When they made a Bollywood movie called PK ,which mocked the hindu religion ,the hindus were quiet ,tolerant and the muslims appreciated and praised the movie. But when someone mocks islam ,muslims become intolerant.
@user-kn2io1jt9v “we will do anything”, sounds like a threat buddy. And don’t forget your people get their livelihood in non islamic nations such as India, Germany, UK and when they oppose you, you consider them racists. Why don’t you just leave such countries and stay in your respective islamic countries?
When he said that they killed "most of the staff", in french he let out "all of it" before correcting himself and saying that it was some of it, you can see what it did to him, all of his colleagues and friends died in this event :(
How do you call a person who made wars to impose his beliefs, raped women, had 11 wives and numerous concubines, married a 6 years old girl, ordered his followers to raid caravans and take hostages, owned slaves, and threatens his followers with death if they abandon his teachings?
Just try to read the whole quran before made up your own opinion .Many people this day are ignorant and judge blindly without understanding the whole context.Well that just my suggestion ,you can ignore it if u want but if you want to truly understand what islam is try to read quran😊
@@muhammadsaifuddinismail2410 The fact that you mention Islam almost shows that you don't truly deny the facts I've mentioned, and it seems like you link them to Muhammad, even though I never mentioned him in my comment. Reading the Qur'an won't change these facts but instead studying both the Qur'an and the Hadiths confirm them. The question is: do you you really want to become like Muhammad?
@@egosum7 i know why you mention the prophet that is because it link with the subject in this video and instead of believing rumor why you don't study the quran yourself .I think maybe your opinion of the prophet will change.Btw ,well if i could i want to be like the prophet because the me now are just a repeat sinner ,i hope one day maybe i can be a better person, well brother instead of always being an ignorant maybe we change to be better me and you😄
@@muhammadsaifuddinismail2410 Do you want me to provide you the verses of the Qur'an and the Hadiths that confirm the acts I've mentioned above? It is not me claiming these, but the Islamic sources themselves. Or are you ashamed of your prophet? Also it needs to be specified, which Arabic original narrative of the Qur'an should someone read. Because there are at least 7 of them: th-cam.com/video/HmUEub1O5FU/w-d-xo.html
@Hisham Malik If the founder of Islam is not the context here, then what is it? By the way, it's funny how people immediately recognize these acts and to who they are attributed.
@@jimskoutas1933 Then what are they ? They can’t return to their original countries because they don’t have their citizenship, some only have have French citizenship.
@Unknown Mystery box Yeah it really takes a lot of courage to kill somebody over a FUCKING CARTOON 🙄 But seriously, you know what it actually takes? A fear-filled, hateful little pissant who is offended by everything and nothing. A true snowflake in every sense of the term.
whoopie what a fucking suprise, people behind the newspaper, the only one that's innovative and brave enough to publish what they are publishing, are actually intelligent and sensetive, because they give enough of a shit to work for a better world, to push free speech and logic over primitive violence. okay, that was a little salty for no reason but you get my point. oh and to clarify before we get another 20 responses leading to nothing - i am against extremists and anyone willing to hurt anyone else, but im not going to go ahead and say "deport all muslims!!1" because that on its own is extremism.
lolpl0000 Hey he has the right to his opinion to stand with them. Besides, it's part of the French culture to critize every part of society and all its values that most countries would not mention.
Teebs131 You lack basic understanding of French law. It is illegal to denial the Holocaust in France and across Europe. A writer at Hebdo was fired for "anti-Semitic" writing which was light compared to what they write about Islam. France arrests their comedians for what they say. Even taking an inane gesture and Israeli groups turning it into some Nazi salute. France banned Dieudonné from preforming on multiple occasions due to "anti-semitism" claims. Yet say whatever the fuck you want about any ethic minority or religious group. Just don't touch Zionism or Israel. So I take it the double standard is the main crux of French culture right?
***** You are just misinformed. Dieudonné was free to make his show when hatred speech against "people" was removed. You are free to speak against zionism and the jewish religion, not to promote murders against people. And Charlie is free of firing people if they want to. The freedom of speech is State based not company based. If you can't talk about some things at Charlie Hebdo, then move to another company where you can. That is what is called freedom of speech at country-level. I don't agree with the denial of the Holocaust law too, I think it's a bit unfair to our concept of the freedom of speech, but it's a tragedy still too fresh for us and trauma is still there.
Voltaire once said 'I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it'. Times like these desperately call for such in order to defend and protect free speech.
Is racism considered free speech ? Is bigotry considered free speech? They invade Middle East and make people’s lives hell and top of that make fun of out prophet No sir !
Free speech??????? Its just freaking hate...!!!!! There is frogivness, yes, a bigger motive....but we don't understand that. If you use your freedom of speech to provoke hate....its just hate...! And hate breeds hate. Don't confuse it with "freedom of speech".
@@truthseeker4785 you do not understand what the definition of "free speech" is. You are a brainwashed sheep. Perhaps CNN would be a better channel for you to watch. Sheep.
Im super proud of Vice for stepping up their game lately. I remember last year the docs were getting super wasteful of the name Vice. But this is the Vice we loved, bringing us super real news. Very touching video. Thank you.
People can say what they want, whether these cartoonists are heroes and symbols or that they were instigators of trouble who had it coming for them. But at the end of the day, 17 people were killed over some drawings. In the end it was just a sad and horrific event.
No why would u purposely draw a picture of something you know is gonna cause a problem and riots so don’t be surprised if someone gets killed in the process
@@snatchedwig2650 how many people these days actually consider what good journalism means? Is it informative? Well presented? Or is it simply something we agree with?
I remember the Charlie Hebdo attacks and the aftermath. It came in the midst of so many other religiously motivated attacks in France and elsewhere in Europe. This incident seemed to be particularly maddening because the target was so deliberate and personal.
I will never unterstand this. What‘s wrong with a cartoon? Who cares what others think about your religion? It‘s actually not a big deal. Violence/Terrorism is never the right response to cartoons
It is, religion is extremely close to some people, it’s just because some religions like Christianity and Judaism have been integrated with media and society that’s why they don’t care but Islam cares, and by the way it’s not only the cartoon, they attacked this guy because he supported the bombings France did in Syria and Iraq which killed thousands of innocent Muslims, we kill some few people and we get called terrorists you kill as much as you like and there’s nothing wrong, that’s what I call double standards, fucking disgusting humans.
@@hello-gx6oi it’s because Islam is different then the western world or the world, the world has integrated modern society with religion. That’s why Islam is the odd one out, which also proves why Islam is reality.
@@wraith7460 and this is why so many people don't respect Islam only libirals and muslims do Honestly we don't really care about religion we just want to live
I agree with "Violence/Terrorism is never the right response". But "Whats wrong about a cartoon?" "Its actually not a big deal" Nope. I completely disagree.
And also French, should only stay in your fucking country and not dropping army in other people's land and robbed their government. You guys are colonial, you should be ashamed of That
@@aflah8890 (well maybe then don't base your governments around some outdated religion which leads to your country falling apart and then asking for aid and assistance from other countries to quell your own separatist rebellions)
Vice you never cease to amaze me. This was seriously one of the best interviews I've seen in months, and for a guy whose been through hell he gave a damn good interview.
@RS Tomar No you go get a life and stop being ignorant and educate yourself it’s people like you that just wanna talk without any knowledge.Plus I don’t understand why people think it’s ok to disrespect other people religion and beliefs by making cartoons figures to make money and make a name for their self in this world but yet not one in history have I see a Muslim person bashing or disrespecting any other religion in any kinda way
@James S then wouldn't it be freedom of expression to kill others if I play by your logic? What limit those kinds of 'freedom' you are saying? Totally barbaric ideology
@James S since you don't know what you're talking about, this might help you regarding those freedoms you were saying. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech
Belief me the freedom level in saudi arabia is better than Europain country especially these days : No huge number for crime cases like Europe. No affront religions and belives like what charlie hebdo doing . No unemployment % like Europe . No huge tax % like Europe . No false news and media which try to control European countries . If im not Saudi , definitely i will wish to be Saudi , god bless KSA .
