Ppl can clearly see what he meant by hindi can be written in devanagari and bhrami script. Bambi or daam is the right name, but they choose to call it bhrami. And hindi cannot be written in daam lipi(script). This guy is a bhramin, and it's their conspiracy and propaganda to capture all the Buddhist legacy.
@@BeneditaFernandes-o7i bro , just leave it, everything that doesn't suit your ideology is Brahmin agenda... He has published multiple research papers , plus he has to prove its theory in front of other professionals using proven methods. so he knows what exactly he is doing .. plus there were no budhha during indus vally... So please come out
As an English guy I’m not used to seeing such an intelligent interviewer allowing a researcher to explain his work in depth. But I’m not that surprised when it’s from an Indian news channel. Good job. I enjoyed it and hope his research continues to pan out.
@@AyushPal124 lol! U mean migration because invasion theory hasn't been used in the west for decades, it's just india hindutva propagandist using it spreads their fake narrative
What a breath of fresh air. A proper interview, with a journalist who has done her homework is so refreshing after seeing so-called journalists barking like dogs.
There is so much to air on media channels with educated anchors ,but unfortunately they find only Sanjay jha,Sajid rashidi,Vivek Srivastava ,only such useless, irrelevant parasites who simply feed on our minds n time !!
Excellent interview. I am surprised that NEWS18 chose this topic. The anchor who interviewed was very good -- she had done her homework well; and she not only asked relevant questions, but also allowed the scholar being interviewed to answer the questions!
Where have you been all my life News18? You have such a beautiful anchor - asks questions, waits for an answer and smiles (eg incredulous argument time). It is as if she is engaged with the interviewer and rhe subject. Doesnt interject act as a know all. (i had use she because I dont know your name lady. Take a bow)
@@dhadumiaBut one of the pretty decent interviews I have seen from India. Otherwise journalists in India are smug, conceited, arrogant, pr*cks. (Sorry to use this word).
Her knowledge of the subject, evident in her questions is remarkable undoubtedly. So is the willingness to listen as opposed to seeking openings to talk that most anchors are cursed with.
@@Keralaforum lol it's an insul t to use dravidian for indus valley language because dravidian is a term used by Britishers for a language. South indians are Aryans not dravidians. Even I'm South Indian kannadiga. I like all indian languages unlike so called dravidians
@@KeralaforumMr Kerala boy tell me Dravidians natives word for swastika? Indus people one of main symbol was swastika Why Dravidians language has no different word for swastika? It used Sankrit termology for this ( more of original sankrit or with corrupted pronunciation)
Some Un-educated people . Don't Know Difference between science and politics This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
Even Ashoka steles are not inscribed in Sanskrit they were in prakrit , Aramaic and greek. Indus is 2000 years older than Ashoka . If a great emperor who lived right when Sanskrit had it's epics written down didn't bother to use it why do you think it would be Sanskrit 2000 years before it. All the hype for Sanskrit is from political and religious circles not from archeological and scientific circles.
@@JohnDoe19991 He used prakrit because he was a buddhist, he promoted prakrit and pali more because it was the language buddha used to deliver his sermons. There are vedic corpuses which existed atleast 600-700 years before him like Baudhayana Grhya Sutras and such
Came across this paper a while back during some leisure reading and have been aggressively asking people to read it for themselves… its wonderful to finally see this brilliant work getting its due recognition
Its a Logo-Syllabic Script. Claiming it as abugida with accepting pictographs is contradictory... Few brahmi signs are found in Indus Script but no sign of abugida style vowel diactricts found with consistancy. Abugida is a later invention, no abugida scripts found in early bronze age.
@@boxguy-e3r or either call it as Ex Hindu or Sanatan Sub-Continent, bcz whether its North India or South India, Culturally 80% of Asia had same or similar cultural origin..
@@boxguy-e3rwest now wants to degrade india that's why they changed the term for 70 yr it was called indian school bcontinent to show it poor, now when india rising they started calling it South Asia to dikute indian identity Logic india bhrata to kabhi historucally tha hi nahi bas 47 me bana hai
Indus valley sculpture art still exist . The 4000 years old sculpture making process passed on to generation . Even today in many parts of India people are still using that ancient Lost -wax casting technique called Dhokra art. The communities who are making the Dhokra sculpture are Gonds , Dhurwas , Jhera and Khond . These communities speak ancient languages like Parji , Gondi , Kuvi , Kuyi as their mother tongue . So please do researches on these languages of Chhattisgarh , Odisha and Madhya Pradesh. Another language which is close to these languages is Kurukh.
please make some effort to spell hia name cirrectly. i know perhaps you might spell his name as per your descritiom beacuse it is a so called south indian name
@TheMalllu are you out of your mind... What's the delma of South Indians... You are indian and I'm indian too... I don't care whether he his from North, South east or from west, it doesn't my concern. He is indian that's enough for me... I accept my mistake that i didn't research about his name(which is Yajnadevam)... I heard the news and by hearing, it sounded yagnadev so i just wrote yugnadev without any I'll intentions. I am proud of his work okay. By the way please correct the spellings of your comment properly .
Bro Sanskrit is just modified language of pali/prakrit. Made by Buddhist scholars panini and other this language is called as Buddhist hybrid Sanskrit and today's Sanskrit is about 7th to 8th century ad called as classical Sanskrit
@@rajnishraina Yea but dont connect it any veda or anything. Pali Prakrit means prakritic language which later infused into Sanskritic language means Sansarik language.
@rajnishraina i dont think it has ever been refuted that sanskrit is indigenous to india. can u pls point us to a formal source which claims that sanskrit came from outside?
Pali prakrit was not a spoken language.....it was an artificial language derived from spoken sanskrit....there is no Indo European language that avoids compound consonants.....for example prakrit is written as pakit in pali....even english words like procreate have same pra and kri roots....prakrit words like dhamma are not found in any Indian spoken language. All spoken Indian languages are derived fron Sanskrit.
@aqeelkhurshid4860 Pakistan itself is a fake name From Peshawar to Bengal from Kashmir to Kanyakumari all of these areas are india India is a geographical religious cultural civilization thing Pakistan is just term used for muslim country of kpk muslim Punjab sindh and Balochistan And in pakistan Balochistan and Afghanistani are Iranian in origin and Punjabi and Sindhi are Indian in origin
States Department,not Pakistanis and few bitches of South Mumbai-South Delhi cult culture.They belong to hip culture.And may I tell you about hip ,well even they do not lie.
I read these. What's shocking is. This research is supported by linear decipherment. Which is used to decipher most ancient scripts and unknown scripts. Also this also matched with machine learning models and with Z. Linear for the first time.
An Indian deciphered Indus valley language and he announced to disclose next day but he mysteriously died or killed in1990s....despite a credible source where I read it ... unfortunately ...I forget the name of scholar who died...we earlier also seen instances when nuclear scientist ,artist killed in that era.
Can't understand obsession with "south indian" term, u could have just said indian. No north indian scientist or or anything ever introduced as north indian but indian
@@aqeelkhurshid4860retrd 🐒 Indus valley was spread out from region near delhi to gujrat where we have literal ports where saraswati civilization people traded with Egyptians through sea.
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 call it Indian because people just moved away from that area but it continued with them. Sindh and Punjab are Muslims now so it should be called Indian civilization.
@@namastehindustan9879 u doubt so many scholars, scientists, historians & genetics & their findings?? Just bcoz it doesn't suit ur ideology doesn't mean its false.
@@royarnab26 atleast read why they came up with theory. Also it begins around colonization and why do you think they have no bias? Also most of their theories have been debunked
@@namastehindustan9879 There r few things u can't ques coz it defies logic. First of all there is no evidence of OIT but all evidences suggest AMT. The amount of similarities between India's Aryavart & Iran or Airyan is insane. Both Rig Vedic Sanskrit & Avestan have common roots in fact sanskrit have common roots with Ancient Greek & Slavic languages all comes under PIE Language Family.
Hope this goes GREAT. This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
Trying so hard bro. Relax. It needs to go through peer review first no matter how advanced and "sciencey" and cool it sounds. It has to be proved first. Many ancient languages and cultures were similar. If IVC was Hindu it would have been right there.
