@@Raptor069 In order to extend friendship with other country, Governments hold partnerships to teach their language to those who are interested. They also give scholorships and incentives to them.
@@rupammalakar3911 First : Neither he nor his government can do anything about it. Students decide what foreign language they want to learn, based on how valuable it will be in their future career. If schools are not teaching Russian language, it means there is little to no enrollment for that language - which also means students don't see Russian language as valuable as say French or German. Second: It is not his or his government's job to promote Russian language in India. That is the job of Russian government. They have to either setup their own institutions in India to teach Russian language or tie up with some private institutes to promote Russian language. This how French, German and Chinese govt. promote their language. Russian govt. also has to be more involved by initiating various cultural events to familiarize Indians with Russian language, culture and opportunities presented by Russia.
Having accepted the drawback without getting offended, loved it how he said at the end , used Sanskrit as a reference to learn Russian. It's a skill to be able to talk and answer like this .
@@Brottasalna-ny9vg if you know sanskrit you can easily understand many of Indian languages.. like Telugu , kannada , odiya , bangali , Marathi , Hindi ..
Russian has indeed reduced drastically but there’s been an increase in teaching of Western European languages like French, Italian and German. I’m a German language elective in high school myself. Cleared the Language test up to B2 level.
Learning western European languages makes sense, but Indians are completely ignoring Chinese. It may not be an easy language but could be very useful in the future or even at present. Indians obviously are only interested in languages that could help them earn a job in Europe. a
@@icouldntthinkofabettername... Google translate is 100% correct, unless you wrote it wrong. Even if it is 90% or 80% correct it will still do. Simply say " He and I wrote in English because it is worthless to write in Sanskrit language"
I would never learned it if I weren't Russian, it seems so hard comparing to English. Well, people from neighboring countries stll learn Russian. But I guess its popularity yet decreased. Generally I don't even see how someone would need other language but English for their career. And probably Spanish for traveling) I am somehow sure that south America is chipper than Europe, and it has beautiful nature too
@@skyloh258 Leadership should be about skills and abilities, not judging someone based on their past job but you liberandus just consider that british education system as a green chit to be PM and even that education system that teaches about being slave and a servant not teaches about leadership and skills that matter to lead a country.... and also a chaiwala will understand ground reality better than a italy walaa....
I'm excited to learn third language probably tamil or Sanskrit (okay guys don't start Tamil vs Sanskrit appreciate both languages both of them are beautiful❤️)
I will advise u to learn Sanskrit bcoz it is an ancient language from where various languages originated in India. I choose Sanskrit in class 10 as optional language but by learning this language u will know the true meaning of life and I also got more humble and moral by understanding this language ❤ Edit: For ur kind information Sanskrit is complex like maths, so cheap and low minded people can't never understand 😂....it is called "mother of all languages " for a reason bcoz of it's grammar and those who call "Tamil aka Ella pode "🤣 is older language than Sanskrit then u have to study hard history subject bcoz Sanskrit is complex language which low minded people can't understand so uneducated people started creating many languages from Sanskrit so people understand 😂
It's probably a good choice since many countries of middle Asia have carriers of Russian language, some west Europe countries as well. I would also consider Spanish cause I wanna visit south America some day)
See that's the reason why I like him... He accept the issues and mistakes and at the same time he have discussions and talk with people... Many of our politicians need to be like him.. Its high time now man... We need RAW AND REAL MAN KI BAAT from MrPM❤... You know I love him
Dr. APJ Kalam was a pioneer and brilliant mind. But this man is just a diplomat and his job is to smooth talk his way out of anything. Don't compare a scientist and elite mind to your average Joe.
@@RyanChristopher777 professions are different. But the spirit isn't. The problem with your reasoning is that you put scientist above diplomat as an universal truth. Both are different and difficult
@@kumarraj197 I merely asked not to compare the stature of Dr. Kalam to a diplomat. Don't belittle a genius mind. And yes Dr. Kalam is above every single diplomat out there in the world. You must learn about his achievements first and then tell me the achievements of your 'intelligent' diplomat.
