Farmers Protest Explained | Faye D'Souza
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ธ.ค. 2020
- Farmers across the country are protesting against the latest farm laws that were passed by the government.
In this explainer video, we try to analyse the entire situation of farmers and simplify the laws to understand the entire context and importance of the story.
Check out the other explainer videos here- bit.ly/33oyMKS
More Videos by Faye D’Souza:
Live with Faye at 8:30 PM: bit.ly/37ji1Ci
6:30PM Live Stream: Amitha Balachandra: bit.ly/2V9b9Sc
Interviews by Faye D’Souza: bit.ly/3fDyUeF
Best of Faye D’Souza: bit.ly/36c9W2Y
Follow Me Here:
► Follow us on Instagram: bit.ly/3eUXB5y
► Like us on Facebook: bit.ly/2VHVZEk
► Follow us on Twitter: bit.ly/3aDIWZ7
I am from Guatemala, and we are currently fighting against unfair bills as well and this farmer protest makes sense to me, I totally support the farmers. Greetings from Guatemala!
And the funny part is this bill is supporter by many farmers working on Field as well as many politicians and main opposition congress mentioned in their election manifesto. The unions demanded it long ago...this is complex politics u won't understand
@@MsManasi People's will, should prevail.
@@Sinserg There r many farmers who r in favour and demanded for long. Especially the poor farmers who suffered because of middle man and currently they r busy in farm... The other side r ready to block road in protest for 6 months... Now 5 % of so called Farmers + Communists +opposition's +anarchist are on road and trust me this way they r defaming the real Farmers. U need to know the background of this
For real? Have you even read these laws? I hope you are not protesting in Guatemala without reading the laws 🙈
@@mohitkhurana163 I know India is far away from where I live and I know that sometimes there is a lot more that one can see, about our situation here, I can tell you that our government and its laws are attempting against a lot of peoples well being but as always time will tell.
Faye, I wish you could teach journalism in colleges
@@asr4327 spam💀
@subhadeep mandal hahaha you still continue to do what you do best! It's been sometime since I last scrolled the comments section on Faye's videos. However, I very clearly remember seeing your comments consistently on her videos couple of months back too, most of which are only spewing negativity, hatred and some more hatred. Going by your comments, it seems you hate Faye/the work she does, however you continue to watch each of her videos and never miss a chance to non-sensically troll her!! Guess that's a big win only for Faye! :D
She's spreading fake news and fear psychosis. India doesn't need such bigots.
Faye works for Corporates and earn 5 digit . But she doesn't want farmer to deal with corporates..what a Hypocrites.. who are we to decide wher should farmer sell their products.. Doesnt Milk and Poeltry are under corporates?? Are they suffering from corporates?? See at what price milk and Poeltry are selling and how Farmers benefited from it...
@@shashankmijar2694 she left mirror now because it is biased as all news channels, she does not work for corporates, don't spread hate.
She has her own online news platform and youtube channels.
You're probably one of the best anchors.
Such a quality news. It’s been some years since I heard such concise, precise, and unbiased news. Please continue to be the same and deliver news in the same way. Wish you all the best.
◽ SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE ◽
@@asr4327 spam💀
Many fact have been intentionally or unintentionally burried by Faye
Unbiased😂😂
She is a biased and fake journalist....anti Hindu and western influenced
Lady
I adore Faye Dsouza's journalism. It's simplicity can open a heart💗 and mind, yet boggles the mind how she crafts her masterpieces🖼️🎨🖌️. Where would our world be without people like her?☺️
Also add your comment on the ongoing farmers'agitation.
🟢 SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🟠
@@asr4327 spam💀
Thank you so much Faye! This is so helpful! This is everything journalism should be. Factual +unbiased, meaningful, and easy to understand.
But you won't express your views on the Farm Bills.
🧶SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🧶
There is nothing unbaised in what she said. It's nothing but biased.
If every journalist in India was this lucid and brave, half the problems would disappear. Glad to see some journalistic integrity left in the country.
Thank you Ms.Faye D'Souza for bringing everyone upto the speed to understand the farmer's protest! Very crisp and no-nonsense reporting as always. Keep up the good work !!
journalism in not dead, bought, sold and pimped out !!! dont expect mrs. faye to like the cooment but huge respect maam
It’s good that you have parted your ways from sycophancy journalism and became an independent player in the world of politics
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
This is the best explainer series I have seen Faye. Please do more of these! Most insightful work on the issue around the topic.
