I was a British soldier for 23 years, so In no way am I a pacifist, but this song makes me weep. Wars are started by politicians, fought by soldiers, won by the blood of soldiers and victory claimed by the politicians, who then abandon the soldiers.
I heard this for the first time today on my community radio station. It was a different version that I can’t find. When he broke into the actual Waltzing Matilda chorus, I broke down crying in the car. It was as if someone had reached into my chest and ripped my heart out. So unexpected and so powerful.
ERIC BOGLE wrote and sang this song at an Australian music contest. When the judges awarded him 3rd place, the audience rioted. Gotta love those Aussies.
Currently the same now - over some bloke who stabbed women, and the polce did bugger-all. Are the Aussies the only men left in the world who know what's right?
I enlisted in the Marines in 1966. Deployed to Vietnam in April of 1967. Spent 13 months on the DMZ from Con Thien to Khe Sanh. War is Hell. We accomplished nothing only to hopefully make it back home. This song really hits hard to the futility of war...there are no winners. I cry for friends who took their last breath 10,000 miles from home. And for a childhood friend who took his life from the scars of that damn war. RIP Danny :(
Love this song...It's almost Irish. I hear you man....I'm an Irish man who are neutral in all wars but what would the world be like without people like you and your mates who fight so we can carry on with the freedom that we have in our daily lives. I just want to express my gratitude for all of you heros who should be so proud of yourselves...I have so much respect for yous....thank you from John
They aren't, they will never be invisible. We don't ever forget them. I thank your husband and all his comrades for their sacrifice. I think of them all the time.
I was lucky to get back from 2 tours in one piece and then got torn apart when I returned. We just weren't the flavor of the month. Socially unacceptable. Jobs? Veterans need not apply.😊
It is an absolute outrage for TH-cam to allow this sacred song to be interrupted by any advertisement. This song is about the birth of the ANZAC legend and no one has a right to defile it with ads.
Google which own TH-cam has no respect for nothing. Along with facebook. They are just shitheads. I use to forward fast as it was allowed back then. Now I just ignore them. Cheers
decisions made by politicians and the sacrifice in blood by ordinary young men and women....and in the final wash up for WWI FOR WHAT....they even sowed the seed in the final ARMISTICE FOR another world war but at least that one had JUSTIFACTION
I was lucky enough to see Eric live at a small folk club in Scotland. For me when I hear the song I remember my grandfather who survived the Western Front from Oct 1914 until the end of the war. He was the only one of four brothers to come home. RIP Roderick Campbell Seaforth Highlanders
Same here at a folk club in Ashington, Northumberland. A wonderful evening and when he played this the reverence among the crowd was simply spellbinding
I too saw Eric at a folk club in Scotland - held in the Golden Lion in Stirling, an amazing experience listening to his songs. I served in the Queen's Own Highlanders (Seaforth and Camerons) formed when the Seaforths Amalgamated with the Camerons
Yeah - the first time I actually heard it was on my IET (initial employment training) - a corporal played it on his guitar and sung along. I was at the back of the tent with my sergeants and I could not keep myself from crying. It is a painful song to listen to.
As a Kiwi l feel this song speaks for us as well and, as Kiwi and Aussies have a long history of borrowing from each other, l'm sure none of my cuzzies across the ditch will really mind. Have listened to it so many times and cannot help but shed a tear every time l hear it. Such a terrible terrible waste of life for an impossible task. RIP brave ANZACs. "Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... you are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore, rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side here in this country of ours... You the mothers who sent their sons from far away countries wipe away your tears. Your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well." Mustafa Kemal Atatürk.
@@gillesbourgeois5348 Apparently there is now some doubt as to whether it's true, and/or was really written by him but, it's so beautiful and must have been so comforting to the mothers he mentions, that l don't really care if it isn't true. 😊 Interesting article by Paul Daley about it in the Guardian 8 years ago. I can't post a link but if you Google, it should come up. Ataturk's 'Johnnies and Mehmets' words about the Anzacs are shrouded in doubt
Tears on my face! 😢 When will this Killing will end? I'm a German and I cry for all the soldiers, who gave theyr live. For what? For nothing. Peace for all the people in the world!
I am an officer of the brazilian Army. I never been not even close to a war. But that was the first song in english I could sing along without the written lyrics to see. And I got my eyes wet, for I could see myself stuck in those beach, fearing for my sorry little life. I salut those who fought and fell in the past so we could live in peace. "A paz queremos com fervor; a guerra só nos causa dor; porém, se a Pátria Amada for um dia ultrajada"!...
Kia ora. What a beautiful comment. Thankyou for singing this song. There were other huge challenges at Gallipoli. There was a lack of water. One result of that was the inability to wash. Lice were a maddening problem for Our Boys. They also weren't necessarily able to bury the dead. Consequently, rats knowledge at the faces of the corpses. The rats were very huge due to the food source. Some of our heroes were younger than 19. In New Zealand and Oz, ANZAC day is of profound importance to us. Our national identities are founded on the ANZACs of WW1. The landings and slaughter only began at Gallipoli. A further 4 years away from home followed for our ANZACs, where tens of thousands more died, or were wounded physically and mentally. Of the men who survived, still many more died of influenza in the weeks or months following the war. From my perspective, war also killed these millions of young people also. It touches my heart very much that you have such strong empathy regarding this relatively brief episode in Mankind's appalling history. I hope you never see War up close, Sir.
@seanbayley7452 Yes, let's hope our Brother doesn't see war. I like your compassion too, Bro, and our Friend's. Have you always been very empathetic? I have, and wouldn't want to lose it. Glad you have elements still in tact. There are so, so many ways war can affect a person. You are a reminder to us all of the human cost of trauma. I have just seen the sun rise and I am wondering if you have something nice, or something horrible where you are today or tonight. Are you okay? I hope there are some good and pleasant things in your life , my camerade. (We might be both fighting against hateful thoughts, grief and sufferings, in very different situations). Pain we can share can make it a little bit easier to bear... Thankyou for your comment.
@joao... how aweso me that you learned the words of this English song first. I always honour our ANZACS who fought there, including our Maori and Pacific heroes. But a lot of English, French, Irish and Scottish also fought there. Deep gratitude and respect for the Irish and them all! This is very very sobering. But I honour the Turks, the good men defending their coast. They lost a lot more than us and are special in our hearts now. We have Memorials ALL over the place here in New Zealand. We have a plaque honouring the Turks and our reconciliation in the Memorial Park that is the closest one to my house.
My Grandfather fought in Gallipoli, aged 20 with the Royal Scots Fusiliers. Joining up in early 1915, he sailed from Liverpool on board the 'Mauretania' on 21st May and landed in Gallipoli on June 6th. His battalion of almost 900 men was part of the 52nd division which was approx 10900 strong. The 2 battalions of RSF were immediately put into the line where between July 3rd and July 13th, division losses were 4800 men. He survived being shot on 3 separate occasions, was returned to action each time and spent the best part of three and a half years in the front line, first in Gallipoli and then in The Western Front. He returned home traumatised with the condition which in those days was known as 'shell shock', but is now known as PTSD or 'post traumatic stress disorder'. From the accounts I heard as a child which were heavily sanitised, he came back a changed man and although was able to function in his previous job as a local postman for a few years, had to undergo increasingly long periods of hospitalisation and ultimately, complete incapacity. All the years I knew him he was bedridden, shaking constantly and largely unable to speak more than a few words ata time. Like many others he never received any war disability pension or recognition of his condition as being war injury related. He died in 1967 having fought his war for fifty years.
Never forget. At the going down of the sun and in the morning such reminiscences must be recalled and ‘remembered’ by those that have never known conflict.
I am a veteran of the U.S. Navy. I studied songwriting at the Berklee College of Music. This stunningly beautiful song is one of the most poignant and powerful songs about the horrors of war ever written. I brings tears to my eyes every time I hear it.
@Leila Saleh Thank you for the years you spent in the Navy... Great song, although not the best version... My favorite is The Dubliners or Liam Clancy's version - haven't decided which one I like best... The gentleman singing this does a beautiful version of The Parting Glass (perhaps the best I've ever heard) That is another lovely farewell ballad...
@@roostersbays95 thats, like, just, your opinion, man... I still cry over songs to do with my countries history, i think about the blood spilt and the lives wasted. I think about the loss and sacrafice made. how dare you denegrate someones memories or feelings, just because they don't conform to your view.
My Uncle served in Galipoli with the Lancashire Regiment. As a cousin says he survived the war because of his leg wounds. The same time my Dad was with the RFA in France, he to was wounded twice but returned to duties. Put this song together with the film Gallipoli to appreciate the hell soldiers endure. As a half mile runner in my day, I identify with the lead characters in the film. Yes, I get tearful listening to the song. Dad 50 when I arrived in the 40's, me 80 +. Thanks, joe
I'm an American disabled Army veteran. Thinking this may be our anthem, regardless the flag under which one served, be you friend or former foe. God Bless, and pray for peace unceasingly.
I am 17 years old, my parents are immigrants from South America with no prior ties to Australia, I first heard this song when I was 11 years old. I never heard that song until my teacher made us perform it, I knew the story of Gallipoli and the bravery of the ANZAC troops. I have always been interested in wars fought over the world throughout history, I have seen many photos of ANZAC’s and heard many stories, I look at the faces of those young men who fought representing Australia. All the Aussies were volunteers, many men were my aged who lied to go for an adventure, instead the found hell. Whenever I go back to listen to this song, I always sing along, as I sing I begin to cry because many men fought and died in service of their countries and I can not see myself in their shoes. I am proud to be Australian, and this is a bloody ripper of a song, wish I could be this talented at writing songs.
That the UK of WW1 declared war on Turkey is not well known. Less well known is that Turkey was in a process of refitting / purchasing ships from the UK for their navy when war broke out and told the UK we're not paying u4true. When armed forces are used in defence of their country it makes sense. What makes greater sense is that if all countries only had armed forces to apply this rule there would be no more wars. My grandfather's brother Edgar died at gallipoli ... here are his postcards held at the AWM to get an idea of what must have they been thinking. It wasn't much, they had no clue what was coming their way invading another nations country defended by men of equal courage. eag.life/Media/albums/gallipoli_postcards/album/index.html Smedley Butler wrote a book abt why we suffer from wars .. he called it >War is a racket< th-cam.com/video/EI3lckqaSk0/w-d-xo.html which makes you pensè who engineers and implement these never ending wars ? th-cam.com/video/Sp4h39qJKqU/w-d-xo.html and behind them are the lading matriarchial families of the sabattean frankist families but that's another story.