Major breakthrough 👏👏 I bet that the national international academic lobbyist will do everything to prove this research wrong at any cost. Wonderful work Mr. YagnVed🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wow! I can not believe that i have lived long enough to hear this joyful news. To the host. Your questions are penetrating, pertinent and remarkably evocative of the answers your remarkable guest subsequently provided. I am astonished how much factual information you provided your audience in such a short period. Superp information delivery management, gracious and elegantly done. Greatly appreciate your style. Respectfully yours sincerely, Daniel Wales.
70% of kannada vocabulary comes from sanskrit. only reason it's considered Dravidian is because it follows writing system inspired by tamil. Things like this happen when you are too secluded from your sanskrit speaking brothers in North and have to rely on Tamils to design your own writing system.
There is a Hadappa seal depicting seven sisters. Seven Devis are worshipped even today in rural Rajasthan called BANYASA. People believe that when these Devis travel above us as flight during the night. If one doesn't make a prayer or something. Devis get angry, cursing paralysis to him.
Same folklore I heard about my grandfather's encounter with them while travelling during night in mountains of Uttarakhand and later him getting ill as he mistook those devis for some evil spirits.
@@drsantoshsinghrathore9308 it’s not belongs to Rajasthan, it’s still worshipped all over south, esp. in Tamilnadu as “Sapthakannigal” or YeluKannigal, Which means “Seven Virgins”
How do you know it doesn't belong to Rajasthan, do IVC people told you ? Stop this rant of 'south' and 'south Indian' everywhere , it seems like bullshit . @@albinsuresh7865
@@anakh the IVC can technically be said to have existed in both regions. However, Indian Subcontinent might be the more historically accurate term, as it refers specifically to the unique geological and cultural region where the civilization flourished.
I believe that Vaginadevam may have been the main beneficiary of the 1,487.9 crores spent by the Brahmin Janata Party on Sanskrit. Brahmins are trying to promote themselves by hiding the history of the indigenous people of India, and substandard graduates like him help them for money and drugs. Most scholars agree that the Dravidian language was spoken in the Indus Valley Civilization, and that its script was the Dravidian script. But at a ratio of 200 to 1, a few people like him are spreading unrelated misinformation. But the truth is that Sanskrit scholars have accepted for centuries that Sanskrit does not have its own writing system.
Swastika is one of THE most oldest symbol of Humanity and was there in IVC. To figure out which language IVC spoke, we have to go through all indic languages and find out, whether is there any other word instead of Swastika used by any group of people in subcontinent, if answer is yes, then its a bulls eye. Now put on a headphone and listen them talking whole day, the language of IVC. If answer is no, then Sanskrit was the language of IVC.
@@vanisridhar5509 You are right, but then we need to find out, what was the alternate word for Swastika, which was used by IVC folks. Anyone like to guess ?
@@vanisridhar5509 All major IVC related words in Dravidian linguistic family are loanwords from Indo-Aryan language. The words for wheat, barley, bricks, wagons, camel, rhinos (standard IVC crops, technologies and familiar animals) in Dravidian languages are all Indo-aryan loanwords. The swastika is a sign (No. 148) in the script. Dravidian languages do not have a word for it.
As per west Sanskrit came from outside to India and I was reading somewhere even Tamil came from outside First west tried to disassociate Sanskrit from India now they are trying same for Tamil, coz in their head if any thing is advanced or good can't be from Indian subcontinent as per the laws of Superiority and racism. We Indian's keep fighting between ourself and in the end their end goal is clear.
If it's really an extraordinary work, he would have published it in a peer-reviewed journal and the entire scientific world would have celebrated it. Nothing of that kind happened. So, it's obviously just an I-pat-your-back and you-pat-mine arrangement with the Sanghis. Definitely no Bharat Ratna. Probably he deserves a cup of gaumutra!
@@Arjun00100-s got offended after listening how much funny death jesus got 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Or aghora eat your mom pu.. ssy 😍😘I think so That's why you have Arjun Hindu Name 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
I wish him so much luck in his fascinating research into this very ancient language of the Indian Subcontinent. I have always hoped that one day not only this script could be read, but that the language itself of the Indus Valley civilisations might again be understood - perhaps one day it will be🙏
The writing direction was left to right on the seals. However since these are seals, the language reading dirdcgion must have been from ldft to right because the seals are a mirror impression of the writing they produce when stamped into wax.
The journalist herself was also very keenly interested in learning about the research. This field of research isn't very easy for a normal person to understand, but both tried their best to simplify it for the viewers.
I read these. What's shocking is. This research is supported by linear decipherment. Which is used to decipher most ancient scripts and unknown scripts. Also this also matched with machine learning models and with Z. Linear for the first time.
South Asia term is used to specify the location of the region in Asia Do u think it will fit here?? : West Asia, Central Asia,North Asia, Bharat,East Asia,Southeast Asia Bharat is used to show the Country of India with its modern borders now
@@boxguy-e3r the time and event you're are describing were related to Bharat only. But the way you're are creating narrative to hid Bharat that is not right. It is similar like if I call you with your continent name rather than specific name.
@@boxguy-e3rBharat is as old as it's civilization. Only this name was famous among Brit , Arab and others at that time. So before making Vedio correct your knowledge first
Nice work Yagna Devam and good interview with to the point questioning. Please keep up the good work. Thank you. Nice use of time during the covid while whole world was running around scared.
Bro , You are saying like Indus valley civilization people used to have a dialect of Vedic people . Than , Why did not Researchers find any traces of vedic people genetic ( DNA ) in those skeletons founded in Indus valley civilization sites ?
Sindhu comes from Tamil language , my dear- the name for a flowing poem, a genre of song and a feminine name for a river. Sanskrit does not ascribe feminine names for rivers. Sanskrit comes from a Patrirachical society. Their names are generally masculine. One example is the name Brahma Putra. Even though names of rivers In India are all feminine, and the mighty river that flows through north east and Bangladesh has many native names in the locality where it flows - all famine names - in official records , named as Brahma Putra , a masculine name. Funny!
Bro , You are saying like Indus valley civilization people used to have a dialect of Vedic people . Than , Why did not Researchers find any traces of vedic people genetic ( DNA ) in those skeletons founded in Indus valley civilization sites ?
@mscreationworks5787 hindus and other indic religion burn the corpse how can u get to know DNA of someone ? Dna data is very limited in indian subcontinent how can u make such big claims
As a fellow sanskrit speaker, I am very prod of this effort by Indians. We should keep proving that everything is related to Sanskrit, because we know how to prove LHS equal to RHS. Jai Hind
🤔Another one not many will talk about is how one sentence can have several meaning to it, or a hole different terminology of from original at the same time. Example🤔Using it in a different context can make it a joke every one laughs or a insult, a wise rebuttal, a foolish remark.🤔A reference to, with two meaning original ues, plus over time reference that takes on a different message but aware of original message.😌😏Just putting that out there and very difficult but with enough evidence undeniable just a thought about such things. 👍Thank you for the video.👍
Reading the comments on this video made me realize that most people have zero understanding of this subject. Yagnadevam is too nice to say this, but the "scholars" of Indology don't have the expertise to review his paper. The expert review needs to be done by fellow cryptologists. That aside, it is very important to explain the whole premise here. The whole subject of comparative linguistics was born when Europeans realized that classical European languages like Greek & Latin were related to Sanskrit. They painstakingly created a model that found a way to connect these and other related languages through time. However, they made many assumptions in the process- the foremost being that the Rigveda was composed at most in 1500 BCE. There is no proof whatsoever for this assumption. If this assumption is false, the whole Indo-European language tree as constructed becomes false (very important- the languages are still related, only there is no Proto-Indo-European at the root of the tree). Coming to the Indus script, every single attempt to "decipher" the script is really just guess work. There's nothing wrong guessing, but your guesses have to be applicable universally to every single character in the script. Every work that was done before this basically fails at this. There was no mathematical grounding to any of the previous work (and hence my original point about those folks not being qualified to review his paper). Yangadevam's work is based on a firm mathematical foundation. Which means that his decipherment is true in the original sense of the word- he has figured out the cipher of the Indus script.
