Library Chat #16: The Return of Jesus In Islamic Theology | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Intro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/oornlz
Outro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official TH-cam Channel
I LIVE for these library chats.
I hope you are doing fine brozer
I love these chats. Allah bless you Sheikh
Man, I love this series and I hope it continues for a long time. So much to learn from every single episode. Jazakallah Shaykh Yasir.
You are the best teacher of the generation ❤
May Allah bless you my brother
Sir please dont stop this library chats. This the most awaited them of yours in my opinion.
Allah bless you Sheikh.
may Allah strengthen him
Ameeen
Great presentation shaykh..... Like the “maliki don” just reminded of the naughty naughty naughty 🤭
😂😂😂😂😂
Let's remind Yasir Qadhi of the salafi Don's 😂😂😂😂 who believed dua to other than Allah is shirk. Sorry yasir qadhi once a hard core believer with quranic and hadith evidence that is clear cut shirk but now its NOT shirk but haram. And he goes against the Don's of the salafi scholars himself 😂😂😂
Allah brightens our day with these. Jazakallahu khairan ya shaikhana
We need more of this library chat yaa shaikh .. may allah bless you with more wisdom and knowledge and make us all benefit from it . Ameen
May ALLAH bless you with more wisdom and knowledge and guides you more to the straight path Ameen ya RAB and make you a light for the Muslim nation. Praise be to ALLAH who gave you the knowledge and made you a blessing for us. May Allah bless you ya sheikh. Keep doing this work you are one of the people to whom i can watch all day without getting tired. lots of prayers and reverence for you.
I love library chats!!!
@ Shaykh Yasir, I understand why clients are turned off on your latest Library Chat (17). But please continue doing talks on early isloc history, along with the analytical, academic, and historical breakdowns that you do. Alhamdulillah I find it very beneficial.
Thank you Sheikh for a beautiful explanation as usual...
Is it just me or these library chats are SOMETHING!
an interesting event...thanks Qadhi sir.........
Great talk, and yes ghazali was not the part of this movement.
Is interesting how many people watch both YQ &MALM
Who is MALM?
@@genuineidea6043 Mufti Abu Layth Al Maliki
I like and watch both. In this topic I am more inclined to believe in MALM view.
I have been benefiting from Dr YQ lecture. JK
7:03
Sheikh Yasir.
Please adjust your lighting. Please go pro!
Make a proper studio. Get proper lighting.
At your level, this is expected of you. Your listeners deserve it too.
You’re the Bill O Riley of the GCC and Western Muslim world.
If you don’t have the funds, start a patreon page. Please do it right.
Then live up to it!
Shaikh please post a library chat I have been waiting for too long.
Asallem alekum
Akhii in islam Dr yasir qadhi could you plz one recture about mamluk dynasty we like 👍
Muhammad Abduh was a Freemason. They don’t believe that Isa (AS) is a prophet, they believe that this is an office that can be held by anyone. It makes sense why he said what he said, but freemasonry is diametrically opposed to Islam and so we should question his beliefs in this regard
Suggestion: Please could you list all referenced books in descriptions. Thanks.
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
OMG🔥😱 Im going to be looking forward for the COMING Monday nights with Mufti Abu Layth al Maliki. I don't know about Jesus (AS) but I'm pretty damn sure Yasir qadhi wont be RETURNING after that😂😂
Abu layth the clown... Some people take him seriously..
@@deanmarvel3169
Yes bro, if you watched all the above video. YASIR QADHI mentioned him by name and had a few digs at him.
Yasir Qadhi takes him seriously why do you think he mentioned his name along side the giant scholars??
That's why people want them to have a discussion together on this topic.
@fahad alam, seriously u don't find him weird, always laughing like mental breakdown, behaving like child... I mean Clown like entertainment, like TH-camr, etc. I question him not for Sheikh Yasir qadhi defence, I question him who he really is. Sorry to say..
@@aliditta7768 sorry to say, I don't find or take him seriously, he always laughing like mental breakdown, doing weird things like child.. Like my sons do..
@@deanmarvel3169 MALM refuted this video, what are you gonna say about that? Nobody till this day has been able to answer bukhari gate and 2nd coming of jesus video made by mufti, all you guys can do is call him joker or kafir and get all emotional, you guys cant bring evidence
I would love to see Shaykh Qadhi having a discussion with MALM on this issue.
Maybe not afraid of the topic itself, but if you look at the general following of Shaykh Qadhi, which is Salafiyyah, it makes it impossible with a discussion. That is because Shaykh Qadhi would be labelled deviant just by saying "Hi" to MALM
Wa alaykumassalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh
Ahmadis should listen to this talk with open mind and then see and how they were made fool out of ignorance.😄
ياخي i love you so much
Classic Salafi Tactic
Claim Ijma whenever someone disagree with their interpretation...
