ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ส.ค. 2018
- You're watching the official music video for Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young - "Teach Your Children" written by Graham Nash. Originally released on the 1970 CSNY studio album "Deja Vu", "Teach Your Children" is featured on a 2018 Graham Nash career retrospective entitled "Over The Years..." Get a copy here
The video is a collaboration between Graham Nash and celebrated filmmaker and animator Jeff Scher.
The imagery frames the youth-led liberal activism of 2018 against the backdrop of the Civil Rights Movement and Peace demonstrations of the 1960's, providing a powerful visual aid to Graham Nash's relevant-as-ever appeal to teach not only our children but also our parents well.
“I wrote Teach Your Children because we have much to teach them. Conversely, I believe we as parents have much to learn from them as well. I think that Jeff Scher did a wonderful job of animating my lyrics and positioning the song in a contemporary setting." - Graham Nash (2018)
Subscribe to the Rhino Channel! Rhino.lnk.to/TH-camSubID
Check Out Our Favorite Playlists:
Classic Rock Rhino.lnk.to/YTClassicRockID
80s Hits Rhino.lnk.to/YT80sHitsID
80s Hard Rock Rhino.lnk.to/YT80sHardRockID
80s Alternative Rhino.lnk.to/YT80sAlternativeID
90s Hits Rhino.lnk.to/YT90sHitsID
Stay connected with RHINO on...
Facebook / rhino
Instagram / rhino_records
Twitter / rhino_records
www.rhino.com/
RHINO is the official TH-cam channel of the greatest music catalog in the world. Founded in 1978, Rhino is the world's leading pop culture label specializing in classic rock, soul, and 80's and 90's alternative. The vast Rhino catalog of more than 5,000 albums, videos, and hit songs features material by Warner Music Group artists such as Van Halen, Madonna, Duran Duran, Aretha Franklin, Ray Charles, The Doors, Chicago, Black Sabbath, John Coltrane, Yes, Alice Cooper, Linda Ronstadt, The Ramones, The Monkees, Carly Simon, and Curtis Mayfield, among many others. Check back for classic music videos, live performances, hand-curated playlists, the Rhino Podcast, and more! - เพลง
i am sitting here watching this over and over and crying. I am 75 years old - this is my life. One good thing I did with my life was follow the advice in this song. Thank you for this.
Your comment warms my heart.
Jim. My name is Raymond. May I give you a big hug?
Only 62. But my heart hurts.
@@johndickerson2126 They're values. Things that are important. Love, caring. Hugs. You, I think, are a genuinely nice person. Have a great life, John.
Isn't it beautiful?
I'm 72 old, but these great songs always keep me young.
I am 71+... and I understand...what you are saying* " Long... May You Run*..."
@@rosemarydaughter Grazie Terri
You too a continuous youth,
in the memory of a beautiful past.
Me too.
86
My all-time favorite song of this group. Sadly I don't think most kids today even know who David Crosby was. RIP buddy and for those of us who grew up with you, thanks for being part of this wonderful group that gave us a lot of great songs.
^ totally
It wasn't just David. Adding Neil Young turned this into a super group!
I listen to this music often and nothing else. I am 14 years old.
This is Marxist BS
Its a great song
"Don't you ever ask them why..."
But I did. And yes, I cried.
Sometimes I still do.
What an honor it is to have grown up listening to music with such honesty and love.
Freedom !!!
Yes!
Make All Your Choices Wisely.
@user-fi3hc8fy8p I agree. As wisely as possible for your age. In my post, I was thinking back to all of the conversations I've had with my (now adult) son. He has always known that he has been able to be open and honest about his life. And his reflections on some of the most significant forks in the road for him did indeed make me cry. The innocence of youth for most of us.
RIP David Crosby (August 14, 1941 - January 18, 2023), age 81
You will be remembered as a legend.
Wow. Aug 14 1962 here. Love this song.