Don’t you think the theory that the Indo-European language originated in Russia is somewhat half-baked? Recent studies suggest that the Indo-European language originated in western Iran. Genetic studies have discovered a Caucasus Hunter-Gatherers component that spread to the steppe and a similar Iranian Neolithic component (in the Zagros) that spread eastward. This component was found in Bronze Age Anatolia without steppe ancestry. The Yamnaya were roughly 1/3 CHG or Iran_Neolithic. Iran_Neolithic ancestry comprises 40-60% of all modern Indians. Don’t you think Iranian Neolithic farmers migrated toward Russia around 7,000-8,000 years ago, forming the Yamnaya culture? Perhaps these people originated from Mehrgarh or Bhirrana in the Indian subcontinent, as India and Iran were better suited for human settlement 10,000 years ago than Russia, which experienced a cold and temperate climate heavily influenced by the last Ice Age. The cow is significant in Indo-Aryan culture. The Indo-Europeans were central to the domestication of the bull/cow, the invention of the wheeled wagon, dairying practices, and milk consumption. However, the cow was domesticated in the Indus Valley Civilization over 9,000 years ago and in Anatolia separately. If one believes the steppe people domesticated the horse and then entered India, this migration never affected the genetic lineage of Indian cow breeds. Cattle genetics conclusively prove that no admixture of Taurine cattle into India has ever occurred. It seems silly to think that Indo-Aryans came to India without a single cow. If we look at Russia, the Proto-Uralic language formed around the same time as the Indo-European language in relatively close proximity without any connection between them. In the Caucasus region or near the Black Sea, there are unrelated Kartvelian languages that formed around the same time or earlier than Indo-European. Do you think the Burushaski language in northern Pakistan might be related to a pre-Proto-Indo-European language, given that haplogroup R2 is significantly present among the Burusho people? Haplogroup R2 is estimated to have emerged around 15,000 years ago, likely in the Indian subcontinent, while R1 originated in Central Asia and R itself in West and South Asia. It seems likely that the Indo-European language originated in Iran, the Indus Valley, or the BMAC culture.
@ Unlike the linguists and archeologists, I’m not one to rush to conclusions based on scant data. But yes, the whole paradigm of the origin of IE languages is built on very shaky grounds. Those who have built their careers based on this framework are going to make sure that any outside attempt to shed light on this shoddiness will be painted as unscientific (killing irony in a thousand ways). The way they’ve tried to weaponize genetics is another thing. Pay attention- there is no correlation between the Steppe genome and languages. None. Yet, the claim is made that the Sanskrit language was brought into India by the Steppe people at around- wait for it- 1500 BCE. Circular logic. I’ve always said this- if every major university in the US institutes a panel made up of Engineers, Physicists and Mathematicians to review the scientific claims made by their linguistics and archeology departments, many careers would be finished.
@@Kalki0025 Looking at this from a different perspective since Harappan language can never be deciphered with accuracy and there will always be debated by one group of the other. - Yamnaya are the result of this influx from Steppe and Caucasus region. This is genetically proven and this population mixed with Indo-Iranian before moving east to Harappan. Yamnaya are nomads and herders. They primarily are herders and only 10-30% of their gene is in mtDNA (maternal chain) of Indian population. North being the most and south being the least. I think the genetic study suggest the other way as you mentioned in your message. ~70% of our mtDNA comes from Ancient Indians who migrated from Africa around 60,000 years back. The Ancient North Indians after the Harappan demise is a mixture of Ancient Indians + Steppe + Harappan. Ancient South Indians are a mixture of Harappan + Ancient Indians. Today’s population is a mixture of ANI and ASI. - Harappan language can never be deciphered with accuracy and there will always be debated by one group of the other. But based on archeology, genetic and cultural findings we can say Harappans cannot be Steppe because of several gaps - herders .vs agriculturalists, lack of cows in Harappa sites, lack of tiger mentioned in Rig Veda, cremation differences between Harappan and Steppe, etc. . Also, one symbol that predominantly used is Fish as meen in dravidian language. No mention of such things in Vedas. So, The list goes on and on. Based on these facts, the predominant agreed upon theory is Harappan language is most likely Elamite and Proto-Dravidian. - w.r.t the cow topic - There is a gene mutation called 13910T that originated somewhere in Europe around 7500 years back and because of this gene Homo Sapians were able to digests milk. Even today, people in north consume milk based diet more than the south. North consumes lesser meat than the south because they get their fair share of protein with milk. In Harappa sites, there is no mention of cows and archeology also proves they had bull but not cows. Cow being so sacred in Rig Veda, but no mention in Harappan sites. This is a small list, with all this conflicts between culture and archeology it is funny to see someone with no qualifications doing some side project during Covid to come up with a theory. I am not sure why are bringing such people to talk!!!
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 yes, that will come back and unify sooner or later...your "Stan" will become a blip on the Indian timeline...don't be too confident. It's a failed state, will disappear eventually.
"Indian timeline" haha Son, India is in the timeline of Sindh. The timeline of people of Pakistan began with Indus valley civilization, along the way Sindh decided to give this subcontinent an identity. Sindh is still going along with Punjab. 90 % of all sindhis are Pakistani citizens 70% of all Punjabis are Pakistani citizens Where do the words India and Hindustan come from?
An Indian telling his father what culture and food are. India's very identity is owed to Sindh. You can't tell your father how to walk. Indus valley civilization is the civilisation of Sindh and Punjab. It predates any notion of Vedas and abrahamic religions. After starting this glorious Indus valley civilization, Sindh and Punjab carry on for centuries, Sindh then decided to give an identity to this subcontinent. No matter how hard you try you'll always be a child of Sindh. I am a half Sindhi and half Punjabi. I look at India as one of my children
I've seen the full interview and videos on his channel. As a computer science engineering graduate myself i have dabbled a bit in NLP. I was initially skeptic since it goes against the established mainstream view. However his explanation is pretty convincing and his methodology is legit. Can't wait for more people to replicate his findings and take the research forward. Really interesting stuff if it turns out right. A lot of our history will need to be rewritten and timelines re-evaluated if his results are substantial. Amazing time to live
@@CHRS-ri5mfTry explaining it to our congress/left/ islamic cabal insode India who believe that India has nothing to offer the world in science or technology. 😂
Big Salute for Alexander Cunningham... Religious ppl can never been able to decipher this script.. for Ashokan Inscriptions would hv done the same it would never decipherd
This Research is great. Some Un-educated people . TAMILS Don't Know Difference between science and politics This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
Well, it's rookie mistake* Well It's implied that they meant Indus Valley Civilization*. "It's in Pakistan" No, some of its excavated sites are along the Indus River Basin in India & Pakistan*. A majority of IVC sites exist along the now dried up river Basin east of Indus called Ghaggar-Hakra. The distribution of Archeological Sites reveals the whole picture. Of all the IVC sites: Region No. of Mature Sites Percentage Hakra Basin (Haryana, Indian Punjab, north Rajasthan, Cholistan) 360 32% Gujarat,India 310 28% Baluchistan 129 11% Sind 108 9% Pakistan’s Punjab 60 5% Others 173 15% Total 1140 100% More the 60 percent of site lie not along the Indus but the Ghaggar Hakra Basin (Saraswati).
@@Nozarks1 Rakhigarhi(greater than Harrapa, mohanjodaro's area combined) , Bhirrana, Binjor, Dholavira, Lothal, Kalibangan . So the expanse of IVC does not map 1:1 on Pakistans political border.
Great work Yadnya Devam ji, and many thanks for this. Where is the paper published? and criticism to CNN on calling it South Asia and unnecessary saying its political.
Please don't say Dravidian language, the word Dravidian itself came from Sanskrit, we can use "Tamil- Bhrami" which means mother of all south Indian languages
@@boxguy-e3rvedic civilization existed well before to the understanding we were rubbed by the then British religious groups. They had Aryan invasion theory, which is debunked. Then had Aryan migration theory, also debunked. However, the Yamnaya invasion theory still holds the credit as it speaks of Indians spreading across western planes rather than the other way around. So vedic civilization existed well before.
