Thanks for watching Rob! I am a huge fan of yours so it means a lot that you commented on this and the other video and that you enjoyed them! Keep doing what your doing!
@@briwuwas waiting until I saw the producer Rob Ruccia first so I could ask him about it :) He’s the one who has the raw stems He’ll be reaching out sometime soon to hand those over 🤘
You know, I found something pretty interesting about their making of that album when I saw it, the ironic mirroring to the late Lennon-McCartney dynamic with Andrew having an explosion of creativity like Paul while Rob was in a bit of a dispiriting slump like John. I almost wonder if there was some kind of vibe thing being in that place creating emotional echoes, or something like that.
I hope Rob and Andrew do an episode on what you did, this deserves recognition and I have a feeling it's just a matter of time before it goes viral. Keep up the great work!
Thank you! I would love for them to react to this or something but sadly I don't think that's the type of content they make. Both Rob and Andrew have commented on the other video of the full album so that is super cool!
Arghhhhh….Im a first generation Beatles fan and thanks to them I became a guitarist and vocalist…..also into recording. I started out on reel to reel and now use Logic Audio. This is a whole other thing. I’m undecided whether I like the future of music used this way. I’m sure John would have been amused. What I would say is create your own music like The Beatles did with your own vocals.
I think creating your own music in the style of the Beatles is awesome but if you've already done that I think it's a cool little experiment to see what it might sound like with the Beatles voices
Hi man, that was freaking awesome 👍😎. The Beatles and FOO were the ones that made me fell in love with music again, and hearing both of them at the same time it's magic. Also, i see a lot of non beatles songs sang by beatles with IA, but most of them are awful, yours definitely not!! Congratulations!! By the way, so glad you didn't put the original beatle stereo, it's much better this way (they know it and now they are remixing everything 😂😂)
One tiny nitpick! The effect George has on his vocals on Not Guilty and Blue Jay Way were done by feeding it through a Leslie speaker. Those speakers were designed to be used with Hammond organs to make them sound more like real organs but the Beatles were one of the first bands to use it with vocals. I think the first song they used it on was Tomorrow Never Knows. It’s not exactly the same sound as a phaser but there’s some great plugins that replicate it pretty much perfectly. Logic Pro has one built in. All in all it sounds really cool tho, love the idea and the video explaining how you did it is super interesting!
I do know it was a Leslie but I was just saying I was inspired by the sound of them not the exact technique used to create them. I also just wanted an example to compare to. I think a phaser is a good way to get a similar effect and it managed to get what I was going for. Glad you enjoyed the video!
I listened to the original album many times on repeat when it came out in October. Listening to it once again with The Beatles singing it was great. I love it when AI is used for good things. You did an outstanding job.
Very good stuff. The vocals on Dorian were especially superb. I noticed some comments were calling it disrespectful and whatever, because you "stole" their voices. As a young Beatles fan, a true Beatles fan appreciates creativity. Anyway, can't wait for more stuff, keep it up buddy 👍
You said it's not perfect. You're right. Is it entertaining? Oh hell yeah it is. It's clearly a labour of love and that shines through. Thank you for this ❤️
@@clynaackThe Beatles made the road name famous (by using it as the name for their last recorded album). In the mid-seventies, EMI wanted to capitalise on their Beatles connection (and attract non-EMI artists to record there) so ‘rebranded’ to Abbey Road Studios. So it wasn’t named after the album, it was named after the road which the Beatles had popularised BECAUSE of the Beatles connection. Connection, not album. I hope that made sense, I’ve rewritten it 10 times 😂 Let’s put it this way… it’s not called Let It Be Studios or Sgt Pepper Studios…. coz it’s named after the road.
I mean I guess you can look at it either way. All I'm saying is that it wouldn't be called Abby road studios if the Beatles album wasn't called that. So in my opinion it's: the road is called Abby road the Beatles then named the album after it then emi renamed it after the Beatles album that is named after the road rather than directly after the road
I dunno, that rationalization just seems intellectually dishonest. There's certainly a conversation to be had about all of this, but if your starting point is using a cultural artifact in ways that another person finds fundamentally offensive, are you really "sharing" it with them?