@Moonmoon Pati what you think about your god thinking...??? Are you think god need have a brain...??? What is your religion...??? Are you think god same as a human or animal parts body...Shame on you...
@@magemaatikko freedom for speech is good but why should someone has to be get killed just because of the cause which was created by others. Look at this coward Charley how his consequences are affecting others and how safely he's hiding and rejoicing protection from authorities.
@@recreationalliesure.6330 I am altruistic person. I think Peace for the whole sinful World and I seek not my glory but glory of God. Not me but for all the glory , pray and salvation to God,! Jesus Christ! Truth, goodness of heart, humble heart and willing to serve others and love others and above all Jesus Christ my ruler of heart! Rex Jesus Christi. Amen!
@@magemaatikko go to hell jesus ain't gonna save u Even he never ever die 4 you people. jesus never claimed in new testament that he died for Americans or for Europeans never U r brainwashed by so called church. If u believe that jesus die 4 me and he will gonna save you from wrath of God then it's your deception. jesus was sent to children of Israel to guide them he wasn't sent 4 you
It's not extremism, it's people taking holy scriptures literal. Extremists are the one's not following such absurd commandments. If I were to stone an homosexual to death because of catholicism I wouldn't be extremist, I'd be a literal Catholic
@@martinosanmartin9523 perfect comment. What these terrorists did is exactly what their prophet did, which is killing people who mocked him. These are true muslims, doing what Allah ordered them to do. This has nothing to do with extremism
Mr. Hebdo, there's one thing never ever regret over the cartoon you drew. Believe me it takes balls and guts to draw prophet Muhammad cartoon and displaying it. Love from INDIA
Muhammad is a loser and just shows you that the people who worship him to the EXTREME should not be allowed out of their scary as middle eastern countries. France needs to be extremely careful who they let in out of respect for everyone in France. I HATE MUHAMMAD
I'm disgusted about what happened to Charlie Hebdo- but what irritate me the most is the irony and the hypocrite people. you ask me how? most people around the world who shouted I'm Charlie and shouted about freedom did it only for attention seeking or living in that moment. why is no one today talk about it or demonstrate about it anymore? if you wanna change the world and fight for the freedom speech. you shouldn't stop demonstrate 1 week after the event. that's what pisses me of.
Swe clasher considering charlie hebdo's offices were burnt down couple of years before, they should have marched in the streets a lot earlier and they might have prevented this tragedy. What's also despicable, is this endless hypocrisy of the majority who only now feels sorry when it's too late and this because they feel the threat coming closer to THEM, since most charlie hebdo cartoonists are dead now, they can no longer be the target or their scapegoat to blame them of being "agitators"; no they might become the next target (that's why only now they "care"). But in the meantime they were dumb enough to help the evil islam grow in power and experience.
I have to admit, seeing this guy alone in his dark and messy apartment, the face still marked, with his cigarettes, drawing..all his mates are dead. He breaks my heart. You're muslim ? Does he really look dangerous or like a guy who want to insult you? I mean.. I didn't want to believe it before, but I start to realize that there are still a lot of "moderated muslim" who are chocked by a 5-years-old style draw of a "PROPHET"(lol..). Moderation starts when you have a bit of distance with things like these, guys. I'm french, I want peace, but when I look at the muslim countries in Middle East, Africa, I really don't see where peace is.
Great interview VICE! I am almost 100% certain you won't read this comment as the majority of comments are horrific but just wanted to let you guys know that I love VICE for doing what it is they do. Sure you guys are biased sometimes, sure you make mistakes sometimes. But at least you give you us information that no one else seems to be willing to give us. Thank you.
Commenters here would do well to actually watch the interview and listen to this cartoonists thoughts. Very spot on. I almost never say this but Bravo to Vice News for this interview, excellent. Side note when he opened the door with his mustache, glass of red wine, and a cigarette he was the most French person I've ever seen
Why would you draw the picture when you know it is gonna cause violent response. It was not the first time you did it. Topics about Prophet Muhammad are very sensitive to Muslims. If you think you can make fun of that you get such incidents.....
Many people insult and criticize Christianity or Hinduism but no one gets offended and ends up killing people mercilessly. You Muslims should be ashamed that people are afraid to even criticize your religion. Islam is intolerant and evil.
That was an incredibly interesting and moving interview. The mind of the satirist is an intelligent one, both concerning ideas and emotionally. I also appreciate that the interviewer let him talk while listening so empathetically. As for the phrase “I am Charlie”, I interpret in terms of identity politics. To assert that you are satire, free speech’s most important test, is to empower the ability of the jester to mock the king in the king’s court. It’s the secular equivalent of religious identity assertions
Doesn't Matter because they Succeeded. Charlie Hebdo will no longer show Muhammad Cartoons and now from their former Editor have gone soft AKA they will no longer be as audacious as before. The Terrorist won and showed Medueval Barbarity can defeat Western Values.
What are you saying? They could offended him back. The difference is, that some people stand above opinions of others and other people will literally kill you. That is Terrorism
I love how many people like to talk about how they support this newspaper, despite the fact that very, very few of them agree with their almost exclusively anarchist message.
Artists and heroes. Remember that only to cowards does bravery appear to be stupidity. Anyone who insults their memory with statements of 'they pushed their luck' or 'they should not have offended' does not understand satire, let alone the principles, importance or cost your freedoms. I criticize my country every day but I never forget nor do I take for granted the sacrifices made by soldiers, leaders, citizens and perhaps most importantly artists to provide and sustain my rights. If you are reading this its because great men and women of your nation have ensured freedom of the web (and by extension thought and speech) to you. It is our duty as the privileged of this world to honor those rights and defend them from enemies. We owe it if not to those who have suffered for these rights then to the millions of others who live without them. JE SUIS CHARLIE
Hero is a term that gets passed out like candy. He made some funny pictures and his friends died because of it. Certainly tragic but I wouldnt call it heroic
what was he thinking ? He would get flowers from muslim community for mocking prophet (sm) ? And yes dont get me wrong i dont support killing for this reason. But there are extremist people in every community . Although it made my blood boil ,i chose to ignore it . Our muslim sister got attacked because she made some joke and said some serious question for lgbt . Country doesnt give her protection .
I'm not a muslim, and don't like some aspects of their religion. But I would never want to disrespect someone's religion. Why would anyone do that? What do you gain from that? You don't have to believe what they believe. Leave them to it. Are you really that out of material? Or are you telling me you really didn't know muslims don't have a sense of humor when it comes to their prophet?
@@neilvare-dd1rs I agree, and I am in no way defending what has happened. But it's all good until something you strongly believe in/live by yourself gets insulted and ridiculed.. Why is this man continuing to draw these things when this puts other French people in danger and in the mean time sits in practically a bunker keeping himself safe.
@@wesleyk3600 that the whole point Wes if Muslims cannot handle being offended in a country where it is ok to offend whoever or whatever that may be then should move to a country where they have blasphemy law instead of trying to implement one in the country they are in..I thought Muslims had to respect the law of the land they live in not try and change it to suit them
You’re clearly one of those Islam apologists, trying to justify murder because it’s what someone “believes.” Go FYS and that nonsensical, backwards-ass thinking.
@@MaryamofShomal You showed no understanding nor the ability to discuss rationally. All name calling and no argument. I didn't justify murder. I called out people who disrespect other people's religion for their own amusement. This thoughtless name calling of yours is as backward as anything, the murderers themselves included.
So we can see clearly here the problem isn’t the cartoons, it’s a much bigger problem with people being murdered, tortured, imprisoned, pushed off buildings and their human rights and freedoms violated. And we are talking whole countries here like Iran, where violence is common place for disobeying rules. France does not have to obey these rules as it is not under Islamic Law, it is under French Law and French society respects and upholds the freedom of all people. Clearly freedom doesn’t exist or is severely limited in Islamic countries, and that’s what is causing the problem here and creating violence daily across the globe and in every country. But we will never submit to the rules of Islam or any religion. The law is above God, as is personal freedom, and human rights.
Great insight to what he thinks. I feel like he represents what free speech is. The right to cause a discussion to happen over a few people creating an image.
