Do you trust any politician to keep the country safe? | LBC debate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 มิ.ย. 2024
- In yesterday's PMQs, Sir Keir quizzed the prime minister on his "chaotic" prisons policy, which could see criminals who pose a threat to children released from prison.
Sunak, who Starmer labelled “some kind of jumped-up milk monitor”, was also mocked on "his seventh relaunch in 18 months" after the prime minister gave a speech this week warning the country would not be safe under Labour.
In response to Sir Keir's attack on the government's policy on banning lanyards, Sunak accused the Labour leader of being "soft on criminals".
But Sir Keir hit back: "He's literally letting criminals out early."
0:00 Who would do a better job of running the justice system?
4:20 Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer's exchange at PMQs
8:13 The PM is in charge of a system letting out people who are deemed to be a risk
10:44 Rishi Sunak has turned rules into mere guidance, says listener Steve
11:30 Problems with the prison state stem from Tony Blair's administration, says caller
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#tomswarbrick #prisons #keirstarmer #rishisunak #labour #conservatives #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
For all the people wondering who are the 18% of idiots who will still vote Tory ?
I give you....... John😂
...or Steve as the case may be
Whatever his name is, he is right about the useless nature of exchanging, Conservatism for milquetoast centerism & Starmer has showed little appetite to change much except to change the sides of the 'leaders', in the Commons Chamber.
As dumb as the others who vote Labour thinking each party is different.
Both parties have the same agenda.
I wouldn't trust Sunak to look after a hamster let alone the country. The man can't even pay for a Twix successfully.
Can't buy a Twix, though ironically most of the country would be quite happy to give him the finger
@@shadowgophr5269 🤣🤣
@@shadowgophr5269 I'm sure he'd be quite happy to take it.
What people don't realise is that "Richi" literally doesn't give a hoot about any of this! He doesn't care, all he's doing is longing out his unelected term. By the end of this year him and his family will have moved to California never to be seen again
The caller is exactly the kind of person the torys are looking for..
he is also inaccurate
The caller is an Indian immigrant.
The one that investigates the Russian Influence on our Politicians and Brexit.
Sad to say, it will not be one of this two.
Our current govt are taking money from Russia so that will never happen with them.
Don't forget america
What do you mean 80s and 90s .. Labour wasnt in power in the 80s. 1979 - 1997 was Tory. Also 8 prisons were built between 1997 - 2004. So no .. not quite accurate
Starmer is obviously far far more qualified on this issue. Sunak's main qualification for being prime minister is being extraordinarily rich. Seems an odd criteria....
Yes a choice between a man in his early 60s with decades of public service under his belt (including heading the CPS and doing an excellent job in spite of the ridiculous Saville/GPO smears) or an early 40s, woefully inexperienced, privileged grifter, whose sole purpose in life has been to make as much money as he can, chiefly by marrying into it. Tough call but I choose the former.
@@gerardmackay8909I choose neither and will vote Reform. Starmer is a flip flop liar who cant be trusted
And he became rich at the expense of the country and its people. He shouldn't be PM, he should be in prison.
@@gerardmackay8909 I won’t be voting for two loosers
@@barbaracartwright2335 I think you’ll find Barbara it will be one loser (looser means less tight) and one winner. The only certain loser is the one you’re going to waste your vote on but of course it’s a free (at the moment) country.
Because it’s worked out so well, people keeping this lot in government hasn’t it?!
Yeah, it's worked alright, like some kind of bad nightmare you cannot wake up from.
Yeah
🤡💃🏽👩🏼🦽🍷🥂🍾🍸🍹🎉
Non of them
I wouldn't trust Sunak to find his own backside with both hands and a paid guide.
😂😂😂😂 brilliant 😂😂😂
Pleases he is a honorable man!
Priceless, made my day😂😂😂😂😂
Tony blair was %100 percent better then richey sunack
And how sad is that!?
@@V4Now I know, I was so happy in 97 and so disappointed next time around.
