Sir ek video reel police aur real police difference pe bhi banao . Kyo ki ordinary people manti hai ki jo power reel police ke pass Hoti hai waise hi powers aur physical ability real police ke pass Hoti hai.
सर ज्यादातर ऑफिसर चमचा का ही ACR अच्छा बनाते है | सर मैं केंद्रीय कर्मचारी हूँ और केरल मे सर्विस दे रहा हूँ | यहाँ ऑफिसर शाही सर चढ़ के बोलती है ग्रुप C और D की हैसियत गुलामों से बेहतर नहीँ है |
(🇮🇳 IMPORTANT NOTICE🇮🇳) ( OFFICE NAME- NITTTR kolkata, This office is Under the Ministry of HRD ) 👉इस ऑफिस में गवर्नमेंट एंप्लॉय के साथ नाइंसाफी हो रही है।गुलामों की तरह बड़े ऑफिसर यूज कर रहे हैं छोटे कर्मचारी को।छोटे एंप्लॉयड के साथ जाति और धर्म का भी भेदभाव किया जाता है।सभी बड़े अधिकारी यहां पर भ्रष्टाचार में शामिल है। कोई भी छोटा कर्मचारी अगर अपनी आवाज को भ्रष्टाचार के खिलाफ उठाना चाहता है तो बड़े ऑफिसर ट्रांसफर करने की धमकी देकर उनके आवाज को दबा देते हैं। अगर यह भ्रष्टाचार रोका नहीं गया तो यह हमारे देश को खोखला कर देगा। अगर हमें अपने देश को बचाना है तो सबसे पहले हमें अपने देश में भ्रष्टाचार को खत्म करना होगा।मैं मोदी जी से रिक्वेस्ट करता हूं। कृपया इस पर ध्यान दें , भ्रष्टाचारी अधिकारी पर जल्द से जल्द कार्रवाई करें। हमारा देश फिर से सोने की चिड़िया कहलाएगा।...जय हिंद वंदे मातरम , जय जवान जय किसान।🇮🇳🇮🇳 👉 My Fight against corruption , Until the last breath.‼️‼️
Ips in up get posted as sp in a district by bribing 30 to 50 lakhs ,and then they rob crores of rupees from that district . From a normal SHO to every police officer give a fixed amount of bribe every month like a normal sho send 30-50 k per month to sp and generally there are 30+ sho's are in a district ,similary applies for ,SICO,ASP ,etc ,so a sp literally earns crores of rupees in a year .....I think reform should start from above bcz India's bureaucrats (ips,ias,irs and etc) are most corrupt in world . ...I have experienced what I have written .
Utkarsh ji! You are absolutely right. Same situation in Haryana but obviously amounts are somewhat higher. SP earns crores from this robbery and sho level officers lakhs per month. Those officials who don't want be a part of this game are never given important postings like sho etc.
First we have to change our mentally.. we commit crime break rules for our own benefit..and if we are unable to pay in return of that..then we called it corruption.. corruption comes from us.. these bureaucrats are simply a chain follower..
Respect for your thoughts and solutions sir I am sub inspector working in Andhrapradesh. I really liked your idea of providing fund to SHO for its maintenance. It will surely help many police officers to become financially independent for station maintenance and remain honest and efficient in their duties.
पुलिस में सिपाही और दरोगा ही सबसे महत्वपूर्ण होता है ।आम आदमी इन्हीं से मिलता है ।बाकी के बडे अफसर आम जनता की पहुंच से बाहर होते हैं ।जनता उन्हें खुश करती है और वे जनता को खुश कर देते हैं ।लेन देन भी होता है ।दरोगा जिन्दाबाद ।
For license renewal my father always has to bribe inspector...he doesn't sign it otherwise.. They say they have to bribe to upper officers also , like dm officer. If you go to court , judge asks for favours 😑... So we bribe police to avoid all this trouble... Why can't we have the provision for online renewal of such license.. They don't approve any such form without bribe...
For this ...there is simple solution like in passport verification ...to fix d no. of days of a file processing either they have to pass on it or they provide a reason behind sacking down
Respected sir i am working as police sub inspector in state of maharashtra. u r explanation so good but never become practically possible. even all officer have to give bribe for legal scrutiny of case file. each and every aspect of policing needs money,money and money. along with that we are helpless to handle habitual offenders. once saint tukaram said"adhamasi to adham" means u should be more evil to handle a evil person. and some problem is occur in officers also like drinking, gambling. hope in future some changes come in criminal justice system.
You are saying , adhamasi to adham, so why don't you feel that it is applicable to police also. And what do you want to say about the case of santhakulam, Tamil nadu.
yes sir, since i am also a government officer witness many thing in day to day working in the system. But sir, many a times the supervisory officer seems reluctant in taking action against their sub-ordinate officer .And if an honest officer makes complaint ,he/she is treated differently,isolated as an alien.Sensing the fear of alienation ,an honest officer does not take stand.
IAS, IPS, IRS officers are mostly corrupt and lazy. They join the service to enjoy the power and get filthy rich. Very few join with an aim to serve the nation. I have zero respect for corrupt people.
Police officials must be terminated rather than suspension . Law must be equal regarding criminal whether it is common person or police official . “ ONE LAW FOR ALL”
THank you sir fr your valueable suggetion fr break a chain of corruption, SIR Nothing id impossble BS naazaria or thori public awareness ki zarrort hai, We can corruptiop free INDIA, public bhi khud corruption krwane me ek role play krti hai THANK You
Aap Jaise logo ko need hai India main..god bless you sir, m staying Singapore honestly sg or India ki koi comparison ni , I feel sad Indians ki reputation Kai countries main Achi ni..