Jajajajajajaj so free speech is about to make funny of other people? For example the cartoon they did about the inmigrant kid who died in the beach? Thats free speech? In what world are u living? Would you like them to make cartoons about one of your family member who is disability so some idiots can laugh about it? Have some respect for human being..
I was surprised at how much respect he still had for [maybe most] Muslims 7:30 a lot of people have a lack respect for those who have harmed them like that
Why don't they condemn the principle of punishment for blasphemy in the Qur'an and Hadiths? That's what needs to be condemned. Not just the actions of the attacker
I'm sorry I didn't make this comment to hope that i get a ton of likes from you i just make it just to warn you to be more careful to read every sensitive comment that people make from this sensitive video, if you guys want to give my comment like it's up to you I don't care if I'm copying this comment or not it's not a big deal I'm just giving a warning.
Plz Don’t Blame Allah Don't Blame Our Religion Or Our Prophet.If U Don't Believe In Islam Than Don't Do What You Believe We Don't Have Any Problems. From 1400 Years We Follow Our Prophet Muhammad (SAW) Without Making Any Sketch Than Why You Guys Do Something Like That...???? Don't Try To Hurt Anyone’s Religion Islam Is The Fastest Religion On Earth You Can't Stop Those People Who Has Believe.... Allah May Give You All Ability To Realise The Truth ♥ From Bangladesh
do you think Charlie Hebdo disrespected muslims ? they disrespected islamists, not muslims. if insulting your prophet is enough to make you kill people, then go to the psychiatrist because youre a psycopath
Why he is pretending he is very innocent .Doesn't he has an idea that Muslims are very touchy about their Prophet and it's not the first time west has done this .Whenever West say bad word about the Prophet Muslims will came out like this .This is a very sensitive topic and he is behaving like he is innocent .If you will touch anybody's heart they will touch yours .It hurts them ( Muslims ) that's why they hurt you ......
Please hear me out cause i have nothing against muslims. Some of you killing individuals over satire is not justified. If people kill others because of one thing a prophet said, then thats haram. The mere hypocrisy of killing people (wich is terrible), over a few not respecting one part of your religion? Dont you realise violence wont help respecting your religion? And also if something is made into a satire, it means its respected pretty much. Now people are afraid of your own religion meaning they quite literaly 1. respect your religion less, and konsekvuently your people and 2. They will fear you, not respect you. And making it into a big deal is only gonna make more people want to draw it, aka those who have nothing left to loose.
Truly a man to aspire to be like. I really like those comics as well, you can find them on the internet and I read them any time I could. Good luck to this man.
'Charlie Hebdo' recently published a number of cartoons of the Russian plane which was bombed by ISIS. I wonder how many cartoons 'Charlie' will publish about the ISIS attack on France. Je suis Charlie?
+Frank Blangeard Oh they will make plenty. Starting tomorrow with the cover: twitter.com/AuskarSurbakti/status/666566182175027200/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
LONG LIVE CHARLIE HEBDO. And all talented cartoonists. If people can't take a joke over a "blasphemous" cartoon, then don't fucking read it. Personally, I think those drawings are hysterical
The problem isn't Islam its the idea that violence is justifiable if in the name of Islam. All monotheistic religions came from one man but the only one that uses violence and terrorizes its critics is the one that claims to be based on peace and love. Some religion Islam is......
Religion should never blind people. What macron did is right. They have to keep a tab on radicalism in France. If some people cant get over a stupid cartoon, they dont belong . If people dint ridicule age old religious beliefs, we would still be in the dark ages.
@@DreadedDormammuWell guess what? Charlie Hebdo stopped making Muhammad Cartoon and even its former and surviving Editors said the that it had gone soft. I'd say the terrorist succeeded.
as someone who loves art and to read about the ways people interact through artworks and especially cartoons this video killed me emotionally this man is suffering in so many ways, the world is suffering in so many ways, sometimes its really hard to believe such violent acts happend i really dont want to go and hate on muslims because of all of this, but ive read so much negativity its hard to help such situation im sorry for being judgemental, but its things like these that make me afraid and anxious when i see people wearing anything that resembles muslim culture or middle east looking people, i will do my best to not be a bad person towards them, but the feeling will forever be there because of such things why all the hate? why such devotion to a being if its causing such troubles to the world, to their own lives? what can people do to stop this madness?
dont care, didnt care, wont care about what people believe. charlie hebdo was in their rights and anyone saying otherwise is playing the game of the islamists
La France est un pays laïque, les préceptes religieux n'ont aucune prise sur la vie et le comportement des citoyens. On dessine le "prohète", si on veut, comme on le veut. Et on est libre de le faire. La religion ne dictera jamais nos lois. Que ceux qui veulent vivre selon les préceptes de l'islam, le judaïsme ou le christianisme fassent ça chez eux. Nous avons fait la révolution, on ne pliera pas devant une bande de fanatiques. Vive la liberté, vive la parole sans interdit. MERDE à ceux qui veulent qu'on se soumette. MERCI à ceux qui dans le monde entier apportent leur soutien à Charlie Nous sommes Charlie Nous sommes LIBRES
There are almost 5 Bollywood movies made each year in India which criticize the Hindu religion and Muslims watch it happily, No Hindu ever goes on a rampage and kills the director. One of the famous movie PK was supposed to criticize every religion but it didn't criticized Islam. Clearly Islam is intolerant, People are afraid to even criticize Islam because Islam is evil.
@M M and where have you read in Quran this? Which verse? Little knowledge could be dangerous. Unfortunately you are the victim of it. Try finding such verse and come back. Study please.
@@serotonin3247" And they urge you to hasten the punishment. And if not for [the decree of] a specified term, punishment would have reached them. But it will surely come to them suddenly while they perceive not. " - surah ankabut .
@@serotonin3247 " But as for those who defiantly disobeyed, their refuge is the Fire. Every time they wish to emerge from it, they will be returned to it while it is said to them, "Taste the punishment of the Fire which you used to deny." " surah sajdah .
Suppose they had mocked prophet of any other religion, whole world would have been criticising them. Because they did against Islam that fits into their agenda. That's why 'call of freedom of speech'. Insulting someone is not FOS. Despite all modernity Europe is still ethnocentric and Islamophobic.
00:07 Luz faces challenges after Charlie Hebdo attack 01:37 Cartoonist Luz narrowly escaped Charlie Hebdo attack on his birthday 03:12 Luz reflects on the shock and unpreparedness during the Charlie Hebdo attack 04:54 Navigating between being provocative and victimized in the role of a symbol 06:13 Charlie Hebdo cartoonist reflects on global reactions to his work 07:45 Advocating for responsible journalism and satire 09:21 Luz expresses sadness over Saudi Arabia's response to Charlie Hebdo 10:41 Discussion on the aftermath of the tragic events at Charlie Hebdo Luz faces challenges after Charlie Hebdo attack - Luz continues to face difficulties and heightened security measures since drawing Prophet Muhammad cover - Luz reflects on drawing his thoughts during a police interview Cartoonist Luz narrowly escaped Charlie Hebdo attack on his birthday - Luz was late for work due to celebrating his birthday with his wife - He witnessed armed men entering the building and the start of the attack Luz reflects on the shock and unpreparedness during the Charlie Hebdo attack - Luz describes seeing the aftermath of the attack and realizing the severity of the situation - Luz expresses feeling unprepared and unsure of how to react to such a traumatic event Navigating between being provocative and victimized in the role of a symbol - Charlie Hebdo faced criticism for being provocative by depicting Mohammed, but also became a symbol of free expression and victimization - Struggled with the challenge of being a symbol and the impact on their freedom to use humor in their cartoons Charlie Hebdo cartoonist reflects on global reactions to his work - Newspapers in the United States hesitant to publish Charlie Hebdo covers - Expresses empathy towards the Muslim community and individual encounter at Charb's funeral Advocating for responsible journalism and satire - Expressing the desire for a responsible approach to drawing and journalism - Reflecting on the impact and support received after the Charlie Hebdo attack Luz expresses sadness over Saudi Arabia's response to Charlie Hebdo - Luz expresses disappointment in the Saudi representative claiming to support Charlie Hebdo while a blogger is being mistreated and flogged in jail. - He reflects on the paradox of the situation and his commitment to drawing good people despite the strange world he sees. Discussion on the aftermath of the tragic events at Charlie Hebdo - The cartoonist Luz reflects on the mutual forgiveness shared between him and the character he drew, symbolizing moving forward from the tragedy. - Luz expresses his apology for possibly affecting the character's image and the character's forgiveness towards him.