I wish he talks on Bidiayya like he did to shirk because these are two things that ummah of prophet saw has been divided with even though there are other definition of them both by prominent scholars and this is not to deny the fact that there exist evil ones (real shirk & bidiyya)
O my brothers and sisters my language is poor. But my point is when prophets came to this world common common people only believe rest of them rejected
Sheikh, Mahmoud Shaltout is written with a ت not ط
محمود شلتوت
When nooh pbuh came to his people only 80 + people accepted his word who were the main against him check it in quran allah saying the big people means king or sheiks or moulavi
This is not library chat for us, it is university chat..
It would be great if you could do a talk on Sahih Bukhari. Some try to argue that there is some weakness in it.
I have heard of Ismail ibn Uwais (allegedly Imam Muslim doesn't take from him) and another narrator that are supposedly weak. There is also the people that argue that the Hadith in Bukhari about music are used as a title or as an addition so he is not saying it is sahih to his standards, allegedly. There is also the question of why it is more authentic than Imam Malik's Muwatta.
Type in Abu layth bukharigate .. he has a comprehensive analysis on bukharigate
I have heard that the Ayah that references that the people of the book shall believe in him before his death is that Esa appears to the people of the book before they die. And that his appearance proves to the Jews that they did not kill him and that is a punishment for them. Do you know where this has come from? If you can answer that would be great.
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
Alhamdulillah
Sir, everyone living in any country is following the Laws/Fiqh of his/her country including the Athiest, Momins of all One God Religions, Hindus, Idol Worshippers, Pagans, etc inspite the differences of their political/religious/philosophical beliefs.
We don't need Jesus coming back except a spirit of compassion and mercy in people to start and movement and reform the society for betterment of its people especially when thr Divine System/Goverment starts to oppress its citizens and not care for refugees, needy, sick, jobless, homeless and poor people. We need every human being to be take care of no matter what colour, religion, race person they are from. We judge the government made for its people and not the people.
Why is that bizare to think that confessing before dying is a sign of belief ? If Allah gave the ability as your last action, to profess your faith when we know that the end is really important, it is an amazing thing. I don't understand how you make it "bizare" .
When Loot pbuh came same thing happend
يوجد سر في اسم الله السلام...مرة واحدة في الحشر..توحيد.....عليه السلام يوم ولد و يومين اخر....
خاطرة.....المسيح من احد المعاني..مسح الارض...توصية الصلاة و الذكاة ليس الصيام..عابري سبيل.....خاطرة فقط...المهدي ابو الصدقات و المال.....
ربنا يغفر لنا جمعيا
و اسماعيل ع.س زكاة و الصلاة.....شيلو محمد و عيسي خط واحد..الله يعلم
I like the fact that the library chat is becoming a weekly thing.
@Siraj Haq noooo sir. it was always intriguing!
@Siraj Haq in that case, yeeeaaah!
I can't have enough of it. I'm at the point of rewachting these library chats.
@@zakariab9591
I always downloaded them even save them on my google drive
@@zakariab9591
If you have watched his library chats you will understand how this talk of Jesus return contradicts his other library chats.
Yasir qadhi should also come and have a academic discussion with MUFTI ABU LAYTH.
As your aware that Yasir Qadhi goes against the majority or even ijmah himself and now he wants us to blind follow the scholars ??
How many belief was Yasir Qadhi very certain with evidence and now has a different view.
Point is he should have a discussion with MUFTI ABU LAYTH.
Ya shaykh, I would not mind if all your library chats were 3 hours+ long like the one you did about najdi dawah.
Sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi,,,I like to apologise to you for saying something negative about you
I am very sorry and I sincerely wish that you forgive me
Regards
@@Atta1992- this guys a qadiani?
@@ziyaaddhorat sheikh qadhi is not a qadiani
@@ffmmain8673 the TH-cam video he linked
I get so hyped everytime I see the shayks library chat videos on my feeds
Ikr
Same
How eagerly I wait for every library chat,only Allah knows.
same to me😂😂😂
When i see it, I would scream it😂😂
♥️♥️
Oida is des a österreich flagge??
@@jona-fs7mv dachte ich mir auch, asalmu alaikum, bin aus wien :)
Just look at the reactions Shaykh, we all love these library chats. They’re very informative. Please continue, jazak Allahu khayran.
