PTI Bias, Zaid Hamid and Audience Q/A with Tamkenat Mansoor, Mustafa Chaudhry and Aamir Mughal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- The first ever live podcast of The Pakistan Experience where the audience got to ask questions from us!
Tamkenat Mansoor, Mustafa Chaudhry and Aamir Mughal join Shehzad Ghias Shaikh for a hilarious and thought provoking interaction with the crowd where we discuss Content Creation, Censorship, Stand-up Girl, Comedy, Satire, Zaid Hamid, Zakir Naik, Counter Culture, PTI Bias, Mental Health and more.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
2:30 Facing Pressures
5:40 Stand up Girl
7:30 Individual relationship with fame, Aftab Iqbal and Sahil Adeem
16:15 Why make such content
19:20 Anwar Maqsood and Aamir Mughal
22:40 Why discuss religion on TPE
31:45 Zaid Hamid, Zakir Naik and Satire
38:20 Counter Culture and Censorship
41:26 Do we focus a lot on PTI?
48:20 Mental Health and coping with Negativity
54:00 Harder to talk about issues in Pakistan
1:03:30 Why does Shehzad always defend the Awaam?
1:09:00 Audience Questions and Interaction - บันเทิง
Sir, I am Muslims, Zakir naik always refer wrong page numbers or Slokas of Bhagavad Gita and Vedas,
I purchased Bhagavad Gita and Yajur Veda Scriptures translated by Dayanand Saraswathi ji and checked it later understood that Zakir naik always refer half sloka or wrong page number to fool Hindus and convert them.
(Secular Hindus used to convert, as they not read their Books).
Later on, When I started reading Sri Bhagavad Gita and Yajur Veda, I got to Understand that Hinduism is Great Religion. (Still now I have those books with me and I daily respect them as they given knowledge to me). Now I am Muslims, but I did not follow Islam fully and I Meditate on God VISHNU. I know many in comment section comment me as u r not Muslim or fake and u became Kaffir.
BUT to all of them my answer is - I am Proud Indian and will die for India, but not for Islam.
I thanks Zakir naik due to him I got Bhagavad Gita and Yajur Veda and exposed to Hinduism and when anyone know Hinduism then nobody will hate Hinduism or GOD, AS GOD is only 1 but we Humans refer him with different languages and as per different cultures. (still if any Muslims think God is not 1 and Hindus or non-Muslims have different Got then its u doing Blasphemy by saying Non-Muslims have different God) but all Non-Muslims agree on GOD is 1.
I'm from Punjab India I'm Sikh b4 Sikhs we ware hindu and I'm proud of that and totally agree with you jai hind
Don't lie u r a bjp it cellar lol 😂😂😂
ty for uploading this now i know how much my voice was quivering, public speaking isn't my thing lol but great panel and I actually learned from what tamkenat had to say
wonderful. When willl be the next program. Kindly update...We love to be the part of it
Yar cant get enough of this. Really fun to watch you guys talk!
🙌
This new flavor of podcast is soo good plz do more 😭
Bring on more of the regular guests maybe adeel bhai or ali aftaab this is genuinely so fun and also super interesting way of discussing issues
🙌
Dekho Shahzad, it is not necessary to crack a joke over every word someone utters, this is that typical Karachi humour that simply doesn’t land, anybody who asks a question or utters their name doesn’t have to be ridiculed or made light of:..in my opinion humour or satire is baked in or interspersed within the entire conversation by picking some well-timed moments to exhibit wit or double-entendre, you can’t be doing this constantly to prove you are brimming with one-liners and hilarious comebacks…Tamkenat is superbly gifted and still understated in terms of what she can bring to the satire table, she needs to run at her own pace, using her own humour repertoire and picking her own timing…a natural rainmaker in the satirical realm…
Actually bohat bachoda samajhta hai apne aap ko.as a comedian also, he has a very inflated sense of self but in reality bohat khushak hai
He is Mr no one I'm amazed you spent more then 1 line for him
Tamkenat Mansoor sahiba and Mostafa Chaudhry sahib are really a great duo on any stage or podcast. Tamkenat Mansoor sahiba especially has a really balanced personality.