This is just lack of wisdom. I can think of 1000 noble causes to did for. But this is not one of them. What do you expect muslims to do? Laugh. Am a christian
Honestly, I've seen so many cartoons of people making fun of Jesus. Literally the most inappropriate things. NOBODY goes on a killing spree because of it. I can tell you what we don't expect... people to be slaughtered over a cartoon! Just absolutely crazy that you even tried to défend that as a Christian!
Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high Where knowledge is free Where the world has not been broken up into fragments By narrow domestic walls Where words come out from the depth of truth Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit Where the mind is led forward by thee Into ever-widening thought and action Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake. --- Rabindranath Tagore
I watched this video as a Muslim disliking him but when he said-‘Those who claim all Muslims are offended take Muslims for imbeciles, I think.’ and when he met that Muslim at the funeral, I gained some respect for him. Me personally, I’m not a snowflake who gets offended easily; I honestly don’t care it doesn’t affect my life massively.
Very important other does not know about muslims, they love prophet Muhammad more than them selfs and more than any this in the world more than Wives parents and children.
What did he gain by insulting Prophet Muhammad ? He could live peacefully and enjoy his life by drawing good things instead of those controversial arts. But he lost his life miserably and all Muslims are now getting slammed for his death.
They got murder fighting for everybody's freedom of conscience and expression. The world don't have to and will not follow the barbaric rules of a bronze age totalitarist sect of war and submition.
Stop. Justifying. Murder. I don’t give AF if the Quran says it’s okay - here in the 21st century, it’s NOT OKAY. You can’t murder people because they make fun of your “prophet.”
When they made a Bollywood movie called PK ,which mocked the hindu religion ,the hindus were quiet ,tolerant and the muslims appreciated and praised the movie. But when someone mocks islam ,muslims become intolerant.
True, Islam in a nutshell.
@md aka you are snowflakes
@user-kn2io1jt9v you are just snowflake
Islam is the only religion that’s cannot take any criticism regardless of much irrelevant or hurtful it might be to the followers.
@user-kn2io1jt9v “we will do anything”, sounds like a threat buddy. And don’t forget your people get their livelihood in non islamic nations such as India, Germany, UK and when they oppose you, you consider them racists. Why don’t you just leave such countries and stay in your respective islamic countries?
When he said that they killed "most of the staff", in french he let out "all of it" before correcting himself and saying that it was some of it, you can see what it did to him, all of his colleagues and friends died in this event :(
so who asked
@@alinneagu4124 just a comment not an answer to any question
@@alinneagu4124 why are you the way that you are?
Good
And on his birthday as well. How traumatic.
How do you call a person who made wars to impose his beliefs, raped women, had 11 wives and numerous concubines, married a 6 years old girl, ordered his followers to raid caravans and take hostages, owned slaves, and threatens his followers with death if they abandon his teachings?
Just try to read the whole quran before made up your own opinion .Many people this day are ignorant and judge blindly without understanding the whole context.Well that just my suggestion ,you can ignore it if u want but if you want to truly understand what islam is try to read quran😊
@@muhammadsaifuddinismail2410 The fact that you mention Islam almost shows that you don't truly deny the facts I've mentioned, and it seems like you link them to Muhammad, even though I never mentioned him in my comment. Reading the Qur'an won't change these facts but instead studying both the Qur'an and the Hadiths confirm them. The question is: do you you really want to become like Muhammad?
@@egosum7 i know why you mention the prophet that is because it link with the subject in this video and instead of believing rumor why you don't study the quran yourself .I think maybe your opinion of the prophet will change.Btw ,well if i could i want to be like the prophet because the me now are just a repeat sinner ,i hope one day maybe i can be a better person, well brother instead of always being an ignorant maybe we change to be better me and you😄
@@muhammadsaifuddinismail2410 Do you want me to provide you the verses of the Qur'an and the Hadiths that confirm the acts I've mentioned above? It is not me claiming these, but the Islamic sources themselves. Or are you ashamed of your prophet? Also it needs to be specified, which Arabic original narrative of the Qur'an should someone read. Because there are at least 7 of them: th-cam.com/video/HmUEub1O5FU/w-d-xo.html
@Hisham Malik If the founder of Islam is not the context here, then what is it? By the way, it's funny how people immediately recognize these acts and to who they are attributed.
That is the most French looking guy I have ever seen
@@Der_Gewagte he means real french...not the immigrants. The immigrants even though they are born in France they are not ethnically french.
@@jimskoutas1933 Then what are they ? They can’t return to their original countries because they don’t have their citizenship, some only have have French citizenship.
@@seldom7288 they are french citizens, not ethnically French. A lizard born in a fish tank is not a fish.
Legit
@@Bishidonscare what does it even mean to be ethnically French? We define what it means, it's not rigid.
Muslims are rioting over cartoons? Now that's called sorting out priorities! smh
They are because they are slandering their prophet
@@valtontony826 yes and who cares ?
@@valtontony826their prophet was also a warlord and a child t0ucher… he deserves all the criticism he can get
@@valtontony826the pedophile prophet? The one who fvcks goat and marry children?
muslims priorities are very disgusting, tbh
This mans ball size must be enormously giant
Kamu indo ya?
lmao
@Abrar Ahmed it must much of money insult everyone and attract all extremist to come
@Unknown Mystery box Yeah it really takes a lot of courage to kill somebody over a FUCKING CARTOON 🙄
But seriously, you know what it actually takes? A fear-filled, hateful little pissant who is offended by everything and nothing. A true snowflake in every sense of the term.
And ?
This man is intelligent, sensitive and brave. The world would be a better place if there were more like him.
whoopie what a fucking suprise, people behind the newspaper, the only one that's innovative and brave enough to publish what they are publishing, are actually intelligent and sensetive, because they give enough of a shit to work for a better world, to push free speech and logic over primitive violence.
okay, that was a little salty for no reason but you get my point.
oh and to clarify before we get another 20 responses leading to nothing - i am against extremists and anyone willing to hurt anyone else, but im not going to go ahead and say "deport all muslims!!1" because that on its own is extremism.
lolpl0000 Hey he has the right to his opinion to stand with them. Besides, it's part of the French culture to critize every part of society and all its values that most countries would not mention.
Teebs131 You lack basic understanding of French law. It is illegal to denial the Holocaust in France and across Europe. A writer at Hebdo was fired for "anti-Semitic" writing which was light compared to what they write about Islam. France arrests their comedians for what they say. Even taking an inane gesture and Israeli groups turning it into some Nazi salute.
France banned Dieudonné from preforming on multiple occasions due to "anti-semitism" claims. Yet say whatever the fuck you want about any ethic minority or religious group. Just don't touch Zionism or Israel.
So I take it the double standard is the main crux of French culture right?
How ironic, men are stupid enough to buy this media jihadi bullshit. The few intelligent men left are censored for telling the truth.
***** You are just misinformed. Dieudonné was free to make his show when hatred speech against "people" was removed. You are free to speak against zionism and the jewish religion, not to promote murders against people. And Charlie is free of firing people if they want to. The freedom of speech is State based not company based. If you can't talk about some things at Charlie Hebdo, then move to another company where you can. That is what is called freedom of speech at country-level.
I don't agree with the denial of the Holocaust law too, I think it's a bit unfair to our concept of the freedom of speech, but it's a tragedy still too fresh for us and trauma is still there.
Voltaire once said 'I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it'. Times like these desperately call for such in order to defend and protect free speech.
If free speech is is permitted then to hear and see shits coming out of everyone's sense....
saying that with a che chevara profile photo hahahah
Is racism considered free speech ?
Is bigotry considered free speech?
They invade Middle East and make people’s lives hell and top of that make fun of out prophet
No sir !
Free speech??????? Its just freaking hate...!!!!! There is frogivness, yes, a bigger motive....but we don't understand that. If you use your freedom of speech to provoke hate....its just hate...! And hate breeds hate.
