I have been learning throat singing for about 3 years. The only style i can do is khoomei. I can never do kagraa and I can barely do sygt. I can't cancel the khoomei sound so that only the sygt remains. Great video keep trying froggie! And also i recognise the music in the background! It's a guitar cover of a song from one of the pokemon games. That is nostalgic.
yeeee man! the music is little root town theme from Pokemon Ruby/Saphire/Emerald :D I'm kinda in a same boat as you, my kargyraa is the strongest, followed by khoomei which is meh, and sygyt/isgeree is the most challenging xD
Keep practicing and you'll get there! I've been learning for 6 years and khagyraa took me the longest time to learn and sygyt the shortest. If you want some tips: when singing sygyt try to place your tongue in the front of your mouth right behind the front teeths. I found it easier to practice khagyraa in the morning because my voice is more crisp then. Lastly, do a lot of warmup exercises for your throat if you're not already doing that. Hopefully this can help you
ปีที่แล้ว +59
You are AMAZING! I just practiced for 2 hours and managed to get my golden vibration tone. Dude, you rock so much! With lots more practice, I can finally use my own throat singing in my music!! Much love from germany
I learned the trick with cupping the tongue against roof of the mouth from an Irish giant many years ago. He used to do a beatboxing/throat singing act, and he said just practice it, its easy. Over the years ive tried it out now and then, and about a month ago ive got it. Ive got the, Humi? Is it Humi? And im beginning to hear a higher pitch tone as well, i just need to work out how to get it louder but what i came here to say is it feels AMAZING! When your head and throat and chest are all resonating away... man it feels so fucking good i love it. 5 minutes of throat singing is worth an hour longer in bed i swear
helps a lot, I can only sing vowels but I will learn entire songs later. I feel special connection to steppe people since my region was ravaged by Huns & Mongols. Our people came to be known from elite heavy cavalry feared in entire Europe. Maybe I am descendant of Mongols or Jurchens ( which used that type of heavy cav ), who knows. Again thank you.
You've explained this really well, and having Froggy learn it shows me what I'm in for. But I would need teacher to learn this. A video can't tell me what I'm doing wrong
Taught myself from a tutorial on an obscure website ten years ago. Such a dope thing. None of my friends can do it even though I've taught them. Need them throat
This is wonderful. I've heard of throat singing roughly a decade ago and two days ago, out of the blue, I started throat singing and just continued throught the day off and on. I was telling my therapist this morning about it this morning about how I wasn't singing anything in particular, just making vowel sounds like you mentioned in the video. Now that I have found your tips video, I think I'm going to start practicing daily. Thank you so much for sharing this lesson. Much gratitude.
Be very careful with screaming - be sure to use head or chest voice, but never your throat. If it starts to tickle or feel sore then you are causing damage to your vocal chords.
This is a very interesting phenomena you have described. If the person is pregnant it is offense and if they are trying to throat sing it’s offense. I will now try to find more of these across my life.
I can’t offer anything when it comes to throat singing BUT I would like to offer 1 tip for teaching people how to breathe with their diaphragm. Learned it from Melissa Cross’ Zen of Screaming DVD over 12yrs ago and it seems to still be the QUICKEST way for anyone (especially beginners) to locate and understand how diaphragmatic breathing works. In a nutshell: - First, stand in attention (like in the army). - Once you’re standing up with your back straight, MAKE SURE to have your arms pointing down(open palms, fingers pointing to the floor just to keep it simple) - Push your shoulders downward as much as possible (without any excessive strain and NO pain) while making sure that the inside of your arms and hands are almost sticking to the side of your body. - If you do this right, you should be literally UNABLE to expand your lungs while breathing in through your nose comfortably … try it. Notice how your diaphragm expands around the bottom of your rib cage, further expanding your belly as your fill more air in. Practice this until you can breathe using your diaphragm without having to stand like a sergeant 🕴🏻 … That’s about it. Hope it helps. I’m sure this entire comment can fit in 60-90seconds of video content, so maybe in a future video, if you could try explaining it this way, I hope a lot more people from every walk of life can relate and understand diaphragmatic breathing. … Nothing wrong with your explanation by the way. I get it, but my friends struggled until I told them this and it was like an instant “AHA” moment. And I’d love for your channel to grow with more aha along with the haha moments. ☯️👻
That's helpful but how do I take deep breaths while diaphragm breathing? I can only fill up my lungs halfway before there's no more room to expand and it makes me feel like I can't breathe
I am SO thankful for your channel ! I wanna learn throat singing so bad because I find it very beautiful and it’s really artistic, but there isn’t any professor in my area so thanks for that !
