Love this father and daughter conversation...They both are well educated caring, knowledgeable open minded practicing Muslim...May Allah bless them and their family...
So true! Shabir ally is just awesome, may allah bless him. I love watching all his videos - he makes good points and explains, doesn't make it up like zakir naik and co company. 😄
Ignorant , nothing else . She has out on so much make up . Huh . May Allah give her hidayah and also this Shabbir aly. Taliban are true war heroes of Islam
if you believe the niqab can be enforced, then i ask you a question. by your logic we can enforce the 5 pillars of islam too right? bc they are much more important acts of worship than niqab. Why enforce niqab but not enforce salat,sawm,zakat,hajj?? By your logic i can drag my friend to the mosque and force him to pray i can kidnap people and send them to hajj we can starve people and make them fast and we can rob people for zakat. This is why Allah says that there is no compulsion in religion.
This country main problem is economic & poor. they should solve this problem first then other. but they just eye wash people name of religion. infact its not religious systerm
I am very confused that allah is really say to force religious rules on people?i need this answer. if someone is forced to be religious, he is not religious from his own heart. they are just forced to be religious that it has no value...authority should establish an Islamic economy based on interest free zakat in this country. so that the inequality between rich and poor of the country is eliminated through zakat in this country. because main problem is economic
I truly believe Dr. Shabir and Dr. Safiyyah are godsend examples of Muslims that are DESPERATELY needed in our times. Their knowledge of Islam demonstrates that they truly understand that the message of Islam is meant for all times and places. Alhamdulilah for you guys!❤
@@Hassan_Cornehno they are not true Muslims if they create their own version of Islam. Banning women from society cut their voices their ability to work and do business their freedom to educate themselves is a big sin because the first word of revelation is Iqra =read and education is command of Allah swt. Of you can this you are nothing but a Iblis
Muslims like Dr.shabir are very much required in society. Otherwise, there is always danger of Islam being treated as a stumbling block for human progression. This person speaks so sensibly we feel like listening to him. He is indeed trying to bring reforms in the islamic society
The problem is that the Quran says that there should be no compulsion in religion. The Taliban is making their awful version of "Islam" compulsory, which is a violation of the Quran.
@ilamos___6853The Taliban have their own version of Islam and force it on people who don't follow it. They also force non believers. They got fucked by the Americans so much so that they went into hiding. It's not winning if you come back after your enemy just leaves
@@Habib7.no he/she very likely lives in some western country enjoying all the privileges of the western lifestyle but has a problem with Muslim countries trying to come to date with the 21st century. At least taliban stays in Afghanistan… this breed is beyond help.
I have never heard such a beautiful discussion. This truly makes sense. Quran came as the guidance of mankind. The Islam introduced by Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was the religion that was supposed to be relevant for eternities. For every era and culture. But the wrong explanations and ignorance of Muslims have lagged our community way behind. May Allah guide us all and bless us with the knowledge to understand Holy Quran. Also, May Allah blesses Dr. Shabir Ally and his family.
I loved it. While I see many in here sympathetic to Dr Shabbir explanation, I see others who seem to be very unhappy regarding his explanation. Taliban???? We live in the 21st century. I am not saying we go full naked or corrupting. I am saying use reason and kindness, for Talibans are neither reasonable or kind. It is brutal.
Shabir is a lair and the taliban exercise islam as it is written. This is the true islam. Like the poor women who was killed and burnt in nigeria. Watch the videos of shabir on concubines. Utterly disgusting. Sham on you.
@@freedomofspeech4512 depends the interpretation and understanding when you really look at tesfir is kind of weird why God would like to women to walk outside with one eye covered like dajal
As an Afghan living in United States I salute Dr Shabir for his stance against Taliban’s ridiculous decisions. I have many girl relatives that are sitting at home and not attending high school because they are not permitted.
I am Afghan, and it amazes me that the world know so little about the crimes Taliban committed in the name of Islam during their first time ruling. They would force people into prayer. Have watch groups during prayer going around town checking if anyone was on streets or in their shops not attending the mosque. If one was found outside mosque they would get beaten. They would also measure mens’ beard if it was long enough. Men without beard would get punished. Women had to be seen with Mahram outside their home. There were some widows and people without Mahram had to come up with absurd ways having young daughters dress in boy’s clothes to accompany them. Aside from that they could pick any young women and demand their family to grant her for marriage. People I know had to flee in middle of night as a whole family abandoning their home to save their daughter.
Strange all of these so called modern scholars are sitting in western world, supporting somehow there system of living by putting their efforts into the system....they can't even imagine implementing all social political and economic system of Islam unto themselves, I mean they can't dare to do this and....... that's ok.... the problem is that they are criticising those who were fighting for their basic human rights for the decades and never accept others rule of law over them and rather accept death......yet these king of so called modern scholars are enjoying their life in West...................why don't they leave these people to take their own decisions as we know they also have Scholars in themselves?
What do you mean by Education ? Is it science and technology and accounting and cosmology and medicine. Or do you mean Liberal Secular values imposed by the Atheist worldview?
@@shahkhan4347 short answer: To acquire knowledge has been made compulsory by divine commandment. The purpose of education in Islam is to associate and balance physical and spiritual development of humankind. Islam deals with the universal education and education for practical life and moral values.
I just want to thank Dr. Shabir for updating his thoughts openly on Afghanistan, and being humble enough to be open to changing his opinion. Many people today think this is a sign of weakness and double down on their views or words out of insecurity. As an afghan, I witnessed many Muslims cheer on the taliban takeover out of ideological or even nationalistic sentiment. It was one the worst moments I've witnessed as a Muslim to see people glide past the historical atrocities these people committed. So, it was nice to hear someone challenge their reading of the quran. Thank you for covering this topic.
Same here, they killed many afghans and made many widows and orphans and instead of apologizing to them they praised the suicide bombers. It’s sick to see members of the ummah praising the very people who targeted us.
SEVERE ⚠️ It is the duty of every muslim to defend the Quran & Hadith Every person Who defends those preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith will gain as much SIN as those preachers.
@@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45 you need to understand the different opinions of scholars. No one is attacking quran and sunnah. But having different opinions make you feel like attacking
And we shall protect them as well. While most dogmas have evolved from the middle ages, some have decided to stay in eras out of reason. About a 115 years ago the last witch was executed in England, I believe it was right after WWI. The Vatican kept Galileo condemn for his scientific proof regarding the order and movement of celestial objects. 90 years ago some peasants in my country thought there was a giant woman cleaning corn that they could see naked eye from their farms. Those fundamentalists are to be feared. They do not see how ego has submitted their souls like many other extremist in history. I HOLD THE TRUTH. We only think of ego when referring to a price winner, a rich person or a spoiled person. Ego manifest in more invisible ways we hardly realize.
@@knowledgezone562 Read multiple times. It was superceded by the verse in surah noor as as it was revealed after surah 33. And surah noor only mentions covering essential body parts. Also there are various ahadith of the prophet pbuh that suggest exposing the face is allowed. Also there is no punishment mentioned for it anywhere in islamic literature.
I am from Afghanistan and I am agree with Dr. Shabir Ally. Unfortunately we usually follow our tradition this shouldn’t be mixed with what actually Islam is. I like when he distinguishes the verses of Quran vs the words of commentators, we should judge Tafsers based on the actual verses rather than actual verses based on Tafsers.
Not many scholars dare to speak against Taliban and their failed political approach . We need more videos to highlight their outrageous policies/regulations that has nothing to do with Islam. Series of such videos will ensure Muslim ummah does not misunderstand them to be the revivers Islam.May God reward you and give you strength to work the way you have been working.
@@FreakyAxeMan how did Taliban become terrorists? Are you even Muslim? All they did was defending country and Ummah. Their deen view may be extreme. But they are not the Terrorists. If you are a Muslim, you are becoming Munafiqh
Surah 4:95 Not equal are those believers remaining [at home] - other than the disabled - and the mujahideen, [who strive and fight] in the cause of Allah with their wealth and their lives. Allah has preferred the mujahideen (Talibans) through their wealth and their lives over those who remain [At Home], by degrees. And to both Allah has promised the best [reward]. But Allah has preferred the mujahideen (Talibans) over those who remain [At Home] with a great reward -......Allah preferred Islamic jihadist fighters than those who are staying at their comfortable homes.
Covering of face is considered mandatory in Hanafi Madhab, and Hambali (out of 4 mainstream madhabs).. And within those madhabs, covering of face is mandatory even within ihram. The only difference is they cannot wear a cloth that sticks to the face skin, and hence those women who follow this have a special kind of hat or something to cover their faces...
@Ahmad Ganteng It has been proven that covering of face was practiced by Sahabiyat (R.A) too. And have been mainstream of majority of Ulema. You saying it a bidah is uncomprrhendable..
I just don’t get the logic of these people who enforce the niqab/burqa when the prophet pbuh LITERALLY said you can’t wear it during hajj and that normal women would cover everything but her face. Like hello???
