Bravissimo! Wonderful rendition - stunning first and fifth movements, never before heard so accentuated and balanced between strings and woodwind/brass, especially in the fifth mvt. Orchestra take great care in listening and following the conductor. It’s a joy to observe his „dancing about the music“, much in a league like Petrenko or Klaiber, always the decisive tat ahead of the music, so it evolves along his lead: this performance of the Rheinische is to me very much consistent and generates great breathing and flow, especially in 1st & 5th mvt. Hanks forthilft offering! ❤😊🎉
During the live concert, just before the "Rheinische" symphony, Florin and Maximilian played Ligeti's "Baladă și joc - für zwei Violinen". It was quite neat to see both pieces be played back to back with no transition in the between - not even claps. Very clever move, not captured here. Unfortunately. As always, one more fantastic performance. Thank you hr-Sinfonieorchester for sharing one more outstanding performance.
@@dorette-hi4j The video of the whole concert was streamed on January 24th and is still available to view. @MrBPOfan I found the Ligeti-Schumann 'attacca subito' very effective.
@@dorette-hi4j Hopefully you know acrostic!! navigating the depths of the soul, 1 step at a time, I unfold. Peeling back the layers of doubt, unveiling the truth that shines without. whispers of the heart, a gentle sway, - minus, plus, we multiply Guiding me through each passing day. kindling the flame of hope anew, transient dreams, I dare to pursue. retread I march, with purpose true, 0 the path that leads me through.
Che meraviglia. Esecuzione stupefacente, mai sentito il primo movimento con accenti così pieni di Phathos e al contempo una coordinazione tra gli strumentisti guidati in maniera notevole dal direttore. Il tema d'apertura della Renana è una meraviglia tra le meraviglie. Grazie per questa perla, grazie all'orchestra magnifica e al direttore eccezionale, infine il più grande grazie a Robert Schumann per averci lasciato questa opera sublime.
Wunderschöne Interpretation dieser meisterhaft und romantisch komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen der Streicher, farbenreichen Tönen der Holzbläser und majestätischen Tönen der Blechbläser und des Schlagwerks. Der intelligente Maestro leitet das erfahrene hr-Sinfonieorchester im gut phrasierten Tempo und mit perfekt analysierter Dynamik und Agogik. Danke fürs Hochladen!
If your heart does not swell with emotions with the first bars of this magnificent opening - you´re dead! What a glorious sound - captured so perfectly by the great technical team! Love the warm tone, the tempi not rushed, the musical themes singing and flowing. Schuhmann' life may have been tragic - but his music is not - it´s geniial in the best sense. Bravo to Orchestra, Maestro Carydis and the technical team. Shoutout to concert master Florin Iiescu who is clearly on fire throughout the evening!
When a diligent conductor simply lets the musicians of an excellent orchestra play at ease and enjoy themselves, the result is... the listener greatly enjoys himself. Light tempos and a good stress on the windwood instruments, at times in a very noticeable way, like in 0:58.
PRIMA! Absolutely outstanding brass and woodwind sections. Why the conductor never had them stand for special section ovation?! Schade! But as always, what an incredible orchestra this is. Still #1 in my book! String section: absolute perfection and mastery. How I envy the audiences in Frankfurt.
I don't know how he did it, but the final movement of this piece is upbeat, uplifting, majestic, and lighthearted at the same time. Probably one of my favourite final movements in a symphony ever!
The tempos are way too fast. The production, video quality & camera work is unsurpassed. This remains for me THE top YT channel for extremely high quality classical music. Thank you from California USA!
I have to disagree about the tempos, they are quite normal, not too fast or too slow. However, the performance is pretty sluggish. The Rhenish needs lots of energy and this conductor does not get it for some reason. Just my opinion, FWIW.
Lebhatfe und wunderschöne Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen aller Streicher, milden Tönen aller Holzbläser und vor allem brillanten Tönen aller Blechbläser. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt lebhaft. Der vierte Satz klingt echt feierlich und auch tragisch. Im Kontrast klingt der letzte Satz echt lebhaft und auch begeisternd. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im rhythmischen Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Notaire2’s comment are always written the same, whaterver the work ! What’s the point, then ? Is he paid by hr Orchestre for systematically laudative comments ?
Just listening to this wonderful and graceful and beautiful performance makes I forget about the trouble and annoyances of this transient world
Bravissimo! Wonderful rendition - stunning first and fifth movements, never before heard so accentuated and balanced between strings and woodwind/brass, especially in the fifth mvt. Orchestra take great care in listening and following the conductor. It’s a joy to observe his „dancing about the music“, much in a league like Petrenko or Klaiber, always the decisive tat ahead of the music, so it evolves along his lead: this performance of the Rheinische is to me very much consistent and generates great breathing and flow, especially in 1st & 5th mvt. Hanks forthilft offering! ❤😊🎉
During the live concert, just before the "Rheinische" symphony, Florin and Maximilian played Ligeti's "Baladă și joc - für zwei Violinen". It was quite neat to see both pieces be played back to back with no transition in the between - not even claps. Very clever move, not captured here. Unfortunately.
As always, one more fantastic performance. Thank you hr-Sinfonieorchester for sharing one more outstanding performance.
I hope they upload it as well. And the Bartok/Kurtag Miniatures that opened the concert. Wonderful programming, great playing.
@@dorette-hi4j The video of the whole concert was streamed on January 24th and is still available to view. @MrBPOfan I found the Ligeti-Schumann 'attacca subito' very effective.
@@BsktImp That would be great, but I can't find it on the hr-sinfonie YT site. Where is it?