Jaishankar is an amazing diplomat. Look how he subtly pointed out that learning Sanskrit opened the doors to learning an otherwise very different language, like Russian. Ie. People should be learning Sanskrit apart from their mother tongue which will help them learn other languages & I completely agree 👏🏼
Well I Am blessed studying in Bengali Medium schools, I learnt Sanskrit in 7th and 8th std and thats how I also know to write and read and speak Hindi very fluently since then... As an Indian We should be fluent in our widespoken Native Language Hindi first I believe along with the mother tongue most importantly and English🇮🇳
I am not Indian, but Russian is kinda of popular among Russian neighbours, like middle Asia or west Europe. So I didn't get how Sanskrit and Russian are related.
I mean it's a little easier since Hindi/English is masculine/feminine only and then what verb form gonna come will get little easier if u know Sanskrit
@@chaitanyakulkarni6416 dude I know 7 myself. English,kannada,punjabi,hindi,Tamil,telugu,hariyanvi. My problem is learning them in school,where it is more like tests and headaches rather than actually learning the language
Russia doesn't provide job opportunities unlike west and Middle east. Only Indian students go for medical Colleges.so Russian language is of not much importance in Bharat.
You are right. Also there are more Indian students in many 3rd world countries including countries around russia such as Georgia than Indian students in russia. I wonder why?
@@francoislechanceux5818 I heard medical education is some what standard in Armenia than Georgia, Russia and Ukraine. But Russia has also lot of Indian students studying.
@@gip6064 My English is not totally perfect. What I was saying is that ALL the number of Indian students in russia whatever their fields of studies is lower in number than Indian students in many 3rd world countries including those bordering russia. Given the kremlin sponsored fake hype online about the supposed greatness of India-russia relation, russia should be among the 3 top nations in the world with Indian students. But it's not even in the first top 20. Lol.
Kinda. But the Russian grammer isn't organised like hindi Or sankrit. It's more like english especially with the curilloc script. Word formations and placements are kinda similar tho
BJP is relatively good for the country, but when they push hindi onto the people by throwing out existing foreign languages already being learnt, it makes one wonder what the hell it is that they're trying to do
Are you a college graduate in humanities? If yes then I think you know the reason but if not then just imagine people from San Francisco communicating with people from California in Spanish (despite English being their mother tongue)🙂
@@Gyaan_with_PKbad analogy for many reasons. 1. India is not America or cannot be compared with even European nations as we have so many Indian languages of our own. 2. Why would Californians use Spanish to communicate with other Californians? But they do learn Spanish cause it helps them relate and connect with Spanish speaking people who are common in America. 3. Hindi isn't India's mother tongue, we have plenty, you see where I'm going with this? 4. The whole world uses English to communicate globally, as result of being English colonies at some point, not because they don't respect their own language or culture.
@@dudee08 for sure you're right in many ways... But it's today's reality which you're talking... I have different point of view sir. lemme tell you few of them and you can have your opinion accordingly... I'm fine with that. 1. After every 200-300 yrs the world order changes drastically be it economic order or cultural order. earlier Sanskrit was prominent in Middle East and Indian subcontinent... And Greek in Europe... And Latin in America... now English is there and after the end of this century with 200cr population even Indians can have their cultural impact on globe again if things go right. For this we should have everything which is our own otherwise the English dominance can't be challenged. 2. You talked about global employment opportunities which comes with English... You're right... We are learning English too but what if we could create a world employment order which revolves around India then A common language which should be solely ours will be required. 3. More than 52% population know how to read 'or' write 'or' speak in Hindi in India so it is easy to make it a common language for us despite Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Punjabi, Odia, Bengali or any other scheduled language. 4. Using Hindi doesn't mean not using scheduled languages just like I'm typing in English and still I know Bhojpuri, Punjabi and Telugu. And yes... I may sound over optimistic but it's a right time to give it a shot because we are here to do something good for future generations. It may not yield desired result but atleast few political regimes should go with it... Otherwise we will forever be in past glory and will never be able to attain success in future as a civilization.
@@Gyaan_with_PK I agree with almost everything you said. I just want to say that pushing Hindi as a primary language in a way(like making it our national language etc) will only kill other dying languages of our country. We as a country need to start valuing Hindi. As you said in terms of employment, in terms of improving hindi education, paying hindi teachers and professors more, buying and reading more Hindi literature. This has to be done by the people and supported by the govt. But the govt does not talk about how it will achieve this, it only talks about pushing Hindi as if Hindi is dying and so is our culture (as if that is the only culture India has). If 52% of India speaks Hindi then surely that isn't the language in danger. Pushing Hindi as a primary language just because more people use it serves only a certain political and social agenda. The govt cannot ask Indians to be atmanirbhar and become entrepreneurs while not providing enough funds to the education sector and say Hindi isn't valued. My mother teaches Hindi in a Hindi medium school, we both know what the state of the schools are in our country. So is the case with urdu and Bangla schools as well. I assume south Indians and north easterns face a similar problem. So what do you do? Politicising saving Hindi as a solution to saving our culture is an easy answer to a difficult problem. That is my opinion.
