Biden is acting incredibly defensively towards people who care about him the most: Arthur Brooks
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Arthur Brooks, AEI president emeritus, Harvard University professor and The Atlantic contributing writer, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss the state of the 2024 race, increasing calls for President Biden to reconsider his bid for reelection, how leaders should transition, and more. For access to live and exclusive video from CNBC subscribe to CNBC PRO: cnb.cx/42d859g
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/Subscri...
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/Subscri...
Turn to CNBC TV for the latest stock market news and analysis. From market futures to live price updates CNBC is the leader in business news worldwide.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedI...
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/Instagr...
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC on Threads: cnb.cx/threads
Follow CNBC News on X: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC on WhatsApp: cnb.cx/WhatsAp...
www.cnbc.com/s...
#CNBC
#CNBCTV
"we didn't know this"😂 everyone else knew for 3.5 years
I dind tknow that still don t.
@@truthhurts5158 Willfully ignorant.
@@truthhurts5158the bots are malfunctioning lol
@@truthhurts5158Ignoring the facts and truth is what you're doing. If you have no shame, then you have no character. If you have no character, you will never be happy. You're not happy now, nor will you be. Your health is not good, belly fat is dangerous and your halitosis is the result of gum disease which is chronic (and stinky), your dependence on EBT isn't good, because your "disability" is curable, though you choose everyday to continue to live an unhealthy life style while tax payers support you.You do take good care of your mother, but of course she wouldn't be happy about you being a shill online. There is a better way. Peace be with you. I hope you can strip the hate and self neglect from your life.
@@AncientCreature-i2o Yes ignoring the facts is what you are doing. I chose to believe in what the doctors say Trump has dementia and Biden is just old. And you have no respect for the elderly shame on you. ANd I will be as happy as hell when Biden wins
Power and money are all politicians care about ... Pathetic .
You answered all the questions Joey, I’m going to give you an ice cream cone 🍦
Instead of criticizing our president, we should be supportive and pray for his wellbeing. Rum, Joe,run!
Rum ?
“He’s defensive about giving up the control”. Ummmm… YEAH?! That’s what old people with dementia do! They can’t see their own mental faculties failing. Makes matters worse when Jill and Hunter are lying to him and telling him, he’s doing fine.
“I didn’t poop my pants. And Jill gave me ice cream and said I answered all the questions. So I won.”
Trump constantly messes up his pants. Catch the smell
@@gabrielalarcon5462 I had hoped Biden was not at Trump’s level of depravity. But now he’s spray painted himself orange, and seems to believe he’s been anointed by “the Lord Almighty.” Pretty Trumpy tbh
All these intellectual leviathans just realized Joe was senile....
Lol great point
Joe isn t senile. Whats that saying takes one to know one
Joes is safe n effective
those silly leviathans.
Good
The liberals (that includes the media) did this to themselves… and I’m loving every second of it.
The media is not 'liberal'. It is pro establishment. Like it's owners.
This is one of the many gifts to come
They would be shocked to discover there's gambling going on in a casino. They made their bed but now they don't want to sleep in it. Time for popcorn.
When I go, I want to check out peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather did, not screaming in terror like the people in his car…
Or the Country.
Well we had many Presidents go out of old age while in office including Roosevelt in the heat of WW2 in 1945 he passed during the war but we dont remember that as we have a very good method of dealing with it thanks to the VP it went very smoothly and Harry Truman took over
Yes, put in Kamala HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You probably hate her because she is black.
Dems please stop crying It's way to late in the game to bring in a replacement you knew how old he was and what kind of health issues he had a long time ago
Facts. The die is cast, trying to replace him now is falling on your own sword.
@@Creslin321 and It would be way too late in my opinion for his replacement to get there message out because most people already have their minds made up
And you repugs should own the fact that you are supporting a con man and convicted criminal and want him to take over our government. Get real!!!!!!!!
And what if he drops dead tomorrow? Continue with the corpse? Strange system you have there in the US. In European (and probably also most other) countries they can decide to do a new election now and have it within a couple of months. In the US a whole circus of 2 years to get to two old men (known half way the process) most don't want. A bit more flexibility would be helpful IMHO.
@@darnellbrown2198 yup, and we can’t forget that we already had a Dem primary in 2024 and Biden won it, easily. What kind of look is it for media elites and party insiders to just anoint another candidate against the will of the people?
And the shocking thing to me is that some of the strongest “replace Biden” voices, are also the people who were crying that the DNC stole the election from Bernie and anointed Hillary and Biden the candidates.
Now they are out here literally advocating that the DNC steal the nomination from Biden.
Tell me MAGA was right about everything all along without telling me MAGA was right about everything all along.