Awesome! This newer software and AI will help keep The Beatles alive and well for a long time. Once this software becomes more sophisticated Its' gonna be incredible. Keep up the good work. Cheers.
@@clynaack when paul mcartney wrote 'get back' in less than an hour he had already penned several hits. what we have here is like cargo cult natives constructing a facsimile and fooling other cargo cult natives with it
@@clynaack you clearly show your lifting original Beatles material and munipulatng it mate. Your not the only one there is a flood of Beatles AI songs on utube.
Would you mind telling me what you dislike about it and why? Considering that both members of the First Of October love this idea and it's exactly up their alley of content I just don't get how a fan of them can say "This is not ok.". A little more context would be nice!
@@clynaack I'm not ok with the use of ai in creative content. Period. I think it puts thousands out of a job needlessly, and I feel it has no place in creative work. There are exceptions, but honestly I normally don't care unless it was a major big media company doing it, I was honestly just in a pissy mood, you can do it for a small project
The fact that you can do these things (or anyone for that matter) doesn't mean that you should. You're using dead people's voices and the remaining members of the Beatles didn't give you permission to do this. That should be enough of a red flag, but you just decided this was a good idea anyway. This is counterfeit music. This is disrespectful. Btw. A mellotron is not a synthesizer.
![โฮ่ง! (SUGOI) - LYKN [ OFFICIAL MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nFp4zjAARFs/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow…
So surreal
Amazing work
Thank you so much for this 🙏
DAAAMN
Thanks for watching Rob! I am a huge fan of yours so it means a lot that you commented on this and the other video and that you enjoyed them! Keep doing what your doing!
So are you going to give him the harmonies?
@@briwuwas waiting until I saw the producer Rob Ruccia first so I could ask him about it :)
He’s the one who has the raw stems
He’ll be reaching out sometime soon to hand those over 🤘
@@robscallon Could you make them available public for remixes etc.?
You know, I found something pretty interesting about their making of that album when I saw it, the ironic mirroring to the late Lennon-McCartney dynamic with Andrew having an explosion of creativity like Paul while Rob was in a bit of a dispiriting slump like John. I almost wonder if there was some kind of vibe thing being in that place creating emotional echoes, or something like that.
I thought the exact same thing
I hope Rob and Andrew do an episode on what you did, this deserves recognition and I have a feeling it's just a matter of time before it goes viral. Keep up the great work!
Thank you! I would love for them to react to this or something but sadly I don't think that's the type of content they make. Both Rob and Andrew have commented on the other video of the full album so that is super cool!
Cool! Its great to hear John's and George's voices again
Thank you!
As a viewer of Andrew/Rob and a Beatles fan, I love this!
Thank you!
Arghhhhh….Im a first generation Beatles fan and thanks to them I became a guitarist and vocalist…..also into recording. I started out on reel to reel and now use Logic Audio. This is a whole other thing. I’m undecided whether I like the future of music used this way. I’m sure John would have been amused. What I would say is create your own music like The Beatles did with your own vocals.
I think creating your own music in the style of the Beatles is awesome but if you've already done that I think it's a cool little experiment to see what it might sound like with the Beatles voices
@andrewhuang @robscallon need to see this immediately
Haha thanks!
Awesome stuff man! Super interesting and well done my friend.
I'm a huge Beatles fan & I still can't fathom how much thought and effort you put into this video, respect bro o.o
Thank you so much!
Hi man, that was freaking awesome 👍😎. The Beatles and FOO were the ones that made me fell in love with music again, and hearing both of them at the same time it's magic.
Also, i see a lot of non beatles songs sang by beatles with IA, but most of them are awful, yours definitely not!! Congratulations!!
By the way, so glad you didn't put the original beatle stereo, it's much better this way (they know it and now they are remixing everything 😂😂)
Glad you enjoyed it!
Interesting. Worked out better than I thought it was going to at the start, honestly. Had a laugh at Paul singing all of Imagine!