@@V4Now 4 hours waight in hospital doctor appointment 20 minits max waight everythink worked 💪 lol
@@politics392 a dentist
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I find it difficult to believe how anyone in their right mind could trust a Tory to provide a straight answer or a positive outcome for the working people of this country.
None of them do i trust
To answer the question in the title,
NEITHER,!!!
All as bad as each other .. Stalmer the flip flop snake can't be trusted either.
Was he a flip flopper before 7th October, or are you just a bit disingenuous?
Sunak letting people out of prison early.
Completely wrong. You have bought into a fallacy that helps the Tories stay in power. Wake up
Paid for Tory comment😂
@@alst4817 paid for by your mum ;)
I’d trust them like I’d trust a packet of Doritos to save my health.
Odd comparison considering Doritos can literally save your life if you’re starving! Newsflash 3million on bank food parcels. 😂
@@ryanoneill4691 well if you want long term health you wouldn't want to be eating Doritos forever right? I meant it in that way. Like I'd trust ultra processed food not to give me cancer etc.
But I 100% agree! I love me Cheese and Onion crisps. Though Doritos ain't my fav brand
And who made the food banks? Tories.
These are the type of people that keeps the country behind!
To be a politician, all you need to do, is swear an oath of loyalty to the lobbyist and donors, support Israel without question ~ and have total contempt for the people
Or appease the woke by not being able to say what a woman is and allowing terroristism to be supported .
So true, best of the day.
It's none of the above..
The way Rushi Sunak debates in the parliament it’s as if he has just joined a debating society
Kier or neither... They are the options
Sir Keir, Lord Dave, and Rishi.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Vote Labour
Fed up from
Tories
Resign rishi
Labour won’t stop the boats either
@barbaracartwright2335 better of the two though.
@@barbaracartwright2335 remind us how many boat crossings there were under the last Lab government?
@@barbaracartwright2335 Labour actually returned a lot of illegal immigrants, more than the tories ever have.
😂😂😂😂😂😂🎉
I think it was Winston Churchills fault.
its white van man's fault
I blame Canada.
clever: they are so polite, they won't take offence...@@uniquerebeljaney3639
Steve in Guildford has not got use of the families brain cell today apparently.
You should've asked Steve who did his job before him, and then does that mean that A) He's responsible for all of that persons mistakes, and B) Does it also mean that he will do the same?
None of them
Where is SANGITTA????
We missed her.
As a little fact check regarding the village idiots who phoned in 26 prisons were built between 1990 and 2010 10 of these were built between 2000-2010
Steven you utter melt......tony Blair wasn't a former director of prosecutions ....Keir starmer was ....and clearly will put the justice system at the heart of his reforms
Blair did open 8 prisons btw xD. So its not even accurate. Also I dont know why he said Labour let people out in the 80s and 90s when they werent even in power in the 80s. 1979-1997 were Tory.
I'm sick and tired of saying it... it's not about 'Sunak or Starmer', the choice is Con-servative or Labour! If you want NO NHS, NO Welfare state (so NO support during the next pandemic! and NO State Pension), NO free education from 5-18 years (to name just a few) - then continue to vote for the "Me, me, me" Con-servative Party! Otherwise, ...
you being practical, which is refreshing!
They might keep the pensions.
Huntercombe had a huge wing built under Blair. I was a partnof building it. It was massive
Using the word Schizophrenia when describing the broken prison policy is unacceptable. Schizophrenia is a serious mental health condition.
Yes it more prevalent in black people, 1 in 8...
Couldn't agree more. Clearly, they don't have family or friends suffering from this debilitating condition. Unbelievable.
Actually if you Google the word you'll find the royal family brought new laws in that schizophrenia is not allowed to be used on people and it's been proved it carnt be used as there's no proof the royal family had the laws changed so noone under the mental health can be diagnosed with schizophrenia any more and other names aswell. The mental health is egnoring the law and still sectioning people under schizophrenia and other labels that is now not allowed to be used as unproofed. I heard a muzlim say we don't care who worked for mental health the royal family we don't listen to them if the queen changed any laws where not listening I tried it's been changed under the law in UK you have to obey and you cannot do that anymore it's disgusting that mental health people workers egnore the laws and rules in our country.
