I've been circling it for more than 50 years. More or less taught myself German and then moved there in the mid-80s...in order, mostly, to understand why my sprachenbegabte, pazifistische Onkel sterben musste in that senseless Huertgenwald insanity...
I watched it a week ago (3rd time) as well as The Bunker - same story with Anthony Hopkins as Hitler. It's pretty good though not in Downfall's league. But it's free on YT.
The final comments at the end got me thinking about this quote from a German officer, Peter Rettich where he wrote in his diary, “Who would ever have thought that it would be just a day's march from the Western Front to the Eastern Front?”
I was just thinking about that during last week's episode while looking at the map on the wall behind Indy, showing the areas that are still under occupation by Axis forces. That's 300,000 soldiers, according to Google, still in Norway on VE Day. That many men could have been very useful, for example if they had been withdrawn back to Germany and added to the forces that attacked in December 1944 on the western front in the Battle of the Buldge. I would say that they could have also been useful on the eastern front but the truth is even with that many more men, if they had been sent to the east, wouldn't be able to do much more than act as a speed bump to buy Hitler's Germany another couple days before they too would have been ground up and defeated by the Soviet Red Army at this point in the war. The way things turned out, those troops stationed in Norway until the end of the war had just about the best posting that a German soldier during WW2 could have hoped for. 😀
Imagine how happy those guys are right now. They got to sit out the worst war in history in a country that hadn't been obliterated by air attacks. Going home will be a shock though.
@@snapdragon6601Sometimes I wonder if the Nazi’s forgot about Norway. Little great importance was actually happening there, so you end up not looking at that side of the map.😅
@@snapdragon6601 The notion that German troops in Norway quietly sat out until the end of war is very misleading, especially when it comes to the _Heer_ and _Waffen-SS_ ground combat formations. Unlike ancient armies, the WW2 forces were not constantly deployed on a well-defined piece of territory and (or) fought for just a single day. Therefore, the forces committed in a particular theater of war can vary tremendously from week to week, from month to month and so on. Especially if one theater has greater needs than the other. The same applies to the Germans in Norway. They constantly shuffled the combat formations around. Nobody kept static militaries in these wars, the transfers were always happening. The difficult German situation on the Western and Eastern Fronts in late 1944-45 meant that the _20. Gebirgsarmee_ in Norway served as an important reservoir of available divisions. Thus, from late 1944 to March 1945, the following formations were transferred from Norway to other fronts, where they were bloodied. To the Eastern Front: - 163. Infanterie-Division (February 1945); - 169. Infanterie-Division (March 1945); - 199. Infanterie-Division (March 1945). To the Western Front: - 269. Infanterie-Division (November 1944); - 560. Volksgrenadier-Division (December 1944) - 2. Gebirgs-Division (February 1945); - 6. SS-Gebirgs-Division "Nord" (January 1945); To the Italian Front, then shortly later to the Eastern Front (Hungary): - 710. Infanterie-Division. The 169. and 199. Infanterie-Divisionen were transfered to the Eastern Front in Berlin area at the end of March 1945, just in time to be crushed during the Soviet Berlin Offensive. Remnants of both divisions were taken prisoner by the Soviets, parts of the 199. broke out west and surrendered to the U.S. forces. Meanwhile the 163. Infanterie-Division was destroyed in Pomerania in March 1945. The formations transferred to the Western Front, with the exception of the 269., were heavily damaged and then surrendered to the Allied forces in April-May 1945. For example, the inexperienced 560. Volksgrenadier-Division, despite crushing Allied material superiority, performed well in the Ardennes Campaign but was badly damaged and by March 1945 it was remnants. The 269. Infanterie-Division, however, was transferred to the Eastern Front in late January 1945, where it was destroyed in the Breslau and Ohlau areas soon after. Meanwhile, the 710. Infanterie-Division, which after the transfer from the Arendal area in southern Norway had a short stay in Denmark, was sent to the Italian Front. Barely half a month later, it was sent to the East in Hungary, where it fought in hard and costly battles. In May 1945, survivors of the division managed to reach U.S. lines in Austria and surrendered there. In addition, numerous _Luftwaffe_ aerial and ground units were withdrawn in the spring of 1945 from Norway to Germany.
Berlin's relatively wide boulevards had been a factor in it never having a fire storm in even the heaviest air raids, unlike Hamburg and Dresden. They acted as firebreaks. But they were also hard to defend, especially against a ground attack in force.
I doubt it. Germany would never have been able to raise navy capable of bringing, and supplying as many troops as they fielded in the east. At most, hundreds of thousands would die.
I am covering WWII this week in my college course! You would be amazed how little students know. Only one student knew what the Nuremberg laws were, and none knew the term blitzkrieg. As the WWII generation is passing people are already forgetting the history. I have my entire set of lectures, survey course material, that I am happy to share. I appreciate any channels that make an effort to educate people about WWII.
No. I am long since past being surprised by what little students know. I can't really condemn them seeing how I know next to nothing about art history. Of course, I have zero interest in art history which is why I know nothing. Some just aren't taught while others don't bother looking up things. Anyway, history is one of the things that should be learned if for no other reason than learning from other peoples' mistakes.
A lot of divisions, the Red Army had more then 500 of them, but none was at full strength and they were probably more like at reinforced brigade levels of strength.
@@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623Its true that Soviet divisions between 1944 and 1945 have a strength of 5000 to 7000 men much smaller compare to the Germans and Western Allies, Soviet Mechanized Corps have a strength of a which around 16000 to 17000 men. And a Soviet Tank Corps is a size of a German or Western Allied armor division.
Haha, that Monty Python bit at the beginning certainly took me by surprise! And may I take a brief moment to say: this project to cover the entirety of the war, week by week, has been nothing but stellar. Everyone at the Time Ghost team deserves a round of applause for their most excellent presentation and preservation of world history.
Years ago, I commented that the schtick of answering the phone was silly, yet you persisted, sometimes proving me absolutely wrong with great effect. None better than this one… thanks for the genuine, hearty laugh! And the closed captions were awesome as a result!
