ru guys dont listen when giselle sing "su su supernova" at first, its have a "ph" voice on her mic 😂😂 they not lipsync, ru all jealous coz ur idol cannot stable like this??? poor girl
Right!! Ppl don't believe them because they sound exactly like the studio. While if they watch their encore. They sounds the same like this. Ppl forget they are singer singing their song. Of course they gonna sounds the same like the original song or the studio version
@@Israhellgonnagetdestroyedsoon YAAP, SM ent choose vocal stable when the idols dance, not the visual, but haters must know, SM pick a perfect person!! can rap, vocal. the visual also good, SM artist have same vocal as mv, and the haters come jealous 😂😂
@@Linlin-jr9oo yea ik their vocals are insane✨✨im just saying that its rlly obvious its prerecorded and its sad bc sm rarely lets them sing live :( im a MY btw and im not hating towards them
@heartsforkarinasx aespa are my faves😭😭😭 this is me genuinely saying sm artists typically dont sing live but they definitely can. Like back to aespas coachella stage they did amazing !! but this show right here isnt live however i cant wait to see a supernova encore stage
This is actually pre record. I know pretty well that Aespa can sing live really good (i always watch their live stage). But lets praise their live stage when its ACTUALLY LIVE, not pre record. Bcuz it seem like u guys all deaf
Its so funny people still arguing if this is live or not. When karina herself already confirmed it on her bubble that they singing live, and the mic was on here. Yes its pre recorded, but all groups doing pre recorded rn, the only live on mushow is just the interview. What is people thinkin, If they live when the program is on air why all the groups need to come to the studio since morning, just came when its time for the program. All we saw in on air program is just the arrangement of pre recorded video. 😂😂
Ngakak banget bacain tiap komen di video yg ada anak aespa mr.removed begini selalu banyak haters yg ngaku² fans terus komennya ngejatuhin aespa, pdhl kalau fans asli mah tau gimana talentednya mereka. pake segala bawa² sayang banget mereka prerecord lah mereka gak live tp lipsing lah KLISE banget. Fans kok ngetajuhin idolnya sendiri 😂😂😂
This is lip silencing i am 1000% sure this is done in le sserafim too they added small ways to prove there not lip silencing but I am not fucking stupid!
@@lina-9652 are u deaf? Its clearly pre record. Just watch other live stage by Aespa (when they using backtrack, watch the mr remover) and u can tell the difference
u can tell its pre-recorded as winters mouth movements don't match up to the sound (in first short of this performance), but it wouldn't surprise me if aespa could pull off a live performance like this anyways plus MOST groups always have a pre-recorded first performance to start off promotions
Ngakak banget bacain tiap komen di video yg ada anak aespa mr.removed begini selalu banyak haters yg ngaku² fans terus komennya ngejatuhin aespa, pdhl kalau fans asli mah tau gimana talentednya mereka. pake segala bawa² sayang banget mereka prerecord lah mereka gak live tp lipsing lah KLISE banget. Fans kok ngetajuhin idolnya sendiri 😂😂😂
Wintahh improved stage presence sm like gurly!!??🤯
Btw their vocals are serving
Yes Winter's improvement could be seen evidently from Spicy era
Her stage presence went for savage era na. One of her fancam @@five8193
@@five8193She's the Acer🔥
에스파보단 뉴진스
@@searchtiangcat no one cares
Keep singing live until people think you're lipsync. My respects to you aespa
LTRLLYYY
뉴진스 미만 잡 ㅋ
@@searchtiangcat 그런 말 하지 마세요.
뉴진스도 정말 멋지고 재능이 있어요
@@searchtiangcat뉴진스 심각하던데요
@@searchtiangcatoh just stfu
just winters vocals serving us😍
*Of course its Aespa, the least you can do is to doubt their live vocals❤❤*
SM have a good vocal and visual😊
겨울이 왔어요!!