@@iandaniel2153 Sorry about your Grand Father's brother, my Great Uncle got shot in the head at Flers in 1917 and was sent back to the lines for a further 12 months until he was sent home discharged unfit for duty, died a tragic in '46 , I think you will find that the British renegged on the sale of the two ships which had been paid for by a public subscription by the Turks, , as war had broken out the Brits decided to keep the two ships, Lest We Forget
He must have played the song many times in his life and, yet, he still sings with full heart and intensitiy. I heard this song for the first time in a pub in Germany. At some point during the night, a guest rose and sang this song without instrumental accompaniment. I could not hold back my tears.
In 1971 I served in Vietnam with a combined force of American and Aussie soldiers. The remarkable, upbeat spirit demonstrated by the Australian infantryman remains in my memory 50 years after this event. This beautiful song is a fitting tribute to both forces.
Eric Bogle has written two of the most formidable and intelligent anti-war songs ever written. He oozes gentleness, humility and generosity of spirit. The world could use more Eric Bogles. Many many more.
I actually know Eric personally because my grandparents are good friends with him. A few weeks ago he reserved tickets to a concert of his for my grandparents bc they were all sold out
I graduated high school in 1970. One day a diploma and the next a draft card. Many went to Nam, some came home in body bags. It wasn't a real declared war and there were lots of protests. Those of us that came home weren't considered heros or patriots. We were hated and spat on for fighting over there. It wasn't our fault and we only obeyed the law of join the service or go to prison. One class mate and his fiancee had their car packed the night of graduation. After our all night graduation party dispersed at 6am the next morning they drove off to Canada. I did then and I still feel he made the right choice.
2 years behind you so Vietnam would've been my war. Went to college with my draft card in my trunk, still have that trunk and my draft card. My dad told me if I had to go, to not volunteer for anything--I'm pretty many fathers over many wars gave that same sage advice. My dad would've known. WWII was his war. 13 years after he died, I discovered a Bronze Star/Valor attachment that I never knew he had. I don't know why I'm writing this. Soldiers of all countries pay the price of wars made by the politicians who rarely pay.
What a great team Eric Bogle and John Munro - two great Scots that became great Aussies. Eric rightly wears his Member of the Order of Australia lapel pin on his jacket . Please keep on keeping on. RIP John Munro - missed by us all these past 4 years.
Hello from the States, my Great Grandfather was a "digger" with the 1st Battalion (Sydney) A.I.F. ANZAC at Gallipoli. Never met him, died from his wounds in 1941, but I am damn proud to be the great grandson of an ANZAC! Mr. Bogle, thank you for writing and performing such a powerful song.
I was a crew chief on an USA OH 6A helicopter in Vietnam (1968). We went down in Indian Country. I was scared. We radioed for help. Nobody could get us except an Australian crew on an UH Bell helicopter. Thank you Australia. I'll be ever grateful and visited Australia in 1969. Eaglegards...
That's what Ozzies do Mate! I recall from being a small kid in England during WW 2 at Bomber Airfields in Yorkshire (where I lived) and in Lincolnshire where my Aunty lived. The Aussies were easily identified. Different uniforms with AUSTRALIA on the Shoulder Badge. Many never got back to Australia.
The Royal Australian Navy sent a helicopter detachment to be embedded with the US Army in South Vietnam. They were in country for several years so you may well have been rescued by the RAN.
>I was only 19 a walk in the light green< by Redgum does it for me and as Smedley Butler, the highest decorated marine in USA's history wrote his book abt war in the 1930's ... titled "War is a racket" and so it always has been and still is.
@@iandaniel2153 I'll look for this. I spent 2 years in the Territorial Army 🇬🇧 at the end of the Cold War so I knew if the proverbial hit the fan I'd be involved. WW1 seemed such a terrible waste of human life though. I think the Nazis had to be stopped though. Hindsight is perfect vision unfortunately.
I first heard Eric Bogle sing this song at the Winnipeg Folk Festival in mid-seventies. It made me cry and it has done so every time I've heard it since.
The way John watched Eric so carefully during the whole song was so moving. They’ve probably played this a thousand time but he is so attentive to every subtle change.
197 "dislikes" (at this writing)? How can anyone dislike this song? This along with Bogle's "Green Fields of France" are the two most moving antiwar songs that know.
I disliked it because Eric Bogle is a Scottish musician, who presumed to critisise Australian veterans for marching on ANZAC Day, without bothering to ask them why they march. ANZAC Day is a commemoration of those died in the service of our country, not a jingoistic celebration of war as that idiot paints it to be. The song is pretty but bloody disrespectful.
I was a soldier. I was injured through an ied. I àm proud to have been a soldier. But this song , I am broken. IAM crying. I am broken. I have been to Gallipoli, I have seen the memorials. Oh my God , I am broken tonight. There is nothing else but to believe. God help us, please
bugler75 - A VN era vet reaching out to you. I hope you're working thru your rough patch. I did 3 tours with UDT & SEAL Team '69-'71. When I got out it was a WWII vet who jumped in the night before D-Day & fought thru the hedgerows and on into Germany who helped me re-adjust to civilian life. So I hope you are reaching out to other Vets - they'll understand and support you. Family can support but other combat vets "understand" on that visceral level. I first heard this song from my SEAL Team mate Bob Kerrey when he sang it at his '88 Senate campaign celebration. He lost his leg & was awarded the MOH. Just got back from a "Alive Day" 50th celebration for my buddy who lost his leg in an aircraft crash. He wound up marrying his Navy nurse, raised 4 boys who are fine men now & he became a computer professor who guided many young students. So my message to you is hang in there mate. If you're still hurting - reach out to me at my email.
I was a soldier too and thankfully got home okay, changed but okay. I’ve made a new life. My dear Dad was not so lucky, a mine at El Alamein crippled him for life. I remember and shed a tear for him, for you too now bugler. I’ll remember you both, and some others besides, whenever I hear this wonderful song. I don’t know what drives us to war, some kind of madness.
I don't believe there will ever be a lovelier song written about the sacrifices of men in war than this one. Thank you, Eric, for creating a masterpiece that will live forever.
@MusicMadMaurice Here is Noman's Land (aka Fields of France) another Eric Bogle song recorded with his permission. th-cam.com/video/1eYGQG9aVZU/w-d-xo.html
It didnt make him the most popular man in Australia initally, but the song has stood the test of time and proven Eric right. Delighted to have heard him perform the song at the Old Pathe Hotel in Roscrea , the best two man gig ever. Nothing better than the writer and composer singing his own sog, with his interpretation uncomprimised.
Our son, born Welsh is now an Aussie. He loves his new land and the history behind its creation but like me When Australia play Wales he will cheer for his land of birth. ME I've seen the the Legerwood carved trees and marvel at how the carving conveys what happened to the !8 husbands/boyfriends who were killed in the war. So Australians this old fella love Australia as well.
What a song, it has to be the most powerful Aussie song by a foreigner of all time. RIP to all the Aussie's and all the Turks that lost their lives in the war.
I landed in Australia a couple of days after Christmas 1977 on my first visit there. Mates picked me up and took me on a guided tour of the pubs of Sydney. In every one I noticed old timers sitting in the dark corners. Whenever it was time for another round I was told by each bartender that mine was taken care of. Even if it was my turn to buy the round it was always, "yours is right mate". Later that evening I was told those old timers were all Returned Soldiers who were signaling the bar tender they were buying mine. That was because they hadn't forgotten the large presence of U.S. military there during World War Two kept the resource-hungry Japanese from landing. It was really put together a few days later when I was taken to the National War Memorials in Canberra. But none of those experiences can match what this song just did to my insides. A deep, respectful Vale to all who served and particularly those who gave all.
Glad you had a good time here Joe. My Aunt married an American who was on R&R in Sydney during the Vietnam War. He made a life for himself in Australia post war. When it was my turn to go to the sandpit he sat me down for a talk before and then after when I got home. He's no longer with us but a good man, appreciated him looking out for me in that regard.
As a fellow Scotsman settled now in Melbourne Australia, I have nothing but love and respect for the 62,000 souls who sacrificed to afford us this beautiful country. Thank you for this reminder, LEST WE FORGET......
My great uncle who I was named after was slaughtered in France. I was named after him. His brother served. My father, my brothers , my uncles, we all served. This song still brings tears to my eyes. Now people thank me for my service. I don't take it well. For so many reasons i can't describe. We did our duty. It was our duty. Thank the crosses and those who never recovered.
Hello Australian and New Zealand friends. İ am from Turkey. This song very sad and very kindfull. Respect from Turkey. Yes we won this "war" but many brave man "lost" in here. And our greatest leader Mustafa Kemal ATATÜRK wrote a letter (1934) for parents and families: "Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... You are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side now here in this country of ours... you, the mothers, who sent their sons from faraway countries wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land. They have become our sons as well." This words maybe a little drop for peoples but it means a lot of things for us. Your grandfathers and our grandfathers still "sleeping" together in the our fields. Because we dont say "they are dead" we say "They are last heroic martrys". Come and see their monuments on the ÇANAKKALE (Gallipoli) You are welcome... "After having lost their lives on this land. They have become our sons as well."
Halis ÖZTÜRK thanks for posting that beautiful poem,, yes we are brothers in peace, laying side by side underground, the turks and the aussie have a special bond , a comradship un equalled,,
Im a Royal Australian Air Force veteran, who served for 8 years and discharged as a CPL at 28. I completed 2 trips to the Middle East, and this songs just hits so so hard. My grandfather was an ANZAC, and this just hits the soul. I cant wait for ANZAC day this year to have a few beers with my mates.
I served in the U.S. Marines in Vietnam in 1969-1970. I heard this song for the first time in 1978 on NPR in California and was smitten with the powerful lyrics and it resonated with my experiences in a much later conflict. However it was not until I moved to Australia in the early 1980s and understood the impact that he Battle of Gallipoli had on the psyche and the identity of Australia. The song took on a new layer of texture with my new home. 41 years now after I first head this song it still rings home. It’s message transcends wars, the sides are irrelevant. It’s about sacrifice, honour, commitment and dare I say, the futility of war? Both Eric Bogle and John Williamson do this song proud.... and as we just celebrated 104th anniversary of the Battle of Gallipoli or Canakkale as the Turks called it. We have just celebrated the 103rd ANZAC Day, and while I did not serve here in Australia, the message resonates true for all of us, for all sides of any conflict.....Lest We Forget.
LW In Aus as an Aussie soldier of 21 years. Who served in Somalia. Thank you for getting to know the story. You can here a pin drop when this is played. Very few dry eyes. Brave men with chests full of medals wipe the dust from their eyes because it can’t be tears. Our Iwo Jima.
I am an old veteran who served with men now gone. I often think of them as they were when we were all young and proud. I was born before WW2 and will die in the 21st century. I don’t know why I have lived this long, except perhaps to honor their memory.