@@WorldWarTwo VA in Europe is coming, and the war will be over in a few months. To Indy Spartacus & extraordinary friends, I just have to say it’s been a privilege and an honour be part of this channel watching learning and discussing the war with you all. 😍👍🦋🙌 never forget.
Nah. Indy already said in this episode that they will be backtracking "in a few weeks" to cover the actions the Philippines. The war in Europe ended on May 6th. That's 9 days from now.
All good things in their time. However, the story doesn't really end, it kind-of morphs into the Cold War. Looking forward to the Korea series. I really hope they do some episodes on the origins of the Cold War as preparation for it.
Viscount Field Marshal Slim tried to retire after the war but kept getting promoted and honoured. 1946-47 Commandant Imperial Defence College in London 1949-52 Commander of Imperial General Staff 1953-60 Governor General of Australia
Can also watch the breakdowns from "The Bunker" and "Hitler: The Last Ten Days", less authentic as they are in English, but Anthony Hopkins and Alec Guinness were great to.
It's hilarious seeing his breakdown..to see how someone so successful for so long can come down that low..at that point.simply from not listening to his generals throughout the war and micromanaging.the war..
So here it is. I started at the beginning of the Great War in March 2023. I watched that, the between 2 wars series, and now I’ve finally caught up to live events. Really remarkable the amount of content the crew have produced over the last decade. It’s enough fill an hour a day 5/7 days a week 50 weeks a year for 13 months.
I got a bad feeling for today... it seems that Steiner failed... There is only one thing left to do... "It's the end, the war has been lost Keeping them safe 'til the river's been crossed."
@@andrewstockwell66 Johann Gambolputty de von Ausfern-schplenden-schlitter-crasscrenbon-fried-digger-dangle-dungle-burstein-von-knacker-thrasher-apple-banger-horowitz-ticolensic-grander-knotty-spelltinkle-grandlich-grumblemeyer-spelterwasser-kürstlich-himbleeisen-bahnwagen-gutenabend-bitte-eine-nürnburger-bratwustle-gerspurten-mit-zweimache-luber-hundsfut-gumberaber-shönendanker-kalbsfleisch-mittler-raucher von Hautkopft of Ulm.
@@Ninja-Alinja he ran for office against Malcolm Peter Brian Telescope Adrian Blackpool Rock Stoatgobbler John Raw Vegetable Brrroooo Norman Michael (rings bell) (blows whistle) Edward (sounds car horn) (does train impersonation) (sounds buzzer) Thomas Moo... (sings) "We'll keep a welcome in the..." (fires gun) William (makes silly noise) "Raindrops keep falling on my" (weird noise) "Don't sleep in the subway" (cuckoo cuckoo) Naaoooo... Smith.
Outside the OKW bunker complex at Zossen, the Soviets find the smoking wreck of a colossal 188 metric ton tank, the V2 prototype of PzKpfw Maus. This massive and gigantic tank was planned from 1942 as the ultimate heavy breakthrough vehicle, with armor all around at least 18cm thick and with both a very powerful 12,8cm cannon and a secondary 7,5cm one. The Germans planned to build 135, but American bombing raids on the Krupp plant in Oct 1943 heavily damaged production and the whole thing was cancelled. Only V1 and V2 prototypes would be completed. The Soviets found the damaged V1, which lacked a turret and thus had no guns, near Kummersdorf. They will go on to salvage the V1, and V2's turret and bring them back to their own Kubinka test facility where they remain to this day
This has been an spectacular episode. For six years I've been following this channel and I just can't believe we're here now, at the gates of Berlin. Congrats to Indy, Sparty, Astrid and the whole team for making this possible. Greetings from Spain.
Once the Western Allies got across the Rhine in force it was off to the races. It really highlights how much of a disaster it was for the Ludendorff bridge to be taken intact.
So many Soviet units marching towards Berlin, the map around Berlin becomes incomprehensible. It's not a bad thing though, it's just the reality of how crazy huge the Soviet force was.
I imagine many of us have watched or re-watched Downfall recently. James Holland rates it fairly highly in terms of accuracy. Hitler's famous rant after he discovers Steiner isn't coming to the rescue is more-or-less how it really went down (based on witness reports).
@@Nintendo0994 Lower ranking people who were in the bunker at that time survived the war and eventually wrote books. For five years, Rochus Misch was part of the Fuehrer's inner circle, as a bodyguard, a courier and telephone operator Secretary Traudl Junge Valet Heinz Linge
I harbor a little guilt for being so relaxed and entertained on the weekend by the presentation of events that caused so much death and destruction. This is mitigated by Time Ghost's conscientious efforts to illustrate well the human element and reality of suffering in WAH and elsewhere. Thanks for keeping it real, and may the fallen rest in peace.
I read “The Last Battle” by Cornelius Ryan a long time ago. It was a fairly painful read during my teenage years. It had been difficult for me to understand why 3-4 million people had been butchered in Bangladesh before its independence. That is when I went on a binge reading journey. My mom fed me books like Anne Franks Diary, war and peace, Decades later, I think I am still far from understanding anything. This series is helping me to accept a few things about the human condition.
The perfect storm of the ego of those commanders wanting the glory, coupled with Stalin playing them against each other because they loathed each other.
I just want to thank you for this show. The week-by-week format helped me grasp just how long three weeks or three months actually are when you're living through them. Without this understanding, I might have gone crazy following the war in Ukraine, but your series has taught me patience.
It took me about a year, but as of today, I am finally caught up. I started watching months ago week to week, but I finally caught all the way up, having watched every single episode. Now I have to do the Great War, Spies and Ties, Between Two Wars, and War Against Humanity as well…
Thanks so much for the Monty Python gag at the opening! Johann Gamblepudding de von blah blah blah yadda yadda etc etc ....of Ulm! Loved it. And congrats, because that is a mouthful to say. Bravo, Indy!
