When I was in Middle School, my teacher offered extra credit to whoever could name a country starting with the letter "G". I had watched the news the night before about Russia invading a country called Georgia so I named Georgia as my answer for my extra credit attempt. My teacher thought I was talking about an American state that happened to also have the name Georgia. She told me, "just because they talk with an accent doesn't mean they are a different country." I did not get credit.
@@Apbricksquadcuh I fixed my big finger typos. That doesn't change the truth of what I said. Truth is objective and is not contingent on the TH-cam software accepting my attempted corrections before posting.
@@castorcarvi It is not asking them to declare sources, but label themselves as foreign government funded. It didnt say 20% from foreign government, but foreign sources. Like if someone in georgia makes a video and it goes viral on youtube, that doesnt make them foreign funded, even if youtube is american. It is a terrible law, and im sure you would be unhappy if everytiktoker has to label themselves as funded by the chinese government.
@@castorcarvi because we(im georgian) don't trust government. talks that our government is pro russian is not new and we see what happened to Russia with this law(small adjustment after small adjustment and now people who "pursuing the interest of foreign power" can't do anything) they ALREADY did adjustments, at first this law was not suppose to affect individual persons, only NGOs but now it affects them too. TLDR the law would be good IF government was good but its not.
@@castorcarvi The US and most western countries have this law. Other foreign lobbying groups in the US have to register as foreign entities including Taiwan, Venezuelan opposition party, South Korea and other countries which control the congress. AIPAC is in a unique position where most the donors listed are Americans (who probably get their money from Israel). But AIPAC is so powerful that anyone who criticises the way they operate gets ousted.
@@castorcarvi Look how it's been used in Russia. The ruling party has carteblanche to be prejudice towards companies who have International investment. It's just an authoritarian form of control that stifles economic growth.
Aphxazians are related circassians?😂 Please don’t ever try educational content about Georgian ethnical groups,this videos provokes our political sovereignty and causing a lot of gap between us. Apkhazians are Georgian native ethnical group,not Apsuas,they aren’t not even close with our homeland,Apsuas with Russians has occupied our territory. Long Live Georgia 🇬🇪
I mean, linguistically the language is related to "Circassian" languages. It does not matter if it offends your political sensibilities, these are just linguistic and anthropological observations.
I was in Georgia back in March. At some of the restaurants in the country, the receipts have a "fun fact" letter that says "Russia controls 20% of Georgia's territory".
@@alexandernico8930 because: 1) Abkazia is unoffical russian territory and they can't win a war against russia. 2) It's not only Abkhazia and SouthOssetia that is occupied by Russia its also their own Goverment. Goverment controles the army which means they won't take it back.
@@Sp4nX383 Besides, an armed resolution would likely end in ethnic violence/cleansing, and many both in the UN and the West wouldn't look at that with good eyes; and with its proximity to Russia, Georgia NEEDS to be seen with good eyes if they want diplomatic/military support
Very interesting and not good for the Russians at all. It most certainly will be built now and Russia wont be able to do anything about it. Invading to stop it would piss off the Chinese even more and as of today, Russia is basicly a puppet of China. Russia needs China alot more than the other way araound. I think that China right now is just trying to build up as much leverage as possible against both West but mostly against Russia for the future. There are so many underlying conflicts brewing in the background between China and Russia.
The Chinese have a long history in genuinely helping build up infrastructure in Georgia so I agree with this decision. The grandiose Rikoti automagistral project is mostly done by them too, it would've otherwise taken decades to complete, but it's nearing completion.
If I had a dollar every time a Western-leaning country on Russia's border had two seperate Russian-back seperatist states appear shortly before a Russian invasion, I'd have 2 dollars. Which isn't a lot, but we really should have seen it coming after the first dollar
2 in Georgia, 2 in Ukraine in 2014, 1 in Moldova. That's 5 right there. We can find more groups of Russian speakers around the world to allow Russia to rescue and extend its borders. It has been doing this for 500 years so it has practiced...
The problem here is the western meddeling that somehow always there. I still remember the Georgian president realizing on video that the US wont support him anymore. HE started eatign his tie.
@@joythought > We can find more groups of Russian speakers around the world to allow Russia to rescue and extend its borders Examples in Europe would be Latvia and Estonia.
Just wanted to say that while Saakashvili did lose the 2012 presidential election, he did not lose to Ivanishvili. Giorgi Margvelashvili won the Georgian presidential election and remained president until 2018 as an independent--though as a part of the Georgian Dream coalition--but slowly became more critical of the Georgian Dream's consolidation of power and ultimately did not seek re-election. Ivanishvili became the Prime Minister of Georgia in 2012, not president. Doesn't change the fact that the Georgian Dream party controls, but there is a slight error in elected positions here.
@@RUTHLESSambition5 Certain Americans are easy to fool, this is an obvious move towards neutrality. Which the US deep state was salty about enough in Ukraine to kick off the current fiasco there.
as a Georgian, Apolitical nature of population is the scariest thing ever to happen to country. 2 things that happened in Georgia during protests: 1) MFA operators would use foreign numbers to call people who took part in protests and start swearing at them threatning to rape their parents and asking why are they taking action in anti-govermental protests. 2) MFA created Database which as they say: will contain data about people who support "war" in country. (According to govermnet you support war if you are not Apolitical)
Must be f***** being neighbor to Russia… Having to be scared of war like it’s the middle ages. How some countries like India can justify this behavior insane to me.
Having Russia as a neighbor must feel scary. Always a chance of getting into a war like it’s the middle ages. How people justify their behavior is insane to me
"According to the last census conducted in Soviet Georgia in 1989, the population of Abkhazia totaled about 525,000 people. As for the ethnic composition, the largest groups were Georgians (239,872 people - 45.7% of the population), Abkhazians (93,267 people - 17.7%), Armenians (76,541 people - 14.6%) and Russians (74,913 people - 14.3%)" The ethic map in 8th minute is kinda misleading. You mention the correct numbers shortly after though. Nice video overall.
Russia is an extremely strong and influential country so it can annex lands if they want. Otherwise what you gonna do, to fight a huge nuclear superpower?
@@Maxhartmann2024 There would not be independent Finland if you'd never fight against overpowered enemy. But let us hope we don't have to fight again. Hello from Finland! We are glad to have friends within EU and NATO!
@@Mrvanish93 the only reason why Soviets didn’t invade Finland once again (after 1945) is a special treaty which was pretty beneficial for Kremlin. It doesn’t mean that USSR wasn’t able to, despite the disastrous loses during winter war. Glad that you guys have allies, though Russia has no more interests in Finland.
It's not about publishing it's about suppressing them. If it was about publishing nobody would have any problems. If you want more info look for attacks on opposition already taking place. Masked things used
I know right really question Russia and west intention aren’t pure and lair want just control. How does open media threat western value simple money. I truly believe Address climate change majority modern geopolitics tension or warfare. Also fuck up moment west and Russia doing “peacekeeper” through violence is most dystopian shit I ever heard.
In theory yes, the problem is the reality of how that bill is designed and how it can be used to suppres information. All you have to do is go look at the Russian law it was cloned from.
@@libraryofpangea7018 could be. All I’m thinking is it would be a really nice thing to know when you ready news as to who funded the paper that wrote it. Or the journalists. Maybe if it were all I. The open people could judge better what the bias is
Hi! A Latvian here. I distinctly remember the 2008 Russian invasion in Georgia - and how fast it was all over. And how only countries that had firsthand experience with Russia's aggression and never dying imperialism were in a loud uproar about it. And I distinctly remember, just having walked out of my parents apartment, heading to the public transport stop, in school, 15 years of age, and thinking - oh. Oh what is my family gonna do when/if Russia invades Latvia again? Oh we would have to get all of our grandparents. Oh good thing my mom's grandparents have a car, and my dad's car is so big. Oh, but maybe we should also pick up some of my friends too. You know. Normal thoughts to have as a fifteen year old. This is why there is this unbridgable gap between most people in the world and the people that have grown up in the old and ongoing, wealthy and always safe empires. If you know how it is, to be afraid of your country's sovereignty, than you know. If you have never felt that fear... you have no idea.
@@impieux are you a fucking moron? Growing up in the fear of very realistic war that could end your country is a normal thing to have as a kid? As a Georgian I relate to this comment so much and how people from America or other countries without war on their land just can't comprehend the terror
Hey, I'm against censorship but I'm still confused about something. Is it easy to get info about who's funding NGOs, companies and politicians there? Because it isn't easy here.
@@johncrocker4209 For the public, it's so-so. Large NGOs usually declare their sources of funding on their websites. However, for the government, it's 100% clear, as such entities are legally obliged to share their full financial statements annually with tax authorities. The Foreign Agent Law (renamed as the Foreign Transparency Law) is primarily to label individuals working in such fields as agents. More importantly, it gives the government the authority to forcibly shut down their activities for six months based on an anonymous tip under the name of investigation. Additionally, if NGOs have any databases of citizens, these become accessible to the government and can potentially be misused. The second law, which wasn't mentioned in the video, is the Offshore Law. This law significantly reduces transfer taxes and eases inspections on funds from offshore accounts. It is intended to benefit Ivanishvili and other Russian oligarchs who are under sanctions, facilitating money laundering activities here.
How about not be anti-Russian and living in peace with Russia, is that too hard to do? It seems to be, as you obviously didn't learn from the Ukraine example with waving the Ukrainian flag.
@@porkerpete7722 He usually is against Russia based on my viewing. I don't know that that counts as a mouthpiece unless they mean to undermine themselves.
US has the same law since 1938 the Foreign Agents Registration Act, it even targets individuals and not only NGO and EU is in process of implementing it as well, in fact they are so far into it they already started gathering information on members of EU parliament about non-EU funds. But its Russian law and Georgia will have problems joining EU because of it.... ROFL!
Nice. Will was see a video on Moldova too? There's a lot to talk about. Unionism with Romania, Transnistria and how it is in the weakest bargaining position ever, Kremlin destabilising measures, Gagauzia. I think there's a lot to talk about.
Was Moldova recently banning all of its TV channels which used to feature the opposing party, also Kremlin's doing? 😂 Nah, Moldova perfectly handles destabilisation on its own.
Because in 2017 russia used this bill to suppress opposition. This bill in georgia can also be used like that. Anyone who has a foreign band is funded from a foreign country loses some rights. Its is not a good law in the hands of corrupt politicians. Nobody wants this fkn law
Because the people who they are working for or getting most of their money from is not from the people they are protesting against most NGOs are highly likely funded by the EU and the US as we see these people protesting ha
It does. The trick is, how they use it. A similar bill was passed here in Hungary, opposition media outlets, NGO-s (and maybe the CEU too, im not sure) came under constant harrassment and intimidation shortly after by governmental organisations. Im not against fair and square financial audits, but there is a clear abuse to silence opposing voices in the country to this day. And the law is written vaguely enough to allow such bullying. Maybe the situation is similar in Georgia.