@farrukhnaqvi3424 What you say makes sense but the pictures of the seals show the symbols, like the bowl which appear at the end of 'sentences' cramped up on the left, suggesting that they would appear on the right upon stamping.
So nice to listen to Shri Yagna ji. Better still to see such dedication to a cause. More power to intellect returning to our quest for knowing what we are.
I like this journalist, she's asking succinct, meaningful questions which shows she has done her research regarding the topic. Fantastic. Glad there are news channels doing this these days.
@@Nozarks1you are just looking at Indus river, that's not how it works. The civilization was between Sarswati and Sindhu. And major sites are found in Haryana and Gujarat than Pakistan. Talking about the human settlements.
@@millennialmind9507 Mohenjodarro and Harappa are in Pakistan. Indus River is in Pakistan. That’s like Pakistanis saying Taj Mahal is in Pakistan just because other Moghul structures are in Pakistan, or it is culturally Pakistani. Saying that would be ridiculous.
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 THERE was NO pakistan at that time. "Sindh" itself is a Sanskrit word. there was only Ancient India. pakistan is Son of INDIA. born in 1947 😂
When most of the people started to look out for reels during covid , this guy started to decipher indus code. 😊
😂😂😂😂😂 TruE
Ppl can clearly see what he meant by hindi can be written in devanagari and bhrami script. Bambi or daam is the right name, but they choose to call it bhrami. And hindi cannot be written in daam lipi(script).
This guy is a bhramin, and it's their conspiracy and propaganda to capture all the Buddhist legacy.
@@BeneditaFernandes-o7i bro , just leave it, everything that doesn't suit your ideology is Brahmin agenda...
He has published multiple research papers , plus he has to prove its theory in front of other professionals using proven methods. so he knows what exactly he is doing .. plus there were no budhha during indus vally... So please come out
@@BeneditaFernandes-o7ilooking from Christian mindset?
lol he didn’t do shit
As an English guy I’m not used to seeing such an intelligent interviewer allowing a researcher to explain his work in depth. But I’m not that surprised when it’s from an Indian news channel. Good job. I enjoyed it and hope his research continues to pan out.
Aah, you probably have not viewed other channels.
@@jamilabagash149 other channels are a racket, this is intelligent interviewer
Hold ur horses, did u check the authenticity of what he is saying?
Not everything that sounds intelligent is guaranteed to be authentic 😅
Rakhigarhi dna test debunked aryan invasion theory
@@AyushPal124 lol! U mean migration because invasion theory hasn't been used in the west for decades, it's just india hindutva propagandist using it spreads their fake narrative
What a breath of fresh air. A proper interview, with a journalist who has done her homework is so refreshing after seeing so-called journalists barking like dogs.
True that.
There is so much to air on media channels with educated anchors ,but unfortunately they find only Sanjay jha,Sajid rashidi,Vivek Srivastava ,only such useless, irrelevant parasites who simply feed on our minds n time !!
@@oundhakar so called secu journalists try to defame and undermine Hindu culture , it seems .
That’s right , she was barking like a dog.
Excellent interview. I am surprised that NEWS18 chose this topic. The anchor who interviewed was very good -- she had done her homework well; and she not only asked relevant questions, but also allowed the scholar being interviewed to answer the questions!
glad to know its urdu
@@riddunyra4373what?? Say clear bro
Lmfaooo, jihadis at it again. Nvm you son of littlr foid, you may cope.@@riddunyra4373
@@riddunyra4373 bro shut up! This ain't Urdu...
Where have you been all my life News18? You have such a beautiful anchor - asks questions, waits for an answer and smiles (eg incredulous argument time). It is as if she is engaged with the interviewer and rhe subject. Doesnt interject act as a know all. (i had use she because I dont know your name lady. Take a bow)
You seem quite enamored 😁. The interview was good though I have to admit
@@dhadumiaBut one of the pretty decent interviews I have seen from India. Otherwise journalists in India are smug, conceited, arrogant, pr*cks. (Sorry to use this word).
The video is on indus script, in case you are still interested
@guharup absolutely. I have been following the Indus Script issue for a long time..
Her knowledge of the subject, evident in her questions is remarkable undoubtedly. So is the willingness to listen as opposed to seeking openings to talk that most anchors are cursed with.
As a fellow Kannadiga I always thought this was Sanskrit. I am very proud that another Kannadiga & Bharathiya proved it.
❤❤❤❤
@@Keralaforum lol it's an insul t to use dravidian for indus valley language because dravidian is a term used by Britishers for a language. South indians are Aryans not dravidians. Even I'm South Indian kannadiga. I like all indian languages unlike so called dravidians
@@Keralaforum dravidians are not different like hit ler. So Dravidians want to create pure race like him lol
It is definitely not Dravidian... Don't even think about it...😂😂@@Keralaforum
@@KeralaforumMr Kerala boy tell me Dravidians natives word for swastika? Indus people one of main symbol was swastika
Why Dravidians language has no different word for swastika? It used Sankrit termology for this ( more of original sankrit or with corrupted pronunciation)
Some Un-educated people . Don't Know Difference between science and politics
This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
True
I am confused, Indus people spoke Earlier forms or sanskrit or not?
Even Ashoka steles are not inscribed in Sanskrit they were in prakrit , Aramaic and greek. Indus is 2000 years older than Ashoka . If a great emperor who lived right when Sanskrit had it's epics written down didn't bother to use it why do you think it would be Sanskrit 2000 years before it. All the hype for Sanskrit is from political and religious circles not from archeological and scientific circles.
True
@@JohnDoe19991 He used prakrit because he was a buddhist, he promoted prakrit and pali more because it was the language buddha used to deliver his sermons. There are vedic corpuses which existed atleast 600-700 years before him like Baudhayana Grhya Sutras and such
Came across this paper a while back during some leisure reading and have been aggressively asking people to read it for themselves… its wonderful to finally see this brilliant work getting its due recognition
Many many thanks to Yagna Devam. Excellent job and excellent contribution to ancient History.
In the comment section, people are not countering his point logically; they are just saying his work is wrong.
People will deny everything that doesn't match their agenda, so let the learners learn and the deniers deny.
Jai Shree Ram 🚩🚩🗿
Its a Logo-Syllabic Script. Claiming it as abugida with accepting pictographs is contradictory... Few brahmi signs are found in Indus Script but no sign of abugida style vowel diactricts found with consistancy. Abugida is a later invention, no abugida scripts found in early bronze age.
He gave same slgn value to 10+ different looking indus signs, which is not possible.
@@manojjadhav7518 Pashupatinath?🤭
It's not South Asia instead it's in Indian subcontinent.
Do u think that word will fit here??
North Asia,West Asia,East Asia, Southeast Asia, Central Asia??
Both are the term for the same region
@@boxguy-e3r or either call it as Ex Hindu or Sanatan Sub-Continent, bcz whether its North India or South India, Culturally 80% of Asia had same or similar cultural origin..
In keeladi excavation 0 religious proof found 🤣🤡 @@truthfinder8652
@@boxguy-e3rwest now wants to degrade india that's why they changed the term for 70 yr it was called indian school bcontinent to show it poor, now when india rising they started calling it South Asia to dikute indian identity
Logic india bhrata to kabhi historucally tha hi nahi bas 47 me bana hai
Indus valley sculpture art still exist . The 4000 years old sculpture making process passed on to generation . Even today in many parts of India people are still using that ancient Lost -wax casting technique called Dhokra art. The communities who are making the Dhokra sculpture are Gonds , Dhurwas , Jhera and Khond . These communities speak ancient languages like Parji , Gondi , Kuvi , Kuyi as their mother tongue . So please do researches on these languages of Chhattisgarh , Odisha and Madhya Pradesh. Another language which is close to these languages is Kurukh.