This reaction people want yasir qadhi to talk to mufti abu LAYTH because the points brought up by yasir qadhi can easily be answered by MUFTI ABU LAYTH
@@aliditta7768 you seem to be posting every where. Layths arguments are usually child like silly rational arguments. He can't think systematically nor does he consider the deeper implications of some of his arguments. More importantly none of what he says is especially knew, he's not a sunni Muslim (having left that a long time ago ).
His views are no different from other Muslim sects that ahlus Sunnah has dealt with before, mainly the mu'tazillites. But with layth what's worse is he doesn't even have any consistency in his own thought. Why take special time to deal with a guy who's pedalling arguments poorly which have already been made before and dealt with. Ultimately layth is backed by secular/white washed Muslims who want to call themselves muslim but essentially have a neutered version of Islam just like Christiania, which today which is almost irrelevant and bends to what ever the society shaping it decides.
36:01 shots fired at Mufti Abu Layth
@Swoosh Swish imam malik is free from the ways of this so called "mufti"
Bro at 55:45 He directly called him out by his real name damn
@fahad alam abu layth couldn't do crap. He'll get owned by YQ in an actual discussion. All of his arguments are rational based, none come from Quran, Sunnah or legacy of scholars. He is a clown.
@fahad alam he doesn't have time to be dealing with children.
@fahad alam you just contradicted yourself. Fool.
Eye opening library chats !!!
How I wish every episode would be 2 hour long.
when I see a video made by Yasir Qahdi I always click it no matter how long it is. :D
Same, brother!
The longer d better
@@nmmirza5853
Yes I agree but I hope he has a long discussion with MUFTI ABU LAYTH
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
@@nmmirza5853 I was just going to comment that. Yes, indeed, the longer the better. I sometimes clean my whole house whilst listening 😁
Such interesting topics
Amazing shaikh.
Someday Insha Allah I will sit in the mosque of yours and listen to your amazing lectures...
Insha Allah
It will be more beneficial of he just comes on mindtrap with Mufti!
@@nrjee6041
Yes I agree with you 1000% it would be more beneficial if Yasir Qadhi comes on MUFTI ABU LAYTHS mindtrap.
@@aliditta7768
He should man up and have a discussion face to face , I guarantee Mufti Saab will be respectful
36:00 YQ coming at mufti abu layths neck like this looool, proper sneak diss.
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
No any name of Jesus appears in 43:61. In this verse, pronoun Inna-Hu points toward Quran; not toward already died Jesus 3:144, 3:55, 5:117. In several verses of Quran, same pronoun is used for Quran. For example, in same Surah 43, just read verse 44, in which pronoun Inna-Hu is pointed toward Quran. To attach verse 43:61 with Jesus is 100% Tampering/Tahreef
وَإِنَّهُۥ لَذِكْرٌ لَّكَ وَلِقَوْمِكَ وَسَوْفَ تُسْـَٔلُونَ
Quran 43:44 *The (Qur'an) is indeed the message, for thee and for thy people; and soon shall ye (all) be brought to account.*
*We know and you also know that Mirza G A Qadiani was a False Nabi. But this never means that we should tamper translation of Quran in order to reconcile stories of fabricated hadiths with Quran*
Salaam Alaikum brother. I’ve noticed that you have lost an awful amount of weight! I hope nothing is wrong with your health. Lots of dua towards you. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I even saw from the thumbnail...
In shaa Allah it is a positive weight loss for better health
@@Shad1991 probably
I love how in asian culture when someone loses weight. Automatically people think something is wrong instead of complimenting them😂
Yes he has lost some weight 😂
@@smurfanb348 well sometimes it may be from sickness lol
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
In verse 4:158, word RAFA is used. This word Rafa is used in several other verses of Quran for the meaning of Spiritual Exaltation and to raise in honor and ranks. *Quran is the most beautiful Book as it fully explains itself, so one needs NOT to run after those tons of CONCOCTED hadiths which were IN PERSON neither certified by Rasool nor by any Sahaabi "as Sahih".* For Contrast, beautiful Quran has used both words "Rafa" and "Yas'ad" in same one verse 35:10. Here meaning of Rafa is exalt and meaning of word yas'ad is to RAISE SOMETHING PHYSICALLY UP. Noun of Yas'ad is Mas'ad, and you know well that if you visit any Arab Country; you will see word "Mas'ad" written on top of Elevators of multistory buildings.
Even in your own so-called Hadiths Literature, word RAFA is used frequently, for to raise in ranks. For example: we read in Book of Sunni sect which is labeled as Sahih-Muslim, that Rasool said:
_A person who humbles to people for the sake of God, God RAISES (RAFA) him_
Clearly, in above-mentioned tradition, it never means that God lifts body of Dust of that person to Himself.
This is also to bring in your kind info that in old copies of Gospels, that story of Ascension and return never exist. Church blended this fable in Gospels much later.
