6yfIts true that you pointed out that people will learn, and I've learnt Hindi of my own accord, but I do see a lot of people taking the southern states for granted and vice versa. I still don't understand this mindset of both places. The people I appreciate are the ones from north-eastern and I always cite them as examples as to how nicely they cope up with the whole language barrier despite being highly culturally diverse themselves.(At least those I've met are really nice and friendly).
@@eternalreverence7578 but you can't deny that some uneducated north Indians won't even try to learn any language that could communicate with people, they will only reply back to you in Hindi which I think is wrong. They should learn to communicate better
I am a Bengali... I have cleared CTET and cleared KVS written. But I got rejected in KVS interview just because I was unable to write Hindi in full speed dictation. My teaching ability and education faced failure just because I am a non Hindi speaking, non Hindi writing candidate. 😢😢
Tumko hindi n likh pane ki wajah se reject kar diya mujhe english n likh pane ki wajah se . Had chutiyapa hain desh me
Isliye hate hota hai south me
that's the problem
Language isn't just a tool of communication, language is part of culture and you already knew it. We can take every language as different cultures so any particular language cannot be national language of India and can't be the official language because India cannot have just one culture, India has different cultures in different parts as we all knew. Hindi speaking peoples are wrong here_ they're trying to destroy other people's cultures by try to make hindi the national language so that's why hindi speaking people receive this much hatred which they of course deserves. India is a concept and this concept isn't created just around hindi speaking people so India isn't private property of hindi speaking people. Any particular language can't be the official language and cannot be the national language period.
WTF !! It’s absurd. You know you’ll find many letters drafted by govt in Hindi in KVS. But they do have English too and these things are very trivial in comparison to teaching talent. These interview peeps reject candidates for stupid reasons. Try your luck in good missionary schools or private colleges. All the best.
ಕರ್ನಾಟಕಕ್ಕೆ ಬಂದು 15 & 2೦ ವರ್ಷ ಆದರೂ ಕನ್ನಡ ಕಲಿಯದವರನ್ನ ಏನು ಮಾಡಬೇಕು..
What exactly will they achieve by learning kannada ? Kannada call centre worker ?
@@shubhamsharma3333
I ask you the same question
What should we do after learning Hindi?
We sell Panipuri in Road side..?
What is the work of Hindi Prachara Samithi in South Indian States?..
Why central government is promoting Hindi language to non-Hindi speaking people all over India..? According to the constitution of India there are 22 official languages out of which Kannada is one.. Kannada is also national language of India.. The word Kannada itself is 5000 years old. Is it possible to compare Hindi,'s antiquity infront of Kannada?
@@shubhamsharma3333what will we in the south do by learning the fucked up third rate language Hindi.
Thika mele Maadi karada pudi hakabeku😂.. Aste macha...😂
@@gansubram4584 aarey smartass who's telling you to learn Hindi you better learn English it will help you.
Many students consider Sanskrit in school a scoring subject as it has vast grammar and many more things so thats why many students choose Sanskrit as a scoring subject when they elevate from class 10th standard to class 11th standard. So they learn Sanskrit to obtain marks not gain knowledge at all. Even many schools teach Sanskrit as a subject from class 5 or 6th standard to till class 8th standard and then when a student elevate to class 9 and 10th standard they select Sanskrit as an optional subject or additional one which is not compulsory. Even same things is going on in arts colleges as well where mostly students choose Sanskrit as an honours or general subject to score marks only not for knowledge. And it happens in university level too where a student choose Sanskrit in Masters degree just as a scoring knowledge and most of them dont apply this language anywhere what they have learnt. I would recommend to Indian education ministry to mandate Sanskrit in every Indian school from lower standard to senior higher secondary school classes to teach our students about our ancient language which is the mother of all languages in the world.
In Mumbai, where I've lived for over five years, I've been amazed by the kindness of the people. My Marathi friends would switch to Hindi when they saw my confusion, showing their consideration. Inspired by their beautiful hearts, I made a personal decision to learn their language. With lots of effort, I can now converse in Marathi and understand others, but my journey of learning this wonderful language continues. The more I delve into Marathi, the more I fall in love with its depth and beauty. While learning Python, Java and C-sharp, I learnt another Language not because it was imposed on me but because of sheer kindness.
That's why marathi is gone from mumbai and now it become hindi city.
Marathi is started degrading in Mumbai.
All Maharashtrian people without studying Hindi knows Hindi, even kids know Hindi in Maharashtra, and i think mumbai doesn't speak Marathi anymore only rest of the Maharashtra speaks Marathi, but yeah we know Hindi also
That's why Marathi is dying in there own state
Every outsider needs to know this.