सर हमारे कानून में कुछ ऐसे प्रावधान है जिससे लिगल तरीके से चलते है तो न्याय प्रक्रिया लंबी होती है तो इस विषय मेंरा ऐसा मानना है कि लोग शोर्टकट तरीका अपना कर न्याय की उम्मीद रखते हैं, हमे समग्र प्रक्रिया को एनलाइज करते हुए लोगो को कम से कम समय में न्याय मिले ऐसी न्याय प्रणालि का निर्माण करना चाहिए।
Best of luck Sir.... It is very important that a person like u is giving opinion on our system... I hope things will change in future because of people like u..... Please share this video to PMO.. I have experience they take actions on these...💐
There will be no police or any corruption within one year in India using this method: 1) There should be a rolling Changing squad of following personals: a) Judge -one nos. b) Army Jawan with automatic weapons - two nos. c) Reporter: One no with hidden camera See and record corruption and remove from service with jail.( Like Road side corruption) The army jawans should not enter the office building, remain out side at entry gate with instruction that they should enter the building after say 30 minutes and raid should be live on TV with hidden camera. All squad personal must be in civil dress. Go to municipality give a complain, if officer refuse then remove from the service and jail( Minimum 5 years) The same will be applied on Neta, Pradhan, and all other departments of India. A solid proof , Judge, Army man. Judge, army man and reporter can sit in truck/ tampoo If traffic police ask for money arrest and jail. But things must be nicely recorded in Cameraaaaaaaaaaaaaaa. Raid on, corruption gone. Catch one- one lakh will not take bribe. Do it in every state with 4 such teams. Note: If any one ask to check the hidden camera then his service is automatically gone.Action is better then telling or listening stories. The raid must be live on TV or face book.
Nice, I would like to add more suggestion if it's practical than kindly reply: if there is any complaint of corruption against any government servant, then rather asking people to prove it , our system only kept vigilance and creating dummy customers that officer must be caught and booked and matter must be fast tracked thru special courts in time barring manner. All employees of trap department must have knowledge of law and police manual and identity of these people should never be made public as spy agency.
Sir I respect your post and experience. I am also a retired person from govt job. But in India 90% of corruption is started from elite group. First of all pay anomaly second promotion third recruitment process. For your kind information in England, British govt never recruit directly an IPS officer. Even police department should be under Home Ministry rather than state govt, this is also causes 90% of crime reduction. Last and not least the education system is without moral. Finally, it is historically proved Islamic mentality never ever eliminate the crime and corruption from the society as well as from the country. Jai hind, rest with your IQ. Without corrupt police force and dishonest political leaders the society will be more safe and secure. Gudas are social product, so the society where weakness are to be rectified.
Pretty good insight into the challenges that need to be dealt with! I feel there are a couple of more things that could be worth mentioning (1) Interference by IAS due to their expectation of supremacy (2) High ethical standards should be promoted within the organization (3) The quantity of IPS officers should be limited to avoid stagnation at thr top. State Police Service Officers ahould be utilized more. (4) Smaller units of Police Force with the ability to manage their funding rather than all the collection going to the state fund. This will encourage the smaller units to modernize and improve themselves rather than waiting for grants/budget that may never come. (5) Police density should be defined and adhered to. Shortage in force will always cause stress among Police Personnel.
Taking complaint from someone, for extortion from someone else, is very common in India. An A.C. IT , Rajeev Benjwal took a complaint from one of my ex-employees, just for extortion. Later on, when i cross examined the complainant, he was proved to be false. Rajeev Benjwal was colluding with his Addl. Commr. Sanjay Shrivastava for extortion. But it took me 14 years to clear my name ultimately from Commr. Adjudication, ITAT, H.C., Supreme court - spending crores of rupees on CA's and lawyers. Better pay bribes in India, otherwise getting justice is very tough. The whole Govt. is a mafia.
Police intervention in civil cases of settlement etc definitely led to some sort of corruption. but it also provides speedy justice to parties associated and further act as a preventive measure to any criminal case rising out of civil disputes. Sir please provide the detail analysis of the matter.
Sir this type of vedio help in personality test of upsc .... I'm very thankful to u sir.... and also thankful to stui IQ team by providing this vedio keep doing it like this....and one request is that how to deal some problems in IAS post also plz Doo sir....
Sir i have been listening to you from couple of your videos....and i can easily tell that you are highly experienced and have seen the working of "system" a real close.....there were instances where you were trying for a change but due to the corruption,no one supported you and stood for you...it is very saddening for any person who is willing to be helpful for the society but in return doesn't get much support.
One of the solution to check police corruption is that the public should be legally privileged to take video of the police activity with the accused during police custody . Thanks
Sir, I have an idea that might be argued as theoritical and not more practical but I think that it is pratical too and has some capabilty to eliminate corruption. The idea is to establish a branch that deals totally with corruption but there are lot of restrictions on it so that it itself doesn't go in corruption. It would be basically a digital handling center. Every police in the system would have a small recording device that should be opened from the start of his duty on a day to the end. Any stop in the recording would indicate something wrong. And if he tries to do corruption, he can be caught by the organization which handles corruption when they will taking recording on surveillance.
One must appreciate your attitude and the way you are trying to approach I think more Retired Offers should develop a group or organisation to implement your approach Thanks for your great and kind affords 🙏🙏🙏
A big thanks for sharing such a wonderful information. It's been really a good thing to interact with an officer who has this kind of hypocracy, who saw all the pros & cons of the system. Have many words to say but it's just like writing an essay on this topic. Once again thanks a lot. Warm Regards, Kevin Sharma.
