Which slicer has the BEST support material?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ค. 2024
- New Customer Exclusive - Get the Creality Ender 3 Pro 3D Printer for $100: micro.center/ix6
Shop Micro Center’s Winter Savings Deals: micro.center/cr3
Check out Micro Center’s Custom PC Builder: micro.center/zm5
Submit your build to Micro Center’s Build Showcase: micro.center/6aa
Maker Coin - www.makersmuse.com/maker-s-mu...
Join the Maker's Muse Community - www.makersmuse.com/maker-s-mu...
3D Printing Quick Start Guide - www.makersmuse.com/fdm-fff-3d...
3D Printer Buyers Guide - www.makersmuse.com/purchasing...
3D Printing Essentials - www.amazon.com/shop/makersmuse
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 Why use support material?
3:22 Support material tutorial
9:55 Results - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Regarding your last point, avoiding support is the best strategy, I have had so many problems with removing support I have an aversion to support material at all! One thing not to be afraid of is to design your part as mutiple parts that screw, glue, or clip together. Its tempting to try to make it print out all as one part, but sometimes you can make a nicer looking part as multiple pieces. This also means that making minor changes means you can just reprint one or two pieces rather than the whole thing, and it also opens the opportunity to make your part multi-colour if the aesthetic is important and you don't have a printer with multiple extruders.
This. Comparing my more recent projects that are designed in pieces to my older projects that are just one big object cut up using meshmixer, designing for it means you have so much more control and can often avoid support entirely
Totally. Printing a model in various parts and gluing them together can be a great way to side-step hassles with supports.
Something else I found helpful and quite easy is to design my own supports instead of relying on the slicer to do it for me.
One thing that helps is using a hair dryer or heat gun to heat up the offending areas. Makes it much much more easy to pull off stuck supports.
Usually layer height x 1.25 worked for me quite well, depends also on material, some just have better layer adhesion than others.
Probably works well for machines and stuff, but I've found that with art designs this usually isn't really an option, especially not when it comes to organics.
Super close to 1 mil Angus!! Very happy for you man, thank you for all the help over the last few years. I started up a 3DP Shop thanks to some of your help. Let me know if there's anything I can do to help in the future.
TL;DR: "Preferences" -> "Configure Cura" -> "General" -> untick "Automatically drop models to the build plate"
Really quick tip for anybody getting angry at Cura for dropping the parts to the build plate automatically (as I was before I looked at the settings): There's an option in the menu bar, "Preferences" -> "Configure Cura". It should start you out on the General tab (otherwise switch to it) and under the heading "Viewport behavior" there should be a checkbox for "Automatically drop models to the build plate". Uncheck that if you don't want the lowest part of your model to touch the build plate (i.e. hang it in midair to generate supports underneath).
Extra tip: if you don't want to switch that option on and off all the time, you can manually drop the model by selecting it, using the "Move" tool (or pressing 'T' ) and setting the z value to exactly 0. Hope this helps somebody :)
Bambu studio sets the Z distance between tree support and model to 0 (if you click yes when choosing tree support). Maybe that's why they were stuck. I'm not sure the other slicers do that.
I've always been lazy and just use simplify 3D as much as version 5 craziness angered me version 4 just works 99% of the time
Can’t imagine paying for a slicer nowadays tbh (for consumer/prosumer machines).
@@tiestofalljays I wouldn’t pay for a new license but did pay for the upgrade to v5, though I still prefer v4. I’ve used it forever and is the slicer that got me printing successfully.
Always used S3D v4 at work for years, does the job perfectly. When the v5 came out, i got pissed off to pay for BS and switched to Ideamaker which is more efficient with a bit of tuning. S3D v4 > Ideamaker > S3D v5 for me. Never used Cura, or Slic3r.
@@tiestofalljays payed for it years ago
@@radish6691 go ask for a refund, i did and got a refund. the upgrade doesn't let you have two instances of s3d v5, you can have one s3d v4 instance on one oc and one s3d v5 on another, they never mentioned that anywhere in the purchasing process, and in the refund request they told me it is mentioned, I checked again and couldn't find any mention of this change so I just refunded and I'm using cura now, much better honestly than s3d v4 or even s3d v5.
