Thanks a lot for the support everyone! I know this video took a lot longer but hopefully the amount of content in the video and my writing makes up for it. Let me know if you guys enjoyed it and what I can try and improve. Also, while you’re here, feel free to follow me on instagram and I’ll start putting out lots of content there as well. instagram.com/thepranavrk/
I can prove astrology is real, if I lose I will give you 1 lakh, if u lose, u don’t have to give anything. Let me know if you are interested in this challenge
Would like to know your opinion on some principles of astrology 1) Saturn and Jupiter take 2.5 and 1 year to transverse one rashi and there are 12 rashis multiply both we get 30 years and 12 years to complete one cycle suggesting Saturn and Jupiter take that many years to complete one cycle around sun 2)Rashis are assigned some elements like Saturn has rashis associated with gas and earth, Suggesting gaseous atmosphere with a earth (solid) core
I love to see this kind of long video...because short videos make my focus level down.....like ..only I think 10min in each topic...(I think I am clear?)
Vedic Astrology is not meant to do Predictive wisdom. Vedic Astrology itself says you should not do prediction. Prediction is not at all Goal. Astrology is used in Diagnostic and study of behavior and characteristics of a person. Whereas you are thinking it is Predictive Science. Astrology is to do more of inference and interpretation not to do conclusions. I'm most fond of science, but I think you have read only Science books and engrossed only within logical science not multidimensional thinking.
While I never trust nor like astrology, I often used to lean towards it earlier. But the nail in the coffin came when I had applied for universities for masters and I got back to back rejects and had lost hopes. Then our neighbors came to us. He is an astrologer. He said stars are not with me and I won't be able to do master's yet. It not only pissed me off but given the state I was in, it completely broke me. Cannot forget how pissed I was at my parents for calling him. Fortunately one university accepted me and now I have completed my master's degree. That day onwards, whenever someone speaks about astrology to me, I shut him up. Had I believed in that shit, I would have never grown to be what I am today.
It thrives because people who face some crisis especially mid life crisis become clueless and meet them as recommended by someone. Then starts their manipulation.
I was in relationship with my girlfriend for 3years. Parents checked with 6 different astrologers and all of them predicted that I would die within 3-6 months of marriage. Also, I would lose wealth. Back then I used to be a believer and I too was scared. I started to learn more about my religion and at some point I felt it was illogical and cringe. I started my journey as an atheist. 15 months after marriage, our net worth grew and I'm still alive 🥂 P.s. I didn't do any remedies the astrologer asked to do.
@@ScienceSimplifiedAcademy Sorry that you had to go through that. I understand how hard it might have felt. At some point, because of parents pressure, we too felt like giving up. I just believed that she is the one for me and tried to research more and find reasons to be with her. That's when I came across many great atheist content creators. They widened my thoughts and made me realize how stupid it is to leave someone you love over society, horoscope and other petty cultural reasons. Now we both are atheists and our lives have never been better. I hope you are feeling better now and get all the happiness you deserve!
@@bhairavsharmavats ahh yes humanoid monkey eating the sun because he thought it's a mango. Truly a logic of all time. I love hanuman as a charecter tho I accept he is fiction. This tale of him eating sun is probably some kind of mythogical explanation for a eclipse
@@xandex69 fake quote from vishudh valmiki ramayan this fake tale is maybe in purana which very regularly adulterated this land had been under invasion for 1400 yrs and earlie Buddhist texts had fairy tale story which attracted people as a complete tution they also added these to puranas and yes I know you are a Abdul right?
The biggest prediction fails of astrology was when an astrologer told me that there's a danger of my life getting ruined by a girl in my higher secondary years.. Guess what, I'm a second year college student and am still looking for that girl who'd ruin my life. There's no sign of her yet...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ha ha.. When I got engaged most of the pundits said that our horoscopes didn't match. One of the guys even challenged that my marriage would break before my first anniversary. Last year went searching for that guy and found him long dead. I just to give him some sweets on the occasion of my 10th anniversary.
On the other hand, my friend was told his kundali (horoscopes ) matched perfectly with his wife's horoscope. Astrologer said they will have happy and understanding life for ever. But they started quarrelling from day 1, after many years of frustration he went to kick that astrologer but he found that he is dead already :)
To a believer, any attack on Astrology doesn't make sense because their personal astrologer is supposed to surpass all boundaries of common sense itself. If you finally debunk a particular Astrologer as well, then they'll just find another one. But anyways, astrology was a topic I had been waiting for, and this is the best video debunking it from an Indian perspective. I addition to all that you said, you could've added the fact that the position of stars in the night sky also changes very slowly over time which means that Astrology can never be a universal law. Lastly, I really get a lot of Vsauce vibes from this channel and you're doing a great job, just keep making quality content that you enjoy yourself.
Thanks a lot man :) Hope to improve along the way. Also yes in fact the sky is different now than when the constellations were first devised. For example all zodiac constellations have shifted by one constellation. I mention this in the video :)
@@scienceisdope It's not just about shifting, over a significant amount of time, the constellations won't even closely resemble anything because all stars would be moving in *different* directions. But really, as you said, all this nuance is exactly like beating a dead horse, astrology can be debunked in more ways than the number of people that subscribe to it.
It's sad that such pseudoscience is not just flourishing but is looked upon with utmost respect leading to these crooks warning millions by doing literally nothing
great work on the research! only one recommendation, avoid calling people 'dumb' who fall for pseudo-science. They are driven by fear, so we need to alleviate that fear with a better alternative. Caaling them dumb or stupid would just shut them out completely, hence making no difference in their belief system.
True. Good research indeed but calling people dumb here, is a bit insensitive. Humans in distress like to cling on to hope thru prayers and positive predictions. An IISc scientist from my family recovered from a chronic illness, while I believe it was medical science... His mother believes it was due to blessings of Amma Bhagwan (a couple in South); my relative spends insane amount of money on Amma Bhagwan, which onlookers find stupid, but for him it is the least he can do to keep his mother happy (his mother had donated her kidney to him). So there are many such factors that have kept the astrology industry thrive.
@@kumarikamohanty yes, prayer is a coping mechanism. It helps clueless people to keep going through the crisis by giving them some hope. These cult people just exploit these gullible ones. I have even seen people with good science degrees joining the cult and even practicing celibacy.
You're right.. My manager who is smarter than me in all aspects believes in God, Spirituality, Superstitions and Pseudoscience. He even suggested me to try Homeopathy medication once when I was sick, He still believes plastic glasses causes cancer and Taj mahal was a Hindu temple.
Keep doing good work bro... Astrology is indeed very very dangerous... People Reject Good Partner just because their stars didn't match that's how stupid people are! People become obsessed with stars and leave hard work .. Which ultimately leads to their ruin. I am an example of that... I spent thousands of ruppes on this fake nonsense and wasted precious precious time of mine! For what? For nothing but deluding Myself... Now I have woke up and looking at how much shit I was doing just Makes me Thank God hundreds of times.
Even seeing some horoscopes astrologers tell that this person is going to have extra marital affair in future .....if you don’t agree with them they will tell you that so and so celebrities have this combination....so and so adult stars having this combination.
Astrology and horoscope have become shit because of too much traffic around them, everyone who can look like an astrologer is predicting future. But this doesn't mean that astrology is wrong or the pre-marriage compatibility calculations are wrong. Earlier people used to match a lot of things to negate any possibility of same blood marriage. But, I don't have any information about Mangal dosh as of now to prove it's legitimacy. Even then i would say that astrology is not fake, astrologers who have knowledge of the subject just don't come on tv or newspaper to tell you your future.
Exactly. I have seen some people were very good but family rejected them due to astrology and partner who was approved by astrologer, was the worst for each other
@@nimishasingh4194 god so true. Some of a random baba came to our locality and said he is from haridwar and travelling whole country. So everyone started giving 5 or 10 Rs. donations and within hour he got more than 300 Rs. He saw me and started saying I am manglik and i need to marry a dog or tree before actual marriage. I was like wtf. 😐😐😐
Once a astrologer told me I am gonna be a doctor and luckily I am studying medicine but now the same guy tells me I am gonna be engineer and he specified “software”
@@scienceisdope I noticed that you don't ask people to subscribe often. You need to ask. Like carryminati does. It has worked for them. I'm sure it'll work you, after putting such dope content.
@@scienceisdope no Bhaiya see it has not yet happened, that is why don't "blindly" follow people. Btw you are among those very few people who properly follow the rules of discussion (Vada- Vivada).
I want to thank you for making this video. Even though I love science I made the mistake of delving deeply into both schools of astrology when I was young and it made some deep impression on me that I haven't been entirely successful in removing. I especially haven't been able to find vedic astrology debunked. There just don't seem to be that many people who have addressed this. I am 71 and freaking out because soon I am entering a long bad period, supposedly. I know rationally that this is garbage but I still am subconsciously affected by it. SO. I'm really grateful to you for this video. You're really funny also. Made me laugh. So thumbs up and keep it up for all of us brainwashed individuals.
@@1989TheAmrita technology came in the hands of common people western society during the 90s unlike India so they are much more aware of the technology and its uses
This is a life saving video. I too was severely affected by a computerized prediction that I won't be able to have higher education. But coming across this video made me realise it wasn't the prediction but the power of my belief that I gave away to the thing that doesn't cost a cent. Keep up the good work, we're with you❤️
I know this type of content is hard to make in a pseudoscience filled society and you might get hatred sometimes so if there is channel membership or some Patreon link to financially support you, I will definitely do my part. Keep going.