Very well explained and a lay man can understand this on going conflict of interests easily. Thank you ma'am once again. 🙏
🟠SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🟠
Same with sheaker Gupta too just check the print , Faye is baised leftist , she can't talk about the other side of the issue, she dint talk about the real problem there in Punjab and Haryana. There are loop holes in the bill that I can understand , but to completely remove it is really bad for india
Whoever speaks the truth is called leftist.
@@somnatharcot2088 yes because there idology is leftist , when you say corporates will make farmer suffer that's communists idology , only talking about one view and not talking about what system exists rt now that's wrong
@@somnatharcot2088 Don't need to go right man, just some centrist view for you man, try its once - th-cam.com/video/B9hSADKW3Cc/w-d-xo.html&ab .... If you dont like it stay with Faye.
Farmers always have had the discretion to sell their produce either to govt at MSP or to traders. So, the crux was that farmers always used to get atleast MSP either by selling to govt or to trader. However, farmers have never had any means nor will they ever have any means to take their produce to sell in other mandis or states, say from Chandigarh to Bangalore. This is also a known fact that only about 6% of entire produce was being bought by government at MSP and rest everything was sold to traders by farmers.
Secondly, passing of all these laws has to be coupled with the intention of Indian Govt. These laws have also removed the storage limit and abetted hoarding, so as to say, govt has rather made hoarding legal. Without pointing out any specific names, everyone knows which business house(s) are ultimately going to establish their monopolies.
Agree, just like issuing 2000 rupee note after banning 1000 rupee note and told that corruption is now over.
Love the concept of an explainer series, Faye. There's so much noise and clutter surrounding these issues and the media exhausts viewers with endless debates and discussions. It's good to have just a simple, straightforward and factual breakdown of events without opinions or views in them. Thanks for this.
You should also do an story on how the mandi system in haryana and Punjab is so effective that they are so worried about it losing it
Mam u don't know ... how much my heart gets filled with so much joy n tears when I hear u break the news piece by piece to us. Thanks a lot faye mam. I would pay to listen to u. God bless u. Long live farmers🙏🙏
I can watch Faye whole day 😍
True
Thank you so much for developing a space where we can gather facts and form our own opinions!❤️
Any one with basic intelligence can understand that the prices of basic food materials will go up at the same time farmers will not get what they deserve.
how?
@@shaurav8008 private companies can buy the produce from farmers at low prices, since farmers won't have any other buyer, then hoard produce to drive up prices. Then sell at high prices, while having to no obligation to give the farmers a fair deal.
@@hemantakaushik4635 see farmers can still sell at mandis who the fk gave you half baked info there are total 3 bills..
@@drbh6331 the fear is that govt will stop operating the apmc mandis in a matter of time. and private companies are under no obligation to purchase at msp. thank you for abusing me.
Faye you are doing an amazing work. Sick of mainstream media feeding garbage in the minds of common people.
Thank you Faye! This is so informative and important to know.
👍
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
If you continue the transparent journalism you've just shown, this channel is gonna fly soon. Such clarity in the news. Keep up.! You've earned a subscriber.
She has not earned. We have earned so much by listening to her. If we don't listen to her it's our loss not hers
What an amazing analysis of the farmers' protest. A clinical analysis. You have left it to the viewers to form their own opinions, without offering your own. That is Journalism, at its best. Thanks, Faye. May I suggest, that you venture into Newspaper Journalism, and write articles analysing the current controversies that are exercising the minds of people in our country? There are a number of good newspapers wherein you could become a syndicated journalist. Please think it over.
The whole issue explained so well in detail .Always a pleasure to view your channel.
🟦SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE ⬜
They are trying to repeat 1984
@@rajpandey8326 may I know your points on how can you say that?
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
Government can surely amend the bills and end the tug of war.
But farmers do not what to amend the bill. They want them to be gone.
Introducing this new feature in your show has been a great idea..... everything lucidly explained, in simple words.👏👏👏
🔲 SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔲
@@asr4327 spam💀
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
Looking forward to more of this format of informative videos on this channel, Faye! Please keep going! ♥
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
Amazing journalist 😊, top scribe, the best of the best.
⚪ SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔘
I like the detail that Faye has presented. There are several points that are reasonable, e.g.,
1. Without procurement + MSP, the farmers are left to the vagaries of supply and demand.
2. If contract farming is to be allowed, robust contract enforcement is a must.
However, can someone provide any alternatives to procurement + MSP? As per some news sources there are 80 million tons of food grains that has already been procured and is lying in storage. Should this status continue? Should more wheat and rice be procured? How can this be tapered off? Should it be reduced? Can farmers be nudged to produce other crops? Can there be oilseed procurement + MSP instead?