Designing parts that don't need support is a challenge I enjoy.
Especially TPU when you can use its flexibility to create living hinges in the print, giving it some origami traits.
One of my designs needed support so I made the pieces myself and put them into the design because I didn't trust the slicers to make them. It works well, the 3 support pieces easily snap off after printing, helping ensure the end users get perfect prints each time.
Angus, try the snug supports in prusaslicer. They are way easier to remove and use less material.
As a beginner to 3d printing this is was incredibly helpful. Perhaps as a part 2 you can also include information and advice on model placement and orientation to help with better print quality and support use. For instance, you mentioned the sharp downward pointing angle and how it must have support. I would assume something like that could be greatly assisted with rotating the model. Placement and orientation is definitely an area I find to be tricky at times, especially when I need t set supports.
I'm at the point where I'm exclusively using my Bambu printer and I do find their supports very easy to work with. I experimented with printing a 1:285 scale Zeta shuttle, from Rogue One, using a 0.2mm nozzle - and was able to get the supports off the less-than-a-mm-thick laser cannons without destroying them! I had to be very careful of course, but it worked. I agree that the tree supports aren't awesome, though; and if aesthetics matter you'll want to try and make the supported surface the less visible one.
I think of BaSl's supports as better than PrSl's, but I suspect that's more to do with the printer itself than the slicer proper, since my experience with Prusa Slicer's supports was all on an Ender 5. So, thank you for including them in this! And while I knew what changing the overhang angle did, I'd never figured out when I'd *want* to do that, so thank you for the mini tutorial there, as well.
Excellent overview man and I really love that you encourage people to create designs that don't need support when they can at the end. Its a good habit to get into especially when you start getting more and more into running production/ batches with your machines. 💪🏼
As somebody who has only been doing 3-D printing for about a month, videos like this are still helpful. I’ve had a few prints so far where I overestimated the support I would need and ended up breaking parts of the print or making them impossible to reach, The worst one of which took almost 2 days to print.
A month in 3D printing is nothing. "videos like this are still helpful" I think you are overestimating your knowledge way, way too much.
I've been 3D printing for 2.5 years and these videos are still helpful
I bought PC parts from microcenter yesterday and built a new rig. Super easy and within $20 of the best prices I could find online. Love it there
Thanks for this video Angus! I think it's a great video for beginners and refresher for people who have been printing for a while! Heck, I even learned something today too! Keep up the great work man!
Very interesting video. Did Cura’s supports fall more in line with Prusa’s if you inverted the angle? As I’m sure you’re aware, the reference is swapped compared to Prusa Slocer. For example, 30 degrees in Prusa is 60 degrees in Cura. Love the videos. Keep up the great work!
You're right, I mixed it up ! I'll do more testing to see how it behaves with a lower angle threshold
I was so bamboozled when he told that. I was doubting myself whether I was increasing or deacreasing support in cura haha
I'm just getting back into 3-D printing after a bit of a hiatus, So videos like these are incredibly helpful!
Cura also has settings for interface layers and some small adjustments pay huge dividends (included my settings). Would be interested to see a follow-up with support interface enabled. Love your vids Angus! Keep it up! Awesome resource for the community.
My settings:
Tree supports, touching build plate
40deg branch angle
0% density
1 support wall line
Enable support brim w/3mm width
.2mm support z distance
.4mm support top distance
⭐️enable support interface
⭐️enable support floor
⭐️enable support roof
⭐️ .12mm interface resolution
⭐️ 100% interface density
⭐️ concentric interface pattern
Came here to say the same. I have my interface on "concentric" and at 80 - 90% density for parts that need to be pretty and sometimes you can't even tell they were overhangs.
Thanks for the tip on the interface, I just never use it so wouldn't even know it makes a difference.
