What Is This Feeling? (Children in Need 2006)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- Idina Menzel and Annalene Beechey performing 'What Is This Feeling?' for the UK's Children in Need 2006.
For deaf or HOH viewers, you are now able to watch this video with captions/subtitles, thanks to 'runawayfelon'.
I think actually their different accents in this contribute to their character roles - showing how different they are = Galinda - the posh Upland, and Elphaba the more rugged Munchkinlander!
The way they described loathing... I thought it sounded more like love
Me too ! n_n
thats the funny part!
They really are almost the same thing anyway. ;P
+MrNegaBlox the line between love and hate is very thin
That's the point 😋
Idina's laugh at the end made me giggle so hard! That was so adorable and heart warming to hear! Xxx
I love her laugh at the end. It's her final personal touch, her laugh is really pleasing to the ears xD
A lot of people seem to not like the different accents, but I actually feel like it was a really simple and convenient way to both cut back pre opening rehearsal time and thematically emphasize the otherness of Elphaba
Sometimes I watch this just to remind myself that Idina got to do an American accent in the West End production just because.
Well yeah, but other people who have not only american accents but irish, or scottish or even a different english accent from the one the choose for the show had to talk differently from their natural accent. But idina got to be american because she's idina menzel
Eliza NoYouCan'tSeeMyRealLastName Number one, she chose to have an american accent, she still has to follow rules! If the producers in London said to her, "You have to have a British accent, she would proabaly have a British accent! Just because she is Idina does not mean she doesn't have too follow rules, she doesn't get to bend them either! Yes she is a huge success, but in no way does that mean she gets to act anyway she wants!
She couldn’t hold it up, she tried in rehearsals to put on an English accent and it didn’t work so they said she didn’t have to put one on
I saw it five times in London with Idina. The accent difference really didn’t matter because it added to Elphaba being different from all the others. The original West End Boq was Scottish and used his own accent too.
@Whiz And Friends I was saying it as a turn of phrase. Normally all Elphabas in the West End Production do an English accent., Idina was the exception. And while there are many rumors floating around as to the way she was given this privilege, I think it has more to do with the fact she originated the role and got a Tony for it, more than anything else. So yeah, she gets to do it just because she's Idina, and the production will probably never let anyone else do that
2:20 "every little trait however small" idina points at the brain
i love her
Idina is beyond adorable here!! :D
i STILL wish I had been able to see Idina when she was in London
I love the American & Brittish accent together tbh 😂😍
Me too!
1:20: How do I put this without being offensive?
1:21: Oh, I know!
Idina was incredible! but the english accent and american accent for this song clashed ...
Emma Melaney Kerry Ellis is from Suffolk =P
Emma Melaney Also this is Annalene Beechey :)
I think it just tells the audience how different Galinda and Elphaba were...
Amber Bond they were both English
Ffion Lloyd They we’re both singing in english but Indian Menzel is american and you can clearly tell the two different dialects of who is british and american when they sing.
I'm listening to this and I just keep thinking: 'They're picking on her, not just because she's green, but also because she's American."
@@imAwareOfYourAddress that was a perfectly good joke, cmon whyd you have to ruin it
I thought it was just popsical? Not papopsical...
In England, it's more common for children to call their fathers "papa". "Pop" is sort of unusual when used to refer to fathers. So it's more like "papa-psical".
D.N.A. Cat Same XD
D.N.A. Cat it is Popsical she just changed it. Which honestly, did not make me happy.
Oh I love Idina's cackle at the end...
I love how at like 3:45 Idina is smiling when she's not suppose to. :)
The "I loathe it all" jingle seem like "I want it all."
Idina was wonderful as always, and taking into account her accent, I thought Annalene did a fine job. I agree that this musical was not made for an English accent, but they rolled with it and made it better than I was expecting with all these comments about it.
How can a musical discriminate an accent? It doesn't make sense
it's for a charity tv programme called 'children in need' in britain. it happens every year to raise lots of money for deprived children around the world, people phone in and donate money, and in return, they throw a big long tv programme that lasts all night and lots of musicals and singers and comedians perform :)
i agree kristin and idina are best
Idina's one of my favourites, although I've never seen her perform live, I've seen Rachel and Rachel's understudy, but I still seem to favour Idina over anyone I may ever see. :)
How did I only go and watch this last week! Want to see it again like now!!! Love Idina cackle at the end that was pure perfection!!
Emma Melaney I think that's part of the acting as well (except the smile, it was definetely not intentional haha)
am i the only one that cant get over that perfect laugh at the end?! idina. is. perfect. :))
i luv her laugh at the end
Elphie has a lovely cackle. :)
Hey! Idina Menzel, the original Elephaba, was in this! I didn't 100% enjoy the Galinda actress, but you can't hate the original artist!
Annalene is so cute, this is my favorite Wicked Performance on TH-cam.
i love how idina said zero instead of "o" =]
Gemma Nevitt I would have too 😂
Love Annalene Beechey!
I love how idina is "meditating" at 2:56 ;)
I saw this back in march, i promise you your in for a wonderful night!
Idinas smile and then her laugh at the end
I already have and my opinion still stand, probably because I fell in love with Idina and Kristens versions of the songs :P
Annalene was lovely.
Annalene is amazing!
love the cackle at the end! XD
Idina Menzel = best Elphaba ever!!
I think this was one of Idina's better performances for this song. The riffs and everything were sooooo good compared to the soundtrack.
Also, I love the British chorus in the background. They enunciate every word so well!