Heisenberg's Uncertainty states "An act of observation changes the observed". The video completely illustrates this point - if someone goes one making general statements about one's future, that person will for sure start thinking about those statements and in some random way connect them to his/her life, meaning higher accuracy on Barnum statements. :D Really a standout video !!!! Loved the end beat :P
There are apps like Astroyogi, Astrotalk etc with their annoyingly cringe worthy ads on TH-cam endorsed by influential personalities and bollywood celebs . Please make a videos on them too. Looking forward to it
@@politeleaf7827 They're very strongly biased. Impossible to get through to them unless they're open minded and willing to talk to you about this face-to-face in an honest conversation
@@scienceisdope you must learn to put up honest facts in your videos... You have titled the video as Vedic astrology but 50% of the things you debunk are of Western astrology.. And the rest 50% you have no idea of what you are speaking
You don't have much knowledge about Sidereal/Vedic astrology. Your horoscope can change! It's depends totally on you. To change your bad horoscope all you gotta need to do is do good karma and meditate. Cause meditation helps you to control your reactions to emotions so bad planets cannot harm you. Even astrologers say this. So, do not worry about your bad horoscope. Your life is in your hands. You get what you do 😀
Pranav... Man... I have been searching for the answers you told for so long now.. Thanks a lot. Thanks again.... I will send this video to my family..especially my mother who is modern enough to understand and follow me but just needs proper proof first... Your video is THE PROOF
Really appreciate the effort put into churning out such content Fact-checking is tedious, so believing what you're told is easy You went through the effort to logically analyse the craft and debunk the myths A wholesome take on this topic
Nice Video. I can illustrate another example of how flawed vedic astrology is. Vedic Astrology goes by Date of Birth, Place of Birth and Time of Birth and the horoscope changes drastically for every 15 minutes. I tested it with an astro software. So if you take the case of twins, who are born with a few seconds, minutes difference, accordingly they should have similar lives or at least similar timelines but we know that twins don't have similar lives or similar timelines. Vedic Astrology goes by a lot of general predictions, like Mars in 7th house is cursed for matrimony; when it coincides, you feel it's right. Therefore creating some kind of illusion in your mind to corroborate. I think all of us need to be extremely careful with this destiny changing business, it's dangerous and psychologically damaging. Best way to predict the future is to invent it :)
And it contributes to the popularity of pseudoscience which harms people with fake alternative meds and political ideologies. Check out other videos on the channel bro. I think you'll like them :) And please help by sharing so more people have access to this information :)
I m in depression coz my kundli showed Kalsarpa dosha and pitra dosha which show you would live miserable life in future . What should I believe about this astrology . The remedies are some kinda pooja related things which I can't perform coz I m not hindu . 😀
@@muneebkhan5020 Even I have that and I have got performed pooja too but nothing works,no remedy will work.I have been in depression on and off for past 10yrs.So don't worry even if u aren't a hindu,that dosha is true but remedies are not.You just have to be careful and if u want to get out of depression,go for CBT(it's a therapy) instead of pooja.Change in your thought processes will help u fight it.
if you learn astrology properly, you will see astrologers/astrology cannot change ur fate... it makes you aware of ur fate... so according to that people can move on if they are in confusion..
I appreciate your boldness & effort in creating this video. It's vital for humanity to be aware of how this can have a dangerous effect. Many people around the world use this base as a guide to important life decisions and end up in darkness. I support you, Sir. Keep SHINING the LIGHT. Please people, have an open mind - Himmat se, Pass it on.
I had a discussion with my friends who are all my batchmate doctors, on astrology. Most of them were surprised by me calling Astrology pseudoscience. I just put 3 questions in front of them. 1. Why are navgrahas given so much importance in astrology. 2. What is the nature of this energy that connects planets to human bodies and has such a massive impact on our lives. 3. What should be considered the time of birth in case of C-sections, which are manipulable. Why is the time of conception and formation of zygote not considered for astronomy. 4. I asked them to show me any prediction that went right. No satisfactory answer from any of them and i was kind of dismissed for my grilling of the supposed ancient wisdom.
Hi pranav, great job as always bro. small request if possible try to do dubbed versions of the same videos in other local languages so that ur reach will increase also increase awareness in common people.
1.Brave 2,Rich 3.Strong 4.Handsome 5.Kind 6.Disciplined 7.Loyal 8.Intelligent 9.Resilient 10.Always positive 11.Self-Critical when needed 12.Confident Here are 12 qualities for 12 zodiac signs place them wherever you want😂.
How Astrology works? Consider the following points: 1. The revolving planets and planetary alignments orchestrates Solar activity where the weak tidal forces of the planets is amplified by Sun’s magnetic field. Resonance is said to play a role here. 2. As a result, there is a formation of sun spots on the surface of sun, because of Solar activity induced by the planets there is a variation or fluctuations in Geomagnetic field which is known to influence a wide variety of organisms. 3. The Geomagnetism is linked to the solar activity, the fluctuations in solar activity causes change in Geomagnetic field variations. 4.Magneto-reception is an ability of an organism to be able to detect Geomagnetic field and able to navigate with the help of geomagnetic field. Organisms are able to detect Geomagnetic field due to magnetic particles present in brains and birds are able to navigate due to cryptochromes present in their eyes which helps in detecting light. 5. Scientists have discovered traces of magnetic particles in human brain particularly in Brain stem,Cerebellum and Cerebrum. Cerebellum is responsible for motor coordination, balance and equilibrium, fine body movements. 6. A study says that Geomagnetic field conditions plays a major role in development of foetus, thus Geomagnetic conditions are responsible for sustaining of life on earth. American Radio Engineer and amateur Astronomer John Henry Nelson discovered that revolving planets and planetary alignments orchestrate Solar activity and thereby affecting the propagation of Radio waves which caused distortion in Radio communication. The discovery of Radio Engineer John Nelson seemed to suggest that alignments of planets with respect to the Sun also had an effect upon Earth. These angles also seem to coincide with Astrological aspects: Opposition- 180 degrees Quincunx- 150 degrees Trine- 120 degrees Square- 90 degrees Sextile- 60 degrees Semi-sextile- 30 degrees In traditional Astrology, the opposition, square and trine aspects are said to be powerful and other aspects are said to be less powerful. Astrologers took keen interest in his discovery. British Astrophysicist and Astronomer Dr. Percy Seymour has written 2 books on Astrology.
One of my good friends in IIT did his first job as a software developer in an astrology start up. He said there were very smart people working in that start up and the company was making very good money. Although he makes fun of astrology in person, he was getting very good salary and it is a booming industry in India.
Back in 1991 , some days before Rajiv Gandhi was assassinated , a lot of famous astrologers were invited by the magazine "The Illustrated weekly of India" to make their predictions about his future, and without exception ALL of them predicted that he was going to become India's next prime minister. Several of them even said that Rajiv had a "raj yog" and so would remain the prime minister of India for a long time to come. None of them predicted his assassination or even a threat to his life. A few days later , Rajiv was dead and after some time had passed , some of them started to claim that they had seen a threat to his life and had warned about it. If someone can access the archives of May 1991 editions of the illulstrated weekly of India they can verify the same. I have personally read it and the magazine's then editor Kushwant Singh had pointed it out as well.
This is a great one so far Pranav! Thanks for putting so much effort in getting into this crap and showcasing in what extent Pseudoscience is being deliberately affecting us. I can suggest you to make a video on the recent AYUSH ministry that the government of India has vested upon and how their basis is mostly from Pseudoscientific fields. Keep making them! Will wait for the next one.
@@anuvab4451 no astronomy is the the study of stars and planets, astrology means predicting the future somehow using stars and planets, which is not possible
It’s great that you are debunking the myth and I appreciate it. But you cannot tell dumb to people who believe on Astrology. It’s someone’s belief. Once again I do appreciate for your work.
It's an stupid argument. Respect people, mothers, Dads etc, but don't respect their stupidity. What if someone's mother tells them to put cow dunk on their body to "detoxify" their skin... Would you respect this stupid. Respect the mother, not her stupidity... Dumb idea ls are dumb and people following those dumb things are stupid. My own family believes in so many of these things. Doesn't mean I don't respect or love... But I tell them when they are being stupid
Dude, thank you SO MUCH! I have been trying to convince my parents that Astrology is a scam. This video will help me and people like me immensely. Thank you once again!
Being a Hindu myself.. I can say that Indians love to talk about mythology, astrology and hindutva... All thanks to the andhvishwas that has haunted this country for centuries 🥺
BeLieVe iN hIgHeSt pOwEeE wHo cOntRol tHe UnIvErsE Did u see the contradiction in ur comment? If u believe in the so called higher power then u r just as "superstitious" as the person who believe in astrology.
Hello Sir!! I really liked the video you have made..... The myths and superstitions regarding astrology and business goons in the name of astrology needs to be stopped.... But a big lot of Hindi speaking people may not understand it completely .So plz do present it's Hindi version.....
It's so crazy and dumb that people are so ignorant that they believe stars and planets millions of miles away affects thier future or day to day life and actually pay money for it. It's beyond my understanding.
sir i am also an youtuber having channel named mad science duo . my ambition is to become an astronomer . i love ur videos i actually like debunking pseudoscience the 3 most common replies whenever i argue about astrology to my parents are we r ur parents we will say for ur well being, dont act over smart , and we dint question our parents like u do . they cant even understand the harm due to it. as an astonomy aspirant i feel very bad that india doest even have a single bsc in astronomy but 18 in astrology until these stupid things go off india will never become great \
its sad that your videos dont hv the number of views that it deserves...its obvious that you have invested hours researching n making this video....its a direct reflection of our mindset/.... awesome work man
Good points! No matter how hard you try to explain but the belifs that are embeded in our senior generation and those that are passed from Generation to generation will take a lot of years to believe in the points that you make in this video ( btw I do agree that your points are relatively true!) I have found a person finally who thinks like me. The diff. is you are putting efforts to explain the world, I am not! Love your videos.. Keep up the good work 😊
I don't know what kind of astrology you have found. According to my experience the kundali and further *janm-patri* are made which are easily 80% true(with not general assumptions but very specific ones) at first didn't believe in it, then I actually saw *janm-patris* of my family members, and they were really really true regarding behaviour, financial conditions, lifestyle, relationships. Surprisingly each one had different things written and not just general points. That time I started believing atleast this certain part of astrology
I have found your channel just a week back. And i became obsessed with your contents. Those all are what i was looking for from my college days. Thanks a lot man.... I really really admire you.. Keep it up🙏
I think he is wrong as we know that Gemini astrology was created by Gemini Rishi around Mahabharata time and normal astrology was older then that. He said that he will provide material to support the statements but I think he is also doing its propoganda. I guess.
@@PankajBhandari Greek never knew zero but zero is very important in Indian astrology. I have read chanakya neeti and arthashastra and in both chanakya mentions of jyotish Vidya. A man like chanakya got knowledge of astrology from his teachers which implies that astrology knowledge was in India before Alexander invasion
@@HarshSharma-jk5hv yes that's what I said in my comment about Gemini Rishi, the inventor of Gemini astrology (more then 5000 years old knowledge). And you aslo added one more point to support that statement as well, thank you. I don't know about that 😅
Hey man, you kept your word😅. Brilliant content, but try to keep it shorter in the future (just a suggestion,I'll watch it anyway). Keep smashing superstitions...Your channel is super Dope
Hey man! Thanks a lot :) Always a man of my word :P Wanted to experiment with a longer video and see the reception. Will try and stick to a more optimum length. Help me reach more people by sharing :)
If Vedic astrology was borrowed from Greece then does that mean the Vedic people enhanced or complicated the existing astrological model by adding Moon positions also in the model?
@@gem7624 no , Greeks and indians exchanged many ideas during the indo greek period. Not all ideas that have horoscope come from greeks. Many are indian additions , improvise etc. This one is worked in india.
Time of birth and place of birth matter in Indian astrology. It is a calculation. I was very skeptical about Indian astrology. Then I discovered, from personal experience, that it is the astrologer that matters. Most Indian astrologers are accurate at telling your exact past. But Most are vague about predicting the exact future, which I agree is impossible. My personal experience is that most astrologers are either fake or not knowledgeable. There are a couple of them (random visits to an unknown astrologers, not planned) that astounded me with not just my personal characteristics, but were accurate about my profession, what my parents do for a living, my interests, number of siblings I have etc. I totally agree that people get fooled by astrologers, but I feel that predicting something or reading a horoscope accurately is a gift, acquired only by a select few. True astrologers don't show off and are to the point. Astrology is mysterious and secretive.
