Just some input from somebody who has been a rocker since rock began. technical, shredding, etc doesn't equate to good. Rock started off as basic as it gets in the 50's. Slowly evolved into all the current subgenres. I like some doo wop from back then as much as i like anything since. My top half dozen rock bands today are all female. The warning is one of the top 2. For me, #1 i gotta "feel" them. #2 gotta be able to play live. #3 gotta have good lyrics #4 gotta have decent songwriting skills. Been listening to dudes all my life, glad i'm still here to enjoy this wave of rocker chicks. I've always listened to many different genres of music from all over the world. Gives u an appreciation & recognition of the simplest to the most complex music. After all, it started with someone beating on a log or rock with a stick. About as basic as it gets but we wouldn't be listening to what we have today without it. Flashy sweep pickers got nothin on Django or Sergovia, etc. A spectacle onstage is entertaining but doesn't necessarly make it great music and usually it's a femine voice that sings the baby to sleep
Thanks, Charlie, for reacting to The Warning. The Villarreal Sisters make a kind of "classic" rock not too complicated, but excellently done and attractive. That's why they've built a huge following of loyal fans from all over the world, The Warning Army, who will give you lots of information about the band in the comments.
You would have told him that if he wanted to see how complicated and badass they are, you should suggest the Metallica - Atlas Rise by The Warning video.
As good as this is, Disciple from the same concert is better and heavier. These girls don’t struggle at all with heavy songs. Animosity is one of their lighter songs. Pau, the drummer, is incredible and in other songs can sing and drum at the same time. You can’t make an opinion on one song - they have 47 original songs in three albums and an EP and two singles. They are from Monterrey, MX. The Warning will be touring in your neighbothood starting this Saturday in Plymouth. They open four Muse shows over the next five weeks. They will also be doing shows in Spain, France, Germany, Switzerland, Czechia, and Poland.
So agree Dave, All their recent stuff is incredible, but The Teartro live version of Disciple is at present their pinnacle. Perfect rock! And Pau...Oh Pau..
Man your right on the money about your reaction! You can have the most technical musicians but if they can't write a good song or have stage presence it's boring,,but I have yet to see that with these sisters! They can hold their own with any band!!! You have to check more of their songs out! They only get better! You have been Warned!🤘🤘🤘
The drummer, named Pau, pronounced like Pow - I know. It's a great name for a drummer, right? - short for Paulina, wrote the lyrics for this song. It was prompted by a friend who pissed her off. The moral of the story, don't piss off Pau or she'll write a song about you. LOL They have a dark concept album called Queen of the Murder Scene (their second album). The album tells the story of a girl who loves a guy who doesn't even acknowledge that she exists. Her love turns to obsession as she stalks him and finally murders him. Then the story follows her descent into madness and self-destruction. A great album that was written by these three young ladies when they were in their teens. They have a total of three albums and two EPs. Even though their ages range from Dany (Daniela, the guitarist) at 23, to Pau at 21, and Ale (Alejandra, the bassist) at 18. they have been performing as a band for over ten years. They just completed an 18-city headliner tour of the US with the support of Plush and Holy Wars, and will be joining Muse in the UK this Saturday and will open for them in five shows before turning their attention to several European festivals and some Headliner shows. You might want to check out some of their recent performances from the 18-City tour for a sample of what they sound like live. I suggest searching for their most recent song, MORE, officially released on May 12th and currently charting in the US. And as others in the comments have directed, any of the shows from the Teatro Metropolitan concert in Mexico City last August will give you an excellent, professionally shot, and recorded example of what it is like to see them live. Don't let their petite statures fool you. As Lzzy Hale of Halestorm described them while The Warning was opening for many of Halestorm's shows last Summer and Fall, "They are fierce...They attack the audience."
Many of the things you say are opinion-based and you are of course entitled to your opinion. And of course you can't have a complete understanding of what they do after one song. That's totally fine. On one thing you are just simply wrong though. I would have thought the days of people being like "okay, they're pretty good ... well ... for being women..." are far behind us. Looks like some people haven't gotten the message though.
"Palatable Rock"? I think Dany is holding more than her own. As far as women not being quite as loud to make themselves heard I think the now late great Tina Turner didn't have an issue making herself be heard, RIP.
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel was going to subscribe but came across this comment. I do believe this is the best band in 30 years so that makes me a moron too, but not enough of a moron to subscribe to your channel ✌ TW❤🤘
Enjoyed your reaction!! I think the real key to _The Warning_ and what first attracted me to them... is their *lyrics* . Every tune is a story, and every aspect of their music is geared towards telling the story - in whatever genera the storyline fits. They wander all over the place, musically. Which is tremendous fun in and of itself, especially because they do it so skillfully. Every song is a *composition* , carefully designed and constructed to tell the tale. I look forward to their future albums, but the three they've already released are each in their own way absolutely epic. And as far as destroying instruments goes.. well, they just sold a kick drum skin Pau demolished several months ago, for 150 dollars. It absolutely wasn't intentional, but she keeps a "quiver" of spare drumsticks by her side for a *reason*... 😋 You have not heard the last of this band; not by a long shot.
Thank you for you calm and measured comment. It's been a breath of fresh air haha. I agree, lyrically this song is very good. Unfortunately, I don't usually pick up the lyrics very well on my first time hearing something. I'm working at it but I'm much more drawn to how it sounds musically
Great to see you reacting to The Warning. Regarding your comment about female singers in rock/metal, I am not sure, but seems like you need to discover European rock/metal bands, as most of the best ones have female singers and they are some of the greatest vocalists you will ever hear, especially Floor Jansen of Nightwish, who in my opinion is the greatest current female singer on the planet, but there are others in bands like Epica, The Gathering, Vuur, etc. and there is also my second favorite singer Brittney Slayes of Unleash The Archers.
Bold statements from one video, this is rock and roll period, your right it’s basic rock, but that makes the best rock and roll and as you stated all that hypo stuff is just that hype… and I think that’s a poor statement as well about women singers, I’m 62 yrs old and I would put Dany of the Warning as well as Ann Wilson, Pat Benatar, Joan Jett, Debbie Harry, to name a few, up there against any male singer, l like the techno rock too but that’s just a flavor of rock, give me the meat and potatoes of basic rock! Music you can sing, clap, and just have a good time with, A Warning and Rock & Roll Fan Forever…
Oh man, power is what these ladies are made of. Seriously, Dany the singer guitarist, is a hurricane, and Pau the drummer is a dynamite truck. Ale on bass has the gravity of a small planet to hold them together. I think you’re making a big mistake when you keep repeating the words easy, simple, basic, etc. You seem to be presuming a lot about what the “Audience is there for.” This song may not be the best to display the complexity you are looking for, or maybe because they are female you didn’t look too hard. Seems you already made your mind up about that.
The Warning write lyrics expressing their views of today's world and deliver the story with their own unique style of rock. I find their sound infectious and love the diversity in their sound. I don't care for bands whose songs sound very similar.
It’s sad that some of the fans don’t listen to what you say and make their own interpretations of it! I’m 71 years old from the UK and have been following them from when I saw a 6 year old Paulina playing the drums and singing, it was amazing to me! It’s been a joy watching them grow into what they are now, a great band that is going to be big. Their songwriting is what makes them special to me, it’s so meaningful and relatable to. It’s not fair to expect you to make a full judgement of their abilities from one song which to me is not really representative of them. The problem is that there are no two songs alike, they are stylistically similar but different in terms of composition and content. You were fair and I’ve liked your reaction, looking forward to more!