I live in a small village in NSW. We have the remembrance in the main street for 3 blocks. The trees were planted by the wives and families of those that did not return. There are 109 trees. Just devastating for a small community. I bought this as a 45 when it was released. Was RAAF then. The 45 is long gone but not lost as I regularly listen to this song. War is crap but when needed. I come from a military family but stopped at the generation under me. Even today at 64 my country calls ...................................
Remember what a guy ar work told me about Viet Nam . He said he had to go - his father told him , he had gone in WW2 & it was his turn Also most young men would rather be DEAD , than called a coward. Works out nicely .
I agree one of the best song's ever written, each year I remember my Dad, My Uncle and my wife's Daddy who all served in WW2 and came home okay. My dad crossed the bar in 2006 and my wife's Daddy US Army passed on Christmas Day 2006, my Uncle served on the HMS Kelly with Lord Mountbatten
One of the best anti-war songs ever written that clearly displays the lunacy of war and the harm done to the young men who are sent off to fight by politicians who would rarely do it themselves.
Men fight wars for several reasons, greed, lust for power, and lust for what someone else has. It take a brave a courageous nation to enter a war, with the idea that they will make it right for the ones attacked. Even at best, some will forget and become as evil as the ones they are trying to defeat.
Aint that the truth....warmongers/bankers sending innocents to the slaughter. EVERY war has been carried out to fuel the Military Industrial Complex...and their $$ backers. Most decent people on this planet just want to live in peace...
Perhaps one of the most powerful songs ever written. The words should be studied by every school student a week before ANZAC day so they will have a very clear understanding what war is all about and the suffering that so many heroes endured. Thank you Eric Bogle for making it as it really was.
This song & the memorial at Monte Casino shows the utter stupidity of war. My dad said that if leaders want a war stick them in a field & let them get on with it. He survived WW11, would fight if needed to protect family, didn't agree with war.
I so agree. often we listen to the music but pay little attention to the words. This is a most unresting story of pain and suffering. I am sadden with no words to add.
@@007JHS Two of the most powerful anti-war songs I know (tho there are others, for sure.) Written in close chronology by a young, gay man, which I don't think is coincidental. And both draw some of their power by referencing other songs that have power and resonance.
I discovered this song on a charity shop CD of the Dubliners who were singing it, and it would all ways get to me. My Grandfather George was Australian and fortunately left OZ in 1914 with his brother Sam. They were welcomed and settled in Brampton Huntingdon England. I say fortunate because he avoided WW1 and met Emma my Grandmother and when he tried to enlist in the forces in England but was turned down, they said he wasn't fit enough or maybe to dark?. My Dad was born early in 1916 and given the name of Royal which seems a bit over the top. We don't think Dad was told who he was named after but recent research revealed that Joseph, Grandads eldest brother had a son who died in Alexandria Hospital Egypt having been shot in Gallipoli in July 1915 He was named Royal. A wonderful song but I can't take it too often.
I attended an ANZAC dawn parade when I was serving with the UN in Nicosia. A Turkish officer marched down to the border point and passed a wreath across to an Aussie officer. After the silence a big Irish army sergeant major sung this song acapella. Not a dry eye on parade...
musr have been very moving in rome afew years ago visited monte casino and the graveyard there lots of young men some of them scots i cried all the way back to rome war is hell linda in scotland
I suspect he would have sung the original Waltzing Matilda - no disrespect to Eric Bogle - but the original is the unofficial australian national anthem.
This song was written by singer-songwriter Eric Bogle himself. He was born in Scotland in 1944 and emigrated to Australia in 1969. Being anti-war over Australians fighting in Vietnam at that time inspired him to write this song in 1971.
I've had several conversations with Australian servicemembers when I was deployed. This song has the same effect for the Aussies that "Ashoken Farewell" has for other older Americans. It's a surprisingly recent tune that paints a very real picture, of the pain and futility of war. Much love and respect from Virginia.
I first heard this song many many years ago. I had no idea then that I would one day stand in the Murrays green basin, nor that I would one day serve in the Australian Army, catch a ferry from Circular Quay, wear the slouch hat, march through Sydney on ANZAC day, or stand in uniform in an RSL with men who had landed at Gallipoli. As a young man you never know where life’s twists and turns wil take you.
So good to hear this song again. Utterly beautiful and devastatingly sad at the same time. How anyone could not appreciate this tune is beyond me. Thank you Eric Bogle for your magnificent contribution to Australian art and mythology.
The generations forward will not let these stories die, the men who gave their lives will live on in these beautiful songs. -a 24 year old American man.
I grew up listening to Walzing Mathilda but never knew what it was about. I am almost 70 and live in 🇨🇦 Canada. My parents are British. I love your song and wish Governments knew what it cost to go to war. Thank you.
Im australian. My grandfather was 1 of the last to leave Gallipoli. Im so happy past is past. Now that terrible war is replaced with love and friendship. So thank you and i wish you all the happyness. 😁👍
During my college years I served as a counselor in our Vets Center. I've seen what war can do to a young man. The world never learns. Young man fight old men's wars. Blessings Georgie.
As a 16 year old I learned about Gallipoli in history and 2 or 3 years later I first heard this song performed by The Piques. It blew me away then and still does. I have listened to many versions since, but strangely enough this is the first time hearing the original songwriter sing it. It is just as powerful as ever and constantly reminds me of the futility of war and how little politicians thought about the regular army soldiers who then routinely threw into battles that could never be won.
How true. Winston Churchill as a young politician with no experience chose Gallipoli as the location. He was responsible but not accountable. The British treated Australians like convict dogs. Dispensible cannon fodder.
Eric Bogle is absolutely one of the world's bets writers. Thisbl song olis so poignant for ANZ, but his best song was Green Fields of France. A master.
Lovely, he has a way with the words does Eric. I mind meeting him a few times and listening to himself, playing his guitar, singing and playing in his Skiffle group in Peebles when I was a wee laddie many, many years ago. A while back I heard him singing a song he'd composed called Journeys. It had me in tears. At that time back then in the very late 1950s/ early 1960s, my father was an alcoholic and I was in the care of a local Dr Barnardo's children's home in Peebles called Craigerne. Many a time I used to walk along the banks of the Tweed like Eric engrossed in my own thoughts back then. Aye like I said, Eric has a way with the words .......in his song " Journeys" he expressed my thoughts in a way that I couldn't. Thankyou Eric.
am Dutch, and have no bonds with Australia, only a nephew and niece live in Australia with their families.. but this song hits me deep over and over again..
@@Frannis Me too. I've heard this original version and many other covers too, but for me MacGowans is the best because he brings so much bitterness to the part which I think suits it the best. The other versions are just sadness and helplessness and ring empty to me. MacGowans seems more genuine. Also for all the people arguing about gallipolli and the turks, you do know this was an anti war song written about Vietnam at the time of Vietnam right? Bogle just changed the subject to galipolli so it would be more popular here with the ANZAC mythology.
One of the best war songs in my opinion and as an Australian, I play it every ANZAC Day. My late father served in Korea and have always been immensely proud of the sacrifices he made to serve for this country. He was English and was trained in both the British and Australian Armies. I would watch him march and look at him in awe with all his medals on. Today is about all wars that should never be forgotten. Lest we forget!
Many years ago, a friend of mine used to play this song. It effected me so much that I had to leave the room when he played it. This is one of the greatest anti-war songs of all time.
As a proud Australian every time I hear this beautiful song I think of my Grandfather who served with the 4th Battalion A.I.F (ANZAC) in Gallipoli, I only hope we don't lose everything they died for , Lest we forget
A most stirring song. I’m also a singer and a few years ago I visited Gallipoli on Anzac Day . The song resonated in my head the whole time. I was at a gathering of Australian tourists, and many Turkish people and I sang this song. Tears flowed everywhere . It was probably the most memorable performance I’ve ever given. 😢
My Great Grandfather, a Londoner in the Royal Hampshire Regiment perished at sea in a troopship off the Greek Island of Kos while en route from Alexandria Egypt to Gallipoli on August 13th. 1915. His ship, the Royal Edward was sunk by a German U-Boat. They were hit at 9:00 a.m. during a lifeboat drill and he and over 900 others were lost when it went down 15 minutes later. He was 31. This song starkly illuminates what was in store for these unsung heroes had they made it to Gallipoli. Getting there was one thing. Getting through it and out of there alive was entirely another.
I attended the centenary celebration in Gallipoli in 2015. Sleeping on that hallowed ground prior to dawn, most likely atop bones of brave ANZACS, was an experience I’ll never, ever take for granted or forget. Bless those diggers and all service men and women. Proud Aussie.
I have heard many versions of this very moving song but no one can put this beautiful rendition more emotionally than Eric, for a person to write such moving words surely is a God given talent, thank you Eric.
As a Vietnam veteran who served two years as an exchange officer at the Royal Australian School of Artillery in the mid-70s, this song touched me on several levels.
I cried my heart out listening to this song , may all the aussie and turks who died in Gallipoli rest in eternal peace , What a song ,no words can describe the emotions i felt ,thankyou for this song
Eric and late John. I'm an Australian on the banks of the Murray.I return to this song often. Never before have the conflicts of war been expressed and played so well. I forever thank you.
I first learned of the importance of Anzac day on a Princess Cruise from Barcelona to Istanbul. As we passed Gallipoli, they made an announcement that they would shut down the engines briefly and encouraged us to join with Australians on board for a wreath laying ceremony. It was solemnly done off the coast, looking up at the virtually impenetrable ridge line. As soon as we got underway again, a pod of dolphins surfaced an escorted us onward. Since then, I've educated myself about this overwhelming bit of history. This song makes me cry and feel a deep kinship with Australians.
Sadly this song will water down our history it’s wrong and Waltzing Matilda should not be on it first 3 mistakes Aus all volunteered no one was sent, Australians didn’t land at Suvla we didn’t wear tin hats,
Funny about the dolphins ... purportedly the ancient Greeks believed that dolphins had the souls of men lost at sea which was given as the reason why they frequently escort ships and boats. My father was in the Royal Australian Navy prior to and during WWII and he said dolphins often escorted vessels he served on.
Today is ANZAC Day and as we couldn’t congregate at the local RSL or have a parade in the city due to COVID-19, we were encouraged to have our own service at home on our driveway by lighting a candle and listening to the service provided by the local radio station. I did this with my partner and a neighbour and his wife. Later I sang Eric Bogle’s song as I do every ANZAC Day. However, I have only ever heard The Pogues version and for the first time today searched for the original version. I love the story of how Eric wrote it after watching a parade in Australia. Such poignant lyrics!
@@pdenn1s Sorry mate, but I think that @Vanessa Burnett-Read's comment sounds like anything BUT an excuse to drink beer. Read it properly please. I've had a quick look at your TH-cam link, and I'll definitely be having a look at the video. Thank you very much for sharing. Take care, and go gently.