I learned the throat bass technique for beatbox but I’m trying to learn the more traditional sense of the technique so I find it difficult to make it lower then the normal throat rhythm this seems to be helping thank you!
I love you boys. @hachapuri keep up your great teaching (I almost did it for a second there, and I'm a Grandma). @Froggy. Keep practicing. You did good.
Thank you for this awesome video! Im a German 17yr old guy and I randomly stumbled across throat singing and was completely amazed. My dream is to one day surprise my friends in a warm summer night around a campfire with such awesome notes connecting with the beautiful nature. I’ve already tested it out a bit with another tutorial from you and I think I can actually learn it! I just have to practise. Thank you for this video, it is really encouraging and it felt so comfortable for some reason. Definitely one of the best tutorials I’ve watched so far, and I watch a lot of tutorials haha
@@Hachapuri69 ahaha, that’s pretty cool! Do you think you can throat sing in German? Because I believe that could sound absolutely awesome given the natural dark/commanding sound of the German language. Sadly wasn’t able to find anything about that online :(
I've been practicing throat sining on my own for a short bit, and have been able to sort of do a throat whistle, but this video will be a huge help to learn how to throat sing properly. also, after a few hours of thoat singing my throat hasnt started to feel sore and i havent gotten dizzy at all, which is hopefully a good sign
Thank you! I'm home from work with a fever. I've been watching 7 videos on, How to throat sing and this is the first that make me give it a try and now I got it. I feel an adrenaline rush and numbness in hands. Think I give it a rest and go back to sleep but tomorrow I will practice and heal some more.🙏
😭 my throat stops vibrating really quick. ... and I sure as hell can't go as low ('cause I'm a girl, so...), which makes it sound weird ☹ I'll try again tomorrow... Thanks for the video!
heeey! its completely normal to lose the vibration, but I'm glad you got it to vibrate! The muscles will probably get used to activating it after trials :D Girls have a bit different sounding, its just very unique for new listeners. Most people are used to the sound of guys, so I believe its important to have more girls doing this to make each other feel confident in this art :D
In the short time I've been trying to learn from your videos one thing I've found is that a slow release of air makes a huge difference. It's not just breathing from the diaphragm, but also exhaling as slowly in as controlled a fashion as possible that allows you to retain notes for longer. Maybe that is obvious to most people but I have no background in singing.
It's possible! Before trying with this, I learned singing opera style, in mezzo soprano tone. I started to sing with that, and than slowly tried every note with the breath technic what the video show. For me, it was an hour with stupid noises and laughing before I started to get the good sound. Than another half hour for learning stay in the tune. If you have any instrument, try to follow the note U play with your voice. If you feel something like dizziness in your head, you are Close!
Hey Hachapuri! nice videos! This technique (throat singing) is the first step to the death-metal voice no? ^^ Like Lorna Shore, Shadow Of Intents and more..
Pretty good video, I started learning thoatsinging a little while ago with a guy who teaches the Tuvan style. But we started with khoomei and sygyt and only justed started kargyraa after I got my khoomei in a good place and watching Froggie pretty much is how I probably sounded trying kargyraa first time, and I can do the sound now but can't hold it long, and from watching this video...I might not be doing enough diaphragm breathing like I do when I'm doing khoomei. But I think out of the 3 techniques, kargyraa is the quickest I've managed to pick up (Sygyt was slowest and heck, I am still not quite there, just really close to getting it right), so maybe a good place to start, especially if throat singing seems too hard or alien to learn, but i have no musical or singing background and one day thought 'sod it' and decided to learn. Maybe videos like these will at least encourage people to give it ago and not feel so bad when they sound like a dying giraffe.
"Maybe videos like these will at least encourage people to give it ago and not feel so bad when they sound like a dying giraffe." - yeee man, that's the idea :D :D :D Kargyraa is probably the easiest for me :P just my personal opinion, I don't think there is anything as Tuvan or Mongolian style. The main principals are the same, unless you are talking about specific people who have their own unique approaches :D
@@Hachapuri69 Learning kargyraa after struggling with sygyt was a nice breath of fresh air lol. Despite knowing what I need to do and being close to getting it right, sygyt still feels like wizardry. But you are right the main techniques are the same (like the kargyraa you're showing is no difference to what I was taught), however, the guy teaching me will also be teaching me Tuvan songs, hence the 'Tuvan' bit.. But I do want to learn Mongolan songs as well, which I have picked up a Mori Khuur for, but my skill level is currently at 'dying giraffe'.
