Poisoning Elf all choices - Thronebreaker the Witcher Tales - (The Black Sheep)

All dialogue and choices about an elf accused for spying ready to be lynched by villagers. Side quest in the first map Lyria.
Quest name: The Black Sheep + Sabotage
What happens when you let the elf join your army, leave him behind or let him die.
Thronebreaker the Witcher tales

[@nylocks8433]

When I first played this game I took the Elf with me, and when they started getting poisoned I instantly realized this decision was probably the one that bit me in the ass. Taught me a lesson afterwards, this game doesn't always reward you for being nice.

[@William-Sunderland]

The thing is meve didnt let the people hang him with no proves, but didnt find a way to prove if he was an spy after. closest option is to spare him but dont allow him to join meve's army.

[@Quasimodo-mq8tw]

@@William-Sunderland Which probably drives him to join the scoiateal. Even if he didnt want on his own after what happend and how he everything he had got taken from him just for beeing an elf under humans, the scoiateal are his best chance of survival at that time. There are no good alternatives in this situation(and yes just letting them kill him is also setting foundations for lawlesnes and anarchy)

[@JmacBogan]

Was curious about this one. Thanks for the great explanation video mate, appreciate it.

[@martoantoniuk]

Wow, this was a hard one to decide. Thanks for the video explaining it!

[@12ambujshukla94]

If you save the elf and don't let him join you you won't be able to battle at turnifen

[@12ambujshukla94]

It may be because he talks about your advancement to the nilfgaardian reenforcement

[@YourKingVid]

That's not true. The battle at Turnifen will become available when you question the Nilfgaardian prisoners who you captured in the ambush (Enemy moves). I didn't come across any new dialogue or outcome when you save the elf or reject him in your army.