I totally love The Pogues and have done so for many years, but I must admit I have always found Shane McGowan's rendition of this song less than ideal. In my opinion, when The Pogues did a song well, well, they were on fire! But the fact cannot be escaped that, at times, they could be absolute shite! I say this as a committed fan of The Pogues. And also may I add, as a proud father of a 24 year old son who told me the other day that he has ordered a framed print-out of the lyrics of The Pogues' version of the song "Broad Majestic Shannon." That's the sort of thing that brings tears to my eyes. Like this version of "The Band Played Waltzing Matilda." which I have previously known of, and knew that it was by Eric Bogle, who I had no idea was, like myself, originally from Scotland. I must say that I have never been, nor I am ever likely to be an adherent to the ANZAC myth, however this song not only brought tears to my eyes, but also sent a shiver up my spine. 12/10
@@louisspeer1255 Not a fan of jingoism, sorry mate. If waving flags and lighting candles makes you feel better then fine, I'm just a little jaded about the whole idea.
@@pdenn1s No worries. I hope you don't think that I'm into "waving flags and lighting candles, and especially jingoism" because I'm not. And I'm not into Anzac Day at all. Never have been. I think that it's a horrible creation, and worse still, it's political manipulation on a grand scale. There's an excellent book called "What's wrong with ANZAC? : the militarisation of Australian history" by Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds with Mark McKenna and Joy Damousi. They describe how John Howard and his cronies were instrumental in creating this modern wave of Anzac patriotism largely through funding the Department of Veterans Affairs for this specific purpose. The end result is that, due to the consequent drop in funding for its core tasks, the DVA now does much less of what it was originally formed to do, which was to support war widows and widowers and the rehabilitation and support of returned veterans. I think that may be the reason why there are these new charities like Soldier On and Mates 4 Mates etc springing up. Another thing they wrote about in the book was that they researched contemporaneous newspaper articles from 1915, and their conclusion was that rather than being lauded as heroes, a lot of other Allied soldiers and the press were actually very critical of the Australian soldiers and described most of them as "garrulous thugs." Anyway, my post was really about how impressed I am with the quality of the song and the musicianship of the guitarist in particular, plus comparing it to The Pogues' version. I wasn't supporting or criticising her post in any way. I have met a few Vietnam Vets in my time and can't begrudge them anything. It was their own personal experience, and I think they have their own valid reasons for being how they are, whatever that means. What I believe is truly reprehensible is the way the governments of the day played "wedge" politics and divided the entire nation. On purpose. It was totally despicable how they treated the returned vets, and virtually encouraged people to treat vets in the way they did. I am totally against war, always have been and always will be. As a tourist, I've visited places like Vietnam and Afghanistan (though only in transit through Kabul, but that was enough) and have been caught in the crossfire during riots in India and even a revolution in Kathmandu. This all happened in 1990. All because I simply happened to be there at the time. I thought I'd put all that behind me, but no I managed to nearly get caught up in 9/11 - fortunately I was 3 hours away in Connecticut at the time. Anyway, that's my little reply. You should put your post back up though, your opinion still matters, and I think that it's important that people have the opportunity to discover the Long Tan story. And My Lai too.
I've heard this song played many times, but never with so much genuine feeling. This and the iconic Redgum song "I was only 19" are the most moving songs of this genre. May the sacrifice on both sides never be forgotten and may we one day all have the courage to stand up to the war mongers that start these conflicts.
I was a British soldier for 23 years, so In no way am I a pacifist, but this song makes me weep. Wars are started by politicians, fought by soldiers, won by the blood of soldiers and victory claimed by the politicians, who then abandon the soldiers.
What makes it worse is that they profit from it. Blood money. :(
you got that right
Exactly.
sad ,and o so true.
I heard this for the first time today on my community radio station. It was a different version that I can’t find. When he broke into the actual Waltzing Matilda chorus, I broke down crying in the car. It was as if someone had reached into my chest and ripped my heart out. So unexpected and so powerful.
ERIC BOGLE wrote and sang this song at an Australian music contest. When the judges awarded him 3rd place, the audience rioted.
Gotta love those Aussies.
I didn't know that. Very interesting.
Everyone forgets the true power lies with the people united in purpose
Currently the same now - over some bloke who stabbed women, and the polce did bugger-all.
Are the Aussies the only men left in the world who know what's right?
@@blatherskite9601not sure mate, it seemed to be an Aussie guy who was stabbing women and kids in the mall.
Aussie woman shot the bugger though.
@@tomnovak8350 i had thought he took out 1st prize. It was so heart rending n brought tears to my eyes. What a waste of lives.
One of the greatest songs ever written.
I’m a veteran and this song is so on point. God bless the Aussie solders. 🇺🇸
God Bless you .... x
❤
I enlisted in the Marines in 1966. Deployed to Vietnam in April of 1967. Spent 13 months on the DMZ from Con Thien to Khe Sanh. War is Hell. We accomplished nothing only to hopefully make it back home. This song really hits hard to the futility of war...there are no winners. I cry for friends who took their last breath 10,000 miles from home. And for a childhood friend who took his life from the scars of that damn war. RIP Danny :(
Love this song...It's almost Irish.
I hear you man....I'm an Irish man who are neutral in all wars but what would the world be like without people like you and your mates who fight so we can carry on with the freedom that we have in our daily lives. I just want to express my gratitude for all of you heros who should be so proud of yourselves...I have so much respect for yous....thank you from John
sorry for the loss of your friend Danny.
..there are no winners. So true. May there be peace. 🙏
rip danny, thanks lad. and my deepest regrets you went the way you did
Semper Fi
Heart weary. My husband lost both of his legs in Vietnam. The men that return from war, whole or not, are forever changed and must not be invisible.
They aren't, they will never be invisible. We don't ever forget them. I thank your husband and all his comrades for their sacrifice. I think of them all the time.
I was lucky to get back from 2 tours in one piece and then got torn apart when I returned. We just weren't the flavor of the month. Socially unacceptable. Jobs? Veterans need not apply.😊
I am grateful for your service. Thank you for keeping us safe.
Without y'all Europe would not have enjoyed the longest period of peace in history.
We ❤ them lest we forget
I am ex military, I am a guitarist of sorts and could learn to play this but for the life of me I could not sing it without breaking down in tears....
Bless you.... please learn the song if only to honor yourself and the tears of us all.
...and the young people ask: “what are they marching for?” Right there is the nub of the problem. How quickly the world forgets.
You are blessed..We are grateful for you sacrificed the most😌
Same here
I was thinking the exact same thing.
It is an absolute outrage for TH-cam to allow this sacred song to be interrupted by any advertisement. This song is about the birth of the ANZAC legend and no one has a right to defile it with ads.
Exactly what I was thinking
It's not just this song, YT does advertising now in longer songs, which is a Nogo, and in this song additionally disrespectful.
Google which own TH-cam has no respect for nothing. Along with facebook. They are just shitheads. I use to forward fast as it was allowed back then. Now I just ignore them.
Cheers
Agreed
Correct
This has to be one of the most moving songs about the futility of war ever written.
decisions made by politicians and the sacrifice in blood by ordinary young men and women....and in the final wash up for WWI FOR WHAT....they even sowed the seed in the final ARMISTICE FOR another world war but at least that one had JUSTIFACTION
Eric has said that if he knew, when he wrote it, how popular this song would be he would have taken more care (!). It is PERFECT, Eric. ❤
@@jacquismith3277 Agreed, It's perfect. Gets your emotions going, don't think he could have made it any better.
after hearingthos you watch "Das Boot" the film version!!
Just brought me to tears again
I first heard this song while a U.S. Marine, fifty-three years ago. I cried then. I cry now. Semper Fidelis
Me too
It breaks your heart to think what ordinary people will do when it comes down to it!
It makes me cry every time I hear it.
Have you heard the green fields of France.
If not I advise you to give it a listen.
It would bring a tear to a glass eye.
reading this almost made me cry.
I was lucky enough to see Eric live at a small folk club in Scotland.
For me when I hear the song I remember my grandfather who survived the Western Front from Oct 1914 until the end of the war. He was the only one of four brothers to come home.
RIP Roderick Campbell
Seaforth Highlanders
Same here at a folk club in Ashington, Northumberland. A wonderful evening and when he played this the reverence among the crowd was simply spellbinding
Seaforth Highlanders... Yikes ! Canadian
@@happycamper848 No. The Scottish Seaforths.
@@irc6587hopscotch
I too saw Eric at a folk club in Scotland - held in the Golden Lion in Stirling, an amazing experience listening to his songs. I served in the Queen's Own Highlanders (Seaforth and Camerons) formed when the Seaforths Amalgamated with the Camerons
Not ashamed to say that this song always makes me cry. Bravo!
Yeah - the first time I actually heard it was on my IET (initial employment training) - a corporal played it on his guitar and sung along. I was at the back of the tent with my sergeants and I could not keep myself from crying. It is a painful song to listen to.
As a Kiwi l feel this song speaks for us as well and, as Kiwi and Aussies have a long history of borrowing from each other, l'm sure none of my cuzzies across the ditch will really mind. Have listened to it so many times and cannot help but shed a tear every time l hear it. Such a terrible terrible waste of life for an impossible task. RIP brave ANZACs.
"Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... you are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore, rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side here in this country of ours... You the mothers who sent their sons from far away countries wipe away your tears. Your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land they have become our sons as well."
Mustafa Kemal Atatürk.
Thanks bro! Cher! Respect from Australia 👍👌👊👊👊
Kemal really wrote that? I wouldn't expect that from Erdogan.
Ofcourse this beautiful Anthem refers to New Zealanders as well. It is dedicated to the ANZAC.
@@gillesbourgeois5348 Apparently there is now some doubt as to whether it's true, and/or was really written by him but, it's so beautiful and must have been so comforting to the mothers he mentions, that l don't really care if it isn't true. 😊
Interesting article by Paul Daley about it in the Guardian 8 years ago. I can't post a link but if you Google, it should come up.
Ataturk's 'Johnnies and Mehmets' words about the Anzacs are shrouded in doubt
@@lynneburridge9082 Yeah. Good point Lynne. 🙂
To put an ad in the middle of this song is unforgivable !
I hope you have an ad blocker by now.
Lol
Absolutely disgusting
If anyone can listen to that without shedding a tear then they don't have a pulse....
Sad yet beautiful xxx
Ken Norton .oh this song means so much to me,memories not nice ones.tears and tears for everyone affected 😢 💔
They're called politicians and they're doing it again in Ukraine. It's not just Putin!
Whenever i need a cry, this song (especially this version), does it for me. Please God, no more war.