We read in 20:55 and also Genesis 3:19 that human body is made of Dust, and he will return to Dust. That Body of Dust CAN NEVER enter in the Spiritual Realm of God. If we say that in 4:158, God has raised Jesus to Himself with Jesus's body of Dust, that is *the greatest nonsense of all times.* Body of Dust cannot enter in Spiritual Realm of God but after death, only Soul is raised to God. I am sure, you have read Quranic verse 7:143 in which Moses requested God to see Him, and then what happened, you know it. Human eye which is part of this body of dust cannot see God, never never never.
Some people do Tehreef of 4:158 by misusing word إِلَيْهِ But that never means body of dust was lifted toward God. Connotation of word إِلَيْهِ is also used in 42:13. God draws to Himself for Guidance whom he want. That never means: that God pull body of dust of man to Himself.
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi, thanks for always recording your thought and opinion. I am a big fan of your lectures. And... I am always amazed to the size of your cups 😀
Greetings from Indonesia,
Wasalamu ‘alaykum-
(Sunu Wibirama / Universitas Gadjah Mada)
Oh my God!! New library chat! Alhamdullilah ! So refreshing 😄
Brother Dr.yashir qadir please all keep going on with library chat. Allah swt knows how much effort you put on this .All your effort is very much appreciatedAllah swt grant you longevity.
The day I learnt that the Jesus, yes the Jesus as we know of, will come back towards the end of time and he is still alive in the heaven, I felt an ecstacy and gush of faith like I never had before. I was at my undergrad years then. I still feel the same.
Its amazing how people trying to smartify Islam by twisting its core in light of what they understand as modern science and philosophy makes a great fool out of themselves.
Modern science and philosophy is dynamic like crazy, and entrapping Islam into them is super shortsighted, but taking nibbles of them to explain Islamic concepts with a disclaimer indeed soothes the heart.
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
3:01 Shaikh YQ: I did spend a lot of time doing research on methodology and spent 1.5 days on it.
Me: I am still working on the essay that I planned on doing after last ramadhan. 😅
*How did Fable of Ascension and Return of Nabi Isa (Jesus) creep into Islam?*
As I have said: this story did not exist in even old copies of Gospels: This fable was invented by Church much later in order to show new converts that Pauline Dogma is a supernatural dogma. Then, when in 7th Century, Christians, Jews, and Zoroastrians embraced Islam. They spread fables of their previous religions among Muslims. Irani Zoroastrians spread fable of Mahdi, Yahood spread fable of Rajam (Talmudic punishment) and Christians spread fable of Anti-Christ=Dajjal and Ascension and Return of Jesus among Muslims.
Then, these fables were blended in CONCOCTED Hadith Books of Sunni and Shia sects (Quran forbids sects 3:103, 3:105, 6:159). *Now, in order to reconcile stories of their forged hadiths with Quran, Sunni and Shia translators and Pseudo Scholars started to tamper translation of several verses which are related to Nabi Isa*
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
Quranic verse 4:157 INDEED never denies nailing of Jesus on the Cross but word "Shubbiha" confirms that he was INDEED on the Cross but Quran powerfully rejects Crucifixion of Jesus which means that he did not die on the Cross. According to all definitions of Crucifixion, death on Cross is a BINDING CONDITION of the Punishment which is called Crucifixion. If Person dies on Cross, he is Crucified but if person survives then true statements will be: though his enemies attempted his Crucifixion but they failed to crucify him.
Besides, all historical sources tell that he was on Cross, and all historical resources cannot be wrong. But same historical sources also show that he survived death on the Cross. In Fact Gospel of John and Luke clearly show that he was alive in same injured body even after the incidence of Cross, and he arranged 12 secret meetings with his Disciples even after that incidence of Cross, and finally he permanently immigrated to East of Parthian Empire and died their at very old age >> Kahlan 5:110. According to ancient Arabic literature of 8th Century, age of Kahlan is that very old age when human skin starts to putrefy and that age starts usually after age 90. History and even your own over 30 hadith Books tell that Jesus died at age 120.