Exactly, people here don't realise how many employment and business opportunities Indians are missing out on which other low income countries and their citizens are cashing out. Because of aging population there is a lot of demand for good skillful employees in europe, latin america and Japan especially in healthcare, hospitality, manufacturing, services sector which gets blocked because of language skills. There should be atleast an option to learn one extra foreign language specifically Spanish, Japanese, French, Russian, Arabic. Ex: You learn spanish and it becomes magnitude easier for you to work in Spain, mexico, developing latin american countries etc. You learn French and along with france you can access an entire list of growing African economies. And the most imp is Japan, probably most human resource starved with aging population, they are even offering full scholarships in order to attract potential students. And please don't think of it as Brain drain or some other ridiculous idea, people can go there explore cultures, learn new things, make money and come back and contribute here as well.
Our Training of Foriegn Language is not growing at that pace is actually wrong. Our Training for Foriegn Language is growing at an insane pace that it is even outpaced indian language growth and now Government is looking to cut it down.
A good citizen, is someone who criticizes it's country when it's wrong, supports it's country with all his strength. Never praises the country, but always looks forward to the future. Like a dad to his child. I think the people online, who contiously think and talk about what we have already done, and are overly proud of the country's achievements, can never be a real part of that achievement, they can never actually contribute to the country's greatness
Respected Foreign Minister has cleared the situation.I had studied long back in Moscow, U.S.S.R. for Mining Engineering during 1968 to1973. in Russian Language.Even the the Final degree was passed in Russian Language.For Indians it is easiest to learn Russian language which is from INDO--SLOVAK group.There are so many synonyms Sanskrit words and grammar.
lower middle, middle and another from upper middle class students are still learning Sanskrit. ab hoga Bhikshit Bharat 🪔 we are so proud of your presence among us Finally Missing Cheetah is our hero and resembles more like our late Homie Baba in some corner of our heart 🇮🇳🪔 vikshit BHARAT hoga, Bahadur beta big beti hi Jeetega
In my college sanakrit language option was cancelled as the teachervretired but when wevasked for the teacher they told there were not sufficient funds.
I learnt German in my school. For real! For 4 years I was learning German in my school. As a IIIrd language after Hindi and English. Most of Indian schools will teach one regional language, then Hindi, then English. But since I am from Delhi so I learnt only Hindi, English and German. Russian should also be taught as in post soviet countries Russian is still used. They are trying to use their own language instead of Russian but Russia is pressuring them so that Russian is prelevant there.
Very awkwardly he had to accept. He must proudly and openly acknowledge that ... Gone are those days where our kids were given exposure to other languages. Now the education here will teach kids to go back and dig in the past.
It's a drawback, we should introduce languages of our foreign language and our allies should do it too. Bdw love the way he accepted the drawback of our country.
Sanskrit and Hindi came handy i was trying to learn Japanese. English was not very close to Japanese. Good to know Sanskrit grammar helped him to learn Russian language. ✔️
Spoken Sanskrit from class 2 across the nation. Fun classes. No exams. In 15 years every child from Guwahati to Chennai will be able to connect. Mother tongue, Sanskrit (national language), English (foreign language).
My daughter has been learning SPANISH since she eas in 4th till 10th .. there was a choice between Spanish and French Now they added German and Spanish making choice between 4 languages After 10th its their choice to continue as 6th subject
I think this gives the cue to create a platform to teach foreign languages along the other job skills, to help new generation to migrate to other nations and find jobs. other wise job scarcity is going to grow more and more...
@ 0.34sec, He said that, his children were taught Russian. This is actually a good thing about that government and in a way he admit that old government had better education policies than current ruling govt. 😊
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 63 | คู่เอก "ยอดภูผา vs โซเนอร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RGVmBsegKEI/mqdefault.jpg)
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.75[1/2] ชวนแร็ปเปอร์เที่ยวประแสแบบไม่ต้องตามกระแส](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/J5ds2AxDp24/mqdefault.jpg)
This is what is accepting the drawback and trying to correct it at the same time. This is how a diplomat should be
Diplomat plays no role in deciding what will be taught in Education system.
