@@TheChristian50 He knew sooner or later he is gonna die. He also knew that John will have the same fate as the Pinkertons lead by Ross would come after him afterwards...
@@TemmieContingenCIt isn't just plot armor, it's well written considering Arthur and Dutch and the other gunslingers in the gang are supposed to be lifelong shooters who basically shoot for a living every single day of their life. Majority of the army started when they were young adults.
The Ending Of This Mission made me think Dutch still hasn't gone incredibly crazy. If Dutch were completely crazy now, he wouldn't have helped Arthur get out of the river. He also never left Arthur while running, and best of all, he still planned on getting Eagle Flies out of the prison.
Dutch lost it when Hosea died , you can see how it gradually breaks him down and changes him , it's a losing battle and deep down he knows it, "have faith" is the plea of never give up hope, but there's only so much a silver tounged fox like Dutch can get away with , Arthur back in Lemonye started to have his doubts during the Gray's and Braithwaite feude. I would love to see a origins story for RDR3
Mozrow Dutch’s madness was caused by his inability to truly fight back against growing civilization; Hosea’s death merely exacerbated it. There’s signs before that, particularly in his execution of the Blackwater girl.
The plan of noise was a decent plan but fuckin with the army?dutch should have just sabotaged the bridge and left the indians alone and make more muneh.I really didnt get why arthur and john didnt understand dutches plan.
@@hoseinmz645 exactly... Making noise was very decent idea for gang's survival. Dutch had analyzed indian situation carefully and thus cleverly thought of causing destruction, and army would naturally think it's done by indians and law will move on to them. Direct involvement of eagle flies would have enough proof for government that it was all done by indians and not by outlaw gang, giving gang plenty of space to escape. Everyone understood the plan including John and Arthur. But they were not happy with it and were rather shocked. Not because plan wasn't good, but because this plan was against principles that Dutch himself had taught them. He was literally using indians and that could result in massacre of already weak community. He wasn't like this before. Remember that scene where bill says "indians were savages" And Dutch gives lecture on that? Or when Arthur mentions that Dutch had scolded him for Robbing poor man? He had completely gone crazy at this point and was acting against his own principles. That's what made Arthur mad and he started thinking Dutch wasn't man he thought he was
he didn't abandon Arthur here because Arthur was still useful to him, not because he wasn't in cuckooland. i also think the 'noise and smoke' plan was a sham which was never guaranteed to work since the gang's profile was much too high to ignore and imo operating discreetly on the process of slipping out in smaller groups (like what eventually happened as they began to fall apart) would've been far more effective. they were pursued by a dedicated team of investigators in the Pinkertons (whom Dutch seemingly forgot about during chapter 6), and they had caused unnecessary trouble in nearly every state they'd previously tried to 'lay low' simply because Dutch never planned on actually keeping a low profile. siccing one group onto another didn't work against the Greys and Braithwaites in chapter 3, it didn't work against the Pinkertons during the big bank heist in chapter 4, and predictably enough it failed dismally here as well. to claim that anything Dutch did from chapter 3 onwards is clever bears no difference from claiming that pigs are graceful flyers. even the Cornwall train robbery at the beginning was a bad idea.
@@dendyhafizhan6243 Agreed, his story is extremely tragic. Having dreams that he knows will never come true and knowing that his reason for living is a lie.
10:19 He sounds Like Hosea So Much, Like he literally took his place after The Bank robbery fail, Only Dutch wouldn’t Listen and instead Followed Micah :( If That was Hosea saying that I bet Dutch would of stood And thought for a second But Because it was Arthur Ofc Dutch came up with the excuse of “I know i know” When he very much clearly doesn’t, It’s so sad how the tables turned so fast
Dutch probably never questioned Hosea when he’d provide input because he saw him as an equal, but when Arthur does it, he sees it as insubordination because he sees Arthur more as a son and someone he raised. The only reason it worked for Micah was because Micah kissed ass and spoke to Dutch’s irrational side in a way where it came off as encouraging and non-demanding. The writing here was impeccable 💯
Funny there’s a video of someone playing this mission, they manage to kill every army soldier except for the one sniper soldier on top of the cliff who’s in God Mode because Rockstar doesn’t want the player to be creative
15:31 I just got passed this mission and I literally stood there just to see if Dutch would say "Our time has passed Captain" and then jumps off, but nope Dutch didn't say it.