I don't think it is an easy choice one way or the other. There will always be pressure from taxpayers on any government to reduce this reliance on procurement+MSP that provides stability to farmers.
You've debunked it so well, that too in a "neutral" and simple manner. Really appreciate what you've been doing ❤️
What do you mean by debunked it? Are you saying the protest is incorrect?
th-cam.com/video/AQ4NQcFdN1w/w-d-xo.html
I was of the view that there were valid arguments on both sides - after listening to P Sainath once again - I am shifting more towards the farmers view.
As an individual who has worked and gained 25 years of work experience - objective of any activity is to be efficient and effective. The whole narrative changes when it becomes conspiratorial, attacks individuals on being misled and sheer force of authority being used to discredit the others POV.
Why are we not seeing the discussions based on each line of the old / new / positive and possible acts and move forward by the government.
Their intention is being questioned and rightly so because of the past actions and behavior.
Thank you for sharing everything in detail, Ma'am!
Farmers' protest best explained by anyone in the recent media coverage. Without taking any sides and giving her own opinion, she has explained in a very elaborate and elegant manner.
Hats off to Faye and her team. Please start the TH-cam membership or any kind of subscription at the earliest.
Also, can we have a DD National style news bulletin wherein only news is shared without any opinions being shared.
Faye, You have always been a superb journalist. Loved watching your debates and missing them too, we can understand the hurdles all good journalists are going through these days..Keep up the good work in these challenging time. All the Best!
*Let's support our farmers ... Remember, without them we won't exist!*
🔷SEARCH ADITYA RATHORE ON TH-cam HE IS ALSO A GOOD JOURNALIST LIKE FAYE 🔷
What a load of bull
Yes but which farmer ??😖😖 khalistanis ??? Or farmers getting biryanis from mosques ?? R farmers present only in punjab ??
What about the farmers of Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Maharashtra,Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Jharkhand, Chattisgarh,North east Indian farmers ?? We all support it. If only Punjab and Haryana farmers are going to decide the fate of bills passed by parliament then what is the use of sending our representative to the parliament.
Thanks Faye for this new segment Explained! Short and direct! Good. Keep up the good work Faye and team!
Faye, there's the FCI angle to it as well, that many of us wish that you cover in your coverage as well. Another thing is, that many of us, who respect you the most, haven't been seeing much of you these days, especially around Covid19 times, and that's quite a disappointment. The wide gap - between honest, pure journalism with mannerisms, and loud raucous, raunchy, playing by the gallery kind of journalism is widely evident. You play the former keeping in mind the dignity of your profession, and simultaneously respecting the sensibilities of viewers like us. You have a role to play in society serving who also form a large chunk, and are in fact growing disillusioned quietly and quickly!
So, the bottom line is, that we wish to see more of you, and keep up the good work that you are doing in your own little way. Do not disappoint us, please. We have a ton of expectations from you.
Explained in such a simple way.. the best explanation so far.. awesome mam. It's always pleasure listening to you. Thank you!
This was amazing...the way you explained everything in the best way possible....doing your share. Thankyou. People will definitely benefit from this.
Weren’t the farmers already selling in the open markets anyways, read that only 6% of farm produce were getting sold into Mandis
Government buys maximum rice and wheat for FCI at MSP in Punjab and Haryana. So in these two states role government mandi is more dominant than any other states thats why these people are protesting to save mandi. Land holdings percentage is highest in these two states compared to marginal land holdings in other states. Once corporates get hold over market, then they manipulate for their own benefit. It's well known truth
Not 6% selling in mandi 6% is getting the benefits of the MSP.
Exactly. The government is advertising the new ordinances as "freedom for farmers", when they already had that freedom in the first place. This ordinance is clearly not intented for the benefit of farmers
@@ankurms corporates holds Milk market ..did they hold their market there??
@@shashankmijar2694 milk and agricultural produce don't stand on the same footing. Onion price is soaring in sky after essential commodities act is relaxed. Tones of onions are rotting in godowns near patrapada (Bhubaneswar) but still they don't release into market to maintain high price.. maneuvering skills of corporates are not same for all products , they keep changing as per times.
Clean and Neat. It sure does take a lot of hardwork to cut down such complex things to present in a simpler way. Kudos to all the teams hard work 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 and to you especially Faye
Putted up the information very nicely and most importantly described the True scenario on the ground.
Well done Faye and her team....
We need gormint employees like this DeSouza to tell us about the evils of the private sector.