Thanks! Yeah the imagine bit was funnier than expected!
One tiny nitpick! The effect George has on his vocals on Not Guilty and Blue Jay Way were done by feeding it through a Leslie speaker. Those speakers were designed to be used with Hammond organs to make them sound more like real organs but the Beatles were one of the first bands to use it with vocals. I think the first song they used it on was Tomorrow Never Knows. It’s not exactly the same sound as a phaser but there’s some great plugins that replicate it pretty much perfectly. Logic Pro has one built in.
All in all it sounds really cool tho, love the idea and the video explaining how you did it is super interesting!
I do know it was a Leslie but I was just saying I was inspired by the sound of them not the exact technique used to create them. I also just wanted an example to compare to. I think a phaser is a good way to get a similar effect and it managed to get what I was going for. Glad you enjoyed the video!
I listened to the original album many times on repeat when it came out in October. Listening to it once again with The Beatles singing it was great. I love it when AI is used for good things. You did an outstanding job.
Thanks for listening
Very good stuff. The vocals on Dorian were especially superb. I noticed some comments were calling it disrespectful and whatever, because you "stole" their voices. As a young Beatles fan, a true Beatles fan appreciates creativity. Anyway, can't wait for more stuff, keep it up buddy 👍
Thanks for that!
@@clynaack no problem bro
Absolutely incredible, dude. INCREDIBLE!!!
Glad you like it!
You said it's not perfect. You're right. Is it entertaining? Oh hell yeah it is. It's clearly a labour of love and that shines through. Thank you for this ❤️
Thank you! Great comment!
I've said before that First of October albums sound like what McCartney IV would sound like so this is a dream for me
great work! you could have put Izotope vinyl for a more 60's sounding feel
Thanks! Also good call
O my god such a good imagination and creativity. Congrats.
Thank you very much!
Sounds much like the Rutles! :)
Don't tell anyone but none of this is AI and I secretly just got Ron nasty and Dirk mcquckly in the studio to record the vocals 🤫
"It's Good To Be Back" and "Dorian" have already made it onto my personal a.i. Album....Thank You!
Awesome I'm glad to hear! Thanks for watching!
Really impressive! I hope you get the harmony stems and can work some more magic. Still sounds great as is.
I should be getting the harmony's soon so stay tuned! Thanks for watching!
I surely enjoyed the concept.
Thanks?
this is awesome, you’re awesome!
Thanks!
You could have used artificial double tracking too instead of re-recording some vocal parts, just like John Lennon would have done. ;-)
EMI Studios wasn’t renamed after the Beatles album!
Both were named after the road that EMI Studios sits on.
That could be right but I dont think thats correct. The Beatles album was named after the road and then the studio was re-named after the album!
@@clynaackThe Beatles made the road name famous (by using it as the name for their last recorded album).
In the mid-seventies, EMI wanted to capitalise on their Beatles connection (and attract non-EMI artists to record there) so ‘rebranded’ to Abbey Road Studios.
So it wasn’t named after the album, it was named after the road which the Beatles had popularised BECAUSE of the Beatles connection.
Connection, not album.
I hope that made sense, I’ve rewritten it 10 times 😂
Let’s put it this way… it’s not called Let It Be Studios or Sgt Pepper Studios…. coz it’s named after the road.
I mean I guess you can look at it either way. All I'm saying is that it wouldn't be called Abby road studios if the Beatles album wasn't called that. So in my opinion it's: the road is called Abby road the Beatles then named the album after it then emi renamed it after the Beatles album that is named after the road rather than directly after the road
@@clynaackYou are correct ❤
The most debased, ungodly heresy assaulting my ears!
And I liked it! I liked it!
Who the hell listens to the early Beatles music in stereo?
Im not sure what to say to this lol
The old guys in the comment section can’t handle it when newer generations want to share the same interests as them 😪
Yeah it really is unfortunate
I dunno, that rationalization just seems intellectually dishonest.