"We cant fight nature, We cant fight gravity, we cant fight change. We cant fight nothin. My whole life, all i ever did was fight. Our time has passed, john." - Dutch van der linde's last words before committing suicide
If anybody is having trouble getting the headshots, right before you trigger the cutscene at 13:58, face the onslaught, and soldiers literally spawn and respawn as you cut them out down.
countof3everybodyOD I literally did the same thing to get that 35 headshot mark. Nearly died because of it though so be careful and quick with your shots
Dutch always says that words when he knows there is no way to escape and he is on a cliff, he says you can't fight nature, you can't fight change, you can't fight gravity.
When the army surrounded dutch nd arthur U can try figting them, by aiming, it automatically goes into dead eye nd arthur will die same as john marston in rdr1.
Yeah, even dutch will start shooting the army, but will eventually die too, even though u select every army member with manual selection in dead eye n shoot them, there are few more that are on side hill, which u cant kill in given time window, no after cutscene like rdr1 tho, worth a try
Bro snake oil is a real historical thing. Dead eye is just a game mechanic. Snake oil was basically a con to sell this liquid for ridiculous prices. It's a fraud, a lie. Think of Nigel West Dickens in the first game
Dutch as president: The general public: "President Dutch, how are we gonna make America great again?" Dutch: I have a plan. We just need faith, and muneh."
Why arthur keeps questioning and doubting dutch is because he doesn't like seeing dutch like this like killing people in cold blood and he doesn't want dutch to be like micah
The music in the mission is similar to a track called “The Disaster” but the other part when Arthur and Dutch run from the army is unknown as far as I’m aware.
Dutch: I’m trying, Arthur. And I’ll keep trying, and you’ll keep doubting, and we’ll keep failing! Arthur: it ain’t like that, Dutch. Look at me. Look at me! *dutch looks at arthur* High honor Arthur: I’m just....I’m worried about folk... Low honor Arthur: I’m just...this ain’t how we do things! Dutch: I know! I- *Ka boom!!* (sorry I love this mission)
It's funny how some of these missions in the trophy guide I got this video from are supposed to be harder to get gold on, yet most of the harder ones for me seem to be the ones rated between a 1/5 to 2/5. The one I found this video in says this is a 3.5/5, yet it was extremely easy for me. I just rushed to the canon right after the first shot hit and killed the guy, then farmed the rest of the headshots before triggering the cutscene that leads to jumping off the cliff.
The whole story was poorly edited. It's like they changed the story and missions over the year (after Trailer 2) to make it more different in the end instead of happy and continue with different character. Even NA looks like reused and poorly edited (not by the desert, but by the buildings/houses/objects). You can notice by dialogues, forgot to edit it. It's good game, but extra year would've been better to they make everything alright. I'm just disappointed on having less snow on north-west part, making the hunter outfit, well, useless. They should've went with more northern parts with more snow to the east and NA being as the story add-on DLC.
@@xXSilentAgent47Xx Sounds like some good ol' fashioned nitpicking. The game's great. A few glitches, that a lot of games have, by the way, and the game should've had an extra YEAR of development on those areas. I personally enjoyed NA, as it stayed true to the original in many aspects. I usually see your comments and enjoy them, but this seems nitpicky, my man.