How could you trust either? Both liars not to be trusted.
The caller ws factually inaccurate , Belmarsh was opened as a new prison in 1983, Downview in 1989, Lo Newton in 1965, Bronzefield in 2004, Berwyn in 2017. etc
Neither of them I wouldn't trust any politician in this godforsaken hole now
Wouldnt trust either of these muppets to keep the country safe!!
even with all that damning summary of just how bad the justice system has become under the Tories, Sunak''s distraction promise is to build more prisons !!!! no apology for how they got to this position
cognitive dissonance
Starmer👍
None of them both invested in Davos
Invested in davos?
🤡
Starmer is far better qualified in this area. Although I can't find it in myself to trust either of them to lead this country
What's the point of talking about crime when we have no control over our streets or borders?
people rampaging through town helping themselves to stock, electric bikes pulling wheelies in the centre, weve lost control.
@@shaun906 It's no surprise when politicians and media drone on and on about how unfair and unjust our society is, which it's fairer and more just than most.
Then they allow police funding to stagnate, open teh doors to uncontrolled migration and the scene is set.
They keep telling us our laws don't matter, and don't enforce teh laws we have.
not voting for neither party
And what are you expecting to achieve by that
@@sanchezz4387people like Slink don’t understand politics.
....which means a vote for the Tories....Give your head a wobble and try a new experience: "Thinking"...you never know, you might like it.
But of course, like most 23-year-olds these days....you haven't done much of that lately, have you....
Oh, and it's 'Either' party...
@@sanchezz4387 both parties are not getting my vote, because as a former labour supporter, they do nothing for the Afro Caribbean community, they ignore us but expect us as default to cast a vote for them, i am achieving something by not voting for jack
Neither will keep us safe because they won’t stop the boats landing
I'm afraid you are completely wrong. Labour will build a processing centre in France. That will end the dinghies overnight. But of course, that's the very last thing Nigel Fartage and the Tories want....all that lovely HATE and Rage...makes you feel all warm and fuzzy doesn't it?
Who will you hate and scream at, in say, two years time, when the small boats are no more....Disabled People? Unemployed People? Random black People? Or will you just wait for the Daily Heil to give you your cue...?
the boats started in 2018?
....shortly after the Tories closed all legal routes for asylum seekers to the UK. Oh, and stopped processing claims. But it's OK, all that Hate and Rage...keeps the Tories hopeful and the voter base happy....they need people to scream at, bless their rotten little souls....@@shaun906
clueless.
@@shaun906 the UK have the right to stop them or return to France. Sunak won’t stop them and Starmer says he is going after the the ones peddling the business, he won’t turn them back or stop them coming here.
There’s no difference between Sunak and Starmer.
Reform UK the only ones saying they will divert them back to France.
The UK is at risk of being a failed state but most the media covers for the Conservative party
Sunak was extremely agitated during PMQs this week and just like he has in the past he misquotes lots of facts to try and tarnish Labour, notice how once Starmer quoted true facts from a recognised report Sunak added COULD & SHOULD into the mor definitive statements he had made a few minutes sooner- backpeddling!!
Anyone who has listened to Kier Starmer will know that his motivation for becoming a politician was the frustration in the way multiple identical cases had to tediously work through every legal aspect taking up court time? Starmer believes that it should be possible to change some laws to speed up the process without impacting the legal outcome.
I trust myself and that's it. Not have I ever or will I ever trust the government in any aspect of keeping this country safe/do right by the public or even listen to 1 single person.
Answer: certainly not the corrupt government
None of them are trustworthy...They pretend to be for the ppl and they are not. Unless your rich and upper class. Labour run my area and the council tax have gone through the roof, my friends in Chelsea pay so much less than me in a similar size property!! They were shocked when they saw my bill
I would trust either Sunak or Starmer to tell me the time.
How did Labour release prisoners in the 80s and 90s?
They took power in 1997.
Neither of these men will be getting my vote
Canadian watching the nation that introduced Tower justice, convict ships, and, well, police.