Ok and? What does this have to do with Niqab in other parts?? Him saying that you can't wear it in hajj/umrah implies that it is to be worn the rest of the times
I clicked on this thinking it might be another “Talibs aren’t so bad” argument. Alhamdulillah I was wrong. Scholars shouldn’t get too caught in politics. But they must at least mention their disapproval of such extremist groups. P.S. I’m one of those who had to flee. We knew they had not changed. Immense praise and commendation for Dr. Ally for acknowledging that he had formed an opinion too soon. How can Muslims accept people who bombed and killed their fellow Muslims as saviors of their faith?
@ilamos ___ You are right. We did not believe their promises of amnesty and safety because we knew them to be liars. If we had believed that they were truthful, we would have stayed and tried to rebuild the country with them. Alhamdulillah that you are safe and I hope you work with them for a better future.
The foreign forces and ANA had done far more atrocious activities in Afghania then the Talibs... sure they are not angels as well, but the fact is most probably u flew as an economic migrant or you prefer foreign culture far more than your own
As a muslim i salute you for using your brain capacities to understand the words of god. Well said on 4:47. The Quran clearly states recognized, and the face is how a person is known and recognized. But unfourtenately people with low brain capacities alter that to suit their agenda or subjective tendencies and insecurities. But people like you or imam malik explain the Quran like it is.
It doesn't clearly state that. It might mean they will be known/recognized as Muslim women. If the verse was telling you to mark your cows and the cows will be recognized/known you would have probably concluded it is about the marking that gives recognition. If I said wear this veil, you will be recognized and not molested, the most probable interpretation is that I mean the veil will give you protection.
@@hyawill8944 The words used in here is (Yu'rafna) which means to know a person, this verb can only be used in knowing people it can't be used to identify or atleast it rarely does. If it was the way you said god would have used another word or added the word known as "Muslim women". I thank god for using Arabic for its vast vocabulary and it's ability be super exact, i'm guessing one of the reasons god used Arabic is to be so exact so people like you can't manipulate it. It is clear as the sun. If you wanna manipulate god's words you will be held accountable in the day of judgement. Woe to those who misinterpret and manipulate the words of god when they're clear. There is no difference between corrupting the Quran via changing words and intrepreting it as you are doing, both lead to the same outcome. Quran has one message, and one interpretation, if god wanted it to be understood as you said he would have said so just as he did in other verses with obscurity, he wouldn't want to leave things unexplained which can cause division.
@@icev1378 Muhammad Sarwar "...This will make them distinguishable from others..." Moshin Khan "...That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) ..." Those are wrong? 55:41 "The criminals will be known by their marks..." - yuʿ'rafu l-muj'rimūna bisīmāhum
@@icev1378 If you are right then it means Arabic language is horseshit. If I can say "You will recognize him by green eyes", but I cannot say "He has green eyes. You will recognize him." using the same verb then it is a very unuseful language. I will try to look up for it in dictionaries.
@@jubairomar2676 Taliban's order are based on quran chapter 33 verse no. 53 and 59 .in verse 53 only for Prophet Muhammad SAW wives but in verse 59 to all Muslim women.
@@binabina7801 Actually, if you look into history, men from the previous religions had already laid the foundations controlling women and Muslim men continued the tradition
it's not exactly true and correct. Men are mostly into islamic knowledge. there are many women but still in limited in numbers. so some men may got wrong and using that in the name of God
Taliban is overdoing things.. If entire society will be so restricted.. What will be left of individual amals and deeds? They need to learn difference between individual and social rules/obligations..
There are not nearly enough muslim scholars, public speakers or youtubers speaking out against the taliban. Thank you dr shabir for at the very least acknowledging their wrong doings and apologizing for your previous assumptions
Then why do you need to follow Islam? when you can enter jannah without following Islam? Because according to you it is a choice like committing zina is a choice but no one can force.
@@kodvavi150 By the way...your ignorant indeed....I really think you need guidance...I actually wear niqab...but it's my choice...as I feel its compulsory but it's not a sin to not wear it.Dont compare zina with niqab...that's ludicrous. Womens modesty is clearly to cover her whole body with a loose attire...only that which shows will be apparent...ie...face and hands & if she wishes she will cover her face..Its not wajib!!! (Face cover).Those extremists interpret it to their agendas...
Agreed... many wrong ideas being written over the centuries by these irresponsible people that confused the current generations. They wrote and teaches from their own interpretation.
As an Afghan the women in Afghanistan are perfectly fine with dress they are wearing, I can understand why you can’t say anything positive about it because you be face consequences
I have been left with a conflicting feelings after hearing the thoughts of Dr Shabbir as very recently I have listened to a talk by Assim Alhakeen where the messages were almost the opposite of what Dr S Ally stated on the matter of covering and traveling alone for a woman - I am a bit confused as I respect both individual and still have great respect for both but the term “liberal Muslim” doesn’t sit well with - US went to Liberate Afghanistan and tried for 20yrs there is a new government formed so it will take a bit to adjust on the other hand India wants to ban hijab completely and many countries already have done so, Saudi Arabia allowing concert to take place I am just very concerned with if I am actually practicing Islam correctly because in the day of information overload It is very difficult to differentiate between truth and lies- I ask Allah to guide me and rest of the my muslim brothers and sisters- Ameen
You're confused because you think there's one right answer.... If it's not in the Quran it's up for you to decide... Difference of opinion comes from the tribes and nations Allah made which is kinda the point. Islam was never about making one cohesive culture. It was about individual cultural expression in the name of Allah.
Regarding your take on India banning Hijab , you ARE FACTUALLY WRONG! Infact I see a sea of Hijab everywhere I stay and travel in India! The Hijab controversy was of a government run school where there was mandatory school uniform for the students , which a board would implement and the parents would have agreed while admitting their children to that school! India is not Saudi Arabia where even non Muslim women are made to wear the attire of Muslim women! India is a constitutionally bound democratic country and not a theocracy or a goddam Kingdom ! I'm looking out of the window as I type this comment and see ladies in Burqa, head and face covered too ! Remember, such fear mongering hype and misgivings will do more harm than good!
@Alexandra Henderson in certain issues there's not one valid opinions. There's a genuine difference of opinion, but not amongst people but amongst the scholars. Bc u can't interpret the quran based on ur own opinions. The interpretation comes from the prophet and the sahaba and the 3 rightly guided generations. Its like saying the quran doesn't really say pray 5 times a day. It only mentions the morning goes and evening so I'm going to pray only that. Islam means to submit to the will of Allah. Islam is all about making a good cohesive society and culture, all confirming to the commands of Allah and his messenger.
May Allah bless you and thank you so much for being so direct ❤️ I am from Afghanistan and I saw the Taliban very closely The majority time they do so much which makes no sense to the Muslims but unfortunately the Muslims countries are so quiet and do nothing. Now because the Muslims countries I mean their government do nothing it is the people job to rise their voices and condemn the Taliban actions. May Allah bless you all
I am very confused that allah is really say to force religious rules on people?i need this answer. if someone is forced to be religious, he is not religious from his own heart. they are just forced to be religious that it has no value...talib authority should establish an Islamic economy based on interest free zakat in this country. so that the inequality between rich and poor of the country is eliminated through zakat in this country
I am an Afghan and I strongly believe these instructions are coming from a neighboring country’s intelligence and not from the Quran. Even some of senior Taliban members clearly said that they don’t know from where these instructions are coming.
@@omarshinwari7823 burka is not an Afghan tradition and there is difference between chadaor and burka. Tell me where in the Quran it says that girls shouldn’t go to school. I am sure you don’t have an answer but to say this is coming from a neighboring country’s intelligence. General Mobeen a prominent and senior Taliban member clearly said that he wants to send her daughter to school but he doesn’t know from where these instructions were coming to stop girls education.
@@hayatullahrahmatzai9839 Quit whining Also quran doesnt mention anything about school. Hadith mention about gaining knowldge but that does not mean western idea of schools which promote haaram also Burka is Pashtun culture aka southern afghans and always has been. You can see it in the old paintings
@@omarshinwari7823 I’m sure you won’t be able to prove the prevention of Girls’ education from the Quran. Show me a single authentic prophet saying which indicates that girls are not allowed to go to school or gain knowledge. Tell me the source of these instructions?
People taking Islamic opinions of a woman covered in make up in public and posting it online for the world to see and also shaping her eyebrows. Modern day Muslims 🤦🏽♂️
Its obvious how this man feel's by the who's he having this conversation with..his daughter. A real father wants for his children be they male or female. Im a Christian but i do enjoy listening to the good Doctor.
May Allah guide Shabir Ally to Islam, cuz he ain't a muslim This guy accepts LGBT, denies hadd punishments of adultery, apostasy, blasphemy etc which is a nullifier of Islam
@@zaid4128It’s funny when a nobody comes and claims that a Muslim who is learned in the field of Islamic studies is not a Muslim. Where are your credentials in Islam?
Thanks for speaking out against these stupid extremists. I can’t see why any educated right minded Muslim would support them. Hopefully more Muslim scholars speak out against them.