I am missing the Turkish perspective. Turkey today is an ambitious geopolitical player and a formidable rival to Russia in the Black Sea and the Middle East. AND Turkey shares Georgia's interests in a save oil and gas corridor, and also would very much prefer Russia tonot control the Turkish-Georgian border. Turkey in 2008 is probably a lot more assertive of its political, military and economic weight than it was in 2008. So how would (might) Turkey react to yet another Russian incursion into - and effective strategic control of - Georgia?
Gamarjoba! I'm from Ukraine and I'm wondering If you really prefer when your country's called Sakartvelo instead of Georgia? I heard it from ukrainians, but I don't have any friends from Georgia to confirm it. I would love to know more about it
Kinda weird that a bill to show foreign influence in media would be called "the Russian bill". Won't that affect Russia too? Seems like it'll only affect the people who control the media
Selective enforcement. Of course it would effect the party in power, but of course people allied with that party will just ignore the law and not face consequences. It also serves as a tool to simply get insight into everybody finances. Oh you do something and you don't want to tell use all your internal information. Must be foreign terrorists then.
It will affect those that go against the government. 'Media' includes posting comments on TH-cam and any newspaper or tv-station that isn't already controlled by government would have to be very concerned about who they got their advertisements from.
Yeah I didn’t know any of this was happening until the protests broke out. I was under the assumption that Georgias government would be supportive of Ukraine for obvious reasons. 🤦🏾♂️
It won't, at least in Western media. Georgian was being used and abandoned by NATO in 2008, now some native Georgian still believe they can join EU someday, It will never happen.
@@孙愉悦 they want to join nato to be safe from Russia. They've been trying that for hundreds of years and they know that eu doesnt care THAT much but we're desperate here. If only we were neighbors with another freaking normal country who doesn't have a tyrant hell bent on invading lands.
Imagine how wealthy and stable Russia could be if they just got along with their neighbours and invested all their money, time and effort into building the nation.
@@paztwel lmao no it is NOT what russia is trying to do, russia chose this path or rather putin, this is just a way for putin to keep power all to himself
thanks for this video that at lest give some light about why me and so many other families leave Abkhazia to save their lives and lost all of their homes and belongings when the Abkhazia/Georgia war started, At 1990 i was 4 year's old and one day i was playing on the balcony then i see and hear a helicopters and soldiers with tanks comming and start the killings, So after 1 hour my mother just take me and a backpack and little money that se manage to find at lest for the food for the journey to greece, I dont even know how she managed all that i only know and remmember that we run at night and was hiding in forests and brushes and we was 2 or 3 days in a small boat-ship with many more peole and earplanes bombing and shouting at us with bad sea and stormy night, I never see again my father, He was at work the day my mother take me and we run he say to my mom you take the kid and go gracce to some family we have ther and i will try come later, Il will find you, many years later when i was 15 my mother tell me that he was killed one week latter, I dont know about russia or georgia i only know that all my life change before even started we lost every thing from this war, money home car papers belongings people we love my very first friends from pre school and neighborhood every thing, And many they're lives people that don't do anything to no one that don't want war but a good life and peaceful one, Am almost 40 years old now and i still have not manage even to visit Abkhazia after all that year's, I really hate them all.
Nah, Russia did pulverise Georgia, twice. And the latter lost Abkhazia and South Ossetia as a result. Their only hope was for NATO to help them, which wasn't existing when the invasion happened.
Drones,,,,, how easy to counter tanks and infantry with drones. Russia didn't pay attention to the Azerbaijan & Armenians. It took Ukraine decimating Russia's military before the Kremlin finally paid attention and still not well focused.
@Sigma_Male_Anti_Female "officially" aka in georgian dreams only. All bark no bite. Like Armenia dreaming of Karabakh or Ukraine dreaming of Crimea or Donetsk.
It’s funny about the law on foreign agents and the values of the West and the EU. The law has been in the USA since 1938, and the same laws have been adopted in Great Britain, Australia, and so on... But we will be most interested in France. An EU country that adopted exactly the same law in 2024, and right this year, and the French law also implies criminal sentences. But the President of Georgia, a French citizen and former employee of the French Foreign Ministry, calls the Georgian law pro-Putin. =) I even do not know why. Maybe because Georgian law does not imply criminal prosecution, or maybe because, unlike Western ones, they do not prosecute individuals, but only legal ones, and the fines there are 10 times less than in French. I just want to ask why EU laws are democratic, but when candidates for the EU want to adopt them, then this is the path to dictatorship? =) And another interesting thing is that for the 3.7 million population of Georgia there are now 25 thousand different NGOs, the same ones that now brought people to the streets =) Just think about it, now in Georgia for every 148 people, from babies to the very old, there is one legal organization funded from abroad. Not a person, but an organization, a legal entity. Is this good or bad?
Потому что сами эти страны думать не умеют , за них это делают западные СМИ. Хороший пример , для ребенка, что бы показать к чему приводит невежество и не умение думать своей головой.
Russia has shown that the CSTO ia just there so that other countries help Russia not the other way round. Once Azerbaijan invaded parts of Armenia, Armenia tried to acrivate article 6 (mutual protection), Russia refused.
so Armenia itself recognized that it occupied territories from Azerbaijan when it joined the CSTO. In your opinion, we should fight with our ally for territories that even the occupier recognized as occupied
@@kutuzovmikhailillarionovic2120 In 2021 and 2022, Azerbaijan invaded Armenia's sovereign territory, bombed Armenian cities, and occupied approximately 250 square kilometers of territory (which it still holds). Russia did nothing.
Why Armenia didn't find then? Did it want Russia to protect it from another Russia's ally? Also, why did Pashinyan recognise Nagorno-Karabakh as Azerbaijan territories?
Russia and Georgia are adopting a law on controlling foreign influence. The West: this is undemocratic, a restriction on freedom of speech and press censorship. Also, the USA: They were the very first in the world to adopt this law in 1938 and actively use it to this day, censoring all foreign media, including European ones. This is considered democratic. In simple terms, an independent country will never allow itself to be influenced even by a friendly country because it is INDEPENDENT. Now look at the EU countries, which claim that such a law is not needed, and at the USA, which has this law. Who among them is independent and the master, and who is a servant actively promoting foreign influence in their country.
we have a similar law in the USA Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA): “The Foreign Agents Registration Act provides the public with an opportunity to be informed of the identity of persons engaging in political activities on behalf of foreign governments, foreign political parties and other foreign principals, so that their activities can be evaluated in light of their associations.”
@@andrewsprague4566@andrewsprague4566 I don't get this: what's wrong with disclosure? Isn't that what you'd want in a democracy? Transparency and knowing exactly who you're dealing with, what their motives are. If we, as the American Government, are Financing your organization, we would want the public to know that this stands for the United States' freedom and democracy: Agents of foreign principals who are not otherwise exempt must comply with FARA's registration requirements, disclosure requirements, and record-keeping requirements. Covered entities must file a registration statement with the DOJ within 10 days of becoming an agent of a foreign principal.Mar 9, 2023
@@andrewsprague4566 The only time you want to be sneaky and hide things is when you are up to no good, as the United States we are the good guys we should have no reason to want to work in the shadows
@@gunnar2300 beyond Russia's selective enforcement there is a different between a government registering you and a government shoving a very specific set of words in your mouth every time you open it, and throwing you in jail if you miss a punctuation mark.
@@andrewsprague4566 TH-cam does it, too. If a channel is funded by any government, then it is written under every single video that the channel uploads.
The “Soviet Government” that incorporated Abkhazia and S Ossetia into Georgia was in fact one man - Joseph Stalin, himself a Georgian from Gori. Stalin did this in other Soviet republics as well in order to dilute the ethnic majority and prevent separatist movements from emerging. S Ossetians and Georgians didn’t just “start fighting” in 2008. Saakashvilli ordered troops to forcibly seize the territory and launched a surprise attack, killing several Russian peacekeepers (there with a UN mandate) in the process. These are just a few of the small details that were omitted here, but such omissions matter. The most salient one is the fact that the Georgian law in question is modeled on a similar U.S. law that has been on the books for decades.
That is of course AFTER two Georgian peacekeepers were killed by the EID and repeated shellings of Geo villages and the head of peacekeeping mission kulakhmetov, who was BTW russian declaring that he lost control over situation on the ground. Yes, ommissions do matter
For the people that are arguing that i.e. the US has a similar law. there are major key differences: 1. FARA deals with lobbying, lobbying is illegal in Georgia 2. FARA requires companies to register on the basis of activity and political involvement, also some types (educational, free media) are not required to register. The Georgian law requires any ngo to register just on the basis of funding, when more than 20% of their funding comes from a foreign source, regardless of intent, activity, or any type of political involvement and labels them as "conductors of foreign influence". this term can be used in a very negative way as propaganda against, i.e. western organizations that are overlooking the legitimacy of our elections, a job with which we don't trust our own government. 3. The Georgian law on transparency gives the active government, legal incentive to spy on ngos that dont even fit the criteria of the law. For example, lets say an organization recieves funding 50% locally and 50% from another country (which do not fit the criteria of the transparency law, which states that more than 20% of funding should come from foreign source), the government, on the basis of mere suspicion that they fit the criteria but did not register willingly (we know how this goes), can spy, disrupt work, extract personal information from people associated with said organization, which may not even be influenced by foreign powers and just be critical of the active government. in summary, this is a tool to be used against oppositional rhetoric and media. and the important part here is that, we know generally governments do spy on the population but it isn't legally supported and cant be used against them in court. however, in this instance, since there is a law that gives the legal incentive, all kinds of information that is obtained in said way could be used against you, which is just atrocious in every way. 4. The US has (atlest in comparison) an independent and just judicial system, with which you are able to prove your truth in the case of being wrongly labeled as a foreign agent. In georgia however, historically and presently, we deal with heavily corrupt courts, and the supreme prosecutor is appointed, solely by the active political party, without any resistance as they hold the majority of the seats in the parliament. so such a law which in the hands of the government, holds such damaging capabilities against free speech and democracy, against the Georgian people, should in no way be active in the country, until said fundamental systemic problems are resolved, which have been eating away at us for the last 3 decades. these are only some of the reasons, there is much more, especially in the context of our country and froeign relations, hopefully i shed the light on the situation.
Great explanation. Thanks. I would like it if all sources declared where their funding comes from, independent of reason. Like Nutrition Facts and Ingredients lists on food. The other things you mentioned are not so good.
American law also requires you to inform about what you're doing, what's your relationship with X country and yadayadayada if you're a foreign agent on your own. "Checking" if it's the truth by a secret service is a given. The point is that this doesn't have any anti-journalism mechanism other than saying that media X is sponsored by country Y (the implication comes from the fact that you de-facto have to treat any Georgian youtube channel as a foreign agent since the money comes from YT, an american entity). Obviously there's also a problem that there's a lot of Russian money in Georgia and that wouldn't count as foreign funding, giving any pro-russian sentiment an unfair advantage. However, this "Russian law" is not nearly as bad as actual Russian law on foreign agents which proved multiple times that once you're labeled as a foreign agent - you're on a timer.