Good cooling also makes an enormous difference in support removal ease. The difference between removing supports (both default settings) between my custom machine with single a 5015 blower with two side cooling duct vs. a stock Ender 3 is absurd. The supports just stick on the Ender 3 like they were supposed to be part of the model.
@@XxBanziixX1 Same results here.
@@Kalvinjj I'm still running a mostly stock Ender 3 v2 and have had great results. But I can totally see how good cooling would help
@@joshuajohnson5121 Nice, so you slow down before the layer above the interface?
I can imagine that helping a lot.
Then again that PLA I'm using prints pretty hot (225°c) so guess the cooling is definitely working extra.
CONGRATS ON ONE MILLION!! I've been here since 800k, and although it has only been 4 or 5 months (I think), I have really enjoyed seeing you grow. Thanks for always sharing so much information, and inspiring me to get a 3d printer, which I now have. Thanks for inspiring others, too. I think you really have achieved empowering creativity through technology. Good job, Angus, and congratulations once again!!!
cheers!!!
I've been splitting PLA models in my slicer to prevent use of supports, then using dichloromethane to weld them together. The joints are very, very strong and you need microscopic amounts of solvent so it's not a hazard.
These are my favorite types of video, your other common slicer settings video has saved me so much time
I appreciate all of your videos for help, as for this one I feel that the settings don't translate exactly to cura 1 to 1 so as a beginner it's hard to know what to change, it would be cool to have a short video going into the settings of each slicer showing what to change.. again love the videos thank you for all your help!
Very nice!
It remembers me the old days of 3D printing, when you could find models with "baked in supports".
It was a life saver as most support generation was really disastrous back then.
Thank you for everything you do for the 3D Printing community Angus.
Another option I almost always change in PrusaSlicer when I need support is Style: Grid to Snug. I find this support generation to create less waste, is easier to remove, and fails less often.
Love your vids! I'm very exited to finish this one! Also your so close to one million! I will be happy to see my favorite youtube to hit that milestone! Nice haircut btw!
Amazing video again Angus. What a wonderful guide. Loved it. Thanks for putting it together!
Im new to printing but ive been using paint on supports with great success so far
If you can use soluble support then a trick you can use to cut down the cost (soluble is very expensive) is to print your model in the base filament and only print the interface layers with soluble.
This has a side benefit of speeding up your print because you are not doing head changes for every layer.
I've always been impressed with the support material in the Zortrax Z-Suite slicer. It seems to leave the nicest surfaces of the slicers I've used while still being easy to remove.
back when I was using ideamaker I remember that the big "selling point" was the amount of manual control you had over the print result. So I think it's fair to assume ideamaker is designed in a way that it assumes the user will place manual supports as the UI for them is pretty well made.
Hello Angus, I wanted to message you in anticipation of you crossing the 1 million subscriber marker on TH-cam. Whether it’s a big deal for you or not, it’s a very large accomplishment and you have earned it. Congratulations and best wishes.
I loved the video too, found the same results with Bambu slicer. Took me a while to figure out that the threshold angle is backwards on that program haha.
Since this is all needed regardless of gravity orientation (or gravity at all), I'd suggest that it's not a support at all, but a platform. Maybe you'd call it semantics, but a support is to resist gravity, where as a platform provides a surface to print against, which sounds like it's more technically correct. The best kind of correct.
Success with supports for quality and ease of removal relies partially on layer height of the print and the z height gap between the print and the model. There's a ton of power in Cura for playing with this and some tuning with z distance, support interface density, and even x y distance can save a ton of print time, material, and cleanup effort. It seems like you talked about tuning in Prusaslicer but didn't bother to tune the support settings in Cura causing your supports to be more difficult to remove with Cura than it needed to. There's also plugins like manual cylindrical supports that can target the areas specifically needing supports too.
That's a useful overview, Angus! Amount of flags and sliders may repel from exploring, especially if you only see the results in 3 hours. Knowing whats important and what can you achieve helps a lot
I think it's important to know that the major thing that controls the angle of overhang that can be printed unsupported is the ratio of the layer height to the line width (nozzle size) Use a 0.8 nozzle with a 0.08 layer height, you'd be shocked now much hang-out you can get away with. I regularly choose thinner layer heights when I want to avoid using supports.