_"True astrologers don't show off and are to the point. "_ Astrologers could rake in a hundreds of thousands or a million dollars by demonstrating in skeptics challenges that astrology works. If they don't want the money, they could donate it to children hospitals or the likes. But this is also not worth it it seems. They either don't want to demonstrate their skills in a controlled setting, or they try it and fail. Why is that? Nobody can explain in detail how astrology could work, nobody can provide good evidence that it works.
Some people are good at reading people. There are literal face readers who's job it is to do this. I think it's a tremendous skill but to attribute it to the constellations would be a collosal claim that requires an equally convincing proof. We claim things to be "mysterious" when we don't know much about it, and perhaps much isn't known bcz there isn't much to be known and this is all yet another desparate attempt of humans to find tools to solve our problems and we're filling the logical gaps with our imaginations. I think we do this as a survival instinct, it's not possible to know everything so we make up stories to make the fear of the unknown palatable.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 Only a fool will try to explain what he/she doesn't understand. I don't understand it. Some things are unexplained and mysterious. We are ordinary human beings, not enlightened ones. Logic and science is very important, I agree. But certain things science can't explain, because we haven't fully understood science either. Scientists are still mystified, despite all the laws of physics, how life is possible on earth at all. They only have theories, not concrete explanations. Of course, you are entitled to your foolish opinion.
I know this reply is a bit late but predicting someone's past can be done with certain accuracy. The way a person walks, talks, behaves and what he talks about can reveal a lot about his past to a sharp and cunning mind. Whatever these astrologers determine about someone's can always be traced back to information they gathered from you. For example, if you attempted suicide long ago but now you're talking happily to an astrologer, he won't conclude that you attempted that suicide.
I always knew it's all about smart psychology. Someone told me that my husband will dominate me after marriage. But he had no idea that I m A level manipulator 😂😂😂
Kudos Pranav! you have known your audience. I like how you are concentrating on Indian version of astrology. And this is clearly beneficial as you could not have surpassed Dr. Tyson. So now even if anyone searches neutal words (neutral adjective + object) like Indian astrology you are at #2 with other debunks, except if we search vedic astrology this video is nowhere to be seen along with other debunks😔. Next time you should target that! If we search for phrase (negative/doubt type) you are always #1!🎉🎉🎉🎊🎊
Some nice points made, but! I gotta disagree here. You know, I was just an atheist/agnostic/skeptical like you and then I got introduced to astrology. Instead of listening to what the science and logic has to say about it I decided to jump into it, learn about it, and try to see if it can predict anything about myself. Remember, all the logic, all the proof are nothing against practical experiment and results. If it's working, it is working, the Universe is not compelled to make sense to you. And no points for guessing, it actually worked for me. After learning to read the chart properly I found out that it can actually predict many things about my personality. And NO! They were not barnum statements, I know cause I was aware of them before I dove into astrology. I hope you will agree that "You will be a good singer" "You will be an atheist/skeptic" are not barnum statements. Now, you must be thinking that oh, he doesnt seem to be an atheist. Well, astrology predicted that as well, my kundali said that I will change my opinions about God/Spiritualism frequently. Which I do.... Also, predicting the future is very hard and only expert astrologers can do it. If doctors fail to save a patient do you say that oh! the medical science doesnt work! NO! You don't say that you say that maybe doctor wasnt good enough or the case was very hard. In the same manner, sometimes astrologers do make wrong predictions but they are not always wrong. For example, when I started digging into astrology my mom told me that once she went to an astrologer and the first thing he said after looking at my dad's kundali was - "DID U BUY ANY PROPERTY IN 2004?" I was shocked because it did actually happen.... She also told me that he predicted a child's death correctly (gave the exact date). Please consider these points and tell me what do you think... Trust me, I want astrology to be proven wrong more than anyone else in this world, because it challenges my atheism. But it just keeps on proving that it has got some substance... EDIT: I also, asked one of my friend to give me his dob, time, and place (remember time of birth is very important) and I tried to predict something about him from my limited knowledge of astrology. The first thing I said about him was "You don't have good relations with your dad" (funny thing is I was afraid of getting ridiculed coz I always thought that he had good relations with his father) but to my surprise he agreed and said you are right me and my dad always fight, argue about something and our view points dont match....
Thanks man for the comment :) I love to be a part of civil disagreements like this because it promotes discourse. And hearing contrasting points of view helps you not fall prey to confirmation bias. My rebuttal: I would say predictions like "you will be a good singer" or "you'll keep changing your opinions about God" are too general and apply to too many people. For instance, the latter applies to me because there was a period when I kept shuttling back and forth on my position on God. The same goes for "you don't have good relations with your dad". It's way too general. Don't most people our generation have disagreements/fights with parents? The predictions you mentioned about buying property in 2004 and predicting the date of someone's death sound like very specific predictions. Even I've heard several predictions like these(and miracles in alternative medicine). But they're always second hand. Just like how you mentioned that it was your mother that told you this. There are many small details that are lost when information transfers hands. So I wouldn't jump to the conclusion that astrology works just because of this. I won't jump to the conclusion the predictions are wrong either, but we can both agree that we should examine this further before drawing conclusions.
@@scienceisdope yes i would advise you to learn reading charts and give it a try on yourself :) about the points that you have made, trust me i have taken care of all these logical fallacies that a common man commits, as i said i was an atheist and i have ridiculed astrologers in the past, it even cost me friendship with some people. So you can understand what kind of atheist i was. But just because I like science and logic, I can't deny the truth that is in front of me, no matter how unscientific it sounds. Also, about my mom, she is a skeptic herself she doesnt worship any god or believe in any kind of ancient rituals and shit. so i can believe in the info i got from her.
@@easytutorials6412 Hello Rahul. I hope you are doing well. Brother I would disagree with your point of view because of few reasons. You started by saying that instead of listening towhat science and logic had to say you jumped into it and so on. Bro, if you have already discarded logic then wouldn't that expose you to being a victim of confirmation bias? You will not be able to evaluate things properly. More or less that's how even faith in religion works, i.e. without logic. And please once again remember correlation does not imply causation. Now, if I make a random prediction of someone's death tomorrow and if it comes true, would I be accurate all the time? And will that mean that my prediction had a logical reasoning behind it? Well, my answer is no. And one more important thing to consider is that no one has explained is that how does planets and stars affect us. They fail to give the reason behind it, all they do is give statements like it will have positive or negative impact on us. And the most surprising thing is that those effects can be changed after a small Pooja or ceremony (and some cash and clothes for Pandits). Now allow me to make 2 statements. 1) I have constant disagreements with my wife all the time and we argue a lot. 2)I love my wife a lot and is willing to anything and everything for her. Now they may sound contradictory. But both are 100% accurate. First statement is true for me and it could also be true for person going through a divorce. I hope I have explained my point. I don't expect you to agree with it though. Regardless, have a wonderful day.
I was laughing hard through out the video. I didn't actually know that there is a 13th zodiac too, apparently my brother falls into that house, I will break that to him now🤣🤣🤣. Also the ending song was dope!!
I got a kundli made for me and its hilarious how events mentioned were completely different from my life till now well most of that were general things that happens to almost everyone.
You don't have much knowledge about Sidereal/Vedic astrology. Your horoscope can change! It's depends totally on you. To change your bad horoscope all you gotta need to do is do good karma and meditate. Cause meditation helps you to control your reactions to emotions so bad planets cannot harm you. Even astrologers say this. So, do not worry about your bad horoscope. Your life is in your hands. You get what you do 😀
True. Everyone life is a lie. What they believe is not what they are rather the cosmos itself. Imagine yourself without the earth, sun, and the mighty cosmos.
Lol i had one girl in my hostel who always asked me to read and explain her Libra horoscope tips, she said it was very accurate and helpful. After a few months she asked again and I started by pointing at the print for Libra, she said that was not her horoscope, she found out her zodiac was different.
@@TeeKeeps answering a reply on my post from two years ago, not fake, we are refugees living in another country, many children were sent to schools without proper documents, some having wrong date of births and even wrong names. The girl I was talking to was a refugee from our former country, she found out her date of birth was not as it was written in the documents. That’s why she said her zodiac was wrong
I appreciate ur efforts for debunking Indian psuedoscience practices,but I would like express my disagreement on indian astrology coming from Greece.The reason being some ancient scriptures like Ramayan and Mahabharat (just to name a few)gave the celestial positions for various events.It would be very nice of you to enlighten me on this.Nice and Informative video btw🤗🤗
The tenets of vedic astrology and rashis migrated to india from greece. But there has been a tradition of nakshatras which were mentioned in ramayana and mahabharata. I've added this as a clarification to my video description. Thank you :) subscribe and share if you find my content useful bro
@@scienceisdope plz get your facts right before preaching it to someone else... Yavana jaataka is one of the many treatise on Vedic astrology which is attributed to the Greeks... There exists works which are much older than this...
Jyotish is the light of the Vedas. Jyotish is subjective. Jyotish deals with consciousness. It is not a material stuff. Every planet and Nakshatras affects human and all the life on earth every which way. Even stupids know moon affects water and human body is 70 % water. Jyotish do not come to everyone. Its blessing for those who saw the jyotish . Fake astrologers existed it doesn't mean that jyotish is untrue. Jyotish embedded in advanced quantum physics. Jyotish deals with karma and past life tendencies. Planets and Nakshatras are conscious. Everything in universe has its own state of consciousness. Jyotish is beyond the brain of ordinary. Never discuss a subject which you are not familiar with. Never defame jyotish when you don't know anything about it.
This is a spectacular video! Please also make a video on how to explain this to people who are neck deep in astrology. They actually believe Venus is the reason why they'll get stuck in traffic
I'm not an atheist , I do worship God, but I don't believe in astrology, yet people think I'm an atheist . Associating a pseudoscience with religion is a wrong thing .
Ok this video has so many factual and conceptual errors. 1. Birth Rashi is not the transit of Sun, it is the transit of Moon in Vedic astrology. 2. Vedic astrologers do take procession of equinoxes into account. It is called Aynamsha. There's a controversy as to what is the exact value of Aynamsha. But overall they agree withan approx value. 3. The claim that India took zodics from Western astrology is not a settled debate. There are out of India theories where it is conjectured that zodiac was taken from India by the Westerners. Or may be there is a third source. This is because the theory that Zodiacs came to India during Alexander(approx 350BC) is inconsistent with mention of Zodiacs in Hindu epics like Ramayana and Mahabharata which are dated atleast before 500BC. But various dates from 700 to 1800 BC are proposed, by Western historians themselves. So this proves that Indians were aware of Zodiacs before the arrival of Alexander. 4. There are only 12 zodiacs along the ecliptic. Not any more. The number twelve is not a random number picked. There are 27 Nakshatras because moon takes approx 27 days to revolve once. It stays in one Nakshatra for one day approx. There are 30 days in Month because that's the frequency at which Full Moon occurs. There are 12 months because there are approx 12 full moons in one year. So the idea is a zodiac is unit where the Sun stays for one month. Its backward working. Once in a while for error correction we have Adhika Masa, something like leap year, that's when we have 13 months. But on a regular year there are 12 months. So 12 zodiacs are arrived from this, as far as I know. 5. Moreover the idea that correlation is not causation, is half true. Undisputed correlation means the two incidents are in the same family of causal links. Disputed correlation is not causation. Undisputed bijunctive correlation is causation. 6. "Indian astrologers don't give an explaination as to how planets influence you" This is not completely true as they do give a supernatural explaination, which ofcourse you would not agree with. But they do make an attempt to explain how it all works. The claim that they don't give any explanation regarding the mechanism of Astrology is technically wrong.