Don't confuse it with "freedom of speech".
@@truthseeker4785 you do not understand what the definition of "free speech" is. You are a brainwashed sheep. Perhaps CNN would be a better channel for you to watch. Sheep.
That was really touching. I think we should thank VICE for giving us access to interviews like this.
Im super proud of Vice for stepping up their game lately. I remember last year the docs were getting super wasteful of the name Vice. But this is the Vice we loved, bringing us super real news. Very touching video. Thank you.
People can say what they want, whether these cartoonists are heroes and symbols or that they were instigators of trouble who had it coming for them. But at the end of the day, 17 people were killed over some drawings. In the end it was just a sad and horrific event.
its not really that sad.... lets make a satire cartoon about it.
No it was funny lol
No why would u purposely draw a picture of something you know is gonna cause a problem and riots so don’t be surprised if someone gets killed in the process
@@icelolly.m329 exactly it's his fault he drew the cartoons
@@icelolly.m329 who are you to say what they should do? France is not an Islamic country.
An example of some very good journalism
true it was very good and informing but what in particular made it good journalism
@@snatchedwig2650 how many people these days actually consider what good journalism means? Is it informative? Well presented? Or is it simply something we agree with?
I remember the Charlie Hebdo attacks and the aftermath. It came in the midst of so many other religiously motivated attacks in France and elsewhere in Europe. This incident seemed to be particularly maddening because the target was so deliberate and personal.
I will never unterstand this. What‘s wrong with a cartoon? Who cares what others think about your religion? It‘s actually not a big deal.
Violence/Terrorism is never the right response to cartoons
It is, religion is extremely close to some people, it’s just because some religions like Christianity and Judaism have been integrated with media and society that’s why they don’t care but Islam cares, and by the way it’s not only the cartoon, they attacked this guy because he supported the bombings France did in Syria and Iraq which killed thousands of innocent Muslims, we kill some few people and we get called terrorists you kill as much as you like and there’s nothing wrong, that’s what I call double standards, fucking disgusting humans.
Yeah but if it's Islam
Then say hello to the religion of peace
@@hello-gx6oi it’s because Islam is different then the western world or the world, the world has integrated modern society with religion. That’s why Islam is the odd one out, which also proves why Islam is reality.
@@wraith7460 and this is why so many people don't respect Islam only libirals and muslims do
Honestly we don't really care about religion we just want to live
I agree with "Violence/Terrorism is never the right response". But "Whats wrong about a cartoon?" "Its actually not a big deal" Nope. I completely disagree.
Very glad that he's still alive, and that he will not stop.
That is all I can say.
Giorgi Jackeli triggered much
@@giojiu I HOPE, WE NUKE YOUR SATANIC RELIGION.
🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕
This comment section clearly shows why muslims should stay in their home countries.
And also French, should only stay in your fucking country and not dropping army in other people's land and robbed their government. You guys are colonial, you should be ashamed of That
@@aflah8890 (well maybe then don't base your governments around some outdated religion which leads to your country falling apart and then asking for aid and assistance from other countries to quell your own separatist rebellions)
I am seriously in disbelief... sick! Defending this slaughter... I just can't believe it.
Vice has deleted the comments I read a few years ago. Curious isn’t it.
Sure they have... not welcome in europe. OUT
Vice you never cease to amaze me.
This was seriously one of the best interviews I've seen in months, and for a guy whose been through hell he gave a damn good interview.
💨🛏️
I am amused to see that an innocent cartoon in a newspaper can violate prophet Muhammad so easily.
Yes you should be amuse how human can project illustrations that violates a lot of morale and ethical principles.
@RS Tomar good day to you sir
@RS Tomar No you go get a life and stop being ignorant and educate yourself it’s people like you that just wanna talk without any knowledge.Plus I don’t understand why people think it’s ok to disrespect other people religion and beliefs by making cartoons figures to make money and make a name for their self in this world but yet not one in history have I see a Muslim person bashing or disrespecting any other religion in any kinda way
@James S then wouldn't it be freedom of expression to kill others if I play by your logic? What limit those kinds of 'freedom' you are saying? Totally barbaric ideology
@James S since you don't know what you're talking about, this might help you regarding those freedoms you were saying.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech
The highest esteem for these men and women of Charlie Hebdo is what I have.
I agree with what he said about Saudi Arabia though.
Saudia arabia is non of ur business we dont care about what u think ..
Sad it's true..
Belief me the freedom level in saudi arabia is better than Europain country especially these days :
No huge number for crime cases like Europe.
No affront religions and belives like what charlie hebdo doing .
No unemployment % like Europe .
No huge tax % like Europe .
No false news and media which try to control European countries .
If im not Saudi , definitely i will wish to be Saudi , god bless KSA .
@Moonmoon Pati what you think about your god thinking...??? Are you think god need have a brain...??? What is your religion...??? Are you think god same as a human or animal parts body...Shame on you...
@@dandyramadhana4485 Why are you shaming her? She raised valid questions...
Playing with religious sentiments is dangerous, situations like this will keep on arising, if not understood and stopped.
If we lose our freedom of speech; what are we and what are we to become, only cry of the wolf can answer your question!
@@magemaatikko freedom for speech is good but why should someone has to be get killed just because of the cause which was created by others.
Look at this coward Charley how his consequences are affecting others and how safely he's hiding and rejoicing protection from authorities.
@@recreationalliesure.6330 I am altruistic person. I think Peace for the whole sinful World and I seek not my glory but glory of God. Not me but for all the glory , pray and salvation to God,! Jesus Christ! Truth, goodness of heart, humble heart and willing to serve others and love others and above all Jesus Christ my ruler of heart! Rex Jesus Christi. Amen!
@@magemaatikko go to hell jesus ain't gonna save u
Even he never ever die 4 you people.
jesus never claimed in new testament that he died for Americans or for Europeans never
U r brainwashed by so called church. If u believe that jesus die 4 me and he will gonna save you from wrath of God then it's your deception. jesus was sent to children of Israel to guide them he wasn't sent 4 you
@@magemaatikko u r living in deception wake up as soon as possible
2019-. I still haven't forgotten about this. The problem with extremists is worse than ever in France.
It's not extremism, it's people taking holy scriptures literal. Extremists are the one's not following such absurd commandments. If I were to stone an homosexual to death because of catholicism I wouldn't be extremist, I'd be a literal Catholic
@@martinosanmartin9523 perfect comment. What these terrorists did is exactly what their prophet did, which is killing people who mocked him. These are true muslims, doing what Allah ordered them to do. This has nothing to do with extremism
@@discospeed good France deserved all of this
Corrupt French government let it fester for to long and for a good reason ...
@@discospeed false
Mr. Hebdo, there's one thing never ever regret over the cartoon you drew. Believe me it takes balls and guts to draw prophet Muhammad cartoon and displaying it.
Love from INDIA
Shame on you
lets’s also make cartoons about 17 people that were killed lmaoooo it was so funny i would buy
Absolutely. This could've been resolved so easily.
Muhammad is a loser and just shows you that the people who worship him to the EXTREME should not be allowed out of their scary as middle eastern countries. France needs to be extremely careful who they let in out of respect for everyone in France. I HATE MUHAMMAD
I'm disgusted about what happened to Charlie Hebdo- but what irritate me the most is the irony and the hypocrite people. you ask me how? most people around the world who shouted I'm Charlie and shouted about freedom did it only for attention seeking or living in that moment. why is no one today talk about it or demonstrate about it anymore? if you wanna change the world and fight for the freedom speech. you shouldn't stop demonstrate 1 week after the event. that's what pisses me of.
***** People Power revolution, the Fall of the Berlin wall, Mahatama Ghandi's fast to remove british rule on india.....
It do work.
Swe clasher considering charlie hebdo's offices were burnt down couple of years before, they should have marched in the streets a lot earlier and they might have prevented this tragedy. What's also despicable, is this endless hypocrisy of the majority who only now feels sorry when it's too late and this because they feel the threat coming closer to THEM, since most charlie hebdo cartoonists are dead now, they can no longer be the target or their scapegoat to blame them of being "agitators"; no they might become the next target (that's why only now they "care"). But in the meantime they were dumb enough to help the evil islam grow in power and experience.
