Renault Megane R.S. Trophy-R vs Honda Civic Type R 決戰大帽山（內附字幕）｜TopGear HK 極速誌
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มิ.ย. 2020
- 兩部紐布靈之王、終極前驅hot hatch，雷諾Megane R.S. Trophy-R和本田Civic Type R（FK8）決戰大帽山，它們在賽道和公路上的速度無庸置疑，但要成為有魅力的跑車，不單止要有速度，還要有獨特的個性和感染力。到底哪一部車比較熱血、狂妄？哪一部較易上手，適合日常駕駛？又，兩部車同樣採用turbo引擎，哪一副的調校比較優勝呢？
－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－
Web：www.topgearhk.com
FB： / topgearhk
IG： / topgearhk
FB Group: / hkdriversclub - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
非一般嘅車評，有深度得黎，夠informative 又夠中肯💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻希望呢d咁高質既影片可以継續出
一路扭一路叫人Subscribe，唔訂閱都唔得啦🤣🤣
🤣🙏🏻
萬眾期待😍
Good job ! 拍多啲！
分析好正, 句句有point
非常非常精彩！ 好有深度嘅車評！ 真係睇到人如痴如醉！😁👍👏
謝謝😁
正呀，好熱血
Thx good job 👍🏻
Edmond紅日半倚山背後講嘢拍得正!
Thank you for the information
🙏 🙏 🙏 👍👍👍
正👍！
Edmond賣廣告賣得好落力🤣🤣🤣
我覺得講得幾好呀，就算係賣廣告都好正常，做呢行都要食飯，加油！
好多野意會得啦 唔使講到明🤫
trophy r冇行貨，fk8又唔憂賣，廣告賣d咩呢？
師兄，我估所謂賣廣告意指不是同d車，可能係指一開波又要忙片彎仲要望下cam笑住叫大家襟like TG,呢d咪PRO 囉！最有價值HK TG員工金求獎啦，其實免費拍比大家睇點可以唔like 😅甘都唔明冇野講收水啦😂
tai chan 我就係指嗰個位😂😂😂
一路劈一路賣 所以我先話佢落力😂
講得好好megane 就算慢渣都要花d心機 個極力子比較難吊要時間適應。fk8基本上塞車代步都好輕鬆
好正嘅車評 👍🏻 好過台灣版好多 💪🏻
Edmond比較得好好，想睇多啲呢類2車比較既片 👍🏻👍🏻
Thank you😘
Honda就是街用的赛道车，而这部megane就是赛道用的街车。
實在很喜歡Edmond跟姚先生的極速誌視頻，評述比較中肯，如雷諾比較熱血，這個我真的非常認同。
Thank you🙏🏻
唔止廣東話 華文媒體入面Top Gear Hk講得最好
最深入 最有感染力！
加油💪🏻
多謝支持😁🙏🏻
正啊，你哋會唔會搵部718gt4翻來整翻期
兩部都係棍👍🏻
正啊。
嘩。有套碳纖軨，有冇試呢? 如果有，有咩感覺?
加油💪！💕💕
多謝支持
想睇同wrx sti JDM比較
For me this is an easy choice... Both are similar fast/fun but the type R is twice more reliable EASILY!!!
过瘾！！！
全條片內容都好豐富
如果加埋兩架車上落大山時間比較就更好喇
出埋時間？認真？比哂証據咪即係叫差佬拉人封舖🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Honda civic type r 真的好帥啊♥
如揾部原裝軨fk8比較會更好，fk8對軨嘅offset好敏感，原裝offset會最肯入彎，加上極穩定嘅車尾，係頭轆車嘅另一種演繹
FK8車尾真係超定，咬得好好，到出彎果陣好有信心「索」住起油
出多條片你揸全段路睇下，應該仲正，不刪剪版
應該出唔到街😝
FK8 係 daily 車。Trophy R 係落場車，拆左唔少野。兩者根本好難比較。要比就 FK8 同 Megane RS 或者 Trophy 比。又或者拎 Trophy R 同 FK8 架黃色 Limited Edition 比。
trophy r禁重料先贏4秒，其實唔太公道，fk8理應同rs300 trophy比，可惜香港只有自動波rs280
@@Linch7 加賽車防滾架跑Nur好公道?
Megane 套brake 真係好吸引。
In Honda We Trust!