Having women wear niqab is not extreme. In fact in all 4 schools, some say its not obligatory but highly recommended and others say it is. The wives of the prophets wore it too. But bc the western masters have said niqab is oppressive. Its oppressive now.
@@mohdshamil5652 that is something that is very rare. The vast majority wear it because they want to please their rab. And its not oppressive. Both men and women have dress codes and this is part of the dress code of women
It was narrated in al-Saheehayn that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to pray Fajr and the believing women would attend the prayer with him, wrapped in their veils, then they would go back to their homes and no one would recognize them because of the darkness. It was narrated that ‘Aa’ishah said: The riders used to pass by us when we were with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) in ihraam. When they came near us we would lower our jilbaabs from our heads over our faces, and when they had passed by we would uncover our faces. Narrated by Abu Dawood, 1562. It's because of these hadiths from aisha ra and other sahaba that some if the schools of thought say it is compulsory whilst others say it is highly recommended to cover ur face. U see in islam, the religion is taken from the quran, the sunnah, and the 3 rightly guided generations bc the prophet said(I'm paraphrasing)the best generations will be his generation, and the two generations after them. These generations include the prophet, sahabah, his wives, thier children, converts, scholars like imam malik, Abu hanifa, Ahmed ibn hanbal, imam shafi and etc
@@doctorsfaithcorner4917 bc it is the sunnah to not cover the face during prayer. Like in jummah when the khutbah starts its is forbidden to even respond to the Salam even tho on other times it is obligatory to respond
@@Sheeeshsheeehs no its not its mandated by the great scholars of this religion and highly recommend by the others. Imam malik, shafi, Ahmed, Abu hanifa. Aisha and ibn abbaas and ibn masood ra narrated about the face covering. These r random people but the wife of the prophet and his companions- and they have authority in fiqh and etc But like I said there's a difference of opinion. Some hold the view that it's not obligatory and some say it is.
As a result of wearing face masks due to covid, I'm beginning to understand the wisdom of face covering; it really hides your actual look. Makes one less attractive. Especially when the woman is wearing a lip gloss or lipstick. Even without it, she looks less attractive in a face mask and same for niqaab. I'm one who never wore niqab, and who never agreed with those who said woman must wear niqab, my view has now changed post-covid..... I'm now inclined to the ruling that young women should wear niqab, what more if she has adorned herself (with lipstick or gloss) I ask Allah to guide me in my understanding and all believing people.
The discussion is not about whether you can choose to wear niqab. Of course you can. It's about what the Islamic Government should do for those who choose not to wear it.
Hi Dr Shabir I pray all people could listen carefully to your teachings on Islam.There has been been too much confusion in the way islam is being interpreted.You made it clear and i thank you for that.We are all brothers and sisters
They are very brutal and unjust. It's a universal problem with humans. The ones in power and their friends always get special treatment and privileges. And they do a lot of torture if anyone messes with them.
You mean they fought unjust aka USA for 20 years . the same empire which killed millions of muslims Sad to see you support the oppressing side against the opressed. does no one here akcnoledge here taliban fought 20 hard years for their own country againsy a terrorist governemtn aka usa
Thank you Dr. Shabir for such a sound, clear and rational discussion. We need more scholars of Islam to speak the truth and be open to challenging the Taliban and extremist and narrow interpretations of Islam.
The hearsay regarding the prophet - peace be upon him, continues to corrupt Islam to the whims, desires, and corruption of man. We need to move back toward the Qur'an as the source of truth. The Qur'an instructs women to cover their bosoms, which to one who is able to think critically, simply means to have modesty. Anything outside of women (and men) having general modesty is simply cultural (not of Islam) or additive to the Qur'an (in order to oppress women). May Allah protect and bless Dr. Ally for speaking the truth.
The mother of the believers Aisha r.a. narrated that hijab was to be worn. Asma bint abi Bakr also said that the their faces would be covered in front of men. Muslims follow the Quran, as well as the Sunnah, and according to the sunnah, hijab in its modern sense is required. This is unanimously accepted among Muslim scholars. We don’t do things according to our desires, we do them according to Islam.
Muslims follow the rulings of Islam, if it is the case according to many, that covering the face is the correct Islamic ruling, then Muslims follow that. It’s not about what scholars want, it’s about what God wants.
One minute (2:42) shabir rejects hadith, then the next minute (7:00) he uses an unidentified "hadith" to try to say women can travel if it's safe. The question i would ask is, does allah want muslim women to be travelling and not home raising more muslim children? It just doesn't really make sense to me.
I appreciate the father daughter duo for really addressing the pressing problems of the Muslim ummah all over the world. May Allah reward both of you for the good work done to enlighten the community. I’m from Sri Lanka.
the taliban are the government. and have the right to impose the dress code. even if it is not in islam. they have the right to impose it. why didnt you oppned your mouth when the west were imposing masks?!
I think we shouldn't comment on a independent nation. Why bother them because their laws are for their own people. Come on. You people live in Canada and why don't you question your govt on so many things they impose on your people.? We are just poking our nose when we didnt bother at all for more than 20 years when America was there. Now you bother. This is not honesty. I'm not a Taliban supporter but I remain honest.
True. Im of the shinwari pashtun/afghan tribe and burka has existed before taliban, formed by my people even existed you could say were conservative. As in men do not talk or look at women unless there from the same family. Aslo burka has been a part of traditon for ages. you can see old painting of our people and they were the same custom burka they do today
Actually we should see the west and then reject Hadiths And Ayats which does not comply and thus westernising Islam and make a place for yourself in west.. It is the methodology of understanding islam should be.. Isn't it?
A state can inforce fard things not sunnah. Like laws for nemaz, zakah, hijab. You can force BURQA let alone niqab. Even scholars of the madhab that consider niqab mandatory dont force niqab or burqa.
@@ferozmohamed5 what brother. Do you know majority of Muslim scholars said that niqab is not obligatory, due to the reason that you want women to cover face doesn't make it obligatory
@@tisko7188 shabir is deviant. He is trying to please liberal Muslims with his wrong interpretation of hadith and quran...and this is not my claim but majority of Olama has refuted his views.
@@tisko7188 this is not obligatory problem...if it is obligated then whole of this ummah will be in danger...hear and hearafter ... niqab is a strong Sunnah of sahabiyas at last era of our beloved prophet times...if this Muslims neglect this Sunnah they still in our faith...but they're account will be with their Lord..
I have a woman friend who is a School Coordinator in Kabul, and she is very frustrated and vocal about the Taliban's broken promises to women God protect them all and lead them to a better way
I am not agreeing with the many things that the Taliban are doing forcefully but am really upset with Dr. Shabir especially him undermining the greatest scholars of Islam. Rasulullah said. "Verily, Allah does not take away knowledge by snatching it from the people but He takes away knowledge by taking away the scholars so that when He leaves no learned person, people turn to ignorant as their, leaders" (Sahih Muslim). Dr. Shabir may merely qualify to be a student of knowledge; he is nowhere near a scholar, and his words against the scholars in such a petty way are disgusting and shows his ignorance to some extent.
@@binabina7801 I am not judging. I am just expressing my thought with what I see in black and white. I'd rather say he is judging the whole scholarship of Islam, without him being a scholar. And if you don't like my expression, you should rather ignore my comment according to what advice you have given me.
@@freedomofspeech4512 I don't think KSA fines for not wearing the niqab, however, it is obviously recommended. In Iran, they do fine for not wearing the niqab.
"Men are the guardians of women by which Allah has given them some things over others..." "A nation will not succeed if it is ruled by a women" Be careful about taking knowledge from Shabir. What does Islam actually say? If a Muslim ruler takes the position that it is obligatory to cover the face then enforces it then all the people must obey it as it is a valid opinion within Sunni Islam. This new notion of westernisation or modernisation is kufr where they bring new ideologies into Islam. Whether the taliban execute everything correctly is perhaps another question but they are doing a lot better than the west at practicing Islam.
Afghanistan is war torn country like Ukrain even worse than that. so its ridiculous to judge them on these issues. as war torn countries have their own priorities like safety and security. girls schools are closed in ukrain and previously in whole world due to covid but media only concerned about Afghanistan schools closed due to war 😄🤦
I watch you from Bangladesh. I think there should be more schoolerly discussion like this one and more in broder way. So that, People can be educated and obey Allah's Deen with better understanding. I really thank Dr. Sabbir.
We are poor nowadays not because we don’t follow islam and Quran but because we don’t understand and our scholars don’t teach and explain the rule of Quran and the correct ways of Quran and prophet Mohammed S.W.T ..
The Afghan people have their own scholars , their own Mufti , their own Syura . They have their right to impose what ever law they implemented based on their scholars opinion. To say they are wrong when we never even step our foot on Afghan is not wise .We are giving the message that they are practising the wrong Islam . The whole entire Afghan is wrong and we are right ? We are opening another doors for the other beliefs to slam on the muslims.