Fun fact: Georgia was the first one to start a fire in 2008, not Russia. It was recognized by United Nations, btw. I do not support current Russian foreign policy, but facts are facts. Let's keep our heads cool and our decision-making process fair.
Also lets not forget how UN classified it as a retaliation to Georgia being bombed by Russian backed separatists and it was Russia that got blamed in the end, with Russia having to pay reparations - which they obviously do not
it was funny 😂 russians bombed georgian controlled villages for days before war was errupted and our gov asked russians what is going on and answer was we don’t know who is bombing georgian villages 😂 good try buddy
@@jonjondi3845 @jonjondi3845 sooo... your expertise is better than UN's? And you don't agree with international institutes? It is hard to counter that point of view
I don’t understand why the police are so complicit in these scenarios… is everyone in law enforcement automatically sympathetic to authoritarian rule and anti democracy? Or is the population not as against these policies as reported?
The first bit. Cops exist to enforce the rules which are set by the authorities and they’re paid by the authorities. Cops have your best interest at heart only insofar as those authorities do. So in most places and circumstances, they don’t.
For the last 30Y, so called civilized democracies killed millions of people and destroyed several regions. Stop believing that West is balanced and responsive system. As of now, West is controlled by deep state of neocons who ready to destroy entire world for own benefits.
При этом ни Абхазия , ни Южная Осетия , также не входят в состав РФ, но они продолжают утверждать , что Россия оккупировала Грузию, говоря именно про эти региоеы🤦♀️
idk man, I always thought the same until he made a video about a topic I know a lot about, that's when I saw how many details were missing and just misrepresented. makes me wonder about the rest of the topics I don't know a lot about.
@@Harut4 I would say, as long as the details he is sharing are accurate, I’m on board with not every detail being shared. I can’t Imagine how difficult it is as a job to research and regurgitate accurately, for the sake of presenting sometimes extremely complex situations in laymen’s terms. If what you’re saying is that he isn’t presenting accurate facts, that’s a whole different thing.
@@ZiggyZei I can only speak on the video that he made about the topic I know a lot about, the omitted facts created a very different narrative than reality.
reading the comments and bit confused here. There is irony and criticism towards Georgian government. So - on the one hand you understand that in the situation like this Georgia doesn't have a chance to be part of EU and NATO, because Russia may not be OK even with the Harbor - not mentioning Economic and Military alliances. On the other hand - what do you want Georgia to do? I don't understand why west and EU wants to fight with Russia with someone else's hands. If you want to get rid of Russian authoritarian regime - do so. If no - don't promise false things to the other nations - like you did with Ukraine. Is Ukraine closer to NATO or EU now than it was before the war? No SHIT.
The Georgian Prime Minister said that the United States wanted to open a second front against Russia, to go to war on Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Russia would have to send troops there. He clearly doesn't want that.
The foreign agent law is good and protects Georgians against NATO-influence and other negative thoughts that it would bring with. Georgians should celebrate this historic protection of their country. You can just look at Ukraine to know how foreign influence ruins the roots of your country from the inside out.
This is a russian bot spreading propaganda on behalf the russian goverment to justify the conquering of indepandent countries please ignore this comment above.
@@deleted5229 This is an EU bot spreading propaganda on behalf the imperialist european union to justify the conquering of indepandent countries around russia to make them apart of european sphere of influence by force. please ignore this comment above me.
And he also did not say that Russia did not attack Georgia, Georgia attacked South Ossetia. And the UN found Georgia guilty. But this is not a convenient truth, which is poorly suited for propaganda. 😃
4:45 how can you be so shameless to flip this into "this benefits Russia" lmao, the Georgian government is literally saying "the US is actively sponsoring subversion in our country" (The US sponsoring a coup d'etat? How surprising!) and you don't even waste a second trying to determine if this is true or not, you only care about how this affects Russia, you don't actually give a shit about Georgia. Maybe the reason for Georgia's increase in trade w/ Russia has more to do with the fact that Russia is GEORGIA'S BIGGEST NEIGHBOR and therefore will always be Georgia's biggest trading partner, or maybe it has to do with the idiocy of sanctions and how they force countries to find loopholes around them through middle-man countries like Georgia or Kazakhstan, instead of some conspiracy theory about how Georgia's ruling party is actually a puppet for Putin or whatever. But no, not only do you not mention this, but you talk as if Georgia & its government are doing something wrong by acting according to their trade interests hahaha you actually want Georgia to be poorer, have bad relations with its biggest neighbor, and be grateful with the West because of it! Who needs enemies when you have allies like these? You also don't talk about the Georgian government's suppression of Abkhazian and Ossetian identities, which of course you just discard as "Russian propaganda".
Some of the points here seem a bit mistaken. For one Armenia isn't really an ally with Russia any more, the increasing hostility between the two due to the loss of Nagorno Karabakh and Russia's failure to even try and stop it is rather clear. Beyond that the geostrategic argument as if tank armies can do anything against a nuclear power just sounds silly. It doesn't matter if intentions change, you'd still disappear in nuclear fire if you tried such things. Far more likely the real reason is that Russia doesn't like how the various nations in its sphere are being slowly eroded away as their prospects with other blocks are just better. Causing them to feel like they are slowly encircled and becoming ever less capable of controlling their future. I think something like that is a far more likely cause then the impossible invasions that can never work as absolutely no one has an answer to nukes. (Something that even trying to devise a solution for is near impossible. Russia will probably see many other changes before it might even be a real concern)
Why should Russia do anything about Karabakh if Armenia itself refused to even recognize it officially? As far as Russia is concerned, it's not a part of Armenia, it's a part of Azerbaijan.
@@ForOne814 Sure that's the official line, but then they kept peacekeepers there afterwards so Azerbaijan couldn't do much about it further. Just like they so often kept troops elsewhere as well. Thus in practise Russia was maintaining the borders unchanged between Armenia and Azerbaijan, thus making Armenia dependent on them. But now that Russia gave up on that Armenia is unsurprisingly pretty angry. Especially as it's pretty easy to take it as a sign in general that Russia can not protect them at all anymore. So they've gone looking elsewhere.
@@Quickshot0 the peacekeepers were there because both states agreed to keep them there. They successfully protected the civilian population against possible and probable ethnic cleansings. As a Russian, I have no idea why we're even dealing with Armenia. It is what we call a suitcase without a handle. Like, "Pashinyan - national hero of Azerbaijan" memes didn't come out of nowhere, their entire government is anti-Armenian. Instead of actually doing something, they play victims in this whole situation. When Azerbaijan was preparing for war for 20 something years, after the humiliation in the 90s, Armenians didn't even bother to officially recognize Karabakh, let alone prepare for war. It's pathetic.
i dont see anything wrong with the law, if anything it's good for georgia, other countries have it too, people in georgia really want to end up like ukraine, eh? trusting the west and then being played while they suffer and the west points fingers at russia "look they're invading", like this very video is doing and any of the previous ones
I really enjoy your content, however, i will say i think it's unfortunate when speaking about Maidan that you don't mention the audio clip of Victoria Nuland (under secretary of state at the time) picking out the future Ukrainian government cabinet, basically proving that Maidan was a CIA organized coup. As an American it serves no one to not recognize the role the US played in escalating tensions with Russia in the last 15 years. Furthermore, there was a WSJ article speaking about the cia safehouses that were discovered in Eastern Ukraine, further proof of that fact. To act like this is all Russian Imperialism is honestly silly.
It is Russian imperialism and the Nuland tapes (yes I've listened to them) are cherrypicked out of context. If it's not Russian imperialism, why did Russia annex all of its' current conquests in Ukraine a year ago? Ukraine is not a threat to Russia, never was.
@@deleted5229 This is an EU bot spreading propaganda on behalf the imperialist european union to justify the conquering of indepandent countries around russia to make them apart of european sphere of influence by force. please ignore this comment above me.
@@JohanDanielsson8802 i do not know what is worse ,this type of law or openly admiting that you are a foregin agent...in my country (serbia) it is a open topic nobody hides that they are using NGO s as foregin goverment tools
Those who occupied now Abkhazia are Apsuas, not Abkhazs. Abkhaz is ethnically Georgians. Apsuas are from north Caucasus, like Adygea and Karachay-Cherkessia. And your numbers about Abkhazia war is incorrect: Forcibly moved - more than 350,000. Killed - more than 10,000.
How could the Abkhazians drive 350,000 Georgians out of Abkhazia when the 1989 census reported only 240,000 Georgians, Mingrelians and Svans combined? I know this will probably start an argument, but I cannot understand why people falsify those numbers when state run, pre war, unbiased numbers said otherwise.
@@filipsykora9506They remove not only Georgians. Greeks, Jews, Armenians, Russians, Ukrainians. There was also some Estonians. Even some Apsuas fled from war to other parts of Georgia. Some of Russians and Armenians returned afterwards. FYI: not Mingrelians, it's Megrelians. Also Megrelians and Svans are Georgians.
@@RussianOccupier190 Nope, as a free and an independent country, Georgia has been here for far longer than Russia, Georgia has an unique language and an unique alphabet as well 🇬🇪🇬🇪
Thank you for your content. I love how you try to stay unbiased as possible and bring the facts. I preach others to watch your informative videos. Thank you for bringing change through transparent information.
Transparent information? In what way? He doesn't even list his sources... That's the opposite of transparency. The only thing he is transparent about is his sponsors that he has no problem advertising as much as possible.
@@ExoCryptic-Exo Just say it: You don't care how transparent any of this entertainment is. Just video essays that anyone could make. Just monetized entertainment with no educational or academic weight.
In XIX century Britain fought Russia from 2 sides. Through Afghanistan from British India and In alliance with Turks and French in Crimean war. British hegemonic paranoia is now handled by US new hegemon. US tries similarly to tease Russia through Ukraine, Georgia and Armenia. US trays hard to open new fronts and to use local population as foots on the ground. Just like they did in Iraq and are still doing in Syria with Kurds.
Coz they are npcs that see Russia has this law, so the law is russian! Russia BAD! Despite US has such a law from like a previous century and every self-respecting country must have this law
Ты задаёшь слишком много вопросов. Не надо сомневаться, просто верь😁 этот закон очень плохой и ужасный. Да, такие же законы есть в США, Франции, Турции, но для Грузии этот закон очень вреден😊
Hmmm. Well, I’m already used to the fact that the channel is anti-Russian and deceitful, but it never ceases to amaze. Russia gradually occupied Georgia.... in reality (which is easy to check) Georgia, in the person of its king, Heraclius 2nd and his son and heir, George 7th and all the Georgian princes, asked for protection Russia from Turkey and Persia, and then become part of Russia. At the same time, all the titles of the Georgian aristocracy were preserved, all the lands also remained with the Georgians. But what's the joke with the "gradual occupation"? Georgia asked to go to Russia when it had already lost more than 2/3 of its lands, and it was Russia that subsequently recaptured these lands and returned them to the Georgians. And this is called in the video “the gradual occupation of more and more Georgian lands.” What a disgusting pseudo-history channel. It’s better to read real historical documents and real historians, and not some bloggers on TH-cam.