+Smitty Werbenjagermanjesen Not exactly nitpicking as what you think, they even admitted that the story had several changes and it has 5h cut contents. What you said is subjective, what people say is it's boring, slow paced, annoying tapping X/A button on horse, holding to pick something up (even looting, which is repetitive. Should've been in The Witcher 3 looting system) and it has clunky controls. There's more info in Metacritic said by everyone who played it. Tbh i do understand what they mean by that and i don't thinks it's great. Game have big problems and it could've been better. Camp system is useless, all of companions just sit there and look pretty instead to put some money in charity box (only Micah did once) and bring foods, then Grimshaw comes all mad at you for not refilling everything looking like you're the only sheep and she's shepherd. I wish they could've replaced that to companion activities because i'd rather enjoy getting drunk with Lenny than seeing them interrupting me when i listen some conversations from others. There's no Liar's Dice, no Arm Wrestling, no cheating in poker from previous game. There's no horse racing either. We never saw Blackwater Massacre chapter, probably cut and saving for SP/Online DLC or completely erased in that 5h they admitted. You know, in The Witcher 3 you be rewarded for doing them all, GTA 5 did have similar thing with parachuting (unlimited parachute bags equipped on characters). They could've done something about that. Perhaps less button tapping A/X and more fast riding as being the reward for completing them all. Why we need big world when it doesn't have much to do than hunting? Just Cause 2 haves big world and it's filled with so many contents everywhere. The knife you collect are useless, they all have same stats. Whatever knife you equip to skin animals, it always switch to default one. Timing, don't use health items and don't get shot for gold medals is total ludicrous (which if you even replay, the items you own from save doesn't exist in inventory), worse of all the Dead Eye timing is playing on normal instead of being slow. NPC's like Micah walk and ride too slow, many people were frustrated with him during the missions like An American Pastoral Scene. Even me, took me 10 tries. Most of contents were already seen, while some minor contents like coach robbery exist. Perhaps blackjack is new, but big open world with nothing much to do is just boring. Especially Ambarino and NA, waste of disk space. It's not interesting to play much as i did The Witcher 3, previous RDR and GTA 4. Nothing else to do than hunting. Plus the story haves lazy writing. All they do is reusing same words: Faith, Money, Tahiti, Plan. People make meme out of it like with Sora's dialogues in KH games. Gun is still my favorite old west game. So many contents and rewards in the small world, but the story is very short. That's where R* took bounty - Eliminate or Alive | Alive/Dead and legendary animals idea for RDR.
P.S. When i said doin them all at GTA 5 unlimited parachute bags part, i mean horse racing. Most of trinkets are tied with hunting, i don't mean on those. I mean 5x better than panther saddle.
The second dutch said "This is a good one" I shouted at the screen thats exactly what you said before you jumped off a cliff not knowing he was about to do it again
"Air Calvary: an old (US Army) calvary unit that traded its horses for helicopters and went looking for the sh!t all over Vietnam..." Captain Willard, "Apocalypse,Now" 🙂
Well I mean imagine you're in close distance and the army sends soldiers to charge and kill you in large numbers while launching artillery, that's very terrifying
14:09 i actually pressed R2 to kill the soldiers killed middle but from the right we was killed it kinda looks like John's death i almost killed the soldiers (note Mauser has the largest pistol capacity Revolver only has 6 rounds) so wanna find out what happensif you use Mauser pistol on them!
After doing this the first time, my stats were all lowered to almost nothing, but I found out you can get them back by getting exp for the stat (I think), but I had maxed out energy before the mission, so now I can't get my energy back to normal. Please help. I beg.
Ah finally somebody notices that too. Yes that's right I think Eagle Flies inspired Dutch to create a gang of natives. But first Dutch uses him for silly reasons
@@masterm537 He didn't care about the Eagle and the others he just used them as a way of creating a distraction and after his original gang fell apart he remembered how easy it is to get young angry native americans to do his bidding and used them again for selfish reasons. He became like Colm O Driscoll if not worst by the end of his life.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - Mission #82 - The King's Son [Gold Medal]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lBo1puXrWV8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - Mission #82 - The King's Son [Gold Medal]](/img/tr.png)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - Mission #85 - Our Best Selves [Gold Medal]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZqGUwN1EGEA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - Mission #57 - Banking, The Old American Art [Gold Medal]](/img/n.gif)
RDR2: Dutch jumps off a cliff to live.
RDR1: Dutch jumps off a cliff to die.
Jimmy Sinclair It wasn't even a jump in RDR 1 lol
@@alexknight1991 More like a leap.
@@kolyasmirno9116 No he fell on purpose
@@alexknight1991 i know.The man give up on life.
*YEET*
"When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster. They have to... because they have to justify their wages. Our time has passed, John".
When I heard Dutch's speech in this mission, I got chills...
“that’s they’re business” god i love red dead 1 john, such a simple man
Can i shoot them all? Instead of jumping
Death pool 04
Dutch: just killed 100 soldiers
Also dutch: Hello, officers!
Also Dutch : Slowly backs off against the commands of the law with no consequences
You mean “Dutch: Killed 10 soldiers while Arthur killed the other 90”
@@patrick-xu1go even though, in our gameplay, Arthur kills the most enemies, but canonically both Arthur and Dutch have their equal amounts of kills
@@theundisputed8350 Pretty sure Arthur kills more since he's the toughest in there
Dutch and the indian: no one will die
Mission requirement: get 35 headsets.