THESE CONVERSATIONS ARE VERY IMPORTANT!! Kudos to you all for conducting this. Thank you❤
❤️
Loved it.. keep posting.
❤️
We in india have much more harmony, but india has to learn and not increase hatred.. India's strength is unity in diversity.
You are wrong brother what you think we was doing for 800 years read real history brother
We don't live in harmony. Wake up from your delusions. Stop enforcing your delusional sentiments of harmony and ganga jamuni tehzeeb on us
Excellent program . Congratulations to all the participants
🙌
loved the groovy nature of this podcast and the interaction with audience, took off fatigue after a long day🖤🖤
🙌
Ukraine or kashmiri pandits ke maslo pe kabhi kuch bola h nhi naa toh Islam ka hi masla hai 😂
Facts❤
as an Indian I love Chaudhary Sahab
Kyun achai ko dhundna padhta hain.Aur burai ko nahi ? U guys r so good that as a indian i am enjoying watching & listening abt those convo & people who i have little or no knowledge.Nice
Shehzad you rock. Keep rocking on. And thanks for bring Amir "the G" bhai on again.
❤️
Thoroughly enjoyed❤🎉!!
🙌
Excellent podcast. Thoroughly enjoyed it.
🙌
32:41 totally agree… still remember zahid tracker 🤣
Baniya is no derogatory term at all, if someone call me Baniya I will be happy considering that he mean I am well behaved, educated, no-nonsense person, expert in business and wealthy :) Unfortunately Baniyas are just 1-2% of entire population and Jutt, gujjars, rajputs, ahir formed majority of population in India
Excellent yar. Dr . Tamkenat hats off to you...
🙌
Very amazing Q&A podcast, amazing discussion on so many issues in Pakistan and Palestine.
🙌
Thanks a lot guys for giving such an amazing, funny and thought-provoking content. and shehzad love you my boy
❤️
Loved this!!
❤️
more live sessions are needed
🙌
Thanks Pakistan experience for providing us with critical precious knowledge 😊
❤️
a very good argument by amir sb abt PTI that it is the manifestation of common pakistani
Oh man. This was such a welcome respite from all the serious content coming out of Pakistan Experience 😂. Not that I am complaining but it was good to see you all have a little bit of lighter content. May Allah give you all mental and emotional energy to continue and keep up the good work 💪💪💪👍👍👍👍
❤️
Love the way you are bro Shazad and Dr Tamkneet ❤❤❤
❤️
Haven't watched all of it, but man, "AAMIR BHAI MARIO MEIN KAAM KIA HAI AAPNE" cracked me up. Keep making podcasts about religious matters brother, it's an important topic. Stay strong. We are with enlightened people like you.
🙌
Sahil adeem and cancer raja both are this generation”s orya maqbool jaan and zaid hamid 🤣🤣
You miss Haqeeqat TV
Jub daleel na ho ri nam bigar deny se ap suchy nai ho jao gy
lol spot on. uncanny resemblance.
This was sooooo good...please bring this to Lahore
🙌
Great podcast 👍
🙌
40 minutes in and loving it
❤️
Amir Bhai ko pehli dfa suna great intellectual, tamakant Twitter py follower or Shahzad plus Chaudhary brothers everywhere. Great people keep working . Ignore bots
🙌
Very nice podcast. I was waiting for it
🙌
Shehzad, loved this free discussion. And glad to realise we have young thinking youth there too who are beyond the religious obsession and the 'jannat-dozak' enforced dilemma.
Reminds me of that John Lennon song-IMAGINE.
But tell me what percentage of youth is educated and free thinking in Pakistan? Madrasa educated passouts excluded, please.
Tamkenat is brilliant with her views but how many of them are there in a society locked and sealed by religious obsession?
Cheers & take care!
🙌
Enforced delima are you brainwashed by uncle Sam or Illuminati agents ,janaat n dozzakh concept is given in Quran, if it is not conveyed in good form it's issue of messenger not message. Shehzad is part of western media agent to spread propaganda and controversies but you are a kid to understand that you are being played
I hope to see A.Maqsood on your podcast.. Keep up the good work.