Once an astrologer gave me a ring and asked me to wear it...he said if I wear it then probably in the next 3 years one big event will happen in my life ...after 3 years He passed away 😅😅😅😅
Stop saying they passed away... I'm gonna start being racist or stereotypical against y'all. Real scammers & unserious with y'all spirituality fr... The United States might just hold some real powers over y'all; Sooner or later, I'm not even joking.
If any spiritual sciences in history are not real at all, why do they transform and work for some ppl. I know of ppl that healed their entire health with Ayurveda. And this is a genuine honest question as a young person that is confused about life and it on a journey trying to understanding things. I always loved both science and spirituality and dont jusge either side. I am a very receptive person and just like to learn, so im looking for a real genuine response. Thanks in advance
Well it's not that ayurveda doesn't work at all, it's just not scientifically accurate. Like there can be things that are wrong but still work as an example take the case of wheather things float or sink in water, we were told in childhood that it depends on the density of the object, but later we come to know that it's because of Archimedes Principle. Now as Ayurveda is a quite old concept, it is bound to have some things that work and others that don't. It has some geniune lifestyle advices which can help you, but as it's basic premise is wrong, it would be very hard to identify good advices.
Well honestly I too was confused like u but I do believe aryuveda and astrology both now it's more about experiences I have personally felt astrology in a big way and I have seen my mom recover from health by aryuveda now like always aryuveda is not all good some things are shady and shirty but that does not cancle all the aryuveda being wrong . As far as astrologer I had met a good astrologer and his predicuisn were on point not only past but future lol and I have seen astrology work at other times too so I personally believe but chances are u will find a bad astrologer and would never believe in It which actually is fine it's totally ok it's life and u have your own experiences I am 20yold btw 💀
idk u will read this comment or not , I just wanna say when I meet my astrologer I was full of confidence that it's all rubbish. But when he started to say all my past things on point and my current problems without even telling him anything. Then I knew that there is something which we don't know about astrology. I was also making a lot of fun of astrologers , but when I meet that 1 guy that gave me an idea that there's something which we still don't know
but what happened to the challenge given by the astrophysicst in the starting of the video ?? i am assuming the astrologers backed out or predicted wrong or maybe predicted right after stalking their social media accounts.
Found your channel by chance. Someone recommended me Autobiography of Yogi,I started reading it and I was wondering how the hell people believe this shit. Then I started searching "paramhansa fraud" sadhuguru fraud and I came to your channel😜. It looks my confirmation bias and Google's algorithm says Science is dope.
same man..!! did you read that After death wala part?.. all the planets and shit like that??.. his so called guru materialized in front of him in Taj Hotel room.. damn that shit is so funny..
A bit of advice. Pls increase the video speed to atleast 1.25x cause it's really slow. I know I can do it as well but if I forward it to someone who doesn't really know how to do that, it doesn't really feel very impactful cuz it feels like you're talking a bit slow
bro just wanted to confirm how did u come to the conclusion that vedic astrology actually migrated from greece to india and not india to greece and how sure are u about the origin dates of indian astrology.
After watching your videos I left the idea of god altogether. The video on sadhguru and sri sri were dope. Man u opened my mind totally. Now i have become agnostic, also still trying to find what is all this about life. Now i will leave this astrology fraud for sure. Also make more videos thumbs up to you 😊❤️
oh man, this is awesome content. Please keep doing it. I couldn't convince my parents that astrology is BS but now I have few more points to persuade. thanks
@@AbhinavKumar-ov3xfI have already done it long back.. Just copy pasting the same for your convenience... Next time educate yourself instead of applauding an idiot... " The title you have mentioned Vedic astrology but where is the definition of Graha as per it .? You just laugh out telling the Greek definition..? just because it supports your cause..? Your Rashi is where your sun is placed..?? Lol... You don't even know Rashi is the sign where your moon is placed and you are making video on Jyotisha..? @11:14 You said the name simha Rashi is because it looks like a lion in the sky and laughed at it... But where is it even mentioned in Vedic astrology...? So you were basically laughing at your own lies... Vedic astrology came with Alexander..!!! Seriously..? Heard about 18 rishis who compiled jyotishya..? No you haven't... Coz you know nothing... Some one has rightly said... fools always finds other fools who admire/follow them... You just have found a bunch of them . Good luck to you .."
@@fact5832 I do not know why you have to resort to personal attacks to support your argument. If you believe that Vedic astrology is accurate, please first provide me a mathematical proof explaining that future is pre determined.
Thanks a lot for the support everyone! I know this video took a lot longer but hopefully the amount of content in the video and my writing makes up for it. Let me know if you guys enjoyed it and what I can try and improve.
Also, while you’re here, feel free to follow me on instagram and I’ll start putting out lots of content there as well.
instagram.com/thepranavrk/
I can prove astrology is real, if I lose I will give you 1 lakh, if u lose, u don’t have to give anything. Let me know if you are interested in this challenge
@@venkateshmabbu9948 prove me
(psycho SD)
Would like to know your opinion on some principles of astrology
1) Saturn and Jupiter take 2.5 and 1 year to transverse one rashi and there are 12 rashis multiply both we get 30 years and 12 years to complete one cycle suggesting Saturn and Jupiter take that many years to complete one cycle around sun
2)Rashis are assigned some elements like Saturn has rashis associated with gas and earth, Suggesting gaseous atmosphere with a earth (solid) core
I love to see this kind of long video...because short videos make my focus level down.....like ..only I think 10min in each topic...(I think I am clear?)
Vedic Astrology is not meant to do Predictive wisdom.
Vedic Astrology itself says you should not do prediction.
Prediction is not at all Goal.
Astrology is used in Diagnostic and study of behavior and characteristics of a person.
Whereas you are thinking it is Predictive Science.
Astrology is to do more of inference and interpretation not to do conclusions.
I'm most fond of science, but I think you have read only Science books and
engrossed only within logical science not multidimensional thinking.
An Astrologer told me that I would be an astronaut, the highest point from earth's surface that I have reached was when I had a pot brownie.
hahaha. that is good enough, man. XD
Underrated comment
th-cam.com/video/RrxxRc2neds/w-d-xo.html
where did you get pot brownie
Astrologer is wrong
While I never trust nor like astrology, I often used to lean towards it earlier. But the nail in the coffin came when I had applied for universities for masters and I got back to back rejects and had lost hopes. Then our neighbors came to us. He is an astrologer. He said stars are not with me and I won't be able to do master's yet. It not only pissed me off but given the state I was in, it completely broke me. Cannot forget how pissed I was at my parents for calling him. Fortunately one university accepted me and now I have completed my master's degree. That day onwards, whenever someone speaks about astrology to me, I shut him up. Had I believed in that shit, I would have never grown to be what I am today.
I know im 3 weeks late but
Kudos!
Hope you grow even more
Congratulations brother.
It thrives because people who face some crisis especially mid life crisis become clueless and meet them as recommended by someone. Then starts their manipulation.
They target your emotions and hit it hard. It's nothing but just a way to make money.
were you ever diagnosed perfectly by a doctor on the first visit for any of your ailments??
"If a star disturbs my life, it would not be worth a cent." ~ Swami Vivekananda
That's such a trash ass quote lol.
I was in relationship with my girlfriend for 3years. Parents checked with 6 different astrologers and all of them predicted that I would die within 3-6 months of marriage. Also, I would lose wealth.
Back then I used to be a believer and I too was scared. I started to learn more about my religion and at some point I felt it was illogical and cringe. I started my journey as an atheist. 15 months after marriage, our net worth grew and I'm still alive 🥂
P.s. I didn't do any remedies the astrologer asked to do.
@@ScienceSimplifiedAcademy Sorry that you had to go through that. I understand how hard it might have felt. At some point, because of parents pressure, we too felt like giving up. I just believed that she is the one for me and tried to research more and find reasons to be with her. That's when I came across many great atheist content creators. They widened my thoughts and made me realize how stupid it is to leave someone you love over society, horoscope and other petty cultural reasons. Now we both are atheists and our lives have never been better.
I hope you are feeling better now and get all the happiness you deserve!
@@Prash5 such a beautiful story Prash. Wish you guys a very happy life ahead
This isn't part of Hinduism go abd study arya samaj you'll know how rationale your Dharma is
@@bhairavsharmavats ahh yes humanoid monkey eating the sun because he thought it's a mango. Truly a logic of all time.
I love hanuman as a charecter tho I accept he is fiction.
This tale of him eating sun is probably some kind of mythogical explanation for a eclipse
@@xandex69 fake quote from vishudh valmiki ramayan this fake tale is maybe in purana which very regularly adulterated this land had been under invasion for 1400 yrs and earlie Buddhist texts had fairy tale story which attracted people as a complete tution they also added these to puranas and yes I know you are a Abdul right?
The biggest prediction fails of astrology was when an astrologer told me that there's a danger of my life getting ruined by a girl in my higher secondary years.. Guess what, I'm a second year college student and am still looking for that girl who'd ruin my life. There's no sign of her yet...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂
LMAO
Ha ha.. When I got engaged most of the pundits said that our horoscopes didn't match. One of the guys even challenged that my marriage would break before my first anniversary. Last year went searching for that guy and found him long dead. I just to give him some sweets on the occasion of my 10th anniversary.
On the other hand, my friend was told his kundali (horoscopes ) matched perfectly with his wife's horoscope. Astrologer said they will have happy and understanding life for ever.
But they started quarrelling from day 1, after many years of frustration he went to kick that astrologer but he found that he is dead already :)
To a believer, any attack on Astrology doesn't make sense because their personal astrologer is supposed to surpass all boundaries of common sense itself. If you finally debunk a particular Astrologer as well, then they'll just find another one. But anyways, astrology was a topic I had been waiting for, and this is the best video debunking it from an Indian perspective. I addition to all that you said, you could've added the fact that the position of stars in the night sky also changes very slowly over time which means that Astrology can never be a universal law. Lastly, I really get a lot of Vsauce vibes from this channel and you're doing a great job, just keep making quality content that you enjoy yourself.
