You do know that Magda is played in cedh right? Like all u need is a vehicle and u start spitting out treasures and tutoring up combo peace’s. Your also extreamly bias against white, white is imo a lot better than mono black and red now as it’s capable of dealing with any permanent type as well as having diecent ramp and card draw now, we just got trouble in pairs and have archivist of ogma and esper centennial. As well as things like archomancers map land tax and smothering tithe. Also myrells text of players can’t play thing on my turn shuts down countermagic and is why he is a great stack commander.
what do you mean black will have trouble untapping? you have all the tutors and umbral mantle, and can tutor of any infinite mana combo you need. or sac it with thousand year elixer, or with unwinding clock if your group bans infinite combos.
I have a friend who plays this, and it gets out of hand FAST if you don't stop it quickly. Last game, she was swinging for 30 (+ 15 from an enchantment) and double strike with flying and protection from all colors but white.
@loganferriera1294 agreed, which also goes for most commanders really. So much of it depends on what else is in the deck in the way of protection and countermeasures. My friend has the deck loaded with lots of those, especially in auras, which Lightpaws can tutor exactly what's needed to adapt for the game at hand. I'm not saying she's S tier, but I'd definitely put her higher than Mitch did.
How could you not have Leonardo da Vinci? It brings in mana level 9 in the portal or chromatic orrary for 3 one blue and 2 colorless I have won a tournament and it wins consistently on turn 5 but being able to go infinite on turn 5 and play platinum Angel for 3 or all the other high costing don’t forget about Leonardo da Vinci.
He said it was the most popular mono color commanders on edhrec dude and no one is playing him I brought him to an lgs close to my wife’s job and nobody knew that he even came out the dude pops off but assassin creed cards except for maybe the regalia they’re not that popular or known, hell I got a serialized da Vinci for 80 bucks because no one wanted it
Where is Dionus?? He's an extremely broken mono green commander who can go infinite on turn 4/5 with relative consistency. Criminal that hes not even on the list
Magda in C tier tsk tsk bro has never gone up against a good Magda deck if he thinks Magda is C arguably the best commander in this list maybe second to urza
Magda in C tier? Imotek in D tier? Tergrid/Sheoldred on the same level/better than K’rikk? Come on Mitch!
Yeah, Magda is a legit budget cEDH commander.
I feel like his play group or his local meta is affecting his bias.
@@TheRupertking88 I mean… I surely hope so. Even then, this tier list is a pretty bad take
Krenko at B???????????????????????????????
Omnath in D tier is criminal. Extremely strong commander that is very easy to ramp up. Probably the best Voltron commander in the game.
Magda wins turn 3-5 for under $50
You do know that Magda is played in cedh right? Like all u need is a vehicle and u start spitting out treasures and tutoring up combo peace’s.
Your also extreamly bias against white, white is imo a lot better than mono black and red now as it’s capable of dealing with any permanent type as well as having diecent ramp and card draw now, we just got trouble in pairs and have archivist of ogma and esper centennial. As well as things like archomancers map land tax and smothering tithe. Also myrells text of players can’t play thing on my turn shuts down countermagic and is why he is a great stack commander.
You sir have never faced a light paws player, it can win as early as turn 2
what do you mean black will have trouble untapping? you have all the tutors and umbral mantle, and can tutor of any infinite mana combo you need. or sac it with thousand year elixer, or with unwinding clock if your group bans infinite combos.
Where is Marwyn??????
K’rrik is a turn 1-3 win… he’s the definition of A tier.
Krenko is only b teir in a vacuum of mono color commanders? That just seems insane.
If kami of the crescent moon isn't on this list, I'm gonna cry.
I see my favorite mono color... my meanest most expensive deck. Although I have plans to build a truly Royal Teysa Karlov.
You don't wheel with sheoldred you make infinite combos that ping off of draw.
Shocked to see Light-Paws so low. I thought it was brokenly powerful (never played it or against it).
Very good but not ok just underestimated alot cus it's monowhite
Has the Typical mono white issues and still a Vultron strategy, which is unfortunately a very glass Canon strategy
I have a friend who plays this, and it gets out of hand FAST if you don't stop it quickly. Last game, she was swinging for 30 (+ 15 from an enchantment) and double strike with flying and protection from all colors but white.
@Balcamion79 I'm not saying it's not strong but a lot can stop it. A board wipes. Single target removal. Fogs. An Enchantment
@loganferriera1294 agreed, which also goes for most commanders really. So much of it depends on what else is in the deck in the way of protection and countermeasures. My friend has the deck loaded with lots of those, especially in auras, which Lightpaws can tutor exactly what's needed to adapt for the game at hand. I'm not saying she's S tier, but I'd definitely put her higher than Mitch did.
It isn’t in the most popular, but Watcher In The Water is an easy A Tier. Maybe S Tier. And yes, this is a hill I will die on.
How could you not have Leonardo da Vinci? It brings in mana level 9 in the portal or chromatic orrary for 3 one blue and 2 colorless I have won a tournament and it wins consistently on turn 5 but being able to go infinite on turn 5 and play platinum Angel for 3 or all the other high costing don’t forget about Leonardo da Vinci.
He said it was the most popular mono color commanders on edhrec dude and no one is playing him I brought him to an lgs close to my wife’s job and nobody knew that he even came out the dude pops off but assassin creed cards except for maybe the regalia they’re not that popular or known, hell I got a serialized da Vinci for 80 bucks because no one wanted it
Magda in C tier...
Rest seems ok though.
Isn't she used in cEDH, what is Mitch smoking?! he should stick to penny cards....
Where is Dionus?? He's an extremely broken mono green commander who can go infinite on turn 4/5 with relative consistency. Criminal that hes not even on the list
Tergrid, God of Bullshit
When are budget decks vids coming back
How is Ashling Flame Dancer not on this list wtf????
syr konrad is OP
also...... Marton Stromgold !
Magda in C tier tsk tsk bro has never gone up against a good Magda deck if he thinks Magda is C arguably the best commander in this list maybe second to urza
YO WHERE IS URABRASK
Interesting
Giada, Font of Hope is also in the top 20 at #17
First
magda C? unsubscribe¡