Claims Georgia owes territories to Moscow because "centuries ago". Na zi Moscow occupies and annexes neighbours, occupants cries response is "anti-Ruzzian".
@@sergeykish Where can you see this? Just rely on the legal meanings of these words. It is very interesting how the inhabitants of these lands, who have lived there for generations, could occupy the lands of some kind of Ukraine. It is also very interesting where annexation is in a national referendum without firing a single shot under the supervision of invited observers from all over the world.
Please stop rotating and tilting the maps. If the map is rotated please put a North indicator on it. Really you don't need those techniques to make it more engaging, a flat map pointed north is cleaner and better.
EU is so slow, that's the reason they are losing this region. If they made dicisions faster like Russia does, Russia woldn't be able to spread their influence. Too late EU, there is no going back for Georgia anymore, with Chinese icreasing influece and Russia's presence the region is lost.
What I want to know is what army they are so afraid of that they are worried about controlling mountain passes? Seems like they have a military that is technologically advanced enough that marching routes shouldn't matter very much. They're not the goddamned Roman Legion.
I don't know how they maintain control of so much territory. There are so many diverse and isolated people in Russian territory who are nothing like the people in Moscow.
@@poorsvids4738 they put ethnic Russians in those territories to run everything during the imperial and soviet eras. That's why Transnistria is the way it is, it's an example of that strategy on the far side of Ukraine from actual Russian land.
Russian should be concerned with China and its relationship with the Russian Federation Countries bordering China. Kazakhstan and the others are warming up to China and China wants Siberia/Outer Manchuria back.
Should've opted to use "j" instead of "c" for the [dʒ] sound. Dedicating "j" for the [ʒ] sound, which is only present in words of foreign origin, seems a bit wasteful. Now, you have to suffer forever.
I know, I speak Turkish (but not natively). I think it's good that Turkish has a phonetic alphabet. Let's look at the letter frequencies in Turkish: Ç: 1.35% C: 1.12% J: 0.16% To me, it makes more sense to use diacritic-less letters for more frequent sounds, so: [tʃ]: C instead of Ç [dʒ]: J instead of C [ʒ]: J̌ (maybe) instead of J Either way, the "damage" is already done, so it's just theoretical.
This video contains a lot of incorrect information about the political context and recent history of Georgia. Saakashvili was not a pro-Western leader, and the Georgian Dream is not a power controlled by Russia. Fact is that Saakashvili celebrated the victory in the Rose Revolution together with Igor Ivanov, who was then the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Russia. I'll leave it up to you to draw your own conclusions This is a fact that the controlled media desperately tries to hide, but there are people who were alive back then and do not have the memory of a fish. When evaluating all of Saakashvili's decisions, any competent analyst will understand whose interests and influences he was actually serving.
I like how western media sphere simply ignoring the fact that Georgia didn't control this territories in the first place after the Soviet Union had collapsed. And even when Georgia was Soviet Republic both Abkhazia and South Osetia had Autonomous Republic status.
When I was in Middle School, my teacher offered extra credit to whoever could name a country starting with the letter "G". I had watched the news the night before about Russia invading a country called Georgia so I named Georgia as my answer for my extra credit attempt. My teacher thought I was talking about an American state that happened to also have the name Georgia. She told me, "just because they talk with an accent doesn't mean they are a different country." I did not get credit.
Teachers don't usually know as much as they think they do.
that might prevent the US from getting too involved because they might accidentally bomb their own state.
@@josephg.3370 now now let’s not get frisky
@@josephg.3370you didn’t know how to spell. So calm down kid.
@@Apbricksquadcuh I fixed my big finger typos. That doesn't change the truth of what I said. Truth is objective and is not contingent on the TH-cam software accepting my attempted corrections before posting.
I don't suppose this bill means that the Georgian Dream party will have to register as a foreign agent?
Maybe the French president of Georgia will need to go home
@@imahuman1996 such a dumb an cynical thing to say
The Dream Party was elected by Georgian people, not by the CIA!
@@eel845Soros and Macron's dogs must go
It applies to everyone else, but the Georgian government. Conveniently :)
“NGOs and media are under foreign influence” - the government under foreign influence 😂
@@castorcarvi It is not asking them to declare sources, but label themselves as foreign government funded. It didnt say 20% from foreign government, but foreign sources. Like if someone in georgia makes a video and it goes viral on youtube, that doesnt make them foreign funded, even if youtube is american. It is a terrible law, and im sure you would be unhappy if everytiktoker has to label themselves as funded by the chinese government.
@@castorcarvi because we(im georgian) don't trust government. talks that our government is pro russian is not new and we see what happened to Russia with this law(small adjustment after small adjustment and now people who "pursuing the interest of foreign power" can't do anything) they ALREADY did adjustments, at first this law was not suppose to affect individual persons, only NGOs but now it affects them too. TLDR the law would be good IF government was good but its not.
@@castorcarvi The US and most western countries have this law. Other foreign lobbying groups in the US have to register as foreign entities including Taiwan, Venezuelan opposition party, South Korea and other countries which control the congress. AIPAC is in a unique position where most the donors listed are Americans (who probably get their money from Israel).
But AIPAC is so powerful that anyone who criticises the way they operate gets ousted.
@@castorcarvi Look how it's been used in Russia. The ruling party has carteblanche to be prejudice towards companies who have International investment. It's just an authoritarian form of control that stifles economic growth.
Nice gymnastics
Aphxazians are related circassians?😂 Please don’t ever try educational content about Georgian ethnical groups,this videos provokes our political sovereignty and causing a lot of gap between us.
Apkhazians are Georgian native ethnical group,not Apsuas,they aren’t not even close with our homeland,Apsuas with Russians has occupied our territory.
Long Live Georgia 🇬🇪
♥️🫡
❤❤
Ucxo is everywhere ucxo, გენაცვალე!
I mean, linguistically the language is related to "Circassian" languages. It does not matter if it offends your political sensibilities, these are just linguistic and anthropological observations.
+
I was in Georgia back in March. At some of the restaurants in the country, the receipts have a "fun fact" letter that says "Russia controls 20% of Georgia's territory".
I hope Georgias borders are restored! Love from 🇵🇱 to Georgians 🇬🇪
@@alexandernico8930 because:
1) Abkazia is unoffical russian territory and they can't win a war against russia.
2) It's not only Abkhazia and SouthOssetia that is occupied by Russia its also their own Goverment. Goverment controles the army which means they won't take it back.
@@Sp4nX383 Besides, an armed resolution would likely end in ethnic violence/cleansing, and many both in the UN and the West wouldn't look at that with good eyes; and with its proximity to Russia, Georgia NEEDS to be seen with good eyes if they want diplomatic/military support
@@alexandernico8930 there is also à big population différence between arzebajan (13M ish) and armenia (3M) its not faire at all
@@alexandernico8930Azerbaijan has huge hydrocarbon reserves and can afford to buy modern weapons. Georgia is quite poot and can't do it.
Just the day this video was uploaded a Chinese company has been officially approved as a sole investor of the Anaklia port project.
F
Interesting
Very interesting and not good for the Russians at all. It most certainly will be built now and Russia wont be able to do anything about it. Invading to stop it would piss off the Chinese even more and as of today, Russia is basicly a puppet of China. Russia needs China alot more than the other way araound. I think that China right now is just trying to build up as much leverage as possible against both West but mostly against Russia for the future. There are so many underlying conflicts brewing in the background between China and Russia.
The Chinese have a long history in genuinely helping build up infrastructure in Georgia so I agree with this decision. The grandiose Rikoti automagistral project is mostly done by them too, it would've otherwise taken decades to complete, but it's nearing completion.
They want multiple ways for their products to reach Europe.
If I had a dollar every time a Western-leaning country on Russia's border had two seperate Russian-back seperatist states appear shortly before a Russian invasion, I'd have 2 dollars. Which isn't a lot, but we really should have seen it coming after the first dollar
2 in Georgia, 2 in Ukraine in 2014, 1 in Moldova. That's 5 right there. We can find more groups of Russian speakers around the world to allow Russia to rescue and extend its borders. It has been doing this for 500 years so it has practiced...
The problem here is the western meddeling that somehow always there. I still remember the Georgian president realizing on video that the US wont support him anymore. HE started eatign his tie.
lol
@@attilamarics3374 Maybe Russia should stop meddling in its former colonies affairs and join the rest of the world in reality and civility
@@joythought > We can find more groups of Russian speakers around the world to allow Russia to rescue and extend its borders
Examples in Europe would be Latvia and Estonia.
The way this man pronounces Belarus is downright jarring every time
The only correct pronunciation of "Belarus" is "White Russia" ;-)
@@gerardvanwilgen9917 White Rus*, Russia is some kind of inbred remnant of Rus colonists deeper north
Yeah, that Bill O'Russ guy shows up a lot in these videos 🤔
You should have heard how he pronounced our last presidents name😭
Your inability to make a video this in depth is downright jarring. Stop nit-picking.
“You’re from Georgia, sweet Georgia as the history books unfold ya!” Rasputin
W reference
ERB of history lol (i edited) wrong YTer lel
@@Zona984 More like ERB of History
"As a messed up motherfucker bent in the mind"
nice
Just wanted to say that while Saakashvili did lose the 2012 presidential election, he did not lose to Ivanishvili. Giorgi Margvelashvili won the Georgian presidential election and remained president until 2018 as an independent--though as a part of the Georgian Dream coalition--but slowly became more critical of the Georgian Dream's consolidation of power and ultimately did not seek re-election. Ivanishvili became the Prime Minister of Georgia in 2012, not president. Doesn't change the fact that the Georgian Dream party controls, but there is a slight error in elected positions here.
Vaime giorgis arseboba saertod damaviwyda. Imena nothingburger presidenti
America has the exact same bill. Russia took the law word for word from the American law😂😂😂 Its easy to fool u types. You all want to be brainwashed
@@RUTHLESSambition5 Certain Americans are easy to fool, this is an obvious move towards neutrality. Which the US deep state was salty about enough in Ukraine to kick off the current fiasco there.
Well at least it wasn't Dzhugashvili that won.😏
@@gremlinton9815 marto bolos amoigo xma maqamde dumilshi iyo
As a peanut farmer from Georgia I am deeply concerned....
the vultures are on you´r air
Did Russia invade Georgia twice in the last 30 years as this video states?
As a habitual Snickers consumer; should I also be concerned?
Is it advisable to stock up before any shortages kick in?
Yes, just google it man. @@utkur765
Protect the peaches!!!
as a Georgian, Apolitical nature of population is the scariest thing ever to happen to country.
2 things that happened in Georgia during protests:
1) MFA operators would use foreign numbers to call people who took part in protests and start swearing at them threatning to rape their parents and asking why are they taking action in anti-govermental protests.
2) MFA created Database which as they say: will contain data about people who support "war" in country.