I like this video you have point. I am from pune, Maharashtra and our local language is marathi. My colleagues are hindi speakers. My problem is my one colleague is been living in Maharashtra for 8 years and still speaks in hindi when i asked why you are not speaking in marathi they said all my friends are hindi here and i am like you are not trying to speak local language thats why you are not making marathi friends dude. Ok the other colleague is from delhi and recently moved to pune so i talked with them in hindi or english because i understand its tuff to quickly switch to new language. so my problem is if you are living more than 3 years in Maharashtra then atleast learn simple marathi. I am not expecting new person to speak marathi i can understand but this people don't even try to learn this amazing language and miss this beautiful culture. Feeling sad for them. At least we are not that extreme like south states. Jai Maharashtra 🚩🚩🚩
these north indians go everywhere and starts interfering in local politics . they deserve to be treated like that
JAI MAHARASHTRA
- baburao ganpatrao apte
And this motherfuckers South Indian they don't even use Hindi ....you see many professors are from south India speak in English.... They don't speak Hindi neither in Marathi ..
I'd such issue when I was in my medical College and i faced this issue...
We are not that extreme like South Indians that's why we are slowly losing our language in our own state 😢
@@p.limbunkar3077 No you are not. You are losing your language because you don't speak it. I am from Rajasthan and people sometimes say this about marwari. I always talk in marwari when the other person knows it too. I speak hindi with those who don't know marwari. The problem starts when you start speaking hindi with people who know your local language.
Thank you for this video,
I am staying in Karnataka Bangalore from last 10 years and I am an bangali guy.
I faced many times issue with the Karnataka people about the language. Not everyone there is some people who forcefully ask to speak kannada.
I am a Kannadiga, I have lived in Bengaluru for over 40 years and I have seen the city grow. What's important is to be respectful of each other cultures, what has happened over the years is people from outside of Karnataka who have lived in Bengaluru for many many years, like more than 20 years have not learnt any Kannada and I know many of my school friends who have lived here even after so many years don't even try to speak Kannada, Instead they try to show their superiority lecture, this is not just about Hindi, this is about everyone who comes here, part of the problem is we Kannadiga's try to help them by talking in their language when they come here and that makes the person lazy. Of course nobody expects anybody to learn a language if you are coming in and going out but if you are staying in Karnataka for more than 10 years and you don't even try to speak because you are lazy or it is not so convenient for you it is a sort of disrespect for the local culture and the people. And the we believe in "Athiti devo bhava" and the reason why we speak in other's language when they come here to accommodate them to make them feel comfortable, but after many years, if the Athiti does not even try to speak broken kannada, it shows superiority complex on the Athiti's part. Unfortunately all societies only pickup the negative's first leaving out all the positives. The fact of the matter is you go and ask any Non-Kannadiga they will say they can live in Bangalore without speaking any kannada which says we are very accommodative, but unfortunately non-Kannadiga's who have lived in Bengaluru for a very long time(10 years) are setting a very wrong examples by not learning Kannada or not speaking kannada in public.
আমি বাঙালী, বাংলায় কথা বলি. কিন্তু হিন্দি আর ইংরেজী বলতে আর পড়তে পারি. কত জন অবাঙালী এখানে এটা পরে বুঝতে পারলে বোলো. অনেক কথার জবাব এটাতে পেয়ে যাবে। 👍
Bujhbena konodin ora
Dada ekhane english e likhlei cholto
Sathik .
हिन्दी , বাংলা , 中國人 ,
Full stop এর জায়গায় দাড়ি ব্যবহার করুন।
Ami nonbengali yadyapi Ami bujhte paarchhi
Sorry for this kachra , I'm not so good at Bengali
Hindi has been forced upon us, and we are not considered "Indian" if we don't know Hindi.
So we need a separate country
It will not happen bro..no one imposing it people are saying to connect with others know Hindi ..but you don't like it then don't do it...
Ok Maan le tum 5 state ko seperate country de diya. Uske baad bhi to tum sabki ek language aaj tak nakki nahi hui hai. To kya 5 alag alag country banaoge chhotu chhotu se 😂😂 And what abt your Armies ? Tumhare south India se army me kitne log bharti hote hai zara batana? North India ke jawan pure desh ki raksha krte hai.