이런가수없죠잉❤
라이브 에이알인데 이런가수 없죠잉 이러네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
얘네보다 잘하는 가수 널려있는데? 약 80억 인구 중에서 잘하는 가수가 에스파만 있다고 생각함..? 에스파가 노래 잘한다는 걸 말하고 싶으면 다른 방식으로 얘기해야지ㅋㅋ 진짜 수준ㅜ
Vocals are vocaling 😍
STOP😭😭 i was blasting songs in the car and supernova came up my mother asked me why the ad is so long😭😭🦟
Lmao 😂 that's shady
@@helenapopotinha2755 ikrr
Winter is really cool with that hairstyle .
헐~ 헤메코 넘 예쁘다
They should have sang live in their debut
SM doesn’t want their idols to sing live most of the time Even if they sing live sm will still put the Record ones
OK but say "SM" cus it's not them. And they sang black mamba live multiple times in their debut ya'll just ignored it.
stabil banget astagaaa pecaaahhh oii, menyala aespakuu 🔥🔥🔥
Stan for kpop singer who can sing😊
ru guys dont listen when giselle sing "su su supernova" at first, its have a "ph" voice on her mic 😂😂 they not lipsync, ru all jealous coz ur idol cannot stable like this??? poor girl
Right!! Ppl don't believe them because they sound exactly like the studio. While if they watch their encore. They sounds the same like this. Ppl forget they are singer singing their song. Of course they gonna sounds the same like the original song or the studio version
@@Israhellgonnagetdestroyedsoon YAAP, SM ent choose vocal stable when the idols dance, not the visual, but haters must know, SM pick a perfect person!! can rap, vocal. the visual also good, SM artist have same vocal as mv, and the haters come jealous 😂😂
you're SO right, but let's not degrade other artists.
NingNing slayed❤❤❤❤🎉
Aespa proving everyone that you can have stable vocals even with intensive choreo.
Its prerecorded
@@kpopqueencard that doesn't change the fact that they have stable vocals even if you don't count this vid
@@Linlin-jr9oo yea ik their vocals are insane✨✨im just saying that its rlly obvious its prerecorded and its sad bc sm rarely lets them sing live :( im a MY btw and im not hating towards them
SM is training the girls SP 🔛🔝🙌
I can’t stop hearing 😭
“ Bring the the light of a dinosaur”
Whyyyyy 😭😭😭😭😭
Idek 🤣
Wow
Damn they really are something
Wow !!!
Y’all realize majority of stages are pre recorded right
No hate i think this is pre recording no 100% live
@heartsforkarinasxno but this is definitely pre recorded... sm idols usually dont sing live during music bank shows
@heartsforkarinasx aespa are my faves😭😭😭 this is me genuinely saying sm artists typically dont sing live but they definitely can. Like back to aespas coachella stage they did amazing !! but this show right here isnt live however i cant wait to see a supernova encore stage
This is actually pre record. I know pretty well that Aespa can sing live really good (i always watch their live stage). But lets praise their live stage when its ACTUALLY LIVE, not pre record. Bcuz it seem like u guys all deaf
This is live...you can literally hear Giselle and winters live voice. Even Karina confirmed it on bubble
if it’s pre-recorded, why didn’t she make the same for le serafim it’s Mr removed are you deaf?
Its so funny people still arguing if this is live or not. When karina herself already confirmed it on her bubble that they singing live, and the mic was on here. Yes its pre recorded, but all groups doing pre recorded rn, the only live on mushow is just the interview. What is people thinkin, If they live when the program is on air why all the groups need to come to the studio since morning, just came when its time for the program. All we saw in on air program is just the arrangement of pre recorded video. 😂😂
Ngakak banget bacain tiap komen di video yg ada anak aespa mr.removed begini selalu banyak haters yg ngaku² fans terus komennya ngejatuhin aespa, pdhl kalau fans asli mah tau gimana talentednya mereka. pake segala bawa² sayang banget mereka prerecord lah mereka gak live tp lipsing lah KLISE banget. Fans kok ngetajuhin idolnya sendiri 😂😂😂
can u do tripleS girls never die❤
노래여??