Haircut looks great, Angus!
IdeaMaker you can add manual supports to specifically cradle and support sharp points like the one in your maker coin.
Congrats on 1,000,000 subscribers! 🥳
There is an option (gradual support infill steps) in Cura to makes the support more dense a few millimeters below it touches the model. It gives much better results without wasting too much material or time.
Great video and I appreciate your dive into the different slicers! I really enjoy using Bambu studio for generating tree supports. At 14:13, it shows your Top Z-distance set to 0 mm. As of course you're aware, increasing this distance even slightly will allow you to remove the support material more easily instead of directly fusing it to the support layer. 0.2mm is the default distance and allows removal. If you want the 0mm distance, a support-specific print material such as Bambu's Support W (printing with multi-filament such as Bambu's AMS) is a great option as it does not lend itself easily to weld to the printed PLA.
When I print D&D minis, I still use MeshMixer, its supports work very well for them. For everything else, I'm still wrestling with Cura to find something that works for most of my models...
I have been playing with Cura's tree supports in the alpha release. I had quite a few failures until i realised that it doesn;t cap off the supports by default. So you can end up with a tall support building up fine but because there was no top on it the thing it was meant to be supporting fails. There is the option to include a top but you need to make sure there is some infil in the supports otherwise there is nothign to build the top on.
Meshmixer's tree supports reign supreme still. What an unrealized gem. On average uses half the material and they come off so nicely.
Congrats on the 1,000,000 subs!!!
Congratulations on achieving 1M subscribers. It's amazing. Well done.
I am surprised you didn't include Simplify3D v5 in the list. S3D v4 had some of the best supports for a very long time and I was wondering if they had gotten any better. I am fully on PrusaSlicer now but I print a lot of things with supports and that may have made v5 worth the money.
I do find S3D is good at supports
Seconding this. Best ever supports.
I also agree as well with the support quality in s3d v4 and v5 i feel has improved it.
Hey dude, I am new in 3D printing and watch your video's, they are great and really helpful, besides that your a great guy, have a nice day 🙂
Re: the tree support in cura I had the same issue with single point contacts and pushed the 'Support floor density' up to 50% and used the support mod to add traditional support towers with the tree support
By far, the absolute best support I have ever seen for fdm is the tree supports in the flashforge oem slicer. I really don't know how they do it, but they come out better than any other fdm tree supports I have seen
Been using Cura trees for a while, and when you play with density and size to get light support. And good interface with the part.
Great video. Ideamaker allows you to manually add custom supports which might address that downward pointy part.
Oh hey I also printed that Egyptian cat statue. But I printed it on its side with supports because I knew I was gonna file it afterwards to make it look like stone. Worked really well though!
I’m surprised no slicer is using local adaptive layer height to increase the printable overhang angle. It shouldn’t be that difficult to have it print the outer edge in two or more layers, and then the rest of the layer at ”normal” layer height. That way you can get away with really steep angles.
I bought my first printer ( Anet A8 ) after seeing your video ( many moon ago )
I bought Simplified 3D after seeing your video
iI now have S3D v 5.01 and i wont change because i can easily predict my result everytime
I think that you should have include it into your test !
I have been using IdeaMaker for a little over a year now and its supports have been the best compared when I used Cura and Prusa Slicer.
i do love the xmas alpha cura trees.... its been wonderful for me so far with lots of tweaking
Nice to see someone include ideamaker. I like the approach in this slicer, although they probably need more feedback from big makers to improve what they have.
Omg hello Angus. Fellow Aussie here. Huge fan of ur vids and really find ur advice helpful. Thank you so much for providing these videos. They help me with my prints a lot.
Just finished a print right now lol. It was the Steinmetz Bicylinder you showed a while back.
Congratulation for 1MILION Subscribers. Keep it up man.