Thank you Darrell. I'm glad you get it. Unfortunately this happens with a lot of artist that I react to that, for whatever reason, have slightly fanatical fans. They take anything that isn't shining praise as not only a criticism but, seemingly, a personal attack. It's very strange. Thank you for getting it 👍🏼
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel You really should check them out live. They'll be at the O2 Academy in London, and tickets are still on sale. They're the first Latin American band to sign with a major US label, and this European tour places them on the launching pad for a stellar career. They're likely headed towards global domination! 🔥 🎸 🤘
One of the biggest "tells" any reactor can give is saying a song isn't "technical" or complex. Guess what? 98% of rock songs aren't. Some of the greatest rock bands in history don't have a single moment that meets this "standard" that only appears when a reactor is covering a bias (that they are often unaware of). The Warning are superlative musicians, both technically and in musicianship. The roll Pau does, that you ridiculously reduced to a straight rhythm, is a perfectly controlled build filled with accents and variation in texture. It is HIGHLY technical. Dany strums a very complex and active chord pattern in the prechorus whilst singing lead, a degree of skill you'd be hard pressed to find in most bands. The Warning are so good they make is seem easy. The through line of their song is always clear to the listener, so on the surface it sounds 'simple', but if you have a good ear, you can hear how active every instrument is, how they trade off parts and fill the sonic space far bigger than most 3-piece can. Good musicians make complexity sound natural, even easy. Good composers make original music sound familiar.
I'm sorry but I'm a producer and I play 5 instruments. I am not ignorant to anything you mentioned. This is not complex musically at all. I'm sorry it just isn't
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel so, can we get a sample of your music? Since The Warning’s music is so simple, and performed by 3 weak women… can we hear your highly complex and Successful music? It must be something amazing if you label TW as tolerable and simple😊
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel may I suggest a bit more humility? Many of us TW fans are actual musicians as well, and we don’t pretend to know more than TW, or how to fix their sound. And yes, some of us are actually retired after 50 yrs, and some of us performed 14 different instruments… so, your qualifications don’t impress us. Just tell us how it makes you feel. We already know enough about music; you’re not educating us, and you’re certainly not qualified to educate The Warning.
@@macgherhardt1061 Jesus! You're a sensitive soul aren't you. I never called them tolerable or weak. I'm afraid you're blinded by your hurt butt. If you don't like what I said then move on. You can't go around bullying people into having a different opinion of something you like. What in the dictatorial shit is that?
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel your true colors come out then? Being caustic and insulting to people who WATCH your reactions; bragging about your qualifications; awkward language regarding women in music, and judging musicians (TW) who are leagues superior to you… I reiterate… try more humility; and stop insulting your viewers.
You have riled up the Warning Army and yes we are an Army that will protect The Warning Ladies. We The Army have watched these Ladies Grow up before our eyes from age 6 and up. We could fill Volumes with their accolades. These girls are superstars and will be remembered as such always.
@@larrybutler8948 well, people are entitled to have an opinion. And, the dude wasn't insulting the Warning, he just had a stereotypical view of Rock as a Non--Rock fan. So, I'll be needing that 11th explanation, if you don't mind. 😉
@@FullTexanEffect As I only expressed my opinion also. He did say thing that riled up the Army just read comments below etc. You seem to think thgat I came down on him hard. I merely stated he had riled up the Army. Do you need a 12th?
Hi,, greeding from german.. I saw last year US Band here in a small Club.. Try :"War on women - pleasure and the beast".. /some german stuff.. :"Jennifer Rostock - Kaleidoskop.. /.. Tauben aus Porzellan,,".. (Enjoy
gran reacción! 🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Tu punto de vista coincide con lo dicho por las hermanas, le apuestan más a la solidez y armonía de los instrumentos en una canción más que incorporar solos de guitarra "sin sentido". 🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Viva The Warning!!!
Get ready in the U.K. cuz their touring with Muse very soon. As others have said the best power trio in the world all things considered. They have already been doing shows for 10 years and the oldest is 23. Incredible.
They are far more capable, and put far more effort into every last detail of their songs, than you might presume upon your first exposure. Speed isn't everything... Check out songs like Ugh, The One, Dull Knives, Evolve, and so on and so forth
Certain judgements should only be made when that person has a comprehensive knowledge of the bands whole catalogue .Some songs will be heavy and some alot softer .
I can only go off what I've seen. If I didn't say what I think so far then there wouldn't be any point in reacting. The whole point is that I comment on what I've seen.....
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel I respect your opinion , and just to add that these girls are different from many other bands in terms of genre , sub genres that they play , eg , a mixture of prog / rock , punk and metal .Delve deeper and you will see .There is no better example than watching / reacting to their concept album , which they played live at Lunario CDMX , and then you get a much better understaning of what this band is all about .Cheers man .
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel i would recommend Dull Knives (live from the warning cave). Or psychotic (live at lunario), dust to dust (live at foro didi), evolve (official music video), etc
Couldn’t disagree with you more about women not having powerful voices. Dany is an exceedingly powerful singer; what about Nancy Wilson? Floor Jensen?Lzzy Hale? And then there is Tatiana…she’s the most dynamic/powerful singer on the planet right now. th-cam.com/video/SQNtGoM3FVU/w-d-xo.html
Yes he did suggest women in rock generally don't have as much resonance and sheer power in their voices but he is only basing Dany on one song which is not really fair.
@@booradley8895 I'm sorry but firstly I've only got one song to off because that's all I've listened to. I can't comment on things I haven't heard. Secondly, men do have more resonant voices. That's just physics and biology
Jesus christ what is wrong with you. Show me where I said 'women don't have powerful voices'. How are you so mad that you are now twisting my words? You're acting like I not only attacked but attacked you personally. It's insane
There's a ton of female fronted metal bands, Arch Enemy and Jinjer just to name 2 great ones. I have no idea where you get that females don't have powerful enough voices for heavy music. Simply isn't true.
Indeed; Ann Wilson, Pat Benatar, and Joan Jett sing their share of heavy songs. Dull Knives and Queen of the Murder Scene are plenty heavy, and Dany uses her powerful low register to add menace.
Nice Reaction! They have been on a U.S. Tour since 5/30/2023 and are now heading over to Europe for their first time. Their first show is on 5/27 in Plymouth, England and I think this is one where they are opening up for Muse (their favorite band). After that they are off to Germany for a few shows and then touring around Europe until 6/26.