I always admire the way you explain the concepts. Thanks Faye and the team!
Thank you Faye. Very informative especially for most of the people who really don't understand the intricacy of these laws.
Mam, farmers are "determined" and not "adamant".
There is nothing wrong in being 'adamant' for the right cause. The word adamant may sound bad only if you put a negative connotation to it. Just like how it is ok to say 'proud' Indian, but hurtful when someone is called a 'proud' person.
Adamant is not necessarily a bad word... It just means that the person won't budge
Mohan is right. Adamant has an adverse connotation. It's like saying they are stubborn. They are determined. Committed.
@@natalieg34 right cause? The complete protest is without cause. Total drama
You seriously have a problem with 'adamant'. dude people like you love to find excuses to get offended
Great explanation. You've earned a new subscriber. Thank you from 🇨🇦
You explained it in such a simple and unbiased way. Thank you Faye. I have become your fan😊🙏
Very nicely explained! This kind of journlism is actually requried on the main stream media! I have been watching main stream regarding this particular news since a week. And i didnt undertand the basic reason of the protest.. this lady explained it very clearly in mere 15 mins!!
So nicely explained !! Simple and precise amount of information that's needed. You're the bomb !
Thank you Faye for your impeccable knowledge and indebth analysis on issues that effect us daily. Mirror Now is not the same as it used to be ever since you've left. I was part of the initial set-up with the traffic team of Times Now and the then Reuters group and was a witness of the first ever news report going live on Times Now. You have been an inspiration to many and to me especially. Love your style of fearless presentation always being unbiased. God Bless and Protect you always." A Tigress with a simple smile" keep going.....Much Love to you - Marcelino Dsouza.
Great narrative.. continue posting. After ages, watching a good quality news. Thanks to you, and all the best for the 4 member team.
I'm from a farmer family based in Gujarat.... I was lucky I got a chance to study in Canada and also explore other countries around the world.... Farmers in western countries are making millions and they work through a system that Indian government want's to implement.
There can be flaws in the current bill that the government has passed but I see this as a very necessary and effective step Indian government has taken and in the long run will help farmers to earn way more money then they are earning right now...
Farmers who are protesting against this laws are not seeing the benefits they will be getting in the long run.... It looks like they want to be dependent on the middle men and govt. subsidies but the current bill allows them to free themselves and grow more....
Also many people are commenting on how this bill will take away there right to go to court in case of dispute but the truth is this bill provides a proper legal framework that is being created to protect the farmers of India and not the big private companies....
Everyone who thinks that this bill is for the benefit for Big Private Corporations are wrong. Yes, Big Corporation will be benefited from this bill but farmers are the one who will be availing the actual benefit from this bill..
Thank you so much for easing this topic out. There're a lot of videos on youtube but I liked your version of it, the most.
Thank you so much for explaining in a simple and easy to understand language.🙌🏻 This is really helpful.
Huge respect for you mam. Thank you for explaining it so thoroughly.
You are the best; loved the way u presented a balanced view from both sides and cleared all the misconceptions! Keep up the good work! 😀
So well articulated and explained. Looking forward to more from the Explainer series. Kudos to you and your team !
Thanks Faye . Have shared it on fb for those who claim they don’t understand why the farmers are protesting !
Thank you Ma'am for educating on the farmers protect which I was not aware. Now I'm able to understand from ur video. Thank you and please help us in educating on the national issues and good things around.
God bless!!
Much appreciated. Thank you!
Thank you for explaining this so well. Appreciate all the good work you're doing.
Salute you Faye for the precise and truthful explanation
Absolutely loved this❤️.
Thank you so much. Previously I don’t know which side to support.
Now I support the farmers protest with full clarity.
Absolutely brilliant unbiased journalism. Much better than the rubbish on WION. I applaud you for not demonising the plight of farmers by associating it with separatist movements. Sikhs are the lions of India and their patriotism can never be questioned.
Thank you very much for explaining it so simply
I just love your simplification of the matter ma'am.Thank you 😇😇😇
Thank you so much for making this so clear!🙏. Also , congratulations to you and your team on the award! First of many more to come!
My ray of hope in journalism and news, Faye! ❤️ Thanks for helping keep my faith in the country
With so much clutter and chaos in the media regarding this issue
It was so difficult to understand what's going on
Thank you for being the clear voice!
Much love and Respect!❤️
Thanks 🙏 so much you explain very well. God bless you. Pls keep bring the truth front of the public. 👏👏❤️
Thank you. ❤️
Indeed the most neutral/unbaised explanation of events! Highlighted the perspective of both sides! Kudos!....I hope both parties reach a middle ground!