Something I appreciate thanks to this weekly coverage is the true scale of specific events. The Battle for Berlin looms large in the history of the war, and is a very evocative event. But this episode highlights how one-sided, how small a geographic area and how short the battle is. The quote is spot on - this is no Stalingrad. Great episode!
that one comment in live chat "THE ALLIES ARE COOKING YA’LL" they really were, advances everywhere, german withdrawals, surrenders seeing Berlin on the map completely surrounded by Soviet forces is incredible after the long LONG trek here. i only started watching when year 3 was being produced but i've thoroughly appreciated this content for all the information given
"Es ist dem Feind gelungen, die Front in breiter Formation zu durchbrechen. Im Süden hat der Gegner Zossen genommen und stößt auf Stahnsdorf vor. Der Feind operiert jetzt am nördlichen Stadtrand zwischen Frohnau und Pankow, und im Osten ist der Feind bis zur Linie Lichtenberg, Mahlsdorf, Karlshorst gelangt."
I remember watching the 1st episode of this show the day it came out. I watched the Barabarossa special live in lockdown. Going further back I remember watching The Great War weekly for 4 years while I was still in school. Crazy how far we've come.
Fun fact: The last german battlefield victory in WW2, where the germans managed to retake ground and force enemy troops into a retreat that was not part of a breakout attempt (so no 12th and 9th army next episode) happenedagainst polish troops fighting for the soviets around the city of Görlitz. The german army group centers "offensive" north, that is mentioned in this video very shortly, breaks through and nearly routes the polish divisions defending the flank of Konevs Berlin advance, forcing the polish troops into retreat and retaking Görlitz from them. The soviets had to send in reserves to stop the breakthrough. Its ironic that germanys first and last "victory" on the battlefield was agaisnt polish troops.
Baguio is an amazing city. A million people at the top of unbelievably steep mountains. 4 roads into the city. I would love to know more about how the troops even climbed to the top of the mountains to literate Baguio.
As a fellow educator and someone who has created a lot of audio and video recordings, this was hands down the best opening I’ve seen for any streaming series. The amount of time to prepare and rehearse that, which cannot be readily done from a teleprompter, is incredibly impressive. Well done!
I imagine it will be about German top brass preparing May Day celebrations down in the Bunker. Parades through Berlin, dancing girls, brass bands, free steines of beer, swastika adorned streamers. Yes, that'll be it.
The ghost of Fredrich the Great will convince the British and Americans to fight against the Soviets, and thus giving Hitler the miracle he wanted to turn this war around.
It feels like forever ago that we started on this long journey through history, so amazing how far all of you at Timeghost have come with all of this amazing content.
I guess they aren't all positioned on the same depth so that's probably not as bad. I mean, not that the difference mattered for the Germans on the receiving end 😅
I can't believe that we now close to the end of this project. 6 years of an overwhelming amount of information, details and stories......realy a great work. Greetings from Germany.
Normally with Steiner, Germany has a 50% chance of winning. But throw in the Belorussian Front, Rokossovsky, Zhukov, you got 33 1/3, at best. Then add Konev's First Ukrainian Front, your chances of winning drastic go down. The numbers don't lie. And that spells trouble for the Third Reich.
Its crazy how far we have come!! Literally started watching this during the times of norway conquest and here we are just two days away from Hitler's suicide!! I have nothing but respect for these creators!! Dedication at its peak!
My Dad was one of the first Poles into Bologna, as a Assault Pioneer they were clearing the rout of mines into the city at 3am , getting there finish line wrong they ended up in the City being mobbed by cheering locals, at least that's how he used to tell it, still miss him
Notice the few nonsoviet flags in Berlin? For political reasons, some Soviet controlled Polish units get to fight in the final battle, just as their countrymen of Second Corps in Italy capture Bologna. Poland might have been first to be invaded, but it never gave up and now has some bitter satisfaction.
Well not quite. The Czechs and Austrians were invaded before the Poles, but the invasion of Poland was the final straw that pushed Britain (and its empire) into declaring war on Germany.
At about this time, a Captain Cooper of the British Army's Border Regiment wrote in his memoirs that his unit captured a Japanese straggler in Burma. Not long after an elderly Sikh who was in Bose's INA was captured, though he tried to talk his way out of it. The Japanese was given some rations and turned loose (for years after, stray Japanese personnel were scattered all over south-east Asia - some never got back to Japan). Cooper decided to hang onto the Sikh as he didn't like "traitors".
@@stevekaczynski3793Probably might be true. But being traitor in this sense is only a perspective. Would one see the Irish as traitors? Not the perfect comparison but anyway
I started watching this series five years ago when it started. Im sorry I didnt end up watching a lot of it. Im a WW2/history freak and its so cool that they covered everyday! So u could almost live through it.
When Indy mentioned Ulm at the beginning, Johan Gambolputty was the first thing that came to my mind and I thought, surely he is not going to go there, right? Right? Well played
Back in August there was an episode titled “Hitler has a bad day” I think this week has definitely topped that day
next week will be even worse
But wait, there's more......
Don’t worry. Next week for Hitler will be mind blowing.
@@senatorarmstrong4168he gonna lose his last ball
Hitler has no balls at all
Next week will be a banger
Spoiler: Steiner couldnt mass enough forces guys
Theres still time
Everybody leave TH-cam except Indy, Astrid, Spartacus, and Mark Felton.
DAS WAR EIN BEFEHL!
Guys Im not gonna sugarcoat it I think Das Krieg ist Forbei
FEGELEIN
It’s been an honor. Watched downfall last night in preparation for this video. Crazy how far we have come to this point.
I've been circling it for more than 50 years. More or less taught myself German and then moved there in the mid-80s...in order, mostly, to understand why my sprachenbegabte, pazifistische Onkel sterben musste in that senseless Huertgenwald insanity...
I watched it a week ago (3rd time) as well as The Bunker - same story with Anthony Hopkins as Hitler. It's pretty good though not in Downfall's league. But it's free on YT.
Where did you see downfall, I can’t find it on streaming?
@@somethingelse516 Downfall is actually on TH-cam for free!
@@somethingelse516it’s free on you tube.
The final comments at the end got me thinking about this quote from a German officer, Peter Rettich where he wrote in his diary, “Who would ever have thought that it would be just a day's march from the Western Front to the Eastern Front?”
Makes commuting quite easy, ja?
Squire has a video about this.
The fact there were hundreds of thousands of German troops in Norway when this was happening will always be something I find staggering.