Okay I’m kinda getting it! Thank you SO MUCH for this video. You’re a gem ✨I’m assuming aka hoping that I won’t make myself gag/cough forever with more practice 😂😅
Its like actively using a muscle u almost never use before. It will hurt in the beginning, follow the tips, let it rest when it hurts. Eventually, it should become natural and won't hurt. But you have to follow the tips, if you do it wrong, it could be bad
The problem is: how can I know my golden vibration if an expert does not tell when I am doing right? I am throat singing now but I don't know if I am just choking myself or I am doing right
I guess an important part of this skill is being able to hold your breth for as long as possible, then you can let out the minimum amount of air to vocalise the tones, then you can hold the tones for much longer.
Nice video, thanks ! 😄 I've been learning throat singing for a year. I can now do sygyt (but my "background" voice is still too loud) and a bit khoomei, but not kargyraa (for now). I'm a woman so maybe that explains why it's a bit more difficult to me. Anyway I wanted to ask you : do you know where I can find some Mongolian songs lyrics ? There's a song I really love, but I can't find lyrics and their meaning anywhere 😥This makes me sad because I would like to learn to sing it. It's called Eruu Tsagaan Boljmor and the version I love is the one sung by Enkhjargal Dandarvaanchig. Anyway thanks a lot for your videos, they're really well filmed and interesting, I love the way you're explaining things.
I did some digging, and I found the lyrics! I think they match your original video. Hope you can finally learn how to sing the song! Original: th-cam.com/video/3MjQNymt8fM/w-d-xo.html Video With lyrics: th-cam.com/video/EKiZ8NYzpNQ/w-d-xo.html The lyrics of the video are under the video. If you use a Mongolian alphabet pronunciation sheet, you should be able to sign it.
So sorry to double comment. Serious question though, is it ok to practice this standing up, or best to sit down? I have to practice outside, walking around. Luckily I'm in mainland China, so lots of traffic to drown me out.😄
@@teacherrussell5206 standing up helps more, I think. The best is when the posture is good, when the airflow goes without hindrance. So, it's preferable not to sit like shrimp 🦐
@@Hachapuri69 Thank you! I've been trying to sit upright, with good posture, but that's great news. I won't sit like a shrimp. I'll stand like ...a dolphin!
@@Hachapuri69 😁About 2 days after my last message, me and the dolphin found the golden vibration. I first practiced with the "o" vowel, but then found it by accident with my mouth closed. Then added vowels later. Now I can speak short sentences, as well. All total, I did this in just over a week, with ONLY the help of your video and 15-30 minutes practice each day. My brother, thank you so much! And thank you, Froggy!
I loved this video so much, I have always wanted to learn this beautiful sound. I would like to know should the neck be straight or where is confrontable to me. I found when my neck is straight the sound is not as deep sounding. I have subscribed so I may one day be able to throat sing. Thankyou so much for sharing. Sending best wishes from London UK
This is an amazing video, thank you! Is there any hope to sing like this for someone who has never had the "golden vibration?" I try to sigh heavily but the air simply passes cleanly through my throat. I have no trouble with breathing properly, I've played clarinet for 8 years. I sing bass so I don't think having a high voice is a problem either.
The throat needs to be slightly constricted… I figured it out by holding my throat closed after swallowing if that makes since? And then going from there!
Amazing video, but I couldn't reach it yet, I did the golden vibration and kept it, but when I make the vowel sound, it doesn't sound like that doubled voice, what am I possibly doing wrong?
I'm learning Throat Singing, im learning a bit of each one. My throat stills hurt when I do like Kargyraa The only one it doesnt hurt my throat is Sygyt lol
ive been struggling a lot with trying to get tone out of it when i try, i have a little background in metal so that is making it harder for me. i can get the golden vibration really easily but its either just that or a straight up metal growl and i cant figure out how to get a nice (or any) tone out of it. does anyone have any tips?
One of the tips which kinda works sometimes is to listen to throatsinging and imitate at the same time. If you keep it up for a while, you'll eventually get the hang of it :D
😅 I was wondering the same 😂. Glad someone believes in those things! Did the gov not tell us that those things would not stop the spread? They did at the beginning, then changed their minds and made them mandatory… bless. The people has a short memory.
😅 I was wondering the same 😂. Glad someone believes in those things! Did the gov not tell us that those things would not stop the spread? They did at the beginning, then changed their minds and made them mandatory… bless. The people has a short memory.
I have troubles keeping my throat relaxed. It just stiffens after I breathe in to full capacity, breathing with my diaphrag, of course. Any advice on keeping it relaxed throughout the process? Great channel by the way, youtube seems especially generous with recommendations recently.