Just in case, you need someone to tell you. MAGA is Wrong. In every way!
Just remove Bumbles and tell him he is still the POTUS. He wont know the difference.
Ha, ha, ha! . . .
"Didn't know this". People questioned this even before the election years ago.
Facts. I was one of them! Years ago!
Everyone knew he was old and voted for him anyway in the primary. We like him. He's done more than any other president in our lifetime. These talking heads are high on their own corporate media power.
@@linguaphile42 The primary? The one without debates? That primary?
@@Elaiyel No one polled hight enough to have a debate, which absolutely is not done by the party when there is the incumbency advantage. Duh. That could only weaken the strongest chance to win. Folks who know nothing about politics are trying to have an opinion here. How cute.
@@linguaphile42 Your penultimate sentence reveals your arrogance. But, even the Republicans held debates with Mr. T as the hands down favorite to win. So that's no excuse. We were robbed. Because they knew the incumbent would not and could not hold his own among other democrats on the debate stage.
Dictator won't step down
We had an election in 2020. Joe Biden won.
And they're worrying about Trump being a dictator...
Thats not what a dictator is numbskull
Panic mode?
President Trump approved $8.4 trillion of new ten-year borrowing during his full term in office, or $4.8 trillion excluding the CARES Act and other COVID relief.
President Biden, in his first three years and five months in office, approved $4.3 trillion of new ten-year borrowing, or $2.2 trillion excluding the American Rescue Plan.
President Trump approved $8.8 trillion of gross new borrowing and $443 billion of deficit reduction during his full presidential term.
President Biden has so far approved $6.2 trillion of gross new borrowing and $1.9 trillion of deficit reduction.
The message from this show; VOTE FOR TRUMP!
Joe needs to step down. Actually if he does not step down congress needs to insist that he have a complete mental and physical exam that will be disclosed to us. He may not be qualified to stay in office for the next several months and VP Harris should take over.
I don't see this happening but it would be great if it could.. Much more transparency for the American people than in previous years
How can we expect a man barely in control of himself to competently plan the end of his own career? The time for planning is way past over. The decision will have to made for him.
Not everybody was fine with it. A lot of people believed the spin and BS coming out of the whitehouse and campaign. I did. I was foolish but fool me twice, shame on me.
So you are voting TRUMP no matter who they replace Biden with?
God bless you. Help wake up your friends.
@@JC-21470 yes
@@JC-21470YES YES YES
If you got fooled it's because you were not paying attention or you're very gullible. Unfortunately there are far too many journalists that are too biased or are too afraid to be objective and report the truth.
This was one of the most honest appraisals of what is going on! Well said! I agree wholeheartedly!
!!! People have to stop thinking about Biden and Trump... They have to think bigger... about America, democracy, and our future ! 🎉
They are hiding his medical condition
Conditions
SPOT ON! I’m absolutely not voting again if Biden stays in office!!!!!!
So you want Project 2025?
No one cares if you leave the basement or not.
@@YunoGasai414 You know Trump has no ties to that right???
Same politicians talking about “saving democracy” are the same politicians trying to come up with a way to take a man off the ticket that VOTERS VOTED FOR.
How does that work?
And the main politician refuses to step down knowing he is too frail.
I don’t even think that it is hypocrisy.
Some people really can’t see that they themselves act like those, they warn us about .
@@jakeforrest It goes beyond hypocrisy when you’re trying to sell me that you’re “SHOCKED” Biden has cognitive issues.
Yes, they are willing to gaslight us to a great extent. Neither party is without sin.
People knew. I'm talking about the public who was paying attention. We knew the situation, the media didn't want to report it.
TH-cam COMMNET AUDITOR HERE!
This is section seems pretty clean. CNBC is keeping it honest. MSNBC on the other hand… 😬😬😬
This is Demitia,my mom died of it last july,she became very combative and stubborn and was never like that before,they do not live in a reality
Does this bloke think that the editorial board of the NYC and Abigail Disney and their ilk care about President Biden the most? Huh?
They clearly care more about the country than the idiots advising biden who are clearly acting in their own self interest and no one else.
Yeah that's a weird take.
this is the first guy from harvard that's impressed me. good interview.
I hope this interview gets a lot of visibility. This is one incredible management lesson for presidents and more importantly for leaders of organizations. Joe and Becky are incredible anchors. I’m so glad Sorkin was not here trying to hog all the limelight!!
He is acting like a 5 y. o. ! Please go Joe ! Let young generation beat Trump!!!
Most young ppl in America believe Jews are an oppressor class, so let’s NOT let young people decide this election.
Trump has met his match. Both love power so much and none wnats to leave office. Forget abot the country.