The irony is they call their religion, religion of peace
Stfu you know nothing about Islam I defend the teachings of Islam not individuals.
@@yaquboulhadj4510 well, congratulations.
@@sachinschn well educated yourself
@@yaquboulhadj4510 well, learn English rather than learning Quran.
@@yaquboulhadj4510 explain what’s violent in the Quran?
Later he made a cartoon saying americans that died in a flooding,Texax were neo-nazis and good for them ... what is your oppinion now
??
The same day Boko Haram destroyed villages and killed thousands of people. We gave Nigeria a blind eye and only focused on Paris.
I have to admit, seeing this guy alone in his dark and messy apartment, the face still marked, with his cigarettes, drawing..all his mates are dead. He breaks my heart. You're muslim ? Does he really look dangerous or like a guy who want to insult you? I mean.. I didn't want to believe it before, but I start to realize that there are still a lot of "moderated muslim" who are chocked by a 5-years-old style draw of a "PROPHET"(lol..). Moderation starts when you have a bit of distance with things like these, guys. I'm french, I want peace, but when I look at the muslim countries in Middle East, Africa, I really don't see where peace is.
@@parkerpeter1795 and he insulted every religion on earth as well . Take it well
So you want peace while People are dropping bombs and burning places in the Middle East
Stfu about the BS
well we are the reason why there is no peace in muslim countries, lets not lie to ourselves lol
@@parkerpeter1795 🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼🖕🏼 Islam Mohammed had a 6 year old wife 🤣🤣 he didn't want his picture drawn because then it would turn into a wanted poster
@@eshalalam237 this doesn't make sense.
Besides the entire video, 10:52-12:00 broke me artistically. It was sad and peaceful at the same time. :'( ❤️
i thought charlie hebdo was a guy
Charlie come from Charles (De Guaule) so yep Charlie is a guy
Same 🤣🤣
@@suarsuar747suar
Great interview VICE! I am almost 100% certain you won't read this comment as the majority of comments are horrific but just wanted to let you guys know that I love VICE for doing what it is they do. Sure you guys are biased sometimes, sure you make mistakes sometimes. But at least you give you us information that no one else seems to be willing to give us. Thank you.
Commenters here would do well to actually watch the interview and listen to this cartoonists thoughts. Very spot on. I almost never say this but Bravo to Vice News for this interview, excellent. Side note when he opened the door with his mustache, glass of red wine, and a cigarette he was the most French person I've ever seen
Why would you draw the picture when you know it is gonna cause violent response. It was not the first time you did it.
Topics about Prophet Muhammad are very sensitive to Muslims. If you think you can make fun of that you get such incidents.....
Many people insult and criticize Christianity or Hinduism but no one gets offended and ends up killing people mercilessly. You Muslims should be ashamed that people are afraid to even criticize your religion. Islam is intolerant and evil.
@@HelloNice-v9uIf that is what you believe then you should read up more on History. You speak from your ass
That was an incredibly interesting and moving interview. The mind of the satirist is an intelligent one, both concerning ideas and emotionally. I also appreciate that the interviewer let him talk while listening so empathetically. As for the phrase “I am Charlie”, I interpret in terms of identity politics. To assert that you are satire, free speech’s most important test, is to empower the ability of the jester to mock the king in the king’s court. It’s the secular equivalent of religious identity assertions
Je suis Charlie
Je suis Kouachi
Adrian C'est meilleur que l'englais. hahah
Lil Jon Tu sais que tu peux être rencontrer par les autorités juste pour avoir écrit ça. Personnellement, je te signale.
vanessarrent Vous prouvez encore votre stupide "liberté d'expression", toute personne disant je suis Charlie pourrait tout autant dire je suis con.
***** ***** l'aggressivité est la réponse des ignorants, j'mattendais pas a mieux de deux charlot completement con.
All this because of a cartoon. Unbelievable!
Doesn't Matter because they Succeeded. Charlie Hebdo will no longer show Muhammad Cartoons and now from their former Editor have gone soft AKA they will no longer be as audacious as before.
The Terrorist won and showed Medueval Barbarity can defeat Western Values.
@@silverhawkscape2677 put your western vales in your ass if people can’t demand ceasefire but can insult a faith
If you don’t want to get hurt or offend by somebody else stop offending others 🙏
'hurt' and 'offended' are two different words with very different meanings. are you implying that 'offending others' justifies 'hurt'?
What are you saying? They could offended him back. The difference is, that some people stand above opinions of others and other people will literally kill you. That is Terrorism
I love how many people like to talk about how they support this newspaper, despite the fact that very, very few of them agree with their almost exclusively anarchist message.
Had me in tears. This man is a hero of free speech and he has suffered for it. He is real.
Artists and heroes. Remember that only to cowards does bravery appear to be stupidity. Anyone who insults their memory with statements of 'they pushed their luck' or 'they should not have offended' does not understand satire, let alone the principles, importance or cost your freedoms. I criticize my country every day but I never forget nor do I take for granted the sacrifices made by soldiers, leaders, citizens and perhaps most importantly artists to provide and sustain my rights. If you are reading this its because great men and women of your nation have ensured freedom of the web (and by extension thought and speech) to you. It is our duty as the privileged of this world to honor those rights and defend them from enemies. We owe it if not to those who have suffered for these rights then to the millions of others who live without them. JE SUIS CHARLIE
Artist hero? Really? How can be a hero when he draw some racist cartoon?
How is he a hero?
Hero is a term that gets passed out like candy. He made some funny pictures and his friends died because of it. Certainly tragic but I wouldnt call it heroic
@@BubbyBold maybe because youre stupid ? and you dont really know what happened ? if you dont call them heroic then WHO ? fucking american soldiers ?
what was he thinking ? He would get flowers from muslim community for mocking prophet (sm) ? And yes dont get me wrong i dont support killing for this reason. But there are extremist people in every community . Although it made my blood boil ,i chose to ignore it . Our muslim sister got attacked because she made some joke and said some serious question for lgbt . Country doesnt give her protection .
France belongs to the french buddy... period. We on europe dont want them here. Out
I'm not a muslim, and don't like some aspects of their religion. But I would never want to disrespect someone's religion. Why would anyone do that? What do you gain from that? You don't have to believe what they believe. Leave them to it. Are you really that out of material? Or are you telling me you really didn't know muslims don't have a sense of humor when it comes to their prophet?
Radical Muslims offended in a democratic country should be removed or very closely watched by the police..there the problem not the cartoonist
@@neilvare-dd1rs I agree, and I am in no way defending what has happened. But it's all good until something you strongly believe in/live by yourself gets insulted and ridiculed.. Why is this man continuing to draw these things when this puts other French people in danger and in the mean time sits in practically a bunker keeping himself safe.
@@wesleyk3600 that the whole point Wes if Muslims cannot handle being offended in a country where it is ok to offend whoever or whatever that may be then should move to a country where they have blasphemy law instead of trying to implement one in the country they are in..I thought Muslims had to respect the law of the land they live in not try and change it to suit them
You’re clearly one of those Islam apologists, trying to justify murder because it’s what someone “believes.”
Go FYS and that nonsensical, backwards-ass thinking.
@@MaryamofShomal You showed no understanding nor the ability to discuss rationally. All name calling and no argument. I didn't justify murder. I called out people who disrespect other people's religion for their own amusement. This thoughtless name calling of yours is as backward as anything, the murderers themselves included.
So we can see clearly here the problem isn’t the cartoons, it’s a much bigger problem with people being murdered, tortured, imprisoned, pushed off buildings and their human rights and freedoms violated. And we are talking whole countries here like Iran, where violence is common place for disobeying rules.
France does not have to obey these rules as it is not under Islamic Law, it is under French Law and French society respects and upholds the freedom of all people. Clearly freedom doesn’t exist or is severely limited in Islamic countries, and that’s what is causing the problem here and creating violence daily across the globe and in every country. But we will never submit to the rules of Islam or any religion. The law is above God, as is personal freedom, and human rights.
Great insight to what he thinks. I feel like he represents what free speech is. The right to cause a discussion to happen over a few people creating an image.