I'm entirely regretting deleting my comment on the video about golden vibration. There are so many things between that video and this one that I've learned - the golden vibration part BEING A LIE! because, for me, what you are explaining is how to activate the portion of my throat where I need to begin in order to produce this wild sound on a level past the "e-'i'e'i" hat tricks I shared with very few. Discovering this voice randomly as a kid and now learning portion of throat, the importance of the diaphragm breathing that is huge, knowing about the scratchiness, etc etc. The symptoms of a little whipper snapper not knowing it may have been more of a froggy scenario than an inability. I have a request though, since I was around the 6-8 year old range when I discovered this, putting me in the early 90s when I was that cool little mountain singer I didn't know about....is it possible I could get that golden vibration video on a cassette tape instead of CD because it would really be embarrassing to get there by time travel only to have a format that didn't exist yet.
Am I high, or am I really seeing a man with beautiful hair, teaching throat singing, to a frog, wearing a mask, accompanied by peaceful guitar music, you literally can’t make this shit up
![Alash Demonstrate Throat-Singing Styles [Interview Video]](/img/n.gif)
Thats the best method to encourage someone to keep practising
I have been learning throat singing for about 3 years. The only style i can do is khoomei. I can never do kagraa and I can barely do sygt. I can't cancel the khoomei sound so that only the sygt remains. Great video keep trying froggie! And also i recognise the music in the background! It's a guitar cover of a song from one of the pokemon games. That is nostalgic.
yeeee man! the music is little root town theme from Pokemon Ruby/Saphire/Emerald :D
I'm kinda in a same boat as you, my kargyraa is the strongest, followed by khoomei which is meh, and sygyt/isgeree is the most challenging xD
Keep practicing and you'll get there!
I've been learning for 6 years and khagyraa took me the longest time to learn and sygyt the shortest.
If you want some tips: when singing sygyt try to place your tongue in the front of your mouth right behind the front teeths.
I found it easier to practice khagyraa in the morning because my voice is more crisp then.
Lastly, do a lot of warmup exercises for your throat if you're not already doing that.
Hopefully this can help you
You are AMAZING! I just practiced for 2 hours and managed to get my golden vibration tone. Dude, you rock so much! With lots more practice, I can finally use my own throat singing in my music!! Much love from germany
I learned the trick with cupping the tongue against roof of the mouth from an Irish giant many years ago. He used to do a beatboxing/throat singing act, and he said just practice it, its easy. Over the years ive tried it out now and then, and about a month ago ive got it. Ive got the, Humi? Is it Humi? And im beginning to hear a higher pitch tone as well, i just need to work out how to get it louder but what i came here to say is it feels AMAZING! When your head and throat and chest are all resonating away... man it feels so fucking good i love it. 5 minutes of throat singing is worth an hour longer in bed i swear
helps a lot, I can only sing vowels but I will learn entire songs later.
I feel special connection to steppe people since my region was ravaged by Huns & Mongols. Our people came to be known from elite heavy cavalry feared in entire Europe. Maybe I am descendant of Mongols or Jurchens ( which used that type of heavy cav ), who knows.
Again thank you.
After this video my throat is definitively dead
You've explained this really well, and having Froggy learn it shows me what I'm in for. But I would need teacher to learn this. A video can't tell me what I'm doing wrong
Taught myself from a tutorial on an obscure website ten years ago. Such a dope thing. None of my friends can do it even though I've taught them. Need them throat
This is wonderful. I've heard of throat singing roughly a decade ago and two days ago, out of the blue, I started throat singing and just continued throught the day off and on. I was telling my therapist this morning about it this morning about how I wasn't singing anything in particular, just making vowel sounds like you mentioned in the video. Now that I have found your tips video, I think I'm going to start practicing daily. Thank you so much for sharing this lesson. Much gratitude.
I feel froggie so much! THank you very much for this video!
Be very careful with screaming - be sure to use head or chest voice, but never your throat. If it starts to tickle or feel sore then you are causing damage to your vocal chords.
@@MareBartleet yes i know. What i meant was that more creators should use somebody in their videos who cant do what they want to teach
Is it impolite to ask someone, "Are you pregnant, or just learning throat singing?"
This is a very interesting phenomena you have described.
If the person is pregnant it is offense and if they are trying to throat sing it’s offense. I will now try to find more of these across my life.
Wow a roaring 🐸 2:30
I am a Froggie, hear me roar! 👍
Your throat singing is beautiful, Batman. Very enjoyable to listen to 🎶
Heeey A Aron! :D
Thank you! :D
@@Hachapuri69 Just so as you know I just saw a typo, and corrected it. My sentence should have been more polite.