@@sabnishshrivastava9127True😂
I am a bihari my regional language is bhojpuri, i spent 4 years in maharastra, they never forced me to learn marathi & i never learnt that because i never felt the necessity to learn it. When i spoke in hindi they also spoke hindi inspite their hindi is not that good but still they talk to you in hindi, this language bs only exists in southern states specially in Tamilnadu because they feel they're superior & that's the reality. Before speaking anything else keep this in mind every northern states have their own regional language but they don't do bs like this
So as a token of gesture and respect, why didn't you learn Marathi? You slept, ate and shat in Maharashtra for 4 years, used the opportunity which would have gone to a Marathi local. And you still have the nerve to say "See, I didn't learn their language, but made use of an opportunity which my state didn't have and for that I am a bastard without gratitude."
Bihar aur Bihari pure Desh me ab ek majak ban ke reh gaye hai 😂
According to me sanskrit should be made the national language as i think almost all languages in india are based on sanskrit so a lot of words will be common and it will be easier to learn and its a very systematic language
tamil will oppose it, some NE states will oppose it and it will be opposed by left
bro hardly some ppl speak sanskrit it should be preserved but cant be made national language
Agree with you, why nobody complains about English imposition?
Lol you think people in North east gives a damn about Sanskrit?
it's a language of pandits
@@nsggaming7096 until india becomes a 10 tn dollar economy then the left cant influence us long way to go
My friends from north and south were debating this very point in my hostel mess today. They were getting quite aggressive. I stay quiet in these kind of emotional discussions. They eventually asked me my opinion and I said loudly Bharat tere tukde honge inshaallah inshaallah. Sab chup ho gaye 😂😂😂😂
Jab yesi naubat ayegi tabh hi sab ke sab sudhrenge
Exactly. People don't realize tukde doesn't just mean balkanization of a country.
It also means communities that used to live in harmony with each other becoming hateful towards each other.
That's what Indians are doing to themselves.
Indians have lived together, moved across regions and traded with each other for millennia despite language barriers.
All of a sudden, learning another language is being seen negatively. And the regional politics makes this worse across the country!
Bro itna bhi sach nhi bolna tha 😂
🤣🤣
average muslim 😂 😂
Good one… but as Kannadiga just want to put my view and reality of Bangalore.
What Kannada organisations are doing is not right and there is no doubt about it but you should have also talked about why it’s been serious from few years now. Migration to Bangalore was started almost 20 years back people from all over India live in Bangalore today. But for years Kannadigas faced ill-informed and disrespectful individuals all the time, who literally made jokes on culture language and tried to show Bangalore is there bcz we are here. Recently one of the famous actor passed away and full of Karnataka was in shock some useless people made unacceptable comments. When these things starts happening in regularly the back clash is inevitable. My request is simple you don’t wanna learn our language it’s fine but be respectful that’s all.
In Karnataka Kannada is national language not other languages I am kannadiga in 3500 years but I am Indian in just 75 years I am proud to be an i am kannadiga jai karnataka
tere se jal kon raha h ke tu kannada h jo tujhe proud ho raha h
😂😂 Karnataka comes under Bharat ( India) or Karnataka name given by government because people who speak kannada are karanatakas..what will you do if you need to connect a Delhi man..how you will communicate with him because your Karnataka is not Europe ..and ya also Bangalore is banglore because of North people company.
@@BULLoorBEAR Bangalore has been developed mainly due to Kannadigas and quite a Tamils Telugus. North Indians came to Bangalore only after 2010's. By that time, Bangalore was already developed (developing stage).. South Indians formed 93% (55% Kannadigas, 15% Tamils, 14% Telugus, 4% Malayalee) of Bangalore. North Indians form only 2%.. Majority of North Indians are workers in Bangalore not owners. So much of blabbering factless comments.
@@studyhard-tl4bx who developed it does your Karnataka government bring big multinational company to banglore...
@@BULLoorBEAR Partially correct. Yes government has its contribution. Also because of the people. Its because of Kannadigas its developed. But you are blatantly claiming that because of nis it is developed which is absolute crap.
I am from Maharashtra & have learned German willingly, now I can see the benefits of it here in Germany.
Good bro.!
You should know the local language of the natives. It is one of the basic things.!
Illiterates won't get the point... They just need reasons to be ignorant..
But can't even no any of the south language. Because German gives some benefits to you. The same way we learn English it's gives benefits to us. Hindi is zero
@@naga143add If I ever move to Southern part of India, I would love to learn the local language 😉
Hindi is waste for us
As a Bihari, I know English,Hindi, Maithili, Bengali and Marwari just because I have grownup with these languages around me.. thanx to all my friends..
Kannadigas dont hate hindi.. but we hate people who disrespect kannadigas by not even trying to reciprocate the courtesy kannadadigas show by talking to Hindi people in Hindi..all we expect is if you are staying in Karnataka for more than 1 year yoy atleast need to make an effort to talk in local language..