Mr. Rajan singh kaafi practicality hai aapki baaton mein... Very well said...is it not possible that lokayukt are given the powers to check the accountability of an government employee and if it finds that a certain official is not accountable for a job then the lokayukt can make the recommendation for removal of that employee and their recommendations are binding
Nice thought sir.....But sir agar kisi Ko Insaaf chahie tu police reform ke sath sath civil court , criminal court and local bodies refome bhi bahut jaruri haa . kyunki end main tu civil court ya criminal court hi to punishment denge . India bahut sare case pending ha jo ki date aane Tak innocent mar jata hai ya bahut hi old ho jata ... Aur sir India me local bodies bhi bahut corruption karti hai bahut sari case me local bodies like ward councillor mayor etc bhai suspect Ko bachati leti hai kyunki suspect bahut powerful hota ya usse uska link of hota hai...so sir Mera manana hai ki local body civil court criminal court or police administration ine sabhi ka reform hona chahie..... I hope ki aap mere query ka jawab jarur denge.....
Thank you very much Gentleman. I appeal to the connected machinery to consider the former Officer's tips, effect the corrections, and present an effective and friendly Police Personnel to the heartsick public. Thank you Sir again. May God bless everyone.
Sir आप सही बोल रहे है में आप की बात से सहमत हूं इसमे जो लोग इन लोगो से काम करा चुके है उनसे भी feeefback लेना चाहिए , और सैलरी भी उसी हिसाब से देना मैने अभी तक भर्स्ट देखे है ईमान्दार नहीं देखे हैं
This is great sir.I am learning too much from your live sessions sir. You gives us ground information which is very much useful. Thank you so much sir. Jai Hind sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you very much sir for sharing your thoughts in such matter. I have seen another video where you have distinguished between Indian bureaucracy with USA. I just want to know how they reached to that level and why India is still lagging behind to reach that level of eliminating lower level corruption?
Reason is simple. Everyone at the top be it politicians or bureaucrats are highly corrupt and enjoying the present mess at the expense of common people. So they resist and sabotage any kind of improvement in system.
thank you sir, ...apke yesabhi suggestions and ideas UPSC ke interview me bhi kam denge ...as i am preparing for UPSC, Sir apse request hai ki aap aur bhi videos post kiya kare.....
Sir, I am working for a PSU, here vigilance is fully functional but I wonder that entire ecosystem of office is so developed that vigilance is also getting its divident in each crime. Unfortunate but it is true.
Thank you sir , you uploaded this video . it was a very educational, it helped me to understand what to aspect and demand from my government for the betterment of indian police system.
Sir, one of the Main earnings of a Police Man comes from investigation of a case when the person is arrested and the court asked for CD to consider the bail of the accused.. And then Investigation Officer of the said case(not everyone) if gets handsome bribe then he prepare the CD in such a way that the person in jail gets bail.. Infact many Advocates smtime tk to the IO on behalf of the client.. Similarly for Zimma Petition too ex. ur Car or valuable items if seized by police then to get the same also sometimes u hv to manage not only the IO even the MVI..And they tk huge bribe for that..
Please make a video on the proper & faster working of indian courts. Why so much delays occurs in courts & how to improve it, specially on Criminal Cases.
Good Afternoon Sir ! I would like to know answer of some questions :- 1. I heard that corruption money has a hierarchy channel from bottom to top e.g. from Inspector to Political leader and each person involved in this malpractice. Could you please explain this and tell me how it can be eradicated ? 2. In the recent case, Gautam Budh Nagar (U.P.) SSP named Vaibhav Krishnan also told that each area had its price for posting of IPS officer that indicates not only junior officers but also senior officers as well as some political leader are involved in this type of malpractice. Explain this if it is possible for you. Thanking you in Advance...
@@snow-rm3jx consolidation of absolute power in hands of few people , colonial mindset of officers , hierarchical tendencies and you know power corrupts and absolute power.........corrupts absolutely.
sir firstly goverment have to setup a online system for complaints. also goverment have to gave some rewards. so where an anonymous can easily do complaint with proof . one main point is that, this system must regulate by supreme court of india.
आप का परामर्श बहुत अच्छा लगा पर मेरा मानना है की अगर पुलिस के काम मे नेता इंटरफेर ना करें तो पुलिस अपना काम अच्छे से सकती है और पुलिस को अपने आप से संकल्प करना होगा की हम रिस्वत नहीं लेंगे और इससे समाज मे पुलिस के प्रति सम्मान बढ़ेगा जय हिन्द
Jay Hind Sir I am security officer aapka video dekhta hun mere ko bahut Achcha lagta hai aur Main Kanoon ke bare mein jaan Pata hun aur mera duty kar pata hu aap ka ham aabhari he aap guru ke jese bata te ho sir me odisha se hu bargadh distic se hu 🙏
आप का कथन सत्य एबं विकल्प अनुकरणीय हैं, कोई भी नियम या संस्था कितनी भी उपयुक्त क्यों ना हो जब तक उसको चलाने बाले ईमानदार नहीं होंगे संभव नहीं, मैं एक सुझाव और देना चाहूंगा, कॉन्स्टेबल, सब इंस्पेक्टर, इंसपेक्टर आदि की सैलरी तथा सुबिधायें बढ़ानी चाहिये क्योंकि डयूटी के हिसाब से मुझे लगता है कि उनका बेतन कम होता है
Respected Sir, Since birth and as a hindu I am being tought that there is three Lokas - Akash, Patal and Mrituya Lok. Almighty i.e. Lord Vishnu operates these three lokas. As a human being I know more about Mrituya Lok. Upon this Mrituya Lok, IAS officers are having the powers just after Lord Vishnu on the Indian island. This is my personal feelings but without any evidence/proof that real disease in the form of corruptions lies here. Regards
Sir you gave a great knowledge and shows another frame. Sir please tells about , how we speed up education system, it's infrastructure, efficiency, skills.