The legacy will never die
4 the vig
Rest in peace, David. We lost a great musical soul, but that music lives on. Beautiful stuff.
by all accounts ..including his own... david was an ass.. graham nash wrote this song.
Such a beautiful song, and a very, very powerful visual, too. For many of us watching and listening to this tonight (Jan 19, 2023), it provides a fitting tribute /memorial. Goodbye, David Crosby. Thank you and your bandmates for providing the soundtrack to our generation.
How did you know I would be listening to this song tonight?
Luv ❤️
I grew up listening to Crosby, Stills, Nash and young. I am honored to say I David Crosby preform 3 different times in different stages of my life. I am 69 now and at the red rocks amphitheater in Colorado on a beautiful fall night, David stepped to the front of the stage while Stills was playing his solo part of a song. He stood there overlooking the crowd like a proud approving elder, his long beautiful freak flag of hair still blowing in the wind and his stern mustached smile beaming out at us! I remember thinking to myself - thank you David - thank God for you and the guys! What an era of music and struggles! An entire generation loves you and there he stood like master of us all gladly following his storied life. I am truly grateful and sadden on this day. Thanks for the memories! You tried to change the world. Someday the world will listen and change for the betterment of mankind. May it be tomorrow. Goodbye David Crosby - fare thee well.
This is beautiful 👌 💜
Very nice words - thank you!
I feel the same way and I'm still proud today that our "little" band in East Germany (former GDR), which was called the most American band in the Erzgebirge, played this song. It was a beautiful time as far as music was concerned and I still love these songs as much as I did back then.
Beautifully written. thank you for sharing what I have felt about David and of this fantastic band and the era I also grew up in. RIP David and thank you for the unforgettable music.
This song always makes me emotional. But wow. This video is so moving, I have tears falling. It's hard to sing along when crying. R.I.P. Dave. Thanks for the good, meaningful music.
Same here💕😪
wow, what a jolting commentary on society, thank you CSN (&Y)
The storyboard cartoon is as timeless as the song. A brilliant piece of work. Rarely do both work so well together. Graham must be well chuffed, 'soft lad'!
God bless David Crosby. He brought so much joy into people's lives.
He was the sound track of my growing up....dad played the vinyl.
My brother blasted it in high school years. Vinyl. Thank you Mr Crosby
🕇
Absolutely, and Teach Your Children Well comes to me out of the blue in our ascension
This song make my heart soar in unison...he says affectionately.
@@janelahmeyer2014 Continue To Make All Your Choices Wisely.
You can't get to much better than this classic, a masterpiece
Anyone else cry whenever this song plays cause I always do
Tell me about it!
I always cry! Like BOOHOO CRYING 😭🙂❤️🙂
Always , Teach your children and Our House 😢😢😢
No. That would be stupid but thanks for asking.
always have
Rest in ✌️ David Crosby! There are 6 generations in my family who love your music!
God speaks to me in various ways. Sometimes it's audible and that's when I need specific information or instructions. Sometimes He asks ME questions, and sometimes He brings a song repeatedly to me. This is the song. The words "And know they love you" is what has struck me in the heart. I think both my grandson (who I say I am raising, but he is really raising me!) and I need to be reminded that we actually love each other. I am teaching him to walk in my footsteps by example, not just words. BUT I am also teaching him (audibly) to NOT walk in my footsteps in all the areas where I tripped and fell. He's listening.
Most people don't realize that Jerry Garcia played the steel guitar on this song. He put it down in 1 take
@@karenciavarini6708 That really is amazing! When I record we have to go back and do a LOT of re-takes and fixes.
I love this song with its pure vocals and its sheer honesty....RIP David Crosby.
R.I.P., David Crosby. You played a big part of my youth. I have loved your music for 5 decades or more.
This song is an anthem for what can be good in life this song has to be passed on through the generations. My dad heard it and asked me why he hadn’t heard it before? Tears came to my eyes
You make great wine
This was the anthem of a generation, who felt we could make the world a better place. Sadly, we ended up going backward instead of forward. The dreamers became teachers and musicians. The greedy and ignorant became politicians.
