I just finished this wonderful book today. It is fascinating and full of introductions of different scholars, intellectuals and writers. It also says how difficult it is to write books and scholarly works. Please do read the books of Ramachandra Guha. He is the finest historian and great public intellectual.
When is Karan Thapar going to do an episode on the “Sandeshkhali” in W. Bengal? These hypocrites have not mentioned the crimes committed by the Mamta and TMC govt. They did episodes after episodes on isolated incidence on BJP govt. but the Mamta govt have been systemically doing crimes against Hindus for years, to which Karan Thapar is completely silent. The left media and pseudo secularist continue to ignore the violence by Mamta & TMC. There is no democracy in W. Bengal.
my my my love of the game and his pal made Mr Ghua - The Author, he is Becos the two help present the side of the game what was hidden from fans in plain sight -:)
Mr KT read out the lines about Rukun’s observation about Mr Modi, but it appears that KT conveniently avoided Rukan and Guha’s observation / comments about Chidambaram ( page 204 ) and NMML & Mrs Gandhi ( page no 199)
Did Mr Guha implied He was a freshman in '76 @St Stephen. Even if High school was thru 11th grade , that would put him to be 16 year (if not younger) when he suggesting he is 65 today! Brilliant back then , too -:)
Ab mujhe PTA chala ki mera upsc kyu nhi nikla main history ram chandra guha ki pad ke jata hu ( Jo ki galat hai ) udhar bjp Wale udhar sahi karte hai or mere number cut jate hai😅😅😅😅😅this is very bed for me and I have same on you Ram c guha😅😅
Pray for innocent Muslim Brothers😔Sisters all innocent family in PakistaN Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent😔😔😔😔😔family May Allah protect innocent😔😔family in Pakistan 😔Free Balochistan😔😔😔
I being HansRaj alum from late 70s-Early 80s, Am delighted to be crossing path on TH-cam for different reasons w/my era alums from DU main campus - Stephinians, HinduCollege, heck even Kirorimal (though old-age incarnation of some make me puke in AB). Well HansRaj has its own celebs in DD news readers or Hindi Movies celebs (since late 80s to date),...
@Salman Rushdie "Hole in his heart" quip - Was it for his yearning Not being able to kiss his mother land sand? COincidentally I came across (again) Mr Rushdie , Ms Arundhati and then NYT reporter stationed in India ('92 Auyodhya era reporting) on a round table with Charlie Rose (then good incarnation) interview - Made my day -:)
Well, it definitely sound like “ grapes are sour” when unreachable type stories 😁 and feels like “ a lot of envy” still at this age?! Come on guys, you can’t be complaining that Mr. Tharoor is more popular, and it reflects poorly on Mr. Guha to publish those letters etc, it’s clearly in bad taste:) We adore Mr. Tharoor, narcissistic suits Mr. Guha and Mr. Advani more, looks like. It’s so weird, they’re complaining at this age, confirms human nature after all 😀
ONLY SHANKA KE AADHAR PAR APNI BIVIYON KO PITNE KA HUKUM DETA HAI ISLAM ( QURAN SURAH 4 AAYAT 34 ) DUSRI AUR MUSALMAN MARDO KE LIYE KUCHH AUR HI KAHETA HAI ISLAM ( QURAN SURAH 4 AAYAT 20 , 24 ) ( QURAN SURAH 33 AAYAT 6 , 50 ) 😢
I just finished this wonderful book today. It is fascinating and full of introductions of different scholars, intellectuals and writers.
It also says how difficult it is to write books and scholarly works.
Please do read the books of Ramachandra Guha. He is the finest historian and great public intellectual.
And again, greatness lies in uplifting others and not belittling them, Mr. Guha seemed wise enough until this:)
Hamare Loktantrik Desh Bharat mein Loktantrik Moolyon ki Raksha Honee Chahiye.---- AJAM, Buxar, Bihar.
Thanks, Karan.
I wish the publisher would call Guha and schedule their long lunch.
Profile of a friendship found and lost. A story of lasting sweetness though.