Thanks a lot man :) Hope to improve along the way. Also yes in fact the sky is different now than when the constellations were first devised. For example all zodiac constellations have shifted by one constellation. I mention this in the video :)
@@scienceisdope It's not just about shifting, over a significant amount of time, the constellations won't even closely resemble anything because all stars would be moving in *different* directions. But really, as you said, all this nuance is exactly like beating a dead horse, astrology can be debunked in more ways than the number of people that subscribe to it.
True true :)
It's sad that such pseudoscience is not just flourishing but is looked upon with utmost respect leading to these crooks warning millions by doing literally nothing
@@garth2356 reminds me of the Sherlock series of where he proves a painting to be fake looking at the painted constellation in the picture
great work on the research! only one recommendation, avoid calling people 'dumb' who fall for pseudo-science. They are driven by fear, so we need to alleviate that fear with a better alternative. Caaling them dumb or stupid would just shut them out completely, hence making no difference in their belief system.
True. Good research indeed but calling people dumb here, is a bit insensitive. Humans in distress like to cling on to hope thru prayers and positive predictions. An IISc scientist from my family recovered from a chronic illness, while I believe it was medical science... His mother believes it was due to blessings of Amma Bhagwan (a couple in South); my relative spends insane amount of money on Amma Bhagwan, which onlookers find stupid, but for him it is the least he can do to keep his mother happy (his mother had donated her kidney to him).
So there are many such factors that have kept the astrology industry thrive.
@@kumarikamohanty yes, prayer is a coping mechanism. It helps clueless people to keep going through the crisis by giving them some hope. These cult people just exploit these gullible ones. I have even seen people with good science degrees joining the cult and even practicing celibacy.
You're right..
My manager who is smarter than me in all aspects believes in God, Spirituality, Superstitions and Pseudoscience. He even suggested me to try Homeopathy medication once when I was sick, He still believes plastic glasses causes cancer and Taj mahal was a Hindu temple.
Excuse me the research was ridiculous and there are dozen of mistakes clearly you appreciated him without ever reading or analysing the subject
@@kumarikamohanty 😱🙄
Keep doing good work bro... Astrology is indeed very very dangerous... People Reject Good Partner just because their stars didn't match that's how stupid people are! People become obsessed with stars and leave hard work .. Which ultimately leads to their ruin. I am an example of that... I spent thousands of ruppes on this fake nonsense and wasted precious precious time of mine! For what? For nothing but deluding Myself... Now I have woke up and looking at how much shit I was doing just Makes me Thank God hundreds of times.
Even seeing some horoscopes astrologers tell that this person is going to have extra marital affair in future .....if you don’t agree with them they will tell you that so and so celebrities have this combination....so and so adult stars having this combination.
Astrology and horoscope have become shit because of too much traffic around them, everyone who can look like an astrologer is predicting future. But this doesn't mean that astrology is wrong or the pre-marriage compatibility calculations are wrong. Earlier people used to match a lot of things to negate any possibility of same blood marriage. But, I don't have any information about Mangal dosh as of now to prove it's legitimacy. Even then i would say that astrology is not fake, astrologers who have knowledge of the subject just don't come on tv or newspaper to tell you your future.
Exactly. I have seen some people were very good but family rejected them due to astrology and partner who was approved by astrologer, was the worst for each other
u r right thats brahman occult shit
@@nimishasingh4194 god so true. Some of a random baba came to our locality and said he is from haridwar and travelling whole country. So everyone started giving 5 or 10 Rs. donations and within hour he got more than 300 Rs. He saw me and started saying I am manglik and i need to marry a dog or tree before actual marriage. I was like wtf. 😐😐😐
Once a astrologer told me I am gonna be a doctor and luckily I am studying medicine but now the same guy tells me I am gonna be engineer and he specified “software”
The first time I went to astrologer with my parents was in 7th grade and 2nd time is when I started studying medicine 🙂
😂😂😂
According to my Astrologer, this channel is going to blow up by the end of 2020. 😉
I've never wanted an astrologer to be right this badly xD
Thanks man. Help me get there by sharing :)
@@scienceisdope just saw your channel it's amazing....
@@scienceisdope I noticed that you don't ask people to subscribe often. You need to ask. Like carryminati does. It has worked for them. I'm sure it'll work you, after putting such dope content.
@@scienceisdope no Bhaiya see it has not yet happened, that is why don't "blindly" follow people.
Btw you are among those very few people who properly follow the rules of discussion (Vada- Vivada).
And I am from future sadly tell you your prediction is wrong.lol
I want to thank you for making this video. Even though I love science I made the mistake of delving deeply into both schools of astrology when I was young and it made some deep impression on me that I haven't been entirely successful in removing. I especially haven't been able to find vedic astrology debunked. There just don't seem to be that many people who have addressed this. I am 71 and freaking out because soon I am entering a long bad period, supposedly. I know rationally that this is garbage but I still am subconsciously affected by it. SO. I'm really grateful to you for this video. You're really funny also. Made me laugh. So thumbs up and keep it up for all of us brainwashed individuals.
Wow .. you really 71 and commenting on TH-cam video - now that is real dope
@@1989TheAmrita technology came in the hands of common people western society during the 90s unlike India so they are much more aware of the technology and its uses
@@frankcastle1862 Still old ppl usually don't leave comments on youtube videos
What do you mean by you haven't been able to find Vedic astrology debunked? You mean debunking video sir ?
This is a life saving video. I too was severely affected by a computerized prediction that I won't be able to have higher education. But coming across this video made me realise it wasn't the prediction but the power of my belief that I gave away to the thing that doesn't cost a cent. Keep up the good work, we're with you❤️
I know this type of content is hard to make in a pseudoscience filled society and you might get hatred sometimes so if there is channel membership or some Patreon link to financially support you, I will definitely do my part. Keep going.
Thanks a lot :) I don't need money. The greatest help you can do for me is to share the video so that it reaches more people :)
You are very right friend. It will take centuries, but we have to work hard.
@PratosX . nah boie we need mr beast then this will work in a month to a year
@@scienceisdope hi , can you give your birth credentials? Let's check the validity of astrology!
Nowadays A-holes are administrating TH-cam too, they are demonetizing channels like this too.
The Simpsons writers are the only qualified astrologers. 😅
LOLLL
Good one 😆 🤣 😂
Thank you. They can talk down on astrology all they want; It's real.
Heisenberg's Uncertainty states "An act of observation changes the observed". The video completely illustrates this point - if someone goes one making general statements about one's future, that person will for sure start thinking about those statements and in some random way connect them to his/her life, meaning higher accuracy on Barnum statements. :D
Really a standout video !!!! Loved the end beat :P
Thanks a lot man :) Really appreciate it. Like you said, confirmation bias plays a huge role in people's rationalizations with astrology
I don't think that's quite what the uncertainty principle states but I got your point.
@@adamthapazz4137 Yes the uncertainty principle is more like you can't determine the position and momentum of a microscopic particle at same time.
@@sigmaandpi2062 exactly
@@scienceisdope can you just tell me that is religion(particularly Hinduism) is worth believing or has any benefits?... If yes then to what extent?
There are apps like Astroyogi, Astrotalk etc with their annoyingly cringe worthy ads on TH-cam endorsed by influential personalities and bollywood celebs . Please make a videos on them too. Looking forward to it
I found your channel today and trust me I have watched almost all of your videos back to back. So informative 🤗 keep up your work...
Thanks a lot... This comment made my day:) Please share my videos with others you think it might help :)
@@scienceisdope shared in my family group and with some of my vedic friends and had illogical arguments with them😂...
@@politeleaf7827 They're very strongly biased. Impossible to get through to them unless they're open minded and willing to talk to you about this face-to-face in an honest conversation
@@scienceisdope you must learn to put up honest facts in your videos...
You have titled the video as Vedic astrology but 50% of the things you debunk are of Western astrology.. And the rest 50% you have no idea of what you are speaking
One of my friend’s astrologer predicted that he would fail in the exam.
So he stopped studying and failed the exams.
Astrologers -1, students -0
You don't have much knowledge about Sidereal/Vedic astrology. Your horoscope can change! It's depends totally on you. To change your bad horoscope all you gotta need to do is do good karma and meditate. Cause meditation helps you to control your reactions to emotions so bad planets cannot harm you. Even astrologers say this. So, do not worry about your bad horoscope. Your life is in your hands. You get what you do 😀
😅😅😂😂
this is y'all issue. a bunch of false prophets in for profit. India is lost... Y'all need guidance over there? How's your government?
Pranav... Man... I have been searching for the answers you told for so long now.. Thanks a lot. Thanks again.... I will send this video to my family..especially my mother who is modern enough to understand and follow me but just needs proper proof first... Your video is THE PROOF
I'm glad I could be of help :)
I like your videos man. Indian society is extremely superstitious.. And as an Indian it's very frustrating
Few years back neem tumeric was also pseudo medicine.
I know you trust a gora more than your dark colored skin haha
@@TanyaWins007 look who got offended🤣
@@millenialmusings8451
Why do people “🤣” at the end of sentences that are not particularly funny?
@@TanyaWins007 yeah really not funny
But
Y know what's funny ??
Deleting your comment asap "🤣"
@@Sohailhgfggggh6 grow up, nobita
Really appreciate the effort put into churning out such content
Fact-checking is tedious, so believing what you're told is easy
You went through the effort to logically analyse the craft and debunk the myths
A wholesome take on this topic
Nice Video. I can illustrate another example of how flawed vedic astrology is. Vedic Astrology goes by Date of Birth, Place of Birth and Time of Birth and the horoscope changes drastically for every 15 minutes. I tested it with an astro software. So if you take the case of twins, who are born with a few seconds, minutes difference, accordingly they should have similar lives or at least similar timelines but we know that twins don't have similar lives or similar timelines. Vedic Astrology goes by a lot of general predictions, like Mars in 7th house is cursed for matrimony; when it coincides, you feel it's right. Therefore creating some kind of illusion in your mind to corroborate. I think all of us need to be extremely careful with this destiny changing business, it's dangerous and psychologically damaging. Best way to predict the future is to invent it :)
And it contributes to the popularity of pseudoscience which harms people with fake alternative meds and political ideologies. Check out other videos on the channel bro. I think you'll like them :)
And please help by sharing so more people have access to this information :)
Can you give some examples of twins that are born with few seconds difference?
I m in depression coz my kundli showed Kalsarpa dosha and pitra dosha which show you would live miserable life in future . What should I believe about this astrology . The remedies are some kinda pooja related things which I can't perform coz I m not hindu . 😀
@@muneebkhan5020 Even I have that and I have got performed pooja too but nothing works,no remedy will work.I have been in depression on and off for past 10yrs.So don't worry even if u aren't a hindu,that dosha is true but remedies are not.You just have to be careful and if u want to get out of depression,go for CBT(it's a therapy) instead of pooja.Change in your thought processes will help u fight it.
if you learn astrology properly, you will see astrologers/astrology cannot change ur fate... it makes you aware of ur fate... so according to that people can move on if they are in confusion..
