1. Because JK explained that she wanted to make it that wizards/witches could be cured/treated for injuries/ailments caused by magic, but standard muggle injuries/ailments are more difficult to treat with magic. She wanted the distinction between the two. 2. The “dentist” part of the clock was never mentioned in the books - this was a discrepancy in the films. 3. I think some kids know about the sorting hat - but other families choose to keep it a surprise 🤷♀️ in the books Fred and George had wound Ron up by saying they face a painful test or something along those lines. 4. Pretty sure the three headed dog would have done a pretty good job as opposed to the rickety old wooden door that could have just been blown up. 5. How do you know they did get the train lol? 6. Again, a discrepancy in the films - not the books. 7. They’re literally wizards and witches 😂 bit different to a normal school. 8. It’s happened, World Cup - victor Kringle caught the snitch but Ireland won. 9. Ron had been staying with them - something I don’t think was mentioned in the films. 10. It did scar Ron, it stayed with him for a while and he mentioned it from time to time, especially in the book, he was freaked out. Fred and George probably didn’t really know who pettigrew was considering they would have been very very young when he supposedly died. Maybe just thought he was a student they didn’t know 🤷♀️ doubt they spent much time staring at Ron in bed on the map 👀. Oh and you’ve gotta think there would have been 100s upon 100s of names on that map and they were only using it for the secret passages so might not have even noticed his name. 11. I’m guessing “accio” would have been taught in charms maybe? We don’t really see much of charms class. 12. The slytherin rivalry goes back to the founders - and in deathly hallows (the book) a lot of them do come back and stand on the side of good. 13. DATDA was a cursed subject ever since old Voldy applied for the job and didn’t get it. 14. Time turners had to be ministry approved. 15. It’s not really relevant? 16. Can’t send a parcel or the daily prophet through a mirror 👀. 17. Any name given by the cup has to compete, It’s a binding magical contract similar to an unbreakable vow, and if you break and unbreakable vow - you die🤷♀️. 18. Multiple job options in the ministry, shop keeper, wand maker, teacher, author, alchemist, astronomer, multiple jobs at gringotts, broom maker, executioner, journalist, owl trainer, quidditch, multiple jobs at st mangos, the list goes on… 19. Molly was the perfect person to kill bellatrix- she did so much damage to her family and friends and it was personal, for an unforgivable curse to work you need to mean it, and molly meant it. 20. Modern muggle technology doesn’t really work properly at hogwarts, and besides we as muggles have many useless pointless gadgets, maybe a rememberall is just one the many gimmicky items the wizarding world possesses 🤷♀️. In short - read the books kids. 📖
Accio has been taught in charms Summoning charm When harry realized he needed something to let him get his wand He went to Hermione so that she could help him perform the charm properly
It doesn't say she used an unforgivable. In the movie she uses a combination of spells most likely Petrificus Totalus and Reducto or Diffindo or possibly Bombarda. The book just says her spell hit Bellatrix in the heart but doesn't describe the color nor name the spell.
@@CommanderCodey true but she also put her seal of approval on the movies so they are canon but the books trump the movies when the movies do something different.
Self-inking quills exist, as do self writing quills (Rita Skeeter's Quick Quotes Quill). As for Molly being the one to take out Bellatrix, I thought is was such a strong character arc for her. She was seen as a mollycoddler, but she was always fierce and formidable. She had just lost her son, and Bellatrix was threatening her only daughter. There is nothing more dangerous than a mother defending her young. Molly was out for blood.
Yeah for Unforgivables to work you have to mean it. Molly meant and wanted to kill Bellatrix so one would work. Except that’s only if she did use an unforgivable. It doesn’t say what spell she uses
A lot of this stuff is actually explained. First off, nobody WANTED the DADA job because it was cursed. That's why we got Lockhart and Quirell. Any other teacher has a reason behind it-- I have a headcanon Remus was hired for more information about Sirius. Mad-Eye was hired for protection from Karkaroff, Umbridge was sent by the ministry, Snape was for Dumbledore's plan that he would die and Amycus Carrow was hired by Voldy so that... yeah.
The issue with Slytherin being a "bad house" and why didn't someone try to change that is a bit flawed. Slytherin is not unpopular with the other houses nearly as much as with Gryffindor. The other houses get along fine with them. They rooted against Slytherin during the quiddich matches because they were tired of seeing them win all the time. Our POV is from Gryffindor and Slytherin, and in particular, Harry and Malfoy.
I mean it’s annoying that Draco Malfoy was bad, if he was from a bad family, I personally would have sent the parents straight to jail and kept the boy in the school. Draco is one of my favourite characters because he’s a boy that has parents that are death- eaters and live in a big mansion but without love and kindness, just being angry and sad, emotional. Draco’s only friends are Vincent Crabbe and Gregory Goyle, that are slow, stupid and evil bullies. Draco became bad because all that pain and hate.
@Hello Live This does look like they only watched the movies. Is as if someone, who does not like the franchise, watched the movies once, took notes and made the video. No further research needed...
Hogwarts is not dangerous considering the outside wizarding world. It might seem so if you look at what happens in the school and take it out of context, but have a look at what's going on in the outside world at the same time. Especially after Voldemort returns in the Goblet of Fire. Hogwarts, however dangerous it might look, is still way safer than anywhere else.
@@peterkornis5377 You are correct. Plus we cannot expect "muggle" values and culture to be the same as theirs. I mean if we look at how some of our own countries are, that we cannot understand how they can be so strict and barbaric with their people. i.e Most dictatorship type countries.
For jobs in the magical world, you are forgetting something: There are all those shops in Diogonally and Hogsmade. Many could get a job at store such as Flourish And Blotts or Honeydukes or they could open their own shop, like Fred and George did!
Not to mention news reporters, working with magical creatures, bus driver, butt-ton of manufacturing jobs for wizard items, authors, seamstresses, I think there are wizard lawyers, healers, all mentioned somewhat in the books.
Ikr... injuries which are caused by magic can be cured by magic. But in eyesight case, eyesight is decreased naturally. It's probably like the case of food...where you can't make food out of nowhere.
I think what you said has some pretty good merit to it! It could be that anything not caused by natural reasons, like being born with it, can be fixed by magic. Then there are probably things they still cannot fix. They may have magic, but they would still need to know how to use that magic in order to repair it correctly. Hence why Harry got a rubber arm after the quiddetch match where professor Lockhart claimed he knew how to fix it, but obviously he really didn't.
