How Auckland swung away from Labour | Q+A 2023
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2023
- Q+A’s John Campbell is all over Auckland to tell the story of how Auckland voters turned away from Labour, including an interview with the first ever National MP for Mt Roskill, Dr Carlos Cheung
Subscribe to Q+A: bit.ly/QandASubscribe
Join Jack Tame and the Q+A team and find the answers to the questions that matter. Made with the support of NZ on Air.
WATCH SUNDAY 9AM ON TVNZ1 OR CATCH UP ON DEMAND: www.tvnz.co.nz/shows/q-and-a/
FOLLOW Q+A ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Facebook: / nzqanda
Twitter: / nzqanda
For stories that matter to you and the very latest from Aotearoa and around the world: 1News.co.nz/
Excellent calm incisive, listening , and responsive interview….giving space for each other to respond and give views, with respect. Thank you to all three of you. And thank you John.
Mt Roskill 40% Asian, almost 50/50 of that being Indian or Chinese I’d say the ram raids had a lot to do with them voting National.
New Zealand has to many Asian Indian immigrants everywhere makes new Zealand a ulgy country
Sure, but it's more that a lot of them are hard working immigrants who don't want a government taking away their opportunity to succeed and reap the rewards
So he wins in a Labour stronghold, and people in the comments section are trying to find anything wrong with him instead of putting the blame on Labour who have miserably failed their constituents. Labour failed NZ so time for a change. I used to vote Labour.
“We want to provide better opportunities for them.”
Yeah but how are you going to do that? What are the concrete actions?
For example when I spoke to Michael Wood, he was able to give example on the existing apprenticeship program for those who need upskilling and wanting to get to the job market.
Labour is NATO… No Action Talk Only
Wonder if Michael Wood could tell you about shares, and if you should sell them after being alerted over 12 times
M W is all talk NO ACTION. A Waste of space
3-4 yrs ago I talked to MW about National handing out flyers about Labour’s lack of clarity on the light rail. He just brushed the issue aside… Feel like he changed over the years, from his humble beginnings putting up campaign hoardings to his not so transparent approach about his shares…
Yep it’s a shame that he got into the shares scandal, that certainly doesn’t help during the election, the other reason why National won Mt Roskill is because people got sick of Labour and they wanted some change
I know many people that voted the local MPs not because they know and trust the candidate, but because they support National, two ticks blue.
The biggest problem in NZ is its too easy to be lazy. Part of that is encouraged by the state, but the majority is people constantly relying on the state.
It's so easy now days to find a job rent a house NZ government stuffed this country with unmanaged immigration
The victim mentality of some of these people.
100%
thats labour ,greens for you lol
The Mt Roskill MP said his science was dependant on government funding not private funding. National !
He did not say that, but of course, you'd twist it to gain a cheap fake point. And I am not a National supporter.
The National guy for Mt Roskill has great outcome from NZ education. But he is part the reason public services are not keeping up. The public funds used to train him are used to do property speculation.
I think it has more to do with the fact that PhD in biology is kinda useless these days. He'd have a much better professional career with a Masters in computer science, for example.
Great outcome if you are just sitting in NZ. NZ education has lost its sheen overseas. Don’t blame him for the property market. You are blaming speculators when the gatekeeper (regulator) has bolted…. When spending increases and councils don’t have budget to provide good services, the Ponzi scheme of keeping up revenue only through increased taxes collected from immigrants and overseas students collapses…
@@grandmundi7107 Keep in mind that we'd all be better off with more research of the kind he was doing, it might not make much money right now but that's because NZ doesn't have a big research sector and that's for 2 reasons. We don't have a strong system to support research and we dont have a strong sector to utilise it. Across the world the first is usually handled by the state with help here and there from private corps and the second is usually handled by the private sector the benefit of public services e.g. research into diabetes medicine funded by the state, private company takes the research develops a product which is then used by patients in the public health care. In NZ we don't have either because we under invest in research and until recently didn't support collaboration between research entities like universities and crown research partners. We also dont have that many private sector capital to take advantage of that because it all goes towards sectors that are related in some major way to property because we've set up our economy to prioritise mortgages. Back in the day (pre 90s) our banks would mostly invest in businesses but nowadays most there loans go to property which doesn't produce jobs(unless your building which isn't most mortages) or medicines, or basically anything else. Basically, a PhD in biology shouldn't be useless but it is because we've screwed our economy and this guy is a living metaphor for that.