@@Blondie42 oh, I didn't notice anything impolite or typos :P :D
I can’t offer anything when it comes to throat singing BUT I would like to offer 1 tip for teaching people how to breathe with their diaphragm. Learned it from Melissa Cross’ Zen of Screaming DVD over 12yrs ago and it seems to still be the QUICKEST way for anyone (especially beginners) to locate and understand how diaphragmatic breathing works.
In a nutshell:
- First, stand in attention (like in the army).
- Once you’re standing up with your back straight, MAKE SURE to have your arms pointing down(open palms, fingers pointing to the floor just to keep it simple)
- Push your shoulders downward as much as possible (without any excessive strain and NO pain) while making sure that the inside of your arms and hands are almost sticking to the side of your body.
- If you do this right, you should be literally UNABLE to expand your lungs while breathing in through your nose comfortably … try it.
Notice how your diaphragm expands around the bottom of your rib cage, further expanding your belly as your fill more air in.
Practice this until you can breathe using your diaphragm without having to stand like a sergeant 🕴🏻
… That’s about it. Hope it helps. I’m sure this entire comment can fit in 60-90seconds of video content, so maybe in a future video, if you could try explaining it this way, I hope a lot more people from every walk of life can relate and understand diaphragmatic breathing.
… Nothing wrong with your explanation by the way. I get it, but my friends struggled until I told them this and it was like an instant “AHA” moment. And I’d love for your channel to grow with more aha along with the haha moments. ☯️👻
That's helpful but how do I take deep breaths while diaphragm breathing? I can only fill up my lungs halfway before there's no more room to expand and it makes me feel like I can't breathe
I am SO thankful for your channel !
I wanna learn throat singing so bad because I find it very beautiful and it’s really artistic, but there isn’t any professor in my area so thanks for that !
Danke! :D
@@Hachapuri69 es ist ein mongolian deutsche?
I learned the throat bass technique for beatbox but I’m trying to learn the more traditional sense of the technique so I find it difficult to make it lower then the normal throat rhythm this seems to be helping thank you!
I love you boys. @hachapuri keep up your great teaching (I almost did it for a second there, and I'm a Grandma). @Froggy. Keep practicing. You did good.
Thank you for this awesome video! Im a German 17yr old guy and I randomly stumbled across throat singing and was completely amazed. My dream is to one day surprise my friends in a warm summer night around a campfire with such awesome notes connecting with the beautiful nature. I’ve already tested it out a bit with another tutorial from you and I think I can actually learn it! I just have to practise. Thank you for this video, it is really encouraging and it felt so comfortable for some reason. Definitely one of the best tutorials I’ve watched so far, and I watch a lot of tutorials haha
Danke! Jetzt bin ich sehr glucklich :D
@@Hachapuri69 are you studying German? That would be awesome
@@sharkquark6252 ich hab Deutsch gestudieren xD
Because of German girls :P
@@Hachapuri69 ahaha, that’s pretty cool! Do you think you can throat sing in German? Because I believe that could sound absolutely awesome given the natural dark/commanding sound of the German language. Sadly wasn’t able to find anything about that online :(
@@sharkquark6252 I think its perfectly doable, you just need to adjust the melody :D
I've been practicing throat sining on my own for a short bit, and have been able to sort of do a throat whistle, but this video will be a huge help to learn how to throat sing properly.
also, after a few hours of thoat singing my throat hasnt started to feel sore and i havent gotten dizzy at all, which is hopefully a good sign
Noice! Your throat is probably getting used to it :D
I watched the three step video And my golden vibration is totaly exausthed. Also thank you for these videos.
I've been doing this in my car for years and didn't know that I'm actually a throat singer Lol. I just love the way it vibrates my body.
it helped seeing you help someone learn, I can do it now. Thanks!
Most chill tutorial ever c: and so awesome you added an acoustic Littleroot Town soundtrack
Eeeeeey! So awesome you noticed it! :O
I KNEW THIS SOUNDED FAMILIAR, I JUST COULDN’T PINPOINT IT
@@Hachapuri69 Hahaha still playing Emerald here :D did you guys record it yourself?
@@jayvandoorn5040 Ruby was my first pokemon game :D
Yeah, we recorded it ourselves :D
That is amazing! I came here for the Mongolian language lessons, but stayed for the throat singing and delightfully random comedy. Subscribed! 🤩👍❤
Best video on the subject! ever!
Thank you! I'm home from work with a fever. I've been watching 7 videos on, How to throat sing and this is the first that make me give it a try and now I got it. I feel an adrenaline rush and numbness in hands. Think I give it a rest and go back to sleep but tomorrow I will practice and heal some more.🙏
😭 my throat stops vibrating really quick.