When is Karan Thapar going to do an episode on the “Sandeshkhali” in W. Bengal? These hypocrites have not mentioned the crimes committed by the Mamta and TMC govt. They did episodes after episodes on isolated incidence on BJP govt. but the Mamta govt have been systemically doing crimes against Hindus for years, to which Karan Thapar is completely silent. The left media and pseudo secularist continue to ignore the violence by Mamta & TMC. There is no democracy in W. Bengal.
What about the perpetrators like Shibu Hazra, Uttam Sardar of Sandeshkhali?
my my my love of the game and his pal made Mr Ghua - The Author, he is Becos the two help present the side of the game what was hidden from fans in plain sight -:)
So enjoyable! Thanks Karan.
Lovely interview ❤
Mr Guha's mother was my class teacher. My best wishes!
Made my day w/quip picked from the book as (is)suggested by the pal: Ranga voice is certification of a "fascist of thorough bred pedigree"!
Mr KT read out the lines about Rukun’s observation about Mr Modi, but it appears that KT conveniently avoided Rukan and Guha’s observation / comments about Chidambaram ( page 204 ) and NMML & Mrs Gandhi ( page no 199)
Read the book. It is magnificent.
Great heartfelt and much valued tribute.
Did Mr Guha implied He was a freshman in '76 @St Stephen. Even if High school was thru 11th grade , that would put him to be 16 year (if not younger) when he suggesting he is 65 today! Brilliant back then , too -:)
Ab mujhe PTA chala ki mera upsc kyu nhi nikla main history ram chandra guha ki pad ke jata hu ( Jo ki galat hai ) udhar bjp Wale udhar sahi karte hai or mere number cut jate hai😅😅😅😅😅this is very bed for me and I have same on you Ram c guha😅😅
Mr Guha had to come back to empty his chalice of poison since it gets filled so quickly.
Pray for innocent Muslim Brothers😔Sisters all innocent family in PakistaN
Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent😔😔😔😔😔family
May Allah protect innocent😔😔family in Pakistan
😔Free Balochistan😔😔😔
Oh the editor/publisher also gave platform to Mr Thapar better half?
I being HansRaj alum from late 70s-Early 80s, Am delighted to be crossing path on TH-cam for different reasons w/my era alums from DU main campus - Stephinians, HinduCollege, heck even Kirorimal (though old-age incarnation of some make me puke in AB). Well HansRaj has its own celebs in DD news readers or Hindi Movies celebs (since late 80s to date),...
What happened to garibhi hatao of Indira Gandhi...Mr Guha have u written anything on this or it's all bu...it???
@Salman Rushdie "Hole in his heart" quip - Was it for his yearning Not being able to kiss his mother land sand? COincidentally I came across (again) Mr Rushdie , Ms Arundhati and then NYT reporter stationed in India ('92 Auyodhya era reporting) on a round table with Charlie Rose (then good incarnation) interview - Made my day -:)
It is interesting to say the least - Editor being reclusive -:)
Well, it definitely sound like “ grapes are sour” when unreachable type stories 😁 and feels like “ a lot of envy” still at this age?! Come on guys, you can’t be complaining that Mr. Tharoor is more popular, and it reflects poorly on Mr. Guha to publish those letters etc, it’s clearly in bad taste:) We adore Mr. Tharoor, narcissistic suits Mr. Guha and Mr. Advani more, looks like. It’s so weird, they’re complaining at this age, confirms human nature after all 😀
*fiction writer not history
Karan thapar A traitor 😮😮
वामपंथी
ONLY SHANKA KE AADHAR PAR APNI BIVIYON KO PITNE KA HUKUM DETA HAI ISLAM ( QURAN SURAH 4 AAYAT 34 )
DUSRI AUR MUSALMAN MARDO KE LIYE KUCHH AUR HI KAHETA HAI ISLAM ( QURAN SURAH 4 AAYAT 20 , 24 ) ( QURAN SURAH 33 AAYAT 6 , 50 ) 😢
Because of Nehru's Nehruvian Economic Policy India became bankrupt in 1991. Also lost big chunk of land to China. Such a timid Prime Minister.
Ram Guha calling himself an author is as ridiculous as Jaggi Vasudev calling himself a Jnani.