Your little speech about rock music and female singers was one of the most condescending and idiotic "know it all" critiques I have heard in a very long time. It is doubling annoying since this is the day that the great Tina Turner passed away. But I guess you think she was just another female that couldn't possibly have the power to sing rock. I was born in 1960 and was fortunate to become a rock music fan at an early age. I can remember when I heard the news that my fellow Texan Janis Joplin had died (I guess she wasn't up to your rock standards either). I was a huge fan of The Runaways, Heart, Linda Ronstadt, Stevie Nicks, Pat Benatar, Joan Jett, Deborah Harry, Donna Summer, Chrissie Hynde, Grace Slick. Patti Labelle, Bonnie Tyler (I could keep going). Have you heard of Doro Pesch, Angela Gossow, Liv Kristine, Amy Lee, Cristina Scabbia, Maria Brink, Morgan Lander, Fernanda Lira, Melissa Bonny, Brittney Slayes, Otep Shamaya, Alissa White-Gluz, Mayu, Tatiana Shmayluk, Floor Jansen, Lzzy Hale (I could keep going)? I could make a long list of powerful current female blues rock singers but I will just go with Beth Hart, Shemekia Copeland, Sue Foley, Ana Popovich, Samantha Fish, Joanne Shaw Taylor and Susan Tedeschi. From one arrogant ass that knows about rock and metal to another that obviously knows very little about rock and metal, I strongly urge you never to discuss female vocalists in rock music ever again.
Wrong. I said female singers in rock can get a bit lost in the heaviness of a certain type of rock but that this didn't apply to the kind they were playing and that they were killing it. Why are you so hurt?
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel I understood exactly what you said and it remains BS. I am not hurt at all. Why would you assume that? I was trying to give you some good advice and introduce you to amazing female vocalists about whom you appear to be clueless.
@@danw6048 I'm sorry but you proved you didn't understand what I said when you said I said that females don't have the power to sing rock. You know we can all see your original comment right?
@The Charlie Smith Channel You failed to clarify which types of rock you believe females are inadequate. Since you are equally wrong, whether talking about all rock or just certain genres, my lack of specificity really doesn't matter. Now the people that read our little back and forth can decide. It is past midnight here, and I am going to bed.
I don't need to specify. It wasn't pertinent to this group or what I was saying. As I said, the voice suits the music in this case and they killed it........ Not really sure what you're so up in arms about
She doesn't struggle at all when they go heavy, in fact even when they were kids doing the cover of Enter Sandman at the ages of 9, 12 and 14 they hold their on, that video has 24 million views, then many years later Metallica ask them to do a song for their Black Album anniversary, called the Black List album, with Alessia Cara, and they did Enter Sandman again, but with their own arrangement, and send it out of this world, and their song it's the 1st song on the Black List album... and the more that 45 songs they have originally, not one it's bad, they are allergic to making bad music.... check any songs. You'll see what I'm taking about....
Solo dire esto, The Warning, de lo mejor que hay en este momento y se convertiran en una banda legendaria gracias a su talento, y son de lo mejor en lo que hacen tocando instrumentos y en lo vocal, ademas de que desde corta edad nos demostraron que sus letras son muy buenas. The Warning 🇲🇽🤘
Couldn’t disagree more with your male /female assessment. For my money, best rock trio out there, of any gender. Their fan base in N America skews towards those who grew up in the 60’s through to the 90’s and enjoyed classic rock. They have a generally younger fan base in Latin America. I, like many who will be commenting, had lost interest in the current music scene. These young women inspired me to buy my first concert tickets in decades.
You don’t think females have resonance…😂. I love the Warning Sisters. These Sister are very young but they are excellent musicians. They are incredible Live. I’d recommend that you react to Diana Ankudinova from Russia 🇷🇺 “Can’t Help Falling in Love”. Dare you!
Animosity ,un gran tema con un excelente contenido y un enorme Riff , un tema energetico , lo que Pau compone cuando se molesta ,sin la menor duda The Warning ,es el mejor grupo de Rock en la historia del Rock en Mexico y muy pronto del mundo ,nadie tiene el volumen de composicion que tiene TW y todos temas excelentes y nadie es tan bueno tocando en vivo
Try "Dust To Dust" live at Lunario and you'll have a better understanding of who The Warning really is. This is a good song (they don't have bad songs) but not the most representative of their creativity and charisma.
Was The Warning just mansplained to me? Males have superior rock voices? Their performance was okay for being not too technical? Okay, Charlie, if you say so. 🤨
Omg your explanation on women against male singers was hilarious. And im 60 + and have listen to metall and rock / hard rock all my life. Just plain silly. Thumbs down. And up for The Warning.😂
Thanks for your honest reaction. It confirms my skepticism about the girls making it big. They are too intellectual, too subtle for today's music scene. No wonder their concept album almost went unnoticed by the mainstream. Most fans believe that solos on guitars & drums (occasionally the bass) define great artists. Hence a song gets judged more by its ornate instrumentation rather than what it is conveying. The lyrics & message in a song therefore take a backseat. It becomes more of an instrumental piece or jazz tune for the contemporary music fan. So for a band like The Warning their metaphorical songwriting becomes redundant straight away. As do their subtle intelligent music arrangements that sound deceptively simple. Subtle innovators seldom get appreciated over showy shredders nowadays. Pink Floyd, Dire Straits would have found it difficult to make an impact today. The highlighted "advantage" of male singers explains why so many front women in rock have to perform in their nightwear with expletive laden interactions. They have to bring something extra to engage audiences that are predominantly male. Cosplay becomes important as well - gothic, vampire, coy girls, maids, etc. The Warning do not fit in. They will incorporate solos only if the song demands it. They have done all those aggressive fills & showmanships in their teens during their first 6 years of existence as a band. They are old hands now with a decade under the belt. However their high technical level of musicianship gets noticed by a handful of discerning listeners only. As one commentator noted elsewhere that he has never seen so many ex-musicians, musicians & music theory savvy fans discuss a "simple" band like The Warning. Whether the Villarreal sisters stay an elite band playing in small venues in front of dedicated fans or fill up stadiums in the future remain to be seen. Reaction like this tells me the latter possibility is bleak.
Hmm I don't think it needs to be hyper technical to be viable for mainstream. The opposite in fact. You don't find the ridiculous musicality in the mainstream because its too much and goes over most people's heads. Obviously I can only speak for this song as its the only one I've done but despite it having great lyrics the track sounds very dated. This sound has passed and so I think it is that that will hinder them making it big rather than a lack of technicality. As many people have pointed out, they are endorsed by muse. Muse are big because they got huge when that sound was huge and they were pioneers of something a bit different. But they're not in the mainstream now. They have millions of fans because they got big when that sound was big. These girls seem to be trying to get big on a sound that is very dated. Doesn't mean they can't have a good and succesful career but I think they will struggle to hit the 'big time' with songs like this. They're 20 years too late
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel Yeah, as I said earlier the average music fan nowadays won't appreciate the girls' subtleties in bass or drums. The fans are too shallow, too easily influenced by showmanship & unwanted musicality. Intellectualism is a non-existent word in their lives. They will bang their heads to noise in the name of being contemporary. Thankfully The Warning aren't locked in a genre or influenced by any band. Yes, their idols are Muse but most of their songs hardly reflect any influence. Let's see how it goes.
I don't want to pile on, I appreciate reactors who express honest opinions but I can only assume that rock is not your expertise area as your views seem very stereotypical of the genre
When you think of rock you think of a male voice. You're correct. Want to know why. Because females were not very represented in rock music for most of it's existence. As a kid I always listened to female rock artists because they were so rare. Heart, Joan Jett, Pat Benatar etc. Females singing rock music isn't different to me. It's just rock.