I was just thinking about that during last week's episode while looking at the map on the wall behind Indy, showing the areas that are still under occupation by Axis forces. That's 300,000 soldiers, according to Google, still in Norway on VE Day. That many men could have been very useful, for example if they had been withdrawn back to Germany and added to the forces that attacked in December 1944 on the western front in the Battle of the Buldge. I would say that they could have also been useful on the eastern front but the truth is even with that many more men, if they had been sent to the east, wouldn't be able to do much more than act as a speed bump to buy Hitler's Germany another couple days before they too would have been ground up and defeated by the Soviet Red Army at this point in the war.
The way things turned out, those troops stationed in Norway until the end of the war had just about the best posting that a German soldier during WW2 could have hoped for. 😀
Imagine how happy those guys are right now. They got to sit out the worst war in history in a country that hadn't been obliterated by air attacks. Going home will be a shock though.
Hans: Good time to be ignored, ja Dietrich?
@@snapdragon6601Sometimes I wonder if the Nazi’s forgot about Norway. Little great importance was actually happening there, so you end up not looking at that side of the map.😅
@@snapdragon6601 The notion that German troops in Norway quietly sat out until the end of war is very misleading, especially when it comes to the _Heer_ and _Waffen-SS_ ground combat formations.
Unlike ancient armies, the WW2 forces were not constantly deployed on a well-defined piece of territory and (or) fought for just a single day. Therefore, the forces committed in a particular theater of war can vary tremendously from week to week, from month to month and so on. Especially if one theater has greater needs than the other.
The same applies to the Germans in Norway. They constantly shuffled the combat formations around. Nobody kept static militaries in these wars, the transfers were always happening.
The difficult German situation on the Western and Eastern Fronts in late 1944-45 meant that the _20. Gebirgsarmee_ in Norway served as an important reservoir of available divisions. Thus, from late 1944 to March 1945, the following formations were transferred from Norway to other fronts, where they were bloodied.
To the Eastern Front:
- 163. Infanterie-Division (February 1945);
- 169. Infanterie-Division (March 1945);
- 199. Infanterie-Division (March 1945).
To the Western Front:
- 269. Infanterie-Division (November 1944);
- 560. Volksgrenadier-Division (December 1944)
- 2. Gebirgs-Division (February 1945);
- 6. SS-Gebirgs-Division "Nord" (January 1945);
To the Italian Front, then shortly later to the Eastern Front (Hungary):
- 710. Infanterie-Division.
The 169. and 199. Infanterie-Divisionen were transfered to the Eastern Front in Berlin area at the end of March 1945, just in time to be crushed during the Soviet Berlin Offensive. Remnants of both divisions were taken prisoner by the Soviets, parts of the 199. broke out west and surrendered to the U.S. forces. Meanwhile the 163. Infanterie-Division was destroyed in Pomerania in March 1945.
The formations transferred to the Western Front, with the exception of the 269., were heavily damaged and then surrendered to the Allied forces in April-May 1945.
For example, the inexperienced 560. Volksgrenadier-Division, despite crushing Allied material superiority, performed well in the Ardennes Campaign but was badly damaged and by March 1945 it was remnants. The 269. Infanterie-Division, however, was transferred to the Eastern Front in late January 1945, where it was destroyed in the Breslau and Ohlau areas soon after.
Meanwhile, the 710. Infanterie-Division, which after the transfer from the Arendal area in southern Norway had a short stay in Denmark, was sent to the Italian Front. Barely half a month later, it was sent to the East in Hungary, where it fought in hard and costly battles. In May 1945, survivors of the division managed to reach U.S. lines in Austria and surrendered there.
In addition, numerous _Luftwaffe_ aerial and ground units were withdrawn in the spring of 1945 from Norway to Germany.
“Berlin was no Stalingrad” what a quote
The British Home Guard would have put them both to shame
@@Matt-xc6spor maybe even Japans home guard
Berlin's relatively wide boulevards had been a factor in it never having a fire storm in even the heaviest air raids, unlike Hamburg and Dresden. They acted as firebreaks. But they were also hard to defend, especially against a ground attack in force.
@@Matt-xc6spyou stupid boy.
I doubt it. Germany would never have been able to raise navy capable of bringing, and supplying as many troops as they fielded in the east. At most, hundreds of thousands would die.
I don’t think Germany are gonna win guys
Bit of a grey area
@@badmutherfunster Darkest hour is just before the dawn.
Are Germany gonna win girls?
Maybe an alien invasion last second can still turn things around?
Defeatists are being shot by the SS. Look out Kamerad.
"Das war ein Befehl!! Der Angriff Steiner's war ein Befehl!"
Fegelein Fegelein Fegelein!!!
I definitely can read this in that voice
This is the first time I am reading this in German and know how it is spelled.
@@bagelsecelle9308 I can, at the End of a hard and frustrating Day in Retail.
Und was heisst hier "Befehl"? Von wem?
After watching this series for 6 years, it’s crazy we’re here and I imagine it’s what it felt when Berlin actually fell.
Indeed it was quite the journey! -TimeGhost Ambassador
I have gotten married, have a house and now 2 kids. It's going to feel weird when this is all over...what a long strange trip it's been.
Much like their coverage of WW1, doing this week by week can ram home how this war was.
I am covering WWII this week in my college course! You would be amazed how little students know. Only one student knew what the Nuremberg laws were, and none knew the term blitzkrieg. As the WWII generation is passing people are already forgetting the history. I have my entire set of lectures, survey course material, that I am happy to share. I appreciate any channels that make an effort to educate people about WWII.
when i was at school, only 2 people knew what pearl harbour was - I was one of them.
@thesupremepizza6893 wow. That is so sad. One reason I put all my lectures on yt is to help folks learn history
No. I am long since past being surprised by what little students know. I can't really condemn them seeing how I know next to nothing about art history. Of course, I have zero interest in art history which is why I know nothing. Some just aren't taught while others don't bother looking up things. Anyway, history is one of the things that should be learned if for no other reason than learning from other peoples' mistakes.
i can kind of see the Nuremberg laws one ig but not ONE of them knew what Blitzkrieg or Bewungenskrieg was?
