actually telling yes to geppetto's question of trustworty father is a lie as we can see carlo getting humanity signs after the answer ( its says you feel you heart ... something) also we already know by king of puppets msg that geppetto betrayed us so telling yes to his answer is a lie and No to his answer is the truth
Not to mention the several signs we find that Gepetto wasn’t a good father to Carlo and he’s most likely trying to bring him back because he feels intense guilt over his neglect. When you know this you can tell he’s projecting Carlo on to you when you tell him he wasn’t a good father and he says “I gave you more loneliness than love”
I honestly lied to Venigni about the cause of the puppet frenzy because hearing the news that a beloved friend was behind a frenzy that probably killed thousands over night would be difficult to hear. I also worried that Venigni would react negatively to me and might not allow me to embark in future side quests or even deny me the ability to use by grindstone anymore. I just wanted to see what would happen if I told him the truth
I mean yeah, that's the point of the truth/lie mechanic. Lying is usually the kinder and "human" option, while the truth is usually heartless. I lied throughout most of the game (Except for Black Cat and Red Fox, who I told to f*** off, and i have ZERO remorse for those scumbags) The NPCs were so well acted and crafted that they felt real!
I think some answer depends on what you learn in game, example when Julian ask you ever heard of human and a puppet in love, you will be lying to tell him "I saw the message she left, saying she loves you", because you didn't but if you go back to Julian's wife corpse, you can see a note behind Julian's wife, write "I loves you, Julian", so choosing this will be truth. Same goes to Polendina ask whether you met a puppet loves a human, you will be lying if you choose "I have" if you didn't read the note Julian's wife leaves but truth if you read it.
Actually, Polendina's would be the truth because one of the collectables talks about a man who married a puppet (before you meet Julian) meaning that kind of love has happened before.
@@revheadcorrado5701well the question is if a puppet fell in love with a human not the other way around. Also that note IS referring to Julian, the note mentioned Gentleman J and how his wedding was ruined, later we meet Julian the Gentleman whose wedding was ruined. Kinda on the nose
Does anyone know what causes you to only get the “do nothing” option when talking to the Atoned? That’s what happened in my play through, but I’ve seen others get the option to give the Stalkers greeting so the Atoned doesn’t attack you. I didn’t get that option, only “do nothing”. What did I miss, anyone know?
There is an emote you can get called the stalkers greeting and an outfit as well so when u wear the outfit and do the greeting it’ll cause a different reaction from the atoned, I don’t exactly remember where I got it from though
@@mr.majorgamer5801Ahh cool, thanks. You pointed me in the right direction. It’s just the Stalkers greeting emote that you need apparently. You get it from fighting and killing the survivor npc in Venigni Works factory. I missed him in my play through, that’s why.
Wait I’m confused for podelina or wtv the butler in love you’ve seen a puppet and a human together the one with the wedding ring I got that option isn’t that the truth
Sorry again, but the line with Simon is not clear. You say he doesnt believe you and we see the red aura after your answer. So if you let Sophia live, what's the truth answer ?
Wait I’m confused for podelina or wtv the butler in love you’ve seen a puppet and a human together the one with the wedding ring I got that option isn’t that the truth
@manugames92 exactly ergo are explicitly stated to be human souls but if put in a machine's body the machine itself must be programmed therefore like the world of blade runner free will is now lobotomized and is now a common
actually telling yes to geppetto's question of trustworty father is a lie as we can see carlo getting humanity signs after the answer ( its says you feel you heart ... something) also we already know by king of puppets msg that geppetto betrayed us so telling yes to his answer is a lie and No to his answer is the truth
Not to mention the several signs we find that Gepetto wasn’t a good father to Carlo and he’s most likely trying to bring him back because he feels intense guilt over his neglect. When you know this you can tell he’s projecting Carlo on to you when you tell him he wasn’t a good father and he says “I gave you more loneliness than love”
I honestly lied to Venigni about the cause of the puppet frenzy because hearing the news that a beloved friend was behind a frenzy that probably killed thousands over night would be difficult to hear. I also worried that Venigni would react negatively to me and might not allow me to embark in future side quests or even deny me the ability to use by grindstone anymore. I just wanted to see what would happen if I told him the truth
I mean yeah, that's the point of the truth/lie mechanic. Lying is usually the kinder and "human" option, while the truth is usually heartless. I lied throughout most of the game (Except for Black Cat and Red Fox, who I told to f*** off, and i have ZERO remorse for those scumbags) The NPCs were so well acted and crafted that they felt real!