How can he correct it?
@@Raptor069he can't correct it but he is our countries representative there... He excepts the problem the gov will correct it
@@rupammalakar3911 but there is no problem
@@Raptor069 In order to extend friendship with other country, Governments hold partnerships to teach their language to those who are interested. They also give scholorships and incentives to them.
@@rupammalakar3911 First : Neither he nor his government can do anything about it. Students decide what foreign language they want to learn, based on how valuable it will be in their future career. If schools are not teaching Russian language, it means there is little to no enrollment for that language - which also means students don't see Russian language as valuable as say French or German.
Second: It is not his or his government's job to promote Russian language in India. That is the job of Russian government. They have to either setup their own institutions in India to teach Russian language or tie up with some private institutes to promote Russian language. This how French, German and Chinese govt. promote their language.
Russian govt. also has to be more involved by initiating various cultural events to familiarize Indians with Russian language, culture and opportunities presented by Russia.
See the level of diplomacy...how unnoticeably he added sanskrit reference....
He is a legend
That may be the case, but it's actually true. Proto Indian languages - you may want to Google this term
@@8debayanbhattacharyaproto-indo-european languages maybe you are talking about
Everything he speaks is Termed great by his bhakts
Sheer Diplomacy: Answer everything and even push Sanskrit, but never answer the main question.
Having accepted the drawback without getting offended, loved it how he said at the end , used Sanskrit as a reference to learn Russian. It's a skill to be able to talk and answer like this .
He is the IFS first before joining the ministry. These are results of years of training 😊
Unfortunately Sanskrit is ded language 😂😂😂
@@Brottasalna-ny9vg Pakistan Kaboom
Can You please 🙏 Explain it to
1. Pappu
2. Mamta Ben
3. Tontichor
4. Natwarlal
THANKS 🙏
@@Brottasalna-ny9vg if you know sanskrit you can easily understand many of Indian languages.. like Telugu , kannada , odiya , bangali , Marathi , Hindi ..
As a student myself
I can tell you the more you learn RUSSIAN the more it'll sounds like HINDI to yourself
Wait what
cyka
@@c4lmchorsuka...not syka😅
@@hehehe4206 it's pronounced and written "suka" in English, but in russian it's сука
@@c4lmchor ohh...idk that one...i've seen that word in Hollywood movies ...
Russian has indeed reduced drastically but there’s been an increase in teaching of Western European languages like French, Italian and German. I’m a German language elective in high school myself. Cleared the Language test up to B2 level.
There's actually no b2 level in German, that's for english and ielts
@@thecreator9913 I think you are mistaken buddy. There is a B2 level, as prescribed by Goethe.
There is B2 level bro.@@thecreator9913
Learning western European languages makes sense, but Indians are completely ignoring Chinese. It may not be an easy language but could be very useful in the future or even at present. Indians obviously are only interested in languages that could help them earn a job in Europe. a
Which exam you gave for German? I'm pursuing undergraduate and currently at A1 level of German. I have yet to learn past tense tho@@satwikskatti
Even Sanskrit is not taught with sheer enthusiasm in many schools. Before promoting foreign languages we should strengthen our own roots.
Nah stick on to English
Ye baat aapko Hindi me likhni chahiye
Then type your message in Sanskrit.
@@icouldntthinkofabettername... nice try bro, but there is a Google Translation option so whatever you type, he can see that in English
@@icouldntthinkofabettername... Google translate is 100% correct, unless you wrote it wrong.
Even if it is 90% or 80% correct it will still do.
Simply say " He and I wrote in English because it is worthless to write in Sanskrit language"
True that. I used sanskrit grammar as a point of reference to learn Russian Grammar. Russian is a beautiful language to learn.
I would never learned it if I weren't Russian, it seems so hard comparing to English. Well, people from neighboring countries stll learn Russian. But I guess its popularity yet decreased. Generally I don't even see how someone would need other language but English for their career. And probably Spanish for traveling) I am somehow sure that south America is chipper than Europe, and it has beautiful nature too
@@firstandlast4435For Hindi and Sanskrit speaking guys it's very easy
Mother of all languages 🙏🕉️
@@firstandlast4435 i started learning out of curiosity. Didn't expect to love the language, try living in Moscow, and make life long friends!
Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, one of the distinguished diplomat 🇮🇳.
Not to offend anyone but mere to smajh hi nahi aata bhai yeh bolna kya chahte hai 😂
Sasta Nasha karkai athe hai jub illiterate log comments pass karte hai
I can literally imagine him as our PM one day. I hope this comes true
Unfortunately it’s only reserved for chaiwalas
he's not a politician, so he will not become our pm
@@skyloh258 Leadership should be about skills and abilities, not judging someone based on their past job but you liberandus just consider that british education system as a green chit to be PM and even that education system that teaches about being slave and a servant not teaches about leadership and skills that matter to lead a country....
and also a chaiwala will understand ground reality better than a italy walaa....
@@Levi_saturo69 who said I am liberal?
@@Levi_saturo69 educated people are far more better leaders than illiterate and uneducated ones
I love how he added sanskrit as reference....
We need more people like him Jai shankar sir
sensible gentleman 👏 👍
I'm excited to learn third language probably tamil or Sanskrit
(okay guys don't start Tamil vs Sanskrit appreciate both languages both of them are beautiful❤️)
I will advise u to learn Sanskrit bcoz it is an ancient language from where various languages originated in India. I choose Sanskrit in class 10 as optional language but by learning this language u will know the true meaning of life and I also got more humble and moral by understanding this language ❤
Edit: For ur kind information Sanskrit is complex like maths, so cheap and low minded people can't never understand 😂....it is called "mother of all languages " for a reason bcoz of it's grammar and those who call "Tamil aka Ella pode "🤣 is older language than Sanskrit then u have to study hard history subject bcoz Sanskrit is complex language which low minded people can't understand so uneducated people started creating many languages from Sanskrit so people understand 😂
@@ashutoshsingh72476 noted📝. Thanks for the advice
@@ashutoshsingh72476why not Tamil 😮😊
@ashutoshkumarsingh7244 tamil is older than sanskrit also many indian languages came from tamil
Tamil is older than Sanskrit!
Very good point i too want to learn Russian language.
It's probably a good choice since many countries of middle Asia have carriers of Russian language, some west Europe countries as well. I would also consider Spanish cause I wanna visit south America some day)
See that's the reason why I like him... He accept the issues and mistakes and at the same time he have discussions and talk with people... Many of our politicians need to be like him.. Its high time now man... We need RAW AND REAL MAN KI BAAT from MrPM❤... You know I love him
Are there any questions on any topic that this man can't answer?
After APJ Kalam sir we have this man in the country that Youth gets inspiration
Dr. APJ Kalam was a pioneer and brilliant mind. But this man is just a diplomat and his job is to smooth talk his way out of anything. Don't compare a scientist and elite mind to your average Joe.
@@RyanChristopher777 professions are different. But the spirit isn't. The problem with your reasoning is that you put scientist above diplomat as an universal truth. Both are different and difficult
@@kumarraj197 I merely asked not to compare the stature of Dr. Kalam to a diplomat. Don't belittle a genius mind. And yes Dr. Kalam is above every single diplomat out there in the world. You must learn about his achievements first and then tell me the achievements of your 'intelligent' diplomat.
Ghanta
I still loved the time where all the humanity simultaneously used to speak OOGA BOOGA DOOGA
Same here😂😂😂
Same here
I read this also in mamamta bannerjee hamba bamba khambha tone 😂😂
@@shouryadronapratapsingtawa4536😂😂😂
😂😂😂
he's so honest. someone else might have defended it.
He is right 👍🏻 We have to learn our India language more ❤
Man He have every quality Our PM should have 😌
Girlfriend: You don't call me anymore 😢.
Boy: Agree. My social interactions should be better 😂😂😂
😅😅😅
😂😂
1. Make a point
2. Accepting drawbacks
3. Stating reasons
This articulation is a learning in itself!