Almost nobody knows anything about WW2. Yet somehow they EXACTLY know who and what a fascist is. Think about that.
3:08 That looks ridiculously dense, the amout of Soviet divisions in that small area is insane.
So many red squares !
A lot of divisions, the Red Army had more then 500 of them, but none was at full strength and they were probably more like at reinforced brigade levels of strength.
That’s about 2.5 million men making up all of those divisions, fucking crazy to see that
@@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623Its true that Soviet divisions between 1944 and 1945 have a strength of 5000 to 7000 men much smaller compare to the Germans and Western Allies, Soviet Mechanized Corps have a strength of a which around 16000 to 17000 men. And a Soviet Tank Corps is a size of a German or Western Allied armor division.
@@yurinalysis8034 Yeah Soviet tank corps were pretty formidable.
Haha, that Monty Python bit at the beginning certainly took me by surprise!
And may I take a brief moment to say: this project to cover the entirety of the war, week by week, has been nothing but stellar. Everyone at the Time Ghost team deserves a round of applause for their most excellent presentation and preservation of world history.
clap!
NOBODY expects a Monty Python reference. Its chief weapon is fear, fear and surprise, TWO chief weapons!
Years ago, I commented that the schtick of answering the phone was silly, yet you persisted, sometimes proving me absolutely wrong with great effect. None better than this one… thanks for the genuine, hearty laugh! And the closed captions were awesome as a result!
The Time Ghost team have made some brilliant gags throughout the series.
Thanks a lot for appreciating them! -TimeGhost Ambassador
It's the old Bob Newhart schtick.
@@WorldWarTwo VA in Europe is coming, and the war will be over in a few months. To Indy Spartacus & extraordinary friends, I just have to say it’s been a privilege and an honour be part of this channel watching learning and discussing the war with you all. 😍👍🦋🙌 never forget.
@@joelellis7035 "That's a torpedo you got there Bob."
Only a couple of weeks until the war in europe and the coverage of it ends. Really sad after getting so used to watching it for 6 years
Remember 2018? Gods we were strong then
Whats with the War in the Pacific?
I thought they said theyd cover the after war period…
Nah. Indy already said in this episode that they will be backtracking "in a few weeks" to cover the actions the Philippines. The war in Europe ended on May 6th. That's 9 days from now.
All good things in their time. However, the story doesn't really end, it kind-of morphs into the Cold War. Looking forward to the Korea series. I really hope they do some episodes on the origins of the Cold War as preparation for it.
_taking glasses off as hand twitching_
"anyone who doesn't get the downfall memes leave the room now"
Mine furher, the broncos have traded Tebow…
My favourite is the insane Crusader father discovering his son's waifu girlfriend on Bread Boys...
Mussolini really shouldn’t have tried to repair that piano
He meant well, but Il Duce is all thumbs...
He really shouldn't have stopped for petrol.
I forsee a series about why Italy was bad in WW2.
”Mussolini really shouldn’t have” is sort of his motto.
I didn't know about (eventual) Field Marshall William Slim before this series. Now I have incredible respect for him. Thanks, Indy.
I was just thinking the same thing after this latest video.
Viscount Field Marshal Slim tried to retire after the war but kept getting promoted and honoured.
1946-47 Commandant Imperial Defence College in London
1949-52 Commander of Imperial General Staff
1953-60 Governor General of Australia
The greatest British general of WW2 hands down.
Uh I wouldn't say that. Considering he might be a pedophile (like a lot of British generals)
Time to watch that scene from "Downfall"/"Der Untergang". The one where Hitler is informed that Steiner is not making the attack he was ordered to.
Can also watch the breakdowns from "The Bunker" and "Hitler: The Last Ten Days", less authentic as they are in English, but Anthony Hopkins and Alec Guinness were great to.
It's hilarious seeing his breakdown..to see how someone so successful for so long can come down that low..at that point.simply from not listening to his generals throughout the war and micromanaging.the war..
@@kurtjammer9568 this is what drugs do to you...😆
@@wikingagresor Yes indeed. His "doctor" Theodor Morell wasn't dubbed the Reich Minister of Injections for nothing.
It’s actually him yelling about being banned from Xbox Live.
Thank you for all the hard work, I can't belive it's over soon!
Thank you very much!
I just know Steiner has this in the bag!
Delusions can be treated.
Thank you for making the same tired unfunny joke 10,000 other people have made in the past year.
DAS WAR EIN BEFEHL! DER ANGRIFF STEINER WAR EIN BEFEHL!
Steiner is helping Dragovich with Nova 6
@@_ArsNovait's still funny, I still laughed
Not only that, but where is Fegelein?
FEGELEIN!! FEGELEIN!! FEGELEIN!!
Conga line ! Conga line ! Cong Line
Wie, bitte?
Spoiler: Oddly enough, he and Ribbentrop will be found respectively in the company of a young woman while wearing nothing.
Partying with women of I'll repute. He even took his tie off!!!!!
@@shaider1982 Huuuh... I didn't know that. Didn't he end up in Nurnburg with Speer, Hess, and Herman Meyer?
"You never heard of Ulm?"
I did. I live there. Nice to here that the town was finally captured.
My wife taught me 'In Ulm, um Ulm, und rund um Ulm herum'
Europa Universalis taught me about Ulm
So here it is. I started at the beginning of the Great War in March 2023. I watched that, the between 2 wars series, and now I’ve finally caught up to live events. Really remarkable the amount of content the crew have produced over the last decade. It’s enough fill an hour a day 5/7 days a week 50 weeks a year for 13 months.
I got a bad feeling for today... it seems that Steiner failed... There is only one thing left to do...
"It's the end, the war has been lost
Keeping them safe 'til the river's been crossed."
Packwatch stands ready
"Nicht ein Schlacht, ein Rettungsaktion"
@@Malkuth-Gaming Holding their ground to the final platoon
@@F15_Churry up we’re waiting for you
@@joemamaobama6863 Man of the Ninth and civilians too.
On this day 27th of April 1945 the last german troops leave finnish territory, ending the Lapland War and thus the WWII for Finland.