I think some answer depends on what you learn in game, example when Julian ask you ever heard of human and a puppet in love, you will be lying to tell him "I saw the message she left, saying she loves you", because you didn't but if you go back to Julian's wife corpse, you can see a note behind Julian's wife, write "I loves you, Julian", so choosing this will be truth.
Same goes to Polendina ask whether you met a puppet loves a human, you will be lying if you choose "I have" if you didn't read the note Julian's wife leaves but truth if you read it.
Actually, Polendina's would be the truth because one of the collectables talks about a man who married a puppet (before you meet Julian) meaning that kind of love has happened before.
@@revheadcorrado5701well the question is if a puppet fell in love with a human not the other way around. Also that note IS referring to Julian, the note mentioned Gentleman J and how his wedding was ruined, later we meet Julian the Gentleman whose wedding was ruined. Kinda on the nose
Does anyone know what causes you to only get the “do nothing” option when talking to the Atoned? That’s what happened in my play through, but I’ve seen others get the option to give the Stalkers greeting so the Atoned doesn’t attack you. I didn’t get that option, only “do nothing”. What did I miss, anyone know?
There is an emote you can get called the stalkers greeting and an outfit as well so when u wear the outfit and do the greeting it’ll cause a different reaction from the atoned, I don’t exactly remember where I got it from though
@@mr.majorgamer5801Ahh cool, thanks. You pointed me in the right direction. It’s just the Stalkers greeting emote that you need apparently. You get it from fighting and killing the survivor npc in Venigni Works factory. I missed him in my play through, that’s why.
You didn't kill The Survivor back in Chapter 3.
Awwkaay.. When all my curiosity was answered here, Thanks 😁😁
You're welcome 😊
hopes to find something out about the bloody wedding ring
guess its just something to look at like the romeo's necklace
Now I feel better for lieing i would feel bad telling the truth 🤣😂🤣
What happens if you say "No" in Arlecchino's last phone call? Do you get the lie notification and the key?
I get a naughty key.
He calls you a liar but gives you a present anyway. The present contains a key but inflicts decay on you.
It's now alidoro who does the phone calls btw
Wait I’m confused for podelina or wtv the butler in love you’ve seen a puppet and a human together the one with the wedding ring I got that option isn’t that the truth
Lies here are likely saying emotional or kindness things.
Ia there a reward or a trophy/achievement locked behind this path, similar to the lairs path?
The trophies will be about NPCs depending on your answers and the ending of rejecting to give your heart.
@@manugames92 already worked through it and got the platinum but thanks for the response 👍
Why do you have to refuse to go with the fox and the cat in Malum ?
No why, just curiosity of alternative answers.
@@manugames92 Ok, thought it could have an impact on the lie/truth playthrough but i couldn't see when. Thanks
This is an honest answer that lies in the player's choice 😁😁
Sorry again, but the line with Simon is not clear. You say he doesnt believe you and we see the red aura after your answer. So if you let Sophia live, what's the truth answer ?
Liberated her is more close to the truth.
What happens if I miss just one truth
No reward for honestly.
Does it count on the cat & fox when u meet then at the last chapter?
Lie or truth doesn't appear to Fox and Cat. except if you don't want to give a golden coin.
Is there an achievement for only telling the truth during a play through???
No.
thx.
Hope for cure is the truth here!! 5:16
You lied at the end haha
No, it was the most close to truth.
Wait I’m confused for podelina or wtv the butler in love you’ve seen a puppet and a human together the one with the wedding ring I got that option isn’t that the truth
Objectly it can be see as something fake.
@manugames92 exactly ergo are explicitly stated to be human souls but if put in a machine's body the machine itself must be programmed therefore like the world of blade runner free will is now lobotomized and is now a common