에스파 노래 잘하는건 아는데,
이건 그냥 live ar인거 아님?
엔믹스 블핑도 허리 숙이고 스텝 밟고 저러는데 저렇게 안흔들리진 않음
바지정보아시는분???
스엠 원래 1즈차때는 라이브 안해서 이거 라이브 아닐텐데
원래 그게 전통이었는데.. 카리나 피셜 이번에 라이브라고 밝혔네요 립싱크하면 밉보일 시기라 그런듯
@@김선빈-c9k아니 립싱크 아녔어요??? ㅁㅊ 걱정했었는데 라이브라니
This is lip silencing i am 1000% sure this is done in le sserafim too they added small ways to prove there not lip silencing but I am not fucking stupid!
pre recorded pls
그냥 녹음한거 아닌가..? 아무리 잘해도 이정도는 불가능인데..
That's pre recorded!!
Nope
if it’s pre-recorded, why didn’t she make the same for le serafim it’s Mr removed are you deaf?
i dont think this is fully live 🤔
Its pre record
@seuluvr yes but the others vocals sound pre recorded
@@chaeyofx they stop singing sometimes but this stage is live!
@@Jodohnya__Jodohku if it’s pre-recorded, why didn’t she make the same for le serafim it’s Mr removed are you deaf?
@@lina-9652 are u deaf? Its clearly pre record. Just watch other live stage by Aespa (when they using backtrack, watch the mr remover) and u can tell the difference
*Bang PD wishes, he wanted Minheejin to step on aespa but Hybe cant even surpass Aespa's vocals oh damn😂*
Mhj gg can't beat these girls, aespa vocal too good to be step on. They better step back 😂
a senior group like Aespa shouldn’t be using pre-record at this day and age
Hey i love your videos and was curious as to why you only make shorts for ggs and not bgs like seventeen
No hate but isnt this prerec??? Like i love them but im really doubting that its live 😔
에스파 이 무대 라이브 아니라서 mr 제거해도 음원처럼 나오는거임
원래 스엠은 1주차땐 라이브 안해
그니깐 아니라고 했잖아
Karina even said on bubble that it was live how much longer are people going to deny aespa live vocals?
This stage isn't live vocals
카리나가 버블로 라이브라 했음 엠카였나
Giselle’s low voice is so attractive lol
Their vocals are not a joke
그냥 AR인 것 같은디..? 숨소리 안 들리고, 음정 아예 안 흔들리고 목소리 큼, 작음도 안 바뀌면서 일정하고.. (노래 못한다고 억까하는거 x)
What? R u deaf fr? how can u not hear the "pfffhhh" in their singing?
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 숨소리가 이렇게 잘 들리는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그 단월드가면 아렇게 되는건가? 막 들리는것도 안들리게 되고?
Юна как на родном шпарит
LiveAR
완전 콜걸어네
걸래둘.!!!!:
닝닝 트와이스 니연 닳은뜻.(?)
아씨..오타 ...
It is lip sync They using Live ar
u can tell its pre-recorded as winters mouth movements don't match up to the sound (in first short of this performance), but it wouldn't surprise me if aespa could pull off a live performance like this anyways
plus MOST groups always have a pre-recorded first performance to start off promotions
Não gosto das roupas..
Yall know sm singers can sing so who cares if it’s prerecord or not …. Comment the hate for hybe groups not THEE aespa .
Ngakak banget bacain tiap komen di video yg ada anak aespa mr.removed begini selalu banyak haters yg ngaku² fans terus komennya ngejatuhin aespa, pdhl kalau fans asli mah tau gimana talentednya mereka. pake segala bawa² sayang banget mereka prerecord lah mereka gak live tp lipsing lah KLISE banget. Fans kok ngetajuhin idolnya sendiri 😂😂😂