The Real Crisis in the West | Melanie Phillips | Peter Kurti
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.ค. 2024
- Former Guardian journalist, writer and political commentator, Melanie Phillips discusses the real crisis facing the West - the undoing of reason. From colonialism to the BLM movement to the breakdown of the family unit and Israel's unequal treatment, Melanie and Peter explore the many issues facing the West that leave little room for optimism.
In what we tell ourselves is an age of reason, we are behaving increasingly irrationally. Whether its people signing up to weird cults, nursing conspiracies, or subscribing to widespread consensus on issues that take more than a google search to understand, unreason is eroding the building blocks of Western civilization. The West has replaced reason and truth with ideology and prejudice.
The exercise of reason has been fundamental to the European Enlightenment forming the spirit of intellectual enquiry. Too often rash judgments of historical western endeavours are often condemned as racist and oppressive, which has led to a new wave of anti-Semitism and historical recreations. Moreover, those who object or take issue with these ideological zealots face immediate and irreversible cancellation.
______________________________________________________________________________________________
CIS promotes free choice and individual liberty and the open exchange of ideas. CIS encourages debate among leading academics, politicians, media and the public. We aim to make sure good policy ideas are heard and seriously considered so that Australia can prosper. Follow CIS on our Socials;
Twitter - / cisoz
Facebook - / centreindependentstudies
Linkedin - / the-centre-for-indepen...
📖 Read more from CIS here: www.cis.org.au/
💬 Join in the conversation in the comments.
👍 Like this video if you enjoyed it and want to see more, it really helps us out!
🔔 Subscribe to our channel and click the bell to watch our videos first: / @cisaus
⏲️ Missed this event live? Subscribe to CIS to be up to date with all our events:
www.cis.org.au/subscribe/
📝 Subscribe to CIS mailing list- www.cis.org.au/subscribe/
💳 Support us with a tax-deductible donation at - www.cis.org.au/support/
![ช่วยพาฉันผ่านเวลา - วสันต์17 [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HFnntWoqc54/mqdefault.jpg)
Always happy to hear from Melanie Phillips
Ralph Dahrendorf, a famous liberal german professor of sociology and director of the London School of Economics, once openly declared that there cannot be any real democracy without a nation state. The nation state is a necessary precondition for democracy. This statement holds still true in my opinion..
As a practitioner I combined social work and psychology degrees to develop an evidence based practice. For twenty years served my community with 70% of my clients coming from word of mouth. Eighty percent were female. Eventually I was forced out by this 'woke' ideology including its lies, slander and defamation. I developed a contempt for my managers and some colleagues who tried to enforce on myself this 'woke' ideology. I finally resigned a well payed job that had become detrimental to my mental health. I am poorer however I still own my mind.
You're integrity is priceless and intelligent society admires and respects you.
Melanie Phillips was one of the first thinkers that helped me move away from the Left. She is truly a Gem.
She sent me further to the left.
💯. Loved this interview. I'm on a similar journey as this Malanie
I really appreciate Melanie Phillips' journey. This helps me to see the bigger picture. In some ways, I have blamed our youth for not being educated (i.e., video games, distracted, hate books, etc.), but I realize now that it is our education system that has let them down. Also the break down of the family has not helped.
It was about five years ago I came to a startling conclusion. The conclusion was that the best model of education for children was indeed the Victorian model of the 19th century. The Victorians taught students the history and philosophy of the Greeks and Romans at a starting point. This is the basis for our modern western society. The only modification I would make would be to include the science of the last 200 years.
How did I come to this conclusion? This is my brief history. Raised as a Catholic in the mid 20th century but lost my belief and faith as I learned of the negatives of religion. Gained an engineering degree. Then a teaching degree 10 years ago. What I was taught in that course and what I saw in schools close up, horrified me. It was chaos and anarchy. While thinking of how this came about I realised that students were disconnected from their origins as taught in the classic Victorian curriculum. So this is what we need to get back to.
The crisis is to remove varnish to show in brilliant colors the great humane aspects of human history
It may be facilitated by reducing materialistic pursuits in journalism and journalist s
Whatever you nutter lol
They were also taught the Bible, which much of our Western Literature refers to (Bible Stories and characters). Today, our children and young adults are completely illiterate about this.
@@deniserobertson7146 Amen to that.
La claridad conceptual de Melanie Phillips enciende una luz de esperanza en estos oscuros tiempos de la cultura occidental. Estupenda entrevista.
Excellent analysis Melanie. I would love to read all your books.
