For a country with so much history in architectural innovation, Japan truly embarassed itself by building Kuma's design rather than the one they had originaly chosen themselves. Hadid's design had some dynamic, it had a huge gallery on the stadium's perimeter and it appeared open and welcoming. The final stadium is nothing. I can accept a different famous architect being chosen for the design, but Kuma could have done MUCH better than that.
you should not judge architecture by the appearances and look alone. that's what makes it a complicated art coz it deals with science, technicalities, economy, emotion, etc. .. there are lots of brilliant architects in japan, im sure they can design whats good for japan, since they understand their culture and context better.
If you are talking about Japanese culture and history, the one made by a JAPANESE architect actually reflects the country it’s in. If a country wants some sleek fancy stadium, that’s fine. But if a country actually wanted something that means a whole lot culturally, we shouldn’t be judging them on that. This is the national stadium, it should represent the nation and the current design does this much more than Zaha. Besides, her version costed way more and considered Covid and everything, it was the right choice.
theo cá nhân mình thì một sân vận động quốc gia thì phải đại diện được cho quốc mang những nét đặc trưng riêng của quốc gia đó và phải được công chúng đón nhận, do đó các ý tưởng của công trình này một phần không được chọn là do từ đầu đến cuối chỉ có người thiết kế ra nó mới cảm được và thấy được các yếu tố truyền thống bê trong đó, nó ko rõ ràng hoặc cũng có thể xem là quá trừu tượng đối với công chúng mặc dù nếu ko xét về yếu tố quốc gia, yếu tố nhìn nhận của công chúng thì nó là một sân vận động tuyệt vời
Pitty Japan didn't have enough money to build it. The chosen design blends in well with the city as it is currently is, but if you want something to inspire the present generation to take on the future, then look no further than this awesome proposal. I guess currently "hope" is scarce in Japan =(
The Japanese rejected the design/stage because it would cost 2 billion to build. Now Japan has suffered a loss of 13 billion with the postponement of the Olympics. Zaha Hadid must be very happy under the grave LMFAOAOAO
Yes the current design is ugly. For example DDM Plaza is a Tourist Hotspot in Seoul that tourists flock to. The new JNS design looks like a Cake tin and was designed clumsily. It will become desolate after the Olympics.
Shouldn't they be telling this to the Japanese officials/ public? Making a video in English with no Japanese subtitles is not exactly going to convince the target audience, who doesn't speak or understand English.
English is a universal language and this is especially true for Japan - a highly developed and prosperous country, hence Japanese officials would definitely be able to understand English.
@@iginantony5516 I don't even remember I ever wrote this comment or watched this video, it's so old. But I do think your estimation of the popularity of English is exaggerated. A lot of people do not speak or understand English on a high level, and that is still true even in large parts of Europe and I believe is true for east Asia as well. How developed or prosperous a country is, is detached from the citizens' ability to speak English. That said, in retrospect, I think there was no reason to believe the campaign was never translated to Japanese to begin with. Maybe this video was just an English version to a Japanese one. But in the end, seeing as this is not the design that was used, it doesn't matter anyway.
Proud to all iraqi people
For a country with so much history in architectural innovation, Japan truly embarassed itself by building Kuma's design rather than the one they had originaly chosen themselves. Hadid's design had some dynamic, it had a huge gallery on the stadium's perimeter and it appeared open and welcoming. The final stadium is nothing. I can accept a different famous architect being chosen for the design, but Kuma could have done MUCH better than that.
you should not judge architecture by the appearances and look alone. that's what makes it a complicated art coz it deals with science, technicalities, economy, emotion, etc. .. there are lots of brilliant architects in japan, im sure they can design whats good for japan, since they understand their culture and context better.
If you are talking about Japanese culture and history, the one made by a JAPANESE architect actually reflects the country it’s in.
If a country wants some sleek fancy stadium, that’s fine. But if a country actually wanted something that means a whole lot culturally, we shouldn’t be judging them on that. This is the national stadium, it should represent the nation and the current design does this much more than Zaha. Besides, her version costed way more and considered Covid and everything, it was the right choice.
-" A design connected to context "-
----- Plays the flute -----
Was beautiful.
Very nice.
theo cá nhân mình thì một sân vận động quốc gia thì phải đại diện được cho quốc mang những nét đặc trưng riêng của quốc gia đó và phải được công chúng đón nhận, do đó các ý tưởng của công trình này một phần không được chọn là do từ đầu đến cuối chỉ có người thiết kế ra nó mới cảm được và thấy được các yếu tố truyền thống bê trong đó, nó ko rõ ràng hoặc cũng có thể xem là quá trừu tượng đối với công chúng mặc dù nếu ko xét về yếu tố quốc gia, yếu tố nhìn nhận của công chúng thì nó là một sân vận động tuyệt vời
cái nhìn của công chúng mà mình nói ở đây là cái nhìn theo thời gian liên tục chứ không phải cái nhìn chỉ vào tại một thời điểm nhất định
Pitty Japan didn't have enough money to build it. The chosen design blends in well with the city as it is currently is, but if you want something to inspire the present generation to take on the future, then look no further than this awesome proposal. I guess currently "hope" is scarce in Japan =(
Such a crying shame that this was scrapped :(
The Japanese rejected the design/stage because it would cost 2 billion to build. Now Japan has suffered a loss of 13 billion with the postponement of the Olympics. Zaha Hadid must be very happy under the grave LMFAOAOAO
she did well with London and other stadiums she designed.
Too late to be begging to have your design reinstated! Shinzo Abe has made up his mind; there will be a new design.
Yes the current design is ugly. For example DDM Plaza is a Tourist Hotspot in Seoul that tourists flock to.
The new JNS design looks like a Cake tin and was designed clumsily. It will become desolate after the Olympics.
Fiasco
Shouldn't they be telling this to the Japanese officials/ public? Making a video in English with no Japanese subtitles is not exactly going to convince the target audience, who doesn't speak or understand English.
English is a universal language and this is especially true for Japan - a highly developed and prosperous country, hence Japanese officials would definitely be able to understand English.
@@iginantony5516 I don't even remember I ever wrote this comment or watched this video, it's so old. But I do think your estimation of the popularity of English is exaggerated. A lot of people do not speak or understand English on a high level, and that is still true even in large parts of Europe and I believe is true for east Asia as well. How developed or prosperous a country is, is detached from the citizens' ability to speak English.
That said, in retrospect, I think there was no reason to believe the campaign was never translated to Japanese to begin with. Maybe this video was just an English version to a Japanese one. But in the end, seeing as this is not the design that was used, it doesn't matter anyway.