The school didn’t give Hermione the time turner, it was McGonagall. She being a great professor I’m sure she saw the potential Hermione carried like those students that do extra curricular activities. Also we do know why Peter disguised as a rat but it’s so long that I’m too lazy to summarize lol so y’all re read the books or sum sheesh.
Have you even read the books because most if not all of the points where answered in the books or later by jk Rowling. This is clearly based on the films and the films got many things wrong or just could not explain things as clearly or at all in comparison to the books Also Molly Weasley was q very powerful witch and sh didn't use an unforgivable curse at all, Molly Weasley came from and extremely powerfull family called the prewets and was a very capable super even is she did not often display that.
You know, when i was little every time i watch shows that have things that doesnt make much sense, i always ask my mom about it, but the more i grow up, the more i realise to ignore those things, because thinking about it just ruin the show. I like to remind myself "these world have their own logic".
About Triwizard Rules, I heard in another video that one whose name emerges from goblet of fire, he or she has to participate otherwise they'll die..... It's somewhat like unbreakable vow.... As for after Hogwarts point there are few other careers such as magic zoologist, diagon alley shopkeeper, newspaper reporter,etc. The whole series is based on mother's love.... So the scene molly kills Bellatrix portrays that it's so strong as to kill the most dangerous death Eater.... And in another video I gotta know that she never actually used the killing curse on Bellatrix... It was some other one otherwise why did she burst into pieces? She should have died like an ordinary person without any scratch and body unharmed.... (exception of Harry and voldemort)
In the book catching the snitch doesn't win the game, it ends the game and gives 150 points to the seeker's team. Apparently the game goes on until someone catches the snitch, which could mean that if the team of the seeker who caught the snitch was behind by more than 150 points, that team would still lose. That's a place where the movies really drop the ball.
It’s the movie. In the book there is no dentist on the clock. Also the sorting hat sings its own song each year. I think the surprise is just for the movie lol I don’t recall anyone shocked or surprised in the book.
@@shareit8193 all the books came before any of the movies. The movies are based on the books. Rather loosely based the books at that. Most of the mistakes pointed out in this video are either explained or do not exist in the books.
molly is really powerful and she was from a powerful family, she didn’t show much power when she was at home tho but that doesn’t mean she’s useless. Also businesses and cooks, waitress, and conducters? wizards did this for money aswell
technically all these things made sense except the remembralls. You will find the answers in the books. and many things that you mentioned were there in the books but not the movies and actual harry potter is the books.
4:06 it was mentioned in the books that he stayed with the Weasleys/a wizarding family because he wanted to be updated on whether Black has escaped or not. He also stayed there because he wanted to know if he was still safe or not.
Many of these can be explained easily. The dentist in the clock was never mentioned in the books. It was mentioned in the books that parents can drop of their children at hogwarts if they want.
Well honestly I think Dumbledore never in his wildest dreams imagined a war to happen on Hogwarts grounds, I mean comon !! Who would think that a war would commence on a school ground ??!! Moreover voldemort was only after harry & not the school so he made sure harry was prepared to face him
Peter Pettigrew stayed in wizard family because he was looking for news of Voldemort returns. It's said in books. As for Dumbledore not hiring better Dada teacher. Voldemort put a jinx on job so no teacher lasted longer than year. It means 30 teachers in 30 years give or take. And look on fate of 7 teachers that were there during Harry's years. No wonder Dumbledore had trouble getting anyone accept the job. It's all in books.
I remember watching harry potter 1 on a school trip in the cinema and it truly was a magical experience. The way the following movies developed, combined with watching the actors grow at roughly the same rate as me is why I'ts still one of my favourites ever since.
Lupin was a good teacher because he changed Harry and Hermione and everyone else very well that's why Hermione didn't snitch that he was a werewolf because he was the best defense against the dark arts professor
One thing that doesn't make since is that Barty Crouch Jr (disguised as Moody) is allowed to use unforgivable curses in front of a bunch of 4th years in a classroom. The Ministry of Magic specifically states that such use is a one way ticket to Azkaban, but get somehow Moody seems to get away with it with no clear explanation
2:00 - remember this was in the first film, and security was increased after the events of the first film. Also remember, being magical people, they have a feeling of being indestructible, which can make them complacent.
It really bothers me in the first book that the philosophers stone was supposed to be better protected at Hogwarts than at Gringotts and yet a group of three first years where able to get it.
Yeah but it’s illegal to change time like that. Also in the books, all the things that Harry and Hermione “change” are all things that were never confirmed to have happened. When buckbeak is presumably killed, they said that they heard the thud of an axe and Hagrid howling, but conveniently, they never turned around to see what had happened. And Hagrids howling was with glee, not sadness, but they couldn’t hear properly. As for saving Sirius, he had never been kissed yet, just locked up, so they could still save him.
She can... but she cant. Hermione was warned, that wizards or witches that is using the time turner can NOT let their past self see them or else... you know what can happen to them 🙄
I do accept that Harry's parents look older in the movies because, well, you know, they are human actors! They age. The biggest problem I have about showing his parents is that we are constantly told how Harry looks exactly like James (except for the eyes). How come when they show flashbacks of James he doesn't look anything like Harry whatsoever. Why not get Radclif to play both parts?
And, you could always charm an ink bottle to keep refilling itself! I mean, isn't that what McGonagall did except, it was on a goblet of pumpkin juice?
An orphaned boy enrolls in a school of wizardry, where he learns the truth about himself, his family and the terrible evil that haunts the magical world.
The reason that worm tail stayed with Ron was that he wanted to know if “he who should not be named” came back. Cuz would muggles know if he came back?😂
The train counts as an extension of the school. Also, most of the students ride the train in order to catch up with their friends in person before they reach the school. They don't have to ride the train. Their parents can drop them off, they can take the Knight Bus, they can get permission to travel by Floo Powder, etc. The only students who are required to travel by the train are those who are muggle-born, and first years; at least if I read the books correctly.
In the movies, Harry isn't carrying Cedric's body when he returns at Hogwarts, but when he appears, he does have it. See, the books are so much better :')
7:25 - if you bothered to show the rest of the scene with Barty Crouch, you will have heard him say that it was a binding magical contract, the moment Harry's name came out of the goblet but also the following scene with Dumbledore, Snape and McGonagall, where Dumbledore takes Snape's suggestion to allow the situation to unfold, so they could understand what was happening.