I’m a long time fan of Melanie. Another fantastic discussion. Yes, we are near the edge…no idea how we will ever get it back now..
I love Melanie Phillips; she is brilliant
I second this comment.
Fantastic summary of the evil perpetuated by the “left”. I am not a tribal religious person, but my life owes its basic morality to religions.
CIS does an excellent job of these videos, I only wish I could get them as audio podcasts. Not everyone uses Spotify...
Hi Andrew, we actually syndicate across most podcasting platforms. Find out more at www.cis.org.au/commentary/podcasts/
MP ,A rock of sense and what she sings should be LISTENED to attentively. An unbelievably intelligent ,crystal clear mind . Surprised that MORE people aren't tuned into her but like Thomas Sowell, if the powers that control us, can't debate these intellectuals , they just hide them from the rest of society.
It's stimulating study
hope views were open to explain the new order
Maybe she should be interviewed by novara media .
Everybody is on about teachers as if they were the primary educators. They are not! The primary educators are parents. Let us lay the blame for the breakdown of western society at the feet of the parent. The parents are responsible for not raising their children to be knowledgable, logical and having a balanced view of the world and humanity.
Correct, but where do the parents get their moral compass from?
@@mikeheath8318 From their humanity, from their parents, from the concept of fairness, etc, it's not necessary to blindly have faith in some fairytale involving an all seeing an impossibly all potent god thingy.
@@mayflowerlash11 Apart from the fairness test which you already failed, your preference to believe that morality exists, apart from their being a moral law giver leaves you as a victim to any one or any group who wishes to devise their own morality based on what they like and don't like. There is actually only one law, the law of physics. Every other law has its roots in the law of physics. The law of physics does not give rist to morality or ethics nor can it. If life arose through random natural processes, every life form is merely a mutated form of a previous mutated lifeform. Life is an endless series of purposeless mutations. All life is merely sacks of chemicals arranged in different ways according to the laws of physics and chance. There is no morality, not good or bad in the laws of physics. Without an absolute good, a higher authority, everything else is just man made.
And Jesus said to him, “Why do you call me good? No one is good except God alone. Luke 18:19. - and so it is.
@@mikeheath8318 Without absolute good, a higher authority? So you base your ethics on the Bible. I refer you to The Skeptic's Annotated Bible. Fortunately somebody else has done all the work to point out in detail the contradictions in the good book. I encourage you to read it, at least so you can make your argument that the Bible is consistent. When I say it is flawed I mean that a person can justify any action by selecting the appropriate verses from the Bible. So absolute is not a term I would use to describe the Bible.
@@mayflowerlash11 well well and bravery spoken. Don't be deceived for God is not mocked. For whatever a man sows the he shall also reap. If you sow to the flesh of the flesh you will reap corruption and if you sow to the Spirit, of the Spirit you shall reap everlasting life. Sounds like you haven't read the Bible for yourself and relied on error and deception to gain your worldview. The biggest trick the devil has played on mankind is to convince them that he doesn't exist. You are being deceived and that's the truth of the matter. Everything that is blinding the eyes of the world is written in the Scriptures. For perilous times will come leading up to the return of Christ. Take heed that no one deceives you. The words of Yahshua Messiah. HalleluYah.
Look lady I was born and christened as a presbyterian and was schooled thoroughly in Christian values in the colonies, immigrated to England then British Army. There I begin to feel the strangeness my Christian values and morality were at odds with what I was now experiencing. Lying is universal, stealing is universal, deception is universal.
I began to question in libraries adults why priests of all denominations. that guided me were which this adult world. What the taught and what the practice was at ods At that point normalization of disadvantage
Your comment is confusing, but if I understand you correctly, you had a religious upbringing that was challenged as you witnessed the wickedness and hypocrisy that mankind is capable of. It might be worth remembering that Jesus Christ didn't come to start any new religions, but came to save sinners.
Thank. Gooness. For. Some. Common sense
Imagine a world where you advertise how and with whom you achieve orgasm with, to be of overwhelming importance.
That's just to much information for me.
It gets better. Then Imagine a Gov that grants special rights, privileges and protections based on said orgasm.
You don't have to Imagine that, because you're familiar with it.
The process of moving to the right is entirely normal when we get older. We do not need to feel shame to use whatever words we find convenient to express our new phase in life.