@@grandmundi7107pay for scientists is quite low given the amount of study they have had to do. Jobs are often fixed term or at risk if your funding dries up, depending where you work. A lot of funding is contestable, you have to apply for it putting considerable effort (months of work) into a proposal that may not be approved by the funding body. There was some work to change funding models and other things underway but National has said they will scrap the new proposals. So yes he’s better off in property investment than being a scientist.
@@ranjitntu and immigrants and international students should pay. The locals didn’t ask y’all to come you made that decision on your own. Life
People aren't stupid. They know the economy needs to move at this time.
They must be stupid, you can’t have tax cuts and improve the economy without many services being cut.
The Govt has little if any control over our economy foreign govts we trade with have more influence.
@@bobdillon1138 What a great thought. No wonder Labour lost . LOL
What are you talking about? There’s a global living crisis the economy isn’t going anywhere get used to this word STAGNANT. Until the supply chain sorts itself sameness for the next three years buuuuutttt this is what you voted for so be prepared to eat shit in the near future.
@@theradfactor9104 The only entity that has any direct influence over our Economy is the Reserve Bank all the Govt does is collect tax and fund public services .The amount of tariffs foreign Govts put on our exports has more influence on our economy than anything the Govt can do.
MANY THANKS
Labour made victim mentality the norm… Time to get NZ back on track…. The original reason why talented people came to these shores…
That’s a ridiculous statement.
@@mariannegilbert8786 time to provide your own ridiculous statement then, rather than just saying something for the sake of it
If you are the prime example, then yes, you pretend to be the victim.
this sounds an awful lot like victim blaming.
How did they make victim mentality the norm? Just a fatuous right wing cliche. What are we, a nation of shopkeepers?
The MP never said that rents will go down as a result of reducing cost . C Luxton said National will reduce cost..
Luxon said rents will face downward pressure from the increase in rental supply as more landlords came back to the market from the lower costs regime and the return of interest deductibility, not what this new MP said. He missed the real reason.
Which means? If cost of a supplier is reduced . Why will they not reduce the price? Because they often pass on all if not all most cost pressures. Well if rents don't fall or cease to rise on average it will indicate the policy failed on one count.
@@roberthooker4970 by the laws of economics, more supply = more downward pressure on rents all things being equal. Whether this plays out remains to be seen
@@shazamacaroniwithcheese296Do not just follow that idea. If peoples incomes mean they cannot afford or not choose to accept price then prices will fall?
Remember National reduced the number of state house over the period 1993 to 2017. That is by 12,000 houses. So they reduced the supply.( Labour during 2000 to 2009 and 2017 to 2023 increased the no. of houses by 17,000).
I’m from Australia and trying to make sense of the election…which voters swung from Labor to the Nationals? Is it Asians in Auckland who want more policing of crime who were the big factor or what?
Yes, and there is some lingering anger and trauma from 2021 lockdowns too
This is only city I have been there once ( Auckland ) Watch test match NZ vs Australia
Right after match finished i departure to Australia.
Landlords have mortgages to pay. The idea that a landlord won't charge market rates or near to it is a joke. It's just a joke.