There's certainly a conversation to be had about all of this, but if your starting point is using a cultural artifact in ways that another person finds fundamentally offensive, are you really "sharing" it with them?
Great video 😀
Thanks! 😀
where did you get the voices ?
Found them all on the AI HUB discord server!
Can u recreate my friend’s dream?
The Beatles Album: Typewriter
Popular track: Fly High 🦅 (first song with Emoji)
that actually sounds super interesting lol
the mellotron is not a synthesizer. It's a sampler
True
the spotify link dosnt work for me i genuinly want to listen to the album
Thanks for letting me know! Ive updated it now!
Can't wait to hear it when it is done.
It is done!
th-cam.com/video/jUmE1A6r9D0/w-d-xo.html
This. Is. AMAZING
Thank you!!
Incredible vid!!!
Thanks!!
Doesn't sound anything like the Beatles. Sorry, but someone had to say it.
Maybe not the songwriting but I think the voices really do
no se porque estos videos no tienen millones de vistas son unos cracks
Gracias
Awesome! This newer software and AI will help keep The Beatles alive and well for a long time. Once this software becomes more sophisticated Its' gonna be incredible. Keep up the good work. Cheers.
Thanks!
the only problem is i am sure that beatles will not write these kind of awful songs
I think they are fantastic songs especially considering each one was written in less than an hour. Bet you couldn't do better
@@clynaack when paul mcartney wrote 'get back' in less than an hour he had already penned several hits. what we have here is like cargo cult natives constructing a facsimile and fooling other cargo cult natives with it
I remember when they made a fake Beatles album in the 70's and called it Klaatu.
I love klaatu! Such an underrated band!
Why don't try writing n recording your own songs instead of ripping off the Beatles
I don't think you watched the video lol
@@clynaack you clearly show your lifting original Beatles material and munipulatng it mate.
Your not the only one there is a flood of Beatles AI songs on utube.
I like this
Thanks!
Thanks!
What's the point???????
What's the point of anything?
@@clynaack why "fix" something that doesn't need fixing? I guess you were bored.
Curious is the word
i kind of did this aswell but 80% more lazy xD
Nice!
No, this is not ok. I’m not even a fan of the Beatles, but I had so much respect for First of October. This is not ok.
Would you mind telling me what you dislike about it and why? Considering that both members of the First Of October love this idea and it's exactly up their alley of content I just don't get how a fan of them can say "This is not ok.". A little more context would be nice!
@@clynaack I'm not ok with the use of ai in creative content. Period. I think it puts thousands out of a job needlessly, and I feel it has no place in creative work.
There are exceptions, but honestly I normally don't care unless it was a major big media company doing it, I was honestly just in a pissy mood, you can do it for a small project
The fact that you can do these things (or anyone for that matter) doesn't mean that you should. You're using dead people's voices and the remaining members of the Beatles didn't give you permission to do this. That should be enough of a red flag, but you just decided this was a good idea anyway. This is counterfeit music. This is disrespectful. Btw. A mellotron is not a synthesizer.
Bro it's just a fun little experiment if you don't like it then don't watch it. It's as simple as that
I'm quite fascinated by these new technologies, but it's becoming very clear that it will not end well.
Cyberdyne Beatle: Model 1 Wing 1
Im slightly confused haha
@@clynaack The beginning of the end. The first piece of Skynet.
Hmmm…. 🤔
Hmmmmmm
TH-cam is destroying The Beatles.
TH-cam is helping their legacy live on!
❌
I love a good bit of constructive criticism
Please don’t do this..
I always love a bit of solid well thought out constructive criticism!
@@clynaackit's the most constructive and well prepared comment on the entire thread.
No?
You should not be doing that 😭 booooo
You must be fun at party's
@@clynaack just to be clear, I love the Beatles, but I hate AI, that's what I meant, sorry 😞
It's cursed. Honestly don't like it
What don't you like about it? Just do I have some feedback!
Boooo
Booooo
Just STOP!!!
Nah
This is the real Everyday Chemistry ❤
I wouldn't say it's quite as good but thank you!