Hmmm something's not adding up here
Crazy how in RDR1 when Dutch made that speech he jumped off a cliff too
He thought he was going to land in an oil well or something
thunder horse no im pretty sure he committed suicide on purpose
@@TheChristian50 yeah i know pretty sad ending for such a lovable character
@@TheChristian50 He knew sooner or later he is gonna die. He also knew that John will have the same fate as the Pinkertons lead by Ross would come after him afterwards...
@@fischerdaniel1196 Bureau*
The moment Dutch said that line, one thing pops in my head...
Oh please, let me land on the water.
9:59 That cavalry charge bugle call playing in the background sounds so terrifying for some reason
I get you
I was scared shitless
Its funny how some gang of cowboys ended up fighting an army with ARTILLERY
@@ramirez4365 And they won, at least with their lives.
@@theonlybigsmoke well considering how many times you catch bullets in this game, it’s just plot armour. Badass nonetheless
@@TemmieContingenCIt isn't just plot armor, it's well written considering Arthur and Dutch and the other gunslingers in the gang are supposed to be lifelong shooters who basically shoot for a living every single day of their life. Majority of the army started when they were young adults.
The Ending Of This Mission made me think Dutch still hasn't gone incredibly crazy. If Dutch were completely crazy now, he wouldn't have helped Arthur get out of the river. He also never left Arthur while running, and best of all, he still planned on getting Eagle Flies out of the prison.
Dutch lost it when Hosea died , you can see how it gradually breaks him down and changes him , it's a losing battle and deep down he knows it, "have faith" is the plea of never give up hope, but there's only so much a silver tounged fox like Dutch can get away with , Arthur back in Lemonye started to have his doubts during the Gray's and Braithwaite feude. I would love to see a origins story for RDR3
Mozrow Dutch’s madness was caused by his inability to truly fight back against growing civilization; Hosea’s death merely exacerbated it. There’s signs before that, particularly in his execution of the Blackwater girl.
The plan of noise was a decent plan but fuckin with the army?dutch should have just sabotaged the bridge and left the indians alone and make more muneh.I really didnt get why arthur and john didnt understand dutches plan.
@@hoseinmz645 exactly... Making noise was very decent idea for gang's survival. Dutch had analyzed indian situation carefully and thus cleverly thought of causing destruction, and army would naturally think it's done by indians and law will move on to them. Direct involvement of eagle flies would have enough proof for government that it was all done by indians and not by outlaw gang, giving gang plenty of space to escape. Everyone understood the plan including John and Arthur. But they were not happy with it and were rather shocked. Not because plan wasn't good, but because this plan was against principles that Dutch himself had taught them. He was literally using indians and that could result in massacre of already weak community. He wasn't like this before. Remember that scene where bill says "indians were savages" And Dutch gives lecture on that? Or when Arthur mentions that Dutch had scolded him for Robbing poor man? He had completely gone crazy at this point and was acting against his own principles. That's what made Arthur mad and he started thinking Dutch wasn't man he thought he was
he didn't abandon Arthur here because Arthur was still useful to him, not because he wasn't in cuckooland. i also think the 'noise and smoke' plan was a sham which was never guaranteed to work since the gang's profile was much too high to ignore and imo operating discreetly on the process of slipping out in smaller groups (like what eventually happened as they began to fall apart) would've been far more effective. they were pursued by a dedicated team of investigators in the Pinkertons (whom Dutch seemingly forgot about during chapter 6), and they had caused unnecessary trouble in nearly every state they'd previously tried to 'lay low' simply because Dutch never planned on actually keeping a low profile. siccing one group onto another didn't work against the Greys and Braithwaites in chapter 3, it didn't work against the Pinkertons during the big bank heist in chapter 4, and predictably enough it failed dismally here as well. to claim that anything Dutch did from chapter 3 onwards is clever bears no difference from claiming that pigs are graceful flyers.
even the Cornwall train robbery at the beginning was a bad idea.
We can't fight nature
We can't fight gravity
We can't fight change.
We can't fight nothin'.
I can't fight my own nature to, that paradox
That Dutch speech was the best line i have heard
@@dendyhafizhan6243 Agreed, his story is extremely tragic. Having dreams that he knows will never come true and knowing that his reason for living is a lie.