True👌
Clear and Concise, thank you, Faye.
not a moment to smile and convey this.. it's farmers, God to the world giving food..
You’re the best journalist.
Shekar Gupta did a good breakdown on the print
IT cell views are everywhere
Every one has the rights to express their views
We don't know exactly who is going to benefit farmer or traders it can go either way corruption is every where
Punjab and Haryana should concentrate on some other crops we have abundance of wheat and rice
As always, thank you Faye for bringing this to our attention in the most lucid manner!
It's nice to hear unbiased news. Great work.
Thank you for this explanation
We can digest our food and sleep well only if our brothers in farming sector are satisfied with filled stomach.
Thank you so much for this Faye! Very nicely explained!
Thank you 🙏🏻
Only 6% of the farmers get the msp,so 94% sell at a higher price or price below the msp. Mainly the farmers from Punjab gets the benefits of msp.
See that's the problem,you don't know actual thing.punjab and haryana farmers sell their product at msp,but they are not only beneficiary.other state's farmers also benefit msp, through state procurement scheme.when there is distress sell,and private sector don't procure and price fall,states intervene and procure at msp.
Your explanation is indeed good. Well researched. You have successfully answered all the questions in my mind.
Thank you for being unbiased and very informative. Journalists nowadays have forgotten to be unbiased. Thank you for not sharing your views on the topic, you're just informing your audiences, a trait that has been long lost in journalism.
I appreciate your journalism. Its clear and away from the andhbhakt and anti-national debate that keeps happening on most of the news channels. I admire your take on farm laws but being a student of economics I have a very different point of view. On the surface level concerns of farmers seem genuine. However, economics doesn't work like that. I do not say that open markets are perfect but they are many times better than regulated markets. History has shown this. First concern of farmers is about cartelization of private sector. Take example of other commodities that are not regulated, better take example of milk. There is a big private sector involvement but its flourishing. Second is the concern of bumper crop. Farmers, especially in Punjab, a semi-arid region, are heavily dependent on rice and wheat. Rice has led to groundwater depletion on alarming rate. At the same time, it has been found that fruits and vegetables that are grown on only a small proportion have given more proportional income to farmers. However, bad infrastructure to store perishables has discouraged this trend. Prices (at least should) depend on demand and supply. Crop diversification and better infrastructure, that stablizes supply, will help farmers realize better rates. Ofcourse companies would make money and if they have huge margins, attractiveness of sector will lead to other companies jumping in. This creates competition and helps on both seller and buyer side. Government is already overflowing with grains and doesn't know what to do with it. FCI behaves as a zombie organization. Third is the dispute settlement done by govt. officials. Not allowing someone to go to courts is something I find astonishing. For me, it should allowed. Its is everyone's right in a democracy.
Thankyou Faye for making us understand the fine prints and whats the main issues. As being in maharashtra i were clueless .Even after reading the 3 bills passed as i could only guess even when its in the benefits or farmers why are they protesting. I got the point they are trying to make.. thankyou and will frwd it to as many ways as i can.. this video was the most needed right now though it was late but still better for the people who are really struggling to know.. thankyou again
Mam u have explained in a simple language thank u we like to see u in mainstream journalism very soon
Really helpful!
Explained so well.....thank you
Very crisp and simple explanation of the farm law.. great job, Faye, as always
Would recommend people here to go watch Shekhar Gupta's take on this issue on today's episode of cut the clutter.
Shekar gupta ... so funny he's just another Arnab of social media
Crisp and perfect, shows u've urself understood the topic pretty well👌
First time I’ve visited this channel. Fantastic clarity and now I have a good idea of the issue. You are indeed correct that while the headlines of the proposals seem logical and rational the devil is indeed in the details. Even here in the US the large digital monopolies are dictating terms and wiping out their competition. Indian government should ensure that small farmers are not exploited by private monopolies.
BTW I’ve liked this video and subscribed to this channel.
Thank you for making it clear
Have you been to Mandi - seen how a farmer is blackemailed by dalals in mandi- they offer their price which is not near the MSP and farmer has no option to take it back additional expense and what will he do after taking it back
Donald Wirathu
- rightly said
I understood so well that I can sit for an exam. My friend, GOI is a worse student and doesn't understand a thing. He is only interested in my other friend, Jio.
Get well soon illiterate 😏👉
Thank you. This was really well explained and succinct. 👌👍
I think we've got ourselves a new and independent media. Keep up the good work and this was very informative. Thank you so much for putting this out for us.