@@olalerelukman9120 There would for sure be people whom support LGBTQ drugs and all sorts of great things.But as we see khurasan has been chosen to preserve what our prophet S.A.W gave us
@Muhammed Naif No, I didn't say that. Amr bilmaroof is a thing though. And it's amr bilmaroof which makes them to legislate certain rules.. so to answer your question.. Not "anything" but those things which are considered amr and they can force to stop certain things too which are munkr. That's also an order of Allah to establish Amr Bil Maroof and nahi anil munkr
May Allah guide Shabir Ally to Islam, cuz he ain't a muslim This guy accepts LGBT, denies hadd punishments of adultery, apostasy, blasphemy etc which is a nullifier of Islam
Alhamdulillah, I really appreciate how tempered Dr Shabir in his responses. He is such a wise person. It comforts me to hear a knowledgeable man like this share his understanding with us.
I felt so relieved as if my entire burden has been taken out, pure and pious articulation of quran. But my contention is who is going to make taliban understand this.
Many of the younger generation of taliban understand this … the problem is with the old ones, they’re very reluctant to change. They also have more power when it comes to affairs of the state.
@@allfamilychannel3922 many young ppl all around the world are brain washed and they didn't want to listen and hate ppl like Dr Shabbir Ally for being in the minority of interpretation of Qur'an as if they're well known more than him.
It is very confusing for people when Religion which is originated in Saudi Arabia is followed differently then in Afghanistan which makes things difficult for women and seems to be harsh in their day to day affairs. Perhaps society in Afghanistan is less educated or elements of culture is mixed up in religion. It also reminds of pre-Islamic culture with no police and no government.
Surah 33, Ayah 59 is clear and this is the Malay language interpretation : Wahai Nabi, suruhlah isteri-isterimu dan anak-anak perempuanmu serta perempuan-perempuan yang beriman, supaya melabuhkan pakaiannya bagi menutup seluruh tubuhnya (semasa mereka keluar); cara yang demikian lebih sesuai untuk mereka dikenal (sebagai perempuan yang baik-baik) maka dengan itu mereka tidak diganggu. Dan (ingatlah) Allah adalah Maha Pengampun, lagi Maha Mengasihani. A Muslimah has to be covered in hijab, so she is recognised as a good and law abiding woman, or a free woman.
I’m very saddened to hear that the Taliban are doing this. It’s what Americans who hate Islam want to see to be able to call Muslims barbaric and backwards evil people who destroy women. Allah help them all.
@@jubairomar2676 you can’t force people to do anything. If they are Muslims they know what Allah swt has commanded them and if they want to answer on the day of judgment for it then let them but, there is no compulsion in religion. Doesn’t the Quran tell you that there is no compulsion in religion?
Agree. We need updated comentarys of the Quran. Shabbir Ali and team. May Allah bless you all. What a blessing you are for our umma today. We need dialogues like you present in your channel. We are a generation that has questions. Its about time to dig deeper and go to the main source which is the Mushaf. Men has controlled woman for so long for their own benefit. We all are awake now…time is up…
Thank you for explaining. I have a question though. Doesn’t ‘recognise’ mean recognise (through their pious clothing) as a believer, as opposed to an infidel who less protection is afforded by the Quran? Thank you🙏
Yes, u are right, I don’t know why he explained recognized meaning face is uncovered( it means in tafseer that should be covered to be recognized as respected and decent women..may allah guide us all
@@R9oskarwell, where it says to cover the face? You can only recognise a person by seeing his/ her face. Not only that, there are other sahih hadiths which clearly says that you can show your face? Moreover in some cases covering face is haram. Like when a woman goes for hajj it's haram for her to cover her face... You can also see jakir naik's video om this topic to know the verses which clearly says, about this.
Love this father and daughter conversation...They both are well educated caring, knowledgeable open minded practicing Muslim...May Allah bless them and their family...
Wow I didn’t know she was his daughter the whole years thanks for mentioning!
So true! Shabir ally is just awesome, may allah bless him. I love watching all his videos - he makes good points and explains, doesn't make it up like zakir naik and co company. 😄
I didn't know they are related now i want to watch them more
Ignorant , nothing else . She has out on so much make up . Huh . May Allah give her hidayah and also this Shabbir aly. Taliban are true war heroes of Islam
@@handymanguide5198 same 😂😂
if you believe the niqab can be enforced, then i ask you a question.
by your logic we can enforce the 5 pillars of islam too right? bc they are much more important acts of worship than niqab. Why enforce niqab but not enforce salat,sawm,zakat,hajj?? By your logic i can drag my friend to the mosque and force him to pray i can kidnap people and send them to hajj we can starve people and make them fast and we can rob people for zakat. This is why Allah says that there is no compulsion in religion.
well said
This people have no knowledge about islamic economic,islamic foreign policy. they only know about hijab. they think only islam means islam
This country main problem is economic & poor. they should solve this problem first then other. but they just eye wash people name of religion. infact its not religious systerm
I am very confused that allah is really say to force religious rules on people?i need this answer. if someone is forced to be religious, he is not religious from his own heart. they are just forced to be religious that it has no value...authority should establish an Islamic economy based on interest free zakat in this country. so that the inequality between rich and poor of the country is eliminated through zakat in this country. because main problem is economic
Well said
I am not Muslim 100% Christian but I love this show. He is so knowledgeable and objective
I truly believe Dr. Shabir and Dr. Safiyyah are godsend examples of Muslims that are DESPERATELY needed in our times. Their knowledge of Islam demonstrates that they truly understand that the message of Islam is meant for all times and places. Alhamdulilah for you guys!❤
Foolish fake scholar. Pretends to know the interpretation more than Ibn Abbas (RadiAllahu Anh)
Alhamdulillah that Taliban doesn’t pay any heed to such fake scholars.
You are right
@@dave84111 Taliban is like kharjites one
@@dave84111 Ibn Abbas the idol worshipper.
The most important thing is that Taliban does not represent Islam .
They are true Muslims!
They are the tru Muslims
@@Hassan_Cornehno they are not true Muslims if they create their own version of Islam. Banning women from society cut their voices their ability to work and do business their freedom to educate themselves is a big sin because the first word of revelation is Iqra =read and education is command of Allah swt. Of you can this you are nothing but a Iblis
@@Hassan_Corneh in what aspect ?
@@Hassan_Cornehno they are not you sir or a radical salafi, get out of the dark ages
Muslims like Dr.shabir are very much required in society. Otherwise, there is always danger of Islam being treated as a stumbling block for human progression. This person speaks so sensibly we feel like listening to him.
He is indeed trying to bring reforms in the islamic society
The problem is that the Quran says that there should be no compulsion in religion. The Taliban is making their awful version of "Islam" compulsory, which is a violation of the Quran.
@ilamos ___ that doesn't make any sense
@ilamos___6853The Taliban have their own version of Islam and force it on people who don't follow it. They also force non believers.
They got fucked by the Americans so much so that they went into hiding. It's not winning if you come back after your enemy just leaves
!
A fair position articulated with such candor and empathy. Salute!
We happy when we heard that Taliban will apply Islamic laws, but if they are wrongly interpreted we have the right to oppose.
They were originally funded by the west in pakistan don't expect them to follow haq
Good point
@ilamos ___ go ... ur self , we have quran and hadith we don't need to follow scholar but to follow a genuine schar like shabeer .
@ilamos ___ do you live in afghanistan?
@@Habib7.no he/she very likely lives in some western country enjoying all the privileges of the western lifestyle but has a problem with Muslim countries trying to come to date with the 21st century. At least taliban stays in Afghanistan… this breed is beyond help.
I have never heard such a beautiful discussion. This truly makes sense. Quran came as the guidance of mankind. The Islam introduced by Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was the religion that was supposed to be relevant for eternities. For every era and culture. But the wrong explanations and ignorance of Muslims have lagged our community way behind. May Allah guide us all and bless us with the knowledge to understand Holy Quran. Also, May Allah blesses Dr. Shabir Ally and his family.
Abal re.
Amra Bangladeshi rai Murkho.
İslam kokhonoi narı der force Kore Naa .
Taliban narı der odhikar niye nicche .
Eta islam support Kore naa
I loved it. While I see many in here sympathetic to Dr Shabbir explanation, I see others who seem to be very unhappy regarding his explanation. Taliban???? We live in the 21st century. I am not saying we go full naked or corrupting. I am saying use reason and kindness, for Talibans are neither reasonable or kind. It is brutal.
Shabir is a lair and the taliban exercise islam as it is written. This is the true islam. Like the poor women who was killed and burnt in nigeria. Watch the videos of shabir on concubines. Utterly disgusting. Sham on you.
That is true
@@freedomofspeech4512 depends the interpretation and understanding when you really look at tesfir is kind of weird why God would like to women to walk outside with one eye covered like dajal
@@freedomofspeech4512 they went overboard in some
@@freedomofspeech4512 ok taliban
Dr. Shabbir is definitely one of the most respectful, knowledgeable and well-spoken Islamic Scholars I've come across
As an Afghan living in United States I salute Dr Shabir for his stance against Taliban’s ridiculous decisions. I have many girl relatives that are sitting at home and not attending high school because they are not permitted.