Autodesk Fusion 360 actually has some pretty interesting support features. They might be more suited to SLA than FFF, but it's worth a look.
As an end user, I feel like the Voron team has mastered the "design your parts with no supports" philosophy, going as far as designing built-in brides and parts that are meant to break away or be cut away after the print is done. Truly one of my best printing experience
Great topic, i just started and your guidance is appreciated!
Have you tried PrusaSlicer's Snug supports? It's basically the same support columns, but they keep the supports a lot closer to the model and the interface layer is more cradle-like. I've gotten better surface finish with it and often it's easier to remove. Also, the Cura, PrusaSlicer 2.6 (when it comes out), and probably Bambu Slicer* all base their supports off a fork of Cura's tree supports. Thomas Rahm forked Cura, did a bunch of the work, the Cura and Prusa teams ended up working with them on the supports and are integrating it into their own slicers. Prusa said that their team came down with flu/*vid/etc. late December and they wouldn't get an alpha out in time. *Bambu indicated they found the supports from Cura, so I assume they are also using the same support setup, maybe with different set of settings.
Thank you so much, very good explanation
For me Cura has the best supports. I really tried using Prusa/SuperSlicer because everybody is superhyped about those. They are good but not for me I think. Cura's standard settings for supports are bad. With little tweaking the regular tree support is ok (sometimes doing crazy stuff) but the new christmass beta is amazing without any adjustment.
Around 11:53 you mention printing stands out of support structures only. I've been doing some explorations lately too, and I'm finding I can make remarkably good filter structures by setting my top and bottom thickness to zero, and playing with infill settings and wall thicknesses. It's remarkably accurate.
Yeah, filter medium is a great use case for infill only structures!
@@MakersMuse do you adjust the X/Y or Z offset settings?
@@danbrunermer4295 I did not, I've always used defaults. The bambulab tree supports might benefit, but I feel they won't support the part if they're made to be further away.
Impressive video as always
Thanks for sharing your work with all of us:-)
PrusaSlicer just announced "organic supports" (their implementation of tree supports) and improved automatic detection of areas that actually need support, for the upcoming PrusaSlicer 2.6 (the alpha is already available).
Need to take the printer's part cooling into account too.
Angus is adorable. What a smile :)
Great video! Another thing that helps a lot is the "snug" setting for PrusaSlicer, it saves a lot of print time and material. (Perfect timing 2.6 alfa is released the same weekend as this video😂)
What does snug do?
One more to add to the mix since they recently added fdm support, Lychee
I literally searched for a video like this but couldn't find it. But now i see this, great.
Congrats on 999k subscribers, I can’t wait to see you make it to 1 mil
I've recently started using the Organic supports in PrusaSlicer (and the support painter) and think they are a game changer. They seem equally effective (in my VERY FEW test cases) but seem easier to print they and use less material. While my strong preference is to figure out how to avoid needing supports completely, in the future if I need supports I'm going to at least look at using Organic.
You need to create a short just for the "Print a stand" tip as it is a great bit of lateral thinking.
Great content, really good info, thanks!
curas support interface gap is tied to layer height too. makes it hard to get supports to both support the print and release well. PrusaSlicer's supports are definitely my preference.
I think the Bambu print's supports actually resulted in a better quality final model once you pried it all off. The lines and integrity of the coin surface looked a lot better. I don't mind putting a little work into cleaning it up if it makes the end model better.
Thanks for the video - I've also found IdeaMaker to have the best supports in my experience (ignoring the issue mentioned in the video). I use SuperSlicer mainly but wish the I could dial in the supports as good as I could get them in IdeaMaker.
Imo, I use the flashprint (i have a flashforge creator pro) and the supports do their job pretty dang good
I've used Cura's standard supports in conjunction with the support enforcer/blocker mod (one of them is official Cura, the other isn't, I forget which) mainly through a process of elimination. The dual extrusion printer we have _really_ doesn't like the GCode from Slic3r lineage programs for some reason, and IdeaMaker's supports were just _awful._
I've had some pretty decent results (as in, the workshop said "Yep we can use this in production") when I used the breakaway support material E3D sold a while back but is now discontinued. It stuck to ABS _just_ enough to support it, but it wouldn't weld to it like HIPS would if it's set to the same distance. It's a total pain when it's encased by the model, of course, and I've reminded the CAD guys on a few occasions to not do that.
