@stray dog7 you say about listening and watching not for keep the gov's power, but we are, they are listening and watching for keep their power to slave us, do you know 8964? when somebody do something we should think what he want finally, the motivation decided the real objective. I am right?
yes they tell you first what they are going to do so karma wont come back on them, its a masonic thing, so things are going to get really bad now, its all in the book of revelations, get right with God, pray, read the bible stock up on some food and money
Yup. That’s what they do though. They talk about a enemy or a problem to make it look like they’re not part of it. It’s like putting something right in your face so you won’t realize that’s not right.
Exactly what I was thinking too, doesn't help that most of the video is just a close-up of him talking. it's got that "big brother is watching you" energy
The book doesn't actually take place in 1984. There are subtle hints throughout the novel that the actual year is not knowable, and with history being rewritten and even erased the setting can be at any point in time.
A bit of all of them. Fahrenheit 451- because censorship is being demanded by people, and only provided by government after the public demands it. Check out Philip K Dick's Electric Dreams, episode titled "Kill All Others". It's exactly what's happening right now. The media is pumping out Rorschach tests: they just start claiming people and things are racists, and if you're one of the critical thinkers who questions why? You're now an "other" yourself. Only an "other" would question this obvious course of action. Others are very dangerous terrorists. You see a woman running from a mob in the streets? You try to help her? Why are you trying to help an other? Just wait till the police get here!
@@terminsane Good point, though you are describing the FAUX-type commercial outlets and conspiracy-theory wrong-wing channels, which thrive by stoking the paranoid fears and resentful hatreds of poorly-educated bigots .
@@Tony-Blake no, I'm talking about what happens when government decides what is true, and bans "misinformation". Cigarettes used to be prescribed by doctors. The surgeon general used to recommend smoking to maintain your health... You're not an anti-science conspiracy theorist are you? You're not trying to hurt people's health by telling them cigarettes cause cancer are you? The science, and scientists agree that smoking improves your health, so why are you spreading misinformation that will stop people from smoking? Did you know lobotomy was a cutting edge scientific advancement in the treatment of ADHD? If your child can't sit and pay attention in school, he should really get a lobotomy. Why would you deny science and refuse to help your own child? You're basically abusing your own child by refusing to give him the medically acceptable, scientifically proven treatment for his condition. Did you see Obama officially apologized in behalf of the US government for when it was infecting orphans with radioactive isotopes to study radiation poisoning on children? Are you a conspiracy theorist for saying it happened before govt admitted to it? Or am I a conspiracy theorist now for pointing out Obama apologized for it? We would ban people for claiming it was happening, before Obama apologized for it. Then we get to ban people who still think it was a conspiracy theory, for claiming the government DIDNT do it when Obama is on video admitting it did happen. Then with the advent of AI deepfake videos, we can just put everyone in prison since nobody will know the truth and you can just call everyone a liar Should we have banned "conspiracy theorists" who claimed the Flynt water crisis isn't over? Government officially said the water is fixed and drinkable again. Even that bright purple water. You're not a conspiracy theorist claiming the government is lying to people, Telling them to drink poison water, are you?
@@Tony-Blake global cooling is real. (At least it was in the 90s when every newspaper and scientist said it was). Scientists published lots of studies proving the earth is headed for another ice age, perhaps within our lifetime. Should we ban everyone who rejects this notion? Should we prohibit funding of science that seeks to prove "global warming" conspiracy? What about now, 20 years later? Do we now ban everyone who was promoting global cooling, and unban yesterday's conspiracy theorists who are now declared correct by government? What about the people who said there's no WMDs in Iraq? Every intelligence agency said we needed to bomb Iraq, because they know for a fact Saddam is on the edge of developing nukes and chemical and biological weapons of every kind. Anyone who suggests that Saddam probably doesn't have WMDs and this is just a ploy to start another foreign war? CONSPIRACY THEORIIIIST! BAAAAN HIIIIM!