So proud that our civilization's language finally got deciphered. A lot of thanks to Yugnadev. Hats of bro
People like you are problem for this nation,who believe everything just by watching one perceptive.
please make some effort to spell hia name cirrectly. i know perhaps you might spell his name as per your descritiom beacuse it is a so called south indian name
@TheMalllu are you out of your mind... What's the delma of South Indians... You are indian and I'm indian too... I don't care whether he his from North, South east or from west, it doesn't my concern. He is indian that's enough for me... I accept my mistake that i didn't research about his name(which is Yajnadevam)... I heard the news and by hearing, it sounded yagnadev so i just wrote yugnadev without any I'll intentions. I am proud of his work okay.
By the way please correct the spellings of your comment properly .
@PoonamSingh-jp7zd shouldn't we need to bother to check sometimes atleast if not possible evevrytime then? my problem is people dont care much.
Lol you didn't care enough to check your mistake in the comments
The hypocrisy
Yagna Devam's work has debunked the myth that Sanskrit came from outside and that it was not indigenous to India.
Bro Sanskrit is just modified language of pali/prakrit. Made by Buddhist scholars panini and other this language is called as Buddhist hybrid Sanskrit and today's Sanskrit is about 7th to 8th century ad called as classical Sanskrit
@@Sheshnāga-x1kWhatever languages do evolve, the point is sanskrit like languages evolved in India and did not come from outside.
@@rajnishraina Yea but dont connect it any veda or anything. Pali Prakrit means prakritic language which later infused into Sanskritic language means Sansarik language.
@rajnishraina i dont think it has ever been refuted that sanskrit is indigenous to india. can u pls point us to a formal source which claims that sanskrit came from outside?
Pali prakrit was not a spoken language.....it was an artificial language derived from spoken sanskrit....there is no Indo European language that avoids compound consonants.....for example prakrit is written as pakit in pali....even english words like procreate have same pra and kri roots....prakrit words like dhamma are not found in any Indian spoken language. All spoken Indian languages are derived fron Sanskrit.
South asia term is used by Pakistani
It's indian subcontinent
India and Hindustan, words that come from a river and province of Pakistan, Sindh and river Indus respectively
@aqeelkhurshid4860 Pakistan itself is a fake name
From Peshawar to Bengal from Kashmir to Kanyakumari all of these areas are india
India is a geographical religious cultural civilization thing
Pakistan is just term used for muslim country of kpk muslim Punjab sindh and Balochistan
And in pakistan Balochistan and Afghanistani are Iranian in origin and Punjabi and Sindhi are Indian in origin
States Department,not Pakistanis and few bitches of South Mumbai-South Delhi cult culture.They belong to hip culture.And may I tell you about hip ,well even they do not lie.
@@avidreader100 Pakistan itself part of Indian subcontinent
I would include at least Persia as well. Persian script is also right to left.
Good to see an anchor ask relevant questions and wait for an answer. Kudos to the researcher as well.
As a history teacher in Pakistan this is very interesting 👍
So do u agree, u were hindu earlier and converted forcefully?
Please don't tell anyone in Pakistan that these symbols are related to hindu gods.. the sites may get desecrated
I read these. What's shocking is. This research is supported by linear decipherment. Which is used to decipher most ancient scripts and unknown scripts. Also this also matched with machine learning models and with Z. Linear for the first time.
Also this also Supported by MIT and Other human sciences Scholars
Hence proved hinduism is older than 10000 years 😊😊 rundra was a suprime god during the dweta yug,and satyug so we can see his evidence
An Indian deciphered Indus valley language and he announced to disclose next day but he mysteriously died or killed in1990s....despite a credible source where I read it ... unfortunately ...I forget the name of scholar who died...we earlier also seen instances when nuclear scientist ,artist killed in that era.
Kindly mention the name of the South Indian
Need more information.. who was it?
Can't understand obsession with "south indian" term, u could have just said indian.
No north indian scientist or or anything ever introduced as north indian but indian
@@Aspirant24-uy3zp right man
Sarrr we are educated sarr South Indian sarr 🤡@@chagotisurendrakumar840
An Indian deciphering Indian sindhu civilization , perfect lovestory !!
Indus valley civilization is the civilisation of Sindh and Punjab
@aqeelkhurshid4860 tell me you are an idiot without telling me .
It's Saraswati Civilization.
@@aqeelkhurshid4860retrd 🐒 Indus valley was spread out from region near delhi to gujrat where we have literal ports where saraswati civilization people traded with Egyptians through sea.
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 call it Indian because people just moved away from that area but it continued with them. Sindh and Punjab are Muslims now so it should be called Indian civilization.
Why do we still use the term Indo-Aryan?? It is Indian, without any hyphenation.
Indo Iranian or Indo aryan is the language family which probably dates back to proto indo iranian mother of all languages in this family
@@akumar9684it is hypothesis. No such language exist
@@namastehindustan9879 u doubt so many scholars, scientists, historians & genetics & their findings?? Just bcoz it doesn't suit ur ideology doesn't mean its false.
@@royarnab26 atleast read why they came up with theory. Also it begins around colonization and why do you think they have no bias?
Also most of their theories have been debunked
@@namastehindustan9879 There r few things u can't ques coz it defies logic. First of all there is no evidence of OIT but all evidences suggest AMT. The amount of similarities between India's Aryavart & Iran or Airyan is insane. Both Rig Vedic Sanskrit & Avestan have common roots in fact sanskrit have common roots with Ancient Greek & Slavic languages all comes under PIE Language Family.
Hope this goes GREAT. This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
Trying so hard bro. Relax. It needs to go through peer review first no matter how advanced and "sciencey" and cool it sounds. It has to be proved first. Many ancient languages and cultures were similar. If IVC was Hindu it would have been right there.
@@AbrarTheQureshiit's in Review by MIT
Major breakthrough 👏👏 I bet that the national international academic lobbyist will do everything to prove this research wrong at any cost. Wonderful work Mr. YagnVed🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Wow! I can not believe that i have lived long enough to hear this joyful news.
To the host.
Your questions are penetrating, pertinent and remarkably evocative of the answers your remarkable guest subsequently provided.
I am astonished how much factual information you provided your audience in such a short period.
Superp information delivery management, gracious and elegantly done.
Greatly appreciate your style.
Respectfully yours sincerely,
Daniel Wales.
Well done Yagna Devam. Keep at it. Jai Bharat mata.
I am proud kannadiga and proud of my language. I am proud of yagna deva who is kannadiga who had deciphered Indus valley language.
❤
70% of kannada vocabulary comes from sanskrit. only reason it's considered Dravidian is because it follows writing system inspired by tamil.
Things like this happen when you are too secluded from your sanskrit speaking brothers in North and have to rely on Tamils to design your own writing system.
He is a pure sangi
@@goat5944Do you have any knowledge on language. By your logic, we can also say, your kannada came from our Tulu not Tamil.
@@goat5944boomer aunty
There is a Hadappa seal depicting seven sisters. Seven Devis are worshipped even today in rural Rajasthan called BANYASA. People believe that when these Devis travel above us as flight during the night. If one doesn't make a prayer or something. Devis get angry, cursing paralysis to him.
Same folklore I heard about my grandfather's encounter with them while travelling during night in mountains of Uttarakhand and later him getting ill as he mistook those devis for some evil spirits.
@@drsantoshsinghrathore9308 it’s not belongs to Rajasthan, it’s still worshipped all over south, esp. in Tamilnadu as “Sapthakannigal” or YeluKannigal, Which means “Seven Virgins”
How do you know it doesn't belong to Rajasthan, do IVC people told you ? Stop this rant of 'south' and 'south Indian' everywhere , it seems like bullshit . @@albinsuresh7865
सात आसरा
Wow so all over Bharat it’s same east west south north 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Why does the anchor use the term south asia,it is Indian Subcontinent.
I hope some one informs her and asks her to change in future. 🙏
Because the Indus valley civilisation flourished in south asia instead of the Indian sub-continent?
@@anakh the IVC can technically be said to have existed in both regions. However, Indian Subcontinent might be the more historically accurate term, as it refers specifically to the unique geological and cultural region where the civilization flourished.
South Asia is new term,
Indian subcontinent is geographical term pertaining to tectonic plates@@anakh
I believe that Vaginadevam may have been the main beneficiary of the 1,487.9 crores spent by the Brahmin Janata Party on Sanskrit. Brahmins are trying to promote themselves by hiding the history of the indigenous people of India, and substandard graduates like him help them for money and drugs.