Jaishankar is an amazing diplomat. Look how he subtly pointed out that learning Sanskrit opened the doors to learning an otherwise very different language, like Russian. Ie. People should be learning Sanskrit apart from their mother tongue which will help them learn other languages & I completely agree 👏🏼
Well I Am blessed studying in Bengali Medium schools, I learnt Sanskrit in 7th and 8th std and thats how I also know to write and read and speak Hindi very fluently since then... As an Indian We should be fluent in our widespoken Native Language Hindi first I believe along with the mother tongue most importantly and English🇮🇳
A very smart man indeed
This guy is an idiot
People aren’t learning Sanskrit in the first place let alone Russian
I am not Indian, but Russian is kinda of popular among Russian neighbours, like middle Asia or west Europe. So I didn't get how Sanskrit and Russian are related.
@@firstandlast4435 Part of the Indo European family.
can Listen to Him… full day
Every Sentence is like a Lesson
Absolute gentleman, to acknowledge the reality and trying to find ways where things can be improved 👏❤️
Russian is a language very similar to Sanskrit. More over because of Google translate tool, it's easy to communicate .
Using Sanskrit grammar as a reference point to learn Russian! Wow. That is incredible.
And that's when he actually adresses , "Diplomacy is art of detail" ❤
So if we knew Sanskrit well, we will understand multiple languages ❤❤❤
Jai hindustani ❤
Yeah matches with many foreign languages.. especially the language which have male,female,neutral and tenses
Eg Russian,German
I mean it's a little easier since Hindi/English is masculine/feminine only and then what verb form gonna come will get little easier if u know Sanskrit
Lol😂 what a conversation
Shit dude i already learn three languages in school. Why would i learn fourth
I already learn four it's quite hard I can understand where you are coming from😭😭
Language sikhna kuch logo ko acha lagta hai mena khudne spanish sikh li
three is bare minimum in india .
normally most of us know like 4-5
@@chaitanyakulkarni6416 dude I know 7 myself.
English,kannada,punjabi,hindi,Tamil,telugu,hariyanvi.
My problem is learning them in school,where it is more like tests and headaches rather than actually learning the language
Learning anything new never does anyone bad....
He had a good point if we share this much friendship then we must include russian
That's the vides we need of him rather than savage replies because this video's are eye-opener for us🙌
Russia doesn't provide job opportunities unlike west and Middle east. Only Indian students go for medical Colleges.so Russian language is of not much importance in Bharat.
You are right. Also there are more Indian students in many 3rd world countries including countries around russia such as Georgia than Indian students in russia. I wonder why?
@@francoislechanceux5818 I heard medical education is some what standard in Armenia than Georgia, Russia and Ukraine.
But Russia has also lot of Indian students studying.
@@gip6064 My English is not totally perfect. What I was saying is that ALL the number of Indian students in russia whatever their fields of studies is lower in number than Indian students in many 3rd world countries including those bordering russia. Given the kremlin sponsored fake hype online about the supposed greatness of India-russia relation, russia should be among the 3 top nations in the world with Indian students. But it's not even in the first top 20. Lol.
Sanskrit and Russian have actually ssme grammer
Kinda. But the Russian grammer isn't organised like hindi Or sankrit. It's more like english especially with the curilloc script. Word formations and placements are kinda similar tho
He has given a Sooperb answer
Honest and intelligent answer.
BJP is relatively good for the country, but when they push hindi onto the people by throwing out existing foreign languages already being learnt, it makes one wonder what the hell it is that they're trying to do
Are you a college graduate in humanities?
If yes then I think you know the reason
but if not then just imagine people from San Francisco communicating with people from California in Spanish (despite English being their mother tongue)🙂
@@Gyaan_with_PK Poor analogy. Try again.
@@Gyaan_with_PKbad analogy for many reasons.
1. India is not America or cannot be compared with even European nations as we have so many Indian languages of our own.
2. Why would Californians use Spanish to communicate with other Californians? But they do learn Spanish cause it helps them relate and connect with Spanish speaking people who are common in America.
3. Hindi isn't India's mother tongue, we have plenty, you see where I'm going with this?
4. The whole world uses English to communicate globally, as result of being English colonies at some point, not because they don't respect their own language or culture.
@@dudee08 for sure you're right in many ways... But it's today's reality which you're talking...
I have different point of view sir. lemme tell you few of them and you can have your opinion accordingly... I'm fine with that.
1. After every 200-300 yrs the world order changes drastically be it economic order or cultural order. earlier Sanskrit was prominent in Middle East and Indian subcontinent... And Greek in Europe... And Latin in America... now English is there and after the end of this century with 200cr population even Indians can have their cultural impact on globe again if things go right. For this we should have everything which is our own otherwise the English dominance can't be challenged.