@@timothycochran4463 yes, now i understand why he was become insane at the end.
We cant fight a plan :P
15:31 sounds like Arthur said "YOUR MOM!!" lmao
Nick Rodriguez omg ye
That made me laugh
It’s your* get it right
YOUR MOM
Fuck sake lads! Lmao I'm sorry. I do this too often now 😅
That moment when the music kicks in and Dutch is looking down at the army man, chills.
Gotta say I love eagle flies defiant “ your humiliation of us has gone on enough” rebuttal to the army
that speech that Dutch gave brought me back to 2010 when i got RDR 1 shit I was so excited when he started to speak to those men
Fun Fact: When Arthur said "Poor fool from New Jersey 8:51" the actor, Roger Clark was born New Jersey
Born in New Jersey, raised in Ireland, yet does a pretty pretty pretty good southern accent:))!!!!
A poor fool of a soldier named Roger Clark from Alderney you mean.
10:19 He sounds Like Hosea So Much, Like he literally took his place after The Bank robbery fail, Only Dutch wouldn’t Listen and instead Followed Micah :( If That was Hosea saying that I bet Dutch would of stood And thought for a second But Because it was Arthur Ofc Dutch came up with the excuse of “I know i know” When he very much clearly doesn’t, It’s so sad how the tables turned so fast
Dutch probably never questioned Hosea when he’d provide input because he saw him as an equal, but when Arthur does it, he sees it as insubordination because he sees Arthur more as a son and someone he raised. The only reason it worked for Micah was because Micah kissed ass and spoke to Dutch’s irrational side in a way where it came off as encouraging and non-demanding. The writing here was impeccable 💯
Who would win?
An entire regiment of the US army
OR
A doubty boi and a boi who has a plan
You spelled BOAH wrong
Doubty Boi could take on the entire US army by himself and win even with late stage TB
Oh this fokin doubty boah ah the fokin doubting
Funny there’s a video of someone playing this mission, they manage to kill every army soldier except for the one sniper soldier on top of the cliff who’s in God Mode because Rockstar doesn’t want the player to be creative
Well looks like the army won.
15:31 I just got passed this mission and I literally stood there just to see if Dutch would say "Our time has passed Captain" and then jumps off, but nope Dutch didn't say it.
Trust me, it looks better in a report that way
Technically the Captain's time didn't pass at all, it was outlaws who were coming to an end but the army was there to stay.
Because it was not his time. Not yet.
*14:57** same speech he made to John Marston before his death in Rdr1*
We can't fight lumbago
What are you doing here, milton
@@johnmarstonisjustlikemefr I don't know
Hey Jim Milton, have you seen John Marston? Also goes by the name of Rip Van Winkle.
cow raiser Milton i will fight you
cow raiser Milton remember you died in Van Horn oh wait you can't you are dead!!! 😈
Dutch just didn’t know when to quit
That tune when we see the scenery with a dear. Goosebumps!
Dutch:I got plan this is the good one Gentelmen!
We can fight gravity,we fight guaaaaaarrrrrrggggg!
"We cant fight nature, We cant fight gravity, we cant fight change. We cant fight nothin. My whole life, all i ever did was fight. Our time has passed, john."
- Dutch van der linde's last words before committing suicide
that cavalry charge bugle call really made me get goosebumps on my first playthrough.. 9:58
The fact Arthur did all this while sick and on death's doorstep is insane, I can't even walk to the kitchen whenever I have a fever
Those health tonics and cocaine gums really did their job.
If anybody is having trouble getting the headshots, right before you trigger the cutscene at 13:58, face the onslaught, and soldiers literally spawn and respawn as you cut them out down.
countof3everybodyOD I literally did the same thing to get that 35 headshot mark. Nearly died because of it though so be careful and quick with your shots
Also if you do it in replay you can check if you completed it in the mission log. If you’re on your first attempt, just count them
I was hitting all headshot through whole mission no body shot as long u target top should count
Dutch in rdr1: You can't fight nature john. Dutch in rdr2: You can't fight nature captain.
"Rebellion! The smell of cordite and integrity." - Dutch
14:20 I didn't ask for this kind of nostalgia trip. 😂 😂
9:00 I was legit shaken. Really.
15:58 the water sounds and seems delicious and cool.