Another common mistake when scabbers ,a.k.a Peter changes to human form he has clothes with him but when he escapes in a scene , while he turns back again to the rat form he leaves the clothes behind but that explains when he was exposed by sirious he had clothes ........ Hmmmm intresting 😐😐🤔
The reason that nobody talked about the sorting hat was because the sorting hat was the secret keeper of the sorting hat. But. Then Voldemort put it on fire and then all the people to have heard of the sorting hat before the battle of Hogwarts would have been the new secret keepers
I think jk Rowling chose molly weasly to kill belletrix lestrege because mollys bogart was all of her children and harry being dead on the floor and belatrix was about to kill all of them so I think that by choosing this charecter it shows how much molly cares and how much anger she felt at the time also it shows she has overcame her fear
When I come to think of it; not many people have glasses in the Harry Potter movies. It's Harry and Dumbledore for the most, and Dumbledore isn't even using glasses all the time. The answer is that Harry Potter is supposed to look like that, and he is too young to even start thinking of it. I am sure that with all his money, and possibly knowledge of the muggle world, he could potencially go fix his eye sight with laser. If this was back in the 70-80s it would be much scarier though. For me it was 2 minutes on each eye, with some apparatus, and the laser itself. Even if it was scary af, it was done very quick, and with no pain.
I read the books and saw the movies and I learned that everything in the Wizarding world is different, dangerous, but also fun. I want to go to this world and never come back!
With the sorting hat they cant tell anyone about it because of an enchantment which means that it's impossible to tell anyone who doesn't know about the sorting hat about it. Once people know they can talk freely. The reason harry can tell James about it at the end of deathly hallow part 2 is because the hat was destroyed in the battle if Hogwarts at the same time breaking the enchantment
One thing we have to remember. We cannot take our human experiences, and Laws, and then compare them to the "Wizarding", world and expect it to be the same. So most of this can just be explained by the fact, that it is a different culture than our own. Look at all all of the stuff that goes on in different countries in our own world, that we think are strange or barbaric, but perfectly normal in that country. As far as the Weasly clock goes, you have to remember that Mr Weasley works in the Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Department. A form of this clock may have been seen at work so they decided to make one. This could also have been a gift from a muggle friend. I'm sure he may have a couple. The fact that you never see or hear Hermione talk about her muggle friends/life can be two things. Either one, she does and it's just not depicted in the movies (it does boil down to writing), or two she doesn't because they do not want her telling too much about the muggle world. This may be done to ensure secrecy of the Wizard world. The fact that Owl's deliver mail, use quils, have rememberalls, or anything else we didn't feel was logical, that stuff again falls under culture. We don't have to understand. Why did Ron get ratty robes at the Yule Ball? We may think they could have just created a wonderful Robe magically. Even if something seem simple to us, it's possible or more, that that's just one of the things they just are not allowed to do or even able to do. So in reality it probably makes more sense than we realize.
. Because JK explained that she wanted to make it that wizards/witches could be cured/treated for injuries/ailments caused by magic, but standard muggle injuries/ailments are more difficult to treat with magic. She wanted the distinction between the two. 2. The “dentist” part of the clock was never mentioned in the books - this was a discrepancy in the films. 3. I think some kids know about the sorting hat - but other families choose to keep it a surprise 🤷♀️ in the books Fred and George had wound Ron up by saying they face a painful test or something along those lines. 4. Pretty sure the three headed dog would have done a pretty good job as opposed to the rickety old wooden door that could have just been blown up. 5. How do you know they did get the train lol? 6. Again, a discrepancy in the films - not the books. 7. They’re literally wizards and witches 😂 bit different to a normal school. 8. It’s happened, World Cup - victor Kringle caught the snitch but Ireland won. 9. Ron had been staying with them - something I don’t think was mentioned in the films. 10. It did scar Ron, it stayed with him for a while and he mentioned it from time to time, especially in the book, he was freaked out. Fred and George probably didn’t really know who pettigrew was considering they would have been very very young when he supposedly died. Maybe just thought he was a student they didn’t know 🤷♀️ doubt they spent much time staring at Ron in bed on the map 👀. Oh and you’ve gotta think there would have been 100s upon 100s of names on that map and they were only using it for the secret passages so might not have even noticed his name. 11. I’m guessing “accio” would have been taught in charms maybe? We don’t really see much of charms class. 12. The slytherin rivalry goes back to the founders - and in deathly hallows (the book) a lot of them do come back and stand on the side of good. 13. DATDA was a cursed subject ever since old Voldy applied for the job and didn’t get it. 14. Time turners had to be ministry approved. 15. It’s not really relevant? 16. Can’t send a parcel or the daily prophet through a mirror 👀. 17. Any name given by the cup has to compete, It’s a binding magical contract similar to an unbreakable vow, and if you break and unbreakable vow - you die🤷♀️. 18. Multiple job options in the ministry, shop keeper, wand maker, teacher, author, alchemist, astronomer, multiple jobs at gringotts, broom maker, executioner, journalist, owl trainer, quidditch, multiple jobs at st mangos, the list goes on… 19. Molly was the perfect person to kill bellatrix- she did so much damage to her family and friends and it was personal, for an unforgivable curse to work you need to mean it, and molly meant it. 20. Modern muggle technology doesn’t really work properly at hogwarts, and besides we as muggles have many useless pointless gadgets, maybe a rememberall is just one the many gimmicky items the wizarding world possesses 🤷♀️.
Oliver Wood: Scared Harry? Harry: uhmm, yeah a little… Draco: Scared Pottah? Harry: no Harry: I’m not scared of you-know-who! Also Harry: scared of myrtle seeing him taking a bath😂😂😂😵😵
They couldn’t make a spell to fix Harry’s eyesight because at the time Danielle Radcliffe did have terrible eyesight and needed to keep on his glasses for every movie.
Its not like schools teach you anything worth knowing in every day life it just prepares you for college which prepares you to work a medial entry level job
The defense against the dark arts teachers wer all last minute pickd since that job is cursed, and umbridhe was given it because Dumbledore couldn't find anyone. These people haven' read the books that much
some of these answers can be answers: dumbldore hired dangerous defense against the dark arts teachers bcs they were the only one who signed up, hagrid said “people say the jobs jinxed”
If you read the books and the Quidditch matches, they are much more intense and exciting than in the movies. You get to know the weather, how people are feeling, and just much more information. So, when you read the books and you hear about the scores, it's more than just catching the snitch to win. Some of the matches are actually really pretty close, even with the snitch in play. One of the reasons it's so important to read the books!