MEN! God man! Not like saving yourself from The Warning Army, for your next reactions you should give a more consistent opinion when you listen to more than 3 to 4 songs with The Warning! They don't have a specific genre of rock. But I'm sorry to tell you that Lzzy Hale adores them and that Matt Bellami himself invites them to your country and TODAY The Warning is in London, just because MUSE asked for them. So I think MUSE knows more about music than you. Nvm well tried! And VIVA México and TW!
Other people endorsing them isn't a good reason why anyone else should think any differently of them. Music is subjective. And for the record I'm not interested in saving myself from anyone. I'm giving my personal opinion. The fact that everyone has come in here getting butt hurt about the fact that someone else doesn't feel the same way as them about a band they like says everything about them
You should listen to more of their music to get a flavor of their style, as it varies considerably. I think that the term I would use is "approachable" rather than "easy listening", which is its own genre that's very different. It's true that they don't focus on hypertechnical instrumentals -- an excellent choice of word -- instead emphasizing solid structure, intelligent lyrics, vocal strength, ensemble skills, and such. IMO this is the least interesting of the songs I have heard from this concert. Disciple, Martirio, and Enter Sandman -- a complete rework -- show them to much better advantage.
This Band SMOKES !!! Dany sings her ass off... on another note about Female singers.. Brittney Slayes from Unleash The Archers pushes Geoff Tate and Rob Halford right off the road .... (check mate)
It seems to me that I detect some prejudice in your judgment due to the fact that they are a rock band of women. Also... The vocalist "defends herself"?!! When has a "voice type" been specified to be suitable or not to sing rock?!! And why that posture or attitude of yours so "condescending"?!! Cheers!!
Sorry that's what you thought I meant. It's not at all. I just mean you don't find female voices much in genres like metal and harder forms or rock for a reason. It was a more general comment rather than a comment about this band
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel I think that you forget, or don't know, the names of several female vocalists of the hard, classic and alternative rock genre, successful icons whose voices left deep traces in musical history, that they would rightly protest your argument. Trust me, the list is huge.
Then go and watch someone else. You think I give a shit? It's for copyright if you must know. You're not supposed to get the same viewing pleasure as the original or it doesn't fall under fair use. Try again 🙄
Great reaction. You just got a taste of what The Warning can do. There's a whole diverse menu to pick from. I would suggest listening to the Q.O.T.M.S concept album in order. It showcases many different styles and tells a story as well. Believe me you won't be disappointed by any song by The Warning. 🤟😎⚠️
Terrible reaction to one of the hottest rock bands on earth! Obviously this guy doesn’t know a thing about The Warning’s music. These ladies can go toe to toe with any male band!
Right I'm going to give you all some sound advice here. Reactors don't care about your beloved artist in the same way that you do the first time we hear them. We don't have that exposure and aren't in any way emotionally invested. If you continue to fail to understand that and go in on anyone who has anything to say that isn't beaming praise then you will ensure that we don't react to them again because we can't be bothered to deal with you. We get it, you love the band. But don't take personal views and perspectives as a personal attack on yourselves. You are actually working against the best interests of the band you love so much when you do that, even though you feel like you're defending them.
Well, look who's "butt-hurt" now. I have never seen any reactor quite so desperate for validation, and I've seen hundreds in recent years. A lot of TWA will appease whatever a reactor might blurt out in order to spread the love. Some of us don't give two shits about any particulare reactor. You're the one taking things personally. Get a grip, or you move on. I for one won't miss your misogynistic arrogance.
@@charlielightfoot7006 To be fair he has listened to numerous female artists. That they all range from Gospel to Jazz and not one single rock singer suggests rock is not his genre.
@@booradley8895 I already tried fair. It just triggered me a bit when he threatened the fan base with emotional blackmail. "Stop being mean to me, or I won't react to your artist anymore." He's not listening to anyone who disagrees with him, and I changed my upvote to a downvote because of his knee-jerk reaction to anyone who isn't blowing sunshine up his sexist skirt. DPA got this far without his support, and I think they'll survive without him going forward. I know I will.
Best power trio in the world! Period!
As a Rush fan I totally Agree!
@@JohnSmith-zl8rz Agreed. They have the spirit of a young Rush, imo.
Just some input from somebody who has been a rocker since rock began. technical, shredding, etc doesn't equate to good. Rock started off as basic as it gets in the 50's. Slowly evolved into all the current subgenres. I like some doo wop from back then as much as i like anything since. My top half dozen rock bands today are all female. The warning is one of the top 2. For me, #1 i gotta "feel" them. #2 gotta be able to play live. #3 gotta have good lyrics #4 gotta have decent songwriting skills. Been listening to dudes all my life, glad i'm still here to enjoy this wave of rocker chicks. I've always listened to many different genres of music from all over the world. Gives u an appreciation & recognition of the simplest to the most complex music. After all, it started with someone beating on a log or rock with a stick. About as basic as it gets but we wouldn't be listening to what we have today without it. Flashy sweep pickers got nothin on Django or Sergovia, etc. A spectacle onstage is entertaining but doesn't necessarly make it great music and usually it's a femine voice that sings the baby to sleep
The Warning rocks!!
Thanks, Charlie, for reacting to The Warning. The Villarreal Sisters make a kind of "classic" rock not too complicated, but excellently done and attractive. That's why they've built a huge following of loyal fans from all over the world, The Warning Army, who will give you lots of information about the band in the comments.
You would have told him that if he wanted to see how complicated and badass they are, you should suggest the Metallica - Atlas Rise by The Warning video.
As good as this is, Disciple from the same concert is better and heavier. These girls don’t struggle at all with heavy songs. Animosity is one of their lighter songs. Pau, the drummer, is incredible and in other songs can sing and drum at the same time. You can’t make an opinion on one song - they have 47 original songs in three albums and an EP and two singles. They are from Monterrey, MX. The Warning will be touring in your neighbothood starting this Saturday in Plymouth. They open four Muse shows over the next five weeks. They will also be doing shows in Spain, France, Germany, Switzerland, Czechia, and Poland.
¡Viva The Warning! ⚡⚡⚡🇲🇽
"Disciple"
th-cam.com/video/xxkPTKyiSqY/w-d-xo.html
So agree Dave, All their recent stuff is incredible, but The Teartro live version of Disciple is at present their pinnacle. Perfect rock! And Pau...Oh Pau..
Thats all subjective. This has more energy.
They are opening 5 shows for Muse over that way coming up real soon
Man your right on the money about your reaction! You can have the most technical musicians but if they can't write a good song or have stage presence it's boring,,but I have yet to see that with these sisters! They can hold their own with any band!!! You have to check more of their songs out! They only get better! You have been Warned!🤘🤘🤘
May 29 is their first concert in the UK you should go see them
27th
is sold out
Watched them a few days ago and they sounded even better live. Absolutely magnificent.
You're right. May 29th at the Bush Hall, London UK (private show organized by TWA UK). May be there is some tickets available !!
@@curieusechine yeah but their first UK show is the 27th
They landed in the UK yesterday
The Warning kicks ass!!
Queen of the murder scene- The Warming
Choke- The Warning.
Disciple- The Warning.
It's 80's Rock for sure, its what rock has been missing the last 30 years!!