I appreciate your boldness & effort in creating this video. It's vital for humanity to be aware of how this can have a dangerous effect. Many people around the world use this base as a guide to important life decisions and end up in darkness. I support you, Sir. Keep SHINING the LIGHT. Please people, have an open mind - Himmat se, Pass it on.
Yeah. A dangerous effect on the falses.
Boss, excellent channel, keep it up
Thanks bro. Please share so that it reaches more people
@@scienceisdope Delete it. Drop it off.
I had a discussion with my friends who are all my batchmate doctors, on astrology. Most of them were surprised by me calling Astrology pseudoscience. I just put 3 questions in front of them.
1. Why are navgrahas given so much importance in astrology.
2. What is the nature of this energy that connects planets to human bodies and has such a massive impact on our lives.
3. What should be considered the time of birth in case of C-sections, which are manipulable. Why is the time of conception and formation of zygote not considered for astronomy.
4. I asked them to show me any prediction that went right.
No satisfactory answer from any of them and i was kind of dismissed for my grilling of the supposed ancient wisdom.
that's 4 not 3 dummy. this is why astrology is real. y'all assume and probably believe in deities like Shiva. 💀
Hi pranav, great job as always bro. small request if possible try to do dubbed versions of the same videos in other local languages so that ur reach will increase also increase awareness in common people.
1.Brave
2,Rich
3.Strong
4.Handsome
5.Kind
6.Disciplined
7.Loyal
8.Intelligent
9.Resilient
10.Always positive
11.Self-Critical when needed
12.Confident
Here are 12 qualities for 12 zodiac signs place them wherever you want😂.
How Astrology works? Consider the following points:
1. The revolving planets and planetary alignments orchestrates Solar activity where the weak tidal forces of the planets is amplified by Sun’s magnetic field. Resonance is said to play a role here.
2. As a result, there is a formation of sun spots on the surface of sun, because of Solar activity induced by the planets there is a variation or fluctuations in Geomagnetic field which is known to influence a wide variety of organisms.
3. The Geomagnetism is linked to the solar activity, the fluctuations in solar activity causes change in Geomagnetic field variations.
4.Magneto-reception is an ability of an organism to be able to detect Geomagnetic field and able to navigate with the help of geomagnetic field. Organisms are able to detect Geomagnetic field due to magnetic particles present in brains and birds are able to navigate due to cryptochromes present in their eyes which helps in detecting light.
5. Scientists have discovered traces of magnetic particles in human brain particularly in Brain stem,Cerebellum and Cerebrum. Cerebellum is responsible for motor coordination, balance and equilibrium, fine body movements.
6. A study says that Geomagnetic field conditions plays a major role in development of foetus, thus Geomagnetic conditions are responsible for sustaining of life on earth.
American Radio Engineer and amateur Astronomer John Henry Nelson discovered that revolving planets and planetary alignments orchestrate Solar activity and thereby affecting the propagation of Radio waves which caused distortion in Radio communication.
The discovery of Radio Engineer John Nelson seemed to suggest that alignments of planets with
respect to the Sun also had an effect upon Earth. These angles also seem to coincide with Astrological aspects:
Opposition- 180 degrees
Quincunx- 150 degrees
Trine- 120 degrees
Square- 90 degrees
Sextile- 60 degrees
Semi-sextile- 30 degrees
In traditional Astrology, the opposition, square and trine aspects are said to be powerful and
other aspects are said to be less powerful.
Astrologers took keen interest in his discovery.
British Astrophysicist and Astronomer Dr. Percy Seymour has written 2 books on Astrology.
One of my good friends in IIT did his first job as a software developer in an astrology start up. He said there were very smart people working in that start up and the company was making very good money. Although he makes fun of astrology in person, he was getting very good salary and it is a booming industry in India.
My Zodiac sign is Leo (Lion)
But in reality - I am introvert, shy, soft spoken, peaceful person.
Idiots.
Thr are 100 thing which are needed to predict it.
In today time 90% ppl who r just here to take money.
That's my Ic. It still applies; Whether it comes to physical appearance or emotions.
Along with gender, colour of skin, you can mention caste as well, that is the most prominent and characteristic differentiation in indian society.
Do you have a p€n!$?
Caste isn't there in Astrology. Who told you this?
Back in 1991 , some days before Rajiv Gandhi was assassinated , a lot of famous astrologers were invited by the magazine "The Illustrated weekly of India" to make their predictions about his future, and without exception ALL of them predicted that he was going to become India's next prime minister. Several of them even said that Rajiv had a "raj yog" and so would remain the prime minister of India for a long time to come. None of them predicted his assassination or even a threat to his life. A few days later , Rajiv was dead and after some time had passed , some of them started to claim that they had seen a threat to his life and had warned about it. If someone can access the archives of May 1991 editions of the illulstrated weekly of India they can verify the same. I have personally read it and the magazine's then editor Kushwant Singh had pointed it out as well.
This is a great one so far Pranav! Thanks for putting so much effort in getting into this crap and showcasing in what extent Pseudoscience is being deliberately affecting us. I can suggest you to make a video on the recent AYUSH ministry that the government of India has vested upon and how their basis is mostly from Pseudoscientific fields. Keep making them! Will wait for the next one.
Thanks a lot man :) For sure. I'm thinking of a video each on A,Y,U,S,H
Astrology is science horoscope are not science please do read astrology texts
Astrology is science related to astronomy physics biology human physiology
Astrology is the study of science of stars planets
@@anuvab4451 no astronomy is the the study of stars and planets, astrology means predicting the future somehow using stars and planets, which is not possible
It’s great that you are debunking the myth and I appreciate it. But you cannot tell dumb to people who believe on Astrology. It’s someone’s belief. Once again I do appreciate for your work.
It's an stupid argument. Respect people, mothers, Dads etc, but don't respect their stupidity. What if someone's mother tells them to put cow dunk on their body to "detoxify" their skin... Would you respect this stupid. Respect the mother, not her stupidity... Dumb idea ls are dumb and people following those dumb things are stupid. My own family believes in so many of these things. Doesn't mean I don't respect or love... But I tell them when they are being stupid
We need more people like you
Dude, thank you SO MUCH! I have been trying to convince my parents that Astrology is a scam. This video will help me and people like me immensely. Thank you once again!
Being a Hindu myself.. I can say that Indians love to talk about mythology, astrology and hindutva... All thanks to the andhvishwas that has haunted this country for centuries 🥺
Funny though to believe that the planets which cannot even decide their own path are actually deciding our future
I know, right? xD
What is your date of birth
I can tell u my dob but whats the guarantee that u won't use survivor bias?
@@aktherocker I am not going to tell anything about you . i just want to know your date and month
@@dishadhouliyan5190 first rule of internet....never share your personal details.....so sorry not interested in whatever ur planning to do with it
That's some really good content Pranav. Really good work. And I was born on Dec 4th and I'm not adopted😅
Thanks man :) And congrats on not being adopted :P
Where is it mentioned that people born in Dec are adopted...? How are you attributing it to Vedic astrology?
@@scienceisdope well astrology is come to india by greek it's not even indian😂
Tu hai tere ko pata nhi hai😴😂
Believe in highest power who control the universe rather than wasting money on astrologer. Good explanation.
its a business now
BeLieVe iN hIgHeSt pOwEeE wHo cOntRol tHe UnIvErsE
Did u see the contradiction in ur comment? If u believe in the so called higher power then u r just as "superstitious" as the person who believe in astrology.
@@Sam-vz8gn sorry I can’t agree with you.
Posting videos on you tube doesn’t make you solid intelligent.
@@Sam-vz8gn BOTH R DIFERENT DMB FCK
Hello Sir!! I really liked the video you have made..... The myths and superstitions regarding astrology and business goons in the name of astrology needs to be stopped.... But a big lot of Hindi speaking people may not understand it completely .So plz do present it's Hindi version.....
It's so crazy and dumb that people are so ignorant that they believe stars and planets millions of miles away affects thier future or day to day life and actually pay money for it. It's beyond my understanding.
sir i am also an youtuber having channel named mad science duo . my ambition is to become an astronomer . i love ur videos i actually like debunking pseudoscience the 3 most common replies whenever i argue about astrology to my parents are we r ur parents we will say for ur well being, dont act over smart , and we dint question our parents like u do . they cant even understand the harm due to it. as an astonomy aspirant i feel very bad that india doest even have a single bsc in astronomy but 18 in astrology until these stupid things go off india will never become great
\
You're right. It's a very dad state that the country is in
@@scienceisdope lol dad state of the country
its sad that your videos dont hv the number of views that it deserves...its obvious that you have invested hours researching n making this video....its a direct reflection of our mindset/.... awesome work man
Good points! No matter how hard you try to explain but the belifs that are embeded in our senior generation and those that are passed from Generation to generation will take a lot of years to believe in the points that you make in this video ( btw I do agree that your points are relatively true!) I have found a person finally who thinks like me. The diff. is you are putting efforts to explain the world, I am not! Love your videos.. Keep up the good work 😊
I don't know what kind of astrology you have found. According to my experience the kundali and further *janm-patri* are made which are easily 80% true(with not general assumptions but very specific ones) at first didn't believe in it, then I actually saw *janm-patris* of my family members, and they were really really true regarding behaviour, financial conditions, lifestyle, relationships. Surprisingly each one had different things written and not just general points. That time I started believing atleast this certain part of astrology
I have found your channel just a week back. And i became obsessed with your contents. Those all are what i was looking for from my college days.
Thanks a lot man....
I really really admire you..
Keep it up🙏
Can u give me any link or any resources which conclusively prove that indian astrology came from Greek astrology
I think he is wrong as we know that Gemini astrology was created by Gemini Rishi around Mahabharata time and normal astrology was older then that. He said that he will provide material to support the statements but I think he is also doing its propoganda. I guess.
@@PankajBhandari Greek never knew zero but zero is very important in Indian astrology. I have read chanakya neeti and arthashastra and in both chanakya mentions of jyotish Vidya. A man like chanakya got knowledge of astrology from his teachers which implies that astrology knowledge was in India before Alexander invasion
@@HarshSharma-jk5hv yes that's what I said in my comment about Gemini Rishi, the inventor of Gemini astrology (more then 5000 years old knowledge). And you aslo added one more point to support that statement as well, thank you. I don't know about that 😅
Hey man, you kept your word😅. Brilliant content, but try to keep it shorter in the future (just a suggestion,I'll watch it anyway). Keep smashing superstitions...Your channel is super Dope
Hey man! Thanks a lot :) Always a man of my word :P
Wanted to experiment with a longer video and see the reception. Will try and stick to a more optimum length.
Help me reach more people by sharing :)
THIS needs more view!!! Please like the video everyone!
If Vedic astrology was borrowed from Greece then does that mean the Vedic people enhanced or complicated the existing astrological model by adding Moon positions also in the model?
Also, from where did this work come from? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brihat_Parashara_Hora_Shastra - Greece?
@@gem7624 no , Greeks and indians exchanged many ideas during the indo greek period. Not all ideas that have horoscope come from greeks. Many are indian additions , improvise etc. This one is worked in india.