AKA Republican politicians 🙄
@@karenlebouef6010 You only see in black and white.
I am deeply saddened but grateful for all of the beautiful music Crosby wrote and produced and sang!😭💔
My uncle played this on cassette in his house, in his studio, smoking cigarettes, humming along, and sending me to make pots of tea. A great education for a young man (who's now in his 50s), and a great legacy for David Crosby.
Journey well Mr Crosby, and thanks for a lifetime of music
RIP, Mr. Crosby. The torch is carried forward because we teach our children well. 🕯
Listening to Crosby, Stills, and Nash makes me think of my Dad...and it makes me cry sad and happy tears all at the same time. It was not always an easy relationship, but this song and this video can sum up so much. Thank you!
Oh crap I don't know shit from school
And Young.
R.I.P David. I grew up listening to ur voice, it's a sad day! Fly high x
R.I.P. David Crosby. Thank you for the great music. Rest easy. 👌✌🙏
THAT GUITAR!
Unmistakable Garcia sound.
R.I.P. Jerry 😔
My ten year older brother bought Déjà Vu right when it came out in The Netherlands in March 1970. As a ten year old I heard him play this album ad infinitum and thus it became my wayfarer for the past 53 years. But only now that my 21 and 20 year old daughters have left the house to go study across the ocean, after gaining adulthood in the universally known painful process of attaining their independence from us, do I not only understand, but also undergo the full force of this Song of Songs. The unbroken circle of life as described in Genesis with first Eve then Adam attaining consciousness, realizing their mortality and self-conscious of their nakedness they flee home to fend for themselves, leaving their bewildered father behind who gave them said consciousness and self-determination. No original sin there, just leaving home, just empty nest…
Om Sri Da ***!***
Make All Your Choices Wisely.
Sadly Crosby has passed away and this song influenced me to teach my child well Thanks for the great music and may you rest in peace
Danke für deine unsterbliche Musik....man wird nie vergessen!!! ❣️❣️❣️
So long, Mr. Crosby. This has been my anthem 60+ years.
Only just discovered this video tho the song has been in my heart since it first came out.
I love the statement the video makes without preaching - just simple truths simply said - and the way it shows our past so interconnected with our present.
I like that it didn't demonize LBJ. He actually did a lot of good for people of color. The Republicans have dismantled most of it.
Yea like the for freedom Republican party Lincoln freed the slaves and later thru history the Republican party got women voting rights with brutal resistance from the Democratic party standing in the school house doors look up and research the true history and learn the truth @@Sally150
@@Sally150 Really? Sally? *I am unsure about either political-party. How have the Republican-Party dismantled the "good" for the People? *I support you, and, I just want to Understand more, you know!
*I am a child of the 60's and early 70's in the USA.
Always Remember to Make All Your Choices Wisely
My parents use this video to make my video album from day I was born to day I was 4 years old to 18. I was adopted from Colombia 🇨🇴 and makes me cry every time I hear or watch my own video. I know they love me 🥺❤️ this world has a lot of catching up to do still
A message that transcends the decades and generations. After all, the core of life is really about family and the changes that we should teach and nurture each other through ..... is it not? A brilliant piece of work that takes me back almost 50 years and also has me looking to a different future.
Having my first child today brought me here!!
Even in this weird world we find ourselves in there is still lots and lots of joy out there, this is the very best day of my life and have a feeling that it always will..
If you start to forget that think of my baby Brittany... I have a family and have never been happier in my life than today. :-) Even in very dark times the world still turns, the sun still rises, and it might be some time but better days are ahead up there, too.
Well a big fucking welcome (sorry i cuss) to baby Britt lol mine are old enough to give me the grandkids blessings to you and yours
Oh nice!! Congrats with Brittany!!!