Such a sad song. Love to watch Eric singing it. So emotional
😢🇨🇦🌹
Tears on my face! 😢 When will this Killing will end?
I'm a German and I cry for all the soldiers, who gave theyr live. For what? For nothing.
Peace for all the people in the world!
Mankind has never understood peace and love to absolutely everybody.
I am an officer of the brazilian Army. I never been not even close to a war. But that was the first song in english I could sing along without the written lyrics to see. And I got my eyes wet, for I could see myself stuck in those beach, fearing for my sorry little life. I salut those who fought and fell in the past so we could live in peace. "A paz queremos com fervor; a guerra só nos causa dor; porém, se a Pátria Amada for um dia ultrajada"!...
Btw Brazil had forces in Vietnam, a very Australian war. Rarely acknowledged.
Kia ora.
What a beautiful comment. Thankyou for singing this song.
There were other huge challenges at Gallipoli.
There was a lack of water. One result of that was the inability to wash. Lice were a maddening problem for Our Boys.
They also weren't necessarily able to bury the dead. Consequently, rats knowledge at the faces of the corpses. The rats were very huge due to the food source.
Some of our heroes were younger than 19.
In New Zealand and Oz, ANZAC day is of profound importance to us. Our national identities are founded on the ANZACs of WW1.
The landings and slaughter only began at Gallipoli. A further 4 years away from home followed for our ANZACs, where tens of thousands more died, or were wounded physically and mentally.
Of the men who survived, still many more died of influenza in the weeks or months following the war.
From my perspective, war also killed these millions of young people also.
It touches my heart very much that you have such strong empathy regarding this relatively brief episode in Mankind's appalling history.
I hope you never see War up close, Sir.
@seanbayley7452 Yes, let's hope our Brother doesn't see war.
I like your compassion too, Bro, and our Friend's.
Have you always been very empathetic? I have, and wouldn't want to lose it.
Glad you have elements still in tact.
There are so, so many ways war can affect a person.
You are a reminder to us all of the human cost of trauma.
I have just seen the sun rise and I am wondering if you have something nice, or something horrible where you are today or tonight.
Are you okay?
I hope there are some good and pleasant things in your life , my camerade. (We might be both fighting against hateful thoughts, grief and sufferings, in very different situations). Pain we can share can make it a little bit easier to bear...
Thankyou for your comment.
@joao... how aweso me that you learned the words of this English song first.
I always honour our ANZACS who fought there, including our Maori and Pacific heroes.
But a lot of English, French, Irish and Scottish also fought there. Deep gratitude and respect for the Irish and them all! This is very very sobering.
But I honour the Turks, the good men defending their coast.
They lost a lot more than us and are special in our hearts now.
We have Memorials ALL over the place here in New Zealand. We have a plaque honouring the Turks and our reconciliation in the Memorial Park that is the closest one to my house.
A song written and sang by a Scottish Australian a border man lowland scot
My Grandfather fought in Gallipoli, aged 20 with the Royal Scots Fusiliers. Joining up in early 1915, he sailed from Liverpool on board the 'Mauretania' on 21st May and landed in Gallipoli on June 6th. His battalion of almost 900 men was part of the 52nd division which was approx 10900 strong. The 2 battalions of RSF were immediately put into the line where between July 3rd and July 13th, division losses were 4800 men.
He survived being shot on 3 separate occasions, was returned to action each time and spent the best part of three and a half years in the front line, first in Gallipoli and then in The Western Front. He returned home traumatised with the condition which in those days was known as 'shell shock', but is now known as PTSD or 'post traumatic stress disorder'. From the accounts I heard as a child which were heavily sanitised, he came back a changed man and although was able to function in his previous job as a local postman for a few years, had to undergo increasingly long periods of hospitalisation and ultimately, complete incapacity. All the years I knew him he was bedridden, shaking constantly and largely unable to speak more than a few words ata time. Like many others he never received any war disability pension or recognition of his condition as being war injury related.
He died in 1967 having fought his war for fifty years.
Never forget, and always push this story forward into next generations.
My absolute respect to that fella. Thanks for sharing
Never forget. At the going down of the sun and in the morning such reminiscences must be recalled and ‘remembered’ by those that have never known conflict.
So so sorry,,,what a waste
😭😭
I am a vet and this song makes me tear, every time I hear it :(
Do you treat only dogs and cats, or also exotics and farm animals?
@@etheldingleberry8075 A veteran USMC
@@stephenoneill1805ah- so ‘vet’ as in “veteran” rather than “veterinarian.” I’m not impressed anymore.
I am a veteran of the U.S. Navy. I studied songwriting at the Berklee College of Music. This stunningly beautiful song is one of the most poignant and powerful songs about the horrors of war ever written. I brings tears to my eyes every time I hear it.
@Leila Saleh
Thank you for the years you spent in the Navy...
Great song, although not the best version...
My favorite is The Dubliners or Liam Clancy's version - haven't decided which one I like best...
The gentleman singing this does a beautiful version of The Parting Glass (perhaps the best I've ever heard)
That is another lovely farewell ballad...
are you familiar with Green Fields of France (Willie McBride) ? th-cam.com/video/ATq5YZLDkQI/w-d-xo.html
@@roostersbays95 thats, like, just, your opinion, man... I still cry over songs to do with my countries history, i think about the blood spilt and the lives wasted. I think about the loss and sacrafice made. how dare you denegrate someones memories or feelings, just because they don't conform to your view.
The Joan Baez version is wonderful too...
Hats off to you sister,you have my thanks and my utmost respect ♥
My Uncle served in Galipoli with the Lancashire Regiment. As a cousin says he survived the war because of his leg wounds. The same time my Dad was with the RFA in France, he to was wounded twice but returned to duties. Put this song together with the film Gallipoli to appreciate the hell soldiers endure. As a half mile runner in my day, I identify with the lead characters in the film. Yes, I get tearful listening to the song. Dad 50 when I arrived in the 40's, me 80 +. Thanks, joe
I am from Lancashire but I was an Australian Army Officer and the Lancs won 5 VC's before breakfast in this appalling campaign. Lions led by donkeys.
Perhaps the best "war" song ever written.
Don't you mean ANTI WAR?
@@johnboyle5865 Note the quotation marks .
BROTHERS IN ARMS also good!
Agree, ‘I was only 19’ is up there too. Both make me solemn. 😢
@@mareecardinale4331 In a field in France...Kevin Johnson ot Jimmy Little
I'm an American disabled Army veteran. Thinking this may be our anthem, regardless the flag under which one served, be you friend or former foe. God Bless, and pray for peace unceasingly.
Yes, it’s universal… and ongoing. 😢
I am 17 years old, my parents are immigrants from South America with no prior ties to Australia, I first heard this song when I was 11 years old. I never heard that song until my teacher made us perform it, I knew the story of Gallipoli and the bravery of the ANZAC troops. I have always been interested in wars fought over the world throughout history, I have seen many photos of ANZAC’s and heard many stories, I look at the faces of those young men who fought representing Australia. All the Aussies were volunteers, many men were my aged who lied to go for an adventure, instead the found hell. Whenever I go back to listen to this song, I always sing along, as I sing I begin to cry because many men fought and died in service of their countries and I can not see myself in their shoes. I am proud to be Australian, and this is a bloody ripper of a song, wish I could be this talented at writing songs.
good luck, live long and prosper.
That the UK of WW1 declared war on Turkey is not well known. Less well known is that Turkey was in a process of refitting / purchasing ships from the UK for their navy when war broke out and told the UK we're not paying u4true. When armed forces are used in defence of their country it makes sense. What makes greater sense is that if all countries only had armed forces to apply this rule there would be no more wars. My grandfather's brother Edgar died at gallipoli ... here are his postcards held at the AWM to get an idea of what must have they been thinking. It wasn't much, they had no clue what was coming their way invading another nations country defended by men of equal courage.
eag.life/Media/albums/gallipoli_postcards/album/index.html
Smedley Butler wrote a book abt why we suffer from wars .. he called it >War is a racket<
th-cam.com/video/EI3lckqaSk0/w-d-xo.html
which makes you pensè who engineers and implement these never ending wars ?
th-cam.com/video/Sp4h39qJKqU/w-d-xo.html
and behind them are the lading matriarchial families of the sabattean frankist families but that's another story.
@@iandaniel2153 You will find that the Germans offered the Turks two battleships? after this event, cheers
@@edjacobs6897 ............. as in the enemy of your enemy is your friend ... makes sense thank you
@@iandaniel2153 Sorry about your Grand Father's brother, my Great Uncle got shot in the head at Flers in 1917 and was sent back to the lines for a further 12 months until he was sent home discharged unfit for duty, died a tragic in '46 , I think you will find that the British renegged on the sale of the two ships which had been paid for by a public subscription by the Turks, , as war had broken out the Brits decided to keep the two ships, Lest We Forget
He must have played the song many times in his life and, yet, he still sings with full heart and intensitiy. I heard this song for the first time in a pub in Germany. At some point during the night, a guest rose and sang this song without instrumental accompaniment. I could not hold back my tears.
In 1971 I served in Vietnam with a combined force of American and Aussie soldiers. The remarkable, upbeat spirit demonstrated by the Australian infantryman remains in my memory 50 years after this event. This beautiful song is a fitting tribute to both forces.
AUSTRALIA/AMERICA/IRELAND.............bonded forever!
Thank you Joseph
Amen 🙏🏻🇦🇺🇺🇸🇬🇧🇨🇦❣️
I mean it's nothing to do with the USA at all
@@TheOCO8 don’t hate….geez.
Eric Bogle has written two of the most formidable and intelligent anti-war songs ever written. He oozes gentleness, humility and generosity of spirit. The world could use more Eric Bogles. Many many more.
Hear fucking hear👏👏
I can't - I can oniy hear the beating of the war drums - see the lads marching in their bonnie dress uniforms - the crowds are cheering !
My grandfather got mustardgased in france in 1918. He survived but died my age because of bad lungs 😭.
The world is full of them but no one is listening.
I actually know Eric personally because my grandparents are good friends with him. A few weeks ago he reserved tickets to a concert of his for my grandparents bc they were all sold out
"We buried ours and the Turks buried theirs then we started all over again".......Says it all........the futility of War
Yes, a very powerful lyric. ❤
An Answer is not needed The song speaks for itself.
I graduated high school in 1970. One day a diploma and the next a draft card. Many went to Nam, some came home in body bags. It wasn't a real declared war and there were lots of protests. Those of us that came home weren't considered heros or patriots. We were hated and spat on for fighting over there. It wasn't our fault and we only obeyed the law of join the service or go to prison. One class mate and his fiancee had their car packed the night of graduation. After our all night graduation party dispersed at 6am the next morning they drove off to Canada. I did then and I still feel he made the right choice.