The drummer, named Pau, pronounced like Pow - I know. It's a great name for a drummer, right? - short for Paulina, wrote the lyrics for this song. It was prompted by a friend who pissed her off. The moral of the story, don't piss off Pau or she'll write a song about you. LOL They have a dark concept album called Queen of the Murder Scene (their second album). The album tells the story of a girl who loves a guy who doesn't even acknowledge that she exists. Her love turns to obsession as she stalks him and finally murders him. Then the story follows her descent into madness and self-destruction. A great album that was written by these three young ladies when they were in their teens. They have a total of three albums and two EPs. Even though their ages range from Dany (Daniela, the guitarist) at 23, to Pau at 21, and Ale (Alejandra, the bassist) at 18. they have been performing as a band for over ten years. They just completed an 18-city headliner tour of the US with the support of Plush and Holy Wars, and will be joining Muse in the UK this Saturday and will open for them in five shows before turning their attention to several European festivals and some Headliner shows. You might want to check out some of their recent performances from the 18-City tour for a sample of what they sound like live. I suggest searching for their most recent song, MORE, officially released on May 12th and currently charting in the US. And as others in the comments have directed, any of the shows from the Teatro Metropolitan concert in Mexico City last August will give you an excellent, professionally shot, and recorded example of what it is like to see them live. Don't let their petite statures fool you. As Lzzy Hale of Halestorm described them while The Warning was opening for many of Halestorm's shows last Summer and Fall, "They are fierce...They attack the audience."
Many of the things you say are opinion-based and you are of course entitled to your opinion. And of course you can't have a complete understanding of what they do after one song. That's totally fine.
On one thing you are just simply wrong though.
I would have thought the days of people being like "okay, they're pretty good ... well ... for being women..." are far behind us.
Looks like some people haven't gotten the message though.
You Have Been Warned!! 🤟
Wow, what a manly man. Such a rocker, so manly powerful and instrumentally complex man 🙄🙄
🤣🤣🤣
"Palatable Rock"? I think Dany is holding more than her own. As far as women not being quite as loud to make themselves heard I think the now late great Tina Turner didn't have an issue making herself be heard, RIP.
They are opening for Muse over the next three weeks in the UK. Worth seeing!
Aun te falta mucho por conocer, pero has sido advertido por las diosas del rock. Saludos
Never seen a guy did a hole for himself so fast. I can nane a dozen powerful female singers without even thinking about it.
Did I say there aren't powerful female vocalists? Nope. That's insane
Yes
He is a moron
@TheCharli
eSmithChannel
You just put shit on probably the best band in 30 years
Sorry pal. If you think this is the best band in 30 years then it isn't me that's the moron 😂😂😂😂 christ almighty
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel was going to subscribe but came across this comment. I do believe this is the best band in 30 years so that makes me a moron too, but not enough of a moron to subscribe to your channel ✌ TW❤🤘
Enjoyed your reaction!! I think the real key to _The Warning_ and what first attracted me to them... is their *lyrics* . Every tune is a story, and every aspect of their music is geared towards telling the story - in whatever genera the storyline fits. They wander all over the place, musically. Which is tremendous fun in and of itself, especially because they do it so skillfully. Every song is a *composition* , carefully designed and constructed to tell the tale. I look forward to their future albums, but the three they've already released are each in their own way absolutely epic.
And as far as destroying instruments goes.. well, they just sold a kick drum skin Pau demolished several months ago, for 150 dollars. It absolutely wasn't intentional, but she keeps a "quiver" of spare drumsticks by her side for a *reason*... 😋
You have not heard the last of this band; not by a long shot.
Thank you for you calm and measured comment. It's been a breath of fresh air haha. I agree, lyrically this song is very good. Unfortunately, I don't usually pick up the lyrics very well on my first time hearing something. I'm working at it but I'm much more drawn to how it sounds musically
Great to see you reacting to The Warning. Regarding your comment about female singers in rock/metal, I am not sure, but seems like you need to discover European rock/metal bands, as most of the best ones have female singers and they are some of the greatest vocalists you will ever hear, especially Floor Jansen of Nightwish, who in my opinion is the greatest current female singer on the planet, but there are others in bands like Epica, The Gathering, Vuur, etc. and there is also my second favorite singer Brittney Slayes of Unleash The Archers.
And even harder: try Jinjer or Spiritbox 😁
The Warning son tan espectaculares que en Abril volverán a Alemania a Holanda, Inglaterra, y debutarán en Suiza y República Checa.👍
Palatable? Never heard the Warning called that before.
He is a moron
Ask him about how he blubbering over the FAKe John Farnham merch
Hilarious
Bold statements from one video, this is rock and roll period, your right it’s basic rock, but that makes the best rock and roll and as you stated all that hypo stuff is just that hype… and I think that’s a poor statement as well about women singers, I’m 62 yrs old and I would put Dany of the Warning as well as Ann Wilson, Pat Benatar, Joan Jett, Debbie Harry, to name a few, up there against any male singer, l like the techno rock too but that’s just a flavor of rock, give me the meat and potatoes of basic rock! Music you can sing, clap, and just have a good time with, A Warning and Rock & Roll Fan Forever…
Oh man, power is what these ladies are made of. Seriously, Dany the singer guitarist, is a hurricane, and Pau the drummer is a dynamite truck. Ale on bass has the gravity of a small planet to hold them together. I think you’re making a big mistake when you keep repeating the words easy, simple, basic, etc. You seem to be presuming a lot about what the “Audience is there for.” This song may not be the best to display the complexity you are looking for, or maybe because they are female you didn’t look too hard. Seems you already made your mind up about that.
they are now right outside your backyard, openig for muse this saturday at plymouth.
To think that as we are going women will dominate the genre
They are on the way to Great Britain as I write this. Playing with Muse.
They write their own music. They have been around since 2014.
You were warned by the queens of rock 🇧🇷🤘❤️
The Warning write lyrics expressing their views of today's world and deliver the story with their own unique style of rock. I find their sound infectious and love the diversity in their sound. I don't care for bands whose songs sound very similar.
Not enough power? Boy are you in for a surprise. You should see the video of them doing “Enter Sandman”. When they were 14,12 & 9.
It’s sad that some of the fans don’t listen to what you say and make their own interpretations of it!
I’m 71 years old from the UK and have been following them from when I saw a 6 year old Paulina playing the drums and singing, it was amazing to me!
It’s been a joy watching them grow into what they are now, a great band that is going to be big. Their songwriting is what makes them special to me, it’s so meaningful and relatable to.
It’s not fair to expect you to make a full judgement of their abilities from one song which to me is not really representative of them. The problem is that there are no two songs alike, they are stylistically similar but different in terms of composition and content.
You were fair and I’ve liked your reaction, looking forward to more!
Thank you Darrell. I'm glad you get it. Unfortunately this happens with a lot of artist that I react to that, for whatever reason, have slightly fanatical fans. They take anything that isn't shining praise as not only a criticism but, seemingly, a personal attack. It's very strange.