Great one 👌
🙌
Yar ye saf video kia hoti hain ?
Great discussion we need more discussion like this please include amir bae in this he,s senior and has more experience like then us 👍👍👍💯
🙌
For an artificial nation that's declining faster than one can bat an eye, these guys are acting as if they are in Brooklyn... amazing!
Thoda sound production ka krna pade ga boss
Your shirt looks great
54:50 Tamkenat , hats off to her ..
1:05:15 shehzad , full throttle loved it
1:21:21 Mustafa , i think his true philosophy of life is this .. in life nothing is wrong nothing is correct .. who are you to judge ..
in short jab bhi koe kehe lamba ho jayega .. eska matlab suno...
🙌
Brother, I have just gone and researched about Dr Zakir Naik on Google myself . Whatever he said and it was true I am not a bought army but thanks to you I made my own research I actually found pdfs of the books or chapters and the things that he said we're mentioned . And he himself has said that he uses various tricks to memorize the verses .Secondly haven't you have seen his debates with huge people of Christianity, Hinduism and Buddhism. So if he was lying then why didn't they point out.
May be but what attract you in this long podcast is only Zakir naik
@@bharatkapoor4062 Yes of course a lot because I like his sincerity with his religion and everyone for which he sacrificed his beloved country, he always tried to tell the truth, he never tried to make irregular or irrelevant statement and he was the reason why so many people converted name me anyone like him who did these things while living in India and even in the USA .
@@bharatkapoor4062Yeah ,It's all crap except for Zakir Naik lol 😂😂
Why? I didn't say that whatever they are saying is completely wrong but I have my right to not agree at something which I did not consider right and why I have explained.
Typical liberals don't like a scholar whom doesn't encourage their liberal thinking.
excellent discussion, I know you won't but I'll still say never big a F about haters... love you bro ❤
❤️
I agree with Tamkenat on the Palestenian issue! Pakistanis have made the issue religious! 58:40
Yes
jbh
@@ThePakistanExperience shehzad you too have made it so. For your information. . . India has since 1947 supported Palestine, Palestinians have their embassy in the most influential diplomatic area of Delhi. On top of it while Pak leadership had always claimed parity of Palestine and Kashmir, Palestinians themselves as also their government has never equated these two and have never supported Pakistan on the Kashmir issue. Needless to add even Prime Minister Sh Narendra Modi ( 🌶️) visited Palestine @ West bank few years back .when was it last when the prime minister of Pak visited Palestine. All that I wrote above is part of the narrative history of the last 75 years and you can check it.
@@viveksehgal1842 u expect too much honesty from him. He says Pakstan has never elected a "mazhabi party". 😁
@@M_R___974 yes . I admit My mistake. Actually at times I see flashes of intelligence in his podcast and then I expect too much from him. I told him to watch Dr Rizwan ( vlog Face to Face) a fellow Sunni Muslim. He had recorded more than 30 blogs on the issue . Thereafter give your critical ( not reaction) views and prove that HAMAS is deliberately and knowing fully well doing everything to harm Palestinians themselves . He never responded to it. I am sure he won't even have bothered to watch it as he is also just out to make more and more blogs ..
you guys are so funny, I love it.
❤️
Live was boring, humour wasn’t good either because it was self focused and bitter about others.
True
Progressive talk with humour,love it❤
❤️
Great program setting, please bring Syed Muzammil next time
All these people present on the stage are the diamonds of Pakistan. Now it depends on the society there whether they save and carve them or throw them away considering them as stones.
🙌
As always they will be thrown away or won't get any recognition, only army people will get the importance, and this scenario will continue for decades to come
Kudos to the sound engineer for fucking up the sound
sir aik adha program islamabad ya pindi mein bhi karein
This program was like reverse zaaviya, where instead of ashfaq ahmed telling stories, its the 'kids' being the voice of discourse, and amir sb being a hall monitor of sorts. Great stuff.
🙌
More live talks are needed!
Shahzad bhai this program has reverse zavia where it approves and normalise Pornography , hails Alcohol, lauds immodest culture.