2 years behind you so Vietnam would've been my war. Went to college with my draft card in my trunk, still have that trunk and my draft card. My dad told me if I had to go, to not volunteer for anything--I'm pretty many fathers over many wars gave that same sage advice. My dad would've known. WWII was his war. 13 years after he died, I discovered a Bronze Star/Valor attachment that I never knew he had. I don't know why I'm writing this. Soldiers of all countries pay the price of wars made by the politicians who rarely pay.
@@sanseijedi how sad but sooo true… others usually pay the price of what people greedy with power and position and wealth do😢
Before Redgum
It took a Scotsman turned Australian to make Aussies eyes in tears everytime we hear this
Lest We Forget
Thank you Eric
What a great team Eric Bogle and John Munro - two great Scots that became great Aussies. Eric rightly wears his Member of the Order of Australia lapel pin on his jacket . Please keep on keeping on.
RIP John Munro - missed by us all these past 4 years.
We had one in the White House. You see what the pols have done to him, and what they are pursuing halfway across the world.
I am saddened to learn that John passed away in 2018 after a battle with cancer. The world of music has lost a true gem. Thanks for everything!
Sad to hear. He lives on in the music.
Omg bless his beautiful soul. He is entertaining the troops up there.
Hello from the States, my Great Grandfather was a "digger" with the 1st Battalion (Sydney) A.I.F. ANZAC at Gallipoli. Never met him, died from his wounds in 1941, but I am damn proud to be the great grandson of an ANZAC!
Mr. Bogle, thank you for writing and performing such a powerful song.
On ya mate.
Bless you mate, full respect and thanks to your grandfather 💞🇦🇺
As an American who has served with Aussies overseas - no better "mates" in a tough spot. Honored to serve with them.
thanks Rob. Likewise to America. Good friends are hard to find.
Cheers mate, your words are appreciated.
Let's find ways to experience and express our brotherhood without butchering each other. The pain is worse than the connection.
Back at you as well! Serious honour there from you guys as well.
@boris boris Boris, go troll somewhere else.
You are depriving some village somewhere out there of an idiot, go find it.
Proud of Eric, my fellow Scotsman who blossomed when he moved to Australia..a true musical genius.Australia's gain is Scotland's loss
We are one the same friend
Thanks Scotland
Aussies are so proud to have him with us.
Anyone who listens to this piece will most definitely have a tear in his/her eye. Great song great musicians.
I was a crew chief on an USA OH 6A helicopter in Vietnam (1968). We went down in Indian Country. I was scared. We radioed for help. Nobody could get us except an Australian crew on an UH Bell helicopter. Thank you Australia. I'll be ever grateful and visited Australia in 1969. Eaglegards...
That's what Ozzies do Mate! I recall from being a small kid in England during WW 2 at Bomber Airfields in Yorkshire (where I lived) and in Lincolnshire where my Aunty lived. The Aussies were easily identified. Different uniforms with AUSTRALIA on the Shoulder Badge. Many never got back to Australia.
✊🇦🇺🇺🇸❣️👱🏻♀️
@@lisamichelle8413 michem
The Royal Australian Navy sent a helicopter detachment to be embedded with the US Army in South Vietnam. They were in country for several years so you may well have been rescued by the RAN.
If ever a song summed up the futility of war, this is it..
war with Iran more innocent people die ,,do lives no longer matter ,,,
Frank Thomas Eric also wrote them green fields of France’ another beautiful song that highlights the futility of war
>I was only 19 a walk in the light green< by Redgum does it for me and as Smedley Butler, the highest decorated marine in USA's history wrote his book abt war in the 1930's ... titled "War is a racket" and so it always has been and still is.
@@iandaniel2153
I'll look for this. I spent 2 years in the Territorial Army 🇬🇧 at the end of the Cold War so I knew if the proverbial hit the fan I'd be involved. WW1 seemed such a terrible waste of human life though. I think the Nazis had to be stopped though. Hindsight is perfect vision unfortunately.
Or stupid planners like Churchill.
I first heard Eric Bogle sing this song at the Winnipeg Folk Festival in mid-seventies. It made me cry and it has done so every time I've heard it since.
@heatherhenderson4883....am sure he wrote the canadian song...bringing buddy home.
RIP John Munro, the guitarist, died 2018. Fantastic artist in his own right as well.
May he rest in peace.
The way John watched Eric so carefully during the whole song was so moving. They’ve probably played this a thousand time but he is so attentive to every subtle change.
197 "dislikes" (at this writing)? How can anyone dislike this song? This along with Bogle's "Green Fields of France" are the two most moving antiwar songs that know.
Maybe they dislike songs that make them cry?
OR, they are just unfeeling arseholes!
@John Raymonda...they are heartless bastards!
May the Dislikes from People who are too stupid to realize that there are no winner at any war at all.
I disliked it because Eric Bogle is a Scottish musician, who presumed to critisise Australian veterans for marching on ANZAC Day, without bothering to ask them why they march. ANZAC Day is a commemoration of those died in the service of our country, not a jingoistic celebration of war as that idiot paints it to be. The song is pretty but bloody disrespectful.
pete segar what did you learn in school today
My father was a French officer who fought 3wars... Eventhough I am a pacifist I am terribly touched by soldier's lives and songs...
I was a soldier. I was injured through an ied. I àm proud to have been a soldier. But this song , I am broken. IAM crying. I am broken. I have been to Gallipoli, I have seen the memorials. Oh my God , I am broken tonight. There is nothing else but to believe. God help us, please
bugler75 - A VN era vet reaching out to you. I hope you're working thru your rough patch. I did 3 tours with UDT & SEAL Team '69-'71. When I got out it was a WWII vet who jumped in the night before D-Day & fought thru the hedgerows and on into Germany who helped me re-adjust to civilian life.
So I hope you are reaching out to other Vets - they'll understand and support you. Family can support but other combat vets "understand" on that visceral level. I first heard this song from my SEAL Team mate Bob Kerrey when he sang it at his '88 Senate campaign celebration. He lost his leg & was awarded the MOH. Just got back from a "Alive Day" 50th celebration for my buddy who lost his leg in an aircraft crash. He wound up marrying his Navy nurse, raised 4 boys who are fine men now & he became a computer professor who guided many young students. So my message to you is hang in there mate. If you're still hurting - reach out to me at my email.
All I can say is, Welcome home Brother.
bugler75 So very sad for you, I wish you light in the darkness ...............
TH e SCOTSMAN who wrote this song deserves acclaim. HE is a man you don't meet everyday...
I was a soldier too and thankfully got home okay, changed but okay. I’ve made a new life. My dear Dad was not so lucky, a mine at El Alamein crippled him for life. I remember and shed a tear for him, for you too now bugler. I’ll remember you both, and some others besides, whenever I hear this wonderful song. I don’t know what drives us to war, some kind of madness.
I don't believe there will ever be a lovelier song written about the sacrifices of men in war than this one. Thank you, Eric, for creating a masterpiece that will live forever.
@MusicMadMaurice Here is Noman's Land (aka Fields of France) another Eric Bogle song recorded with his permission. th-cam.com/video/1eYGQG9aVZU/w-d-xo.html
Here here. I agree. It encapsulates the violence and futility of war in a special way.
Cameron Smith $
It didnt make him the most popular man in Australia initally, but the song has stood the test of time and proven Eric right. Delighted to have heard him perform the song at the Old Pathe Hotel in Roscrea , the best two man gig ever. Nothing better than the writer and composer singing his own sog, with his interpretation uncomprimised.
Unless you hear....The Green Fields Of France 🇫🇷.. stunning
Our son, born Welsh is now an Aussie. He loves his new land and the history behind its creation but like me When Australia play Wales he will cheer for his land of birth. ME I've seen the the Legerwood carved trees and marvel at how the carving conveys what happened to the !8 husbands/boyfriends who were killed in the war. So Australians this old fella love Australia as well.
What a song, it has to be the most powerful Aussie song by a foreigner of all time. RIP to all the Aussie's and all the Turks that lost their lives in the war.
Hi Ashley,
Aussies, Turks, Kiwis , Irish, English, Scots, Welsh and many more besides all died there.
But I appreciate you probably knew that.
A walk in the light green by Redgum is right up there. Sometimes known as I was only 19
Everyone is a foreigner in OZ
@@iandaniel2153 - I sing A Walk in the Light Green at Karaoke, as well as other songs, such as Cohen The Partisan, so that we do not forget.
Prelim Curran. DUBLIN FUSILIERS. DiedApril 28 1915. Not forgotten phelim. I’m glad today we can celebrate you. On our island of Ireland 🇮🇪.
I landed in Australia a couple of days after Christmas 1977 on my first visit there. Mates picked me up and took me on a guided tour of the pubs of Sydney. In every one I noticed old timers sitting in the dark corners. Whenever it was time for another round I was told by each bartender that mine was taken care of. Even if it was my turn to buy the round it was always, "yours is right mate". Later that evening I was told those old timers were all Returned Soldiers who were signaling the bar tender they were buying mine. That was because they hadn't forgotten the large presence of U.S. military there during World War Two kept the resource-hungry Japanese from landing. It was really put together a few days later when I was taken to the National War Memorials in Canberra. But none of those experiences can match what this song just did to my insides. A deep, respectful Vale to all who served and particularly those who gave all.
Well said Jon We thank you
@@billyboy1441
Thank you for a great time there. I went for 30 days and it took them a year to get rid of me!😁
war is ridiculous, who wins! seriously who does? not you or me but the wealthy who make their millions on war!
Glad you had a good time here Joe. My Aunt married an American who was on R&R in Sydney during the Vietnam War. He made a life for himself in Australia post war. When it was my turn to go to the sandpit he sat me down for a talk before and then after when I got home. He's no longer with us but a good man, appreciated him looking out for me in that regard.
One of the most beautiful, and one of the saddest, songs in the entire catalogue of Australian folk music... written by a Scotsman. 'Onya Eric! 🙂
As a fellow Scotsman settled now in Melbourne Australia, I have nothing but love and respect for the 62,000 souls who sacrificed to afford us this beautiful country. Thank you for this reminder, LEST WE FORGET......
You missed the point.
@@williamdonnelly723 I Guess you did ...
Epic song that had reduced this grown man to tears.... not for the first time - one of the finest songs ever written performed immaculately.
I like the pouges version
I shed a tear every time I here this beautiful version of Waltzing Matilda. War is a abomination.
I didn’t realise a Scotsman wrote this. Thank you so much ❤️❤️❤️
We come from all the lands on earth 🌎
I can only listen to this song once a year. Tears in my eyes.
My great uncle who I was named after was slaughtered in France. I was named after him. His brother served. My father, my brothers , my uncles, we all served.