Sir aapne bhut si baaten sahi khi hai lekin aapne jo tarike bataen hai unse shayd hi curruption kam hoga or.....jitna mene is system ko samjha hai hamare desh se shayd hi kabhi curruption jesi problem khatm ho paayegi ....aapne jo baaten batai vo sirf curruption rupi ek rakshas ki ungli ke saman thi jabki pura rakshas to abhi baki hai ....is tarh se sir cruption hamare desh ki jado me hai jo sambhav nhi ki jado se nikal diya ja sake 🙏
सरकारी विभाग में भरस्टाचार को खत्म करना बहुत आसान है बस सरकार में इक्षा शक्ति होनी चाहिए । सबसे आसान उपाय है कि सभी सरकारी कर्मचारियों को डीजिटल भुगतान 100 प्रतिशत अनिवार्य कर देना चाहिए, सभी सरकारी कर्मचारियों के पत्नी बच्चो के नाम की प्रॉपर्टी को उस सरकारी कर्मचारी को के आय को माना जाए अगर वह कुछ नही करते है अगर वह कोई काम करते है तो उनको भी डिजीटल भुगतान को बाध्य करना चाहिये।
official fund now can be allocated , and can be told to that police officer to spend it via elctronically not by cash, so that transaction is recorded.
Hum ko lag ta hai kam salary aur slow promotion bhi ak reason hai. Mey kai police constable ko janta hun jin ko computer operate kar ne hai ata hai aur unke group me ak ko bhut acha se ata yahan tak ki wo log us ak constable 70% work jo wo 1 din me complete kar ta hai wo log 10 se 20 din laga dange karne me aur tabhi barabar salary milta hai
Sir , Good Presentation on the topic . But I think , some of the imp points are missed here and it’s about the Transfers & postings of Officers of various cadres in Police Deptt at certain imp places / Thanas of good income sources etc by Politicians/ Minister on some considerations/ on the basis of bribery etc as I heard from the horses mouth . I also heard that it’s a chain from top to bottom and most of the Officers / Staff are engaged in regular hafta Vasuli from Street Vendors/ Liqour Shop walas / Liqour , Sand Mafias, Truck owners / drivers and other sources . I may be wrong but just mentioned this as I heard and also seen Traffic Police in doing so .
Watch former IPS Officer Rajan Singh’s all videos here
th-cam.com/play/PLpuxPG4TUOR7j9nsScL6yZNoiAbULuAOD.html
Sir ek video reel police aur real police difference pe bhi banao .
Kyo ki ordinary people manti hai ki jo power reel police ke pass Hoti hai waise hi powers aur physical ability real police ke pass Hoti hai.
I love his suggestion as a ex ias officer
Sir ek din apane upsc k interview k bare m b bataye.
Study IQ education क्या anonymous Police station wise पब्लिक reporting , भ्रष्टाचार को कम कर सकती है?
Rajan sir,Please start podcast on spotify. It would much time saving and I would be able to listen more
सर ज्यादातर ऑफिसर चमचा का ही ACR अच्छा बनाते है | सर मैं केंद्रीय कर्मचारी हूँ और केरल मे सर्विस दे रहा हूँ | यहाँ ऑफिसर शाही सर चढ़ के बोलती है ग्रुप C और D की हैसियत गुलामों से बेहतर नहीँ है |
Aap NE shai khah
Rightly remarked bro
Ye dekh lo......har deptt mein ye haal hain......I don't know how long we survive with such rotten system
आपने सही कहा मेरे साथ रेलवे में भी यही होता है
(🇮🇳 IMPORTANT NOTICE🇮🇳)
( OFFICE NAME- NITTTR kolkata, This office is Under the Ministry of HRD ) 👉इस ऑफिस में
गवर्नमेंट एंप्लॉय के साथ नाइंसाफी हो रही है।गुलामों की तरह बड़े ऑफिसर यूज कर रहे हैं छोटे कर्मचारी को।छोटे एंप्लॉयड के साथ जाति और धर्म का भी भेदभाव किया जाता है।सभी बड़े अधिकारी यहां पर भ्रष्टाचार में शामिल है। कोई भी छोटा कर्मचारी अगर अपनी आवाज को भ्रष्टाचार के खिलाफ उठाना चाहता है तो बड़े ऑफिसर ट्रांसफर करने की धमकी देकर उनके आवाज को दबा देते हैं। अगर यह भ्रष्टाचार रोका नहीं गया तो यह हमारे देश को खोखला कर देगा। अगर हमें अपने देश को बचाना है तो सबसे पहले हमें अपने देश में भ्रष्टाचार को खत्म करना होगा।मैं मोदी जी से रिक्वेस्ट करता हूं। कृपया इस पर ध्यान दें , भ्रष्टाचारी अधिकारी पर जल्द से जल्द कार्रवाई करें। हमारा देश फिर से सोने की चिड़िया कहलाएगा।...जय हिंद वंदे मातरम , जय जवान जय किसान।🇮🇳🇮🇳 👉 My Fight against corruption , Until the last breath.‼️‼️
Ips in up get posted as sp in a district by bribing 30 to 50 lakhs ,and then they rob crores of rupees from that district .
From a normal SHO to every police officer give a fixed amount of bribe every month like a normal sho send 30-50 k per month to sp and generally there are 30+ sho's are in a district ,similary applies for ,SICO,ASP ,etc ,so a sp literally earns crores of rupees in a year .....I think reform should start from above bcz India's bureaucrats (ips,ias,irs and etc) are most corrupt in world .
...I have experienced what I have written .
Actually it is the top which forces the bottom to do corruption if the top is good than bottom will be forced to follow it.