Brittany is being born into an awakening world where our old conditionings and fears are being shed, but needing to be exposed first - as what is shown in the video. Her future with parents like you will show her the beauty and harmony that is possible for humanity's future. We are in a process of awakening and needing to remember to live from our Essence-Hearts that know and live from Love, Tolerance, patience and forgiveness, and respect for all living things. Blessings to you and baby Brittany.
10 thousand hearts to you
❤️
My son chose this song to dance with him at his wedding. Yes, tears flowed.....
My hand automatically went over my heart when I read this Loretta. Lump in my throat ❤
Ah jeeze! Now you went and brought this big tough biker, retired construction worker and USN Veteran to tears!
I wish my dad could be there when i get married. go hug your dads, and dads hug your sons. Rest in peace dad.
@@eurybaric im with you dude..i really miss him..he raise me up listening to these songs and eveytime i miss him id come back here just to listen to this song! We gotta stay strong! Goodluck with your life, im pretty sure they're watching over us from above!
That's called respect x
RIP David Crosby! Thanks for the music!
This song brought tears to my eyes....its the truth they sing about....Treat your parents and teach your children well....
Still fresh. meaningful, poignant and....beautiful. Loved it then and love it still.
Graham Nash's finest moment.
I'm just happy I chose THIS Utube video to watch today! The words, video scenes, and memories both warmed and touched my heart SO! I am so thankful for both : Our children that love and, that have loved us so much AND for Crosby, Stills & Nash. RIP David Crosby, you greatest barefoot hippy ever. Fly well always!
Why does history have to repeat itself for 👨 to re-experience the same. BEAUTIFUL SONG..😍
Hello Irene
It always will.
The very first song that I played in the guitar. Very memorable. Love to play it forever!
RIP David! Your Music lives on forever!! ❤🌹
I have always thought that kindness and helping those in need will make the world a better place for your children to grow up in.
Such a powerful and poignant song, no less relevant today than 50+ years ago. The animation on this version is outstanding!
The animation is ass backwards.
Oh yes ! It's one of my most favorite songs since my 14 th Year.
Now I am 63, and still sing it, at home or driving in the car, always thinking and wishing, that there should always be the best love you can bring up in raising your children.
Wow, now I am sad, that David Crosby has left this earth.
I so hope to meet with all those wonderfull musicians, CSNY, Joni Mitchel and more in heaven.....🕊🙏
This song is so beautiful in so many ways. - I know every single person has a different story and feeling.
Reached number 16 on the charts in June of 70. Factoid: Jerry Garcia played the steel guitar for the in the studio!. Well done!
Hello guys from FRANCE! I remember this record 'cause it was the first record i bought with my first pay.I kept it and some times to times i listen to it.Almost cut my hair,carry on .....listened a lot of times so the vinyl is scratching but it doesn't matter, it's ever working!!! What an incredible record! A masterpiece.
Vinyl is great, scratches and hisses and all. Represents being cherished, and that’s a good thing. They were an amazingly productive and wonderfully gifted group and this album is one that shows just how truly talented they were and, I suppose some still are. Bon Nuit 💿🎼
Greetings from pas d calais
You have excellent taste!
Thanks, Mike. This growing old is quite a trip, every day another person from our lives is gone.
❤
Rest in peace David Crosby.
Rest in peace and thank you, David Crosby, for your poignant and timeless music.
WHY IS THIS PIECE NOT EVERYWHERE RIGHT NOW??
I,m 70 yrs old, and am wondering what happened that all our pleas were ignored! Tears in my eyes and heart, yet feel so blessed I lived it, felt it, loved it, and will always have it in spirit ❤ greetings from a Brit in Greece 😊
AN OLD SONG PROMOTING PEACE AND TOLERANCE!!!! WITH LOVE FROM ITALY.
Apparently, it promotes Marxism. Do some research. Marxism is anything but tolerant. -Jon
@@timmorgan9483 What? It's saying to be positive for your kids even if the world is shit, that's literally the point of the song. There is no apparently it means this or that, it's very clear lyrics.