(According to govermnet you support war if you are not Apolitical)
As a Georgian this is calming…
Must be f***** being neighbor to Russia… Having to be scared of war like it’s the middle ages. How some countries like India can justify this behavior insane to me.
As a Turkish, this isn't calming at all!
Having Russia as a neighbor must feel scary. Always a chance of getting into a war like it’s the middle ages. How people justify their behavior is insane to me
What? That Mother Russia plans to “defend” you?
As an Iowan, ... Hi!
@Gattsu needs to watch this
Real
Looking for this comment
@@raymondleung6522I came here just to comment Gattsu
Hes a cuck for the EU and NATO. I used to enjoy watching his videos but the guy is just pathetic now
this felt like they took quite a few pages from what Gattsu has said
I like reading history about wars, I do not want to become a part of one.
Wars have always been bad, we really shouldn't glorify mass death in state(eltes or rich ppl) land acquisition. 😅
"According to the last census conducted in Soviet Georgia in 1989, the population of Abkhazia totaled about 525,000 people. As for the ethnic composition, the largest groups were Georgians (239,872 people - 45.7% of the population), Abkhazians (93,267 people - 17.7%), Armenians (76,541 people - 14.6%) and Russians (74,913 people - 14.3%)"
The ethic map in 8th minute is kinda misleading. You mention the correct numbers shortly after though. Nice video overall.
Russia is an extremely strong and influential country so it can annex lands if they want.
Otherwise what you gonna do, to fight a huge nuclear superpower?
@@Maxhartmann2024 There would not be independent Finland if you'd never fight against overpowered enemy. But let us hope we don't have to fight again. Hello from Finland! We are glad to have friends within EU and NATO!
@@Mrvanish93 the only reason why Soviets didn’t invade Finland once again (after 1945) is a special treaty which was pretty beneficial for Kremlin. It doesn’t mean that USSR wasn’t able to, despite the disastrous loses during winter war.
Glad that you guys have allies, though Russia has no more interests in Finland.
@@Maxhartmann2024 what we're gonna do...? I don't know, but I can say that there are options and accepting to live in Mordor isn't one of them.
@@Maxhartmann2024 Call Russia's bluff as they can't afford a nuclear war.
Have to say, I kinda think it’s a good idea that media organizations have to publish their funding, for all sides
It's not about publishing it's about suppressing them. If it was about publishing nobody would have any problems. If you want more info look for attacks on opposition already taking place. Masked things used
I know right really question Russia and west intention aren’t pure and lair want just control. How does open media threat western value simple money. I truly believe Address climate change majority modern geopolitics tension or warfare. Also fuck up moment west and Russia doing “peacekeeper” through violence is most dystopian shit I ever heard.
In theory yes, the problem is the reality of how that bill is designed and how it can be used to suppres information.
All you have to do is go look at the Russian law it was cloned from.
@@libraryofpangea7018 true
@@libraryofpangea7018 could be. All I’m thinking is it would be a really nice thing to know when you ready news as to who funded the paper that wrote it. Or the journalists. Maybe if it were all I. The open people could judge better what the bias is
Hi! A Latvian here. I distinctly remember the 2008 Russian invasion in Georgia - and how fast it was all over. And how only countries that had firsthand experience with Russia's aggression and never dying imperialism were in a loud uproar about it.
And I distinctly remember, just having walked out of my parents apartment, heading to the public transport stop, in school, 15 years of age, and thinking - oh. Oh what is my family gonna do when/if Russia invades Latvia again? Oh we would have to get all of our grandparents. Oh good thing my mom's grandparents have a car, and my dad's car is so big. Oh, but maybe we should also pick up some of my friends too.
You know. Normal thoughts to have as a fifteen year old.
This is why there is this unbridgable gap between most people in the world and the people that have grown up in the old and ongoing, wealthy and always safe empires. If you know how it is, to be afraid of your country's sovereignty, than you know. If you have never felt that fear... you have no idea.
So you got scared as a kid and call this unbridgable gap? Plenty sure kids think about stuff which may or not be normal all the time dude
@@impieux are you a fucking moron? Growing up in the fear of very realistic war that could end your country is a normal thing to have as a kid? As a Georgian I relate to this comment so much and how people from America or other countries without war on their land just can't comprehend the terror
Why would you think this when Latvia was a NATO member since 2004? Russia isn't going to invade such a strong alliance.
About that...@@geeljire9247
Great insight thanks for your honesty, we know nothing of fear.
the title isn't helping our constant anxiety at all ;)))
what a 34 minutes of bull 💩💩
A chinese company just won the bid to build the port in Anaklia
and what about ken tucky?
watch out for those debt-traps
so? look at how chinese treat africans.
@@Jart988 Like the International Monetary Fund?
@@saint2867 The IMF doing shady things like that doesn’t magically make it good when China also does it.
Me Georgian reading the title of the video 💀
Hey, I'm against censorship but I'm still confused about something. Is it easy to get info about who's funding NGOs, companies and politicians there? Because it isn't easy here.
As a Canadian, I was like wtf then I saw the thumbnail and was like ohh.
@@johncrocker4209
For the public, it's so-so. Large NGOs usually declare their sources of funding on their websites. However, for the government, it's 100% clear, as such entities are legally obliged to share their full financial statements annually with tax authorities. The Foreign Agent Law (renamed as the Foreign Transparency Law) is primarily to label individuals working in such fields as agents. More importantly, it gives the government the authority to forcibly shut down their activities for six months based on an anonymous tip under the name of investigation. Additionally, if NGOs have any databases of citizens, these become accessible to the government and can potentially be misused.
The second law, which wasn't mentioned in the video, is the Offshore Law. This law significantly reduces transfer taxes and eases inspections on funds from offshore accounts. It is intended to benefit Ivanishvili and other Russian oligarchs who are under sanctions, facilitating money laundering activities here.
How about not be anti-Russian and living in peace with Russia, is that too hard to do? It seems to be, as you obviously didn't learn from the Ukraine example with waving the Ukrainian flag.
Lucky you.
only putin can predict reallifelore's timing
putin is a baw bag.
🗿
Russian mouthpiece?????????
@@porkerpete7722 He usually is against Russia based on my viewing.
I don't know that that counts as a mouthpiece unless they mean to undermine themselves.
US has the same law since 1938 the Foreign Agents Registration Act, it even targets individuals and not only NGO and EU is in process of implementing it as well, in fact they are so far into it they already started gathering information on members of EU parliament about non-EU funds. But its Russian law and Georgia will have problems joining EU because of it.... ROFL!
not for AIPAC, they don't have to register.
At least someone educated enough makes comment
Georgian protesters don't know that in both cases they will have this law 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Sanctus-Susanin тебе хоть платят за коменты здесь? 😂
Nice. Will was see a video on Moldova too? There's a lot to talk about. Unionism with Romania, Transnistria and how it is in the weakest bargaining position ever, Kremlin destabilising measures, Gagauzia. I think there's a lot to talk about.
I don't know why, but for some reason all of the unionist parties in Romania are on the right. As a left-wing European, I see it as quite a shame.
He's defo done one, might be nebula exclusive
Was Moldova recently banning all of its TV channels which used to feature the opposing party, also Kremlin's doing? 😂
Nah, Moldova perfectly handles destabilisation on its own.
@@FairyCRatwhy? Because the left parties în România are pro Russia. The biggest left party (PSD) passed a same law regarding ONG’s!
@@FairyCRatleft wing Europa is not the same as left wing Eastern Europe! They don’t care about pronouns, their agenda is Russia!
The song used in this video is "Blue Lantern" - Yi Nantiro in case anyone was interested. Not sure why he didn't credit it.
Thanks, and what is the name of the song used in his video about Poland?
@@michaelderose3551Darude - “Sandstorm”
Don't care, didn't ask.
@@Reshiram32Zekrom23 Aint no one care about your opinon lil boy😊
@@MontgomeryGator-q1z don't care. Didn't ask
The bill actually sounds pretty reasonable. Why would a rational person object to NGOs having to reveal who they're working for?
Because in 2017 russia used this bill to suppress opposition. This bill in georgia can also be used like that. Anyone who has a foreign band is funded from a foreign country loses some rights. Its is not a good law in the hands of corrupt politicians. Nobody wants this fkn law
Because the people who they are working for or getting most of their money from is not from the people they are protesting against most NGOs are highly likely funded by the EU and the US as we see these people protesting ha
It does. The trick is, how they use it. A similar bill was passed here in Hungary, opposition media outlets, NGO-s (and maybe the CEU too, im not sure) came under constant harrassment and intimidation shortly after by governmental organisations.
Im not against fair and square financial audits, but there is a clear abuse to silence opposing voices in the country to this day. And the law is written vaguely enough to allow such bullying.
Maybe the situation is similar in Georgia.
I hope Georgia 🇬🇪 gets a fertility rate of 3 children per woman, becomes a high-income advanced core economy and becomes an EU member...
I am missing the Turkish perspective. Turkey today is an ambitious geopolitical player and a formidable rival to Russia in the Black Sea and the Middle East. AND Turkey shares Georgia's interests in a save oil and gas corridor, and also would very much prefer Russia tonot control the Turkish-Georgian border. Turkey in 2008 is probably a lot more assertive of its political, military and economic weight than it was in 2008.
So how would (might) Turkey react to yet another Russian incursion into - and effective strategic control of - Georgia?
No way. Russia will remind Turkey where its place is. Turkey exists as long as it is beneficial to Russia.
@@ЕвгенийХромов-б2иlooks like a kremlebot comment
Turkey will do what it did to ukrn
sell supply weapons, turkey has own southern border to worry for 2 explosive states
Russia will support Armenia and Iran
@@ЕвгенийХромов-б2иlike they reminded turkey in karabakh 2020 where theyre place is? U overestimate russia and underestimate turkey
Sakartvelo mentioned 🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
არ ვიცი კარგია თუ არა რომ იმ ვიდეოში გვახსენეს
YESSS!!!!🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪
@@გიორგი-უ4ყ its always a good thing when corruption is exposed
კარგ კონტექსტში მაინც იყოს ლოლ
Gamarjoba! I'm from Ukraine and I'm wondering If you really prefer when your country's called Sakartvelo instead of Georgia? I heard it from ukrainians, but I don't have any friends from Georgia to confirm it. I would love to know more about it
Honestly that media law should be a law everywhere. If people only knew how much foreign money influences their political lives
Trump wouldn't be elected if that were the case. All his funding comes from Russia. He's just Putin's dog.
@@PodyPearPearl😂😂
Kinda weird that a bill to show foreign influence in media would be called "the Russian bill". Won't that affect Russia too?
Seems like it'll only affect the people who control the media
Selective enforcement. Of course it would effect the party in power, but of course people allied with that party will just ignore the law and not face consequences.
It also serves as a tool to simply get insight into everybody finances. Oh you do something and you don't want to tell use all your internal information. Must be foreign terrorists then.
It will affect those that go against the government. 'Media' includes posting comments on TH-cam and any newspaper or tv-station that isn't already controlled by government would have to be very concerned about who they got their advertisements from.