I love this song
I think they were both phenomenal! Personally I think the real problem is the mixing of the two accents. They don't sound all that great together because they're singing the song two different ways really. But they're both really good
Idina did the show in london for the original cast, too.
i love her laugh at the end of their song
oh Idina, I love your laugh :
how can I not remember this memory I always watched children in need oh right I was 8 damn
Whoever did these captions is a Saint! Best captions I've ever seen.
when you hear it when both characters have english accent it sounds so much better i saw it on wednesday with nikki davis jones and gina beck they were really good!!
Remember seeing this and fell in love with the story musical.
For people saying the accents don’t suit it’s because it’s not the accent your used to, I remember seeing this in New York and accents ruined it for me as I wasn’t used to the voices but I love it outside of the New York accent
I loved it but the accent kinda didn't fit together. The British was very powerful while the other one sounded more American and that kinda didn't fit together. However this was amazing!
Storm Swirl I think it's because the other one is an American named idina menzel who also originated the role ...
Elphaba and Galinda are from two different parts of Oz.
The fancy accent is weird.
Idina Menzel is a goddess though
I absolutely love it when idina goes “your voice” in an English accent it’s so cute !
without kristen chenowith theres just something missing!
I'm British too, I'm seeing it in London for my 16th and hoping my opinions change when I see it live :)
my childhood best friend and i practiced this song and popular for weeks and auditioned for our elementary school talent show. they wouldnt let us do loathing, but they let us do popular. as if telling someone theyre not good enough and you're gonna teach them how to be better liked is any better than an equal hatred, lmfao
Didn't even wait for the end of the video before hitting "like"
When I saw this just two weeks ago, the cast were finding it really hard to keep a straight face at the scene just after the flying house appears! It was really endearing and funny! XD
@d0ggylover21 well to the start with, it's the london production and kristen never performed in london. the original (and at the time - current) glinda, helen dallimore must have been ill or away which is why the understudy, annalene beechey performed tonight :D
I loved Helen but I aaadore Annalane. I am sooo sad Louise is leaving. I've seen her twice this year. Once for my sis's birthday and again for mine. I may be seeing her on leaving night for christmas
i think it works with a british person as Glinda (unfortunatley we have a talent for snotty accents) and it works well with Indina's dulcet tones
I know but at least their talent has been captured in the recordings of the songs they did :D x
idina was so funny here
i agree it doesn't flow as well with a English accent but she is still a very good actress and singer :)
@DEFiiANCE yes there is :) haha...click on the box bottomright of the video which has a pointing up arrow, then click on the 'cc' box and then you can turn on or off closed captioning x
I love how Elphaba nods to herself like "Yep, she's blond-"
Annalene
same here
is it just me or was Idina smiling at 3:45 and 3:46 then suddenly drop back into character at 3:47?
This Galinda look like she doesn't know the lyrics that well... I think Kristin Chenoweth's Galinda was by far the best!! ...and Idina is perfect like always! ;)
The bear is the logo for Children in Need - it's called Pudsey
is it me, or does idina mezel look better with a green face/ in the role of elphaba, than normally
She doesn't have a bad voice, really. It's just that the accent doesn't really go well (well, to us) with how it should sound like. I agree Idina's amazing though. :D
I didn't know Idina was in the West End cast of Wicked?
She moved
it's unbearable as the British/American accents do not go well together.
Oh, I don't know...It kind of grew on me after a while...
1:32 lmao 😂😂😂😂😂
Annalene Beechey - stand-by Glinda at the time
i kinda like the glinda in this clip especially how she sounds so posh but no one could ever be as good as kristen with idina.
i love the...
BOO!
ahh!
*cackles*
yes she is? glinda the good witch of the north.
I actually like the clash of accents
haha yeah they are. my school is going for a field trip. im so excited! haha that sucks. i hope you can get the money for a ticket:)
well rachel is playing till october then louise dearman who used to play glinda on west end is taking over and shes pretty amazing tbh
Is it just me or are Wicked always doing charity nights! They did when I was there as well! :) (I mean this in a good way btw! :P)
i agree....and im british
i think kristen is the only one who can truly match idina's voice perfectly. no offence annalene. :D
love kristin more though!!
xxx
i can count the pixels
:( I didnt get to see the one in Rochester! I just didn't/don't have the money at the time. Did you know they're back? I got an email from DanCap bugging me to buy tickets with the money I don't have lol.
@Imerry16 I wonder why she snapped back from smiling (I know your comment was 4 years ago its shown in top comments first page)
Is that Idina?
Yes
0:59 i thought they said there's been some confusion here and shiz XD
I wish Kristin was there :/
aw! did Pudsey have a pic with them? i want to see Idina with Pudsey. :)
I don't think she's playing Elphaba when I see it, someone said she was leaving before I go
and it's the understudy glinda as well. I don't know where Helen was.
I thought Idina only was on Broadway ?
Megan Hilty is my personal favourite.
id say if anyone can change ur opinion it will be rachel tucker
For ages I thought that this was Helen Dallimore as Galinda! Then, I actually got to know the London cast & finally realised! What a plank! :L
Now, I think I've watched Wicked a few too many times (well, okay, twice) 'cos I love watching videos just to spot old ensemble members or whoever! Oliver Tompsett + Sarah Earnshaw :D Was it James Gillan as Boq in this? I can't make it out.
Long comment :] Is there any way to turn off the transcript? It's driving me crazy!!
She left that year and Idina went on to England for this benefit.
that no Kristen
346 idina smiles