Trump is government. Trump said there's no collusion. You're not a conspiracy theorist, are you? Why should people be allowed to spread dangerous lies on the internet?
saaj90 I’m not sure the only books I remember studying were ‘of mice and men’ and Romeo and Juliet, I guess because those two had films they could stick on the TV rather than engage with kids school was a fuckin joke, if I ever have children I’ll never send them to public school
It is one of those "must reads" that is on everyone's list. It has been banned under Soviet Russia back in the 50s/60s. I don't think it will ever be outlawed in the sense you mean though :-)
Bullshit. I'll wager against that. If this book get outlawed in the uk in the next 50 years, I'll give you £1000, if not you give me. I'll come back in 50 years to collect my grand
The parallel between the BBC and Newspeak with all their propaganda and politically correct language is striking so this is a bit ironic coming from them lol.
Reloaded. So many negative comments last time.....even when non political people see through the BBC and Victoria Derbyshire, the BBC has a serious problem.
BBC, George Orwel used to work for the BBC and the fact is, the ministry of truth is based from you. In the book, he talks about a much more advanced form of propaganda and how it was beyond the Soviet union. In fact, it was ridiculing the Soviet Union and comparing it as stepping stone, and amateurs compared to the "nations" they were in.
Darren Bywater Diversity is very much like income tax no one wants it but government punishment is extreme if you don’t pay it. PAYE was also supposed a short term fix. Establishment Lies
Diversity was escourted by police to throw rocks at other police, women and children in Oldham, all caught on camera yet no arrests and no media reporting, because it was from a religious group that is clearly above the law. That's "diversity" for you.
all the people saying "We live in 1984" fails to realise that by having the option to read 1984 proves we dont live in a censored world, atleast not of INGSOC standards.
There are degrees of totalitarian control. Venezuela is a totalitarian nation but due to its very inneficient security service the actual level of control is limited. Then you have North Korea. Plus is it possible that the 'system' is posting comments that create the impression of freedom of thought in order to fool the common man?'Well if 1984 was real there wouldn't be so many comments about it.' When in fact only 1% of comments are by real people. Not saying its the case here but it can be in others. The security services can very easily manipulate social media to create an impression.
@@monakw they had an operative take a video of him just after he was incarcerated and they've just released that after he was admitted to hospital to make it look like he's ok. His father has been refused visits in hospital due to two doctors by his bed.
I read '1984' by George Orwell' in, well, 1984. I've also read it since then. Eric Blair's critique of unexamined human false optimism is as satirically relevant as it was in 1948.
No, the BBC isn't big brother. The fact that the comments here can openly criticise and dislike their video proves that they don't have the same power as he does
I had to read this book in 6th grade, 25 years ago. Needless to say the book was pretty hard to comprehend. Maybe my teacher was using her short opportunity to warn us what may happen in the future.
George Orwell was the greatest Author of the 20th Century, my favourites are Homage To Catalonia, and Burmese Days, where in my opinion he has his “ Road to Damascus “ experience. 1984, all true, is now FF...Ing Game Show.
Presented by a "journalist" who works for the Guardian (a former newspaper). The same Guardian thats spreads false information about chemical attacks in Syria. This piece was taken down once already and the comments scrubbed for another go and the irony of the BBC/Guardian talking about 1984 is not lost upon us.
When I used to live in London there was a report on the news that said if you pay a visit into central London your photo is likely to be taken over 300 times .
The truth hurts. Thanks for this significant and meaningful video, dear BBC. I read this book nearly 3 years ago in English (my native language is Turkish btw), and I got really critical lessons from it. Broadened my view of life in the sociological context.
_[comment removed for thought crime]_
If you are even allowed a comment in the first place. You certainly aren't allowed on the BBC news site!
Neuralink is the pathway to Orwellian Civilization. Government can read and controlling your mind.
The "powers that be" always telegraph their punches before they're thrown"
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂
Classic comment lol th-cam.com/video/kby14Voy7-g/w-d-xo.html
The BBC warning about big brother. Doesn't get much more Orwellian than that.
Exactly.
00:52 after all "the texture of the 'Ministry of Truth" was based on his time working for the BBC"!
haha
I dont want scared you, but If British still cooperate with CCP, we all will like in 1984 reality. I am Chinese, I know this too clearly.
@stray dog7 you say about listening and watching not for keep the gov's power, but we are, they are listening and watching for keep their power to slave us, do you know 8964? when somebody do something we should think what he want finally, the motivation decided the real objective. I am right?
Step 1: *grab popcorn*
Step 2: *scroll through comments section*
All very predictable 'O the irony!' and and so on and so forth.