_Several top Bible Scholars have written that through a plan, Essene (Hawaari Quran 3:52) drugged Jesus on the Cross in order to save him from dying on Cross. On Cross, when Jesus said: Me Thirst; a Roman Soldier dipped sponge in POSCA and extended to the lips of Jesus. As soon as he sipped, his neck was turned aside and now apparently, he _*_appeared=Resembled=Shubbiha_*_ a dead body but he was not dead. Thinking that Jesus has been died, Romans returned body to Essene. They treated him, and on 3rd day he was resuscitated (never resurrected). _*_In order to learn; then, later where did Jesus go; you are suggested to read our IN DEPTH Research on this subject._*
Essene were mere Instruments of God. It was Plan/Scheme of God to save Jesus, and no one is better Planner than God >> Read Quran 3:54
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
Quranic verse 3:144 makes as clear as is 1+1=2 that all Rasool (Rusul) before Prophet Mohammad are passed away=died. And Jesus is not exempted from this verse. So he is also dead
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
In verse 4:159, word Moute-hi points to Mout of every Kitaabi, and not to any future death of already dead Jesus. Even tons of your own Mufassars including Zamakhshari has said same
And [beware the Day] when Allah will say, "O Jesus, Son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as deities besides Allah ?'" He will say, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within myself, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, it is You who is Knower of the unseen.I said not to them except what You commanded me - to worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them as long as I was among them; but when You took me up, You were the Observer over them, and You are, over all things, Witness. Sura 5:116-117
Jesus is not coming back, this verse is the clear evidence for it. If he came back and broke the cruisses and kill the piggs he would not act on the Day of judgement like he didnt know about anything because then he would be lying to Allah what is impossible. Jesus confirm in the verse that he didnt know what the Christians where doing or believing after Jesus death. Yes Allah did let hem die and ibn hazm and ibn abbas confirm this
قَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ { مُتَوَفِّيكَ } مُمِيتُكَ
Ibn Abbas said: “Mutawaffeeka [means] ‘I’ll cause you to die’ (Mumeetuka)” (Sahih Bukhari 14/149, Kitabul Tafsir)
ولم يرد عيسى عليه السلام بقوله (فلما توفيتنى) وفاة النوم فصح أنه انما عنى وفاة الموت
Translation: “And Jesus (peace be upon him) did not mean by his saying Falammaa Tawaffaytanee (5:117) that he was made to sleep. What is correct is that he was made to Die.”
Reference: Al-Muhalla; v.1 p.23 (Mas'alah no.41)
The interpetation of the Quran is done in Light of the hadith and all the hadith about Jesus are coming from Ibn Shihab Al Zuhri, If the hadiths are not true than all the scholars after who are taking the hadith as true and do interpetation of the Quran with it a new false claim in the islamic History and faith is created. Malik wrote his Muwatta after the middle of the second century, about 150 years after the Prophet. During this time the belief in the return of Jesus -- an interesting, fascinating and important belief -- would have spread far enough for a man of Malik’s knowledge to come to know about it. And if Malik knew about it but did not believe in it, then his judgment in the matter carries some weight since he lived a considerable time before Bukhari and Muslim.
In Bukhari all the ahadith about the return of Jesus have chains that pass through Ibn Shihab and then after one more link through Abu Hurayrah. If the isnad method was very dependable this would have been acceptable but given the fact that the isnad method has not produced too dependable results we cannot put too much confidence in the reliability of these ahadith. There is a distinct possibility that (Ib Shihab) al-Zuhri heard these “ahadith” from not-too-reliable sources and then transmitted them without mentioning the source, as he was at times wont to do. This will explain why these “ahadith” are not found in Muwatta: Imam Malik might have heard these traditions from al-Zuhri, but he did not put much trust in them since no reliable source was given by (Ibn Shibab) al-Zuhri. Later, by the time of Bukhari and Muslim these traditions had been attributed to the Prophet through Abu Hurayrah and then they became acceptable."
Dear. Mr. Qadhi:
In verse 3:55 and 5:117, word Wafat appears for the death of Jesus. In your own native country India or Pakistan and also in Arabic Schools, even a 5th grader knows that "Wafat" means: Death. For example:
آگر ٹی-وی پر یہ خبر نشر ہوتی ہے کہ مولوی ڈیزل وفات پا گیا ہے تو اس کا مطلب ہے کہ وہ مر گیا ہے۔ یہ نہیں کہ مولوی اپنے مٹی کے جسم کے ساتھ خدا کے ہاں اٹھا لیا گیا ہے اور یہ بھی نہیں کہ وہ سو رہا تھا اور اسے خدا کے ہاں اٹھا لیا گیا ہے
In over 25 verses, word "Wafat" is used for death. In 10:46, word "Wafat" is used for the death of Prophet Mohammad, and same word Wafat is used for the death of Jesus in 3:55, 5:117. All verbs used in 5:116-117 in are past tense. That show: that conversation of Jesus with God has already taken place after Jesus' death when his Soul was raised to God 32:11, 6:94
There is no any reason nor any logic and rationally to translate word WAFAT in 5:117, 3:55 as "To Take up to God". That is 101% Tehreef=tampering
SYQ & MALM must come on mindtrap, I am waiting for that day to come Insha Allah.