Thank you for getting it 👍🏼
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel You really should check them out live. They'll be at the O2 Academy in London, and tickets are still on sale. They're the first Latin American band to sign with a major US label, and this European tour places them on the launching pad for a stellar career. They're likely headed towards global domination! 🔥 🎸 🤘
This band is just brilliant
The warning No1 🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘👏👏👏👏
One of the biggest "tells" any reactor can give is saying a song isn't "technical" or complex. Guess what? 98% of rock songs aren't. Some of the greatest rock bands in history don't have a single moment that meets this "standard" that only appears when a reactor is covering a bias (that they are often unaware of). The Warning are superlative musicians, both technically and in musicianship. The roll Pau does, that you ridiculously reduced to a straight rhythm, is a perfectly controlled build filled with accents and variation in texture. It is HIGHLY technical. Dany strums a very complex and active chord pattern in the prechorus whilst singing lead, a degree of skill you'd be hard pressed to find in most bands. The Warning are so good they make is seem easy. The through line of their song is always clear to the listener, so on the surface it sounds 'simple', but if you have a good ear, you can hear how active every instrument is, how they trade off parts and fill the sonic space far bigger than most 3-piece can. Good musicians make complexity sound natural, even easy. Good composers make original music sound familiar.
I'm sorry but I'm a producer and I play 5 instruments. I am not ignorant to anything you mentioned. This is not complex musically at all. I'm sorry it just isn't
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel so, can we get a sample of your music? Since The Warning’s music is so simple, and performed by 3 weak women… can we hear your highly complex and Successful music? It must be something amazing if you label TW as tolerable and simple😊
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel may I suggest a bit more humility? Many of us TW fans are actual musicians as well, and we don’t pretend to know more than TW, or how to fix their sound. And yes, some of us are actually retired after 50 yrs, and some of us performed 14 different instruments… so, your qualifications don’t impress us. Just tell us how it makes you feel. We already know enough about music; you’re not educating us, and you’re certainly not qualified to educate The Warning.
@@macgherhardt1061 Jesus! You're a sensitive soul aren't you. I never called them tolerable or weak. I'm afraid you're blinded by your hurt butt. If you don't like what I said then move on. You can't go around bullying people into having a different opinion of something you like. What in the dictatorial shit is that?
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel your true colors come out then? Being caustic and insulting to people who WATCH your reactions; bragging about your qualifications; awkward language regarding women in music, and judging musicians (TW) who are leagues superior to you… I reiterate… try more humility; and stop insulting your viewers.
Who has "The Best Rock Drummer Wears A Dress" on their bingo card?
You have riled up the Warning Army and yes we are an Army that will protect The Warning Ladies. We The Army have watched these Ladies Grow up before our eyes from age 6 and up. We could fill Volumes with their accolades. These girls are superstars and will be remembered as such always.
What video did you watch? Cause, this video doesn't seem to match what your comments are referring to.
@@FullTexanEffect Since you are from Texas , I don't want to explain it 10 different times to you.
@@larrybutler8948 well, people are entitled to have an opinion. And, the dude wasn't insulting the Warning, he just had a stereotypical view of Rock as a Non--Rock fan. So, I'll be needing that 11th explanation, if you don't mind. 😉
@@FullTexanEffect As I only expressed my opinion also. He did say thing that riled up the Army just read comments below etc. You seem to think thgat I came down on him hard. I merely stated he had riled up the Army. Do you need a 12th?
Great reaction! Please continue with more TW (Metropolitan theater songs has good live quality sound) and do mot forget to see them live.
When Dany sings a lyric, you believe her.
It's a little reminisant of female rock icons Pat Benetar or Joan Jett from the eighties. 👍❤
Absolutely Mo. Joan Jett is a great shout ♥️
Hi,, greeding from german.. I saw last year US Band here in a small Club.. Try
:"War on women - pleasure and the beast".. /some german stuff.. :"Jennifer Rostock - Kaleidoskop.. /.. Tauben aus Porzellan,,".. (Enjoy
They dont struggle..... Welcome to the Rabbit Hole.....
The Singer is AMAZING live
They are opening several shows for Muse and Royal Blood, the next few weeks. Amazing band.
gran reacción! 🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Tu punto de vista coincide con lo dicho por las hermanas, le apuestan más a la solidez y armonía de los instrumentos en una canción más que incorporar solos de guitarra "sin sentido". 🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Viva The Warning!!!
Welcome to your new addiction you have been Warned 🤘 😎 ⚠️
it 'muse' vibes mate 😁
Get ready in the U.K. cuz their touring with Muse very soon. As others have said the best power trio in the world all things considered. They have already been doing shows for 10 years and the oldest is 23. Incredible.
They are far more capable, and put far more effort into every last detail of their songs, than you might presume upon your first exposure. Speed isn't everything... Check out songs like Ugh, The One, Dull Knives, Evolve, and so on and so forth
Certain judgements should only be made when that person has a comprehensive knowledge of the bands whole catalogue .Some songs will be heavy and some alot softer .
I can only go off what I've seen. If I didn't say what I think so far then there wouldn't be any point in reacting. The whole point is that I comment on what I've seen.....
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel I respect your opinion , and just to add that these girls are different from many other bands in terms of genre , sub genres that they play , eg , a mixture of prog / rock , punk and metal .Delve deeper and you will see .There is no better example than watching / reacting to their concept album , which they played live at Lunario CDMX , and then you get a much better understaning of what this band is all about .Cheers man .
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel i would recommend Dull Knives (live from the warning cave). Or psychotic (live at lunario), dust to dust (live at foro didi), evolve (official music video), etc
🙋⚡⚡⚡🔥🔥🔥
June 29, 2023 UK gig at Islington London
Couldn’t disagree with you more about women not having powerful voices. Dany is an exceedingly powerful singer; what about Nancy Wilson? Floor Jensen?Lzzy Hale? And then there is Tatiana…she’s the most dynamic/powerful singer on the planet right now. th-cam.com/video/SQNtGoM3FVU/w-d-xo.html
That's not what I said at all
Yes he did suggest women in rock generally don't have as much resonance and sheer power in their voices but he is only basing Dany on one song which is not really fair.
@@booradley8895 I'm sorry but firstly I've only got one song to off because that's all I've listened to. I can't comment on things I haven't heard. Secondly, men do have more resonant voices. That's just physics and biology
Hopefully you do react to another Warning song and see if your sweeping assessment that women don't have powerful voices rings true.
Jesus christ what is wrong with you. Show me where I said 'women don't have powerful voices'. How are you so mad that you are now twisting my words? You're acting like I not only attacked but attacked you personally. It's insane
⚡✌️🤟⚠️🪖⚡The Best! Rock On!⚡✌️🤟⚠️🪖⚡
The warning army ❤❤❤❤ presente 🇲🇽
There's a ton of female fronted metal bands, Arch Enemy and Jinjer just to name 2 great ones. I have no idea where you get that females don't have powerful enough voices for heavy music. Simply isn't true.
Indeed; Ann Wilson, Pat Benatar, and Joan Jett sing their share of heavy songs. Dull Knives and Queen of the Murder Scene are plenty heavy, and Dany uses her powerful low register to add menace.
Ale🎸Pau🥁Dany🎸 México !!!🎵ole ole ole ole Warning Warning🎵¡¡¡ Greetings from Argentina
Nice Reaction! They have been on a U.S. Tour since 5/30/2023 and are now heading over to Europe for their first time. Their first show is on 5/27 in Plymouth, England and I think this is one where they are opening up for Muse (their favorite band). After that they are off to Germany for a few shows and then touring around Europe until 6/26.