Also the US has exactly the same law e.g. Tiktok and China
I was wondering when this would come up. This is the issue that the global West seems to have forgotten.
Yeah I didn’t know any of this was happening until the protests broke out. I was under the assumption that Georgias government would be supportive of Ukraine for obvious reasons. 🤦🏾♂️
@@ShabazzTBL the people are so thats atleast good
No, the West is forcing it again!
It won't, at least in Western media. Georgian was being used and abandoned by NATO in 2008, now some native Georgian still believe they can join EU someday, It will never happen.
@@孙愉悦 they want to join nato to be safe from Russia. They've been trying that for hundreds of years and they know that eu doesnt care THAT much but we're desperate here. If only we were neighbors with another freaking normal country who doesn't have a tyrant hell bent on invading lands.
This guy is the reason why I love geography.
it's a decent video but dewd, get a life.
this is geopolitics, not geography. does your parents know your skipping classes.
@Davidsleith7222. Do your parents know that you’re missing spelling and grammar class? (What exactly was so triggering about OP’s post?)
Geopolitics not geography
u mean geopolitics?
Because of the BIG SCARY RED ARROWS that's why
BEEEG RED SCARY ARROWS
Imagine how wealthy and stable Russia could be if they just got along with their neighbours and invested all their money, time and effort into building the nation.
then they would be in a commercial war with the US like china is now
This is exactly what it is trying to do, but some other large states are constantly interfering in the internal affairs of other countries
@@paztwel lmao no it is NOT what russia is trying to do, russia chose this path or rather putin, this is just a way for putin to keep power all to himself
@@paztwel Maybe in parallel universe mate.
@@xchelidze I do not know what is happening in your parallel universe, but in our reality everything is as I described it
thanks for this video that at lest give some light about why me and so many other families leave Abkhazia to save their lives and lost all of their homes and belongings when the Abkhazia/Georgia war started, At 1990 i was 4 year's old and one day i was playing on the balcony then i see and hear a helicopters and soldiers with tanks comming and start the killings, So after 1 hour my mother just take me and a backpack and little money that se manage to find at lest for the food for the journey to greece, I dont even know how she managed all that i only know and remmember that we run at night and was hiding in forests and brushes and we was 2 or 3 days in a small boat-ship with many more peole and earplanes bombing and shouting at us with bad sea and stormy night, I never see again my father, He was at work the day my mother take me and we run he say to my mom you take the kid and go gracce to some family we have ther and i will try come later, Il will find you, many years later when i was 15 my mother tell me that he was killed one week latter, I dont know about russia or georgia i only know that all my life change before even started we lost every thing from this war, money home car papers belongings people we love my very first friends from pre school and neighborhood every thing, And many they're lives people that don't do anything to no one that don't want war but a good life and peaceful one, Am almost 40 years old now and i still have not manage even to visit Abkhazia after all that year's, I really hate them all.
I hope you will manage to go back once... We will take that land back!
daim chill
@@Gigi-yp4yt This is me being chill..
@@IraclisPapadopoulos you writed so many words😭
@@Kalasha0123 Thanks you brother, and for understanding...
Putin watching this video: "You know what. Lets remake the 2008"
Russia cant match the power of georgian people
Nah, Russia did pulverise Georgia, twice. And the latter lost Abkhazia and South Ossetia as a result.
Their only hope was for NATO to help them, which wasn't existing when the invasion happened.
@Sigma_Male_Anti_Female They are "a part of georgia" but russia controls them, so in reality they are a part of russia
Drones,,,,, how easy to counter tanks and infantry with drones. Russia didn't pay attention to the Azerbaijan & Armenians. It took Ukraine decimating Russia's military before the Kremlin finally paid attention and still not well focused.
@Sigma_Male_Anti_Female
"officially" aka in georgian dreams only. All bark no bite. Like Armenia dreaming of Karabakh or Ukraine dreaming of Crimea or Donetsk.
It’s funny about the law on foreign agents and the values of the West and the EU.
The law has been in the USA since 1938, and the same laws have been adopted in Great Britain, Australia, and so on... But we will be most interested in France. An EU country that adopted exactly the same law in 2024, and right this year, and the French law also implies criminal sentences. But the President of Georgia, a French citizen and former employee of the French Foreign Ministry, calls the Georgian law pro-Putin. =)
I even do not know why. Maybe because Georgian law does not imply criminal prosecution, or maybe because, unlike Western ones, they do not prosecute individuals, but only legal ones, and the fines there are 10 times less than in French.
I just want to ask why EU laws are democratic, but when candidates for the EU want to adopt them, then this is the path to dictatorship? =)
And another interesting thing is that for the 3.7 million population of Georgia there are now 25 thousand different NGOs, the same ones that now brought people to the streets =)
Just think about it, now in Georgia for every 148 people, from babies to the very old, there is one legal organization funded from abroad. Not a person, but an organization, a legal entity.
Is this good or bad?
Underrated comment
In 30 years time, a small Russia child will ask their Grandma why every country they touch hates them. I hope Russians are able to accept this.
Потому что сами эти страны думать не умеют , за них это делают западные СМИ. Хороший пример , для ребенка, что бы показать к чему приводит невежество и не умение думать своей головой.
Russia has shown that the CSTO ia just there so that other countries help Russia not the other way round. Once Azerbaijan invaded parts of Armenia, Armenia tried to acrivate article 6 (mutual protection), Russia refused.
so Armenia itself recognized that it occupied territories from Azerbaijan when it joined the CSTO. In your opinion, we should fight with our ally for territories that even the occupier recognized as occupied
@@kutuzovmikhailillarionovic2120 In 2021 and 2022, Azerbaijan invaded Armenia's sovereign territory, bombed Armenian cities, and occupied approximately 250 square kilometers of territory (which it still holds). Russia did nothing.
Why Armenia didn't find then? Did it want Russia to protect it from another Russia's ally?
Also, why did Pashinyan recognise Nagorno-Karabakh as Azerbaijan territories?
No they didn't. Armenian prime minister said himself that they didn't ask for protection
@@rebeli-argum He said the opposite
Russia and Georgia are adopting a law on controlling foreign influence.
The West: this is undemocratic, a restriction on freedom of speech and press censorship.
Also, the USA: They were the very first in the world to adopt this law in 1938 and actively use it to this day, censoring all foreign media, including European ones. This is considered democratic.
In simple terms, an independent country will never allow itself to be influenced even by a friendly country because it is INDEPENDENT. Now look at the EU countries, which claim that such a law is not needed, and at the USA, which has this law. Who among them is independent and the master, and who is a servant actively promoting foreign influence in their country.
As Georgian, it's not so comfortable to read the name of my country in that kind of video
we have a similar law in the USA Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA): “The Foreign Agents Registration Act provides the public with an opportunity to be informed of the identity of persons engaging in political activities on behalf of foreign governments, foreign political parties and other foreign principals, so that their activities can be evaluated in light of their associations.”
It doesn't require them to include a message declaring themselves as such in every publication as far as I know though.
@@andrewsprague4566@andrewsprague4566 I don't get this: what's wrong with disclosure? Isn't that what you'd want in a democracy? Transparency and knowing exactly who you're dealing with, what their motives are. If we, as the American Government, are Financing your organization, we would want the public to know that this stands for the United States' freedom and democracy: Agents of foreign principals who are not otherwise exempt must comply with FARA's registration requirements, disclosure requirements, and record-keeping requirements. Covered entities must file a registration statement with the DOJ within 10 days of becoming an agent of a foreign principal.Mar 9, 2023
@@andrewsprague4566 The only time you want to be sneaky and hide things is when you are up to no good, as the United States we are the good guys we should have no reason to want to work in the shadows
@@gunnar2300 beyond Russia's selective enforcement there is a different between a government registering you and a government shoving a very specific set of words in your mouth every time you open it, and throwing you in jail if you miss a punctuation mark.
@@andrewsprague4566 TH-cam does it, too. If a channel is funded by any government, then it is written under every single video that the channel uploads.
Georgia should not get involved with NATO and RUSSIA EU yes but not NATO it is dangerous. Georgia should be neutral.
I support Georgia to be neutral it well in their best interest.
The “Soviet Government” that incorporated Abkhazia and S Ossetia into Georgia was in fact one man - Joseph Stalin, himself a Georgian from Gori. Stalin did this in other Soviet republics as well in order to dilute the ethnic majority and prevent separatist movements from emerging. S Ossetians and Georgians didn’t just “start fighting” in 2008. Saakashvilli ordered troops to forcibly seize the territory and launched a surprise attack, killing several Russian peacekeepers (there with a UN mandate) in the process. These are just a few of the small details that were omitted here, but such omissions matter. The most salient one is the fact that the Georgian law in question is modeled on a similar U.S. law that has been on the books for decades.
That is of course AFTER two Georgian peacekeepers were killed by the EID and repeated shellings of Geo villages and the head of peacekeeping mission kulakhmetov, who was BTW russian declaring that he lost control over situation on the ground. Yes, ommissions do matter
And "Russian law" has nothing to do with FARA.
For the people that are arguing that i.e. the US has a similar law.
there are major key differences:
1. FARA deals with lobbying, lobbying is illegal in Georgia
2. FARA requires companies to register on the basis of activity and political involvement, also some types (educational, free media) are not required to register. The Georgian law requires any ngo to register just on the basis of funding, when more than 20% of their funding comes from a foreign source, regardless of intent, activity, or any type of political involvement and labels them as "conductors of foreign influence". this term can be used in a very negative way as propaganda against, i.e. western organizations that are overlooking the legitimacy of our elections, a job with which we don't trust our own government.
3. The Georgian law on transparency gives the active government, legal incentive to spy on ngos that dont even fit the criteria of the law. For example, lets say an organization recieves funding 50% locally and 50% from another country (which do not fit the criteria of the transparency law, which states that more than 20% of funding should come from foreign source), the government, on the basis of mere suspicion that they fit the criteria but did not register willingly (we know how this goes), can spy, disrupt work, extract personal information from people associated with said organization, which may not even be influenced by foreign powers and just be critical of the active government. in summary, this is a tool to be used against oppositional rhetoric and media. and the important part here is that, we know generally governments do spy on the population but it isn't legally supported and cant be used against them in court. however, in this instance, since there is a law that gives the legal incentive, all kinds of information that is obtained in said way could be used against you, which is just atrocious in every way.
4. The US has (atlest in comparison) an independent and just judicial system, with which you are able to prove your truth in the case of being wrongly labeled as a foreign agent. In georgia however, historically and presently, we deal with heavily corrupt courts, and the supreme prosecutor is appointed, solely by the active political party, without any resistance as they hold the majority of the seats in the parliament. so such a law which in the hands of the government, holds such damaging capabilities against free speech and democracy, against the Georgian people, should in no way be active in the country, until said fundamental systemic problems are resolved, which have been eating away at us for the last 3 decades.
these are only some of the reasons, there is much more, especially in the context of our country and froeign relations, hopefully i shed the light on the situation.