@fahad alam Lol it would have been a very interesting debate 🤔never mind lol.
@@abulislam8421
Why doesn't yasir qadhi have a discussion with mufti abu LAYTH??
@@aliditta7768
YQ is too scared to come on Mindtrap even though he knows Mufti Saab will be respectful
@fahad alam
Your absolutely right his own followers will boycott him and make takfir of him and if Yasir Qadhi looses. It makes the fans look really stupid too!
Please discuss this with Mufti Abu Layth on his MindTrap show. Mufti Abu Layth is not argumentative, and is respectful to those that want to have a discussion with him even if they have different viewpoints. Please see the debate on Bukhari with Dr Abdul Majid for an example.
We have the Quran and Sahih Hadith. Jesus a.s ate food he was human and Allah would cause him to die a natural death and two Isa’s are mentioned in Sahih Bukhari. Stop trying to pull the wool over our eyes and accept the fact that Isa a.s fulfilled his mission c2000 yrs ago and the second Isa will be a nabi as mentioned by Muhammad SAW. People can read more and have done during Covid - we don’t need scholars giving us conflicting views. Jzk
MashaAllah! The quality of the videos is getting better each time! Keep them coming Ya Shaikh!
As a Ph.D. student studying religious intellectual history, I really hope these library chats return. 'Alf shukran to Dr. Qadhi and his team for uploading them!
If they do come back, I would absolutely love an accompanying reading list (perhaps 5-10 books, chapters, or articles for further reading -- Arabic or English) in the video description for those who want to explore further.
Be like Mike..
The absolute joy and sheer excitement I feel when I see a new library chat's been uploaded is completely unparalelled! May Allah shower you with all good, and protect you from every evil everywhere shaykh.
Ameen.
ٱلسَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ
I would recommend you (since you speak Urdu) to watch Javed Ahmed Ghamidi’s 23 Questions Series on this particular issue. I hope it will give you his perspective aswel.
This is a timely gift to Nigerian Muslims. جزاكم الله خيرا
Any talk given by Sheikh Yasir, turns out as knowledge treat for me. Regardless of complete agreement or part disagreement
1:04:52 Mufti there's your Masala hahahaha what was that
My sheikh Yasir Qadhi, what is wrong with u? MUFTI ABU LAYTH IS GOING TO GET YOU, ILL BET MY HOUSE ON that 😀😀😀
Who is that?
Abu Layth?
A Jesus Christ contender?
😂.
Be my guess, I have done my job.
😂😂😂.
Surely the Al-Qur'ăn currents all things including current {electric} truth of the hour.
V/R = I.
V x I = W (what ever humans have with them now)
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
(159) - وَإِنْ مِنْ أَهْلِ الْكِتَابِ إِلَّا لَيُؤْمِنَنَّ بِهِ قَبْلَ مَوْتِهِ ۖ وَيَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ يَكُونُ عَلَيْهِمْ شَهِيدًا
And there is none from the People of the Scripture but that he will surely believe in Jesus before his death. And on the Day of Resurrection he will be against them a witness.
An-Nisa'
A physical raising - “To Allah” clashes with fundamental creed. Allah is not bound by time and space. Allah is omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent. So what does it even mean for Prophet Isa to be raised (UP) to Allah? In space, there isn’t really an “up” or “down”. Prophet Isa could not have been raised physically But rather Rafa (Raising) here is similar to the raising of Idris, in terms of honor and status.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
(61) - وَإِنَّهُ لَعِلْمٌ لِلسَّاعَةِ فَلَا تَمْتَرُنَّ بِهَا وَاتَّبِعُونِ ۚ هَٰذَا صِرَاطٌ مُسْتَقِيمٌ
And indeed, Jesus will be [a sign for] knowledge of the Hour, so be not in doubt of it, and follow Me. This is a straight path.
Az-Zukhruf
Please watch mufti abu layth Response on his last monday Nights at 1h and 3 minutes
The library chat's quality is TOP, a privilege truly for the viewers ma sha Allah. BarakAllah fik for making it available for free Shaykh!
Assala mu alaikum Dr Qadhi.
Please do a talk on the Mongols.
And perhaps Muawiyyah r.a.
In sha Allah.
Jazak Allah khair.
Sheikh, there is an imam at my local mosque sent from Turkey that rejects Isa's (as) second coming. He isn't a hadith rejector, just ignorant. Can you get this video translated into Turkish so that I can show him? Jazakallah Khair.