The reason they can't get good defense against the dark arts teachers is because Tom riddle when he didn't get the job he cursed it so no one could keep it for more than a year
The one about slitheryn being rude and stuff is because if they were nice people they would have been in Hufflepuff or something and the one about Bellatrix's death is because Moly loved her children so naturally she wanted to protect them in the best way possible
for some parts of the video i think you did not read the books. for your information Pettigrew lived with the weasleys to keep up on what is happening in the wizarding world. I also think that the battle of hogwarts took place at hogwarts is because they couldn't get 1000 students out of the school in time.
In the philosophers stone book when Oliver Wood is training Harry, Harry says so it’s like basketball but in the air with broomsticks. And then Wood asks What’s basketball? I dont get it, they all grew up in the muggle world (except Ronald and some others)
I just don't understand why nothing of the muggles swaps over to the wizards (Rubber Duck). I mean that muggles dont know anything about the wizarding world is no big deal because they are not supposed to know. But the other way around is a bit strange to me. The wizarding world is simply stuck in another time period, but why dont they catch up?
O.W.L.s always confused me. There are three passing and three failing grades. You can pass, but then a professor can decided you didn't score high enough to continue taking that class. So you're shit out of luck. The most confusing thing about Hogwarts is the actual education.
In the Deathly Hallows pt 1 Hermione says that The sword of Godric Gryffindor appeared for Harry in the "Chamber of secrets" but if Hermione was actually a student at Hogwarts she wouldn't say "chamber of secrets" unless they had names for each year. This doesn't make sense to me and really confuses me. I know they are trying to make the viewer/reader realize in what book/film they are taking about but I still am very confused.
Ur thoughts are right but harry was in the 'Chamber of Secrets with the basilisk and Tom Riddle, she wasn't addressing the book/movie name, but where it happened :)
The Quidditch thing is a bit confusing at first, but gets explained better in the books. Been a while since I read them, so I'll try to remember the best I can... The opposing Quidditch team can have 510 points and still lose to the other at 360 points after the Snitch had been caught. The Quidditch season determines, not by the amount of wins you have at the end of the season, but by the amount of points you've accumulated by then.
Yeah but still why such a big gap? It's not even fair, like the other team would have to be DUNKING on you for it not to matter. It's not good competitively
Harry's bad eye sight is not because of a biological reason.....its due to the killing curse he survived. This is proved when in the last book harry meets dumbledore in limbo after "Dying" and he observes that his scar (caused by a curse), dumbledore's black hand (caused by a curse) and his eye sight are all fixed.....clearly u don't carry ur magical injuries to the afterlife and can't fix them in life.....
This pisses me off. They didn't even try to read the books, watched about 30 min of each movie, and decided to rant about all the things they didn't like. They just don’t understand the wizarding world.
They don't make sense because the film makers are only interested in making a film for a certain amount of budget and under 3 hours. They also had to inject more action and violence to them to keep the audience interested. They left out any details that would explain some of the odd things, such as Voldermorts curse on the Defence Against The Dark Arts posts, since he applied for the job and was refused. There was another problem, when the films were being made some of the other books had not been written. So the adaptations left out things that later became important to know. Had they waited for all the books to be written then they might have made a better job of it. My own belief is that the entire thing could be redone as a TV serial. Giving it more time to fill in the missing bits. Lastly some of the problems were created as a result of cost measures. Especially the special effects around goblins. Having a real person helping Harry is a lot cheaper than a special effect. So they gave things a goblin did to Neville Longbottom.
![fellow fellow - PROUD feat. INK WARUNTORN [STRING QUARTET]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BQrVkMPTdHE/mqdefault.jpg)
"Do wizards go to the dentist?"
No, they obviously cast a spell to have straight, white teeth!
Oh I forgot that
well there is St. Mungo's Hospital where they have healers help people.
Yeah I like Hermione fixes her teeth before going to the yual ball
@@Maayrakk ya
@@cloudxgacha1 Yep
1. Because JK explained that she wanted to make it that wizards/witches could be cured/treated for injuries/ailments caused by magic, but standard muggle injuries/ailments are more difficult to treat with magic. She wanted the distinction between the two.
2. The “dentist” part of the clock was never mentioned in the books - this was a discrepancy in the films.
3. I think some kids know about the sorting hat - but other families choose to keep it a surprise 🤷♀️ in the books Fred and George had wound Ron up by saying they face a painful test or something along those lines.
4. Pretty sure the three headed dog would have done a pretty good job as opposed to the rickety old wooden door that could have just been blown up.
5. How do you know they did get the train lol?
6. Again, a discrepancy in the films - not the books.
7. They’re literally wizards and witches 😂 bit different to a normal school.
8. It’s happened, World Cup - victor Kringle caught the snitch but Ireland won.
9. Ron had been staying with them - something I don’t think was mentioned in the films.
10. It did scar Ron, it stayed with him for a while and he mentioned it from time to time, especially in the book, he was freaked out. Fred and George probably didn’t really know who pettigrew was considering they would have been very very young when he supposedly died. Maybe just thought he was a student they didn’t know 🤷♀️ doubt they spent much time staring at Ron in bed on the map 👀. Oh and you’ve gotta think there would have been 100s upon 100s of names on that map and they were only using it for the secret passages so might not have even noticed his name.
11. I’m guessing “accio” would have been taught in charms maybe? We don’t really see much of charms class.
12. The slytherin rivalry goes back to the founders - and in deathly hallows (the book) a lot of them do come back and stand on the side of good.
13. DATDA was a cursed subject ever since old Voldy applied for the job and didn’t get it.
14. Time turners had to be ministry approved.
15. It’s not really relevant?
16. Can’t send a parcel or the daily prophet through a mirror 👀.
17. Any name given by the cup has to compete, It’s a binding magical contract similar to an unbreakable vow, and if you break and unbreakable vow - you die🤷♀️.
18. Multiple job options in the ministry, shop keeper, wand maker, teacher, author, alchemist, astronomer, multiple jobs at gringotts, broom maker, executioner, journalist, owl trainer, quidditch, multiple jobs at st mangos, the list goes on…
19. Molly was the perfect person to kill bellatrix- she did so much damage to her family and friends and it was personal, for an unforgivable curse to work you need to mean it, and molly meant it.
20. Modern muggle technology doesn’t really work properly at hogwarts, and besides we as muggles have many useless pointless gadgets, maybe a rememberall is just one the many gimmicky items the wizarding world possesses 🤷♀️.