I disagree that the christian bible is the only basis for morality. Have you read that book, that scripture. It contains so many inconsistencies that I marvel that anybody can survive the mental contortions need to believe that it is a suitable basis to lead a moral life. So what is the alternative. Certainly not the ideologies of Marxism, post modernism or any of the twisted flawed ideals. There must be a philosophy based on sound ideas which can be used to guide ones choices in a morally acceptable manner. I am shocked that it occurs to me that I, the philosophical amateur, must formulate this plan on my own. Where is the philosophy which contains no racism, no bias, that is ethically fair and can be practically used to help me make the best decisions?
Without God, you can try to define the law of the jungle or make up whatever you want to make the law of the jungle more palatable for your chosen group of people.
@@mikeheath8318 Are so bereft of a sense of fairness, honesty, and good will that you cannot determine what is good and what is bad? You are a hollow person in that case. Don't ask yourself what Jesus would do, ask yourself what a fair reasonable person would do.
@@mayflowerlash11 Unfortunatley you show your concept of fairness already by responding to a single comment and making a judgement about a person simply becasue you don't agree with something they said.
@@mikeheath8318 What is the difference between an individual who decides what is ethical and a person who decides to get their morality by selecting the verses in the Bible they think are the right verses to base their ethics on? You have not addressed the contradictions in the Bible. One verse says thou shalt not kill, another verse says turn your ploughshares into swords. If you decide to use the Bible you can choose to be a killer or a pacifist, and be morally right on both occasions. Selectively picking verse from the Bible to follow is the same as deciding what you yourself want to be morally correct. So the answer to my first question is, there is no difference. The Bible is a flawed text to base ones ethics on.
@@mayflowerlash11 You should check your sources, especially when it comes to the Bible. The commandment says that you shall not murder (Hebrew). Clearly the Hebrews were told to kill, it was war etc, so it would indeed be a contradiction if God had said do not kill - but he didn't. The same is often true for all other so called Bible contradictions. However, this is not the issue.
A person can choose any source for his morality or ethics, including any religious or non-religious book, and if God doesn't exist then they are all likewise relativistic and delusional. However, if God does exist, and he is the creator of all we see and know, and is Holy as he claims, then he knows what is best, and has the right to say so.
Ahhh, good to know...
It all goes back to the Holocaust.
Well then...
Look lady I was born and christened as a presbyterian and was schooled thoroughly in Christian values in the colonies, immigrated to England then British Army. There I begin to feel the strangeness my Christian values and morality were at odds with what I was now experiencing. Lying is universal, stealing is universal, deception is universal
I began to question in libraries, adults, priests of all denominations, teachers, and anyone who would listen to my concerns. What was taught to me at times was used selectively , in tune, and also the opposite? Point in Question A native (tribe group, clan ) in Australia Americas, etc Are they not then entitled to their homeland from where they were dispossessed. Based on Israel's rights. If going into someone's space killing them and possessing their space taking their valuables destroying their civilization is deemed to be right, is that in line with Christian values, slavery is that in line with Christian values? Eugenics Christian values? I create a God who tells me to go to London and destroy all the people there and to take their property, You deem that to be right and just, on one hand, and the same act carried out by another group as wrong, Christian values? That's what I confronted as a young man, today it has bubbled to the surface, that war rages on.
I can relate to your position because I too being a gen x was sent to church on Sundays and Wednesdays and I was pounded with “anything worth doing is worth doing right!” Faith without WORKS is dead! By grace I was found byHim in 1995 and also by grace immediately began a dispensational bible study. I was a republican until 2006 and was horrified with the torture, murder, wars for profit….but then Obama who I hoped in too much. He became a crook when he let the crooks walk. The smashing of Bernie and President Trump who can take credit for forcing me (us) to pay attention. Neoliberals have robbed the people and bankrupted our country. I have a garden growing I practice normal inventories NOT JUST IN TIME! For Jessie’s seizure meds, migraine meds and music lessons-my alternative treatment for complex trauma. Let’s keep talking it out give other people the right to their own views if they deny mine or become aggressive stay away from them (my ex) and keep 😆 laughing.
Tradition is tyranny of the old thugs.
Only if you don't understand what the tradition is
@@jakewalklate6226 nope, it is. If the idea stood on its own it wouldn't need to be forced, or lent gravitas
@@justicar5 that’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard in my life. Can you explain how the internet works? No, but you still use it.
@@jakewalklate6226 because the internet stands on its own as an idea and doesn't require enforcement, like I can't give more than a basic explanation of nuclear fission, but the tech based on the idea just works. Tradition is anti human ideas enforced with violence, and lent false gravitas by history
@@justicar5 Education is enforced
Now I am become progressive, the destroyer of worlds.