We have a couple of Markforged Onyx Ones now, and although I wish Eiger had more features and avoided stupid things like creating tiny support towers, it's a really solid package. Sometimes you get these slinky or accordion like things when you peel off the supports.
Friend of mine loves idea maker supports.
i'm finding as i dig more into these settings, is that there's so many it becomes tough to keep things straight. well i did this, now i should do this, this should be done etc. checklists, discussions on what exactly effects what, 4etc, things like that. do you have any things that you have put together like that? a flow-chart of sorts? i had my printer pretty tuned in for printing a specific voxel model with a bunch of tiny over hangs etc, and it still needs to have the profile tuned a little more to perfect it, but i'm at the point where when i change this setting or that setting, it's enough to screw up the prints again. hopefully i'm making sense and if you know of a resource, i would appreciate being pointed twoards it! you have a great day sir!
I am excited for Prusas new organic supports!
as someone new to 3d printing supports have been my biggest headache, so many times ive given up on printing something ive tried to do like 5x times only for the supports to weld onto the print or just impossible to break off regardless of what settings ive tried.
Check out the “snug” support option in PrusaSlicer. Way better than their original supports. I’m surprised they have not made it the default.
I agree. I haven't found a reason to turn it off.
I'll have to check that out. I get way better prints with prusa slicer, but supports always suck...
Yes, "snug" is much easier to remove and less wasteful. I would prefer it the default option as well. Maybe not best for all purposes but especially good when supporting a detail over another layer.
in cura to make the surface cleaner you have to play with the support z distance a bit for traditional supports
And support interface density. That really helps with the quality. I use 90%
The second best option is to build the supports into the model.
I can always turn to your chanel for good reliable answers
did you try the other settings for tree supports on Bambu slicer? I think it could help a lot.
Nice. I need to make my video of my support system. All I will say is I had to print an item which was 969 grams, and CURA wanted to use over 350 grams of support, (I only wanted to use 1 x 1KG spool) and I did supports in 32 grams and had better results.
I find Prusaslicer calculates heights wrong when I combine raft and supports which is usually for first couple of hundred layers of a segmented hydrofoil with leading edge pointed downwards. The supports start mashes into the raft layer. I still get great wing prints though.
12:50 LOL here we are 3 days later and PrusaSlicer 2.6.0-alpha2 is out, "It brings the most anticipated Organic supports..."
Using tree supports on the Bambo X1 work incredibly in my opinion. Had the X1 for just a few weeks, but I will probably never use any other support on this printer. I thought the tree supports in their slicer were one of the greatest benefits!
maybe the tree support for bambuslicer is tuned to the accuracy of the bambu printer so when it's used for an ender 3 the tolerance is too small
@@aronseptianto8142 the accuracy is crazy on the Bambu, I imagine it would be fused on other printers
Been using tree supports in cura and cheap enders for quite a while. 🤷
@@aronseptianto8142 Work fine on my enders. 🤷
@@whopperlover1772 It's no more accurate than any other printer that's been dialed in properly. 🤷
newest cura alpha has some pretty nice supports imho.
No discussion on SNUG vs standard supports in PrusaSlicer? SNUG supports are a game changer 😮
How about a video about designed supports? Support that you design as part of the model. How do you design the support shape and what does the interface to the desired part need to.look like to break away easily yet still give adequate support?
I see that LTT shirt. I picked up the $100 ender 3 from Micro Center and I've been really happy with it.
Ya know even as an expert I always learn. I had never seen that sheath option, and for some huge models where support had to be used it would have saved me.
Microcenter is an unbelievable place that is so widely unknown still it seems like. I am so grateful i live 20 minutes away from one. It's heaven on earth