What a pure river it was
We can't always fight nature John...
We can’t fight change
We can’t fight... gravity
We can’..fight..nothing
Well, i can't give up neither, i cant fight my own nature, that's the paradox John, you see?
Them jumping off that cliff was so reminiscent of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.
Arthur is such a well developed character. This game is a masterpiece
14:15 For RDR1 reference
Dutch always says that words when he knows there is no way to escape and he is on a cliff, he says you can't fight nature, you can't fight change, you can't fight gravity.
i know DAMN well this mission isn't gonna end with a "prank" it never ends without a shoot out XD
Imagine :
Dutch and Eagle : This is gonna be just a peaceful prank, no one's gotta die
Mission requirement : get 35 headshots
@@tofferooni4972" have an accuracy of 95%"
This "it's just a prank bro" shit is on new levels.
When the army surrounded dutch nd arthur U can try figting them, by aiming, it automatically goes into dead eye nd arthur will die same as john marston in rdr1.
Really?
Yeah, even dutch will start shooting the army, but will eventually die too, even though u select every army member with manual selection in dead eye n shoot them, there are few more that are on side hill, which u cant kill in given time window, no after cutscene like rdr1 tho, worth a try
@@Shubham.Kochhar theres even a sniper on the cliff on top of us
@@trollege9618 yup, whose in god mode xD u cant kill him, like we saw in the video that i previously shared in the comments above.
@@Shubham.Kochhar xD
Throwback to rdr 1 is real nice
9:59 Cavalry Charge
When Dutch said “let’s sell them a little snake oil” does that mean Dutch has dead eye?
from their persperctive it's called focus.
Noobmaster69 yes
He shot a pair of binoculars out of John's hand from sniper range with a pistol in rdr1. Of course he has dead eye lol
Bro snake oil is a real historical thing. Dead eye is just a game mechanic. Snake oil was basically a con to sell this liquid for ridiculous prices. It's a fraud, a lie. Think of Nigel West Dickens in the first game
Adam Jones i understand that now haha i didnt know what that meant at the time of this comment
Dutch for The White House 2020
Dutch as president:
The general public: "President Dutch, how are we gonna make America great again?"
Dutch: I have a plan. We just need faith, and muneh."
Ironically, that’s actually happened already; Ronald Reagan’s childhood nickname was “Dutch.”
Gun Troller So we already have President Dutch
11:30 your horse shat
Does Arthur have a vision of a wolf here with low honor, or is it always a deer?
notfeedy notlazy low honor you get the wolf -high honor you get the deer 🦌
@@TheWayTheTruthTheLife_ I guessed so. Thanks.
It's a coyote
Assassino275 it’s a wolf not a coyote the game even says it
Legacyofoutlaws HD no it’s a deeryote
Why arthur keeps questioning and doubting dutch is because he doesn't like seeing dutch like this like killing people in cold blood and he doesn't want dutch to be like micah
Sebastian Garcia
Dutch manipulated the natives
Dutch: You can't fight gravity
Arthur: YOUR MOOOM
dutch had practically the same speech as he did in rdr2 damn apparently he had a whole thing written down for whenever he gets forced to a cliff
Arthur kills like five guys before dutch even finishes his sentence "they fired first son"
The music in the mission is similar to a track called “The Disaster” but the other part when Arthur and Dutch run from the army is unknown as far as I’m aware.
Dutch: I’m trying, Arthur. And I’ll keep trying, and you’ll keep doubting, and we’ll keep failing!
Arthur: it ain’t like that, Dutch. Look at me. Look at me!
*dutch looks at arthur*
High honor Arthur: I’m just....I’m worried about folk...
Low honor Arthur: I’m just...this ain’t how we do things!
Dutch: I know! I-
*Ka boom!!* (sorry I love this mission)
Imagine it's John with Dutch here in this mission, RDR2 would then end right here and RDR would never happen.
15:34 - Dutch THROWS His Hat!
It's funny how some of these missions in the trophy guide I got this video from are supposed to be harder to get gold on, yet most of the harder ones for me seem to be the ones rated between a 1/5 to 2/5. The one I found this video in says this is a 3.5/5, yet it was extremely easy for me. I just rushed to the canon right after the first shot hit and killed the guy, then farmed the rest of the headshots before triggering the cutscene that leads to jumping off the cliff.