I don't eat popcorn it's bad for you
More in comments, than we ever get from BBC. th-cam.com/video/kby14Voy7-g/w-d-xo.html
Thx
Ik it’s so annoying seeing people trying to make this political lol
BBC = Ministry Of Truth.
Isn't it ironic? 😂
Same! I thought so too
...Certainly !!
Yep.... Lol.
😭😭😭
This novel was not supposed to be an instruction guide. Yet here we are, witnessing prophetic events...
It's not prophetic it's just the logical conclusion of where society is headed
Then a revolution must come. We still have time.
You're so dumb did you even read the book.
A year later, 1984 is 2020. th-cam.com/video/kby14Voy7-g/w-d-xo.html
True...much like Marx's Thesis on communism!
It's so ironic that BBC is uploading this 😂😂 i don't think this video is supposed to warn us, more like bragging about it.
yes they tell you first what they are going to do so karma wont come back on them, its a masonic thing, so things are going to get really bad now, its all in the book of revelations, get right with God, pray, read the bible stock up on some food and money
Neuralink is the pathway to Orwellian Civilization. Government can read and controlling your mind.
they dont even care anymore
@@Morningstar-xz5bl new testament is bullocks
The "elite" always show what is coming before they do it!
They mock everybody by doing it".
1984 is no longer fiction. It is everyday reality.
Neuralink is the pathway to Orwellian Civilization. Government can read and controlling your mind.
You are insane
@Klik B That's the thing I wanna overcome, but not sure how to do it since I am such a socially awkward regular folk
Woah we live in a society
Beto Ortiz You obviously havent read the book, or your life is insane paranoia.
This is the most ironic video I’ve ever seen in my life, big brother explaining what big brother does
Exactly, thus is what I was thinking
Yup. That’s what they do though. They talk about a enemy or a problem to make it look like they’re not part of it. It’s like putting something right in your face so you won’t realize that’s not right.
hey at least they have comments on there vids unlike other news sites
spot on! 😀
Exactly what I was thinking too, doesn't help that most of the video is just a close-up of him talking. it's got that "big brother is watching you" energy
George Orwell: "1984 is a terrible year"
2020: "Hold my beer..."
The book doesn't actually take place in 1984. There are subtle hints throughout the novel that the actual year is not knowable, and with history being rewritten and even erased the setting can be at any point in time.
Nah 1984 much worse mate
@@cocomarchant1486 Yup. Hindsight has 20/20 vision 👀
@@CorvusCorax. ok
2022 hold my whiskey....
Ironically, we now live in a combination of 1984 and Brave New World.
A bit of all of them.
Fahrenheit 451- because censorship is being demanded by people, and only provided by government after the public demands it.
Check out Philip K Dick's Electric Dreams, episode titled "Kill All Others". It's exactly what's happening right now.
The media is pumping out Rorschach tests: they just start claiming people and things are racists, and if you're one of the critical thinkers who questions why? You're now an "other" yourself. Only an "other" would question this obvious course of action. Others are very dangerous terrorists.
You see a woman running from a mob in the streets? You try to help her? Why are you trying to help an other? Just wait till the police get here!
@@terminsane Good point, though you are describing the FAUX-type commercial outlets and conspiracy-theory wrong-wing channels, which thrive by stoking the paranoid fears and resentful hatreds of poorly-educated bigots .
@@Tony-Blake no, I'm talking about what happens when government decides what is true, and bans "misinformation".
Cigarettes used to be prescribed by doctors. The surgeon general used to recommend smoking to maintain your health... You're not an anti-science conspiracy theorist are you? You're not trying to hurt people's health by telling them cigarettes cause cancer are you? The science, and scientists agree that smoking improves your health, so why are you spreading misinformation that will stop people from smoking?
Did you know lobotomy was a cutting edge scientific advancement in the treatment of ADHD? If your child can't sit and pay attention in school, he should really get a lobotomy. Why would you deny science and refuse to help your own child? You're basically abusing your own child by refusing to give him the medically acceptable, scientifically proven treatment for his condition.
Did you see Obama officially apologized in behalf of the US government for when it was infecting orphans with radioactive isotopes to study radiation poisoning on children? Are you a conspiracy theorist for saying it happened before govt admitted to it? Or am I a conspiracy theorist now for pointing out Obama apologized for it?