And this day has ever since been a National Veterans' Day in Finland.
СССР имел право превратить Финляндию в пустошь😂😂😂за блокаду Ленинграда
P.s.: that Monty Python reference was epic.
Was that the "write a book" line? I had to listen to that 3 times and I still don't get it, what's the reference?
@@andrewstockwell66 Johann Gambolputty de von Ausfern-schplenden-schlitter-crasscrenbon-fried-digger-dangle-dungle-burstein-von-knacker-thrasher-apple-banger-horowitz-ticolensic-grander-knotty-spelltinkle-grandlich-grumblemeyer-spelterwasser-kürstlich-himbleeisen-bahnwagen-gutenabend-bitte-eine-nürnburger-bratwustle-gerspurten-mit-zweimache-luber-hundsfut-gumberaber-shönendanker-kalbsfleisch-mittler-raucher von Hautkopft of Ulm.
@@Ninja-Alinja oh lol the thing at the beginning 😅
Not the joke we expected, but the one we laughed at. :)
@@Ninja-Alinja he ran for office against Malcolm Peter Brian Telescope Adrian Blackpool Rock Stoatgobbler John Raw Vegetable Brrroooo Norman Michael (rings bell) (blows whistle) Edward (sounds car horn) (does train impersonation) (sounds buzzer) Thomas Moo... (sings) "We'll keep a welcome in the..." (fires gun) William (makes silly noise) "Raindrops keep falling on my" (weird noise) "Don't sleep in the subway" (cuckoo cuckoo) Naaoooo... Smith.
Outside the OKW bunker complex at Zossen, the Soviets find the smoking wreck of a colossal 188 metric ton tank, the V2 prototype of PzKpfw Maus. This massive and gigantic tank was planned from 1942 as the ultimate heavy breakthrough vehicle, with armor all around at least 18cm thick and with both a very powerful 12,8cm cannon and a secondary 7,5cm one. The Germans planned to build 135, but American bombing raids on the Krupp plant in Oct 1943 heavily damaged production and the whole thing was cancelled. Only V1 and V2 prototypes would be completed. The Soviets found the damaged V1, which lacked a turret and thus had no guns, near Kummersdorf. They will go on to salvage the V1, and V2's turret and bring them back to their own Kubinka test facility where they remain to this day
This has been an spectacular episode. For six years I've been following this channel and I just can't believe we're here now, at the gates of Berlin. Congrats to Indy, Sparty, Astrid and the whole team for making this possible. Greetings from Spain.
Mussolini may be battered and on the ropes, but he's not falling down!
Italians: We don’t traditionally do pinatas….but you know there’s a first time for everything….
Yeah, he'll still be... hanging around for a bit.
@@sonicgoo1121 🤣👊
You just now Mussolini will go out feet first.
I don't know, i think hes on the hook for a lot of things.
It's unreal to see Soviet Union and Western-Allies frontlines so close to each others. It's like "wow! When did you guys get here?"
It was sad that the joy both sides felt when meeting each other turned to division so soon after.
Once the Western Allies got across the Rhine in force it was off to the races. It really highlights how much of a disaster it was for the Ludendorff bridge to be taken intact.
We drove here from Atlantic City, a lot of water the middle. How was your trip?
@@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 And ever since then, apart from 1991-2014, it's been the same.
So many Soviet units marching towards Berlin, the map around Berlin becomes incomprehensible. It's not a bad thing though, it's just the reality of how crazy huge the Soviet force was.
“…of Ulm!” The Monty Python reference was epic! One of my favorite skits!
I imagine many of us have watched or re-watched Downfall recently. James Holland rates it fairly highly in terms of accuracy. Hitler's famous rant after he discovers Steiner isn't coming to the rescue is more-or-less how it really went down (based on witness reports).
What members of the german high command present at that meeting ended up giving these accounts?
@@Nintendo0994 Lower ranking people who were in the bunker at that time survived the war and eventually wrote books.
For five years, Rochus Misch was part of the Fuehrer's inner circle, as a bodyguard, a courier and telephone operator
Secretary Traudl Junge
Valet Heinz Linge
So he was really that upset about being banned from Xbox live?
i saved the book for 2 years.. started reading it april 20th
I harbor a little guilt for being so relaxed and entertained on the weekend by the presentation of events that caused so much death and destruction.
This is mitigated by Time Ghost's conscientious efforts to illustrate well the human element and reality of suffering in WAH and elsewhere.
Thanks for keeping it real, and may the fallen rest in peace.
Can’t believe it’s been 5 years with you guys . Thanks for making my Saturday always more interesting and more enjoyable .
Hard to believe I've been following this for almost 6 years now. I'm going to miss this series in a few months.
I'm astounded by Indy's ability to speak German in the intro
He is, in fact, a man of many talents -TimeGhost Ambassador
I was tempted to tell Indy "supercalifragilisticexpyalidocious" but it is nowhere near long enough to impress him! 🤯
These are filmed in Berlin (correct me if I’m wrong) so it would make sense if he had a good command of the German language.
@@Icicle_RacingYou are wrong.
That was probably just one word. 😆And I know where Ulm is having been there a few times.
I read “The Last Battle” by Cornelius Ryan a long time ago. It was a fairly painful read during my teenage years. It had been difficult for me to understand why 3-4 million people had been butchered in Bangladesh before its independence. That is when I went on a binge reading journey. My mom fed me books like Anne Franks Diary, war and peace, Decades later, I think I am still far from understanding anything. This series is helping me to accept a few things about the human condition.
Frankly, the human race is a mess and always has been.
It's truly remarkable given our ability to do literally anything we want, that's what we've been doing for the most part in history.
this has been an epic series, def going to rewatch it once its done, mass respect for the team for managing to do this for 6 whole years
Indy, you are among the best historical journalists of all time. Thank you for your work.
With all the soviet commanders rushing to get to berlin first, really puts into perspective why soviet casualties were so high for such a short battle
The perfect storm of the ego of those commanders wanting the glory, coupled with Stalin playing them against each other because they loathed each other.