This song still brings tears to my eyes.
Now people thank me for my service.
I don't take it well. For so many reasons i can't describe.
We did our duty. It was our duty.
Thank the crosses and those who never recovered.
Hello Australian and New Zealand friends. İ am from Turkey. This song very sad and very kindfull. Respect from Turkey. Yes we won this "war" but many brave man "lost" in here. And our greatest leader Mustafa Kemal ATATÜRK wrote a letter (1934) for parents and families:
"Those heroes that shed their blood and lost their lives... You are now lying in the soil of a friendly country. Therefore rest in peace. There is no difference between the Johnnies and the Mehmets to us where they lie side by side now here in this country of ours... you, the mothers, who sent their sons from faraway countries wipe away your tears; your sons are now lying in our bosom and are in peace. After having lost their lives on this land. They have become our sons as well."
This words maybe a little drop for peoples but it means a lot of things for us.
Your grandfathers and our grandfathers still "sleeping" together in the our fields. Because we dont say "they are dead" we say "They are last heroic martrys".
Come and see their monuments on the ÇANAKKALE (Gallipoli) You are welcome...
"After having lost their lives on this land. They have become our sons as well."
Halis ÖZTÜRK thanks for posting that beautiful poem,, yes we are brothers in peace, laying side by side underground, the turks and the aussie have a special bond , a comradship un equalled,,
Halis ÖZTÜRK wow...
Respect to every country and every senseless massacre
You didn't win the war though =P. You probably mean the battle.
Yes, you are right. i mean "Battle"
I was a soldier for 22years and I have just learnt to play this it's a beauty❤
Im a Royal Australian Air Force veteran, who served for 8 years and discharged as a CPL at 28. I completed 2 trips to the Middle East, and this songs just hits so so hard. My grandfather was an ANZAC, and this just hits the soul. I cant wait for ANZAC day this year to have a few beers with my mates.
Much respect, Sir. Lest we forget.
I served in the U.S. Marines in Vietnam in 1969-1970. I heard this song for the first time in 1978 on NPR in California and was smitten with the powerful lyrics and it resonated with my experiences in a much later conflict. However it was not until I moved to Australia in the early 1980s and understood the impact that he Battle of Gallipoli had on the psyche and the identity of Australia. The song took on a new layer of texture with my new home. 41 years now after I first head this song it still rings home. It’s message transcends wars, the sides are irrelevant. It’s about sacrifice, honour, commitment and dare I say, the futility of war? Both Eric Bogle and John Williamson do this song proud.... and as we just celebrated 104th anniversary of the Battle of Gallipoli or Canakkale as the Turks called it. We have just celebrated the 103rd ANZAC Day, and while I did not serve here in Australia, the message resonates true for all of us, for all sides of any conflict.....Lest We Forget.
My heart goes out to you. I was lucky. I didn't have "serve the cause". My Granddad never got over Ypres. Funny how few politicians didn't die.
A standing salute to you, brother
LW In Aus as an Aussie soldier of 21 years. Who served in Somalia. Thank you for getting to know the story. You can here a pin drop when this is played. Very few dry eyes. Brave men with chests full of medals wipe the dust from their eyes because it can’t be tears. Our Iwo Jima.
the pogues do a great version to.
townes potter just listened to that version. Must say I’m a fan of the pouges but that version is terrible. Sorry buddy
I am an old veteran who served with men now gone. I often think of them as they were when we were all young and proud. I was born before WW2 and will die in the 21st century. I don’t know why I have lived this long, except perhaps to honor their memory.
I live in a small village in NSW. We have the remembrance in the main street for 3 blocks. The trees were planted by the wives and families of those that did not return. There are 109 trees. Just devastating for a small community. I bought this as a 45 when it was released. Was RAAF then. The 45 is long gone but not lost as I regularly listen to this song.
War is crap but when needed. I come from a military family but stopped at the generation under me. Even today at 64 my country calls ...................................
Australia such a brave and noble people.
God bless you all.
Remember what a guy ar work told me about Viet Nam .
He said he had to go - his father told him , he had gone in WW2 & it was his turn
Also most young men would rather be DEAD , than called a coward.
Works out nicely .
Seriously, every time I watch this I simply tear up, 74 yrs here..making my way out ..♥️
I agree one of the best song's ever written, each year I remember my Dad, My Uncle and my wife's Daddy who all served in WW2 and came home okay. My dad crossed the bar in 2006 and my wife's Daddy US Army passed on Christmas Day 2006, my Uncle served on the HMS Kelly with Lord Mountbatten
One of the best anti-war songs ever written that clearly displays the lunacy of war and the harm done to the young men who are sent off to fight by politicians who would rarely do it themselves.
Thank you Turkey.
Maybe people can try asking nicely in future?
@@williamhumble1175 Why?
Men fight wars for several reasons, greed, lust for power, and lust for what someone else has. It take a brave a courageous nation to enter a war, with the idea that they will make it right for the ones attacked. Even at best, some will forget and become as evil as the ones they are trying to defeat.
Aint that the truth....warmongers/bankers sending innocents to the slaughter. EVERY war has been carried out to fuel the Military Industrial Complex...and their $$ backers. Most decent people on this planet just want to live in peace...
Perhaps one of the most powerful songs ever written. The words should be studied by every school student a week before ANZAC day so they will have a very clear understanding what war is all about and the suffering that so many heroes endured. Thank you Eric Bogle for making it as it really was.
This song & the memorial at Monte Casino shows the utter stupidity of war. My dad said that if leaders want a war stick them in a field & let them get on with it. He survived WW11, would fight if needed to protect family, didn't agree with war.
I so agree. often we listen to the music but pay little attention to the words. This is a most unresting story of pain and suffering. I am sadden with no words to add.
I will add to a required viewing list "All Quiet on the Western Front"...
Always played it to my class... along with Willie McBride.
@@007JHS Two of the most powerful anti-war songs I know (tho there are others, for sure.) Written in close chronology by a young, gay man, which I don't think is coincidental. And both draw some of their power by referencing other songs that have power and resonance.
I discovered this song on a charity shop CD of the Dubliners who were singing it, and it would all ways get to me. My Grandfather George was Australian and fortunately left OZ in 1914 with his brother Sam. They were welcomed and settled in Brampton Huntingdon England. I say fortunate because he avoided WW1 and met Emma my Grandmother and when he tried to enlist in the forces in England but was turned down, they said he wasn't fit enough or maybe to dark?. My Dad was born early in 1916 and given the name of Royal which seems a bit over the top. We don't think Dad was told who he was named after but recent research revealed that Joseph, Grandads eldest brother had a son who died in Alexandria Hospital Egypt having been shot in Gallipoli in July 1915 He was named Royal. A wonderful song but I can't take it too often.
I attended an ANZAC dawn parade when I was serving with the UN in Nicosia. A Turkish officer marched down to the border point and passed a wreath across to an Aussie officer. After the silence a big Irish army sergeant major sung this song acapella. Not a dry eye on parade...
musr have been very moving in rome afew years ago visited monte casino and the graveyard there lots of young men some of them scots i cried all the way back to rome war is hell linda in scotland
I suspect he would have sung the original Waltzing Matilda - no disrespect to Eric Bogle - but the original is the unofficial australian national anthem.
I HAD A SIMILAR EXPERIENCE IN NICOSIA IN 85 WITH AN IRISH RANGER SINGING THE GREEN FIELDS OF FRANCE
Doesn't mean a FLIP to those who's brains & blood stained the water .
@@douggodfrey6521 edgy. thanks for weighing in
This song was written by singer-songwriter Eric Bogle himself. He was born in Scotland in 1944 and emigrated to Australia in 1969.
Being anti-war over Australians fighting in Vietnam at that time inspired him to write this song in 1971.
I've had several conversations with Australian servicemembers when I was deployed. This song has the same effect for the Aussies that "Ashoken Farewell" has for other older Americans. It's a surprisingly recent tune that paints a very real picture, of the pain and futility of war. Much love and respect from Virginia.
I first heard this song many many years ago.
I had no idea then that I would one day stand in the Murrays green basin, nor that I would one day serve in the Australian Army, catch a ferry from Circular Quay, wear the slouch hat, march through Sydney on ANZAC day, or stand in uniform in an RSL with men who had landed at Gallipoli.
As a young man you never know where life’s twists and turns wil take you.
@Rosco 1953 You post says little, but also says a lot when thought about.
So good to hear this song again. Utterly beautiful and devastatingly sad at the same time. How anyone could not appreciate this tune is beyond me. Thank you Eric Bogle for your magnificent contribution to Australian art and mythology.
The generations forward will not let these stories die, the men who gave their lives will live on in these beautiful songs.
-a 24 year old American man.
I grew up listening to Walzing Mathilda but never knew what it was about. I am almost 70 and live in 🇨🇦 Canada. My parents are British. I love your song and wish Governments knew what it cost to go to war. Thank you.
A most haunting plaintiff song about the horror and tragedy of futile war
One of the the best songs ever penned and sung, by a brilliant wordsmith.
Greetings from friendly and brotherly country Turkey. All heroes rest in peace.
well said, friend, stay safe, lest We Forget!
lest we forget my friend
Im australian. My grandfather was 1 of the last to leave Gallipoli. Im so happy past is past. Now that terrible war is replaced with love and friendship. So thank you and i wish you all the happyness. 😁👍
Lest we forget. Much respect, and all the best to you
Turkey is perhaps the only country who respects a foreign force who were trying to invade them, Australia. It says a lot about both countries.
During my college years I served as a counselor in our Vets Center. I've seen what war can do to a young man. The world never learns. Young man fight old men's wars. Blessings Georgie.
This song is timeless, this Scotsman has an Aussie soul.
He is Irish. The Joan Baez cover is great.
@@iand8365 I'd check your facts on that one! Maybe he had Irish parents but he was born in Scotland.
My apologies for my confusion. No matter his heritage, he is a talented man.
I would be interested to hear people's thoughts regarding this incredible song and comparisons with Red Gum's "I Was Only Nineteen".
@@iand8365 I think 19 is better personally but both songs are awesome.
As a 16 year old I learned about Gallipoli in history and 2 or 3 years later I first heard this song performed by The Piques. It blew me away then and still does. I have listened to many versions since, but strangely enough this is the first time hearing the original songwriter sing it. It is just as powerful as ever and constantly reminds me of the futility of war and how little politicians thought about the regular army soldiers who then routinely threw into battles that could never be won.
How true. Winston Churchill as a young politician with no experience chose Gallipoli as the location. He was responsible but not accountable.
The British treated Australians like convict dogs. Dispensible cannon fodder.
Eric Bogle is absolutely one of the world's bets writers. Thisbl song olis so poignant for ANZ, but his best song was Green Fields of France. A master.