I’ve seen a mosh pit with them. Depends on audience and song they are playing.
Your little speech about rock music and female singers was one of the most condescending and idiotic "know it all" critiques I have heard in a very long time. It is doubling annoying since this is the day that the great Tina Turner passed away. But I guess you think she was just another female that couldn't possibly have the power to sing rock. I was born in 1960 and was fortunate to become a rock music fan at an early age. I can remember when I heard the news that my fellow Texan Janis Joplin had died (I guess she wasn't up to your rock standards either). I was a huge fan of The Runaways, Heart, Linda Ronstadt, Stevie Nicks, Pat Benatar, Joan Jett, Deborah Harry, Donna Summer, Chrissie Hynde, Grace Slick. Patti Labelle, Bonnie Tyler (I could keep going). Have you heard of Doro Pesch, Angela Gossow, Liv Kristine, Amy Lee, Cristina Scabbia, Maria Brink, Morgan Lander, Fernanda Lira, Melissa Bonny, Brittney Slayes, Otep Shamaya, Alissa White-Gluz, Mayu, Tatiana Shmayluk, Floor Jansen, Lzzy Hale (I could keep going)? I could make a long list of powerful current female blues rock singers but I will just go with Beth Hart, Shemekia Copeland, Sue Foley, Ana Popovich, Samantha Fish, Joanne Shaw Taylor and Susan Tedeschi. From one arrogant ass that knows about rock and metal to another that obviously knows very little about rock and metal, I strongly urge you never to discuss female vocalists in rock music ever again.
Wrong. I said female singers in rock can get a bit lost in the heaviness of a certain type of rock but that this didn't apply to the kind they were playing and that they were killing it. Why are you so hurt?
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel I understood exactly what you said and it remains BS. I am not hurt at all. Why would you assume that? I was trying to give you some good advice and introduce you to amazing female vocalists about whom you appear to be clueless.
@@danw6048 I'm sorry but you proved you didn't understand what I said when you said I said that females don't have the power to sing rock. You know we can all see your original comment right?
@The Charlie Smith Channel You failed to clarify which types of rock you believe females are inadequate. Since you are equally wrong, whether talking about all rock or just certain genres, my lack of specificity really doesn't matter. Now the people that read our little back and forth can decide. It is past midnight here, and I am going to bed.
I don't need to specify. It wasn't pertinent to this group or what I was saying. As I said, the voice suits the music in this case and they killed it........ Not really sure what you're so up in arms about
She doesn't struggle at all when they go heavy, in fact even when they were kids doing the cover of Enter Sandman at the ages of 9, 12 and 14 they hold their on, that video has 24 million views, then many years later Metallica ask them to do a song for their Black Album anniversary, called the Black List album, with Alessia Cara, and they did Enter Sandman again, but with their own arrangement, and send it out of this world, and their song it's the 1st song on the Black List album... and the more that 45 songs they have originally, not one it's bad, they are allergic to making bad music.... check any songs. You'll see what I'm taking about....
Easy listening? No
Psssssssst🤫 come here let me tell you a little secret!
(THE WARNING) can become a scary addiction!)
Ok got to go you didn't hear it from me!🤐
Solo dire esto, The Warning, de lo mejor que hay en este momento y se convertiran en una banda legendaria gracias a su talento, y son de lo mejor en lo que hacen tocando instrumentos y en lo vocal, ademas de que desde corta edad nos demostraron que sus letras son muy buenas.
The Warning 🇲🇽🤘
Couldn’t disagree more with your male /female assessment. For my money, best rock trio out there, of any gender.
Their fan base in N America skews towards those who grew up in the 60’s through to the 90’s and enjoyed classic rock. They have a generally younger fan base in Latin America.
I, like many who will be commenting, had lost interest in the current music scene. These young women inspired me to buy my first concert tickets in decades.
Exactly - I wanna hear Steven Tyler’s deep bass voice. LOL
buenas devoluciones hacia la rola de tremenda banda de ROCK como lo es THE WARNING, me suscribo esperando que tengas mas reacciones hacia la banda🤘🤘⚡⚡
You don’t think females have resonance…😂. I love the Warning Sisters. These Sister are very young but they are excellent musicians. They are incredible Live.
I’d recommend that you react to Diana Ankudinova from Russia 🇷🇺 “Can’t Help Falling in Love”. Dare you!
No. That's not what I said. You can't make a noise out of your voice without resonance. That's what sound is
Animosity ,un gran tema con un excelente contenido y un enorme Riff , un tema energetico , lo que Pau compone cuando se molesta ,sin la menor duda The Warning ,es el mejor grupo de Rock en la historia del Rock en Mexico y muy pronto del mundo ,nadie tiene el volumen de composicion que tiene TW y todos temas excelentes y nadie es tan bueno tocando en vivo
Try "Dust To Dust" live at Lunario and you'll have a better understanding of who The Warning really is. This is a good song (they don't have bad songs) but not the most representative of their creativity and charisma.
"Dust to Dust"
th-cam.com/video/Jb7Hi0X16DU/w-d-xo.html
His análisis are all over bye!
😂 What?
Was The Warning just mansplained to me? Males have superior rock voices? Their performance was okay for being not too technical? Okay, Charlie, if you say so. 🤨
He needs to hear more Floor Jansen or Jinjer those women out perform a lot of male singers.
Taylor Momsen, Maria Brink
Watch it Man..the Warning army Will fall on you sooner than later
Brittney Slayes of Unleash the Archers, Angela Gossow and Alissa White-Gluz of Arch Enemy or more from my time Grace Slick and Janis Joplin.
@@lonelywind3511 How about the late Tina Turner? RIP 😢 Beth Hart? Susan Tedeschi? Lydia Pense? Brittany Howard? I'm sure there are many more.
Don't forget to reach the king of harmonic fingerstyle Alip Ba Ta because he has 6 Millions subs.
Omg your explanation on women against male singers was hilarious. And im 60 + and have listen to metall and rock / hard rock all my life. Just plain silly. Thumbs down. And up for The Warning.😂
Locura en UK!!!
🤘⚠️good reaction ⚠️🤘
Disciple live by the warning please!!
Es solo ROCK pero me gusta
Importante aportación 😏
man you shoud do "bruises by lloyiso" breath taking this guy is the living jesus or something im crying everytime i listern to his songs
Actually, the best at what they do. 🥰🥰
Thanks for your honest reaction. It confirms my skepticism about the girls making it big.
They are too intellectual, too subtle for today's music scene. No wonder their concept album almost went unnoticed by the mainstream.
Most fans believe that solos on guitars & drums (occasionally the bass) define great artists. Hence a song gets judged more by its ornate instrumentation rather than what it is conveying. The lyrics & message in a song therefore take a backseat. It becomes more of an instrumental piece or jazz tune for the contemporary music fan. So for a band like The Warning their metaphorical songwriting becomes redundant straight away. As do their subtle intelligent music arrangements that sound deceptively simple.
Subtle innovators seldom get appreciated over showy shredders nowadays. Pink Floyd, Dire Straits would have found it difficult to make an impact today.
The highlighted "advantage" of male singers explains why so many front women in rock have to perform in their nightwear with expletive laden interactions. They have to bring something extra to engage audiences that are predominantly male. Cosplay becomes important as well - gothic, vampire, coy girls, maids, etc.