Shahzad bhai you are well read you must be on other side and be out educating masses on the vices which are not only detrimental for human health and well being but a step further lead to an absolute choas when practiced and approved collectively in human cluster . Please @@shairdill
Shehzad bhai you handled the question on Islam rather well!!
🙌
Truly, you should only focus on these kinds of episodes.
Welcome to Pakistan
Much enjoyed. ha ha a.
🙌
Toooooo Good!
🙌
thanks for sharing :) . kitne heart send karu ................................................................................ love from india.
❤️
This lady qnd her thought could be a little hope for Pakistan.
Host has exposed himself.... At least not an intellectual figure anymore ...
I disagree to your opinion about #ZakirNaik . Still I think such conversations are very important for overall intellectual growth of society , same time having humor, at large. Keep it up SG & Team ! Greetings from #China 🇨🇳
🙌
54:44 discussed about Palestine, Baloch, Pashtun issues
Bhai too good
🙌
My Fav people in one frame. Thoroughly enjoyed it 👏👏👏
❤️
I am lowkey ashamed that Zaid Hamid seemed reasonable to me for atleast one year. Chaudhary brothers are legends 🙌🏽
🙌
I don't support liberalism in Pakistan
Fake ummati
Mat kar
@1:00:54 bari such baat kahi,
Amir bhai chaa gaye ... Zabardast...
🙌
Shahzad bhai this program has reverse zavia where it approves and normalise Pornography , hails Alcohol, lauds immodest culture.
Shahzad bhai you are well read you must be on other side and be out educating masses on the vices which are not only detrimental for human health and well being but a step further lead to an absolute choas when practiced and approved collectively in human cluster . Please @shairdill
Love Tamkenat.
Shehzaad janniiiiii tune le li sahil ki…. Jokes apart I really liked that podcast..
I know it was obvious that sahil was discomforted. But hats off to him too for coming to the show. I just wish that sahil would use his platform better for education technology science industry etc so that we can get out of STARVATION and poverty
57:28 is Hindu bania a cuss word ?
Because in India they are among jain, parsi, marwadi, guju etc. rich rich
Just like miyan is used as cuss word in India. The point is every word is good but it's how people use it
@@abedkhan4629 miyan a cuss word whattt
Learn something new everyday
Hindu baniya is a very common and old cuss word in Pak mainstream tv channels. It has reduced in recent years because of access to Pak videos in India, earlier it freely used and the anchor/host didn't blink an eye. When Pak crickets were left out of IPL auction in 2010, Pak cricketer Sohair Tanvir was cursing hindus and "hindu baniya" along with the tv hosts. Few years ago one Nimra Ali used it on gnn channel and the audience laughed with claps.
It's how you say it as well they are saying when people in Pakistan say it they use with hate same way chura is not bad word it's a caste but the way it use it same way bihari is considered gaali now
@@bharatkapoor4062 exactly
Amir Bhai Love hein 😊
❤️
First. Finally I did it.
🙌🙌🙌🙌
Shehzad kb zakir Naik ne koi page no btaya ho or koi reference dia or wo page hi na ho ya reference na mily ye kb hova tha ager juth nai bol rhy to avoidance zror dena.
Shehzad bhai note arahe hain. Rastah ki shirts chal rahi hain. 🤣
They sent it for free bhai
1:6:40 ❤
Great question by the guy. Islam q discuss kia jatha hai?
Ghiaas . Sir Aftab Iqbal show respect to sohail ahmad. When you and adeel afzal show courage and accept you were wrong ?
Apart from Islamic conversations ,I agree on most things
Amir kehta 39.57 min py k boht acha kam kia with fect and figers se to shezad achnak se shocked hova ap bhi dekh k batana kia shahzad shocked tha ya nai.
yeh quaid e azam wali story qadeem he. hum ne school me suni thhi a couple of decades ago
Wonderful program guys !!! But I would like to add here. The seeds of hatred were sown in 1940s by Muslim league and Mohd ali Jinnah. The Pakistani polity and Army and mullah only nurtured it to grow as a tree. Unfortunately you guys are reaping it.