We would ban people for claiming it was happening, before Obama apologized for it. Then we get to ban people who still think it was a conspiracy theory, for claiming the government DIDNT do it when Obama is on video admitting it did happen.
Then with the advent of AI deepfake videos, we can just put everyone in prison since nobody will know the truth and you can just call everyone a liar
Should we have banned "conspiracy theorists" who claimed the Flynt water crisis isn't over? Government officially said the water is fixed and drinkable again. Even that bright purple water. You're not a conspiracy theorist claiming the government is lying to people, Telling them to drink poison water, are you?
@@Tony-Blake global cooling is real. (At least it was in the 90s when every newspaper and scientist said it was).
Scientists published lots of studies proving the earth is headed for another ice age, perhaps within our lifetime.
Should we ban everyone who rejects this notion? Should we prohibit funding of science that seeks to prove "global warming" conspiracy?
What about now, 20 years later? Do we now ban everyone who was promoting global cooling, and unban yesterday's conspiracy theorists who are now declared correct by government?
What about the people who said there's no WMDs in Iraq? Every intelligence agency said we needed to bomb Iraq, because they know for a fact Saddam is on the edge of developing nukes and chemical and biological weapons of every kind.
Anyone who suggests that Saddam probably doesn't have WMDs and this is just a ploy to start another foreign war? CONSPIRACY THEORIIIIST! BAAAAN HIIIIM!
Trump is government. Trump said there's no collusion. You're not a conspiracy theorist, are you? Why should people be allowed to spread dangerous lies on the internet?
1984 was my favorite book that was mandatory to read in High School...and that was 30 years ago. It's continued relevance is astounding.
I’m English and this book was never even mentioned in the public school I attended.
@@TommyClif its mandatory to read here in the US.
@@TommyClif Animal Farm was read in secondary schools in the 90s.
@@TommyClif That's so weird, what exam board did you take for english Literature?
saaj90 I’m not sure the only books I remember studying were ‘of mice and men’ and Romeo and Juliet, I guess because those two had films they could stick on the TV rather than engage with kids school was a fuckin joke, if I ever have children I’ll never send them to public school
Let that be a lesson to you BBC. He was talking about YOU.
I came here because I was watching video about how it was talking about the watchtower!! JW's
This comment has been vaporized by the thot police
Mark Lewis THOT POLICE
Your not allowed to say " thot" it's sexist , but only from heterosexual white guys who like trump.
@Ed McClucksky ?
"fact checking," would say that this is not true.
EVERYONE needs to read this AMAZING book. We are living in an Orwellian time at this very moment. This book will be outlawed soon.
It is one of those "must reads" that is on everyone's list. It has been banned under Soviet Russia back in the 50s/60s.
I don't think it will ever be outlawed in the sense you mean though :-)
@@znxster the way censorship is running rampant throughout different countries of the world... I do believe they will outlaw it.
Bullshit. I'll wager against that. If this book get outlawed in the uk in the next 50 years, I'll give you £1000, if not you give me. I'll come back in 50 years to collect my grand
@@SM-ly5tf let's do it like this: if the book gets outlawed in UK, you give me 1000£. If it doesn't, you give me just 100£. So, what do you say?
@@makeromaniagreatagain9697 Fair game. Stick to it if your a man. Give me a time period too. Dont want to be collecting the money on my deathbed.
The Irony.
Lol. BBC be telling the truth in plain sight about themselves.
biased opinion?
The parallel between the BBC and Newspeak with all their propaganda and politically correct language is striking so this is a bit ironic coming from them lol.
"BB-Speak" (British boardcast/Big brother speak)
y'know that Orwell was left-wing?
Reloaded. So many negative comments last time.....even when non political people see through the BBC and Victoria Derbyshire, the BBC has a serious problem.
I have read it at 15 years old, it was difficult but I never regretted because I had knowledge that is very valuable in today’s society.
1984 is no longer fiction. It is propaganda.
BBC, George Orwel used to work for the BBC and the fact is, the ministry of truth is based from you.
In the book, he talks about a much more advanced form of propaganda and how it was beyond the Soviet union. In fact, it was ridiculing the Soviet Union and comparing it as stepping stone, and amateurs compared to the "nations" they were in.