Utkarsh ji! You are absolutely right. Same situation in Haryana but obviously amounts are somewhat higher. SP earns crores from this robbery and sho level officers lakhs per month. Those officials who don't want be a part of this game are never given important postings like sho etc.
@pushpendra singh you are absolutely right.
First we have to change our mentally.. we commit crime break rules for our own benefit..and if we are unable to pay in return of that..then we called it corruption.. corruption comes from us.. these bureaucrats are simply a chain follower..
Nice perspective sir!! Court cases kese jaldi niptaye Jaye aur police ki usmai bhumika ke bare Mai video banaiye
Respect for your thoughts and solutions sir
I am sub inspector working in Andhrapradesh. I really liked your idea of providing fund to SHO for its maintenance. It will surely help many police officers to become financially independent for station maintenance and remain honest and efficient in their duties.
पुलिस में सिपाही और दरोगा ही सबसे महत्वपूर्ण होता है ।आम आदमी इन्हीं से मिलता है ।बाकी के बडे अफसर आम जनता की पहुंच से बाहर होते हैं ।जनता उन्हें खुश करती है और वे जनता को खुश कर देते हैं ।लेन देन भी होता है ।दरोगा जिन्दाबाद ।
What happened to Dypt.SP SHAILENDRA SINGH in UP is well known to Nation.
For license renewal my father always has to bribe inspector...he doesn't sign it otherwise..
They say they have to bribe to upper officers also , like dm officer.
If you go to court , judge asks for favours 😑...
So we bribe police to avoid all this trouble...
Why can't we have the provision for online renewal of such license..
They don't approve any such form without bribe...
Logo ke man meh hi khot hai 🙁Indians bahut hi laalchi swabhav ke hote hain isliye hum pichde hain 😡
very true.
@@rgcse2400 ha bhai judge sab mile rahte he advocate se bhai bhai ka pyarr
For this ...there is simple solution like in passport verification ...to fix d no. of days of a file processing either they have to pass on it or they provide a reason behind sacking down
Respected sir
i am working as police sub inspector in state of maharashtra. u r explanation so good but never become practically possible. even all officer have to give bribe for legal scrutiny of case file. each and every aspect of policing needs money,money and money. along with that we are helpless to handle habitual offenders. once saint tukaram said"adhamasi to adham" means u should be more evil to handle a evil person. and some problem is occur in officers also like drinking, gambling. hope in future some changes come in criminal justice system.
Very Good keep it up . Absolutely true
You are saying , adhamasi to adham, so why don't you feel that it is applicable to police also.
And what do you want to say about the case of santhakulam, Tamil nadu.
Sir, Keep it up👍
You are honest officer.
🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲🤲
But don’t harass common people for Rs200 300 everyone don’t have money source of bribery like you guys.... don’t expect everyone same please...
yes sir, since i am also a government officer witness many thing in day to day working in the system. But sir, many a times the supervisory officer seems reluctant in taking action against their sub-ordinate officer .And if an honest officer makes complaint ,he/she is treated differently,isolated as an alien.Sensing the fear of alienation ,an honest officer does not take stand.
Good experience. If every police employee/officer works under CCTV cameras under control of higher authority. 95%corruption will be stopped.thanks
Please bring an ex ias also - showcasing ias struggles( related to corruption, insult of junior ias by seniors- while doing work, etc.)
IAS, IPS, IRS officers are mostly corrupt and lazy. They join the service to enjoy the power and get filthy rich. Very few join with an aim to serve the nation. I have zero respect for corrupt people.
@@wolfmangoland7972 mostly people from IIT,IIM or both will not be corrupt
Your honesty speaking through these brilliant suggestions. People shall also come forward and cut the circle of corrupt practices.
Solution is to minimize human interface, digitization, standard SOPs, Decentralization, minimum laws
Police officials must be terminated rather than suspension . Law must be equal regarding criminal whether it is common person or police official .
“ ONE LAW FOR ALL”
THank you sir fr your valueable suggetion fr break a chain of corruption,
SIR Nothing id impossble BS naazaria or thori public awareness ki zarrort hai,
We can corruptiop free INDIA,
public bhi khud corruption krwane me ek role play krti hai
THANK You
Aap Jaise logo ko need hai India main..god bless you sir, m staying Singapore honestly sg or India ki koi comparison ni , I feel sad Indians ki reputation Kai countries main Achi ni..
मैंने अपने करियर में इतने विश्वासघाती अधिकारी देखें हैं कि अब मेरा आप जैसे व्यक्तित्व पर भी विश्वास नहीं हो पाता।
Thank you Sir for sharing your thoughts on this. We don't get such practical information even in standard books.
सर हमारे कानून में कुछ ऐसे प्रावधान है जिससे लिगल तरीके से चलते है तो न्याय प्रक्रिया लंबी होती है तो इस विषय मेंरा ऐसा मानना है कि लोग शोर्टकट तरीका अपना कर न्याय की उम्मीद रखते हैं, हमे समग्र प्रक्रिया को एनलाइज करते हुए लोगो को कम से कम समय में न्याय मिले ऐसी न्याय प्रणालि का निर्माण करना चाहिए।
Dear Sir, आपकी जानकारियाँ बहुत लाभकारी सिद्ध होंगी यदि हम साधारण जनता से अधिक ध्यान सरकार दे दें तो
Thank you sir for showing us the flip side of coin...
Befor this I was only thinking opposite to this
Best of luck Sir....