I'm sorry to hear that. Hoping they can learn online soon.
I am Afghan, and it amazes me that the world know so little about the crimes Taliban committed in the name of Islam during their first time ruling.
They would force people into prayer. Have watch groups during prayer going around town checking if anyone was on streets or in their shops not attending the mosque. If one was found outside mosque they would get beaten. They would also measure mens’ beard if it was long enough. Men without beard would get punished.
Women had to be seen with Mahram outside their home. There were some widows and people without Mahram had to come up with absurd ways having young daughters dress in boy’s clothes to accompany them.
Aside from that they could pick any young women and demand their family to grant her for marriage. People I know had to flee in middle of night as a whole family abandoning their home to save their daughter.
You are a voice of reason in an unreasonable world , Dr Shabbir . May Allah bless you and you r family
Strange all of these so called modern scholars are sitting in western world, supporting somehow there system of living by putting their efforts into the system....they can't even imagine implementing all social political and economic system of Islam unto themselves, I mean they can't dare to do this and....... that's ok.... the problem is that they are criticising those who were fighting for their basic human rights for the decades and never accept others rule of law over them and rather accept death......yet these king of so called modern scholars are enjoying their life in West...................why don't they leave these people to take their own decisions as we know they also have Scholars in themselves?
education is very important for Muslim men and women
What do you mean by Education ? Is it science and technology and accounting and cosmology and medicine. Or do you mean Liberal Secular values imposed by the Atheist worldview?
@@shahkhan4347 instead of condemning evil Talibans.. you twist ppl's word , smh
@@bangbang-nb7gi Well we're talking about education here ? You answer my question !
@@shahkhan4347 short answer: To acquire knowledge has been made compulsory by divine commandment. The purpose of education in Islam is to associate and balance physical and spiritual development of humankind. Islam deals with the universal education and education for practical life and moral values.
@@bangbang-nb7gi so does liberalism teach moral values ?
I just want to thank Dr. Shabir for updating his thoughts openly on Afghanistan, and being humble enough to be open to changing his opinion. Many people today think this is a sign of weakness and double down on their views or words out of insecurity. As an afghan, I witnessed many Muslims cheer on the taliban takeover out of ideological or even nationalistic sentiment. It was one the worst moments I've witnessed as a Muslim to see people glide past the historical atrocities these people committed. So, it was nice to hear someone challenge their reading of the quran. Thank you for covering this topic.
Same here, they killed many afghans and made many widows and orphans and instead of apologizing to them they praised the suicide bombers. It’s sick to see members of the ummah praising the very people who targeted us.
SEVERE ⚠️ It is the duty of every muslim to defend the Quran & Hadith
Every person Who defends those preachers who are contradicting the Quran & Hadith will gain as much SIN as those preachers.
@@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45 you need to understand the different opinions of scholars. No one is attacking quran and sunnah. But having different opinions make you feel like attacking
But didnt USA did worse?
I was against Taliban from day 1 of their takeover.
These people Taliban make Islam to be too difficult to follow.
No, they make it into something that is NOT Islam.
Nobody forces you to follow Islam, You end up the loser
Thank you Dr. Shabbir. More scholars need to speak out against the Taliban and the murder of Shariah by their hand.
Fake scholar talking to a woman caked in makeup
And we shall protect them as well. While most dogmas have evolved from the middle ages, some have decided to stay in eras out of reason. About a 115 years ago the last witch was executed in England, I believe it was right after WWI. The Vatican kept Galileo condemn for his scientific proof regarding the order and movement of celestial objects. 90 years ago some peasants in my country thought there was a giant woman cleaning corn that they could see naked eye from their farms. Those fundamentalists are to be feared. They do not see how ego has submitted their souls like many other extremist in history. I HOLD THE TRUTH. We only think of ego when referring to a price winner, a rich person or a spoiled person. Ego manifest in more invisible ways we hardly realize.
So true
Go and read the surat 33 verse 59
@@knowledgezone562 Read multiple times. It was superceded by the verse in surah noor as as it was revealed after surah 33. And surah noor only mentions covering essential body parts. Also there are various ahadith of the prophet pbuh that suggest exposing the face is allowed. Also there is no punishment mentioned for it anywhere in islamic literature.
I am from Afghanistan and I am agree with Dr. Shabir Ally. Unfortunately we usually follow our tradition this shouldn’t be mixed with what actually Islam is. I like when he distinguishes the verses of Quran vs the words of commentators, we should judge Tafsers based on the actual verses rather than actual verses based on Tafsers.
Not many scholars dare to speak against Taliban and their failed political approach . We need more videos to highlight their outrageous policies/regulations that has nothing to do with Islam. Series of such videos will ensure Muslim ummah does not misunderstand them to be the revivers Islam.May God reward you and give you strength to work the way you have been working.
Your ignorance has nothing to do with Islam either
@@VVH0AMI And, your blind faith on terrorists taliban got nothing to do with Islam. Go and educate yourself first.
@Antonia Lopez yep
@@FreakyAxeMan how did Taliban become terrorists? Are you even Muslim? All they did was defending country and Ummah. Their deen view may be extreme. But they are not the Terrorists. If you are a Muslim, you are becoming Munafiqh
Surah 4:95 Not equal are those believers remaining [at home] - other than the disabled - and the mujahideen, [who strive and fight] in the cause of Allah with their wealth and their lives. Allah has preferred the mujahideen (Talibans) through their wealth and their lives over those who remain [At Home], by degrees. And to both Allah has promised the best [reward]. But Allah has preferred the mujahideen (Talibans) over those who remain [At Home] with a great reward -......Allah preferred Islamic jihadist fighters than those who are staying at their comfortable homes.
Q for taliban, why women don't cover their face for umrah or Haj? .... if it's mandatory outside mecca.. it should be the same inside mecca.
It’s only unnecessary whilst in ihram
@@bilalitani803 whyits forbidden in ihram. Then why it's obligatory according to you while not in ihram
To mandate face covering to women are indeed a bidah. We muslim should just follow what Allah and our prophet has ruled.
Covering of face is considered mandatory in Hanafi Madhab, and Hambali (out of 4 mainstream madhabs)..
And within those madhabs, covering of face is mandatory even within ihram. The only difference is they cannot wear a cloth that sticks to the face skin, and hence those women who follow this have a special kind of hat or something to cover their faces...
@Ahmad Ganteng
It has been proven that covering of face was practiced by Sahabiyat (R.A) too. And have been mainstream of majority of Ulema. You saying it a bidah is uncomprrhendable..
What a brave and honest answer from our beloved dr Shabir. 💪🏻👏🏼💚💚🙌🏼💐
I just don’t get the logic of these people who enforce the niqab/burqa when the prophet pbuh LITERALLY said you can’t wear it during hajj and that normal women would cover everything but her face. Like hello???
Nice explanation some people try to make islam so hard and impractical,while god says in quran we made religion easy for you
Ok and?
What does this have to do with Niqab in other parts?? Him saying that you can't wear it in hajj/umrah implies that it is to be worn the rest of the times
Your criticism would be valid if the Taliban were the rulers of Hijaz and and enforced women to cover their faces in umrah
Dr Shabir is the best speaker ever. Love this channel
I clicked on this thinking it might be another “Talibs aren’t so bad” argument. Alhamdulillah I was wrong. Scholars shouldn’t get too caught in politics. But they must at least mention their disapproval of such extremist groups.
P.S. I’m one of those who had to flee. We knew they had not changed. Immense praise and commendation for Dr. Ally for acknowledging that he had formed an opinion too soon.
How can Muslims accept people who bombed and killed their fellow Muslims as saviors of their faith?
@ilamos ___ You are right. We did not believe their promises of amnesty and safety because we knew them to be liars. If we had believed that they were truthful, we would have stayed and tried to rebuild the country with them.
Alhamdulillah that you are safe and I hope you work with them for a better future.
The foreign forces and ANA had done far more atrocious activities in Afghania then the Talibs... sure they are not angels as well, but the fact is most probably u flew as an economic migrant or you prefer foreign culture far more than your own
@@tonystark-gx7tx No, as I have mentioned in my comment, I fled because I did not trust the Talibs not to harm me.
As a muslim i salute you for using your brain capacities to understand the words of god. Well said on 4:47. The Quran clearly states recognized, and the face is how a person is known and recognized. But unfourtenately people with low brain capacities alter that to suit their agenda or subjective tendencies and insecurities. But people like you or imam malik explain the Quran like it is.
It doesn't clearly state that. It might mean they will be known/recognized as Muslim women. If the verse was telling you to mark your cows and the cows will be recognized/known you would have probably concluded it is about the marking that gives recognition. If I said wear this veil, you will be recognized and not molested, the most probable interpretation is that I mean the veil will give you protection.