西門威龍，葉孤思域 之
決戰大帽之巔
FK8唔係vtec引擎加turbo咩？
Renault 連櫈都拆埋, 拆到無可拆黎勝Honda, Civic要勝翻佢無難道
觉得本田可能会出部Fk8 Type RR 再去北环片多次🤣
FK8 好D
一諗到𠝹花Megane副carbon fibre軨就肉赤
後面個卷野咩黎？
太飛仔型啦！不過題材好好。👍但沒有動機去研究。
type r 需要一个clubsport版本再来战
八卦一下3:59中Trophy R 既induction hose 的結紥手術是不是原車已經有？謝謝，我鄕下仔小見識，莫怪🙇🏿♂️
應該是的，但還是要再問問那位車主才能確定。
點解LIKE制只可襟一次?? LIKE到爆
🤣
大冒山行50公里決鬥！真係快過單車喎
Insane person found🚨
Support
聽師傅你咁講 我玩雷諾 出彎可能有力DD😬
可惜香港冇賽車場啫，最後先講
Tai Mo Shan呀師兄 🙈
兩架都好重喎
最後一句真係夭心夭肺...
😢
我觉得还有一部不错的作品就是i 30 n. 虽然马力会比这两部小。
但係個外型真係同普通I30太似
这个hyundai算是hot hatch中的惊喜作品，加上由几位youtuber驾驶后，都有不错的回应
i30n係部好車，但hothatch嚟講未及megane 3 rs
个人口味哦。我其实是很喜欢I 30 n, 小型一点就是铃木雨燕sport.
汽油机日糸是好过欧洲的、柴油机就相反。
Honda 日使用比 Renault 更好, 但如果上場決戰, Megane RS > Civic Type R.
English CC are from Google Translate?
Yes😅
Type R始終係部daily sports car, 對家係半track day car咁hardcore，咁樣比較根本對Type R唔係太公平，更何況本田係好務實，唔好會為爭成績又再出多部hardcore既type R爭到你死我活。反之如果本田有心搞，唔會贏唔到法國仔。第二樣野就唔夠講，例如e power個D
如果可以同場試埋i30n同golf GTi就好了
阿陳x泰好似有段片
唔同級
Megane RS 同wrx sti JDM邊部快啲？
原裝計 megane rs會快少少 sti 比較重 睇你手車 sti 就會敢去踩多d容易渣得快d
@@kimmywong9995 咁 fk8同 sti 呢
@@kk-yy8oi一定 fk8 一部好易上手開得快既車
香港幾時可以起賽車場!!!
唔駛十年後, 有新聞話 2022年 11代既Type R 會有400hp
你好呀，2022年FL5得330匹咋
Clio V6先至係快車
Record NURBURGRING : Renault Mégane RS Trophy R '' 7'40''10 '' (05/04/2019) 🇫🇷 : Honda Civic Type R '' 7'43''80 '' ( 03/04/2017 ) 🇯🇵 !
For me... Both are similar fast/fun but the type R is twice more reliable EASILY!!!
Trophy-R的Record Set你能买到，Type R你不能，这就是最大区别啊。
Megane 3 RS车主表示RS给我带来太多揸车乐趣，从未后悔过~
I like both Renault and Honda a lot. Best FWD cars in the world. However, I prefer the Honda Civic Type R’s superior engineering, performance, practicality, and reliability. Red Bull-Honda Formula 1 is faster too.
Red Bull-Honda Formula 1 is faster too??
Then you should buy AMG
F1 and production car cannot be compared at all
Totally agreed. For me this is an easy choice... Both are similar fast/fun but the type R is twice more reliable EASILY!!!
edmond兄,喘哂氣咁.....究竟係你跑山定架車跑山? XDD
一齊跑。Edmond辛苦啲。
FK8 實用同抵玩D!
香港FK8抵玩??
笑左
想問下,megane後座個卷係咩?
四隻碳纖維軨
@@topgearhongkong thank you
TopGear HK 極速誌 點解佢要放多四條spare鈴在車箱內？
@@abrahamrazack9293 跟車番就係咁，出車有兩套軨
@@Linch7 雖然係碳纖，多多少少都會加大重量，廠方係吾係預咗您不放在車内的？
Renault are trying WAY too hard to beat Honda.
And, in my book, they have failed.
No rear seats, no independent rear suspension... the need for carbon ceramic brakes, the need for carbon wheels...
Seriously, with that kind of extra "equipment", the Civic would beat the Megane on the 'ring again.
Without talking about comfort or price, RELIABILITY is always an issue with Renault. I'm French, and because of my job, I know Renault inside and out...
Don't even consider buying the Megane unless you absolutely need to unlock that "exclusive club" trophy ;)
Totally agreed. For me this is an easy choice... Both are similar fast/fun but the type R is twice more reliable EASILY!!!
但FK8改裝潛力會唔會更大?
一定會
邊部車主有錢咪邊部改裝潛力更大囉,上代trophy-r副F4RT換個TUBRO上4~500無難度.係要駛幾錢者.