Most scholars agree that the Dravidian language was spoken in the Indus Valley Civilization, and that its script was the Dravidian script. But at a ratio of 200 to 1, a few people like him are spreading unrelated misinformation. But the truth is that Sanskrit scholars have accepted for centuries that Sanskrit does not have its own writing system.
India is not limited to current Indian border on map just, it includes Pakistan, Nepal also...
Best wishes to the team trying to decipher the Indus Valley Script.......🙏
Kudos to the anchor from News18 - She is very well informed but above all very respectful. Hardly seen on News18 anymore.
Her using South Asia is disgusting and a way to erase indian history and influence across the all eras.
Swastika is one of THE most oldest symbol of Humanity and was there in IVC.
To figure out which language IVC spoke, we have to go through all indic languages and find out, whether is there any other word instead of Swastika used by any group of people in subcontinent, if answer is yes, then its a bulls eye.
Now put on a headphone and listen them talking whole day, the language of IVC.
If answer is no, then Sanskrit was the language of IVC.
Yes
😂🤣 Sanskrit was not even entered india at that time.
@@vanisridhar5509
You are right, but then we need to find out, what was the alternate word for Swastika, which was used by IVC folks.
Anyone like to guess ?
@@vanisridhar5509 All major IVC related words in Dravidian linguistic family are loanwords from Indo-Aryan language. The words for wheat, barley, bricks, wagons, camel, rhinos (standard IVC crops, technologies and familiar animals) in Dravidian languages are all Indo-aryan loanwords.
The swastika is a sign (No. 148) in the script. Dravidian languages do not have a word for it.
@@kalpeshkumarpatel380 That's a letter in indus script. It's not a swastika symbol.
As per west Sanskrit came from outside to India and I was reading somewhere even Tamil came from outside
First west tried to disassociate Sanskrit from India now they are trying same for Tamil, coz in their head if any thing is advanced or good can't be from Indian subcontinent as per the laws of Superiority and racism.
We Indian's keep fighting between ourself and in the end their end goal is clear.
This man is a hero. He turned the despair of Covid into ground breaking research. Truly inspiring!
This is an extraordinary work.He should get a Bharat Ratna.
If it's really an extraordinary work, he would have published it in a peer-reviewed journal and the entire scientific world would have celebrated it. Nothing of that kind happened. So, it's obviously just an I-pat-your-back and you-pat-mine arrangement with the Sanghis. Definitely no Bharat Ratna. Probably he deserves a cup of gaumutra!
@@Manithan123 came here I will gave your jesus 4 pins in hands and feet once again 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@yashtyagi8033you came here I will give you Aghora's Two Angoor, Eat It In the Name Of Shivarpanam 😂,
@@Arjun00100-s got offended after listening how much funny death jesus got 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Or aghora eat your mom pu.. ssy 😍😘I think so
That's why you have Arjun Hindu Name 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Definitely it will go up to the journal. Why are you so critical in the beginning?
Looks like you drank a cup of 🐖 Pee.
@@Manithan123
A great logic effort by sri yagna devam in deciphering
A Great job done for every Indian to be proud of.
I wish him so much luck in his fascinating research into this very ancient language of the Indian Subcontinent. I have always hoped that one day not only this script could be read, but that the language itself of the Indus Valley civilisations might again be understood - perhaps one day it will be🙏
1.written Right to left ok ,but page down to up
2.some tablets are day to day rituals
3.most of them symbolize way of life
4.vedic agriculture
What a breath of fresh air.
A VERY BEAUTIFUL QUESTION THE LADY ASKED ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE LANGUAGE AND SCRIPT. SENSIBLE
The writing direction was left to right on the seals. However since these are seals, the language reading dirdcgion must have been from ldft to right because the seals are a mirror impression of the writing they produce when stamped into wax.
The journalist herself was also very keenly interested in learning about the research. This field of research isn't very easy for a normal person to understand, but both tried their best to simplify it for the viewers.
I so badly want to understand. ❤🙏 Thank you.
I read these. What's shocking is. This research is supported by linear decipherment. Which is used to decipher most ancient scripts and unknown scripts. Also this also matched with machine learning models and with Z. Linear for the first time.
The paper has been published.
@@govindindurkar3100 where are the translated scripts?
Not south Asia. It was Bharat. Correct your vocabulary
Bro it's Liberal news channel what do you expect 😂
No one used that world during Indus Valley Civilization
Bharat word comes from only Vedas
South Asia term is used to specify the location of the region in Asia
Do u think it will fit here?? :
West Asia, Central Asia,North Asia, Bharat,East Asia,Southeast Asia
Bharat is used to show the Country of India with its modern borders now
@@boxguy-e3r the time and event you're are describing were related to Bharat only. But the way you're are creating narrative to hid Bharat that is not right. It is similar like if I call you with your continent name rather than specific name.
@@boxguy-e3rBharat is as old as it's civilization. Only this name was famous among Brit , Arab and others at that time. So before making Vedio correct your knowledge first
Nice work Yagna Devam and good interview with to the point questioning. Please keep up the good work. Thank you. Nice use of time during the covid while whole world was running around scared.
Great achievement by Yagna Devam to decipher Indus valley language
What an Interview..!
Truly commendable how she brings depth, clarity, and precision to the interview and the topic..!
It's big achievement❤congratulations🎉
My language is Dravidian language I proud
Gondi language in Central India mp, mh, ch,ts, odisha
आना कोईतूर आंदोना सबेतूं नावां सेवा 🙏🙏🙏
Gondi is not dravadian
@@b.l.0427 Gondi is indeed Dravidian belonging to south central group along with telugu
@02abishekprasad91 gondi originated from talangana it has Sanskrit admixture
Gondi is austro-asiatic not Dravidian m
I am a PhD in language
I appreciate his effort
Very Nice Work
What a great interviewer , she did her homework
Sindhu is a Sanskrit name so there shouldn’t be any confusion.
Yppp, it’s continues civilisation. And if not, how can rivers old name disappeared and no written evidence found?;
Bro , You are saying like Indus valley civilization people used to have a dialect of Vedic people .
Than , Why did not Researchers find any traces of vedic people genetic ( DNA ) in those skeletons founded in Indus valley civilization sites ?
As if Sindhu was an endonym.
Sindhu comes from Tamil language , my dear- the name for a flowing poem, a genre of song and a feminine name for a river. Sanskrit does not ascribe feminine names for rivers. Sanskrit comes from a Patrirachical society. Their names are generally masculine. One example is the name Brahma Putra. Even though names of rivers In India are all feminine, and the mighty river that flows through north east and Bangladesh has many native names in the locality where it flows - all famine names - in official records , named as Brahma Putra , a masculine name. Funny!
@@aruchase what nonsense. How is Ganga masculine for example?
Jai Shri Krishana.
Good work. Research is important to discover many hidden things in the evolution of Indian subcontinent.
The interviewer is remarkably intelligent, well informed, person whose thoughts, questions are very;well expressed. I am very impressed.
Outcome of the decipher of the indus Saraswati civilization script is goosebumps me..
Since it is now almost confirmed that Rigveda is Harappan literature, I was convinced that Sanskrit was their language and now it has been proved.
Bro , You are saying like Indus valley civilization people used to have a dialect of Vedic people .
Than , Why did not Researchers find any traces of vedic people genetic ( DNA ) in those skeletons founded in Indus valley civilization sites ?
@@mscreationworks5787 What is Vedic People Genetics reference for you?
@mscreationworks5787 hindus and other indic religion burn the corpse how can u get to know DNA of someone ?
Dna data is very limited in indian subcontinent how can u make such big claims
@@kuamrrishabh , Rigveda is the oldest literature of the World !!!!
@@anilkrmostthe DNA genetic are found in skeleton if mostly matches with Dravidian...and Dravidians don't use Sanskrit as their language
As a fellow sanskrit speaker, I am very prod of this effort by Indians. We should keep proving that everything is related to Sanskrit, because we know how to prove LHS equal to RHS. Jai Hind
Sanskrit is only 1000 years old
Sangam Talks Decoded it 2 yrs ago. 1:15
He's the one who presented that talk on Sangam Talks
That proves these westen platforms are last ones to realise. it took 2 years.