@@szzk7937 Hi, I've got no problem with the actual lyrics of the song, that's why I loved it back in '70! Good message, right! Now, with this new video artwork, I'm going, WHAT?? At 1:48 Black Lives Matter is presented. Are you familiar with this organization? They spent last summer burning and looting our cities, destroying SMALL BUSINESSES, many of them BLACK-OWNED. They preach that white folks are incurably racist-- evil. They DESTROY THE MESSAGE OF DR. KING. Their lies are now the official curriculum in our public schools. They are the OPPOSITE of what I taught my kids: namely TOLERANCE FOR ALL. The video is racist propaganda. BTW, Trump, who is demonized here at 2:00, ELEVATED Blacks, who enjoyed a higher standard of living under his leadership. More black-owned businesses. --Tim
@@timmorgan9483 - Lay off the right wing media. Black Lives Matter is a very loosely-organized, worldwide movement to promote positive policing and criminal justice reform and social equality. There isn't a central leadership with any specific goals, let alone the nefarious ones that you alleged. If you want to use the genetic fallacy to condemn the movement based upon the ideologies of some of the founders, then why not do the same to the U.S. and virtually all of its institutions based upon the racism, sexism, classism, etc. of the Founding Fathers and most of the influential people from the subsequent 200 years?
Beautiful music for confusing times. The struggle continues.
RIP David Crosby
The world's a better place because you were in it.
I don’t think so
@@donburr4191 Lisen to the words Donald
Rest in peace Mr Crosby you were the voice of a generation
Society should be living by these lyrics.
But, for the most part, we haven't been.
And that is our loss.
Hey you might like a band called The Doublejumps if you like Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. Similar vocal harmony styles ❤
today: baby girl is 25, baby girl 22 and baby boy 9. have managed to survive up to 54 now. am so so so very grateful i studies these folks in 1980s college. songs still resounding. sound must have embedded itself into some part of my brain, tons of professional work up to this point, and still: most potent in my life is waking up each morn with this song on my lips.... must have been saved somewhere 35 years ago in some pristine part of my brain. Hope this 3rd child is the charm
Awesome song Rip David
the first song I performed as 'a child' , learning harmony and what it feels like to sing in real time. best ever
just a pure crystal of sensitive life and humanity!
Will miss this song and many more amazing songs. David Crosby I will remember you in my heart ❤️ and mind . Being present at 2 of your concerts 🙏😪
I've always loved this song, and this video is a work of art. The depictions of a few major events of two generations really made me realize what this song was really about.
It's relevant today, in 2024.
@@Valtitude Yes, very true.
Ink and water color.
It's a leftwing trash video.
I cried at my h.s. graduation in 1977 when this was played...now another generation is stepping up to fight for what is right...help them...
We are here Tom. Do not be discouraged. I tell you this from the past history of my life. May 4 1970. Kent State. PUSH FORWARD!
Remembering 1992 your ramblings in response to someone who witnessed a historical American point in time are full of nothing but speculation and contempt. You’re showing your true colors by not only dismissing a turning point on their life as “bullshit”, but insulting them “personally” without knowing anything about them. Extremely common and typical of the current regime of trump cultists; “insult what you don’t understand; only because the attempt to understand is far too mentally challenging”
Remembering 1992 Let it be known that I hold no contempt for you whatsoever. I feel sorry for the fact that you see others as brainwashed, as I felt that way for a long time. Only reading liberal new sources isn’t good for the psyche, and the same is true for only reading breitbart and fox news. Since, I have begun reading al jazeera, reuters, and pbs newshour, as well as cnn, fox, msnbc, and most other sources I can find with articles about recent happenings. Obviously, nothing should ever be trusted outright unless it can be seen with your own eyes, or proved veritable with public information. Things such as the curvature of the earth, the efficacy of vaccinations, and the existence of covid-19 can all be proven with either the naked eye, very simple instruments and calculations, or publicly available information from countries on every continent, in every language. I am sure that at some point in your life, you will look back, and you will realize that you were within your right to have your own opinions, but not to discredit the painful experiences of others. I wish you luck.