The irony of the BBC posting this
2020 - 'Silence is Violence'. You're were spot on, George.
NO HATE SPEECH.
NO MALICIOUS COMMUNICATIONS.
DO NOT GROSSLY OFFEND.
1984 was required reading when I was in middle school in the 1950's
BBC=Ministry of Truth
I can’t believe the BBC had the gumption to make this clip haha
The BBC are Orwellian. When will the BBC start talking about the Robin Tilbrook Brexit court case I wonder ?
Weeks ago? www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-31754733
Kirk Summerwill Your link just proves his point
The BB€ is a joke
Facepalm*
I have an exam on 1984 tomorrow lol
good luck
How was the book, and how did you do with the exam?
@@HiClassHarlow I actually haven't read the book
@@HiClassHarlow If there is hope, it lies in the proles.
Just remember that you saw this on the ministry of truth's channel.
They always tell us that diversity is our strength. They never tell us why.
Darren Bywater Diversity is very much like income tax no one wants it but government punishment is extreme if you don’t pay it. PAYE was also supposed a short term fix. Establishment Lies
yups
If diversity is strength then is unity weakness?
@@benbow7 no and not comparable
We can have unity without mixing
Diversity was escourted by police to throw rocks at other police, women and children in Oldham, all caught on camera yet no arrests and no media reporting, because it was from a religious group that is clearly above the law. That's "diversity" for you.
Orwell just disintegrated from the centrifugal force.
_"1984"_ should be made into a movie another time. But _this_ time it should be adapted as a detailed TV-series, just like _"A Handmaid's Tale"_ .
the bbc talking about 1984, fuck me i have seen it all
We’re literally living the book.
A bit ironic that the BBC has a piece on this.....
this aged well
The BBC talking about censoring speech, pushing propaganda, and criticising people who don’t think the way they should, is so ironic
all the people saying "We live in 1984" fails to realise that by having the option to read 1984 proves we dont live in a censored world, atleast not of INGSOC standards.
There are degrees of totalitarian control. Venezuela is a totalitarian nation but due to its very inneficient security service the actual level of control is limited. Then you have North Korea. Plus is it possible that the 'system' is posting comments that create the impression of freedom of thought in order to fool the common man?'Well if 1984 was real there wouldn't be so many comments about it.' When in fact only 1% of comments are by real people. Not saying its the case here but it can be in others. The security services can very easily manipulate social media to create an impression.
China is already 1984, India is slowly becoming the same.
No, india and all other corporate controlled countries are already living 1984.
Lmfao. Sure and BBC is epitome of truth.
@nehem Yes definitely after seeing Sky News getting banned
the sheer irony dripping off this is tangible, it just refilled my drink right infront of me!
The irony of this vid being by the BBC.....
Feel like 1984 should be assigned reading in high school. Animal farm is good but 1984 is so much more relevant
Meanwhile Julien Assange is in Belmarsh Prison because the British justice system delivered a political judgement on the European Arrest Warrant.
I heard that they poisoned him is it true?
@monakw if you heard on BBC Probably part of the dept of truth “that’ll be a lie then”
@@monakw they had an operative take a video of him just after he was incarcerated and they've just released that after he was admitted to hospital to make it look like he's ok.
His father has been refused visits in hospital due to two doctors by his bed.
Nowadays the reality has surpassed fiction.
Orwell wasn't such a big pessimist.
According to the BBC, he lacked vision/imagination.
I put a comment on the previous version of this last week but it went down the memory hole.
I read '1984' by George Orwell' in, well, 1984. I've also read it since then. Eric Blair's critique of unexamined human false optimism is as satirically relevant as it was in 1948.
hi there! was it very current for you back in 1984 when you first read it?
The BBC are back for more!
is the ministry of truth trying to assert some sort of double think?
yups
this aged fabulously
Ironically, the big brother is telling the truth through its Ministry of TRUTH.
Whose comments got scrubbed?
I'm really surprised BBC have opened themselves to comments on this!!! They're deplorable when it comes to bias and propaganda.
No, the BBC isn't big brother. The fact that the comments here can openly criticise and dislike their video proves that they don't have the same power as he does
It's wierd that the comments section of these videos are the only thing what bring back my faith In humanity
You would know, oh Ministry of Propaganda.