It's amazing how a fabricated letter of Paul which mentions the anti christ happens to be correct in Islam. Subhanallah. 🙌
Shaikh...we would be benefited if u have a lecture on the story of Jesus(pbuh)
Extremely true
But watch his story on islamic inspiration channel. Shaykh talks there for some time
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
pls pls, never stop library chat❣️❣️❣️
It covers the topics which are untouched by everyone and we really need to hear it
Dr Qadhi. You are an inspiring scholar and academic. Allah has used you to guide me to Islam and rediscover the intellectual beauty of this religion. May Allah continue to bless you with wisdom. Allah has allowed you to be used to open the hearts of so many Muslims. Please continue with this library series talks.
I rarely come across this high level discussion as I am unfortunately not an arabic speaker but also an academic albeit in medicine.
Keep this up and always stay focused and disregard the plethora of needless critics and harmful people ya Dr Qadhi.
th-cam.com/video/wEj_mbd-Xkg/w-d-xo.html
Great video today keep it up your doing amazing job
You naughty naughty . Come to mind trap qadhi sahab .
Bhai kaha se hai ?
@fahad alam ho bangali to . India thake
@fahad alam na Tripura .. It's on the north east side near Assam .
@fahad alam hai let's stay in touch we can exchange WhatsApp if you will .
@fahad alam that's ok .
By Allah, I love you for his sake.
I ask Allah to allow me to study from you in person and grant me and yourself great knowledge, and unite us in Jannah Al Firdaws
54:00 Abu layth gets smoked loool
@fahad alam lol u seem a hardcore fan.
@fahad alam Your back and forth with @sbasha7
and this comment: haha mufti will nuke YQ . . YQ cant even deal with that sajid lipham gang
...its like you are watching some anime fight of bosses, and taking sides. Argumentations between scholars, undermines sharia, so should not be encouraged, that is basic, acquire knowledge that is beneficial and ignore the rest.
Backbiting is haram.
@ayadollar khomaini =.= are you another opinionated fellow?
@@shafqatishan437 whom?
36:00 For Mufti Abu layth in the audience, the Dons of Maliki madhab believe in the coming of Jesus as. Aaaaaritteeee
That comment is so stupid why ??
YASIR QADHI was a hard core follower of the Don's of the salafi dawah and yet he clearly now said that dua to other than Allah is NOT shirk but only haram. Yet yasir qadhi is going against ALL the Don's of the salafi dawah scholars who believe it's not haram but SHIRK.
@@aliditta7768 what is pseudosalafi dawah?
A phenomenon of the 18th century. Pseudosalafis have no scholarship linkage beyond 18th century.
@@aliditta7768 bro u forgot one thing ,he left salafi/najdi dawah long before making these decision.But its a fair point,u can agree/disagree even though they are don
@@altairlahad9469
Correction he left the label and associating with the salafi group but never left what the Don's have taught him. He still have the same belief of everything the dons taught him and the enemy ( non salafi ) he once warned against corrected Yasir qadhi on his understanding of tawheed and shirk and other views he had about Abdul Wahab. It was those deviants callers who attacked islam and distaughted islam that CORRECTED yasir qadhi years later.
That's why yasir qadhi believes that dua to other than Allah is NOT shirk but just haram.
@@gsb433
YASIR QADHI learnt his islam from madinah university. Sitting at the feet of the salafi Don's.
I get so excited every time I see there is a new Library Chat :)
Thank Allah for being alive today. No way I would have access to so much knowledge and such great scholars if I was born in an earlier era.
The one big issue with this is this Ayah: ‘And I was a witness over them while I dwelt amongst them, but when You took me up, You were the Watcher over them; and You are a Witness to all things’” (al-Ma'idah 5:117)
I.e. Allah asks Jesus if he told people to worship him and his mother after his departure. Jesus denies this here by saying that he only told them to worship Allah, and that he was witness over them while he was on earth.
Now, if Jesus were to return again, then most certainly he would know that christians took him as God and worshiped him. But in his answer to God, it seems he is indicating thtat he did not know what they did after he left, i.e. he did not know that they started worshiping him.
Oh, and I am not a Qadiani or something - as I know they bring up this issue. No, I am bringing up this issue because because it does seem to strongly indicate that on the Day of Judgement Isa will not know that people worshiped him after his departure - which is in opposition to the claim of his second coming.
The second thing, which you brushed away, but seems to be very important is: How come that the OLDEST collection of hadith, i.e. the Muwatta does not have anything about the second coming of Isa?
Does this not strike you as strange? That all the other, later collections have the supposed hadiths, but the earliest ones does not have it? And the same, as you mentioned, regarding the signs of the hour -- you mentioned that Muwatta does not have this ... yet the newer hadith collections have so many "signs", partly contradicting each other.
Does this not strike you as odd?
Ummm... You know God could simply tell him
See bellow..