"We need to ride hard"..they literally stop riding like after 100 meters..smh
True
The whole story was poorly edited. It's like they changed the story and missions over the year (after Trailer 2) to make it more different in the end instead of happy and continue with different character.
Even NA looks like reused and poorly edited (not by the desert, but by the buildings/houses/objects).
You can notice by dialogues, forgot to edit it.
It's good game, but extra year would've been better to they make everything alright.
I'm just disappointed on having less snow on north-west part, making the hunter outfit, well, useless.
They should've went with more northern parts with more snow to the east and NA being as the story add-on DLC.
@@xXSilentAgent47Xx Sounds like some good ol' fashioned nitpicking. The game's great. A few glitches, that a lot of games have, by the way, and the game should've had an extra YEAR of development on those areas. I personally enjoyed NA, as it stayed true to the original in many aspects. I usually see your comments and enjoy them, but this seems nitpicky, my man.
+Smitty Werbenjagermanjesen Not exactly nitpicking as what you think, they even admitted that the story had several changes and it has 5h cut contents.
What you said is subjective, what people say is it's boring, slow paced, annoying tapping X/A button on horse, holding to pick something up (even looting, which is repetitive. Should've been in The Witcher 3 looting system) and it has clunky controls.
There's more info in Metacritic said by everyone who played it.
Tbh i do understand what they mean by that and i don't thinks it's great. Game have big problems and it could've been better.
Camp system is useless, all of companions just sit there and look pretty instead to put some money in charity box (only Micah did once) and bring foods, then Grimshaw comes all mad at you for not refilling everything looking like you're the only sheep and she's shepherd.
I wish they could've replaced that to companion activities because i'd rather enjoy getting drunk with Lenny than seeing them interrupting me when i listen some conversations from others.
There's no Liar's Dice, no Arm Wrestling, no cheating in poker from previous game. There's no horse racing either.
We never saw Blackwater Massacre chapter, probably cut and saving for SP/Online DLC or completely erased in that 5h they admitted.
You know, in The Witcher 3 you be rewarded for doing them all, GTA 5 did have similar thing with parachuting (unlimited parachute bags equipped on characters).
They could've done something about that. Perhaps less button tapping A/X and more fast riding as being the reward for completing them all.
Why we need big world when it doesn't have much to do than hunting? Just Cause 2 haves big world and it's filled with so many contents everywhere.
The knife you collect are useless, they all have same stats. Whatever knife you equip to skin animals, it always switch to default one.
Timing, don't use health items and don't get shot for gold medals is total ludicrous (which if you even replay, the items you own from save doesn't exist in inventory), worse of all the Dead Eye timing is playing on normal instead of being slow. NPC's like Micah walk and ride too slow, many people were frustrated with him during the missions like An American Pastoral Scene. Even me, took me 10 tries.
Most of contents were already seen, while some minor contents like coach robbery exist.
Perhaps blackjack is new, but big open world with nothing much to do is just boring. Especially Ambarino and NA, waste of disk space.
It's not interesting to play much as i did The Witcher 3, previous RDR and GTA 4. Nothing else to do than hunting.
Plus the story haves lazy writing. All they do is reusing same words: Faith, Money, Tahiti, Plan.
People make meme out of it like with Sora's dialogues in KH games.
Gun is still my favorite old west game. So many contents and rewards in the small world, but the story is very short.
That's where R* took bounty - Eliminate or Alive | Alive/Dead and legendary animals idea for RDR.
P.S. When i said doin them all at GTA 5 unlimited parachute bags part, i mean horse racing. Most of trinkets are tied with hunting, i don't mean on those.
I mean 5x better than panther saddle.
I love Dutch's Bandanna, I wish there was more like that witch the player could use instead of the basic one.
If played the first game then Dutch's speech on the cliff should sound familiar!
You can’t fight nature
You can’t fight change
You can’t fight *_lumbago_*
The spirit animal scene always give me chills, no matter how much I see them.
This whole mission- amazing. Dutch in this mission- a complete bonehead that again made things much worse
Dutch is a great speaker
The fact Dutch literally admitted to Arthur they were using the Indians as a distraction and then immediately denied sent a massive red flag up.
Dutch is not dismounting he is just running in circles
Lol the plan to trap them was so dumb
The song that starts at 10:30 I need it lol. Been looking everywhere for it and it's not in any of the soundtracks listed on TH-cam thus far.