That's not free speech!!! That's playing with fire and they got buuurnnneddd!!!
Jajajajajajaj so free speech is about to make funny of other people? For example the cartoon they did about the inmigrant kid who died in the beach? Thats free speech? In what world are u living? Would you like them to make cartoons about one of your family member who is disability so some idiots can laugh about it? Have some respect for human being..
I was surprised at how much respect he still had for [maybe most] Muslims 7:30
a lot of people have a lack respect for those who have harmed them like that
Luz and charlie hebdo were firmly anti-racist, and islamists cant change that
Anyone watching this in 2019 after the New Zealand massacre?
Action make reaction , never get peace with insult and violation , there is no different word and gun ,
Why don't they condemn the principle of punishment for blasphemy in the Qur'an and Hadiths? That's what needs to be condemned. Not just the actions of the attacker
Teaching freedom of speech and expression by using the charlie hebdo attack as an example is not blasphemy.
@xaviervanhouten3047 Right? These people are so delusional
Who are here after Charlie hebdo 2020 cartoons
Luz is so French, and the French are special, sometimes incomprensibly evolved, thinkers. Luck and life to all thinkers and free speech defenders.
I warn you don't read the comment scroll back up you it will only make you not calm down
Stolen comment
Stolen comment
I'm sorry I didn't make this comment to hope that i get a ton of likes from you i just make it just to warn you to be more careful to read every sensitive comment that people make from this sensitive video, if you guys want to give my comment like it's up to you I don't care if I'm copying this comment or not it's not a big deal I'm just giving a warning.
Freedom of speech has its limits, unchecked freedom is simply anarchy, there are lines you don’t cross
Can we get rid of Islam then, it's clearly anti semitic.
..... Well Said 👍
Plz Don’t Blame Allah Don't Blame Our Religion Or Our Prophet.If U Don't Believe In Islam Than Don't Do What You Believe We Don't Have Any Problems.
From 1400 Years We Follow Our Prophet Muhammad (SAW) Without Making Any Sketch Than Why You Guys Do Something Like That...????
Don't Try To Hurt Anyone’s Religion
Islam Is The Fastest Religion On Earth
You Can't Stop Those People Who Has Believe....
Allah May Give You All Ability To Realise The Truth ♥
From Bangladesh
We indians feel same like u ur people doing same here.
Karma returns
you don't have to disrespect and insult others simply to hold your own ground. if you do that, it shows how shaky your own position is
do you think Charlie Hebdo disrespected muslims ? they disrespected islamists, not muslims. if insulting your prophet is enough to make you kill people, then go to the psychiatrist because youre a psycopath
Thank you, Vice News, for putting such an amazing video out. Thank you, Luz, for telling the truth and telling us your story.
Why he is pretending he is very innocent .Doesn't he has an idea that Muslims are very touchy about their Prophet and it's not the first time west has done this .Whenever West say bad word about the Prophet Muslims will came out like this .This is a very sensitive topic and he is behaving like he is innocent .If you will touch anybody's heart they will touch yours .It hurts them ( Muslims ) that's why they hurt you ......
Please hear me out cause i have nothing against muslims. Some of you killing individuals over satire is not justified. If people kill others because of one thing a prophet said, then thats haram. The mere hypocrisy of killing people (wich is terrible), over a few not respecting one part of your religion? Dont you realise violence wont help respecting your religion? And also if something is made into a satire, it means its respected pretty much. Now people are afraid of your own religion meaning they quite literaly 1. respect your religion less, and konsekvuently your people and 2. They will fear you, not respect you. And making it into a big deal is only gonna make more people want to draw it, aka those who have nothing left to loose.
I don't care how touchy they are. If you don't like what someone says about a supposed prophet, then don't listen to them.
what crime has he done by drawing images?
Truly a man to aspire to be like. I really like those comics as well, you can find them on the internet and I read them any time I could. Good luck to this man.
but dont forget that this has nothing to do with islam
Stop denying it, we Muslims must fight the infidels
'Charlie Hebdo' recently published a number of cartoons of the Russian plane which was bombed by ISIS. I wonder how many cartoons 'Charlie' will publish about the ISIS attack on France. Je suis Charlie?
they are a bunch of filthy hippocritts(i dont know how to spell it)
+David Kasomov yeah the lack of educations reflects it
+Frank Blangeard Oh they will make plenty. Starting tomorrow with the cover: twitter.com/AuskarSurbakti/status/666566182175027200/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
@@davidkasomov6936 you don't even know how to write
Live away of our free and technological societies
Live in your shit hole tyrannical CALIPHAT
him saying "thats why I wear a belt now" was just... so sad 3:58
LONG LIVE CHARLIE HEBDO. And all talented cartoonists. If people can't take a joke over a "blasphemous" cartoon, then don't fucking read it. Personally, I think those drawings are hysterical
lol he opens the door with a glass of wine and a cigarette french as fuck
no words.
respect from India.
Newspapers of India should Learn from the french.
minds alike Jaques Russeu still lives.
My dad's air-force coworker was killed in Paris in the early 80's by terrorists. They are there.
We are with you Paris
I do have to say that I love Charlie Hebdo a little more now because of the blank "responsible" newspaper. That's actually completely hilarious.
His imaginations, his talents,and his hand ... all bloody.
I hope you mean the extremists who attacked them. Because if you're talking about the interviewee, you need to re-examine your life and belief system.
1:02
french stereotype
The problem isn't Islam its the idea that violence is justifiable if in the name of Islam. All monotheistic religions came from one man but the only one that uses violence and terrorizes its critics is the one that claims to be based on peace and love. Some religion Islam is......
Bro, Just respect people and their religion
just respect the law of the land first!
Bro, just don't shoot people who did nothing to you.
Religion should never blind people. What macron did is right. They have to keep a tab on radicalism in France. If some people cant get over a stupid cartoon, they dont belong . If people dint ridicule age old religious beliefs, we would still be in the dark ages.
I am totally against the fact that those people were killed but what the fuck did they expect?
They were begging for it.
lulzaccount In my ass
Yeah sure just be gentle
You sound like the people who say girls who wear short skirts or get drunk deserve to be raped.
How were they begging for it ? Not joking, wanna know how you think they were.
Insulting our beloved Prophet Muhammadﷺ is not freedom of speech
ALLAH hu Akbar
We will never ever accept our beloved Prophet Muhammad SAW insult
It is freedom of speech. Muhammad was a pedophile and a false prophet.
Just dont leave muslim countries
Stay in muslim countries. Dont live in the west if you cant abide by their laws.
@@DreadedDormammuWell guess what? Charlie Hebdo stopped making Muhammad Cartoon and even its former and surviving Editors said the that it had gone soft. I'd say the terrorist succeeded.
Good News. Charlie Hebdo will no longer make Muhammad Cartoon and now have gone soft. So you succeeded and took down Charlie Hebdo.
Such a great interview. What a amazing man.
as someone who loves art and to read about the ways people interact through artworks and especially cartoons this video killed me emotionally
this man is suffering in so many ways, the world is suffering in so many ways, sometimes its really hard to believe such violent acts happend
i really dont want to go and hate on muslims because of all of this, but ive read so much negativity its hard to help such situation
im sorry for being judgemental, but its things like these that make me afraid and anxious when i see people wearing anything that resembles muslim culture or middle east looking people, i will do my best to not be a bad person towards them, but the feeling will forever be there because of such things
why all the hate? why such devotion to a being if its causing such troubles to the world, to their own lives?
what can people do to stop this madness?
Lmao
As long as they follow their religion blindly and with ignorance on their side, there will always be this. Their religion is poison.
Freedom of speech doesnt mean freedom from consequences.
True, but those consequences were undeserved and retarded. Islam is backwards.
Silly stinkers getting mad over a joke.
You don't mess with peoples beliefs. All but that, you trigger trouble automatically!
Ah yes Islam the religion that leaves you in pieces
dont care, didnt care, wont care about what people believe. charlie hebdo was in their rights and anyone saying otherwise is playing the game of the islamists
La France est un pays laïque, les préceptes religieux n'ont aucune prise sur la vie et le comportement des citoyens. On dessine le "prohète", si on veut, comme on le veut. Et on est libre de le faire. La religion ne dictera jamais nos lois. Que ceux qui veulent vivre selon les préceptes de l'islam, le judaïsme ou le christianisme fassent ça chez eux. Nous avons fait la révolution, on ne pliera pas devant une bande de fanatiques.