It is very important that a person like u is giving opinion on our system... I hope things will change in future because of people like u..... Please share this video to PMO.. I have experience they take actions on these...💐
There will be no police or any corruption within one year in India using this method:
1) There should be a rolling Changing squad of following personals:
a) Judge -one nos.
b) Army Jawan with automatic weapons - two nos.
c) Reporter: One no with hidden camera
See and record corruption and remove from service with jail.( Like Road side corruption)
The army jawans should not enter the office building, remain out side at entry gate with instruction that they should enter the building after say 30 minutes and raid should be live on TV with hidden camera.
All squad personal must be in civil dress.
Go to municipality give a complain, if officer refuse then remove from the service and jail( Minimum 5 years)
The same will be applied on Neta, Pradhan, and all other departments of India.
A solid proof , Judge, Army man. Judge, army man and reporter can sit in truck/ tampoo If traffic police ask for money arrest and jail.
But things must be nicely recorded in Cameraaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.
Raid on, corruption gone.
Catch one- one lakh will not take bribe. Do it in every state with 4 such teams.
Note: If any one ask to check the hidden camera then his service is automatically gone.Action is better then telling or listening stories. The raid must be live on TV or face book.
Dear sir. Corruption is from top and you were one of the top most corrupt officer and you know it. God bless the nation.
Nice, I would like to add more suggestion if it's practical than kindly reply: if there is any complaint of corruption against any government servant, then rather asking people to prove it , our system only kept vigilance and creating dummy customers that officer must be caught and booked and matter must be fast tracked thru special courts in time barring manner. All employees of trap department must have knowledge of law and police manual and identity of these people should never be made public as spy agency.
Sar logo me aam dharna hai niche se kamai up to D G P and above Home or C M
सर 5 साल से कम 3 साल मात्र होना चाहिए। यदि दोषी है तो सीधा घर,
बहुत सुंदर सर
as you said, we should include technology in it, human interference should be minimized.
Sir I respect your post and experience. I am also a retired person from govt job. But in India 90% of corruption is started from elite group. First of all pay anomaly second promotion third recruitment process. For your kind information in England, British govt never recruit directly an IPS officer. Even police department should be under Home Ministry rather than state govt, this is also causes 90% of crime reduction. Last and not least the education system is without moral. Finally, it is historically proved Islamic mentality never ever eliminate the crime and corruption from the society as well as from the country. Jai hind, rest with your IQ. Without corrupt police force and dishonest political leaders the society will be more safe and secure. Gudas are social product, so the society where weakness are to be rectified.
Pretty good insight into the challenges that need to be dealt with! I feel there are a couple of more things that could be worth mentioning (1) Interference by IAS due to their expectation of supremacy (2) High ethical standards should be promoted within the organization (3) The quantity of IPS officers should be limited to avoid stagnation at thr top. State Police Service Officers ahould be utilized more. (4) Smaller units of Police Force with the ability to manage their funding rather than all the collection going to the state fund. This will encourage the smaller units to modernize and improve themselves rather than waiting for grants/budget that may never come. (5) Police density should be defined and adhered to. Shortage in force will always cause stress among Police Personnel.
Taking complaint from someone, for extortion from someone else, is very common in India. An A.C. IT , Rajeev Benjwal took a complaint from one of my ex-employees, just for extortion. Later on, when i cross examined the complainant, he was proved to be false.
Rajeev Benjwal was colluding with his Addl. Commr. Sanjay Shrivastava for extortion. But it took me 14 years to clear my name ultimately from Commr. Adjudication, ITAT, H.C., Supreme court - spending crores of rupees on CA's and lawyers.
Better pay bribes in India, otherwise getting justice is very tough.
The whole Govt. is a mafia.
Police intervention in civil cases of settlement etc definitely led to some sort of corruption. but it also provides speedy justice to parties associated and further act as a preventive measure to any criminal case rising out of civil disputes.
Sir please provide the detail analysis of the matter.
Sir this type of vedio help in personality test of upsc .... I'm very thankful to u sir.... and also thankful to stui IQ team by providing this vedio keep doing it like this....and one request is that how to deal some problems in IAS post also plz Doo sir....
Sir i have been listening to you from couple of your videos....and i can easily tell that you are highly experienced and have seen the working of "system" a real close.....there were instances where you were trying for a change but due to the corruption,no one supported you and stood for you...it is very saddening for any person who is willing to be helpful for the society but in return doesn't get much support.
Salute hai sir aapko
Aap jaise log ho to is desh me crime nhi rahega
MR. Rajan, thanks for sharing your views and experience on this issue. What a panchayat can do to avoid abuse of power by police personnel.
Very nice sir....I m ips aspirant ...and I m really getting very good exposure about police Dept through ur videos..thanks alot
Sir UPSC ke point of view se interview me good answer diya ja Sakta h , sir aap ese hi various topic par video late rahiye,thanks sir.
Excellent suggestions Sir. 👌👌👍🎉
Your teaching style is fantastic sir
One of the solution to check police corruption is that the public should be legally privileged to take video of the police activity with the accused during police custody . Thanks
Sir, I have an idea that might be argued as theoritical and not more practical but I think that it is pratical too and has some capabilty to eliminate corruption.
The idea is to establish a branch that deals totally with corruption but there are lot of restrictions on it so that it itself doesn't go in corruption. It would be basically a digital handling center. Every police in the system would have a small recording device that should be opened from the start of his duty on a day to the end. Any stop in the recording would indicate something wrong. And if he tries to do corruption, he can be caught by the organization which handles corruption when they will taking recording on surveillance.
One must appreciate your attitude and the way you are trying to approach
I think more Retired Offers should develop a group or organisation to implement your approach
Thanks for your great and kind affords
🙏🙏🙏
A big thanks for sharing such a wonderful information. It's been really a good thing to interact with an officer who has this kind of hypocracy, who saw all the pros & cons of the system. Have many words to say but it's just like writing an essay on this topic.