... and I sure as hell can't go as low ('cause I'm a girl, so...), which makes it sound weird ☹
I'll try again tomorrow... Thanks for the video!
heeey! its completely normal to lose the vibration, but I'm glad you got it to vibrate! The muscles will probably get used to activating it after trials :D
Girls have a bit different sounding, its just very unique for new listeners. Most people are used to the sound of guys, so I believe its important to have more girls doing this to make each other feel confident in this art :D
@@Hachapuri69 yeah, I'll keep trying! 💪
... and I'm sure youtube has some women throat singing somewhere... 😬I'll go look for examples.
Good fun, very instructive. Great lads. Just started throat singing. Amazing stuff.❤
I seriously learned how to do this in like 20m, but I had randomly been making these sounds for years
Love your videos
bro this is sick its giving me chills! and laughs froggie def made learning fun!
Good luck with the Channel and all the best
In the short time I've been trying to learn from your videos one thing I've found is that a slow release of air makes a huge difference. It's not just breathing from the diaphragm, but also exhaling as slowly in as controlled a fashion as possible that allows you to retain notes for longer. Maybe that is obvious to most people but I have no background in singing.
Wow bruh I never thought I could learn it so easily, you're phenomenal
Great instructions!!! I practiced just over two of your videos and managed to find my golden vibration! Will keep practicing! Thank you!❤
That's so metal. I'm trying to learn this so I can generate a lofi mix based on this. Also, my throat hurts now.
I wish these guys were more popular so we could get a grunting compilation.
This is really helpful, thank you!
I wish ladies could do this. I'm an alto, and there's no way I could get my vocals this low to do this 😂. Wish I could. It'd be amazing to awe people.
There are plenty of examples of women throat singing, look them up
It's possible! Before trying with this, I learned singing opera style, in mezzo soprano tone. I started to sing with that, and than slowly tried every note with the breath technic what the video show. For me, it was an hour with stupid noises and laughing before I started to get the good sound. Than another half hour for learning stay in the tune. If you have any instrument, try to follow the note U play with your voice. If you feel something like dizziness in your head, you are Close!
Thank you 🙏
you got some funny videos you got yerself a new fan!
danke brudah! :D
Hey Hachapuri! nice videos! This technique (throat singing) is the first step to the death-metal voice no? ^^ Like Lorna Shore, Shadow Of Intents and more..
First step is the basis of all vocals :D
Origin of Koreans are mixed, but mostly central Asian Mongoloids.
I shall follow you as a man from country of son in law.
Yeee brudah! :D
It is somehow quite easy to get along with Koreans, culturally, we just get each other :D
Pretty good video, I started learning thoatsinging a little while ago with a guy who teaches the Tuvan style. But we started with khoomei and sygyt and only justed started kargyraa after I got my khoomei in a good place and watching Froggie pretty much is how I probably sounded trying kargyraa first time, and I can do the sound now but can't hold it long, and from watching this video...I might not be doing enough diaphragm breathing like I do when I'm doing khoomei. But I think out of the 3 techniques, kargyraa is the quickest I've managed to pick up (Sygyt was slowest and heck, I am still not quite there, just really close to getting it right), so maybe a good place to start, especially if throat singing seems too hard or alien to learn, but i have no musical or singing background and one day thought 'sod it' and decided to learn.
Maybe videos like these will at least encourage people to give it ago and not feel so bad when they sound like a dying giraffe.
"Maybe videos like these will at least encourage people to give it ago and not feel so bad when they sound like a dying giraffe." - yeee man, that's the idea :D :D :D
Kargyraa is probably the easiest for me :P
just my personal opinion, I don't think there is anything as Tuvan or Mongolian style. The main principals are the same, unless you are talking about specific people who have their own unique approaches :D
@@Hachapuri69 Learning kargyraa after struggling with sygyt was a nice breath of fresh air lol. Despite knowing what I need to do and being close to getting it right, sygyt still feels like wizardry.
But you are right the main techniques are the same (like the kargyraa you're showing is no difference to what I was taught), however, the guy teaching me will also be teaching me Tuvan songs, hence the 'Tuvan' bit.. But I do want to learn Mongolan songs as well, which I have picked up a Mori Khuur for, but my skill level is currently at 'dying giraffe'.
Thank you so much for sharing - your explanations are fantastic 😊🙏💛
loving this videos
You are beautiful .. thank you for this marvelous tutorial !!! 🙏♥️🙏
I am already be able to growl, so thats a very good start for me xD (Its very chilling to watch your videos)
Okay I’m kinda getting it! Thank you SO MUCH for this video. You’re a gem ✨I’m assuming aka hoping that I won’t make myself gag/cough forever with more practice 😂😅
Is that throat singing damage your throat? I'm trying to sing but my throat hurt. It is healthy or not?