@@hyawill8944 The words used in here is (Yu'rafna) which means to know a person, this verb can only be used in knowing people it can't be used to identify or atleast it rarely does. If it was the way you said god would have used another word or added the word known as "Muslim women". I thank god for using Arabic for its vast vocabulary and it's ability be super exact, i'm guessing one of the reasons god used Arabic is to be so exact so people like you can't manipulate it.
It is clear as the sun. If you wanna manipulate god's words you will be held accountable in the day of judgement. Woe to those who misinterpret and manipulate the words of god when they're clear. There is no difference between corrupting the Quran via changing words and intrepreting it as you are doing, both lead to the same outcome. Quran has one message, and one interpretation, if god wanted it to be understood as you said he would have said so just as he did in other verses with obscurity, he wouldn't want to leave things unexplained which can cause division.
@@icev1378 Muhammad Sarwar "...This will make them distinguishable from others..."
Moshin Khan "...That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) ..."
Those are wrong?
55:41 "The criminals will be known by their marks..." - yuʿ'rafu l-muj'rimūna bisīmāhum
@@icev1378 If you are right then it means Arabic language is horseshit. If I can say "You will recognize him by green eyes", but I cannot say "He has green eyes. You will recognize him." using the same verb then it is a very unuseful language.
I will try to look up for it in dictionaries.
I think if Dr. Shabir would publish his own tafsir/translation of the Quran we all would benefit a great deal.
So true
I would definitely buy it
@@alyzak.8997bro buy meezan book of javed ahmed ghamdi
Excellently answered and explained.
Nope
@@jubairomar2676 Taliban's order are based on quran chapter 33 verse no. 53 and 59 .in verse 53 only for Prophet Muhammad SAW wives but in verse 59 to all Muslim women.
Not to forget, all the commentary was by men about women. It seems men have nothing better to do than talk and think about women.
i totally agree. especially muslim men.
@@binabina7801 Actually, if you look into history, men from the previous religions had already laid the foundations controlling women and Muslim men continued the tradition
I'm gonna assume you aren't Muslim.
@@yasminea7149I think it's in our DNA😂...
it's not exactly true and correct. Men are mostly into islamic knowledge. there are many women but still in limited in numbers. so some men may got wrong and using that in the name of God
Taliban is overdoing things.. If entire society will be so restricted.. What will be left of individual amals and deeds? They need to learn difference between individual and social rules/obligations..
i hope you put this on your other social media platforms to be able to share this side of the trueth to more people
Dr. Shabir is my favorite. I really enjoy listening to him. Nothing but love for both of you.💙❤️
Taliban would never change. There is a saying, "A leopard never changes its spots".
الحمد لله
I hope they stay like that and font become a reformist like Shabir who supports LGBT
@@zaid4128 why don’t u go and live under them?
There are not nearly enough muslim scholars, public speakers or youtubers speaking out against the taliban. Thank you dr shabir for at the very least acknowledging their wrong doings and apologizing for your previous assumptions
Amazing Dr Shabir!We need more voices like yours!
So true
Wearing niqab is a choice...not a force
Then why do you need to follow Islam? when you can enter jannah without following Islam? Because according to you it is a choice like committing zina is a choice but no one can force.
@@kodvavi150 By the way...your ignorant indeed....I really think you need guidance...I actually wear niqab...but it's my choice...as I feel its compulsory but it's not a sin to not wear it.Dont compare zina with niqab...that's ludicrous. Womens modesty is clearly to cover her whole body with a loose attire...only that which shows will be apparent...ie...face and hands & if she wishes she will cover her face..Its not wajib!!! (Face cover).Those extremists interpret it to their agendas...
Agreed... many wrong ideas being written over the centuries by these irresponsible people that confused the current generations. They wrote and teaches from their own interpretation.
That is what actually happened in our community.
Read quran 2:1-20
irresponsible?
As an Afghan the women in Afghanistan are perfectly fine with dress they are wearing, I can understand why you can’t say anything positive about it because you be face consequences
Dr. Shabir talks logic. Dr. Shabir look at the facts. Way to go! Keep up the good work!
Thank you Haji Shabir❤️
I have been left with a conflicting feelings after hearing the thoughts of Dr Shabbir as very recently I have listened to a talk by Assim Alhakeen where the messages were almost the opposite of what Dr S Ally stated on the matter of covering and traveling alone for a woman - I am a bit confused as I respect both individual and still have great respect for both but the term “liberal Muslim” doesn’t sit well with - US went to Liberate Afghanistan and tried for 20yrs there is a new government formed so it will take a bit to adjust on the other hand India wants to ban hijab completely and many countries already have done so, Saudi Arabia allowing concert to take place I am just very concerned with if I am actually practicing Islam correctly because in the day of information overload It is very difficult to differentiate between truth and lies- I ask Allah to guide me and rest of the my muslim brothers and sisters- Ameen
Just Go ahead with what the Majority of the Muftis say. The prophet saw said My Ummah will not make consensus on The wrong path.
You're confused because you think there's one right answer.... If it's not in the Quran it's up for you to decide... Difference of opinion comes from the tribes and nations Allah made which is kinda the point. Islam was never about making one cohesive culture. It was about individual cultural expression in the name of Allah.
Shabir Ali is waffling. Ignore him
Regarding your take on India banning Hijab , you ARE FACTUALLY WRONG!
Infact I see a sea of Hijab everywhere I stay and travel in India!
The Hijab controversy was of a government run school where there was mandatory school uniform for the students , which a board would implement and the parents would have agreed while admitting their children to that school!
India is not Saudi Arabia where even non Muslim women are made to wear the attire of Muslim women!
India is a constitutionally bound democratic country and not a theocracy or a goddam Kingdom !
I'm looking out of the window as I type this comment and see ladies in Burqa, head and face covered too !
Remember, such fear mongering hype and misgivings will do more harm than good!
@Alexandra Henderson in certain issues there's not one valid opinions. There's a genuine difference of opinion, but not amongst people but amongst the scholars. Bc u can't interpret the quran based on ur own opinions. The interpretation comes from the prophet and the sahaba and the 3 rightly guided generations. Its like saying the quran doesn't really say pray 5 times a day. It only mentions the morning goes and evening so I'm going to pray only that.
Islam means to submit to the will of Allah. Islam is all about making a good cohesive society and culture, all confirming to the commands of Allah and his messenger.
How important it is to have a sound explanation, which sees things in a different light.
May Allah bless you and thank you so much for being so direct ❤️
I am from Afghanistan and I saw the Taliban very closely
The majority time they do so much which makes no sense to the Muslims but unfortunately the Muslims countries are so quiet and do nothing.
Now because the Muslims countries I mean their government do nothing it is the people job to rise their voices and condemn the Taliban actions.
May Allah bless you all
Cry about it
You're the same reformist who denied punishments of Blasphemy, adultery, and Apostasy
did he actuallt say that?
They should just say everyone should cover their faces because of covid.
good idea
I am very confused that allah is really say to force religious rules on people?i need this answer. if someone is forced to be religious, he is not religious from his own heart. they are just forced to be religious that it has no value...talib authority should establish an Islamic economy based on interest free zakat in this country. so that the inequality between rich and poor of the country is eliminated through zakat in this country
@@NRFP i don’t know from where taliban getting this rules!
I will say some foolish Rules!!
COVID just for women or also for men???
I am an Afghan and I strongly believe these instructions are coming from a neighboring country’s intelligence and not from the Quran. Even some of senior Taliban members clearly said that they don’t know from where these instructions are coming.
What the hell are you talking about as for chadaor/burka
its part of islam and pashtun traditon even before taliban
@@omarshinwari7823 burka is not an Afghan tradition and there is difference between chadaor and burka. Tell me where in the Quran it says that girls shouldn’t go to school. I am sure you don’t have an answer but to say this is coming from a neighboring country’s intelligence. General Mobeen a prominent and senior Taliban member clearly said that he wants to send her daughter to school but he doesn’t know from where these instructions were coming to stop girls education.
@@hayatullahrahmatzai9839 Quit whining
Also quran doesnt mention anything about school. Hadith mention about gaining knowldge
but that does not mean western idea of schools which promote haaram
also Burka is Pashtun culture aka southern afghans and always has been. You can see it in the old paintings
@@omarshinwari7823 I’m sure you won’t be able to prove the prevention of Girls’ education from the Quran. Show me a single authentic prophet saying which indicates that girls are not allowed to go to school or gain knowledge. Tell me the source of these instructions?
@@hayatullahrahmatzai9839 Ghalasha Rahmatazay
Lots of love for Dr. Shabir and his daughter. One of the best scholar to explain things in a better way.♥️♥️♥️
You are so brave and full of knowledge. Thank you.
People taking Islamic opinions of a woman covered in make up in public and posting it online for the world to see and also shaping her eyebrows.
Modern day Muslims 🤦🏽♂️
Its obvious how this man feel's by the who's he having this conversation with..his daughter. A real father wants for his children be they male or female. Im a Christian but i do enjoy listening to the good Doctor.