Will be following this very interesting development....
Now to get a proper decoding of Minoan Linear A....
🤔Another one not many will talk about is how one sentence can have several meaning to it, or a hole different terminology of from original at the same time. Example🤔Using it in a different context can make it a joke every one laughs or a insult, a wise rebuttal, a foolish remark.🤔A reference to, with two meaning original ues, plus over time reference that takes on a different message but aware of original message.😌😏Just putting that out there and very difficult but with enough evidence undeniable just a thought about such things.
👍Thank you for the video.👍
Reading the comments on this video made me realize that most people have zero understanding of this subject. Yagnadevam is too nice to say this, but the "scholars" of Indology don't have the expertise to review his paper. The expert review needs to be done by fellow cryptologists.
That aside, it is very important to explain the whole premise here. The whole subject of comparative linguistics was born when Europeans realized that classical European languages like Greek & Latin were related to Sanskrit. They painstakingly created a model that found a way to connect these and other related languages through time. However, they made many assumptions in the process- the foremost being that the Rigveda was composed at most in 1500 BCE. There is no proof whatsoever for this assumption. If this assumption is false, the whole Indo-European language tree as constructed becomes false (very important- the languages are still related, only there is no Proto-Indo-European at the root of the tree).
Coming to the Indus script, every single attempt to "decipher" the script is really just guess work. There's nothing wrong guessing, but your guesses have to be applicable universally to every single character in the script. Every work that was done before this basically fails at this. There was no mathematical grounding to any of the previous work (and hence my original point about those folks not being qualified to review his paper). Yangadevam's work is based on a firm mathematical foundation. Which means that his decipherment is true in the original sense of the word- he has figured out the cipher of the Indus script.
So, are u saying that vedic Sanskrit is much older?
Don’t you think the theory that the Indo-European language originated in Russia is somewhat half-baked? Recent studies suggest that the Indo-European language originated in western Iran. Genetic studies have discovered a Caucasus Hunter-Gatherers component that spread to the steppe and a similar Iranian Neolithic component (in the Zagros) that spread eastward. This component was found in Bronze Age Anatolia without steppe ancestry.
The Yamnaya were roughly 1/3 CHG or Iran_Neolithic. Iran_Neolithic ancestry comprises 40-60% of all modern Indians. Don’t you think Iranian Neolithic farmers migrated toward Russia around 7,000-8,000 years ago, forming the Yamnaya culture? Perhaps these people originated from Mehrgarh or Bhirrana in the Indian subcontinent, as India and Iran were better suited for human settlement 10,000 years ago than Russia, which experienced a cold and temperate climate heavily influenced by the last Ice Age.
The cow is significant in Indo-Aryan culture. The Indo-Europeans were central to the domestication of the bull/cow, the invention of the wheeled wagon, dairying practices, and milk consumption. However, the cow was domesticated in the Indus Valley Civilization over 9,000 years ago and in Anatolia separately. If one believes the steppe people domesticated the horse and then entered India, this migration never affected the genetic lineage of Indian cow breeds. Cattle genetics conclusively prove that no admixture of Taurine cattle into India has ever occurred. It seems silly to think that Indo-Aryans came to India without a single cow.
If we look at Russia, the Proto-Uralic language formed around the same time as the Indo-European language in relatively close proximity without any connection between them. In the Caucasus region or near the Black Sea, there are unrelated Kartvelian languages that formed around the same time or earlier than Indo-European.
Do you think the Burushaski language in northern Pakistan might be related to a pre-Proto-Indo-European language, given that haplogroup R2 is significantly present among the Burusho people? Haplogroup R2 is estimated to have emerged around 15,000 years ago, likely in the Indian subcontinent, while R1 originated in Central Asia and R itself in West and South Asia. It seems likely that the Indo-European language originated in Iran, the Indus Valley, or the BMAC culture.
@ Unlike the linguists and archeologists, I’m not one to rush to conclusions based on scant data. But yes, the whole paradigm of the origin of IE languages is built on very shaky grounds. Those who have built their careers based on this framework are going to make sure that any outside attempt to shed light on this shoddiness will be painted as unscientific (killing irony in a thousand ways).
The way they’ve tried to weaponize genetics is another thing. Pay attention- there is no correlation between the Steppe genome and languages. None. Yet, the claim is made that the Sanskrit language was brought into India by the Steppe people at around- wait for it- 1500 BCE. Circular logic.
I’ve always said this- if every major university in the US institutes a panel made up of Engineers, Physicists and Mathematicians to review the scientific claims made by their linguistics and archeology departments, many careers would be finished.
@@mlg1279 Based on its internal evidence- yes. The thing is, that’s the only evidence that doesn’t rely on a hundred assumptions.
@@Kalki0025 Looking at this from a different perspective since Harappan language can never be deciphered with accuracy and there will always be debated by one group of the other.
- Yamnaya are the result of this influx from Steppe and Caucasus region. This is genetically proven and this population mixed with Indo-Iranian before moving east to Harappan. Yamnaya are nomads and herders. They primarily are herders and only 10-30% of their gene is in mtDNA (maternal chain) of Indian population. North being the most and south being the least. I think the genetic study suggest the other way as you mentioned in your message. ~70% of our mtDNA comes from Ancient Indians who migrated from Africa around 60,000 years back. The Ancient North Indians after the Harappan demise is a mixture of Ancient Indians + Steppe + Harappan. Ancient South Indians are a mixture of Harappan + Ancient Indians. Today’s population is a mixture of ANI and ASI.
- Harappan language can never be deciphered with accuracy and there will always be debated by one group of the other. But based on archeology, genetic and cultural findings we can say Harappans cannot be Steppe because of several gaps - herders .vs agriculturalists, lack of cows in Harappa sites, lack of tiger mentioned in Rig Veda, cremation differences between Harappan and Steppe, etc. . Also, one symbol that predominantly used is Fish as meen in dravidian language. No mention of such things in Vedas. So, The list goes on and on. Based on these facts, the predominant agreed upon theory is Harappan language is most likely Elamite and Proto-Dravidian.
- w.r.t the cow topic - There is a gene mutation called 13910T that originated somewhere in Europe around 7500 years back and because of this gene Homo Sapians
were able to digests milk. Even today, people in north consume milk based diet more than the south. North consumes lesser meat than the south because they get their fair share of protein with milk. In Harappa sites, there is no mention of cows and archeology also proves they had bull but not cows. Cow being so sacred in Rig Veda, but no mention in Harappan sites.
This is a small list, with all this conflicts between culture and archeology it is funny to see someone with no qualifications doing some side project during Covid to come up with a theory. I am not sure why are bringing such people to talk!!!
Fantastic work and results! Wishing you tremendous success ahead!
"South Asia", please use Indian subcontinent!
A subcontinent that is a child of a province and river of Pakistan, Sindh and river Indus respectively
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 yes, that will come back and unify sooner or later...your "Stan" will become a blip on the Indian timeline...don't be too confident. It's a failed state, will disappear eventually.
Your genetics, your language, your food, music all are Indian...even if you don't realize so!!!!
"Indian timeline" haha
Son, India is in the timeline of Sindh.
The timeline of people of Pakistan began with Indus valley civilization, along the way Sindh decided to give this subcontinent an identity.
Sindh is still going along with Punjab.
90 % of all sindhis are Pakistani citizens
70% of all Punjabis are Pakistani citizens
Where do the words India and Hindustan come from?
An Indian telling his father what culture and food are.
India's very identity is owed to Sindh. You can't tell your father how to walk.
Indus valley civilization is the civilisation of Sindh and Punjab. It predates any notion of Vedas and abrahamic religions.
After starting this glorious Indus valley civilization, Sindh and Punjab carry on for centuries, Sindh then decided to give an identity to this subcontinent.