@@gem7624at the end I will say ,, it's all are worst vedic astrology is totally worst
Let me tell you the future: I'm going to subscribe to your channel within a minute.
Very good prediction buddy. Hope that came true👍🏾
@@samuelthamburaj bots on a more human level.
Time of birth and place of birth matter in Indian astrology. It is a calculation.
I was very skeptical about Indian astrology. Then I discovered, from personal experience, that it is the astrologer that matters. Most Indian astrologers are accurate at telling your exact past. But Most are vague about predicting the exact future, which I agree is impossible.
My personal experience is that most astrologers are either fake or not knowledgeable. There are a couple of them (random visits to an unknown astrologers, not planned) that astounded me with not just my personal characteristics, but were accurate about my profession, what my parents do for a living, my interests, number of siblings I have etc.
I totally agree that people get fooled by astrologers, but I feel that predicting something or reading a horoscope accurately is a gift, acquired only by a select few. True astrologers don't show off and are to the point.
Astrology is mysterious and secretive.
_"True astrologers don't show off and are to the point. "_
Astrologers could rake in a hundreds of thousands or a million dollars by demonstrating in skeptics challenges that astrology works. If they don't want the money, they could donate it to children hospitals or the likes. But this is also not worth it it seems. They either don't want to demonstrate their skills in a controlled setting, or they try it and fail. Why is that? Nobody can explain in detail how astrology could work, nobody can provide good evidence that it works.
Some people are good at reading people. There are literal face readers who's job it is to do this. I think it's a tremendous skill but to attribute it to the constellations would be a collosal claim that requires an equally convincing proof. We claim things to be "mysterious" when we don't know much about it, and perhaps much isn't known bcz there isn't much to be known and this is all yet another desparate attempt of humans to find tools to solve our problems and we're filling the logical gaps with our imaginations. I think we do this as a survival instinct, it's not possible to know everything so we make up stories to make the fear of the unknown palatable.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 Only a fool will try to explain what he/she doesn't understand. I don't understand it. Some things are unexplained and mysterious. We are ordinary human beings, not enlightened ones. Logic and science is very important, I agree. But certain things science can't explain, because we haven't fully understood science either. Scientists are still mystified, despite all the laws of physics, how life is possible on earth at all. They only have theories, not concrete explanations. Of course, you are entitled to your foolish opinion.
I know this reply is a bit late but predicting someone's past can be done with certain accuracy. The way a person walks, talks, behaves and what he talks about can reveal a lot about his past to a sharp and cunning mind. Whatever these astrologers determine about someone's can always be traced back to information they gathered from you. For example, if you attempted suicide long ago but now you're talking happily to an astrologer, he won't conclude that you attempted that suicide.
@@cauliflowerhead2735 This is correct
I always knew it's all about smart psychology.
Someone told me that my husband will dominate me after marriage.
But he had no idea that I m A level manipulator 😂😂😂
Y'all come up with the most washed down excuses and laugh about it like that's a joke. Fact checks for the real manifestos please!
Nice work please make a short video on numerology, palm reading, vastu useless techniques of reading future is taking over human being confidence.
With the divorce rate in Metro cities in India well over 50 percent it's quite evident that 'horror'scopes are indeed that that.
Pranav your videos are so on point in cutting through the BS. Keep doing the good work, thank you!!!!
Kudos Pranav! you have known your audience. I like how you are concentrating on Indian version of astrology. And this is clearly beneficial as you could not have surpassed Dr. Tyson. So now even if anyone searches neutal words (neutral adjective + object) like Indian astrology you are at #2 with other debunks, except if we search vedic astrology this video is nowhere to be seen along with other debunks😔. Next time you should target that!
If we search for phrase (negative/doubt type) you are always #1!🎉🎉🎉🎊🎊
Some nice points made, but! I gotta disagree here. You know, I was just an atheist/agnostic/skeptical like you and then I got introduced to astrology. Instead of listening to what the science and logic has to say about it I decided to jump into it, learn about it, and try to see if it can predict anything about myself. Remember, all the logic, all the proof are nothing against practical experiment and results. If it's working, it is working, the Universe is not compelled to make sense to you. And no points for guessing, it actually worked for me. After learning to read the chart properly I found out that it can actually predict many things about my personality. And NO! They were not barnum statements, I know cause I was aware of them before I dove into astrology. I hope you will agree that "You will be a good singer" "You will be an atheist/skeptic" are not barnum statements. Now, you must be thinking that oh, he doesnt seem to be an atheist. Well, astrology predicted that as well, my kundali said that I will change my opinions about God/Spiritualism frequently. Which I do....
Also, predicting the future is very hard and only expert astrologers can do it. If doctors fail to save a patient do you say that oh! the medical science doesnt work! NO! You don't say that you say that maybe doctor wasnt good enough or the case was very hard. In the same manner, sometimes astrologers do make wrong predictions but they are not always wrong. For example, when I started digging into astrology my mom told me that once she went to an astrologer and the first thing he said after looking at my dad's kundali was - "DID U BUY ANY PROPERTY IN 2004?" I was shocked because it did actually happen.... She also told me that he predicted a child's death correctly (gave the exact date). Please consider these points and tell me what do you think...
Trust me, I want astrology to be proven wrong more than anyone else in this world, because it challenges my atheism. But it just keeps on proving that it has got some substance...
EDIT: I also, asked one of my friend to give me his dob, time, and place (remember time of birth is very important) and I tried to predict something about him from my limited knowledge of astrology. The first thing I said about him was "You don't have good relations with your dad" (funny thing is I was afraid of getting ridiculed coz I always thought that he had good relations with his father) but to my surprise he agreed and said you are right me and my dad always fight, argue about something and our view points dont match....
Thanks man for the comment :) I love to be a part of civil disagreements like this because it promotes discourse. And hearing contrasting points of view helps you not fall prey to confirmation bias.
My rebuttal: I would say predictions like "you will be a good singer" or "you'll keep changing your opinions about God" are too general and apply to too many people. For instance, the latter applies to me because there was a period when I kept shuttling back and forth on my position on God. The same goes for "you don't have good relations with your dad". It's way too general. Don't most people our generation have disagreements/fights with parents?
The predictions you mentioned about buying property in 2004 and predicting the date of someone's death sound like very specific predictions. Even I've heard several predictions like these(and miracles in alternative medicine). But they're always second hand. Just like how you mentioned that it was your mother that told you this. There are many small details that are lost when information transfers hands. So I wouldn't jump to the conclusion that astrology works just because of this. I won't jump to the conclusion the predictions are wrong either, but we can both agree that we should examine this further before drawing conclusions.
@@scienceisdope yes i would advise you to learn reading charts and give it a try on yourself :)
about the points that you have made, trust me i have taken care of all these logical fallacies that a common man commits, as i said i was an atheist and i have ridiculed astrologers in the past, it even cost me friendship with some people. So you can understand what kind of atheist i was. But just because I like science and logic, I can't deny the truth that is in front of me, no matter how unscientific it sounds.
Also, about my mom, she is a skeptic herself she doesnt worship any god or believe in any kind of ancient rituals and shit. so i can believe in the info i got from her.
@@easytutorials6412 Hello Rahul. I hope you are doing well. Brother I would disagree with your point of view because of few reasons. You started by saying that instead of listening towhat science and logic had to say you jumped into it and so on. Bro, if you have already discarded logic then wouldn't that expose you to being a victim of confirmation bias? You will not be able to evaluate things properly. More or less that's how even faith in religion works, i.e. without logic. And please once again remember correlation does not imply causation.
Now, if I make a random prediction of someone's death tomorrow and if it comes true, would I be accurate all the time? And will that mean that my prediction had a logical reasoning behind it? Well, my answer is no.
And one more important thing to consider is that no one has explained is that how does planets and stars affect us. They fail to give the reason behind it, all they do is give statements like it will have positive or negative impact on us. And the most surprising thing is that those effects can be changed after a small Pooja or ceremony (and some cash and clothes for Pandits).
Now allow me to make 2 statements. 1) I have constant disagreements with my wife all the time and we argue a lot. 2)I love my wife a lot and is willing to anything and everything for her. Now they may sound contradictory. But both are 100% accurate. First statement is true for me and it could also be true for person going through a divorce.
I hope I have explained my point. I don't expect you to agree with it though. Regardless, have a wonderful day.
@@canutraceme You've responded better and more eloquently than I ever could. Thanks a lot :)
@@scienceisdope thanks bro. You are an inspiration.
You are literally a life saver Pranav !! Thanks for these debunking stuff 🥳
I was laughing hard through out the video. I didn't actually know that there is a 13th zodiac too, apparently my brother falls into that house, I will break that to him now🤣🤣🤣. Also the ending song was dope!!
There isn't
@@TanyaWins007 Notice how all of these comments seem to be unserious? Watch the party die in silence.
I got a kundli made for me and its hilarious how events mentioned were completely different from my life till now well most of that were general things that happens to almost everyone.
Astronomy is do difficult to get the thing which is written in my kundli is 60 percent accurate
@@randomindianboy-wb9eq That's Astrology not astronomy
Astronomy is something like researching about Space or Planets, that's Astronomy.
@@megarobot6921 sorry 😞
You don't have much knowledge about Sidereal/Vedic astrology. Your horoscope can change! It's depends totally on you. To change your bad horoscope all you gotta need to do is do good karma and meditate. Cause meditation helps you to control your reactions to emotions so bad planets cannot harm you. Even astrologers say this. So, do not worry about your bad horoscope. Your life is in your hands. You get what you do 😀
That awkward moment you realize that your life has been a lie. Hey Pranav, how about a video on high rates of existential crises among Millenials?
Check out healthygamergg, he has great information. There's a video on why mental health issues are rising.
True. Everyone life is a lie. What they believe is not what they are rather the cosmos itself. Imagine yourself without the earth, sun, and the mighty cosmos.
This guy is doing best thing on internet
well said
So do you want to say that before Alexander arrived india there was no vedic astrology ?? It's a very big claim. If you say it.
Lol i had one girl in my hostel who always asked me to read and explain her Libra horoscope tips, she said it was very accurate and helpful. After a few months she asked again and I started by pointing at the print for Libra, she said that was not her horoscope, she found out her zodiac was different.
😂
I feel like a lot of you people on youtube lie for attention. (edit: Thanks for the likes) type shit.
@@TeeKeeps answering a reply on my post from two years ago, not fake, we are refugees living in another country, many children were sent to schools without proper documents, some having wrong date of births and even wrong names. The girl I was talking to was a refugee from our former country, she found out her date of birth was not as it was written in the documents. That’s why she said her zodiac was wrong
I appreciate ur efforts for debunking Indian psuedoscience practices,but I would like express my disagreement on indian astrology coming from Greece.The reason being some ancient scriptures like Ramayan and Mahabharat (just to name a few)gave the celestial positions for various events.It would be very nice of you to enlighten me on this.Nice and Informative video btw🤗🤗
The tenets of vedic astrology and rashis migrated to india from greece. But there has been a tradition of nakshatras which were mentioned in ramayana and mahabharata. I've added this as a clarification to my video description. Thank you :) subscribe and share if you find my content useful bro
Ohh ok thanks
@@scienceisdope plz get your facts right before preaching it to someone else...