I like this guy! Arthur Brooks! Can I vote for him instead of Joe.?
This is not about individuals wishes and feelings. It’s about the nation
I am so disappointed at him now!!!
People with Parkinsons, Alzheimers, and Dementia are EXTREMELY DEFENSIVE ... Joe, you're proving our point!
I’m astounded that Joe Kernen is still employed at CNBC, speaking truth to power the way he does. Young Andrew must be on the verge of an aneurysm. I’m kinda laughing about that…
I will never vote for Biden! Because a vote for Biden guaranties K. Harris as President and that would be devastating to the county!
She would replace him just for a while, they would have to elect another one. America is not ready for a woman and certainly not a black one. Vote for Trump, it means you like Dictators that Trump admire so much...
@@ginettegarceau6638 "America is not ready for a woman and certainly not a black one." So the sexists and racists aren't all on the Republican side.
@@ginettegarceau6638 Yeah we had 4 years to see Trump is no dictator. That's not working.
Not only for the county but for the country too 😂
Vote for the old slow stuttering guy who won’t destroy our democracy.
When the commentator said, "Going out on a slab", I spit out my coffee laughing.
People care about him??? If they cared they would have never voted him in in the first place. The"concern" about Biden is all about the election.
The Tom Brady analogy is incorrect. New England Patriots were trying to keep him playing for their team, but he chose to play in Tampa Bay instead.
Go away, Joe!! I wanted to vote for you but not now! You’re going to let trump win. FJB.
The pressure put on this guy to do more is going to break him. It's cruel.
No one wants Biden to step down more than me, but some of the comments here are ridiculous. People who can't even put a proper sentence together in a short written comment are suggesting that Biden is one step away from being a vegetable just because he had a terrible debate performance in a high-pressure environment. Yes, he is past his prime and not the strongest candidate to defeat Trump. However, let's not overstate his difficulties. He's still way more capable than a lot of the people commenting here.
Sometimes you have to miss spell on purpose to avoid TH-cam censorship. But that is of course not something you would know, if you have the “right opinions”
Absolutely. The problem with American Democracy as we stand right now is old. You got 75%+ in Congress, Senate and House that are all 70+ years old. How on earth are you gonna maintain the young people in this country's interest when people that old generally have 0 clue how to connect to young people. Absolutely younger generations need to be given the ball. Why cant someone in their 40s be President of the United States. Someone that is charismatic and you know has the energy to carry on future generations. Its the old people in general in American Democracy that refuse to acknowledge just how out of touch they all are.
Love the truth u are telling...love it.
Poor old guy won't give up the keys to the office. Going down in flames while we all go for a ride
I would be very interested to know, what is Arthur Brooks' opinion about Trump's performance on the debate? And also, Arthur Brooks's opinion on Trump's mental status as well as fitness to be a president, including some conclusions to be drawn from the Trump's performance on the debate?
25th Amendment!
And have cackling kamala running the show? Hell no!
Love this 👌
Tough it out till the bitter end.
Conservative media outlets such as Fox has been talking about Biden's mental problems literally for years.
I wholeheartly believe that Biden is the most qualified person to do the job, given his 52 years in the public, including 8 years as Vice President of the United States and 3.5 years as the President of the United States, and most importantly, what he has accomplished in 3.5 years.
I think that the Media should actually evaluate Trump's performance, his incoherence, etc etc, as well as what Trump has actually done in his 4 years in office with the public
“The fact that WE didn’t know any of this” means you’re totally incompetent.
The incapacitated CANNOT make proper decisions for themselves!!! IT is people that we see saying "AFTER LAST WEEK" that are the REAL problem!!!
Biden should leave with dignity.
Too late for that.
For a second i thought she meant Joe Scarborough, but then i remembered this NBC subsidiary is somewhat rooted in reality.
There is irony to the Tom Brady analogy. Drew Bledsoe was qb for the Patriots but was injured badly in late September 2001. A young Tom Brady stepped in and led his team all the way to the Superbowl.
He is not in control. There are groups of people who don’t give a dam about our country National security
"Gerontocracy" -- Oh, I"m gonna start using that word. It's amazing the people who will not retire. I get that incumbents are valuable and so is experience but wow way too many people are literally dying and deteriorating in front of us instead of retiring. It's gross and wrong in so many ways!
"We didn't know any of this," said the Harvard guy? How come the rest of us did? We've been screaming about it for 4 years.
So much for Harvard.
Now tell us how calling for the genocide of Jews depends on the context.
Stop the drama
Retire with deginity NOW !
give america a chance
I love Arthur Brooks!!!!
Did she just compare Biden to Tom Brady?