@@Remembering-rq6si your channel has no content. Nor do your empty words.
I am missing my 23 year old daughter and crying. I would like to think I brought her up well. She's an amazing kid.
this is just as prevalent in this day and age as it was back then. i think it's sad that we haven't grown nearly as much as we should have in that time.
Nothing ever stopped. There are more people in every generation with hearts & consciences that inspire them to keep going. We are going forward.
Great harmonies and Jerry Garcia on pedal steel takes the song to the next level. A masterpiece.
RIP David Crosby thanks for the tunes..
"Teach Your Children"
You, who are on the road,
Must have a code
That you can live by.
And so become yourself
Because the past is just a goodbye.
Teach your children well.
Their father's hell
Did slowly go by.
And feed them on your dreams.
The one they pick's the one you'll know by.
Don't you ever ask them, "Why?"
If they told you, you would cry.
So, just look at them and sigh,
And know they love you.
[Verse in the background:]
Can you hear and do you care
And can't you see
We must be free
To teach your children
What you believe in,
Make a world that we can live in?
And you, of tender years,
Can't know the fears
That your elders grew by.
And so please help them with your youth.
They seek the truth
Before they can die.
Teach your parents well.
Their children's hell
Will slowly go by.
And feed them on your dreams.
The one they pick's the one you'll know by.
Don't you ever ask them, "Why?"
If they told you, you would cry.
So, just look at them and sigh
And know they love you.
Thank you for the lyrics ❤
Powerful."Pick's" always threw me off. I understand it now.
Have always lived by these words, and I cherish them 💕 thank you 💕
R.I.P. David, thank you for sharing the sound track as I came age. We'll not be far behind, our generation.
Thank you for shining a light on its eternal relevance.
Tears. This is powerful and perfect.
But it missed the opportunity to show Bill Clinton locking up a generation of Black men in the '90s and paying Paula Jones almost a million bucks! Can you imagine an animated watercolor of him shooting on the blue dress?! How about $hillary getting the answers to the debate questions, Debbie Wasserman-Schultz and Donna Brazile stepping down for cheating, Bernie getting cheated out of his donations, votes and the nomination?!!! And what about Seth Rich getting murdered?
I only found this video today. I'm glad that I have. Thank you to all involved, though today, thank you most of all Dave Crosby.
RIP David Crosby. Thanks for the music
Jeff Scher does it again in Black & White & Color...VOTE, the Whole World is Watching.
Hello Alice
Great music from CSN. Always melodic and with a purpose, nice and easy. The swinging 70s when I was a teen was probably the best decade in music. 60 now and I still love their music.
71+...and still like a magnet...always come to visit their Tunes*
Listening to CSNY brings back memories of when my brother & I did a.lot of traveling in his Toyotwitla pickumtruck and not oh boy the singing & harmonizing was a blast!! Thank you, big.bro. I surely do miss you, but you're in a better place and NO MORE SUFFERING.
RIP Mike: b..01/06/1956
d..02/23/2021
Love, hugs, and a 💋 from Ringtail Mahoney Pot (older of the 2 sisters), and my feline, FAITH, 1st cousin to Funky Winkerbeam and Miss Tiggy, who went 2 mos. prior to Mike's passing.
Since this was posted I come back and play it & watch it at least once a week.
Peaceful but angry Grandfather
Who taught his child well.
Who's son is now is teaching his child well.
I got two girls & a boy. I'm doing my best to raise them right, teach them love & kindness-& definitely Grateful Dead music.
@@matthewatwood2581
I love hearing stuff like this.
Too many of us baby boomers sold out.
Not me. I'm a treehugging , peace lovin, ,hippie to the end.
Now 63 yrs old , I'm teaching my grandchildren the struggles of the movement.