@@chaptermasterpedrokantor1623 The animal cunning and treachery of Stalin knows no bounds.
nice pfp bro
Is disgusting how they are willing to sacrifice so many man for glory
@@jamessicker Almost like Patton, actually...
I just want to thank you for this show. The week-by-week format helped me grasp just how long three weeks or three months actually are when you're living through them. Without this understanding, I might have gone crazy following the war in Ukraine, but your series has taught me patience.
It took me about a year, but as of today, I am finally caught up. I started watching months ago week to week, but I finally caught all the way up, having watched every single episode. Now I have to do the Great War, Spies and Ties, Between Two Wars, and War Against Humanity as well…
Your previous channel has a great documentary about the battle of Berlin.
For anyone curious, the documentary is 16 Days in Berlin, I’ve watched it and I gotta say it’s fantastic
Yes
“Mein Fuhrer…Steiner…”
“Steiner has been playing his Xbox for the past few months. He’s 243rd on Battlefield 4’s leaderboard.”
Thanks
Thank you very much!
We all know what we want after the WWII series come to end:The 100 years war - week by week!
It will be very boring though. For 95% of that war nothing happened.
So, they turn this into a generational channel, where it starts with them and ends with their great grand children?
remember kids it actually lasted 116 years, you'll need a longer life extending machine
It should be a post world war two channel and early iron curtain era of stalin until 1953 😎
I can't believe we're here already. I swear you just did the Pearl Harbor special
Time flies when you’re learning, I guess.
Same here. Feels like the D-Day special was just a couple of weeks ago.
@@JarodFarrant It needs to stop doing that, I'm getting old.
Thanks so much for the Monty Python gag at the opening! Johann Gamblepudding de von blah blah blah yadda yadda etc etc ....of Ulm! Loved it. And congrats, because that is a mouthful to say. Bravo, Indy!
Something I appreciate thanks to this weekly coverage is the true scale of specific events. The Battle for Berlin looms large in the history of the war, and is a very evocative event. But this episode highlights how one-sided, how small a geographic area and how short the battle is. The quote is spot on - this is no Stalingrad.
Great episode!
that one comment in live chat "THE ALLIES ARE COOKING YA’LL" they really were, advances everywhere, german withdrawals, surrenders
seeing Berlin on the map completely surrounded by Soviet forces is incredible after the long LONG trek here.
i only started watching when year 3 was being produced but i've thoroughly appreciated this content for all the information given
There's a bullet out there somewhere about to have a big day
Too bad it came from his own gun. The man had the Devil's luck!
Nine grams, as the Soviets would say...
It's not like he could retire to an old age home.
The pistol used looks like the type favored by James Bond.
@@joelellis7035 yup, he does has the devil"s lucm as said by Mark Felton.
"Es ist dem Feind gelungen, die Front in breiter Formation zu durchbrechen.
Im Süden hat der Gegner Zossen genommen und stößt auf Stahnsdorf vor. Der Feind operiert jetzt am nördlichen Stadtrand zwischen Frohnau und Pankow, und im Osten ist der Feind bis zur Linie Lichtenberg, Mahlsdorf, Karlshorst gelangt."
Mit der Angriff Steiner's mit des alles nung ordnung kommen.
Mein Führer, Steiner...
Steiner konnte nicht genügend Kräfte für einen Angriff massieren. Der Angriff Steiner ist nicht erfolgt!
Es bleiben im Raum Keitel,Jodel, Krebs und Burgdorf.
Es bleiben im Raum: Keitel, Jodl, Krebs und Burgdorf.
An absolute tour de force this week guys. Many thanks.
5:13 Wow, that was cool how you superimposed your animated map of the battle on the table in front of AH.
Having done a Battle Staff ride of the Battle of Berlin -you do a great job breaking this battle down. Bravo
kudos for the Monty Python reference
We're in the endgame now, folks.
Ironically Endgame came out this week 5 years ago
Nah, Germany will turn it around. You'll see!
@@keithscott1957did not see that coming
@@keithscott1957 Rrrrrrriiiiiigggggghhhhhttttt
We’ve been here mate
I have watched ww2 channel since 2019 thanks for all your hard work.
I remember watching the 1st episode of this show the day it came out. I watched the Barabarossa special live in lockdown. Going further back I remember watching The Great War weekly for 4 years while I was still in school. Crazy how far we've come.
How many takes did it take Indy to get that intro?
That's why it was so late in posting. 😂
I have a mental image of Spartacus standing behind the camera holding up cue cards with this... guy's name...
It was like yesterday the Germans were at the gates of Warsaw, and now the Polish 1st army is at the gates of Berlin.
Fun fact: The last german battlefield victory in WW2, where the germans managed to retake ground and force enemy troops into a retreat that was not part of a breakout attempt (so no 12th and 9th army next episode) happenedagainst polish troops fighting for the soviets around the city of Görlitz.
The german army group centers "offensive" north, that is mentioned in this video very shortly, breaks through and nearly routes the polish divisions defending the flank of Konevs Berlin advance, forcing the polish troops into retreat and retaking Görlitz from them. The soviets had to send in reserves to stop the breakthrough.
Its ironic that germanys first and last "victory" on the battlefield was agaisnt polish troops.
Bill Slim's hat and moustache combo is just spectacular
His troops said he always came across as so casual and friendly that they almost forgot he was a Field Marshal.
Baguio is an amazing city. A million people at the top of unbelievably steep mountains. 4 roads into the city. I would love to know more about how the troops even climbed to the top of the mountains to literate Baguio.
So... finally the day of The Rant came.
I dont understand why this channel does not get more views, i love your videos
20:01 Eastern Hunan is where my ex-wife is from, her great-grandparents got to see the fighting there.
As a fellow educator and someone who has created a lot of audio and video recordings, this was hands down the best opening I’ve seen for any streaming series. The amount of time to prepare and rehearse that, which cannot be readily done from a teleprompter, is incredibly impressive. Well done!
The Karens rising up is not something I thought I would hear about in WW2.
They are literally fighting the Myanmar government right now in 2024.
They had enough of the jokes lmao
they want to speak to Japan's manager
I’m not surprised at how merciless they are, however, I am surprised that the Karens are so effective.
"Do you know who I am!"