I think people who work should be rewarded… people on the dole (not to due to disability reasons) should be made to think hard about just collecting money
More prison especially with National the only was is to get society to change their upbringing of their children, change in the public thinking
Co Governance or for National Co Management. That is the reason we put ACT and NZF in
Lol. Otara has been in declined for years. Even when Labour was in parliament
Campbell came across a little sycophantic. Fair comment? 🤔
That is right Prime Minister the environments
yeah wonder how that happened 🤨
Yawn. All platitudes and no concrete plans. Nz is doomed
Enver Hoxha Campbell.
yes but he still does not answer the question
He is good
You try and live on a benefit Mr.Vanker😮
More Campbell “victimhood” campaigning…………..
Q & A John Campbell 🤣 What a joke .
If you weren't elite maori or academic activist, Labour was not in it for you
He might have a good education and job but he doesn't know what this country needs from what he's said, Go learn some economics
Michael Wood lost Mt Roskill,which is good.Renters are going to lose out big time
cris topher nutson
This guy, John Campbell, should seriously stop waiving his hands pointing his fingers everywhere. When he’s in studio, he’s pointing the fkn pen at everyone. Has got no control of his hands and fingers?
The MP said Election day was on Friday not Saturday. The National candidate for Te At Tu said " National does not care about Pacifuc people".
Get off it ya sound like a actual racist
christoper lux cinema ticket experience free drinks
Great fn religious running thing again
Who cares….new toilet paper same old shit.
I am a young person. I almost did not vote. All parties are uninspiring and useless. Will absolutely not be voting next time.
id suggest at least spoiling your ballot idk draw a picture or something on it just to show that you you're annoyed with all the parties. who knows enough people do this it might actually get parties listen to people
They will regret their rejection of Labour. It will take years to rebuild Labour. The poor little Aucklanders couldnt handle the lockdowns which SAVED lives. The new bunch will be found out in no 😢time at all
Indeed the left has bn going down and confused for a long time with big iwi corporates getting sucked in by mandates it will take a long time to rebuild trust and relationships.
Lets be honest, this has nothing to do with lockdowns. It has everything to do with the ram raids that followed the lockdowns and the lack of action to arrest the escalating crime in the area.
Auckland lockdowns ....dont ever 4get it
Woods hair too slimey....and personality
What a dork lol
Vomit
Cry about it
Wear a bucket.
Looked in the mirror dikhed@@AilsaPehi
A Phd with no substance in his speech, what on earth did I get from this interview? buch of words but nothing.
He answered the questions he was asked, and he did that clearly and concisely. But obviously you were not gonna like him anyway... 😂😂
@@theradfactor9104 Commies obviously dont like someone who want people to work to make a living. Some people have pipedreams of unlimited money just growing on trees
The issue is Pacific Islander and Maori doesn't want to work, grow or proser, they are to comfortable on the Benefits. Now they are blocking the health system, just go to ED 80% of them are P.I waiting in line!
As a conservative national supporter who happens to be a Pacific Islander, MY SENTIMENTS EXACTLY! This is the reason why many Pacific Islanders and Maori are always living below the average living standards they don't as they did before cherish hardwork, self-reliance, independence, and self supported. But since the government keeps increasing the benefits, they have grown accustomed to the victim mentality and therefore grown attached to dependence on government assistance. It's vicious.
Shut your mouth there are a lot of people who are unable to work due to mental health or other disability issues and they're not maori/pasifika.
Take your foreign interloper racist garbage back to where you came from secondhand Kiwi
You sound like a colonised islander keeping your white master happy, happy to live on stolen Maori land and complain about the bad old Maori/Pasifika on benefits, white collar tax evasion crime is in the billions ya clown. Youre a joke @@HouseOfAntioch
Sadly that’s what the stats show us, but don’t you think the better way of approaching things are to invest in the people?
For example incentivising people of P.I. or Maori background to study and work in higher income work such as STEM? I don’t believe that they are lazy, there isn’t much role model in their community at the moment.
I appreciate your sentiment about the need of working hard and you get what you worked for, but simply bashing this community will only widen the wealth gap, resulting in more you guessed it, crime.
Mt Roskill MP has never been seen in the community 🤣🤦🏽♂️ guys a flop