Once again thanks a lot.
Warm Regards,
Kevin Sharma.
Respect and love for you Sir. 🇵🇰
Mr. Rajan singh kaafi practicality hai aapki baaton mein... Very well said...is it not possible that lokayukt are given the powers to check the accountability of an government employee and if it finds that a certain official is not accountable for a job then the lokayukt can make the recommendation for removal of that employee and their recommendations are binding
Thanks you for great information and with examples. Hope someday we will have less corruption in India
Please make video on Licensing process of Gun in INDIA and the possibility of getting a Licensed Gun for a civilian
Nice thought sir.....But sir agar kisi Ko Insaaf chahie tu police reform ke sath sath civil court , criminal court and local bodies refome bhi bahut jaruri haa . kyunki end main tu civil court ya criminal court hi to punishment denge . India bahut sare case pending ha jo ki date aane Tak innocent mar jata hai ya bahut hi old ho jata ... Aur sir India me local bodies bhi bahut corruption karti hai bahut sari case me local bodies like ward councillor mayor etc bhai suspect Ko bachati leti hai kyunki suspect bahut powerful hota ya usse uska link of hota hai...so sir Mera manana hai ki local body civil court criminal court or police administration ine sabhi ka reform hona chahie..... I hope ki aap mere query ka jawab jarur denge.....
Thank you very much Gentleman.
I appeal to the connected machinery to consider the former Officer's tips, effect the corrections, and present an effective and friendly Police Personnel to the heartsick public.
Thank you Sir again.
May God bless everyone.
Awareness is almost solution for any type of corruption. .so ur initiative way is very good job sir..salute apko.🙏🙏🙏
Sir
आप सही बोल रहे है में आप की बात से सहमत हूं इसमे जो लोग इन लोगो से काम करा चुके है उनसे भी feeefback लेना चाहिए , और सैलरी भी उसी हिसाब से देना मैने अभी तक भर्स्ट देखे है ईमान्दार नहीं देखे हैं
This is great sir.I am learning too much from your live sessions sir. You gives us ground information which is very much useful. Thank you so much sir. Jai Hind sir 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Tooo Good sir ... Thank you fr giving such information so. We actually knows abut police and It’s working...
Thank you very much sir for sharing your thoughts in such matter. I have seen another video where you have distinguished between Indian bureaucracy with USA. I just want to know how they reached to that level and why India is still lagging behind to reach that level of eliminating lower level corruption?
Reason is simple. Everyone at the top be it politicians or bureaucrats are highly corrupt and enjoying the present mess at the expense of common people. So they resist and sabotage any kind of improvement in system.
Beurocracy ko system sey khtm krne ki jaroorat hai
thank you sir, ...apke yesabhi suggestions and ideas UPSC ke interview me bhi kam denge ...as i am preparing for UPSC, Sir apse request hai ki aap aur bhi videos post kiya kare.....
Sir please also talk about talk about caste based discrimination. This is the reality.
Thanks for very nice Suggestions🇮🇳🌸🙏
V good and practical deliberation. Hope Govt.s will adopt it some day.👍👍
Public awareness and political will power is the basic requirement to face any negative aspect of society
Thanku Sir... We need officers like u.. U r contributing now on a large scale.. By instilling these ideas
Sir, I am working for a PSU, here vigilance is fully functional but I wonder that entire ecosystem of office is so developed that vigilance is also getting its divident in each crime. Unfortunate but it is true.
Please influence your aura in our deep rooted societies. Your endeavour can teach moral values to corrupted minds.
Thank you sir , you uploaded this video . it was a very educational, it helped me to understand what to aspect and demand from my government for the betterment of indian police system.
Real and effective knowledge sir. Thanks a lot.
Sir, Aap itne Confidential video kaise share karte ho Ex-Officer ho k bhi. Yeh sab baat aaj tak sirf Film mai hi dekhi hai. Aapko Darr nahi lagta?
Sir, one of the Main earnings of a Police Man comes from investigation of a case when the person is arrested and the court asked for CD to consider the bail of the accused.. And then Investigation Officer of the said case(not everyone) if gets handsome bribe then he prepare the CD in such a way that the person in jail gets bail.. Infact many Advocates smtime tk to the IO on behalf of the client.. Similarly for Zimma Petition too ex. ur Car or valuable items if seized by police then to get the same also sometimes u hv to manage not only the IO even the MVI..And they tk huge bribe for that..
I would be greatful if i got a chance to be your subordinate, your views are 100% realistic
Nice to see somebody came flowered to enlighten and share experience
Police system should be alike as defence system. In deffence systems corruption is very less. Deffence bodies r very disciplined.
Please make a video on the proper & faster working of indian courts. Why so much delays occurs in courts & how to improve it, specially on Criminal Cases.
Superb discussion sirji.
Very nice guidelines, Sir.
Good Afternoon Sir ! I would like to know answer of some questions :-
1. I heard that corruption money has a hierarchy channel from bottom to top e.g. from Inspector to Political leader and each person involved in this malpractice. Could you please explain this and tell me how it can be eradicated ?
2. In the recent case, Gautam Budh Nagar (U.P.) SSP named Vaibhav Krishnan also told that each area had its price for posting of IPS officer that indicates not only junior officers but also senior officers as well as some political leader are involved in this type of malpractice. Explain this if it is possible for you.
Thanking you in Advance...
Sir, ACR system suggested by you will lead to dictatorship in the system.....
How please explain
@@snow-rm3jx consolidation of absolute power in hands of few people , colonial mindset of officers , hierarchical tendencies and you know power corrupts and absolute power.........corrupts absolutely.
sir firstly goverment have to setup a online system for complaints. also goverment have to gave some rewards. so where an anonymous can easily do complaint with proof . one main point is that, this system must regulate by supreme court of india.