Vive la liberté, vive la parole sans interdit.
MERDE à ceux qui veulent qu'on se soumette.
MERCI à ceux qui dans le monde entier apportent leur soutien à Charlie
Nous sommes Charlie
Nous sommes LIBRES
Tellement bien dit!
Il n'y a pas de place en France - ni, à mon sens, nulle part ailleurs en Europe - pour la loi de la charia.
Opens the door red wine and cigarette in hand. Most French move ever.
Free speech is cool and all but if you tell them to uneducated people you will need to expect violent
There are almost 5 Bollywood movies made each year in India which criticize the Hindu religion and Muslims watch it happily, No Hindu ever goes on a rampage and kills the director. One of the famous movie PK was supposed to criticize every religion but it didn't criticized Islam. Clearly Islam is intolerant, People are afraid to even criticize Islam because Islam is evil.
You may not value your own religion, we do, We risk everything for this
@@Ondoo3332 We value freedom of speech. You value a pedophile. Stay out of the west.
I'm already stay out the west. But Muslims have now infiltrated the West.
You F spineless coward.@@GeertWilders-cw8nt
Respect to this artist!
He says he isn't obsessed and yet he does everything to hurt Muslim .
@M M and where have you read in Quran this? Which verse? Little knowledge could be dangerous. Unfortunately you are the victim of it. Try finding such verse and come back. Study please.
awesome interview 10/10
That's not prophet Muhammad pbuh . That's now how he or any other prophet looked. Pls stop this
These cartoonists are crazy.
Wth are people support him. He is so disrespect to islam
My question is : 'DID MUSLIMs go to insult french ? does muslim insult jesus ? moses ? ' ---- why french is trying to insult muhammed (pbuh)?
If your allah is so powerful, let him punish them, why ur people picking up guns ?Just belive in allah and move ahead in life
@@serotonin3247" And they urge you to hasten the punishment. And if not for [the decree of] a specified term, punishment would have reached them. But it will surely come to them suddenly while they perceive not. " - surah ankabut .
@@serotonin3247 " But as for those who defiantly disobeyed, their refuge is the Fire. Every time they wish to emerge from it, they will be returned to it while it is said to them, "Taste the punishment of the Fire which you used to deny." " surah sajdah .
@@serotonin3247 Be open mided . Maybe You will understand .
@@hasnathabdullah1253 don't worry isreal took revenge of this they are taking every day
France is beautiful....
Alhamdulillah it will be all Muslim. Ameen
@@boxingmonthly No. Keep it to yourself and let live. We don't need your rotten death cult in the west.
Umm.. no it’s not
@@torilan2672 I posted this comment 5 years ago😂😂😂 it is not to be honest
@@warsthunder hyyy .....after five years you come again ......
Suppose they had mocked prophet of any other religion, whole world would have been criticising them. Because they did against Islam that fits into their agenda. That's why 'call of freedom of speech'. Insulting someone is not FOS. Despite all modernity Europe is still ethnocentric and Islamophobic.
They mocked almost everything
And Charlie Hebdo isn't the only cartoon in France so cartoons mocked everything they could.
What you said is what you want to think but it's wrong
Draw what you want! If it comes down to safety, I will stand guard for you. ~American Citizen
moral of the story: celebrate your fucking birthday, and never be in a rush
00:07 Luz faces challenges after Charlie Hebdo attack
01:37 Cartoonist Luz narrowly escaped Charlie Hebdo attack on his birthday
03:12 Luz reflects on the shock and unpreparedness during the Charlie Hebdo attack
04:54 Navigating between being provocative and victimized in the role of a symbol
06:13 Charlie Hebdo cartoonist reflects on global reactions to his work
07:45 Advocating for responsible journalism and satire
09:21 Luz expresses sadness over Saudi Arabia's response to Charlie Hebdo
10:41 Discussion on the aftermath of the tragic events at Charlie Hebdo
Luz faces challenges after Charlie Hebdo attack
- Luz continues to face difficulties and heightened security measures since drawing Prophet Muhammad cover
- Luz reflects on drawing his thoughts during a police interview
Cartoonist Luz narrowly escaped Charlie Hebdo attack on his birthday
- Luz was late for work due to celebrating his birthday with his wife
- He witnessed armed men entering the building and the start of the attack
Luz reflects on the shock and unpreparedness during the Charlie Hebdo attack
- Luz describes seeing the aftermath of the attack and realizing the severity of the situation
- Luz expresses feeling unprepared and unsure of how to react to such a traumatic event
Navigating between being provocative and victimized in the role of a symbol
- Charlie Hebdo faced criticism for being provocative by depicting Mohammed, but also became a symbol of free expression and victimization
- Struggled with the challenge of being a symbol and the impact on their freedom to use humor in their cartoons
Charlie Hebdo cartoonist reflects on global reactions to his work
- Newspapers in the United States hesitant to publish Charlie Hebdo covers
- Expresses empathy towards the Muslim community and individual encounter at Charb's funeral
Advocating for responsible journalism and satire
- Expressing the desire for a responsible approach to drawing and journalism
- Reflecting on the impact and support received after the Charlie Hebdo attack
Luz expresses sadness over Saudi Arabia's response to Charlie Hebdo
- Luz expresses disappointment in the Saudi representative claiming to support Charlie Hebdo while a blogger is being mistreated and flogged in jail.
- He reflects on the paradox of the situation and his commitment to drawing good people despite the strange world he sees.
Discussion on the aftermath of the tragic events at Charlie Hebdo
- The cartoonist Luz reflects on the mutual forgiveness shared between him and the character he drew, symbolizing moving forward from the tragedy.
- Luz expresses his apology for possibly affecting the character's image and the character's forgiveness towards him.
This is just lack of wisdom. I can think of 1000 noble causes to did for. But this is not one of them. What do you expect muslims to do? Laugh. Am a christian
The problem is politician.Using religion to wage wars and exploit others.
Honestly, I've seen so many cartoons of people making fun of Jesus. Literally the most inappropriate things. NOBODY goes on a killing spree because of it. I can tell you what we don't expect... people to be slaughtered over a cartoon!
Just absolutely crazy that you even tried to défend that as a Christian!
Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high
Where knowledge is free
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments
By narrow domestic walls
Where words come out from the depth of truth
Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way
Into the dreary desert sand of dead habit
Where the mind is led forward by thee
Into ever-widening thought and action
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake.
--- Rabindranath Tagore
I watched this video as a Muslim disliking him but when he said-‘Those who claim all Muslims are offended take Muslims for imbeciles, I think.’ and when he met that Muslim at the funeral, I gained some respect for him. Me personally, I’m not a snowflake who gets offended easily; I honestly don’t care it doesn’t affect my life massively.
Your not a real muslim, neither the one who was at the funeral.
Shut up atheist
how about making a satire cartoon about his dead coworkers and see his and all the the Charlie Hebdo cartoonist reaction....
10:30 This image is the reason our office was burned down
Very important other does not know about muslims,
they love prophet Muhammad more than them selfs and more than any this in the world more than Wives parents and children.
Thank you for likes I appreciate it
And they should show some faith and respect their religion by ignoring what others say, as others ignore what they say. That’s how it works.
So this s what ismlamic extremism is....
What did he gain by insulting Prophet Muhammad ? He could live peacefully and enjoy his life by drawing good things instead of those controversial arts. But he lost his life miserably and all Muslims are now getting slammed for his death.
They got murder fighting for everybody's freedom of conscience and expression.
The world don't have to and will not follow the barbaric rules of a bronze age totalitarist sect of war and submition.
Stop. Justifying. Murder.
I don’t give AF if the Quran says it’s okay - here in the 21st century, it’s NOT OKAY. You can’t murder people because they make fun of your “prophet.”
Remember... Either you die a hero or you live long enough to become a villian.
KILLING over a CARTOON is SO EVIL.
they r from evil cult 😈 club..