2. You talked about global employment opportunities which comes with English... You're right... We are learning English too but what if we could create a world employment order which revolves around India then A common language which should be solely ours will be required.
3. More than 52% population know how to read 'or' write 'or' speak in Hindi in India so it is easy to make it a common language for us despite Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Punjabi, Odia, Bengali or any other scheduled language.
4. Using Hindi doesn't mean not using scheduled languages just like I'm typing in English and still I know Bhojpuri, Punjabi and Telugu.
And yes... I may sound over optimistic but it's a right time to give it a shot because we are here to do something good for future generations. It may not yield desired result but atleast few political regimes should go with it... Otherwise we will forever be in past glory and will never be able to attain success in future as a civilization.
@@Gyaan_with_PK I agree with almost everything you said.
I just want to say that pushing Hindi as a primary language in a way(like making it our national language etc) will only kill other dying languages of our country.
We as a country need to start valuing Hindi. As you said in terms of employment, in terms of improving hindi education, paying hindi teachers and professors more, buying and reading more Hindi literature. This has to be done by the people and supported by the govt.
But the govt does not talk about how it will achieve this, it only talks about pushing Hindi as if Hindi is dying and so is our culture (as if that is the only culture India has). If 52% of India speaks Hindi then surely that isn't the language in danger.
Pushing Hindi as a primary language just because more people use it serves only a certain political and social agenda.
The govt cannot ask Indians to be atmanirbhar and become entrepreneurs while not providing enough funds to the education sector and say Hindi isn't valued.
My mother teaches Hindi in a Hindi medium school, we both know what the state of the schools are in our country. So is the case with urdu and Bangla schools as well. I assume south Indians and north easterns face a similar problem. So what do you do?
Politicising saving Hindi as a solution to saving our culture is an easy answer to a difficult problem. That is my opinion.
Exactly, people here don't realise how many employment and business opportunities Indians are missing out on which other low income countries and their citizens are cashing out. Because of aging population there is a lot of demand for good skillful employees in europe, latin america and Japan especially in healthcare, hospitality, manufacturing, services sector which gets blocked because of language skills.
There should be atleast an option to learn one extra foreign language specifically Spanish, Japanese, French, Russian, Arabic.
Ex: You learn spanish and it becomes magnitude easier for you to work in Spain, mexico, developing latin american countries etc.
You learn French and along with france you can access an entire list of growing African economies.
And the most imp is Japan, probably most human resource starved with aging population, they are even offering full scholarships in order to attract potential students.
And please don't think of it as Brain drain or some other ridiculous idea, people can go there explore cultures, learn new things, make money and come back and contribute here as well.
Hey stfu man, keep ur briliiant ideas to yourself
Japanese Kanji learning is hell.
Excellent answer by jaishanksr
I have two reasons to feel proud bcoz of this man....
1) proud to be an Indian 🎉
2) proud to be a Tamilian 🎉
True. I'm learning German. It's tough but not givin up. Gib neimals auf!
How many russians learn hindi, tamil, bengali etc
Thats great .ge is great guy🎉🎉❤❤
Been learning Russian language from various sources other thaj Duolingo, such a beautiful language which has similar grammer to that of Sanskrit.❤
Jaishankar lecturing whole world but meanwhile in india chicken heist is happening.
That kind of heist happens in most developed countries too.
Our Training of Foriegn Language is not growing at that pace is actually wrong. Our Training for Foriegn Language is growing at an insane pace that it is even outpaced indian language growth and now Government is looking to cut it down.
A good citizen, is someone who criticizes it's country when it's wrong, supports it's country with all his strength. Never praises the country, but always looks forward to the future. Like a dad to his child. I think the people online, who contiously think and talk about what we have already done, and are overly proud of the country's achievements, can never be a real part of that achievement, they can never actually contribute to the country's greatness
I hate those kinds of people, bcz people who really do something to contribute to the nation' s wealth and pride never talk about it
Respected Foreign Minister has cleared the situation.I had studied long back in Moscow, U.S.S.R. for Mining Engineering during 1968 to1973. in Russian Language.Even the the Final degree was passed in Russian Language.For Indians it is easiest to learn Russian language which is from INDO--SLOVAK group.There are so many synonyms Sanskrit words and grammar.