No matter how hard you try you'll always be a child of Sindh. I am a half Sindhi and half Punjabi. I look at India as one of my children
I've seen the full interview and videos on his channel. As a computer science engineering graduate myself i have dabbled a bit in NLP. I was initially skeptic since it goes against the established mainstream view. However his explanation is pretty convincing and his methodology is legit. Can't wait for more people to replicate his findings and take the research forward. Really interesting stuff if it turns out right. A lot of our history will need to be rewritten and timelines re-evaluated if his results are substantial. Amazing time to live
This is great!! Kudos for giving this much space to this!
It clearly indicates that there was no islam in Indus valley during those days
Bro, islam literally Just 1400 Years old or below it. Indus Valley is more than 5300 Years.
Abrahamic Criminals Come very recently
@@CHRS-ri5mfTry explaining it to our congress/left/ islamic cabal insode India who believe that India has nothing to offer the world in science or technology. 😂
Ewwww,,, dont even compare that religion with our culture and Itihas.
Obviously!😂 islam is just 1400 years old!
Buddha is everywhere in Asia ❤
Apabhraṃśa in Sanskrit literally means "corrupt" or "non-grammatical language", that which deviates from the norm of Sanskrit grammar.
Big Salute for Alexander Cunningham... Religious ppl can never been able to decipher this script.. for Ashokan Inscriptions would hv done the same it would never decipherd
😊 thank you been waiting for years for a breakthrough
Yajnadevam's research hammers the final nail in the theory of the Aryan invasion.
hahahahah😂😂😂😂😂. keep diwali Ying lindu Northiees. By Ambani funded News 18 propagadaaa
Legendary contribution. Keep it up.
Kudos to this man and to anyone that can refute the work in public
Don't hesitate to say it's Tamil. Dravida language came through Tamil.
This Research is great. Some Un-educated people . TAMILS Don't Know Difference between science and politics
This research is supported by Linear models which are used to decipher most of the Ancient scripts. Also this Is supported by MIT and Human Sciences scholars. So Yejana Devam Used Machine learning models, equations and other Scripts and mixed it with LINEAR model. making it advanced.
What are you talking about loser?
Literally copied comment lol
@@calamityZ-nh1yu yes someone Copied me
@@CHRS-ri5mf you copied them lol. AVG stupid northie.
Lol his theory is debunked by AMBIKA VIJAY of Quora🤣🤣🤣. It is not Sanskrit
Great Anchors. Unlike Republic TV. Kudos
@@gigilolo4660 she doesn’t even know her geography. She said Indus valley’s in India. It’s in Pakistan 🥵
Well, it's rookie mistake* Well It's implied that they meant Indus Valley Civilization*.
"It's in Pakistan"
No, some of its excavated sites are along the Indus River Basin in India & Pakistan*. A majority of IVC sites exist along the now dried up river Basin east of Indus called Ghaggar-Hakra. The distribution of Archeological Sites reveals the whole picture.
Of all the IVC sites:
Region No. of Mature Sites Percentage
Hakra Basin (Haryana, Indian Punjab, north Rajasthan, Cholistan) 360 32%
Gujarat,India 310 28%
Baluchistan 129 11%
Sind 108 9%
Pakistan’s Punjab 60 5%
Others 173 15%
Total 1140 100%
More the 60 percent of site lie not along the Indus but the Ghaggar Hakra Basin (Saraswati).
@@gigilolo4660 it’s a rookie mistake. Mohenjodarro and Harappa are in Pakistan.
@@Nozarks1 Rakhigarhi(greater than Harrapa, mohanjodaro's area combined) , Bhirrana, Binjor, Dholavira, Lothal, Kalibangan . So the expanse of IVC does not map 1:1 on Pakistans political border.
@@Nozarks1Mohenjodaro and Harappa are just 2 sites out of 1000+ IVC sites. India has more IVC sites than Pakistan.
So proud
Great work Yadnya Devam ji, and many thanks for this. Where is the paper published? and criticism to CNN on calling it South Asia and unnecessary saying its political.
True. When Something bad happens they tell it's india . When Good Happens It's south asia 😢
On his x
OMG how did i miss this channel till now 😞.... subscribing now. Thank you for bringing some meaningful interview/news/ and the anchor ❤
Please don't say Dravidian language, the word Dravidian itself came from Sanskrit, we can use "Tamil- Bhrami" which means mother of all south Indian languages
Dravidian is another word tamil actually
Sanskrit is new. Tamil and pali is older than Sanskrit. And Sanskrit use devnagiri scripts.. That's only 1000 year old.
@@user-xnex Pali is a middle Indo-aryan Language and Vedic Sanskrit is old Indo-aryan language.
Tamil is not the mother language... I think you people have brain washed deeply
@@Akscharm96 he said south indian languages
Thank you for this info. God Bless.
👏👏 Excellent work. World history should be written again
Yajna Devam ji, this nation will always be grateful you.
perfect anchor
Indus Valley Civilisation ❌
Sindhu Saraswati Sabhyata ✅
Sindhu Sarswati Sabhyata✅
Sarswati vedic civilization ✅
What's the difference??
One is in English and other is in Hindi that's it 😁
@@AzibGhadi are u serious vedic civilization started after IVC
Indus Valley wasn't vedic
@@boxguy-e3rvedic civilization existed well before to the understanding we were rubbed by the then British religious groups. They had Aryan invasion theory, which is debunked. Then had Aryan migration theory, also debunked. However, the Yamnaya invasion theory still holds the credit as it speaks of Indians spreading across western planes rather than the other way around. So vedic civilization existed well before.
@@Quasarrr i literally heard some of things for the first time
IF THE SEALS ARE WRITTEN FROM RIGHT TO LEFT, once they are inked and stamped, the reading would be from LEFT TO RIGHT.
@farrukhnaqvi3424 What you say makes sense but the pictures of the seals show the symbols, like the bowl which appear at the end of 'sentences' cramped up on the left, suggesting that they would appear on the right upon stamping.
Came for leisure, left with deciphered Indus Civilization Codes.
So nice to listen to Shri Yagna ji. Better still to see such dedication to a cause. More power to intellect returning to our quest for knowing what we are.
Great work..appreciate your efforts and contribution to our culture
I like this journalist, she's asking succinct, meaningful questions which shows she has done her research regarding the topic. Fantastic. Glad there are news channels doing this these days.
@@Rohan20103 she lost me when she said Indus Valley’s in India🙄. She doesn’t even know her geography. 🫢not very smart.
@@Nozarks1you are just looking at Indus river, that's not how it works. The civilization was between Sarswati and Sindhu. And major sites are found in Haryana and Gujarat than Pakistan. Talking about the human settlements.
@@millennialmind9507 Mohenjodarro and Harappa are in Pakistan. Indus River is in Pakistan. That’s like Pakistanis saying Taj Mahal is in Pakistan just because other Moghul structures are in Pakistan, or it is culturally Pakistani. Saying that would be ridiculous.
@@Nozarks1Also she doesn’t know about Rosetta Stone.
@@AnirudhSingh-gq7mp true.
Congratulations 🎊
Whoa!
While focus at HAYAGRIVA PUJA, will know all you want to know about the Veda text CORRECT meaning and CORRECT stories.
HAYAGRIVA undo demonic influence that polluted the scripture.
Great content. Can you cut down on all the rolling video and flashing graphics. I had to turn my head and just listen
Upsc syllabus increased 😮
😂
No his theory is debunked by AMBIKA VIJAY of Quora
Need to explore more indus valley sites
South asia😂
Its indian subcontinent
Pakistan civilisation
Bharat Mata Pakistan Papa
@DoloMalo-mw4zl THERE was NO pakistan at that time. "Sindh" itself is an Sankrit word. there was only ancient India. Pakistan is Son of INDIA
Sindh is India's daddy
@@aqeelkhurshid4860 THERE was NO pakistan at that time. "Sindh" itself is a Sanskrit word. there was only Ancient India. pakistan is Son of INDIA. born in 1947 😂
Also, THERE was NO pakistan at that time. "Sindh" itself is a Sanskrit word. there was only Ancient India. pakistan is Son of INDIA. born in 1947 😂
This is not "South Asia" but Indian Subcontinent ( situated in the southern part of Asia continent !!😊