In short - read the books kids. 📖
Victor Krum* stupid autocorrect lol
And st Mungos** 🙄🙄
you are so right
Accio has been taught in charms
Summoning charm
When harry realized he needed something to let him get his wand
He went to Hermione so that she could help him perform the charm properly
It doesn't say she used an unforgivable. In the movie she uses a combination of spells most likely Petrificus Totalus and Reducto or Diffindo or possibly Bombarda. The book just says her spell hit Bellatrix in the heart but doesn't describe the color nor name the spell.
For the dentist one, i just wanted to say that that detail on the clock was left out of the book so it’s actually more of a movie mistake lol 🤣
Most of these are based on the movies
@@LayeGull yeah it’s dumb. The book and Pottermore is the only applicable canon because JK R wrote the info not the movies.
@@CommanderCodey true but she also put her seal of approval on the movies so they are canon but the books trump the movies when the movies do something different.
Self-inking quills exist, as do self writing quills (Rita Skeeter's Quick Quotes Quill).
As for Molly being the one to take out Bellatrix, I thought is was such a strong character arc for her. She was seen as a mollycoddler, but she was always fierce and formidable. She had just lost her son, and Bellatrix was threatening her only daughter. There is nothing more dangerous than a mother defending her young. Molly was out for blood.
And auto correction quills exist too .
@@ahmedayaat2727 Oh that's right! They were banned from the OWL exams.
Yeah for Unforgivables to work you have to mean it. Molly meant and wanted to kill Bellatrix so one would work. Except that’s only if she did use an unforgivable. It doesn’t say what spell she uses
@@CommanderCodey I think it might have been a non-verbal, which is pretty terrifying in itself.
It annoys me that all of these are based off the films. The books have three times more details.
I totally agree. Another thing is if they added all the details then it would be a really long movie and movies are supposed to be 1 to 3 hours long.
omg so true
be greatful fucking haters
So true tho
True. The films are innacurate
The Things: "Why is this like this?"
Me: "So the movie can happen."
Yep
Yeah!
A lot of this stuff is actually explained. First off, nobody WANTED the DADA job because it was cursed. That's why we got Lockhart and Quirell. Any other teacher has a reason behind it-- I have a headcanon Remus was hired for more information about Sirius. Mad-Eye was hired for protection from Karkaroff, Umbridge was sent by the ministry, Snape was for Dumbledore's plan that he would die and Amycus Carrow was hired by Voldy so that... yeah.
Harry Potter is my past, present and future 😜
Ya Harry Potter is my life
Ya ya avada kevadra
Yeah girl me and my mom loves Harry potter
Same😅😁🤣
As tom riddle would say.. Voldemort is my past,present and future
The issue with Slytherin being a "bad house" and why didn't someone try to change that is a bit flawed.
Slytherin is not unpopular with the other houses nearly as much as with Gryffindor. The other houses get along fine with them. They rooted against Slytherin during the quiddich matches because they were tired of seeing them win all the time. Our POV is from Gryffindor and Slytherin, and in particular, Harry and Malfoy.
Yeah it was dumb how they did that. All the books were in the POV of Harry so the rivalry with slytherin was only in the gryffindor pov.
I mean it’s annoying that Draco Malfoy was bad, if he was from a bad family, I personally would have sent the parents straight to jail and kept the boy in the school. Draco is one of my favourite characters because he’s a boy that has parents that are death- eaters and live in a big mansion but without love and kindness, just being angry and sad, emotional. Draco’s only friends are Vincent Crabbe and Gregory Goyle, that are slow, stupid and evil bullies. Draco became bad because all that pain and hate.
Alternative title: "Lets rant about TheThings that would have made sense if I had read the books..."
@Hello Live This does look like they only watched the movies. Is as if someone, who does not like the franchise, watched the movies once, took notes and made the video. No further research needed...
Sorry but I will correct you a bit friend. "Lets rant about TheThings that would have made sense if I paid Any attention"
Yes. Yesyesyes.
For real
if Hogwarts wasn't dangerous then half the books and movies would just be a normal school who did typical things. Where would the creativity be?
Hogwarts is not dangerous considering the outside wizarding world. It might seem so if you look at what happens in the school and take it out of context, but have a look at what's going on in the outside world at the same time. Especially after Voldemort returns in the Goblet of Fire. Hogwarts, however dangerous it might look, is still way safer than anywhere else.
@@peterkornis5377 You are correct. Plus we cannot expect "muggle" values and culture to be the same as theirs. I mean if we look at how some of our own countries are, that we cannot understand how they can be so strict and barbaric with their people. i.e Most dictatorship type countries.
For jobs in the magical world, you are forgetting something:
There are all those shops in Diogonally and Hogsmade.
Many could get a job at store such as Flourish And Blotts or Honeydukes or they could open their own shop, like Fred and George did!
Yup!
Not to mention news reporters, working with magical creatures, bus driver, butt-ton of manufacturing jobs for wizard items, authors, seamstresses, I think there are wizard lawyers, healers, all mentioned somewhat in the books.
Glasses were a fashion statement. Moreover, wizards might be able to fix bones, but not necessarily eyes, like muggles can fix cough, not cancer.
Ikr... injuries which are caused by magic can be cured by magic. But in eyesight case, eyesight is decreased naturally. It's probably like the case of food...where you can't make food out of nowhere.
I think what you said has some pretty good merit to it! It could be that anything not caused by natural reasons, like being born with it, can be fixed by magic. Then there are probably things they still cannot fix. They may have magic, but they would still need to know how to use that magic in order to repair it correctly. Hence why Harry got a rubber arm after the quiddetch match where professor Lockhart claimed he knew how to fix it, but obviously he really didn't.
Maybe your writer could read the books and check Pottermore before complaining about things that have already been explained.
The school didn’t give Hermione the time turner, it was McGonagall. She being a great professor I’m sure she saw the potential Hermione carried like those students that do extra curricular activities.
Also we do know why Peter disguised as a rat but it’s so long that I’m too lazy to summarize lol so y’all re read the books or sum sheesh.
Harry Potter videos always comes with some new details.
Have you even read the books because most if not all of the points where answered in the books or later by jk Rowling. This is clearly based on the films and the films got many things wrong or just could not explain things as clearly or at all in comparison to the books
Also Molly Weasley was q very powerful witch and sh didn't use an unforgivable curse at all, Molly Weasley came from and extremely powerfull family called the prewets and was a very capable super even is she did not often display that.