Well said
The one who knows his own weakness is the one most difficult to defeat
Now we are literally learning Korean💜 it wasn't force, just the internet did
Thanks minister
lower middle, middle and another from upper middle class students are still learning Sanskrit. ab hoga Bhikshit Bharat 🪔 we are so proud of your presence among us
Finally Missing Cheetah is our hero and resembles more like our late Homie Baba in some corner of our heart 🇮🇳🪔 vikshit BHARAT hoga, Bahadur beta big beti hi Jeetega
Great FM..,,
My father had a book on and in Russian. And we live thousands of miles away from Delhi.
Learning any foreigner language is a + point..
Sanskrit is the mother of all languages. See how russian is linked to it 🙏🕉️
i am studying Japanese on my own.. it's tough but it's progressing
👏👏👏
In Dibrugarh University,assam teacher's from Japan and Korea teaching Japanese and Korean here🎉
In my college sanakrit language option was cancelled as the teachervretired but when wevasked for the teacher they told there were not sufficient funds.
We need to promote Sanskrit more actively.. It can help to learn all other languages...
He always starts his answers with a 'NO', even wen he agrees 😂
Right sir
❤
Why not our Govt promotes our Sanskrit Language at least in our own country if not in foreign countries
I learnt German in my school. For real! For 4 years I was learning German in my school. As a IIIrd language after Hindi and English. Most of Indian schools will teach one regional language, then Hindi, then English. But since I am from Delhi so I learnt only Hindi, English and German. Russian should also be taught as in post soviet countries Russian is still used. They are trying to use their own language instead of Russian but Russia is pressuring them so that Russian is prelevant there.
Very awkwardly he had to accept. He must proudly and openly acknowledge that ... Gone are those days where our kids were given exposure to other languages. Now the education here will teach kids to go back and dig in the past.
Jayashankar is an intelligent Broker...he brokes for modani.
True
It's a drawback, we should introduce languages of our foreign language and our allies should do it too. Bdw love the way he accepted the drawback of our country.
Foreigners should now start learning Indian languages
I also referenced sanskrit grammar when I was learning French
We have English Hindi and a local language in school till 10th grade..how many more are possible at school level😢
I think it wouldn't be mandatory.
It will be open as a choice for the people who wish to learn it.
Not everyone has the capacity to be multilingual.
भाषा सीखे या न सीखें
रशियन यहूदी पारसी हमारे दिल देश के आधार हैं
Sanskrit and Hindi came handy i was trying to learn Japanese. English was not very close to Japanese. Good to know Sanskrit grammar helped him to learn Russian language. ✔️
Whichever government comes in . I want Jaysakhar sir to be our foreign minister.
Don't worry translation is best option only basic requirement 😊
Russian and Mandarin langauge should be taught in all schools
early 2000s in my school they teach sanskrit, french and german. but its gone now sadly
Spoken Sanskrit from class 2 across the nation. Fun classes. No exams. In 15 years every child from Guwahati to Chennai will be able to connect. Mother tongue, Sanskrit (national language), English (foreign language).
What is the value of learning Russian language?
But obviously as a diplomat you can't say the truth on their face. And he handled it brilliantly.
I would have loved to learn like that and also learn Sanskrit...but now school, ive finished
Nice
He's Chad! Russian also has something akin to 'vibhaktiyaan' in Sanskrit. This man is a man of culture !!
I used Sanskrit grammer as a reference point to learn German
i found russian easy to grasp because i know hindi well.
DO NOT FORGET SANSKRIT
My daughter has been learning SPANISH since she eas in 4th till 10th .. there was a choice between Spanish and French
Now they added German and Spanish making choice between 4 languages
After 10th its their choice to continue as 6th subject
Indian schools are growing.... Iam hearing this since I was a kid and even my grand children would sure will hear the same 😶🌫️
I think this gives the cue to create a platform to teach foreign languages along the other job skills, to help new generation to migrate to other nations and find jobs. other wise job scarcity is going to grow more and more...
Meanwhile i cried while trying to learn french (skill issue)
Every school in India should teach... Russian,Arabic,Chinese,French and Spanish simultaneously....
We all must learn Russian with English.
Its true sanskrit language has many words that are used in Russian language
@ 0.34sec, He said that, his children were taught Russian. This is actually a good thing about that government and in a way he admit that old government had better education policies than current ruling govt. 😊