Here are evidences what rasul(sa) understood the word "tawaffathanee"... in surah maidah. 5:117.. Rasul(sal) understood as death meaning himself and he(sa) did not meant this as raised up alive. Then why we need to twist this as Jesus raised up alive??? It is really twisting meaning . Rasul(sa) meant tawaffaithanee means death and same applies to Jesus as well.
Evidence in bukhari and Muslim. Sahih.
Hadith
""
It was narrated that Ibn 'Abbas (رضي الله عنه) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) stood before us, exhorting us, and he said:
“You will be gathered unto Allah barefoot, naked and uncircumcised. ‘As We began the first creation, We shall repeat it. (It is) a promise binding upon Us. Truly, We shall do it’ [al-Anbiya’ 21:104]. The first of mankind to be clothed will be Ibraheem, the Close Friend of the Most Merciful (Khaleelur-Rahman). Then some of you will be taken to the left - Ibn Ja'far said; Some men of my ummah will be brought and taken to the left - and I shall say: 'My Lord, my companions!’ but it will be said to me: ‘You do not know what they introduced after you were gone; they kept turning on their heels since you left them.’ And I shall say the same as the righteous slave [‘Eesa] said: ‘And I was a witness over them while I dwelt amongst them, but when You took me up, You were the Watcher over them; and You are a Witness to all things. If You punish them, they are Your slaves, and if You forgive them, verily, You, only You, are the All Mighty, the All-wise’” (al-Ma'idah 5:117).
Its isnad is saheeh, al-Bukhari (3349) and Muslim (2860)]
Musnad Ahmad 2096
Arabic/English book : Book 25, Hadith 2096
There are some references where ibn abbas ral interpreted as death for related verses...
Nestorian christians of those times when islam set foot on sham were given higher positions durind ommayad dynasty. They injected their beliefs to islam thru ahadith.
Historically speaking, those were theocratical society. Earlier periods were theocrstical society .. when evil spread by rulers much, in order to pacify public, savior theories were spread by religious authoriities of those times by their hand with those rulers. Evry religion of those times had savior theoru for future. Christianity judaism too had. Christianity believes on second coming of jesus becuase as oer the bible jesus has to come to establish God's kingdom... Thsts their belief. Same injected to islamic literstures thru hadiths. Not all accepted islam when islam set foot on sham. Obviously some hypocrites among christians too. They injected these to islam thru ahadith. They cant mutilate quran coz Allah protects it. They cant inject thru fiqh as fiqh was deeply living tradition of those times. Only way is thru hadith they have to. Early hadith books did not mention any second coming of jesus. E.g if u refer muwatta , there is none there. Hammam ibn munabbih the earliest hadith book dont have these second coming of jesus ahadiths.
I’m seriously not sure if I should be taking any knowledge from yasir qadhi, May Allah guide us all.
Why are you saying like this ?
@@rameezahamed he is a reformist and teaches Islam from oriental sources. I don’t know what he is up to now but I would rather stay away. Any of our scholars wouldn’t take anything after the things he has said etc.
@@Tislyfe Can you mention those scholar names as well. Yes, I agree to your point to an extent. May Allah guide us all to be in straight path till our death.
@@rameezahamed this is my decision after viewing some of his behaviour. I used to watch YQ many years ago….. Search for these brothers who provide evidence, Sakai’s Lipham, The muslim Skeptic and Sheikh Karin Abu Zair even wrote a book to refute yasir qadhi! One example is “grave worship”. We only worship Allah, but YQ made it seem like it is ok to do so and is not shirk! Astaghfirullah. And Allah knows best, I would rather stay away.
@@rameezahamed ameen brother. I already posted some who have discussed the YQ issue like saajid Lipham, Sheikh Karim abu zaid, also FaridResponds to name a few.
Thank you Sheikh for teaching us!!
Wow. Great presentation. Call for Evidence part is great.
I love YQ, Ghamidi ji and MALM. May Allah give us a better understanding on Religion when this dust gets settled.
Malm the Don of 21 century
IT DOESN'T MATTER WHO YOU LIKE OR FEEL GOOD FOR..
BUT WHAT MATTERS IS THAT WHEN JESUS(ALEHISALAAM) RETURNS WILL YOU ACCEPT HIM?
IF YOU DON'T THEY YOU HAVE TO FALL INTO DAJJALS TRAP
So exited to c the topic , my fav
I am sure ghamdi never read this many books.
He is clearly a rejector of Hadith o Athaar
My bro Ghamdi isn't an Islamic Scholars..he is a professor of history and has no academic qualification comparing YQ to Ghamidi is like comparing a head surgeon(YQ) with a nursery science teacher