The Warning do not fit in. They will incorporate solos only if the song demands it. They have done all those aggressive fills & showmanships in their teens during their first 6 years of existence as a band. They are old hands now with a decade under the belt. However their high technical level of musicianship gets noticed by a handful of discerning listeners only. As one commentator noted elsewhere that he has never seen so many ex-musicians, musicians & music theory savvy fans discuss a "simple" band like The Warning.
Whether the Villarreal sisters stay an elite band playing in small venues in front of dedicated fans or fill up stadiums in the future remain to be seen. Reaction like this tells me the latter possibility is bleak.
Hmm I don't think it needs to be hyper technical to be viable for mainstream. The opposite in fact. You don't find the ridiculous musicality in the mainstream because its too much and goes over most people's heads.
Obviously I can only speak for this song as its the only one I've done but despite it having great lyrics the track sounds very dated. This sound has passed and so I think it is that that will hinder them making it big rather than a lack of technicality.
As many people have pointed out, they are endorsed by muse. Muse are big because they got huge when that sound was huge and they were pioneers of something a bit different. But they're not in the mainstream now. They have millions of fans because they got big when that sound was big. These girls seem to be trying to get big on a sound that is very dated. Doesn't mean they can't have a good and succesful career but I think they will struggle to hit the 'big time' with songs like this. They're 20 years too late
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel Yeah, as I said earlier the average music fan nowadays won't appreciate the girls' subtleties in bass or drums. The fans are too shallow, too easily influenced by showmanship & unwanted musicality. Intellectualism is a non-existent word in their lives. They will bang their heads to noise in the name of being contemporary.
Thankfully The Warning aren't locked in a genre or influenced by any band. Yes, their idols are Muse but most of their songs hardly reflect any influence. Let's see how it goes.
If you want heavier I would suggest their Metallica's Atlas Rise cover live at the Whiskey a Gogo
I don't want to pile on, I appreciate reactors who express honest opinions but I can only assume that rock is not your expertise area as your views seem very stereotypical of the genre
When you think of rock you think of a male voice. You're correct. Want to know why. Because females were not very represented in rock music for most of it's existence. As a kid I always listened to female rock artists because they were so rare. Heart, Joan Jett, Pat Benatar etc. Females singing rock music isn't different to me. It's just rock.
"Mayday! Mayday!...."
MEN! God man! Not like saving yourself from The Warning Army, for your next reactions you should give a more consistent opinion when you listen to more than 3 to 4 songs with The Warning! They don't have a specific genre of rock. But I'm sorry to tell you that Lzzy Hale adores them and that Matt Bellami himself invites them to your country and TODAY The Warning is in London, just because MUSE asked for them. So I think MUSE knows more about music than you. Nvm well tried! And VIVA México and TW!
Other people endorsing them isn't a good reason why anyone else should think any differently of them. Music is subjective.
And for the record I'm not interested in saving myself from anyone. I'm giving my personal opinion. The fact that everyone has come in here getting butt hurt about the fact that someone else doesn't feel the same way as them about a band they like says everything about them
Females struggle with Rock Vocals?? Someone call Lzzy Hale.
You should listen to more of their music to get a flavor of their style, as it varies considerably. I think that the term I would use is "approachable" rather than "easy listening", which is its own genre that's very different. It's true that they don't focus on hypertechnical instrumentals -- an excellent choice of word -- instead emphasizing solid structure, intelligent lyrics, vocal strength, ensemble skills, and such. IMO this is the least interesting of the songs I have heard from this concert. Disciple, Martirio, and Enter Sandman -- a complete rework -- show them to much better advantage.
I🖤TW🤘
Este vídeo salió hace milenios, actualízate, ya sacaron nuevo sencillo, deberías de reaccionar a ello
Tell me you've never listened to Nemophila without telling me you've never listened to Nemophila.
🤘😎❤️⚠️
This Band SMOKES !!! Dany sings her ass off... on another note about Female singers.. Brittney Slayes from Unleash The Archers pushes Geoff Tate and Rob Halford right off the road .... (check mate)
You really should check out Lizzy Hale for a powerful female voice in rock
It seems to me that I detect some prejudice in your judgment due to the fact that they are a rock band of women. Also... The vocalist "defends herself"?!! When has a "voice type" been specified to be suitable or not to sing rock?!! And why that posture or attitude of yours so "condescending"?!!
Cheers!!
Sorry that's what you thought I meant. It's not at all. I just mean you don't find female voices much in genres like metal and harder forms or rock for a reason. It was a more general comment rather than a comment about this band
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel
I think that you forget, or don't know, the names of several female vocalists of the hard, classic and alternative rock genre, successful icons whose voices left deep traces in musical history, that they would rightly protest your argument.
Trust me, the list is huge.
Can't watch your head bobbing while taking up 3/4 of the screen!!! Give the artist 3/4!!! 1/4 is plenty for your reaction. Gone!
Then go and watch someone else. You think I give a shit? It's for copyright if you must know. You're not supposed to get the same viewing pleasure as the original or it doesn't fall under fair use. Try again 🙄
Great reaction. You just got a taste of what The Warning can do. There's a whole diverse menu to pick from. I would suggest listening to the Q.O.T.M.S concept album in order. It showcases many different styles and tells a story as well. Believe me you won't be disappointed by any song by The Warning. 🤟😎⚠️
Not a representative song. Try Martirio from the same concert.
Not a representative song. Try another, perhaps Disciple from the same concert.
Terrible reaction to one of the hottest rock bands on earth! Obviously this guy doesn’t know a thing about The Warning’s music. These ladies can go toe to toe with any male band!
Palatable 🙄
Right I'm going to give you all some sound advice here. Reactors don't care about your beloved artist in the same way that you do the first time we hear them. We don't have that exposure and aren't in any way emotionally invested. If you continue to fail to understand that and go in on anyone who has anything to say that isn't beaming praise then you will ensure that we don't react to them again because we can't be bothered to deal with you. We get it, you love the band. But don't take personal views and perspectives as a personal attack on yourselves. You are actually working against the best interests of the band you love so much when you do that, even though you feel like you're defending them.
Well, look who's "butt-hurt" now. I have never seen any reactor quite so desperate for validation, and I've seen hundreds in recent years. A lot of TWA will appease whatever a reactor might blurt out in order to spread the love. Some of us don't give two shits about any particulare reactor. You're the one taking things personally. Get a grip, or you move on. I for one won't miss your misogynistic arrogance.
@@charlielightfoot7006 To be fair he has listened to numerous female artists. That they all range from Gospel to Jazz and not one single rock singer suggests rock is not his genre.
@@booradley8895 I used to be in a rock band and also wrote a song with Robert Hart from Bad Company. Trust me, I LOVE rock
@@booradley8895 I already tried fair. It just triggered me a bit when he threatened the fan base with emotional blackmail. "Stop being mean to me, or I won't react to your artist anymore." He's not listening to anyone who disagrees with him, and I changed my upvote to a downvote because of his knee-jerk reaction to anyone who isn't blowing sunshine up his sexist skirt. DPA got this far without his support, and I think they'll survive without him going forward. I know I will.
@@TheCharlieSmithChannel Like to listen to something you're done.