Kannada is not local language. Kannada is regional language.
Wts your oroblem
I Speak In Bhojpuri ( Witch Is Not Hindi )
But I Will Promote Hindi Language Couse It's Help Me To Connecte Me With Other Indian's | 🙏🚩🚩
Bhojpuri is not a language it's a boli.
@@priyanshuk1330 Witch Is Mentioned ✌️
Other Hindi speakers*
I can't speak Hindi bro
@நேதாஜி Netaji it's ok bro as long as you are Indian we are brothers from another mothers
Open Letter, you covered a whole lot of great points. Well done.
If people fall for political posturing of a language supremacy, the country will disintegrate by civil war. This is a dangerous trend.
I am out of india for close to five decades and while i was born in non Hindi speaking family, i can fully converse even now in hindi and can read/write as well. But i should not be compelled to speak Hindi only - despite the fact that I really love Hindi.
I would just close by saying that perhaps English should be kept as common language for commerce and government business and then people can converse in any language they want. From what I understand, India has either highest or second highest English speaking populous and its still a world common language. Loose the mindset that it makes us slave.
Other than that, the sign language 😅😅, this way the whole country can communicate and it will be a whole lot peaceful.
Love and best wishes from the USA 🙏🙏
English is a colonial language and that’s a fact.
so you want hindi nationalism instead of indian nationalism
Very good analysis bhai. I believe everyone should try to learn at least basics (numbers, you, am i etc) of the language, where you are staying.
When I came to Bangalore, I learned Kannada and then Tamil, office guys get so happy when I speak their language ☺ but still not much mingling 🥲
When I changed my company, I worked with mostly Tamil guys, not a single North Indian but I spoke English or Tamil most of time, great!!
They will call me for lunch and stuff.
After few weeks they come to know I am actually North Indian 😁 and they were impressed 🥰
But then I am not called for lunch anymore😂
Y dis Kolaveri? 😅 Now I don't give a fuuck! 🤣🤣
There is just a innate hate I believe they grow up with against North Indians and it is not language issue at all!!
Just like Pakistanis grow up hating Indians, Marathis and Delhites and ROI grow up hating Biharis, it is just the same😂😂
Oh yeah! just see them in front of a foriegner though, all self respect goes to dustbin 🤣🤣
Yr last line killed it bero😂
u r right...they never mingle with North indians...i too had a south indian roommate...he always used to keep MUM... although we never had a fight he was cooperative but whenever he got some southie...then his happiness used to be on next level...
same i think but they discriminate like crazy , itna hate kyu . mai japan rhelunga lekin tamil nadu nahi rahunga . atleast will not feel sad that our own people
I don't know whom you met man, but having a learning attitude in life important.
I hope none gets aliennated, this feels bad dude
@@marudhupandian1689 Don't feel bad, I don't give a fuuck anymore about respecting South Indians or their culture anymore, its a facade. I also fired bunch of them after some months 🤣
Just to showcase their hate they bring this culture and language topic up. I had so much respect for their culture, how they celebrated every single of their festivals in companies and metro life, it was eye opening for me but then I came to see their true nature and their discriminating behaviour.
because you all force it on us
We Indians need to be more loving and respectful of each other!! Guys Let's not get petty with language, region etc Spread more Love 💕,☮️🇮🇳💝❤️
10:00 'Land ki apni koi language nhi hoti bhai, language use krte hai waha ke insaan'
Nailed it! Only if more people would understand this, i bet more than half of such conflicts would automatically be resolved
Why are you Lalas, Baniyas, Pandits and Thakurs of North India opposed to English,then ?
Tbh land ki language ke upar anti British poem bani thi
@@rishavkumar1250 First of all, nobody is inherently 'opposed' to english, we just oppose it's imposition over our mother tongue, because it serves as an unpleasant reminder of a colonial hangover.
Secondly, it's not just prevalent in North India
@@rishavkumar1250 british used that language to enslave us.
@@rishavkumar1250 bcs English enslaved us
I'm from West Bengal and there are many people here in my city who are either from Bihar, Jharkhand or UP many came in West Bengal just 1-2 yrs back and many are staying here for more than 10 yrs. Mostly the ones who are staying here for more than 10yrs know bengali well, obviously not like a native one but you can easily communicate with them. But the ones who came here recently don't know bengali so we talk with them in hindi as we both can understand it and we know they will slowly slowly learn bengali as we have seen other non-bengalis slowly slowly learning Bengali in a span of 5-10 yrs,in west bengal hindi is taught as 3rd language in many schools and there have been no protests against it. I personally think no language should be imposed on anyone whether its hindi,tamil, kannada or bengali. But if you move to some different state then it's beneficial for you yourself to learn that language in a span of few years. For that the locals should co-operate and also the one who newly shifted. Like the locals should not say we won't help you if you don't know our language and the new one should also be in a learning mode and try to learn the native language of that state from the locals.