I'm so happy that harry potter was made like 20 years ago and people are still talking about harry potter
4:50 Fred and George: Our brother has been sleeping with this Peter-guy for a while now…
*proceeds to ask Ron about his secret boyfriend*
Snape, "My office is protected by a spell only a wizard could break!" In a castle with a 1000 wizards in it.
You do realize that out of those 1000s of wizards, only around 50+- would be fully trained as others are students and are not skilled enough.
@@podml I'd say most of the 6Th and 7th years shouldn't have a problem.
Fixing Eye Sight Spell
Interesting.
Your childhood is nothing if u havent watched HARRY POTTER
You know, when i was little every time i watch shows that have things that doesnt make much sense, i always ask my mom about it, but the more i grow up, the more i realise to ignore those things, because thinking about it just ruin the show. I like to remind myself "these world have their own logic".
About Triwizard Rules, I heard in another video that one whose name emerges from goblet of fire, he or she has to participate otherwise they'll die..... It's somewhat like unbreakable vow....
As for after Hogwarts point there are few other careers such as magic zoologist, diagon alley shopkeeper, newspaper reporter,etc.
The whole series is based on mother's love.... So the scene molly kills Bellatrix portrays that it's so strong as to kill the most dangerous death Eater.... And in another video I gotta know that she never actually used the killing curse on Bellatrix... It was some other one otherwise why did she burst into pieces? She should have died like an ordinary person without any scratch and body unharmed.... (exception of Harry and voldemort)
In the book catching the snitch doesn't win the game, it ends the game and gives 150 points to the seeker's team. Apparently the game goes on until someone catches the snitch, which could mean that if the team of the seeker who caught the snitch was behind by more than 150 points, that team would still lose. That's a place where the movies really drop the ball.
'What... is a rUbBeR dUcK?'
'Oh.'
Love this
For the Scotland back tracking one, I think that the Scottish students are given a different way to hogwarts
It’s the movie. In the book there is no dentist on the clock. Also the sorting hat sings its own song each year. I think the surprise is just for the movie lol I don’t recall anyone shocked or surprised in the book.
But didn't the movie come first??or was it the book???
@@shareit8193 all the books came before any of the movies. The movies are based on the books. Rather loosely based the books at that. Most of the mistakes pointed out in this video are either explained or do not exist in the books.
@@emeraldcountess8471 ok
@@emeraldcountess8471 the movie is like a short summary of the books basically.
molly is really powerful and she was from a powerful family, she didn’t show much power when she was at home tho but that doesn’t mean she’s useless. Also businesses and cooks, waitress, and conducters? wizards did this for money aswell
technically all these things made sense except the remembralls. You will find the answers in the books. and many things that you mentioned were there in the books but not the movies and actual harry potter is the books.
4:06 it was mentioned in the books that he stayed with the Weasleys/a wizarding family because he wanted to be updated on whether Black has escaped or not. He also stayed there because he wanted to know if he was still safe or not.
Three important words that you have to take into consideration: READ THE BOOKS.
Many of these can be explained easily. The dentist in the clock was never mentioned in the books. It was mentioned in the books that parents can drop of their children at hogwarts if they want.
Well honestly I think Dumbledore never in his wildest dreams imagined a war to happen on Hogwarts grounds, I mean comon !! Who would think that a war would commence on a school ground ??!! Moreover voldemort was only after harry & not the school so he made sure harry was prepared to face him
With the hat thing, Ron wasn't told he thaught you had to fight a troll
remous was a good teacher!!!!
Peter Pettigrew stayed in wizard family because he was looking for news of Voldemort returns. It's said in books. As for Dumbledore not hiring better Dada teacher. Voldemort put a jinx on job so no teacher lasted longer than year. It means 30 teachers in 30 years give or take. And look on fate of 7 teachers that were there during Harry's years. No wonder Dumbledore had trouble getting anyone accept the job.
It's all in books.
For the first one , it is clearly mentioned that even magic has its limits
I remember watching harry potter 1 on a school trip in the cinema and it truly was a magical experience. The way the following movies developed, combined with watching the actors grow at roughly the same rate as me is why I'ts still one of my favourites ever since.
We never know what spell Mrs weasley uses in the book to down bellatrix. A lot of this is movie mistakes. Y’all didn’t read the book and it shows lmao
Lupin was a good teacher because he changed Harry and Hermione and everyone else very well that's why Hermione didn't snitch that he was a werewolf because he was the best defense against the dark arts professor
One thing that doesn't make since is that Barty Crouch Jr (disguised as Moody) is allowed to use unforgivable curses in front of a bunch of 4th years in a classroom. The Ministry of Magic specifically states that such use is a one way ticket to Azkaban, but get somehow Moody seems to get away with it with no clear explanation
Molly didn't use an unforgivable curse.
2:00 - remember this was in the first film, and security was increased after the events of the first film. Also remember, being magical people, they have a feeling of being indestructible, which can make them complacent.
There is actually a dentist in diagon alley😌
A magical safety net during quidditch match’s would have made a massive difference.
:)
It really bothers me in the first book that the philosophers stone was supposed to be better protected at Hogwarts than at Gringotts and yet a group of three first years where able to get it.
If hermoine had a time turner she could’ve easily gone back in time before the war to warn Harry or dumbledore she had soo much power
No but after for third year she gave a time turner back to McGonigal
@@Maayrakk Yep, and also in Order of the Phoenix, the time turners were destroyed.
@@nrlstatistics4898 Yeah
Yeah but it’s illegal to change time like that. Also in the books, all the things that Harry and Hermione “change” are all things that were never confirmed to have happened. When buckbeak is presumably killed, they said that they heard the thud of an axe and Hagrid howling, but conveniently, they never turned around to see what had happened. And Hagrids howling was with glee, not sadness, but they couldn’t hear properly. As for saving Sirius, he had never been kissed yet, just locked up, so they could still save him.
She can... but she cant. Hermione was warned, that wizards or witches that is using the time turner can NOT let their past self see them or else... you know what can happen to them 🙄
I do accept that Harry's parents look older in the movies because, well, you know, they are human actors! They age.
The biggest problem I have about showing his parents is that we are constantly told how Harry looks exactly like James (except for the eyes). How come when they show flashbacks of James he doesn't look anything like Harry whatsoever. Why not get Radclif to play both parts?
And, you could always charm an ink bottle to keep refilling itself! I mean, isn't that what McGonagall did except, it was on a goblet of pumpkin juice?