Its like actively using a muscle u almost never use before. It will hurt in the beginning, follow the tips, let it rest when it hurts. Eventually, it should become natural and won't hurt. But you have to follow the tips, if you do it wrong, it could be bad
Wowowo good video👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏
danke brudah :D
The problem is: how can I know my golden vibration if an expert does not tell when I am doing right? I am throat singing now but I don't know if I am just choking myself or I am doing right
❤
I guess an important part of this skill is being able to hold your breth for as long as possible, then you can let out the minimum amount of air to vocalise the tones, then you can hold the tones for much longer.
6:14 bro invented the moai sound effect
I just sound like louise armstron when i try
Maybe bronze edition at the start of this video. ❤️
Super Video
very impressive your deep voice i cant do this
The skill matures after a bit of time, I think :D
@@Hachapuri69 thanks for your work on youtube u are awesome keep doing these videos please very entertaining
beautiful
Nice video, thanks ! 😄 I've been learning throat singing for a year. I can now do sygyt (but my "background" voice is still too loud) and a bit khoomei, but not kargyraa (for now). I'm a woman so maybe that explains why it's a bit more difficult to me. Anyway I wanted to ask you : do you know where I can find some Mongolian songs lyrics ? There's a song I really love, but I can't find lyrics and their meaning anywhere 😥This makes me sad because I would like to learn to sing it. It's called Eruu Tsagaan Boljmor and the version I love is the one sung by Enkhjargal Dandarvaanchig. Anyway thanks a lot for your videos, they're really well filmed and interesting, I love the way you're explaining things.
I did some digging, and I found the lyrics! I think they match your original video. Hope you can finally learn how to sing the song!
Original: th-cam.com/video/3MjQNymt8fM/w-d-xo.html
Video With lyrics: th-cam.com/video/EKiZ8NYzpNQ/w-d-xo.html
The lyrics of the video are under the video. If you use a Mongolian alphabet pronunciation sheet, you should be able to sign it.
@@ArcticFox-lb3hl Oh wow, amazing ! Thank you so much for searching for it and posting it here, that's really nice from you !!! ❤
@@TihocanRiley No problem!
Is it true that throat singing dmaages throat
Google it
We need updates 😉✌
So sorry to double comment. Serious question though, is it ok to practice this standing up, or best to sit down? I have to practice outside, walking around. Luckily I'm in mainland China, so lots of traffic to drown me out.😄
@@teacherrussell5206 standing up helps more, I think. The best is when the posture is good, when the airflow goes without hindrance. So, it's preferable not to sit like shrimp 🦐
@@Hachapuri69 Thank you! I've been trying to sit upright, with good posture, but that's great news. I won't sit like a shrimp. I'll stand like ...a dolphin!
@@teacherrussell5206 like fuhrer a dolphin? :O
@@Hachapuri69 😁About 2 days after my last message, me and the dolphin found the golden vibration. I first practiced with the "o" vowel, but then found it by accident with my mouth closed. Then added vowels later. Now I can speak short sentences, as well. All total, I did this in just over a week, with ONLY the help of your video and 15-30 minutes practice each day. My brother, thank you so much! And thank you, Froggy!
I loved this video so much, I have always wanted to learn this beautiful sound. I would like to know should the neck be straight or where is confrontable to me. I found when my neck is straight the sound is not as deep sounding. I have subscribed so I may one day be able to throat sing. Thankyou so much for sharing. Sending best wishes from London UK
Good video
Could you do a vid on the khoomei technique as well?
I'll think about it :D
"The mongolian STEP"...almost died lol
This is an amazing video, thank you! Is there any hope to sing like this for someone who has never had the "golden vibration?" I try to sigh heavily but the air simply passes cleanly through my throat. I have no trouble with breathing properly, I've played clarinet for 8 years. I sing bass so I don't think having a high voice is a problem either.
The throat needs to be slightly constricted… I figured it out by holding my throat closed after swallowing if that makes since? And then going from there!
Really nice editing style on this one
Danke brudah! :D
Took me lots of effort with this one :O
How do you get that high piched Whistle while you throat sing? is it by singing two vowels at the same time?
Amazing video, but I couldn't reach it yet, I did the golden vibration and kept it, but when I make the vowel sound, it doesn't sound like that doubled voice, what am I possibly doing wrong?
Try it out the next day or two, maybe after a vocal warm up :D
They help:P
you sing normally while you vibrating your throat or only the vibration making the sound?
Can you make similar sound but from the lungs? Or if it sounds like this, then I'm doing it right?
Can a woman do it?