May Allah guide us to be sincere in our approach to his religion
May Allah guide Shabir Ally to Islam, cuz he ain't a muslim
This guy accepts LGBT, denies hadd punishments of adultery, apostasy, blasphemy etc which is a nullifier of Islam
@@zaid4128It’s funny when a nobody comes and claims that a Muslim who is learned in the field of Islamic studies is not a Muslim. Where are your credentials in Islam?
Thanks for speaking out against these stupid extremists. I can’t see why any educated right minded Muslim would support them. Hopefully more Muslim scholars speak out against them.
Because it does fit into their personal, limited world where woman need to be more like slaves of the men while men are god alike, I guess.
@@noahspengler1232 what... The... Hell.... Are you... Talking about 🙄
Having women wear niqab is not extreme. In fact in all 4 schools, some say its not obligatory but highly recommended and others say it is. The wives of the prophets wore it too.
But bc the western masters have said niqab is oppressive. Its oppressive now.
@@HassanAli-rb5hq not every women finds its opressive.. But some parents forced daughters to do so
@@mohdshamil5652 that is something that is very rare. The vast majority wear it because they want to please their rab.
And its not oppressive. Both men and women have dress codes and this is part of the dress code of women
Can anyone show me atleast one Hadith where Prophet SAW clearly stated that women must cover their face..
It was narrated in al-Saheehayn that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allaah be pleased with her) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to pray Fajr and the believing women would attend the prayer with him, wrapped in their veils, then they would go back to their homes and no one would recognize them because of the darkness.
It was narrated that ‘Aa’ishah said: The riders used to pass by us when we were with the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) in ihraam. When they came near us we would lower our jilbaabs from our heads over our faces, and when they had passed by we would uncover our faces. Narrated by Abu Dawood, 1562.
It's because of these hadiths from aisha ra and other sahaba that some if the schools of thought say it is compulsory whilst others say it is highly recommended to cover ur face.
U see in islam, the religion is taken from the quran, the sunnah, and the 3 rightly guided generations bc the prophet said(I'm paraphrasing)the best generations will be his generation, and the two generations after them.
These generations include the prophet, sahabah, his wives, thier children, converts, scholars like imam malik, Abu hanifa, Ahmed ibn hanbal, imam shafi and etc
@@HassanAli-rb5hq in prayer a women keep her face open..if it is compulsory in case of awrah then how it is permitted in prayer to keep face open?
@@doctorsfaithcorner4917 bc it is the sunnah to not cover the face during prayer.
Like in jummah when the khutbah starts its is forbidden to even respond to the Salam even tho on other times it is obligatory to respond
@@Sheeeshsheeehs it kind of is tho, and did u get that off dr ally
@@Sheeeshsheeehs no its not its mandated by the great scholars of this religion and highly recommend by the others. Imam malik, shafi, Ahmed, Abu hanifa.
Aisha and ibn abbaas and ibn masood ra narrated about the face covering. These r random people but the wife of the prophet and his companions- and they have authority in fiqh and etc
But like I said there's a difference of opinion. Some hold the view that it's not obligatory and some say it is.
Really amazing. God bless you dear, Dr and your lovely daughter. We need many more like you. Thank you.
As a result of wearing face masks due to covid, I'm beginning to understand the wisdom of face covering; it really hides your actual look. Makes one less attractive.
Especially when the woman is wearing a lip gloss or lipstick.
Even without it, she looks less attractive in a face mask and same for niqaab.
I'm one who never wore niqab, and who never agreed with those who said woman must wear niqab, my view has now changed post-covid..... I'm now inclined to the ruling that young women should wear niqab, what more if she has adorned herself (with lipstick or gloss)
I ask Allah to guide me in my understanding and all believing people.
Masha Allah!
The discussion is not about whether you can choose to wear niqab. Of course you can. It's about what the Islamic Government should do for those who choose not to wear it.
Hi Dr Shabir
I pray all people could listen carefully to your teachings on Islam.There has been been too much confusion in the way islam is being interpreted.You made it clear and i thank you for that.We are all brothers and sisters
Well said sir. People are hungry, and they force women to cover their faces.
Really enjoy this conversation...islam is such a balanced deen
It’s just a matter of different interpretations!
In that region that’s the common understanding of religion!
They are very brutal and unjust. It's a universal problem with humans. The ones in power and their friends always get special treatment and privileges. And they do a lot of torture if anyone messes with them.
You mean they fought unjust aka USA for 20 years . the same empire which killed millions of muslims
Sad to see you support the oppressing side against the opressed. does no one here akcnoledge here taliban fought 20 hard years for their own country againsy a terrorist governemtn aka usa
Thank you Dr. Shabir for such a sound, clear and rational discussion. We need more scholars of Islam to speak the truth and be open to challenging the Taliban and extremist and narrow interpretations of Islam.
According to The Holy Quran, face covering isn’t mandatory rule or prohibition. It depends on place,time & person.
Right
In hanafi Madhab it isn't obligatory but is wajib in times of fitnah
So there isn't anything wrong with enforcing it
@@zaid4128 The Holy Quran is universal for all. There is no racism & classification. Everyone supposed to obey the believe every verse of it.
@@mechanicholmes7918 I agree
But how's this relevant to the discussion of niqab?
@@zaid4128 🥰🥰👌
Thanks to Shabbir and Safiyya for talking about this
The hearsay regarding the prophet - peace be upon him, continues to corrupt Islam to the whims, desires, and corruption of man. We need to move back toward the Qur'an as the source of truth. The Qur'an instructs women to cover their bosoms, which to one who is able to think critically, simply means to have modesty. Anything outside of women (and men) having general modesty is simply cultural (not of Islam) or additive to the Qur'an (in order to oppress women).
May Allah protect and bless Dr. Ally for speaking the truth.
The mother of the believers Aisha r.a. narrated that hijab was to be worn.
Asma bint abi Bakr also said that the their faces would be covered in front of men.
Muslims follow the Quran, as well as the Sunnah, and according to the sunnah, hijab in its modern sense is required. This is unanimously accepted among Muslim scholars. We don’t do things according to our desires, we do them according to Islam.
Dr shabir is knowledgeable person and speak clearly about goals of islam
Thanks!
Thank you for your support! We appreciate it!
Dr shabir is the guy who said secularism is best option and there is no rajam and cutting hand of theif in islam so becareful guys
Dr shabir is too moderate and taliban is too extreme. There are many scholars who agreed on covering the face.
Muslims follow the rulings of Islam, if it is the case according to many, that covering the face is the correct Islamic ruling, then Muslims follow that.
It’s not about what scholars want, it’s about what God wants.
THANK YOU SIR🤲
One minute (2:42) shabir rejects hadith, then the next minute (7:00) he uses an unidentified "hadith" to try to say women can travel if it's safe.
The question i would ask is, does allah want muslim women to be travelling and not home raising more muslim children? It just doesn't really make sense to me.
I appreciate the father daughter duo for really addressing the pressing problems of the Muslim ummah all over the world. May Allah reward both of you for the good work done to enlighten the community. I’m from Sri Lanka.
@Student Of Knowledge it's a one sided opinion and doesn't represent the opinion of the entire umma.
@@quotablequotes1 we aren't here to gather opinions but the actual interpretations without being brainwashed.
the taliban are the government. and have the right to impose the dress code. even if it is not in islam. they have the right to impose it. why didnt you oppned your mouth when the west were imposing masks?!
I think we shouldn't comment on a independent nation. Why bother them because their laws are for their own people.
Come on. You people live in Canada and why don't you question your govt on so many things they impose on your people.?
We are just poking our nose when we didnt bother at all for more than 20 years when America was there. Now you bother. This is not honesty.
I'm not a Taliban supporter but I remain honest.
True. Im of the shinwari pashtun/afghan tribe
and burka has existed before taliban, formed by my people even existed
you could say were conservative. As in men do not talk or look at women unless there from the same family. Aslo burka has been a part of traditon for ages. you can see old painting of our people and they were the same custom burka they do today
Dr Shabir, he gone check you
Actually we should see the west and then reject Hadiths And Ayats which does not comply and thus westernising Islam and make a place for yourself in west..
It is the methodology of understanding islam should be.. Isn't it?
How can we recognize them if they cover their eyes? Doesn't the Quran say that we should be able to recognize them?
@@romakhajiev9535 recog ize who?
A state can inforce fard things not sunnah.
Like laws for nemaz, zakah, hijab.
You can force BURQA let alone niqab.
Even scholars of the madhab that consider niqab mandatory dont force niqab or burqa.
Very good explanation, very apt to meaning of Quran. Masha Allah. ❤️
Afghanistan is basically a big boarding school.
Mr shabir is like sharukh khan, he has his own interpretation of hadiths and quran.
Yes brother exactly 💯
@@ferozmohamed5 what brother. Do you know majority of Muslim scholars said that niqab is not obligatory, due to the reason that you want women to cover face doesn't make it obligatory
@@tisko7188 dude, even sheikh nasir uddin albani, scholar with salafi tilt said niqab is not mandatory, hijab is.