差部clubsport s
建議你哋d英文字幕搵個真係識英文嘅人嚟翻譯
Auto Google translate😅🙏🏻
TopGear HK 極速誌 真係google translate咩？🤔
Purpose wise, my S2000 is setup exactly the same as Trophy R. Wait, my S2000 doesn't live in Hong Kong. :p
幾萬個廣告
部megane限量幾多部啊⋯⋯又拆後座，完全唔覺得佢贏得公道囉
加賽車防滾架跑Nur好公道?
these two are track cars, not street cars, not suitable for everyday rides.
FK8張凳好唔好坐？
好坐，承托夠之餘亦算舒適
好好坐，好包，但唔硬，真係好照顧日用
Fk8唔夠佢黎
點解會無GTI ?
雷諾own by Nissan? 所以Nissan想再次證明給公眾知道邊個喺紐布靈王 ? (Similar to they beaten Porsche 911 by Nissan GTR R35 in 2008?) 個人認為Honda FK8 CTR 好D !! 全面 take care屋企可能只得一部車需要, wonderful 選擇駕駛模式 Comfort/Sport/+R drving mode..... Honda 諗野好似入屋D.... : )
雷諾同日產係聯盟，互相持股
@@Linch7 Thanks.
部Megane RS都係買返黎炒，不過無水位啦哩部，咁既價錢大把選擇
真係「炒」埋山
I live fk8 more
A35 S3 都好
前驅
有megan先點讚
跑山算不算违法？
翻牆算不算違法?
呢啲路梗係歐洲車好玩😄
A bigger brake doesnt make you brake later, try to learn your stuff please
16:26
:(
Golf GTI Club Sport-S呢
??????????
如果 Megane 個會長唔好響青公不停閃人過車就好D，攬炒就神車都無用啦。
我諗你認錯人喇，佢極少喺青公出沒
@@Linch7 香港得一架，少去，但唔代表無去嘅。可能唔係會長啦，T牌，我有相同片噃
@@kitcheebluewave T牌咪唔係會長嚕😂架車唔係佢的
點解你會被閃呢？
@@Linch7 我又真係唔係唔知係咪會長，只係見到會長Gary咁高調周圍搵報道，我以為係咋。咁三百幾匹車係快嘅。
點解俾人閃，我都唔知噃，由葵涌道衝到落青公，可能覺得我揸舊M5應該要快吧。一家大細又落雨，我祝君好運。
點解有誤會? 可能睇咗篇訪問，T牌，option 軨加青公影相吧。
hk.appledaily.com/car/20200519/H2AF4IK6ULGE4Y24SBE2JNTDDM/
買日本車...做頭七讚...哈哈哈
Megane should be the real Type-R... they took up what Honda gave up
当年Type R上咗防滚架，好似有少少矛😬
上nur試車 可以唔加防滾架既咩
yau Yau 但系部Megane無啵
讓多幾KG
Leung 有防滾架，部車差好遠嘎
@@CheChanYan 條友真係唔識架喎
Honda is the best
Honda the best, after Renault Sport ! 😄
how rich do you have to be to buy this in england , lol
As rich as Richard 67😂😂😂
其實佢揸慢少少講嘢咪唔使咁struggle lor
THE RENAULT MEGANE TROPHY R 7:40 RECORD IS NOT ACCURATE COMPARED TO THE TYPE R RECORD. THE TYPE R TECHNICALLY IS STILL THE FASTEST FWD IN NURBUGRING AND NOT THE MEGANE TROPHY R. NOT MANY PEOPLE KNOW AND REALIZED THIS TRUTH. TYPE R TOP END SPEED IS ALSO HIGHER THAN MEGANE. TYPE R CAN REACH 185 MPH TOP SPEED IN REAL WORLD, ON PAPER IT SAYS 169 MPH. THE MEGANE TROPHY R TOP END SPEED IS 163 MPH. THE TYPE R IS THE BETTER AND FASTER CAR HERE.
Megane has higher speeds in corner.
@@kaiyuen2000 TYPE R IS THE BEST IN CORNERS AND FASTER
@@cooleye8887 wow you’re right! Type R is the best! Worlds best car ever!
@@kaiyuen2000 😂😑
废话多，根本没比到武🤨
啲英文字幕咁嘅水平，不如唔好加啦，俾邊個睇？
求其揾個例子…
13:16
...Very many numbers
🤔
其實其他方面係做得好好嘅，但係正正係咁，冇理由畀啲字幕影衰哂㗎嘛，我諗求其搵個中學生翻譯都唔係咁嘅質素啦下嘛？
Auto Google translate😅🙏🏻
唔怪之得啦…
"...can make the driver's blood boil"
慢揸=jogging
開得快啲=open it fast
咁多年嚟我哋笑啲國內同胞將 "一次性嘅膠袋" 譯做 "one time sex plastic bag"，我只係唔想呢啲香港製作他朝有一日畀人笑返轉頭啫，始終你哋都算係比較有代表性嘅TH-cam channel...
Why is the guy wearing a face mask inside the car lol?