@@shanedarcy361 Listen to Eric's song called "All The Fine Young Men" That's another masterpiece.
The pogues?? Perhaps
@@Kev-son_of_kev Almost positive that's who he meant. My favorite version for what that's worth.
Lovely, he has a way with the words does Eric. I mind meeting him a few times and listening to himself, playing his guitar, singing and playing in his Skiffle group in Peebles when I was a wee laddie many, many years ago. A while back I heard him singing a song he'd composed called Journeys. It had me in tears. At that time back then in the very late 1950s/ early 1960s, my father was an alcoholic and I was in the care of a local Dr Barnardo's children's home in Peebles called Craigerne. Many a time I used to walk along the banks of the Tweed like Eric engrossed in my own thoughts back then. Aye like I said, Eric has a way with the words .......in his song " Journeys" he expressed my thoughts in a way that I couldn't. Thankyou Eric.
am Dutch, and have no bonds with Australia, only a nephew and niece live in Australia with their families.. but this song hits me deep over and over again..
There’s no better version of this song than by the man that composed it
From one Scotsman to another superb stuff
69th like
Personally I prefer the pogues version, MacGowens' roughness adds to it. Great song.
John Williamson's version is pretty good. No where near the haunting atmosphere of this one though
@@Frannis Me too. I've heard this original version and many other covers too, but for me MacGowans is the best because he brings so much bitterness to the part which I think suits it the best. The other versions are just sadness and helplessness and ring empty to me. MacGowans seems more genuine. Also for all the people arguing about gallipolli and the turks, you do know this was an anti war song written about Vietnam at the time of Vietnam right? Bogle just changed the subject to galipolli so it would be more popular here with the ANZAC mythology.
He’s Australian. Has lived in Oz nearly all his life
One of the best war songs in my opinion and as an Australian, I play it every ANZAC Day. My late father served in Korea and have always been immensely proud of the sacrifices he made to serve for this country. He was English and was trained in both the British and Australian Armies. I would watch him march and look at him in awe with all his medals on. Today is about all wars that should never be forgotten. Lest we forget!
Many years ago, a friend of mine used to play this song. It effected me so much that I had to leave the room when he played it. This is one of the greatest anti-war songs of all time.
So true mate. I started mist up when I read your reply .....hearts atcha mate.
Along with "The Green Fields of France".
I wonder if they play it in Russia in March 2022? They should.
As a proud Australian every time I hear this beautiful song I think of my Grandfather who served with the 4th Battalion A.I.F (ANZAC) in Gallipoli, I only hope we don't lose everything they died for , Lest we forget
Few songs tell a story so eloquently beautiful and yet so haunting. Absolute masterpiece!❤
A most stirring song. I’m also a singer and a few years ago I visited Gallipoli on Anzac Day . The song resonated in my head the whole time. I was at a gathering of Australian tourists, and many Turkish people and I sang this song. Tears flowed everywhere . It was probably the most memorable performance I’ve ever given. 😢
😊😊 I'm very pleased to know I'm not the only one that loves the song but when last did you play it.
My Great Grandfather, a Londoner in the Royal Hampshire Regiment perished at sea in a troopship off the Greek Island of Kos while en route from Alexandria Egypt to Gallipoli on August 13th. 1915. His ship, the Royal Edward was sunk by a German U-Boat. They were hit at 9:00 a.m. during a lifeboat drill and he and over 900 others were lost when it went down 15 minutes later. He was 31. This song starkly illuminates what was in store for these unsung heroes had they made it to Gallipoli. Getting there was one thing. Getting through it and out of there alive was entirely another.
I'm a proud Australian. 👏 Thank you for writing this song.
This is worth three hundred thumbs !!!
I attended the centenary celebration in Gallipoli in 2015. Sleeping on that hallowed ground prior to dawn, most likely atop bones of brave ANZACS, was an experience I’ll never, ever take for granted or forget. Bless those diggers and all service men and women. Proud Aussie.
At the going down of the sun an in the morning we will remember them I hope we do an will always be grateful for what they gave
I have heard many versions of this very moving song but no one can put this beautiful rendition more emotionally than Eric, for a person to write such moving words surely is a God given talent, thank you Eric.
In memory of my grand father who came from the first World War amputated of his legs.Eric Bogle ,an exceptional composer and singer
Michel Guillaume Lest We Forget
Hi guys ....a Pom here....my utmost respects to all those Diggers to whom we all owe such a huge debt of gratitude....God Bless Ozz...👍🏼👍
As a Vietnam veteran who served two years as an exchange officer at the Royal Australian School of Artillery in the mid-70s, this song touched me on several levels.
I cried my heart out listening to this song , may all the aussie and turks who died in Gallipoli rest in eternal peace ,
What a song ,no words can describe the emotions i felt ,thankyou for this song
another of Churchillls bad ideas...
World War I one of the greatest example of stupidity in human history.
The song everyone wishes they wrote, performed by the fine man who did!
hi Doc, you're most welcome mate.
You may like this? th-cam.com/video/LST-Q_OVG14/w-d-xo.html
Eric and late John. I'm an Australian on the banks of the Murray.I return to this song often. Never before have the conflicts of war been expressed and played so well. I forever thank you.
I first learned of the importance of Anzac day on a Princess Cruise from Barcelona to Istanbul. As we passed Gallipoli, they made an announcement that they would shut down the engines briefly and encouraged us to join with Australians on board for a wreath laying ceremony. It was solemnly done off the coast, looking up at the virtually impenetrable ridge line. As soon as we got underway again, a pod of dolphins surfaced an escorted us onward. Since then, I've educated myself about this overwhelming bit of history. This song makes me cry and feel a deep kinship with Australians.
Sadly this song will water down our history it’s wrong and Waltzing Matilda should not be on it first 3 mistakes Aus all volunteered no one was sent, Australians didn’t land at Suvla we didn’t wear tin hats,
#Mile Mcconnell
Thankyou for sharing your experience with the Aussies. It is humbling to read.
Funny about the dolphins ... purportedly the ancient Greeks believed that dolphins had the souls of men lost at sea which was given as the reason why they frequently escort ships and boats. My father was in the Royal Australian Navy prior to and during WWII and he said dolphins often escorted vessels he served on.
Just to add, they're also very curious!
Today is ANZAC Day and as we couldn’t congregate at the local RSL or have a parade in the city due to COVID-19, we were encouraged to have our own service at home on our driveway by lighting a candle and listening to the service provided by the local radio station. I did this with my partner and a neighbour and his wife. Later I sang Eric Bogle’s song as I do every ANZAC Day. However, I have only ever heard The Pogues version and for the first time today searched for the original version. I love the story of how Eric wrote it after watching a parade in Australia. Such poignant lyrics!
@@pdenn1s Sorry mate, but I think that @Vanessa Burnett-Read's comment sounds like anything BUT an excuse to drink beer. Read it properly please. I've had a quick look at your TH-cam link, and I'll definitely be having a look at the video. Thank you very much for sharing. Take care, and go gently.
I totally love The Pogues and have done so for many years, but I must admit I have always found Shane McGowan's rendition of this song less than ideal. In my opinion, when The Pogues did a song well, well, they were on fire! But the fact cannot be escaped that, at times, they could be absolute shite! I say this as a committed fan of The Pogues. And also may I add, as a proud father of a 24 year old son who told me the other day that he has ordered a framed print-out of the lyrics of The Pogues' version of the song "Broad Majestic Shannon." That's the sort of thing that brings tears to my eyes. Like this version of "The Band Played Waltzing Matilda." which I have previously known of, and knew that it was by Eric Bogle, who I had no idea was, like myself, originally from Scotland. I must say that I have never been, nor I am ever likely to be an adherent to the ANZAC myth, however this song not only brought tears to my eyes, but also sent a shiver up my spine. 12/10
@@louisspeer1255 Not a fan of jingoism, sorry mate. If waving flags and lighting candles makes you feel better then fine, I'm just a little jaded about the whole idea.
@@louisspeer1255 I deleted the comment and to be honest you are right....
@@pdenn1s No worries. I hope you don't think that I'm into "waving flags and lighting candles, and especially jingoism" because I'm not. And I'm not into Anzac Day at all. Never have been. I think that it's a horrible creation, and worse still, it's political manipulation on a grand scale. There's an excellent book called "What's wrong with ANZAC? : the militarisation of Australian history" by Marilyn Lake and Henry Reynolds with Mark McKenna and Joy Damousi. They describe how John Howard and his cronies were instrumental in creating this modern wave of Anzac patriotism largely through funding the Department of Veterans Affairs for this specific purpose. The end result is that, due to the consequent drop in funding for its core tasks, the DVA now does much less of what it was originally formed to do, which was to support war widows and widowers and the rehabilitation and support of returned veterans. I think that may be the reason why there are these new charities like Soldier On and Mates 4 Mates etc springing up. Another thing they wrote about in the book was that they researched contemporaneous newspaper articles from 1915, and their conclusion was that rather than being lauded as heroes, a lot of other Allied soldiers and the press were actually very critical of the Australian soldiers and described most of them as "garrulous thugs." Anyway, my post was really about how impressed I am with the quality of the song and the musicianship of the guitarist in particular, plus comparing it to The Pogues' version. I wasn't supporting or criticising her post in any way. I have met a few Vietnam Vets in my time and can't begrudge them anything. It was their own personal experience, and I think they have their own valid reasons for being how they are, whatever that means. What I believe is truly reprehensible is the way the governments of the day played "wedge" politics and divided the entire nation. On purpose. It was totally despicable how they treated the returned vets, and virtually encouraged people to treat vets in the way they did. I am totally against war, always have been and always will be. As a tourist, I've visited places like Vietnam and Afghanistan (though only in transit through Kabul, but that was enough) and have been caught in the crossfire during riots in India and even a revolution in Kathmandu. This all happened in 1990. All because I simply happened to be there at the time. I thought I'd put all that behind me, but no I managed to nearly get caught up in 9/11 - fortunately I was 3 hours away in Connecticut at the time. Anyway, that's my little reply. You should put your post back up though, your opinion still matters, and I think that it's important that people have the opportunity to discover the Long Tan story. And My Lai too.
I've heard this song played many times, but never with so much genuine feeling. This and the iconic Redgum song "I was only 19" are the most moving songs of this genre. May the sacrifice on both sides never be forgotten and may we one day all have the courage to stand up to the war mongers that start these conflicts.
That's a Bloody Amazing song about Vietnam:
th-cam.com/video/aisR-Lz5YpQ/w-d-xo.html
This song & I was only 19, sky pilot, Arkansas grass & I'm still in Saigon all haunting songs. Beautifully tolled true stories.
Watched this again for the umpteenth time and I’m tears again.