Hermione was 14 when she had the Time Turner. Her birthday is September 12th.
An orphaned boy enrolls in a school of wizardry, where he learns the truth about himself, his family and the terrible evil that haunts the magical world.
“They look like 30”
Them: EMOTIONAL DAMAGE
7:15 - These were not just regular owls. They were magical owls with far more power and understanding than their muggle version.
i think fred and george didnt know who peter pettigrew was, because they didnt know anything about harry's parents or sirius
The reason that worm tail stayed with Ron was that he wanted to know if “he who should not be named” came back. Cuz would muggles know if he came back?😂
The train makes me confused hermionie wasnt on school and used magic
The train counts as an extension of the school.
Also, most of the students ride the train in order to catch up with their friends in person before they reach the school. They don't have to ride the train. Their parents can drop them off, they can take the Knight Bus, they can get permission to travel by Floo Powder, etc. The only students who are required to travel by the train are those who are muggle-born, and first years; at least if I read the books correctly.
In the movies, Harry isn't carrying Cedric's body when he returns at Hogwarts, but when he appears, he does have it. See, the books are so much better :')
7:25 - if you bothered to show the rest of the scene with Barty Crouch, you will have heard him say that it was a binding magical contract, the moment Harry's name came out of the goblet but also the following scene with Dumbledore, Snape and McGonagall, where Dumbledore takes Snape's suggestion to allow the situation to unfold, so they could understand what was happening.
For the scabbers Weasley one, Peter became a rat so he can get information and give it to Voldemort
Well, I've always been wondering what happens when the witches' periods come for a visit. Like do they use pads or not
🤔
Sorry, but I would just as soon not think about that.
The thing about the dentists... Ron’s family is just careful and the others are stereotypical brits
even if Harry potter was the most insane book series ever i'd still read it lol
Another common mistake when scabbers ,a.k.a Peter changes to human form he has clothes with him but when he escapes in a scene , while he turns back again to the rat form he leaves the clothes behind but that explains when he was exposed by sirious he had clothes ........ Hmmmm intresting 😐😐🤔
The reason that nobody talked about the sorting hat was because the sorting hat was the secret keeper of the sorting hat. But. Then Voldemort put it on fire and then all the people to have heard of the sorting hat before the battle of Hogwarts would have been the new secret keepers
I think jk Rowling chose molly weasly to kill belletrix lestrege because mollys bogart was all of her children and harry being dead on the floor and belatrix was about to kill all of them so I think that by choosing this charecter it shows how much molly cares and how much anger she felt at the time also it shows she has overcame her fear
Nah don’t disrespect molly she had the power of love on her side
When I come to think of it; not many people have glasses in the Harry Potter movies. It's Harry and Dumbledore for the most, and Dumbledore isn't even using glasses all the time. The answer is that Harry Potter is supposed to look like that, and he is too young to even start thinking of it. I am sure that with all his money, and possibly knowledge of the muggle world, he could potencially go fix his eye sight with laser. If this was back in the 70-80s it would be much scarier though. For me it was 2 minutes on each eye, with some apparatus, and the laser itself. Even if it was scary af, it was done very quick, and with no pain.
I’m surprised Wizards don’t know about Dentistry and rubber ducks.
I read the books and saw the movies and I learned that everything in the Wizarding world is different, dangerous, but also fun. I want to go to this world and never come back!
With the sorting hat they cant tell anyone about it because of an enchantment which means that it's impossible to tell anyone who doesn't know about the sorting hat about it. Once people know they can talk freely. The reason harry can tell James about it at the end of deathly hallow part 2 is because the hat was destroyed in the battle if Hogwarts at the same time breaking the enchantment
One thing we have to remember. We cannot take our human experiences, and Laws, and then compare them to the "Wizarding", world and expect it to be the same. So most of this can just be explained by the fact, that it is a different culture than our own. Look at all all of the stuff that goes on in different countries in our own world, that we think are strange or barbaric, but perfectly normal in that country. As far as the Weasly clock goes, you have to remember that Mr Weasley works in the Misuse of Muggle Artifacts Department. A form of this clock may have been seen at work so they decided to make one. This could also have been a gift from a muggle friend. I'm sure he may have a couple. The fact that you never see or hear Hermione talk about her muggle friends/life can be two things. Either one, she does and it's just not depicted in the movies (it does boil down to writing), or two she doesn't because they do not want her telling too much about the muggle world. This may be done to ensure secrecy of the Wizard world. The fact that Owl's deliver mail, use quils, have rememberalls, or anything else we didn't feel was logical, that stuff again falls under culture. We don't have to understand. Why did Ron get ratty robes at the Yule Ball? We may think they could have just created a wonderful Robe magically. Even if something seem simple to us, it's possible or more, that that's just one of the things they just are not allowed to do or even able to do. So in reality it probably makes more sense than we realize.
. Because JK explained that she wanted to make it that wizards/witches could be cured/treated for injuries/ailments caused by magic, but standard muggle injuries/ailments are more difficult to treat with magic. She wanted the distinction between the two.
2. The “dentist” part of the clock was never mentioned in the books - this was a discrepancy in the films.
3. I think some kids know about the sorting hat - but other families choose to keep it a surprise 🤷♀️ in the books Fred and George had wound Ron up by saying they face a painful test or something along those lines.
4. Pretty sure the three headed dog would have done a pretty good job as opposed to the rickety old wooden door that could have just been blown up.
5. How do you know they did get the train lol?
6. Again, a discrepancy in the films - not the books.
7. They’re literally wizards and witches 😂 bit different to a normal school.
8. It’s happened, World Cup - victor Kringle caught the snitch but Ireland won.
9. Ron had been staying with them - something I don’t think was mentioned in the films.
10. It did scar Ron, it stayed with him for a while and he mentioned it from time to time, especially in the book, he was freaked out. Fred and George probably didn’t really know who pettigrew was considering they would have been very very young when he supposedly died. Maybe just thought he was a student they didn’t know 🤷♀️ doubt they spent much time staring at Ron in bed on the map 👀. Oh and you’ve gotta think there would have been 100s upon 100s of names on that map and they were only using it for the secret passages so might not have even noticed his name.
11. I’m guessing “accio” would have been taught in charms maybe? We don’t really see much of charms class.
12. The slytherin rivalry goes back to the founders - and in deathly hallows (the book) a lot of them do come back and stand on the side of good.