आप का परामर्श बहुत अच्छा लगा
पर मेरा मानना है की अगर पुलिस के काम मे नेता इंटरफेर ना करें तो पुलिस अपना काम अच्छे से सकती है
और पुलिस को अपने आप से संकल्प करना होगा की हम रिस्वत नहीं लेंगे और इससे समाज मे पुलिस के प्रति सम्मान बढ़ेगा
जय हिन्द
Imandar sirf wo hi hai jisko corruption ka moka nahi milta.
Jay Hind Sir I am security officer aapka video dekhta hun mere ko bahut Achcha lagta hai aur Main Kanoon ke bare mein jaan Pata hun aur mera duty kar pata hu aap ka ham aabhari he aap guru ke jese bata te ho sir me odisha se hu bargadh distic se hu 🙏
आप का कथन सत्य एबं विकल्प अनुकरणीय हैं, कोई भी नियम या संस्था कितनी भी उपयुक्त क्यों ना हो जब तक उसको चलाने बाले ईमानदार नहीं होंगे संभव नहीं, मैं एक सुझाव और देना चाहूंगा, कॉन्स्टेबल, सब इंस्पेक्टर, इंसपेक्टर आदि की सैलरी तथा सुबिधायें बढ़ानी चाहिये क्योंकि डयूटी के हिसाब से मुझे लगता है कि उनका बेतन कम होता है
To fir jinki tankhvah above 50 thousand he vo Kyu risvat lete he niyat saaf honi chahiye na ki tankhvah
The only and only solution is-
Bachoo se lekar bado tak har stage par, har course me, sabhi me moral values develop ki jaee
Yes and parents play a huge role in imparting moral values to their children. Everybody has to take it's own responsibility.
सब मिले हुए होते हैं...आप जैसे बड़े अधिकारी भी मिले होते हैं,,छोटे अधिकारी तो छोटा घूस लेते हैं, आप जैसे बड़े अधिकारी तो बड़ा घूस लेते हैं
There can a system like short service commission and full service commission Officers can be sorted based on various gradings.
Respected Sir, Since birth and as a hindu I am being tought that there is three Lokas - Akash, Patal and Mrituya Lok. Almighty i.e. Lord Vishnu operates these three lokas. As a human being I know more about Mrituya Lok. Upon this Mrituya Lok, IAS officers are having the powers just after Lord Vishnu on the Indian island. This is my personal feelings but without any evidence/proof that real disease in the form of corruptions lies here. Regards
Good knowledge about working of system .
U made things more clear and vivid.
Wonderful Lecture on Indian Police Administration.
Sir you gave a great knowledge and shows another frame. Sir please tells about , how we speed up education system, it's infrastructure, efficiency, skills.
Nice sir , good ideas we have to implement the ideas Which was described by u ,and I hope so ,we will get better results 🙏
Sir i was listening your video while cutting grass for cows....i really like your video....
Sir very True and realistic information and suggestions Every policemen has to follow for better Indian police work system
Sir aapne bhut si baaten sahi khi hai lekin aapne jo tarike bataen hai unse shayd hi curruption kam hoga or.....jitna mene is system ko samjha hai hamare desh se shayd hi kabhi curruption jesi problem khatm ho paayegi ....aapne jo baaten batai vo sirf curruption rupi ek rakshas ki ungli ke saman thi jabki pura rakshas to abhi baki hai ....is tarh se sir cruption hamare desh ki jado me hai jo sambhav nhi ki jado se nikal diya ja sake 🙏
Thank you sir for sharing your knowledge and experience.
Thank you sir
Your videos always tell about reality of our administration and these are always information
सरकारी विभाग में भरस्टाचार को खत्म करना बहुत आसान है बस सरकार में इक्षा शक्ति होनी चाहिए । सबसे आसान उपाय है कि सभी सरकारी कर्मचारियों को डीजिटल भुगतान 100 प्रतिशत अनिवार्य कर देना चाहिए, सभी सरकारी कर्मचारियों के पत्नी बच्चो के नाम की प्रॉपर्टी को उस सरकारी कर्मचारी को के आय को माना जाए अगर वह कुछ नही करते है अगर वह कोई काम करते है तो उनको भी डिजीटल भुगतान को बाध्य करना चाहिये।
official fund now can be allocated , and can be told to that police officer to spend it via elctronically not by cash, so that transaction is recorded.
भ्रष्टाचार के खिलाफ पब्लिक ओपिनियन ही सटीक आधार हो सकता है....
Thank you Sir, Apke wajah se police system samjane Ke madad milati hai.
Hum ko lag ta hai kam salary aur slow promotion bhi ak reason hai.
Mey kai police constable ko janta hun jin ko computer operate kar ne hai ata hai aur unke group me ak ko bhut acha se ata yahan tak ki wo log us ak constable 70% work jo wo 1 din me complete kar ta hai wo log 10 se 20 din laga dange karne me aur tabhi barabar salary milta hai
really good if we have whistle blower kind of thing implemented, it can really impact the way police behave with general public
Sir , Good Presentation on the topic . But I think , some of the imp points are missed here and it’s about the Transfers & postings of Officers of various cadres in Police Deptt at certain imp places / Thanas of good income sources etc by Politicians/ Minister on some considerations/ on the basis of bribery etc as I heard from the horses mouth . I also heard that it’s a chain from top to bottom and most of the Officers / Staff are engaged in regular hafta Vasuli from Street Vendors/ Liqour Shop walas / Liqour , Sand Mafias, Truck owners / drivers and other sources . I may be wrong but just mentioned this as I heard and also seen Traffic Police in doing so .
Very practical and implementable suggestions