I dont think winston is a ""hero"" he's just the protagonist of his own story
I had to read this book in 6th grade, 25 years ago. Needless to say the book was pretty hard to comprehend. Maybe my teacher was using her short opportunity to warn us what may happen in the future.
George Orwell was the greatest Author of the 20th Century, my favourites are Homage To Catalonia, and Burmese Days, where in my opinion he has his “ Road to Damascus “ experience. 1984, all true, is now FF...Ing Game Show.
Presented by a "journalist" who works for the Guardian (a former newspaper). The same Guardian thats spreads false information about chemical attacks in Syria. This piece was taken down once already and the comments scrubbed for another go and the irony of the BBC/Guardian talking about 1984 is not lost upon us.
The British government and most of the press have their 1984 playbooks well learned and in force.
First read it in high school. Rediscovered it thanks to several audio recordings Audible had in stock, even bought one of them.
Where is Brexit?
Always found it Rich that this came from BBC
War is peace, Freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength
Is it just me or is there some irony in the BBC telling us the relevancy of 1984.
This was brave of you, BBC.
A employee must have escaped the dungeon to broadcast this
@@normanlegend4936
Orwell worked for the BBC.
So calm down K?
My comment was scrubbed
😂😂😂😂 hilarious.
Same
ironic coming from BBC like bro 😳
2 +2 =5, Of course, it is, because the party says so! Oh, the party also says that anyone can be a woman as long as they identify as one.
I read the book, a truly concerning and accurate description of what is going on, a warning that every one should read
Now read: "Brave New World".
Both books combined describe modern society.
@@AlanWattResistance I have read it, recomend Fahrenheit 451, it describes key aspects of modern society very well,
When I used to live in London there was a report on the news that said if you pay a visit into central London your photo is likely to be taken over 300 times .
The bbc even trying to cover this is a thoughtcrime in itself.
The BBC enforces the very things George Orwell wrote about.
Why you post this video again after it's been removed two days ago.
I don't think they like our comments. Probably hoping we don't bother commenting again on the reupload
@@terminsane fat chance
The truth hurts. Thanks for this significant and meaningful video, dear BBC. I read this book nearly 3 years ago in English (my native language is Turkish btw), and I got really critical lessons from it. Broadened my view of life in the sociological context.
Considering you just addressed the BBC as “dear” I think you need to have a read of that book again matey
Cat Got Ya Tongue forreal 🤣🤣🤣🤣
The bbc is part of the big brother. How have you not realised this? The media is big brother
Practically everything Orwell wrote is still as - if not more - relevant today.
BBC don't do irony. But If it they did...
It matters because we living it nowdays . 1984 it's this place and this time. We give up our freedom for our security, they keep telling Us .
Watching this in 2021 🥺
The BBC, What a joke truth mixed with lies .
Big Brother Corporation
The answer to 1984 is 1776.
Whose land do you want to invade and colonise this time?
1776 will lead you into Brave New World.
1984 by George Orwell: *exists*
The World Economic Forum (the mainstream media and the vast majority of politicians): "Is this an instruction manual?"
Isn’t this a reupload?
Yep. With a clean slate of comments. So I just posted again.
In America, you watch TV
In Soviet Russia, TV watches you.
119 dislikes? Doubtful. Censoring the response to a criticism of censorship. Now that's Orwellian.
WE ARE LITERALLY LIVING THIS BUT WE WILL PREVAIL!
I have some feeling that this video is going to disappear soon
The lack of self awareness...
This video is DOUBLE THINK
Irony is lost on the BBC huh
I'd laugh at the irony if the BBC wasn't so terrifyingly Orwellian
Newspeak + Ingsoc = BBC
Mindlessly and endlessly repeating this message you wrote =
Not thinking critically
The only thing george orwell was wrong about was the date!
Yes, Big Brother is watching. No, there’s nothing you can do about it. Have a nice day. 🤖
BBC Needs to rewatch this and learn what they're doing and actually become a media for the people not the governments control narrative!
It matter so much because We are living in 1984
It matters more than ever now, bc we are living in it! Esp you there in UK 😢😠
And now look ..! 🙈we're fucked BIG TIME
ironic when the BBC are talking about 1984
Ironic how the bbc are showing this
Britain is literally 1984, brave new world, and camp of the saints all rolled into one awful wrapping