It's so surreal to watch the Battle of actual Berlin unfold. We've come a long way.
A bonus regular episode on April 30? I wonder what's gonna happen
Must be Steiner's attack. ;)
🤔🤔🤔
I imagine it will be about German top brass preparing May Day celebrations down in the Bunker. Parades through Berlin, dancing girls, brass bands, free steines of beer, swastika adorned streamers. Yes, that'll be it.
Think ‘kaput.’ Think ‘downfall’. Think about the guy who did the world a service by killing Hitler.
The ghost of Fredrich the Great will convince the British and Americans to fight against the Soviets, and thus giving Hitler the miracle he wanted to turn this war around.
It feels like forever ago that we started on this long journey through history, so amazing how far all of you at Timeghost have come with all of this amazing content.
I'll watch the episode later. I hope Steiner succeeds. No spoilers pls
Delusions can be treated.
I thought I knew everything about ww2 but obviously not. Awesome content, I love the format
Thank you, glad you enjoy these videos.
-TimeGhost Ambassador
650 guns per Km is 154cm per gun. Those guns are no longer wheel to wheel there is only a barrel’s width between the barrels.
😂😂
I guess they aren't all positioned on the same depth so that's probably not as bad. I mean, not that the difference mattered for the Germans on the receiving end 😅
@@amogusenjoyer I think we also have to assume that Katushya is still sending her aid and best wishes to her soldier love in the west as well.
I think you're confusing centimeters and millimeters. 155 cm is 10x longer than 155mm.
155 cm = just over 5ft.
155 mm = just over 6 inches.
I just noticed the map on Adolfs' desk at 5:11-5:35, very nice little detail. Well done.
16:47 Just noticed that Switzerland in the top left is marked red
It’s finally here boys and girls! The most anticipated episode, the meme lives. Rip Bruno Ganz
You all be excited about Berlin, while I'm just waiting for the world to be turned upside down in Milan
Mussolini will be a toilet tomorrow
I can't believe that we now close to the end of this project. 6 years of an overwhelming amount of information, details and stories......realy a great work. Greetings from Germany.
Everything’s just collapsed by now
Especially now that the Karens have risen up, demanding to speak to the emperor
Literally who
Can't believe I've been watching since Stalingrad and Midway all the way to Berlin. It's been a great ride
I was here since the Germans approached Moscow. It's insane how far this series has come.
I have been waiting on Steiner for weeks!
So has Hitler 😂
@@DazzleCamo You beat me to it
One of the best channels on the internet period.....
Normally with Steiner, Germany has a 50% chance of winning. But throw in the Belorussian Front, Rokossovsky, Zhukov, you got 33 1/3, at best. Then add Konev's First Ukrainian Front, your chances of winning drastic go down. The numbers don't lie. And that spells trouble for the Third Reich.
NEVER !!!!!
The
Russians
Overtake
Ulm,
Berlin,
Linz,
Etc.
That spells trouble.
Stalin is reputed to have said that quantity has a quality all its own, and that was largely how the Red Army conducted the war.
@@stevekaczynski3793 Or as some armchair youtube historian once put it: "In war, having stuff is good"
You and your team are always brilliant, Indy. I love watching this series and learn so much from it.
Hmmm, I wonder why would you choose 30th to talk about the bunker🤔
Mind-blowing isn't it!
Its crazy how far we have come!! Literally started watching this during the times of norway conquest and here we are just two days away from Hitler's suicide!! I have nothing but respect for these creators!! Dedication at its peak!
I know Ulm because that’s where the unfortunate General Mack surrendered before the battle of Austerlitz.
Best. Best. Best phone call of all sir. Bravo.
My Dad was one of the first Poles into Bologna, as a Assault Pioneer they were clearing the rout of mines into the city at 3am , getting there finish line wrong they ended up in the City being mobbed by cheering locals, at least that's how he used to tell it, still miss him
Notice the few nonsoviet flags in Berlin? For political reasons, some Soviet controlled Polish units get to fight in the final battle, just as their countrymen of Second Corps in Italy capture Bologna.
Poland might have been first to be invaded, but it never gave up and now has some bitter satisfaction.
Well not quite. The Czechs and Austrians were invaded before the Poles, but the invasion of Poland was the final straw that pushed Britain (and its empire) into declaring war on Germany.
Just rewatching this and noticing the animated map at 5:26, awesome touch!
Didn't notice any special on Chandra Bose's Indian National Army. Might be worth a shot. Al Murray has a podcast on it
At about this time, a Captain Cooper of the British Army's Border Regiment wrote in his memoirs that his unit captured a Japanese straggler in Burma. Not long after an elderly Sikh who was in Bose's INA was captured, though he tried to talk his way out of it. The Japanese was given some rations and turned loose (for years after, stray Japanese personnel were scattered all over south-east Asia - some never got back to Japan). Cooper decided to hang onto the Sikh as he didn't like "traitors".
@@stevekaczynski3793Probably might be true. But being traitor in this sense is only a perspective. Would one see the Irish as traitors? Not the perfect comparison but anyway
@@PS-nf3xw The British at the time saw them that way. They never called the INA by its own name in WW2, preferring JIF for "Japanese Indian Forces".
I started watching this series five years ago when it started. Im sorry I didnt end up watching a lot of it. Im a WW2/history freak and its so cool that they covered everyday! So u could almost live through it.
There is a ton of campaigns in East Africa, the Eastern Front, China and Burma that you missed
Holy hell that’s a lot of red
Da comrade!
Benefit of having units half as big as everyone else. Basically a single Red Corps was a division, etc.
When Indy mentioned Ulm at the beginning, Johan Gambolputty was the first thing that came to my mind and I thought, surely he is not going to go there, right? Right? Well played
i still believe, Berlin will never fall!
Delusions can be treated.
Keep thinking that, Meier 😉
@@caryblack5985Bot
Thanks for everything these last few years
Es bleiben im Raum: Keitel, Jodl, Krebs und Burgdorf.
Das war ein befehl! Der angriff Steiners war ein befehl!!
Wer sind sie, das sie es wagen, sich meinen Befehlen zu widersetzen?!