Storm Shadow yeah me too :(
Is the Disaster
Name of the theme
favored sons soundtrack
Amazing rdr1 call back bro
That is Dutch's go to jumping off the cliff speech
Does anybody mind telling me where i can find that U.S Army fanfare from 9:59?
the animation so detail
9:58 what is the sound name?
US Army cavalry charge bugle call*
@@bigsmilereviews100 thx
12:35 Ain't that the bridge you destroy a mission earlier ?
Yeah l thought that too
I checked it again. Not the same bridge . They are different.
@@angelobronte1452 No the little building on the right isn't here as well
Actually, the mission where we destroy the bridge with John is after this mission if we follow the official guide
@@frenchtoad1308 because it's a different bridge?
The second dutch said "This is a good one" I shouted at the screen thats exactly what you said before you jumped off a cliff not knowing he was about to do it again
Every time I hear that Bugle call I get a chill,
Never underestimate the US Army Calvary.
"Air Calvary: an old (US Army) calvary unit that traded its horses for helicopters and went looking for the sh!t all over Vietnam..." Captain Willard, "Apocalypse,Now" 🙂
I love how similar the cliff scene in this mission is to the one in rdr1
I'd say it's a direct reference. Only this time it was a whole army against him and Arthur, and there was water at the bottom of the cliff.
10:30 song name please?
I thought I was the only one who spammed dead eye like this. Everyone else just gets their hat shot off.
What’s the name of the song that plays at 7:54
14:21 Now where have I heard that before?
9:59 what is the name of this sound?
Cavalry charge
I'm glad Arthur got his hat back at the end
9:59 this sound is terrifying
Well I mean imagine you're in close distance and the army sends soldiers to charge and kill you in large numbers while launching artillery, that's very terrifying
When america comes to you
9:58 love that bugle
same
14:09 i actually pressed R2 to kill the soldiers killed middle but from the right we was killed it kinda looks like John's death i almost killed the soldiers (note Mauser has the largest pistol capacity Revolver only has 6 rounds) so wanna find out what happensif you use Mauser pistol on them!
Even if you manage to kill em all, there's an Invincible sniper up the hill to eliminate you no matter how many times u hit him.
5:59 when I’m about to win a nerf gun war with my friends😂
After doing this the first time, my stats were all lowered to almost nothing, but I found out you can get them back by getting exp for the stat (I think), but I had maxed out energy before the mission, so now I can't get my energy back to normal. Please help. I beg.
When i tried to get the gold medal, i uses a bow and a long green jacket and i was counting headshots like legolas, fifteen, sixteen, seventeen
Good to see that you have good honor
dutch gave this speech twice, jumps off a cliff twice. the only difference is he didn't survive the second time
I got a plan. This is a good one. Rdr1 reference
What’s the music at 10:30
Chüngüs the disaster
I think 357 magnum existed in 1899
I know for a fact 7mm or 8mm mauser was around.
It would have been bad ass if RDR2 had like 12 different mausers
Liking the black shirt, where did you get it?
Dutch: they fired first
Rambo: They drew first blood not me. How similar.
This game the soundtrack 😢 how come it is so perfect
10:28 I love how they freeze up when they hear the bomb coming
9:58 this was a moment where I realized I was fighting the literal army.
A chill every single time goes up my face every time I hear that.
RDR2: Dutch uses Eagle Flies and other young angry native Americans
RDR1: Dutch has an army of young angry native Americans
Ah finally somebody notices that too. Yes that's right I think Eagle Flies inspired Dutch to create a gang of natives. But first Dutch uses him for silly reasons
@@masterm537 He didn't care about the Eagle and the others he just used them as a way of creating a distraction and after his original gang fell apart he remembered how easy it is to get young angry native americans to do his bidding and used them again for selfish reasons. He became like Colm O Driscoll if not worst by the end of his life.
The mission when we realized that Dutch is using the Indians and putting more attention towards them away from the gang
In my rdr2 when i walk down the cliff in the first part in the mission with dutch, dutch's game model freezes
I love this reference to first RDR.
Dutch sounds so evil at the beginning of this mission 😈
The moment you here the military horn
Did you notice that the speech when dutch is about to jump off the moutain is just the same as his death speech in rdr1?