13. DATDA was a cursed subject ever since old Voldy applied for the job and didn’t get it.
14. Time turners had to be ministry approved.
15. It’s not really relevant?
16. Can’t send a parcel or the daily prophet through a mirror 👀.
17. Any name given by the cup has to compete, It’s a binding magical contract similar to an unbreakable vow, and if you break and unbreakable vow - you die🤷♀️.
18. Multiple job options in the ministry, shop keeper, wand maker, teacher, author, alchemist, astronomer, multiple jobs at gringotts, broom maker, executioner, journalist, owl trainer, quidditch, multiple jobs at st mangos, the list goes on…
19. Molly was the perfect person to kill bellatrix- she did so much damage to her family and friends and it was personal, for an unforgivable curse to work you need to mean it, and molly meant it.
20. Modern muggle technology doesn’t really work properly at hogwarts, and besides we as muggles have many useless pointless gadgets, maybe a rememberall is just one the many gimmicky items the wizarding world possesses 🤷♀️.
Oliver Wood: Scared Harry?
Harry: uhmm, yeah a little…
Draco: Scared Pottah?
Harry: no
Harry: I’m not scared of you-know-who!
Also Harry: scared of myrtle seeing him taking a bath😂😂😂😵😵
They couldn’t make a spell to fix Harry’s eyesight because at the time Danielle Radcliffe did have terrible eyesight and needed to keep on his glasses for every movie.
Scabers lived with ron so he could hear if voldormort was back in power so he could rejoin him
Its not like schools teach you anything worth knowing in every day life it just prepares you for college which prepares you to work a medial entry level job
The thing that Neville forgot was his uniform everyone was wearing their full uniform but he was not
The defense against the dark arts teachers wer all last minute pickd since that job is cursed, and umbridhe was given it because Dumbledore couldn't find anyone. These people haven' read the books that much
I think madam pomfrey Will be every type of doctor like making hermiones teeth smaller like being the dentist like that
8:12 Molly did not use an Unforgivable Curse, she used something else.
some of these answers can be
answers: dumbldore hired dangerous defense against the dark arts teachers bcs they were the only one who signed up, hagrid said “people say the jobs jinxed”
3:15 that's because Hagrid does not know whats dangerous to others
If you read the books and the Quidditch matches, they are much more intense and exciting than in the movies. You get to know the weather, how people are feeling, and just much more information. So, when you read the books and you hear about the scores, it's more than just catching the snitch to win. Some of the matches are actually really pretty close, even with the snitch in play. One of the reasons it's so important to read the books!
The reason they can't get good defense against the dark arts teachers is because Tom riddle when he didn't get the job he cursed it so no one could keep it for more than a year
The one about slitheryn being rude and stuff is because if they were nice people they would have been in Hufflepuff or something and the one about Bellatrix's death is because Moly loved her children so naturally she wanted to protect them in the best way possible
for some parts of the video i think you did not read the books. for your information Pettigrew lived with the weasleys to keep up on what is happening in the wizarding world. I also think that the battle of hogwarts took place at hogwarts is because they couldn't get 1000 students out of the school in time.
In the philosophers stone book when Oliver Wood is training Harry, Harry says so it’s like basketball but in the air with broomsticks. And then Wood asks What’s basketball? I dont get it, they all grew up in the muggle world (except Ronald and some others)
I got an ad that said “Mugler” and I thought that it said “Muggle” 👱♀️🤛
I just don't understand why nothing of the muggles swaps over to the wizards (Rubber Duck). I mean that muggles dont know anything about the wizarding world is no big deal because they are not supposed to know. But the other way around is a bit strange to me. The wizarding world is simply stuck in another time period, but why dont they catch up?
O.W.L.s always confused me. There are three passing and three failing grades. You can pass, but then a professor can decided you didn't score high enough to continue taking that class. So you're shit out of luck. The most confusing thing about Hogwarts is the actual education.
In the Deathly Hallows pt 1 Hermione says that The sword of Godric Gryffindor appeared for Harry in the "Chamber of secrets" but if Hermione was actually a student at Hogwarts she wouldn't say "chamber of secrets" unless they had names for each year. This doesn't make sense to me and really confuses me. I know they are trying to make the viewer/reader realize in what book/film they are taking about but I still am very confused.
Ur thoughts are right but harry was in the 'Chamber of Secrets with the basilisk and Tom Riddle, she wasn't addressing the book/movie name, but where it happened :)
@@ashwaryaahuja3985 Oh now I understand, I was just at first confused :) :)
Actully Hermione was taking a lot more than a few more classes. She was taking at least 10 more classes
The Quidditch thing is a bit confusing at first, but gets explained better in the books. Been a while since I read them, so I'll try to remember the best I can...
The opposing Quidditch team can have 510 points and still lose to the other at 360 points after the Snitch had been caught. The Quidditch season determines, not by the amount of wins you have at the end of the season, but by the amount of points you've accumulated by then.
Yeah but still why such a big gap? It's not even fair, like the other team would have to be DUNKING on you for it not to matter. It's not good competitively
Harry's bad eye sight is not because of a biological reason.....its due to the killing curse he survived. This is proved when in the last book harry meets dumbledore in limbo after "Dying" and he observes that his scar (caused by a curse), dumbledore's black hand (caused by a curse) and his eye sight are all fixed.....clearly u don't carry ur magical injuries to the afterlife and can't fix them in life.....
This pisses me off. They didn't even try to read the books, watched about 30 min of each movie, and decided to rant about all the things they didn't like. They just don’t understand the wizarding world.
Molly didn't use an unforgivable curse.
It was unknown what spell she used but I'm sure she would never
They don't make sense because the film makers are only interested in making a film for a certain amount of budget and under 3 hours. They also had to inject more action and violence to them to keep the audience interested. They left out any details that would explain some of the odd things, such as Voldermorts curse on the Defence Against The Dark Arts posts, since he applied for the job and was refused. There was another problem, when the films were being made some of the other books had not been written. So the adaptations left out things that later became important to know. Had they waited for all the books to be written then they might have made a better job of it. My own belief is that the entire thing could be redone as a TV serial. Giving it more time to fill in the missing bits. Lastly some of the problems were created as a result of cost measures. Especially the special effects around goblins. Having a real person helping Harry is a lot cheaper than a special effect. So they gave things a goblin did to Neville Longbottom.
It would have been better to have based the comments on the books rather than the films, i.e. source material
They do make sense we just don't understand much in harry potter, and i know this is just for content.