Great explanation. Thanks.
I would like it if all sources declared where their funding comes from, independent of reason. Like Nutrition Facts and Ingredients lists on food.
The other things you mentioned are not so good.
Well they can spy as well on prorussian or prochina organizzation...Is It not good tò know Who are beyond...?
American law also requires you to inform about what you're doing, what's your relationship with X country and yadayadayada if you're a foreign agent on your own. "Checking" if it's the truth by a secret service is a given.
The point is that this doesn't have any anti-journalism mechanism other than saying that media X is sponsored by country Y (the implication comes from the fact that you de-facto have to treat any Georgian youtube channel as a foreign agent since the money comes from YT, an american entity). Obviously there's also a problem that there's a lot of Russian money in Georgia and that wouldn't count as foreign funding, giving any pro-russian sentiment an unfair advantage. However, this "Russian law" is not nearly as bad as actual Russian law on foreign agents which proved multiple times that once you're labeled as a foreign agent - you're on a timer.
Finally someone that explains in tired of them arguing
funny the jewish AIPAC doesn't have to... altough JFK tried and was assassinated.
Ah, a new video from mah favourite propaganda channel, RealLifeLore😁
Propaganda
Fun fact: Georgia was the first one to start a fire in 2008, not Russia.
It was recognized by United Nations, btw.
I do not support current Russian foreign policy, but facts are facts.
Let's keep our heads cool and our decision-making process fair.
Also lets not forget how UN classified it as a retaliation to Georgia being bombed by Russian backed separatists and it was Russia that got blamed in the end, with Russia having to pay reparations - which they obviously do not
it was funny 😂 russians bombed georgian controlled villages for days before war was errupted and our gov asked russians what is going on and answer was we don’t know who is bombing georgian villages 😂 good try buddy
Of course we started it. No one cared and once again eu bought russias lies cause they didn't care about georgia and the rest of the world did too
Доказать дуракам, что они дураки не возможны, лучше оставить их в неведении.
@@jonjondi3845 @jonjondi3845 sooo... your expertise is better than UN's? And you don't agree with international institutes? It is hard to counter that point of view
I don’t understand why the police are so complicit in these scenarios… is everyone in law enforcement automatically sympathetic to authoritarian rule and anti democracy?
Or is the population not as against these policies as reported?
If they don't work they can't feed their kids, Georgia is still quite poor
Because police is educated on how americans install their puppets in governments around the world. Democracy is the easiest regime to infiltrate.
The first bit. Cops exist to enforce the rules which are set by the authorities and they’re paid by the authorities. Cops have your best interest at heart only insofar as those authorities do. So in most places and circumstances, they don’t.
For the last 30Y, so called civilized democracies killed millions of people and destroyed several regions. Stop believing that West is balanced and responsive system. As of now, West is controlled by deep state of neocons who ready to destroy entire world for own benefits.
Cops are thugs who will brutalize the citizenry if not kept rigidly in check.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
W-e d-o-n-'t n-e-e-d a S-a-t-a-n-i-c E-u-r-o-p-e. E-u-t-o-n-a-s-i-a, S-o-d-o-m, l-e-g-a-l-i-z-e-d p-r-o-s-ti-tu-tio-n, le-g-a-l-iz-e-d dr-u-g-s, a-dul-t-er-y o-f ch-i-ld-r-en!!! Y-ou h-a-ve lo-st th-e wa-y -o-f C-hr-i-st. We are n-ot go-in-g to r-ep-ea-t t-he sa-m-e s-tu-pid-ity. We ar-e th-e pe-op-le wh-o ne-v-er be-tr-ay C-hr-ist!!! W-e w-i-ll f-in-d a -w-ay ou-t w-i-th th-e e-ne-my a-ga-in, rat-h-er th-a-n re-ce-ive s-pir-it-u--al d-e-a-th f-ro-m y-o-u!!!
Went Georgia last year! Beautiful place!
you go to kentucky? kenturkey?
__ Just a little detail _ Abkhazia and South Ossetia are not part of Georgia __
При этом ни Абхазия , ни Южная Осетия , также не входят в состав РФ, но они продолжают утверждать , что Россия оккупировала Грузию, говоря именно про эти региоеы🤦♀️
The music in the background is distracting
Your work is so detailed.. For some reason after hundreds of hours watched, I felt like letting you know, Its impressive af
This particular one is poorly researched and heavily biased.
@@mkontentBiased in whoms favor?
idk man, I always thought the same until he made a video about a topic I know a lot about, that's when I saw how many details were missing and just misrepresented. makes me wonder about the rest of the topics I don't know a lot about.
@@Harut4 I would say, as long as the details he is sharing are accurate, I’m on board with not every detail being shared. I can’t Imagine how difficult it is as a job to research and regurgitate accurately, for the sake of presenting sometimes extremely complex situations in laymen’s terms. If what you’re saying is that he isn’t presenting accurate facts, that’s a whole different thing.
@@ZiggyZei I can only speak on the video that he made about the topic I know a lot about, the omitted facts created a very different narrative than reality.
Russia did not invade Georgia, Georgia attacked south ossetia which caused a russian response.
reading the comments and bit confused here. There is irony and criticism towards Georgian government. So - on the one hand you understand that in the situation like this Georgia doesn't have a chance to be part of EU and NATO, because Russia may not be OK even with the Harbor - not mentioning Economic and Military alliances. On the other hand - what do you want Georgia to do? I don't understand why west and EU wants to fight with Russia with someone else's hands. If you want to get rid of Russian authoritarian regime - do so. If no - don't promise false things to the other nations - like you did with Ukraine. Is Ukraine closer to NATO or EU now than it was before the war? No SHIT.
The Georgian Prime Minister said that the United States wanted to open a second front against Russia, to go to war on Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Russia would have to send troops there. He clearly doesn't want that.
The foreign agent law is good and protects Georgians against NATO-influence and other negative thoughts that it would bring with. Georgians should celebrate this historic protection of their country. You can just look at Ukraine to know how foreign influence ruins the roots of your country from the inside out.
This is a russian bot spreading propaganda on behalf the russian goverment to justify the conquering of indepandent countries please ignore this comment above.
@@deleted5229 This is an EU bot spreading propaganda on behalf the imperialist european union to justify the conquering of indepandent countries around russia to make them apart of european sphere of influence by force. please ignore this comment above me.
Man... this channel is pure American propaganda. Not even subtle
Man… yet here you are watching 🤷🏻♂️
Watching again for the algorithm that gets you paid. Damn the man!
neat, but really, he doenst need the help, he is a large channel - 7.5m subs for godsake.
@@xBINARYGODx he made a complaint earlier about being censored
you go back to kentucky, tennessee
So, the USA has this law but Georgia can’t😃
>CIA funds color revolution
>government introduces law to crack down on this
>government gets blamed for being puppets
laughable
Ah yes, it's completely impossible the population was sick of a corrupt and incompetent government it's always the CIA no other reasons possible
@@gherkinisgreatus has a similar law,,,
@@belkacemFand not only the USA. also France, Turkiye, Hungary and many other countries
The video omits that same type of law exists in the US, not only Russia.
In the EU as well
Yeah this is weird
Russians literally copy this law from US
And he also did not say that Russia did not attack Georgia, Georgia attacked South Ossetia. And the UN found Georgia guilty. But this is not a convenient truth, which is poorly suited for propaganda. 😃
Because it's not the same law
CCCP ❤
sounds like a completely fair law and the protests look astroturfed
excellent work as usual...no other channel made me understand the importance of maps, the terrain is the story
4:45 how can you be so shameless to flip this into "this benefits Russia" lmao, the Georgian government is literally saying "the US is actively sponsoring subversion in our country" (The US sponsoring a coup d'etat? How surprising!) and you don't even waste a second trying to determine if this is true or not, you only care about how this affects Russia, you don't actually give a shit about Georgia.
Maybe the reason for Georgia's increase in trade w/ Russia has more to do with the fact that Russia is GEORGIA'S BIGGEST NEIGHBOR and therefore will always be Georgia's biggest trading partner, or maybe it has to do with the idiocy of sanctions and how they force countries to find loopholes around them through middle-man countries like Georgia or Kazakhstan, instead of some conspiracy theory about how Georgia's ruling party is actually a puppet for Putin or whatever.
But no, not only do you not mention this, but you talk as if Georgia & its government are doing something wrong by acting according to their trade interests hahaha you actually want Georgia to be poorer, have bad relations with its biggest neighbor, and be grateful with the West because of it! Who needs enemies when you have allies like these? You also don't talk about the Georgian government's suppression of Abkhazian and Ossetian identities, which of course you just discard as "Russian propaganda".
Relax, this channel never cared about understanding of international politics or economy. Just farming ad moneys
Everytime I watch RLL I feel like the President getting a briefing by an advisor. I leik it
Some of the points here seem a bit mistaken. For one Armenia isn't really an ally with Russia any more, the increasing hostility between the two due to the loss of Nagorno Karabakh and Russia's failure to even try and stop it is rather clear.
Beyond that the geostrategic argument as if tank armies can do anything against a nuclear power just sounds silly. It doesn't matter if intentions change, you'd still disappear in nuclear fire if you tried such things.
Far more likely the real reason is that Russia doesn't like how the various nations in its sphere are being slowly eroded away as their prospects with other blocks are just better. Causing them to feel like they are slowly encircled and becoming ever less capable of controlling their future. I think something like that is a far more likely cause then the impossible invasions that can never work as absolutely no one has an answer to nukes. (Something that even trying to devise a solution for is near impossible. Russia will probably see many other changes before it might even be a real concern)
Why should Russia do anything about Karabakh if Armenia itself refused to even recognize it officially? As far as Russia is concerned, it's not a part of Armenia, it's a part of Azerbaijan.
@@ForOne814 Sure that's the official line, but then they kept peacekeepers there afterwards so Azerbaijan couldn't do much about it further. Just like they so often kept troops elsewhere as well.
Thus in practise Russia was maintaining the borders unchanged between Armenia and Azerbaijan, thus making Armenia dependent on them.
But now that Russia gave up on that Armenia is unsurprisingly pretty angry. Especially as it's pretty easy to take it as a sign in general that Russia can not protect them at all anymore. So they've gone looking elsewhere.
@@Quickshot0 the peacekeepers were there because both states agreed to keep them there. They successfully protected the civilian population against possible and probable ethnic cleansings.