It’s give me pleasure too. As there are people like you who are working hard to undo many things. Keep doing good job!!!!
Saint Kabir has said :
Jab boya ped Babool ka
Aam kahan se hoye
So true.
You're talking at the political level only, at the societal level these seeds were sown well before that, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan would create the "Two Nation-Theory" in the mid 1800s, an idea that the British vehemently supported. They even knighted him because of how loyal he was to the colonial empire.
So the Muslim League and Jinnah come much after that, the source problem was the British.
Yes. History has all these evidences. hardly any Pakistani knows these facts.
But the good thing is that there are Pakistanis curious to know real history. May not make much difference but still.
Now who is sowing the seeds in India of hate 😊
what she said about Dr. Zakir Naik
What is your problem if someone gets a show from Pakistan... It was not you ???
Tamkenat on fire 🔥
Shahzad bhai ye podcast khatam karne wali baat aaj kr di, aenda na krna 😢😂
🙌❤️
love u shezad chubb
❤
❤️
Shehzad bhai's reaction at 40:57😂
😅
As a indian last 10 min is superb
🙌
Shehzad, comedy chor do! You are doing GREAAAAAAAAAT with the podcast!
it is kinda annoying.
Yaar note kero jab mustafaa taali bajatay hain, tu un kay biceps kaisay hiltay hain, bulkay “thalthalaatay” hain 😅.
Mustafa dunya ka Wahid aadmi hai jiss ko gym mein biceps kay bhi sports bra pehanaa chahiye 😂
I used to like Mustafa Chaudhry’s comedy until I did not know the fine line between comedy and insult.
1:07:44 Well i completely agree with the fact what shezad said but the example you chose is completely wrong and very lengthy topic separately...
Us hindu civilization mai Oraton ko Top pehany ka tax (mulakram) daina hota tha jo mostly Rich or upper cast oratain dai sakti thi... Only poor and lower casted women had no choice but to be topless and higher Cast pandits and men used to tease and harass them, then there came a civil war against the Tax ruling and the ruling class priest have to revoke the Law, they were afraid lower class would turn against there own religion and ritual's which eventually will harm them financially and religiously.
Interesting
Art, Morality and 'Humans' - Demystifying Indian History - Manu S. Pillai - Historian - #TPE146
th-cam.com/video/t9INhxY3908/w-d-xo.html
I feel sorry for Palestinians but Israel akela responsible nahi hai is genocide ka, HAMAS is elected govt by Palestinians. So if Israel js attacked, you can’t say its only HAMAS who did this, it was Palestine . So whatever is happening, its their own government. But I am never a supporter of such a genocide , mai bas ye kehna chahta hoon ke is genocide me PALESTINIAN govt ( HAMAS ) utna hi responsible hai.
Read. Take a course on Colonization 101. M not saying bcz it affects me or us because we have surpassed that stage but am saying to read for your own soul and consceicne.
@@Shazi_Li so when Palestinians were dragging Israeli women naked and people were cheering for them, where was their consciousness ? So they were happy for HAMAS or they were happy for Palestine ? Everyone knows its all about hate for the jews .. don’t ask me where is that written. But what u expect when they killed 1000 plus people just like that? There is no point in playing the victim card.. Palestine started the war and now they got the war.. what else did they expected ? I hate all this war stuff coz I hate how innocent people bear the consequences .. Quran 7:176, the culprit behind the hate against Jews.. so what u expect when little kids are reading that and u think they will be in love with the Jews where they are called dogs . How come nobody talks about why there are so many terrorist organisations in this whole wide world which are fuelled by all the hatred through this book . The war will stop when islam will accept everyone their equal which is never going to happen coz nobody can change that book..so go and read quran first and then , hopefully that will wake ur conscience..
'Aur ye but tora kisne'...... Shehzad bhai aapne ye baat waise bahut innocence me kahi. Matlab bhi ham samajh gaye ki Zaid Hamid ka image kisne tora. lekin But torne itni muhabbat kyon hai? Ya but se itni nafrat kyon hai?
❤❤❤❤
❤️❤️❤️