@@dorette-hi4j Hopefully you know acrostic!!
navigating the depths of the soul,
1 step at a time, I unfold.
Peeling back the layers of doubt,
unveiling the truth that shines without.
whispers of the heart, a gentle sway,
- minus, plus, we multiply
Guiding me through each passing day.
kindling the flame of hope anew,
transient dreams, I dare to pursue.
retread I march, with purpose true,
0 the path that leads me through.
@@dorette-hi4j th-cam.com/video/n1Puw-Gktr0/w-d-xo.html
played this with my uni orchester.
just beautiful ^^ fun to play and beautiful to hear
Magnifique interprétation, d'une grande profondeur romantique et d'une grande précision musicale, vraiment superbe : merci et bravo !
Che meraviglia. Esecuzione stupefacente, mai sentito il primo movimento con accenti così pieni di Phathos e al contempo una coordinazione tra gli strumentisti guidati in maniera notevole dal direttore. Il tema d'apertura della Renana è una meraviglia tra le meraviglie. Grazie per questa perla, grazie all'orchestra magnifica e al direttore eccezionale, infine il più grande grazie a Robert Schumann per averci lasciato questa opera sublime.
Thank you so much for having this channel so I can listen to glorious music from Indianapolis Indiana USA.
Wunderschöne Interpretation dieser meisterhaft und romantisch komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen der Streicher, farbenreichen Tönen der Holzbläser und majestätischen Tönen der Blechbläser und des Schlagwerks. Der intelligente Maestro leitet das erfahrene hr-Sinfonieorchester im gut phrasierten Tempo und mit perfekt analysierter Dynamik und Agogik. Danke fürs Hochladen!
If your heart does not swell with emotions with the first bars of this magnificent opening - you´re dead! What a glorious sound - captured so perfectly by the great technical team! Love the warm tone, the tempi not rushed, the musical themes singing and flowing. Schuhmann' life may have been tragic - but his music is not - it´s geniial in the best sense. Bravo to Orchestra, Maestro Carydis and the technical team. Shoutout to concert master Florin Iiescu who is clearly on fire throughout the evening!
When a diligent conductor simply lets the musicians of an excellent orchestra play at ease and enjoy themselves, the result is... the listener greatly enjoys himself. Light tempos and a good stress on the windwood instruments, at times in a very noticeable way, like in 0:58.
PRIMA! Absolutely outstanding brass and woodwind sections. Why the conductor never had them stand for special section ovation?! Schade! But as always, what an incredible orchestra this is. Still #1 in my book! String section: absolute perfection and mastery. How I envy the audiences in Frankfurt.
I don't know how he did it, but the final movement of this piece is upbeat, uplifting, majestic, and lighthearted at the same time. Probably one of my favourite final movements in a symphony ever!
Wow! I've never heard such an amazing interpretation of the last movement! I'd say "too fast?" but not, it works perfectly! Congratulations!
Well, I've never heard it played like that! Wonderful accents and inspired liberties with tempo - especially that last movement.
truly outstanding performance. bravo
While listening, the number of likes is increasing. I have just enjoyed Constantinos' rendition too.
Impressionant!! Deurien fer una gravació amb aquest director.
Чудесный концерт! Большое спасибо!
So many details! Wow!
The tempos are way too fast. The production, video quality & camera work is unsurpassed. This remains for me THE top YT channel for extremely high quality classical music. Thank you from California USA!
I have to disagree about the tempos, they are quite normal, not too fast or too slow. However, the performance is pretty sluggish. The Rhenish needs lots of energy and this conductor does not get it for some reason. Just my opinion, FWIW.
Una sinfonía netamente alemana. ¡Me encanta!
なんかとてもユニークで好きやなぁ
みんながよくするaccel.をしなかったり（第１楽章）
急に止まったり（第４楽章）
すさまじくaccel.して終わったり（第5楽章）
個性的で気に入りました
C'est encore plus fort à la deuxième écoute 😊
Wow--never heard the inner voices and off-beat melodic figurations so clearly! Very refreshing.
Fantastic conducting.
Genial!!! Danke
Wenn mal der Optimismus Klang hätte, der wäre die dritte Symphonie Schumanns!!!
Lebhatfe und wunderschöne Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen aller Streicher, milden Tönen aller Holzbläser und vor allem brillanten Tönen aller Blechbläser. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt lebhaft. Der vierte Satz klingt echt feierlich und auch tragisch. Im Kontrast klingt der letzte Satz echt lebhaft und auch begeisternd. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im rhythmischen Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Notaire2’s comment are always written the same, whaterver the work ! What’s the point, then ? Is he paid by hr Orchestre for systematically laudative comments ?
amazing very nice ❤
WOW!!!
Super danke
An interesting interpretation!
Veeeeery good !
Schumann, here again demonstrated, was a great symphony composer. The carpers, on small aspects of orchestration, are forgettable. Wonderful music.
No wonder Bruckner had a special affection for Mvmt. IV.
I have noticed asian players in all the major orchestras now in the West, even the Vienna Philharmonic has a violinist who's half-asian.
А в XIX веке было много азиатов-композиторов; евреев!
Is there a trumpet playing along with the alto trombone and horn at the beginning of IV?
Only the two notes that Schumann scored himself.
💝💗💖❤️🩹💜💚💛💙 ..
James Horner listening 1st mov: "Oh! i Think I found Willow's Main Theme" :)
So beautiful and sexy first Flute
Too fast at the end.
molto resoluto...interessant!
Rough ensemble and poorly balanced
says who?
@@katharinabauer4060 Me
@@katharinabauer4060 Says me
Stupid comment