Of course! :D
There are a few female artists out there if not mistaken :D
Absolutely.
TH-cam.com/watch?v=qhSEKxQjOpY
(It's a compilation. And the first woman is doing sygyt, throat whistling)
@@Hachapuri69 Not so fast, batman. It's not that simple. For women, it actually depends on wether they have a mouth and a throat. See, not that easy.
The pokemon background music is perfect do you have the youtube link to it?
never mind i read the comments
Any tips for a woman trying to learn? I am having trouble figuring out if I'm doing it correctly.
I'm learning Throat Singing, im learning a bit of each one.
My throat stills hurt when I do like Kargyraa
The only one it doesnt hurt my throat is Sygyt lol
Is this kargyraa a vibration of the epiglottis?
I cannot even find vibration with the first "exhausted sound" you demo
ive been struggling a lot with trying to get tone out of it when i try, i have a little background in metal so that is making it harder for me. i can get the golden vibration really easily but its either just that or a straight up metal growl and i cant figure out how to get a nice (or any) tone out of it. does anyone have any tips?
One of the tips which kinda works sometimes is to listen to throatsinging and imitate at the same time. If you keep it up for a while, you'll eventually get the hang of it :D
@@Hachapuri69 jesus that was a fast response lmao. ill try that tysm
I still can’t do the golden vibration thing. Is it supposed to be far back in the throat?
3:58 autobots, transform
is this sanitary towel helps to breath better ?
I have no idea xD
😅 I was wondering the same 😂. Glad someone believes in those things! Did the gov not tell us that those things would not stop the spread? They did at the beginning, then changed their minds and made them mandatory… bless. The people has a short memory.
😅 I was wondering the same 😂. Glad someone believes in those things! Did the gov not tell us that those things would not stop the spread? They did at the beginning, then changed their minds and made them mandatory… bless. The people has a short memory.
I have troubles keeping my throat relaxed. It just stiffens after I breathe in to full capacity, breathing with my diaphrag, of course. Any advice on keeping it relaxed throughout the process?
Great channel by the way, youtube seems especially generous with recommendations recently.
Trying to learn kargyraa. At the moment I really sound like froggy, but how can I begin sounding like you?
When i do it i sound like marge simpson, is that normal?
@@BillyBobJoeJamalJenkins it matures over time :P
Guys is it supposed to hurt at the beginning?
Yeap :P
Phroge🐸
How do I stop the burning in my throat
I'm entirely regretting deleting my comment on the video about golden vibration. There are so many things between that video and this one that I've learned - the golden vibration part BEING A LIE! because, for me, what you are explaining is how to activate the portion of my throat where I need to begin in order to produce this wild sound on a level past the "e-'i'e'i" hat tricks I shared with very few. Discovering this voice randomly as a kid and now learning portion of throat, the importance of the diaphragm breathing that is huge, knowing about the scratchiness, etc etc. The symptoms of a little whipper snapper not knowing it may have been more of a froggy scenario than an inability.
I have a request though, since I was around the 6-8 year old range when I discovered this, putting me in the early 90s when I was that cool little mountain singer I didn't know about....is it possible I could get that golden vibration video on a cassette tape instead of CD because it would really be embarrassing to get there by time travel only to have a format that didn't exist yet.
It a GUTURAL primal warriors cry.
It comes from the entire body.
Just as in nature..
I dont know if i do it right
Am I high, or am I really seeing a man with beautiful hair, teaching throat singing, to a frog, wearing a mask, accompanied by peaceful guitar music, you literally can’t make this shit up
@@charlesstitchwong3124 whyaha nice 😅👍
U do Kharhiraa or smth.
I do Kargyraa.
We are not the same
xD
Can 11 year olds do throat sing?
Edit: i cant seem to do the vibration part and the tongue
Sure man! The technique can be done by anyone :D
@@Hachapuri69 Thx! now i only have to practice not to burp after doing golden vibration too much
@@Hachapuri69 Hello! I'm back i now learned khoomei style from your other vid
@@Hachapuri69 it just needs a little practice tho but Tysm now ik how to do it
@@Krushclub_freak noice! :D
Hi Battur, I have a potential voice over projects for you. Please let me know how I can reach out to you. Thanks!
здравствуйте! если вы пользуйтесь телеграмом, то вы сможете найти меэя с этим именем - @Borturuu
😁😆i tried😄it is so pleasnt
10 minutes in, neither me nor frogging can throat sing
@@MrMattberry1 xD
How does this work for women? Same techniques? Different? Probably both...
I am guessing same :D
I try this and i choked on my spit, sounds like possessed and choke🤣 not easy so yea, its awesome if u can do it