Yeah WTF?? Tom was on top of his game
At 1:30 he says: “ You can have an administration that is isolating itself to an extent that not even the media, let alone the American public, knows what is going on”
So the main stream media claims to be ignorant?
Super hilarious that these journalists aren’t really taking accountability for their own actions in this debacle. Had they been true journalist we might not be where we are today.
2 issues with the Tom Brady analogy.
1. Brady was essentially forced out by Belichick an old guy who couldn't let get of power and accept the changes and failed because of his refusal adapt.
2. Biden has never had anywhere near the comparative greatness of Brady that would afford him the comparison
The difference, is that Brady was asked to leave so that the Patriots could prepare for the future. Biden is being asked to leave because he's been in the game too long without a Helmet.
Let's see: You're criticizing the DEMOCRATS for lying to the public, when your candidate is Donald Trump? Wooo, that's weird.
Since the Democrats have been harping on Mr. T for deception, and rightly so. What's sauce for the goose, is sauce for the gander. They have been lying to us about his condition all along.
Classic signs of dementia: defensiveness.
Wow, this guy just told it as it is...rare to see this on corporate media, they must be really desperate but as one of the guests said, the media, everyone was complcit.
The public was not fine with the dems not having a primary. If no one wanted a rematch of Biden vs trump, then don’t suggest the American public was complicit. Those of us with sense knew that Biden was cooked. The presidential debate simply exposed the lies the media put forward about Biden.
The media needs to quit it. A few politicians and big news outlets shouldn't decide what voters have brought about. They need to STFU.
It's now Team Biden vs the Dem "Elite". WIN for Trump. Sickening.
Who are you? Let President Joe Biden make his own decisions. The American voters will vote for him, agains, or not vote at all.
Too much is on the line. We can't wait till the last minute.
If we had known prior to primaries, Joe would not be our nominee. I'm guessing that's why they hid it from us.
JUST SAYIN: Media's anti-Biden noise is no accident: NBC CEO TRUMP DONOR
Don't care. We saw it with our own eyes.
I don’t blame him! Trump needs to learn his lesson by losing once for all. POs
I didn’t vote for Biden in the primary because he is not the best choice. I voted for marianne Williamson. #ruthBaderBiden
He doesn’t remember if he saw the debate. Independent voter who will only cast a vote for a Biden replacement.
you tell ‘em!
Joe kernan having his job is european american male privilege in action.
Behind the scenes there could be a contender who will show up at the Democratic Convention. Who knows? BTW: I didn't know that the Joe Biden of the cheese-ball debate existed.
These two parties are the actual problem
Go RFK
Didnt the people vote for him?
Yes, and he thought that we were voting for him. He didn't realize that we were really voting against his opponent.
It’s ageism. He has done so much and can still do the job. If Harris ever had to take over, it will not ruin the country. She supports Biden/ the Dems policies. If Trump gets in, democracy is done!!
Believe your eyes and ears. There are plenty of democrats who could win. If given the opportunity and media exposure.
With people who "care about him" like this, he doesn't need enemies. Unite behind Joe! He's the nominee and starting a fight between 8 or 10 other candidates for the Dem ticket is ridiculous. It seems like these hand-wringers are working for the other team.
No. Biden is brain dead, stop the lies. Blue MAGA is not the solution
Didn’t know he was like this???? What have you been watching the past 4 years
He is still the best chance to pull off a win. He would secure the 13 keys and if he does not run, he needs to step aside and let Harris become president as soon as possible and give her his delegates
WHY CAN’T you tell the truth??! We didn’t have a real primary. It was squashed and many Americans did not want this rematch. You can’t gaslight us into not knowing this
This Joe on Squawk box is also past his prime, and should leave now rather than go out on a slab.
Lesson: Jill is the Queen of this show
Care about him? The democrat party is responsible.
Honestly, I consider myself pretty well informed and I never saw that level of decline before the debate. But if the issue was raised it got tamped down by the White House and you were accused of parroting Fox News talking points.
It blew up in their faces.
If you want to anger a leftist, tell them the truth;
If you want to anger a conservative, lie to them.
With all due respect. It was brought up even in 2020. But tamped down. Now it's plain for everyone to see.
CNBC Joe is more unhinged everyday
Joe is spot on.
Who does Jill Biden things she is kidding ?..😂 A neurologist visits eight times in eight months and privacy...LOL...keeps her from answering why he was there...give us a break and don't insult our intelligens, please....😢😢😢😢
THE QUESTION IS DOES BIDEN GET BETTER OR WORSE WITH TIME? 2. IS THIS A CONDITION? 3. HOW MUCH TIME DOES HE HAVE?
brilliant. i wish i'd done this when i was a leader.
Don’t believe your eyes and ears. Believe the bubblewrap media & Dr Jill.