✌& respect
Jack
@@angelblue314
Don't you ever ask them "why. " ?
if they told you
you would cry
So just look at them and sigh
And know they ❤ you
When ever dad hears this song.He would just Smile and look at me and the ceiling.He's 56 :)
RIP David Crosby play up in Heaven in The Biggest Band ever xx
So long, David Crosby. Thanks for the music. ...and the attitude. 😊✌️
One of the most powerful songs and films for what we must do and teach today...in these times of protest we must protect our children and our plantet.
teach them not to be human shield division for a group of people trying to get them shot from far away to score political points....
and if you don't agree, then you are blinded by psychotropics, hubris, or something else sinister.
Power of the film shows what has gone wrong with this society and your woke idealist.
@@penguinjay oh ok. You must be a trump republican. Anyone who doesn’t agree with you is wrong and evil. But what you morons don’t get is that’s called FREEDOM OF SPEECH. People are allowed to disagree with you and your view is not always the right one. I think you’re the one with the hubris issue.
I don't think you are getting the message Karin. The idea is that we honor our ancestors, including our parents, and teach our children that some things are too precious in this life to just sit by and let happen... like wrong things being done to others and freedoms being taken away. We protest and work towards making life better for ALL of us and that is how we honor our parents and teach our children precious things like morals and ethics.
@@davidalzofon540 the song said one thing but the video says another.......... woke ideology
Being a teacher, I am thankful for this time and place in our history of song😍
Amazing, thank you! And very fitting for our times and current issues. ❤️
What a fabulous "bland", yet riveting video, that records an incredible part of our lives. {78 YEARS OLD}. The Music endures! .
Jerry Garcia plays the pedal steel guitar on this. It reminds of me of watching the sunset out in the country. God, i wish he did more with CSNY.
Thank you for the music, David Crosby
This is something my generation and future generations need to hear…
RIP David Crosby - and thanks for all the music
Rest in peace David and thank you for the music legacy!!!
I have always loved this song, now I love it even more.
Whenever I listen to this song..i cry!! Love this song so so so much❤️
RIP Master Crosby an American icon. This song alone would have showcased him as a master musician.
RIP Jerry Garcia on beautiful pedal steel
really?
What Ted Pearce said - is that really Garcia on the pedal steel?!
Yep that's Jerry :-)
Sweet sweet Jerry !!
Cliff Smith I just read in Graham's autobiography that he asked Jerry to add the pedal steel and Graham liked the first take and Jerry said no, no, I want to do it again and Graham said you can but I''m using that one.
I relate to this song both as a young adult (,I was 18 when I first heard it,) AND as a parent (well now my kids are 30-ish and I'm 68.)
"Parents" to me include beIN a single parent, too, and also using "father" in a more metaphorical sense (with echoes of the generational struggle waged by my family members earlier than even my dad - and mom.)
I played it for my son, too, (as a single mom,) because I wanted him to know that *I knew* -- it was as hard for him as a young adult figuring out who he was -- as it was for me as his parent wanting the best for him. (I REMEMBERED my own struggle.)
This song is BEAUTIFUL because it acknowledges the pain and struggle both sides endure❤️ and emphasises peace and mutual understanding.
I have always thought these guys were way more emotionally intelligent for their young years (when they wrote these songs.)
Yes, the pictorial representation of this video adds even another layer of meaning that gives me chills anew.)
BEAUTIFUL & MEANINGFUL visuals!! L❤VE this!
Yet another favorite song from CSN. I remember a bunch of friends and I made a tape of this at the college radio station. Gawd, we were terrible. I'd rather listed to this song from my heroes here.
This has to be the BEST presentation of this song I have ever seen. This is one of my favourite songs of all time, and I have been performing it live since it was written.
To All the Artists: Beautiful. I was there at Kent State. I knew you were going there and I love you for it.
Hello Deborah
Jeff Scher! The timing in this thing is so moving. Each image is burned into America's soul.
I'm about to sing this with a friend of mine at the Unitarian Church, may peace and blessings come to everyone today!
This song has always brought tears to my eyes. This video made it all the more poignant.