Hindi also Indo-European language, only south languages pure indian languages
As a Assamese i understand hindi but difficult to talk. Here in Assam hindi speaking people's are easily understand assamese between 5-6 months. And you know hindi or english ( not mendatory proper hindi Or english) then you survive in anywhere of Northeast India.
Mainland indian peoples teach other foreign languages as elective subject, But they really need to teach Assamese as elective subject. It's an easy language.
I am an Assamese staying at Bangalore for the last 1 year and now I came to know why Assamese language will be replaced by Bengali or Hindi language
@@udbhashjyotinath2482 It's hard to replace assamese by other language in Assam. But what do you want to talk about? I didn't understand.
( And you are assamese studying in bangalore , or you are an assamese studying in bangalore . I didn't understand)
@@sudarshanbora9865 I am an Assamese currently studying at Bengaluru. I mentioned it coz I saw how still kannada language is hugely spoken in the entire state of Karnataka. I mean to say that soon Assamese language will get replaced by Hindi or Bengali language as Assamese people donot put a lot of efforts to save our language as compared to South Indians. If you believe that it's hard to get replace, pls visit places like Lumding, Hojai etc (At Brahmaputra valley itself) . Also, we can see hindi monopoly at many areas of GHY like Maligaon, Jalukbari, Fancy Bazar etc.
@@udbhashjyotinath2482 U can speak in Assamaese in thos areas...ppl will still understand...so how i assmese getting replaced? Just because they know one more language vaguely doesnt mean original native language is getting destroyed.
To give another example, nearly all gujaratis understand hindi.....but does that mean gujarati is dying?? If anything I see gujarati being understood more by hindi speakers.
@@udbhashjyotinath2482 I am from upper Assam. So i have less knowledge about South Assam, lower Assam.But I heard in Silchar area ppl mainly bengali speaking, And few lower Assam dist also. In guwahati hindi is more speaking because here native assamese ppl is less then other ppls like bihari, maruwais etc.
I Agree with you kannada ppl is more afford to protect their language ,& easy to protect because karnataka is less diverse then Assam ( southern states have no illegal Bangladeshi immigrants issue like Assam) .But In assam some districts of South & lower Assam, Guwahati & other town areas ppl are not speak assamese, it's not means that assamese is in danger. We all majority of upper assamese ppl (ahom, shutia, kchari, kuch, motok, missing etc like native ppls) are hardly protect our assamese language . Jai ai axom.
Mein Bengal Se Hoon & Local Se Bengali Mai Baat Karta Hoon & Non Bengali Logon Se Hindi Mai Baat Karta Hoon.
I Love My India 🇮🇳
Bahut acha...mein nepali hoon nepali logo k saath nepali mein baat karta hoon or non nepali logo k saath hindi mein baat krta hoon.. i repect hindi language i proud to be nepali jay hindi jay baharat
@@laxmanmagar7849 Thank You Brother
Problem is not learning Kannada or Tamil. Problem is once you learn Kannada or Tamil, they will start segragating you based upon your accent, then something else and then something else. Problem is that they feel they are superior to outsiders. And there is no solution to it.
Why can't someone learn basic language of a area where they want to stay for long.... Just like someone goes to foreign country and learn their language
u know whats funny even south india has many languages (malayalam, tamil ,telugu, etc) but they all have no problem with each other LOL no one is forcing a tamilian to speak kannada or telugu . see thats unity . (just wanted to share something which i have noticed)
Tamil has highest migration than hindi people. But they learn kannada.
Kannada majority
Tamil
Telugu
Malayali
And then hindi
Only hindi people have problems
Exactly. It's because we mutually learn each other's languages. Ppl in Karnataka tend to know many languages like Telugu Tamil but everyone together hold kannada at a higher regard because we live in their land. They respect us by talking to us in Telugu or Tamil if we are new but no one takes that for granted. Others also learn kannada and make sure to promote that language even if it isn't their own
They do have problems and they can't speak with each others, few educated ones use english in that case, how is making a case of hindi difficult along the same lines?
@@rickycool6083 No we don't, it's mostly Hindi speaker that expects everyone else to speak Hindi, In south states most prefer English to Hindi if we have to communicate in different state except few minority
You lemurs fight with each other on basis of language.