David Cameron should run again , he won , he knows what hes taling about , he loves his country , he should be the prime minister
Labour and Cons have had their time.. Vote Reform Uk to make Britain great again
Both of them can’t be trusted to be honest, both change
Labour weren't in power until 97.
In England and Wales since 2010 I think 18 prisons have been closed
all we know for sure is that labour won't even send these people to jail, in FACT, they won't even prosecute them if their serial abuser's of women, children, and the disabled !
Steamer obviously 🙄
I would trust Sangita Myska
Neither
No idea!! 😠
None
What would Sangita say?
Don't trust either, my vote would be a tactical one, just to get the Tories out, not sure labour will be any better 🤷🏻♀️
Neither of them as Labour will let in much more asylum seekers! 😡🤬
Which is clearly a lie as the Tories let in more than Labour ever could.
We need them or the country will fail to make its way out of this black hole. Public services will be doomed.
Except legal and illegal immigration has been highest under the tories. Why not learn some facts?
@@ne-ht4zx Tony Blair opened the floodgates in 1997 when he became our Prime Minister as HE wanted a multicultural society.
@@JET_60we always have been. Ever since the British began adventuring around the world, colonising so many countries, that gave rise to a multicultural society. The Empire gave the UK an unprecedented multicultural society for the time. That is British culture.
Security of the Nation. Remember that report into Russian Interference in UK Democracy. The one BogJob buried upon election? What happened to that eh? Seems pretty critical information.
Whar a horrific thought trusting sunak with yor families lives...
Erm... Blair didn't get in in 89... that was Thatcher/Major...
Neither - it has to be Reform!!.
Who's more likely to have an underground nuclear fallout bunker? Vote for the other one ...
Nigel Farage
Starmer , sick of Tories ..
None! They all take the money!
80s and 90s???? What about the 90s-2010?
Politic is not scoring cheap political points. The issue is what the labour plan on prisons? No plan as usual. We saw it when we gambled with Liz. Let's not make the same with Starmer.
Same cheek of the same beast!!!
No
I would trust and belive prince Harry more to look after this country and make every decision than I would the government
Steve a man so adimant his facts are right except one thing 4 prisons were built under the last labour goverment, these people genuinlly need a political refresher course before being aloud to vote
I take it this is a rhetorical question?
SANGITA
The why are they in prison in the first place 🥳🥳🥳😘😊🥳😊🙏🙏💰😭💰😭🙏💰
Nope.
I loathe PMQs. The bickering and name calling is just so you excruciatingly embarrassing. The lack of pragmatism to the questions being asked and the responses given make the whole pantomime a complete waste of time.
I’m not expecting the PM and the leader of the opposition to be united in their approach, but at least acknowledge the fact that they are there to serve the public. These exchanges are made public because it is supposed to inform us on the way the country is being governed. All these clowns do is perpetual campaigning. So tiresome
The comments shows you who can understand a question and who cannot!
Reform isn’t even in the question thickos!
George Galloway.
didn't you hear....he's in Libya...looking for Ghadaffi....
Sunak couldn’t run a bath
Both sunak and starmer cannot be trusted.
As if it would make any difference, both work for the same hive mind
Steve the thicko lol
The title of this video only demonstrates how stuck on the cult of personality politics is today.
Bring sangita back. This guy is a clown
Labour any day while nothing is working anymore.
You'll get another tory government with Starmer.
Both parties are a joke vote reform uk
Donald duck 🦆
😂🤦
i will not vote tory
None of them that's why I've never voted 🤣😂😭💀☠️ seen the ish show for what it was years ago.
running a country
🤣😂😭💀☠️
They couldn't even run a SPOON RACE. 🤣😂😭 let alone organise one. 🤣😂😭💀☠️
COUNTRY
bad news for you: If you have never voted, then sorry, the rule is YOU CANNOT EVER Criticise the Government of the day. Keep your mouth shut and your opinions to yourself. Them's the rules. ONLY PEOPLE WHO VOTE...have the right to complain.
Do you think all your rantings will make a jot of difference. Close down LBC now.