Yavana jaataka is one of the many treatise on Vedic astrology which is attributed to the Greeks... There exists works which are much older than this...
@@fact5832 provide valid sources and research papers to prove your point then instead of acting like a holier-than-thou beacon of truth.
Jyotish is the light of the Vedas. Jyotish is subjective. Jyotish deals with consciousness. It is not a material stuff. Every planet and Nakshatras affects human and all the life on earth every which way. Even stupids know moon affects water and human body is 70 % water. Jyotish do not come to everyone. Its blessing for those who saw the jyotish . Fake astrologers existed it doesn't mean that jyotish is untrue. Jyotish embedded in advanced quantum physics. Jyotish deals with karma and past life tendencies. Planets and Nakshatras are conscious. Everything in universe has its own state of consciousness. Jyotish is beyond the brain of ordinary. Never discuss a subject which you are not familiar with. Never defame jyotish when you don't know anything about it.
Finally someone who is brave enough to call out this BS
11:36 swami vivekanand also mentioned in a book that Greek people taught astrology to Indians and Indians taught Greek astronomy.
🤣🤣🤣u like west history more
@@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 bruh do you even hear yourself?!
Astrology is never false , Astrologer maybe false .
It's false , because God never tell that you will predict the future ,,, believe in karma not in astrology
@@radheo-qb2uc are you the manager of god?
Thank you.
@@chiggywiggy524 right lol. nice try tho. Karma is real... Astrology too.
@@radheo-qb2uc Numerology
This is a spectacular video! Please also make a video on how to explain this to people who are neck deep in astrology. They actually believe Venus is the reason why they'll get stuck in traffic
Great Job bro .... clickastro ad showed up while watching this video .... youtube algorithms are being naughty I guess !
An astrologer told me I will have 3 wife , I am in my 20s and not even have a girlfriend 😭
Rahu in 7th house? 😂
L joke. If this is real, They're slow.
I'm not an atheist , I do worship God, but I don't believe in astrology, yet people think I'm an atheist . Associating a pseudoscience with religion is a wrong thing .
Ok this video has so many factual and conceptual errors.
1. Birth Rashi is not the transit of Sun, it is the transit of Moon in Vedic astrology.
2. Vedic astrologers do take procession of equinoxes into account. It is called Aynamsha. There's a controversy as to what is the exact value of Aynamsha. But overall they agree withan approx value.
3. The claim that India took zodics from Western astrology is not a settled debate. There are out of India theories where it is conjectured that zodiac was taken from India by the Westerners. Or may be there is a third source. This is because the theory that Zodiacs came to India during Alexander(approx 350BC) is inconsistent with mention of Zodiacs in Hindu epics like Ramayana and Mahabharata which are dated atleast before 500BC. But various dates from 700 to 1800 BC are proposed, by Western historians themselves. So this proves that Indians were aware of Zodiacs before the arrival of Alexander.
4. There are only 12 zodiacs along the ecliptic. Not any more. The number twelve is not a random number picked.
There are 27 Nakshatras because moon takes approx 27 days to revolve once. It stays in one Nakshatra for one day approx. There are 30 days in Month because that's the frequency at which Full Moon occurs. There are 12 months because there are approx 12 full moons in one year. So the idea is a zodiac is unit where the Sun stays for one month. Its backward working. Once in a while for error correction we have Adhika Masa, something like leap year, that's when we have 13 months. But on a regular year there are 12 months. So 12 zodiacs are arrived from this, as far as I know.
5. Moreover the idea that correlation is not causation, is half true.
Undisputed correlation means the two incidents are in the same family of causal links.
Disputed correlation is not causation.
Undisputed bijunctive correlation is causation.
6. "Indian astrologers don't give an explaination as to how planets influence you" This is not completely true as they do give a supernatural explaination, which ofcourse you would not agree with. But they do make an attempt to explain how it all works. The claim that they don't give any explanation regarding the mechanism of Astrology is technically wrong.
Bro hoping you'll reach 5 mil soon. I believe it's possible. Keep the faith.
The thing you told about 12 constilations 👌 eye opener. Thanks Pranav.
Nicely researched video man. Btw, make that music as your permanent intro or outro. Boy that tune is catchy!😆😆
Haha true. Thanks man :)
Once an astrologer gave me a ring and asked me to wear it...he said if I wear it then probably in the next 3 years one big event will happen in my life ...after 3 years
He passed away 😅😅😅😅
Stop saying they passed away... I'm gonna start being racist or stereotypical against y'all. Real scammers & unserious with y'all spirituality fr... The United States might just hold some real powers over y'all; Sooner or later, I'm not even joking.
Astrology is real... Y'all just have some real faulty false prophets.
If any spiritual sciences in history are not real at all, why do they transform and work for some ppl. I know of ppl that healed their entire health with Ayurveda. And this is a genuine honest question as a young person that is confused about life and it on a journey trying to understanding things. I always loved both science and spirituality and dont jusge either side. I am a very receptive person and just like to learn, so im looking for a real genuine response. Thanks in advance
Well it's not that ayurveda doesn't work at all, it's just not scientifically accurate. Like there can be things that are wrong but still work as an example take the case of wheather things float or sink in water, we were told in childhood that it depends on the density of the object, but later we come to know that it's because of Archimedes Principle.
Now as Ayurveda is a quite old concept, it is bound to have some things that work and others that don't. It has some geniune lifestyle advices which can help you, but as it's basic premise is wrong, it would be very hard to identify good advices.
Well honestly I too was confused like u but I do believe aryuveda and astrology both now it's more about experiences I have personally felt astrology in a big way and I have seen my mom recover from health by aryuveda now like always aryuveda is not all good some things are shady and shirty but that does not cancle all the aryuveda being wrong . As far as astrologer I had met a good astrologer and his predicuisn were on point not only past but future lol and I have seen astrology work at other times too so I personally believe but chances are u will find a bad astrologer and would never believe in It which actually is fine it's totally ok it's life and u have your own experiences
I am 20yold btw 💀
idk u will read this comment or not , I just wanna say when I meet my astrologer I was full of confidence that it's all rubbish. But when he started to say all my past things on point and my current problems without even telling him anything. Then I knew that there is something which we don't know about astrology. I was also making a lot of fun of astrologers , but when I meet that 1 guy that gave me an idea that there's something which we still don't know
The thing you are worrying today gonna take sometime to go from your life
but what happened to the challenge given by the astrophysicst in the starting of the video ??
i am assuming the astrologers backed out or predicted wrong or maybe predicted right after stalking their social media accounts.
They predicted with accuracy of 42.5%, coin toss gives better accuracy by 7.5%🤣🤣🤣 (he mentioned it later in the video)
@@AnalystSarvesh lmao 😂
27:05 my new ringtone😀
Check out his music bro. I've shared the link. There's one killer song called "Azhagu"
Mine too....Brilliant ROFL
Great video!! Would you consider doing a similar video on palmistry? Keep up the great work.
No one knows what's going to happen in future/time.
We know we are doomed when a science student starts believing in shits like this and I know a lot of people like this
Having maanglish dosha in kundali, effects so many people’s prospects of marriage. This is also an example of harm caused by following pseudo-science.
Just wanted to ask that can't it be the other way round that Greek Astrology was inspired from Vedic Astrology ??
No
@@achyuththouta6957 Care to give a proper reasoning?
Questioning is very important in Hinduism.....
But to know the answers you need to search for right people ....
Yea why caste system, untouchability and dev dasi system?
Unfortunately people seem to be reaching just for the wrong people for answers - scam gurus, astrologers.
@@kamartaj3010 bro caste system is not only limited to Hinduism.
@@kamartaj3010 even constitution has caste system, only difference is its named group a, group b, group c, groud d workers
@@ashwanichandola7899 which other religions have casteism, untouchability
Found your channel by chance. Someone recommended me Autobiography of Yogi,I started reading it and I was wondering how the hell people believe this shit. Then I started searching "paramhansa fraud" sadhuguru fraud and I came to your channel😜.
It looks my confirmation bias and Google's algorithm says Science is dope.
same man..!! did you read that After death wala part?.. all the planets and shit like that??.. his so called guru materialized in front of him in Taj Hotel room.. damn that shit is so funny..
Brilliant....was here and was waitting for u to talk about this as its very famous in subcontinent
A bit of advice. Pls increase the video speed to atleast 1.25x cause it's really slow. I know I can do it as well but if I forward it to someone who doesn't really know how to do that, it doesn't really feel very impactful cuz it feels like you're talking a bit slow
Great quality of video boss, had to subscribe
Thanks a lot man :) Help me reach more people too by sharing :)
bro just wanted to confirm how did u come to the conclusion that vedic astrology actually migrated from greece to india and not india to greece and how sure are u about the origin dates of indian astrology.
Because Vedas don't have astrology
@@shubhamayush7232 you sure about that?
@@shubhamayush7232 nope, jyotidh is part of vedang, and rituals and all are done according to jyotish
After watching your videos I left the idea of god altogether. The video on sadhguru and sri sri were dope. Man u opened my mind totally. Now i have become agnostic, also still trying to find what is all this about life. Now i will leave this astrology fraud for sure. Also make more videos thumbs up to you 😊❤️
Your horoscope holds the key to unlocking a world of possibilities. Let the cosmic energy inspire you to reach new heights! 🚀💖
Uff, this channel is so underrated!
oh man, this is awesome content. Please keep doing it. I couldn't convince my parents that astrology is BS but now I have few more points to persuade. thanks
Lol .. Which points..?
Could you enlighten us with those points...?
Coz this video is filled with base less lies...
@@fact5832 wtf can you point out the flaws
@@AbhinavKumar-ov3xfI have already done it long back.. Just copy pasting the same for your convenience... Next time educate yourself instead of applauding an idiot...
" The title you have mentioned Vedic astrology but where is the definition of Graha as per it .? You just laugh out telling the Greek definition..? just because it supports your cause..?
Your Rashi is where your sun is placed..?? Lol... You don't even know Rashi is the sign where your moon is placed and you are making video on Jyotisha..?
@11:14 You said the name simha Rashi is because it looks like a lion in the sky and laughed at it... But where is it even mentioned in Vedic astrology...? So you were basically laughing at your own lies...
Vedic astrology came with Alexander..!!! Seriously..? Heard about 18 rishis who compiled jyotishya..? No you haven't... Coz you know nothing...
Some one has rightly said...
fools always finds other fools who admire/follow them... You just have found a bunch of them . Good luck to you .."
@@fact5832 I do not know why you have to resort to personal attacks to support your argument. If you believe that Vedic astrology is accurate, please first provide me a mathematical proof explaining that future is pre determined.