@@tisko7188 shabir is deviant. He is trying to please liberal Muslims with his wrong interpretation of hadith and quran...and this is not my claim but majority of Olama has refuted his views.
@@tisko7188 this is not obligatory problem...if it is obligated then whole of this ummah will be in danger...hear and hearafter ... niqab is a strong Sunnah of sahabiyas at last era of our beloved prophet times...if this Muslims neglect this Sunnah they still in our faith...but they're account will be with their Lord..
I have a woman friend who is a School Coordinator in Kabul, and she is very frustrated and vocal about the Taliban's broken promises to women God protect them all and lead them to a better way
Lmao only kabul womem cry about it whears rest of afghanistan are fine it.
I am not agreeing with the many things that the Taliban are doing forcefully but am really upset with Dr. Shabir especially him undermining the greatest scholars of Islam. Rasulullah said. "Verily, Allah does not take away knowledge by snatching it from the people but He takes away knowledge by taking away the scholars so that when He leaves no learned person, people turn to ignorant as their, leaders" (Sahih Muslim). Dr. Shabir may merely qualify to be a student of knowledge; he is nowhere near a scholar, and his words against the scholars in such a petty way are disgusting and shows his ignorance to some extent.
who are you to judge? The beautiful thing about islam is that it always says to think for yourself!
@@binabina7801 I am not judging. I am just expressing my thought with what I see in black and white. I'd rather say he is judging the whole scholarship of Islam, without him being a scholar. And if you don't like my expression, you should rather ignore my comment according to what advice you have given me.
@@freedomofspeech4512 I don't think KSA fines for not wearing the niqab, however, it is obviously recommended. In Iran, they do fine for not wearing the niqab.
Both are very loving persons.
They share lots and lots of love and respect for their listeners. We all have lot to learn from them.
Thank you
"Men are the guardians of women by which Allah has given them some things over others..." "A nation will not succeed if it is ruled by a women" Be careful about taking knowledge from Shabir. What does Islam actually say? If a Muslim ruler takes the position that it is obligatory to cover the face then enforces it then all the people must obey it as it is a valid opinion within Sunni Islam. This new notion of westernisation or modernisation is kufr where they bring new ideologies into Islam. Whether the taliban execute everything correctly is perhaps another question but they are doing a lot better than the west at practicing Islam.
True, this man rejected stone to death punishment for adultery, accepted LGBTQ, etc and he lecturing the Taliban
Bravo well said brother
ماشاء الله عليك
If everyone followed the Taliban form of Islam, you will see evilz
@@mikeylejan8849 why?
@@Masters_Revolutionjust look at how they are running it
Afghanistan is war torn country like Ukrain even worse than that. so its ridiculous to judge them on these issues. as war torn countries have their own priorities like safety and security. girls schools are closed in ukrain and previously in whole world due to covid but media only concerned about Afghanistan schools closed due to war 😄🤦
I watch you from Bangladesh.
I think there should be more schoolerly discussion like this one and more in broder way. So that, People can be educated and obey Allah's Deen with better understanding.
I really thank Dr. Sabbir.
Bangladesh waz huzur ey answer Dita gela.......comedy show shur Hoya Jaba 😂
Don't listen to Dr shabir. He is distorting what the religion says, and is diluting it with Liberalism and feminism
সৌন্দর্য প্রদর্শন করতে নিষেধ করেছে, মুখ খোলা থাকলে কি উদ্দেশ্য পুরো হয়?
But İslam never force these .
+ Covering face is not compulsory
Islam gave everyone equal rights but Taliban didn't
We are poor nowadays not because we don’t follow islam and Quran but because we don’t understand and our scholars don’t teach and explain the rule of Quran and the correct ways of Quran and prophet Mohammed S.W.T ..
The Afghan people have their own scholars , their own Mufti , their own Syura . They have their right to impose what ever law they implemented based on their scholars opinion. To say they are wrong when we never even step our foot on Afghan is not wise .We are giving the message that they are practising the wrong Islam . The whole entire Afghan is wrong and we are right ? We are opening another doors for the other beliefs to slam on the muslims.
Why did you thé whole afghan,as if thé entire populace are in support of thé Law .?
@@olalerelukman9120 There would for sure be people whom support LGBTQ drugs and all sorts of great things.But as we see khurasan has been chosen to preserve what our prophet S.A.W gave us
The Taliban are evil no progress has been made by them, they are uneducated fools
If there were a Muslim Pope, Shabir Ally would certainly be someone to seriously consider: wisdom, compassion, and knowledge in abundance.
Says their judgment is based on commentary not the verse itself and then passes his own judgement based on his own commentary.
He actually quotes Quran though... They don't. And he's also not forcing women or men to do anything with his commentary
@Alexandra Henderson
Because he isn't in power or government 🥲.. What you said doesn't relate at all lol
@@FaizanKhan-um6bn so for you by having power, can force anything on peopel
@Muhammed Naif
No, I didn't say that. Amr bilmaroof is a thing though. And it's amr bilmaroof which makes them to legislate certain rules..
so to answer your question.. Not "anything" but those things which are considered amr and they can force to stop certain things too which are munkr. That's also an order of Allah to establish Amr Bil Maroof and nahi anil munkr
May Allah guide Shabir Ally to Islam, cuz he ain't a muslim
This guy accepts LGBT, denies hadd punishments of adultery, apostasy, blasphemy etc which is a nullifier of Islam
Alhamdulillah, I really appreciate how tempered Dr Shabir in his responses. He is such a wise person. It comforts me to hear a knowledgeable man like this share his understanding with us.
Shabir doesn't have a sound knowledge to counter the Taliban's authentic Islamic guidelines as he does to Christian preachers' heresy!
He has.
Chill !!! it's not like they 're forcely stripping & killing them like westerners !
I felt so relieved as if my entire burden has been taken out, pure and pious articulation of quran. But my contention is who is going to make taliban understand this.
Many of the younger generation of taliban understand this … the problem is with the old ones, they’re very reluctant to change. They also have more power when it comes to affairs of the state.
@@allfamilychannel3922 many young ppl all around the world are brain washed and they didn't want to listen and hate ppl like Dr Shabbir Ally for being in the minority of interpretation of Qur'an as if they're well known more than him.
It is very confusing for people when Religion which is originated in Saudi Arabia is followed differently then in Afghanistan which makes things difficult for women and seems to be harsh in their day to day affairs. Perhaps society in Afghanistan is less educated or elements of culture is mixed up in religion. It also reminds of pre-Islamic culture with no police and no government.
Sir, you are the voice of logic and you both are the best 🙏
Surah 33, Ayah 59 is clear and this is the Malay language interpretation : Wahai Nabi, suruhlah isteri-isterimu dan anak-anak perempuanmu serta perempuan-perempuan yang beriman, supaya melabuhkan pakaiannya bagi menutup seluruh tubuhnya (semasa mereka keluar); cara yang demikian lebih sesuai untuk mereka dikenal (sebagai perempuan yang baik-baik) maka dengan itu mereka tidak diganggu. Dan (ingatlah) Allah adalah Maha Pengampun, lagi Maha Mengasihani.
A Muslimah has to be covered in hijab, so she is recognised as a good and law abiding woman, or a free woman.
I’m very saddened to hear that the Taliban are doing this. It’s what Americans who hate Islam want to see to be able to call Muslims barbaric and backwards evil people who destroy women. Allah help them all.
Taliban are right. This guy isn't. He's just waffling cluelessly
You are sad because american got what they wanted and not because of the state of afghan women says a lot about you
@@jubairomar2676 you’re wrong. Allah swt does not like extremists
@@jubairomar2676 you can’t force people to do anything. If they are Muslims they know what Allah swt has commanded them and if they want to answer on the day of judgment for it then let them but, there is no compulsion in religion. Doesn’t the Quran tell you that there is no compulsion in religion?
@@fredericktaylor1693 where did you get your Islamic education from if I might ask?
Agree. We need updated comentarys of the Quran. Shabbir Ali and team. May Allah bless you all. What a blessing you are for our umma today. We need dialogues like you present in your channel. We are a generation that has questions. Its about time to dig deeper and go to the main source which is the Mushaf.
Men has controlled woman for so long for their own benefit. We all are awake now…time is up…
Thank you for explaining. I have a question though. Doesn’t ‘recognise’ mean recognise (through their pious clothing) as a believer, as opposed to an infidel who less protection is afforded by the Quran?
Thank you🙏
Yes, u are right, I don’t know why he explained recognized meaning face is uncovered( it means in tafseer that should be covered to be recognized as respected and decent women..may allah guide us all
@@R9oskarwell, where it says to cover the face? You can only recognise a person by seeing his/ her face. Not only that, there are other sahih hadiths which clearly says that you can show your face? Moreover in some cases covering face is haram. Like when a woman goes for hajj it's haram for her to cover her face... You can also see jakir naik's video om this topic to know the verses which clearly says, about this.