As a Russian, I have no idea why we're even dealing with Armenia. It is what we call a suitcase without a handle. Like, "Pashinyan - national hero of Azerbaijan" memes didn't come out of nowhere, their entire government is anti-Armenian. Instead of actually doing something, they play victims in this whole situation. When Azerbaijan was preparing for war for 20 something years, after the humiliation in the 90s, Armenians didn't even bother to officially recognize Karabakh, let alone prepare for war. It's pathetic.
i dont see anything wrong with the law, if anything it's good for georgia, other countries have it too, people in georgia really want to end up like ukraine, eh? trusting the west and then being played while they suffer and the west points fingers at russia "look they're invading", like this very video is doing and any of the previous ones
I really enjoy your content, however, i will say i think it's unfortunate when speaking about Maidan that you don't mention the audio clip of Victoria Nuland (under secretary of state at the time) picking out the future Ukrainian government cabinet, basically proving that Maidan was a CIA organized coup. As an American it serves no one to not recognize the role the US played in escalating tensions with Russia in the last 15 years. Furthermore, there was a WSJ article speaking about the cia safehouses that were discovered in Eastern Ukraine, further proof of that fact. To act like this is all Russian Imperialism is honestly silly.
It is Russian imperialism and the Nuland tapes (yes I've listened to them) are cherrypicked out of context. If it's not Russian imperialism, why did Russia annex all of its' current conquests in Ukraine a year ago? Ukraine is not a threat to Russia, never was.
This is a russian bot spreading propaganda on behalf the russian goverment ignore this comment.
@@deleted5229 This is an EU bot spreading propaganda on behalf the imperialist european union to justify the conquering of indepandent countries around russia to make them apart of european sphere of influence by force. please ignore this comment above me.
No one talks that this bill exists for 50 years allready in USA...
It's different one. Pls do research before commenting
Here in Sweden, "taking of foreign support" is a criminal offense, which can land someone in prison for up to two years.
@@JohanDanielsson8802 i do not know what is worse ,this type of law or openly admiting that you are a foregin agent...in my country (serbia) it is a open topic nobody hides that they are using NGO s as foregin goverment tools
It looks like CIA is working as they did in Ukraine 2012
Those who occupied now Abkhazia are Apsuas, not Abkhazs.
Abkhaz is ethnically Georgians.
Apsuas are from north Caucasus, like Adygea and Karachay-Cherkessia.
And your numbers about Abkhazia war is incorrect:
Forcibly moved - more than 350,000.
Killed - more than 10,000.
How could the Abkhazians drive 350,000 Georgians out of Abkhazia when the 1989 census reported only 240,000 Georgians, Mingrelians and Svans combined? I know this will probably start an argument, but I cannot understand why people falsify those numbers when state run, pre war, unbiased numbers said otherwise.
@@filipsykora9506They remove not only Georgians. Greeks, Jews, Armenians, Russians, Ukrainians. There was also some Estonians. Even some Apsuas fled from war to other parts of Georgia.
Some of Russians and Armenians returned afterwards.
FYI: not Mingrelians, it's Megrelians. Also Megrelians and Svans are Georgians.
Levanika where did you find that information? Bro just asking out of curiosity- numbers and the people currently in Abkhazia
As a Georgian, I am happy that you’ve made a video about my country, საქართველოს გაუმარჯოს ;)
Long live Georgia as a part of Russia.
@@RussianOccupier190
Long live Georgia, as an independent country 🇬🇪🤘
@@Clock_Man_2763 nope as a part of Russia🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
@@RussianOccupier190
Nope, as a free and an independent country, Georgia has been here for far longer than Russia, Georgia has an unique language and an unique alphabet as well 🇬🇪🇬🇪
@@RussianOccupier190 long live Russia as a part of great China
Hello friend, glad you got a new mic
This video fails to mention that Armenia has started the process of leaving CSTO.
Thank you for your content. I love how you try to stay unbiased as possible and bring the facts. I preach others to watch your informative videos. Thank you for bringing change through transparent information.
Transparent information? In what way? He doesn't even list his sources... That's the opposite of transparency. The only thing he is transparent about is his sponsors that he has no problem advertising as much as possible.
@@goldbullet50 hey look your comment is helping boost his content too! Thanks for helping spread transparent information goldbullet!
@@ExoCryptic-Exo Just say it: You don't care how transparent any of this entertainment is. Just video essays that anyone could make. Just monetized entertainment with no educational or academic weight.
@@goldbullet50 im glad you help promote educational content my friend
@@ExoCryptic-Exo You should see a doctor. Problems with thinking are not a joke
First rows on a city protest….women… first rows in war..men
Great Job! So wonderfully and thoroughly informative! Thanks!
In XIX century Britain fought Russia from 2 sides.
Through Afghanistan from British India and
In alliance with Turks and French in Crimean war.
British hegemonic paranoia is now handled by US new hegemon. US tries similarly to tease Russia through Ukraine, Georgia and Armenia. US trays hard to open new fronts and to use local population as foots on the ground. Just like they did in Iraq and are still doing in Syria with Kurds.
wait wasnt that a law in USA? for quite a while?
I don’t understand why this law is a bad thing? Shouldn’t people have a right to know who influencing businesses?
Because its hypocritical in nature and wont apply to russia puppets that rolled this law out in the first place
he literally said why in the vid
Coz they are npcs that see Russia has this law, so the law is russian! Russia BAD!
Despite US has such a law from like a previous century and every self-respecting country must have this law
Ты задаёшь слишком много вопросов. Не надо сомневаться, просто верь😁 этот закон очень плохой и ужасный. Да, такие же законы есть в США, Франции, Турции, но для Грузии этот закон очень вреден😊
@@IvGor ознакомься с законом в сша для начала, а потом сравни с российским и тебе все станет понятно почему он не просто плох а помойка
I just discovered this channel… I’ve never subscribed to a channel so fast!
You did't explain why it is better for Georgia to be controlled by US and EU but not having good relations with it's first neighbour!?
Well Amerika is not gonna invade and annax it.
Unlike russia
‘Countries are more concerned about capabilities and not intent’
I love how realism framework slowly gains momentum.
Realism is a junk science spouted by the biggest fools in International Relations theory
Hmmm. Well, I’m already used to the fact that the channel is anti-Russian and deceitful, but it never ceases to amaze. Russia gradually occupied Georgia.... in reality (which is easy to check) Georgia, in the person of its king, Heraclius 2nd and his son and heir, George 7th and all the Georgian princes, asked for protection Russia from Turkey and Persia, and then become part of Russia. At the same time, all the titles of the Georgian aristocracy were preserved, all the lands also remained with the Georgians.
But what's the joke with the "gradual occupation"? Georgia asked to go to Russia when it had already lost more than 2/3 of its lands, and it was Russia that subsequently recaptured these lands and returned them to the Georgians. And this is called in the video “the gradual occupation of more and more Georgian lands.”
What a disgusting pseudo-history channel.
It’s better to read real historical documents and real historians, and not some bloggers on TH-cam.
Claims Georgia owes territories to Moscow because "centuries ago".
Na zi Moscow occupies and annexes neighbours, occupants cries response is "anti-Ruzzian".
@@sergeykish What are you about?
Some kind of drug addiction? Who is seizing territory and where?
@@dimushka383 Na zi pretends like Moscow has not occupied and annexed Ukraine
@@sergeykish Where can you see this? Just rely on the legal meanings of these words.
It is very interesting how the inhabitants of these lands, who have lived there for generations, could occupy the lands of some kind of Ukraine.
It is also very interesting where annexation is in a national referendum without firing a single shot under the supervision of invited observers from all over the world.
@dimushka383 Na zi supports occupation and annexation of Ukraine by Moscow. How occupation and annexation of neighbours ended for Germany?
Russia opening a secondary front goes against the last 200 years of military tactical history.
as soon as i saw the video title I got even more scared cuz somebody thinking the same (says a russian living in Georgia for almost 5 years)
Please stop rotating and tilting the maps. If the map is rotated please put a North indicator on it. Really you don't need those techniques to make it more engaging, a flat map pointed north is cleaner and better.
I see notification I clicked. 😂
2:25 wouldn't that make Georgia the 6th EU member state bordering Russia? Seeing as Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland are already 5
Poland doesn't border Russia
Poland literally borders Russia. What're you smoking? @@ajdeez46
@capes8395 it borders kaliningrad, not mainland Russia.
@@ajdeez46 That's a pointless distinction to make don't you think? It's literally Russia lol plus a massive military presence there, and Belarus.
@capes8395 you should ask the Armenians in ngarno-karabak if it makes a difference
EU is so slow, that's the reason they are losing this region. If they made dicisions faster like Russia does, Russia woldn't be able to spread their influence. Too late EU, there is no going back for Georgia anymore, with Chinese icreasing influece and Russia's presence the region is lost.
It’s incredible that Russia can have such geography to drive it to control as much territory as possible by any means possible.
Its kind of a wild spiral. Russia sees its biggest risk as it's vast borders, and it seeks to resolve that by... expanding its borders
What I want to know is what army they are so afraid of that they are worried about controlling mountain passes? Seems like they have a military that is technologically advanced enough that marching routes shouldn't matter very much. They're not the goddamned Roman Legion.
I don't know how they maintain control of so much territory. There are so many diverse and isolated people in Russian territory who are nothing like the people in Moscow.
@@poorsvids4738 they put ethnic Russians in those territories to run everything during the imperial and soviet eras. That's why Transnistria is the way it is, it's an example of that strategy on the far side of Ukraine from actual Russian land.
Russian should be concerned with China and its relationship with the Russian Federation Countries bordering China. Kazakhstan and the others are warming up to China and China wants Siberia/Outer Manchuria back.
It's not "Say Han". Ceyhan is pronounced as "Jay Han"
Should've opted to use "j" instead of "c" for the [dʒ] sound. Dedicating "j" for the [ʒ] sound, which is only present in words of foreign origin, seems a bit wasteful. Now, you have to suffer forever.
And here I've been, pronouncing it as "Kay Han".
@@inkerilain lol At least the language is 100% phonetic unlike others. Makes it easy
C = Je Ç= Ch and J= sounds like the 'g' in mirage.
I know, I speak Turkish (but not natively). I think it's good that Turkish has a phonetic alphabet.
Let's look at the letter frequencies in Turkish:
Ç: 1.35%
C: 1.12%
J: 0.16%
To me, it makes more sense to use diacritic-less letters for more frequent sounds, so:
[tʃ]: C instead of Ç
[dʒ]: J instead of C
[ʒ]: J̌ (maybe) instead of J
Either way, the "damage" is already done, so it's just theoretical.
no its pronounced general E. LEE
Plz this is ridiculous do you work for NATO this is at least stupid speculation or worst Western propaganda
This video contains a lot of incorrect information about the political context and recent history of Georgia. Saakashvili was not a pro-Western leader, and the Georgian Dream is not a power controlled by Russia. Fact is that Saakashvili celebrated the victory in the Rose Revolution together with Igor Ivanov, who was then the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Russia. I'll leave it up to you to draw your own conclusions
This is a fact that the controlled media desperately tries to hide, but there are people who were alive back then and do not have the memory of a fish. When evaluating all of Saakashvili's decisions, any competent analyst will understand whose interests and influences he was actually serving.
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺👍👍👍
I like how western media sphere simply ignoring the fact that Georgia didn't control this territories in the first place after the Soviet Union had collapsed. And even when Georgia was Soviet Republic both Abkhazia and South Osetia had Autonomous Republic status.
Nobody wants to be part of Russia anymore.