Metal fan here. Marr is mind blowing. He's our generation's George Harrison, the man who everyone who knows how to play guitar looks up to because he's not showy, but he does things that make you go "what just happened there?!"
Yeah, it kind of seems to me that the original was all about Johnny Mars guitar lead and he hands it off here. Nothing against them or him, but it’s like a tribute band and I’m thinking it really shouldn’t be that way.
Sem o andy fica mais dificil ainda! É mwlhor deixar como está! The Smiths já é uma lenda um Mito. Umas das bandas que mais influenciaram outras. Se não for A Primeira?! Superando até os Beatles !
Nobody who's remotely sensible turns up to a Johnny Marr gig for anything other than the guitar. If you're going to a Marr gig expecting stellar vocals, you've missed the point entirely.
Dude, look up Morrissey's version of this, it totally sucks, his guitarists don't even attempt to play the famous riff. Johnny does it the way it was meant to sound.
@@Malto_Dextrin Alain Whyte is a great guitarist. But he was recently pushed out (again) Alain is probably better than Marr in many ways especially in his solo pursuits. I'll always love Johnny's playing forever and always.
Shame Morrissey has revealed himself to be a monumental tw*t. Thankfully, the Smiths was always about Marr, once you realise the sheer complexity of his playing.
@@sammealor4564 I don't even think Johnny would agree with that. Morrissey may be an arse as a person, but he is one of the most distinct and nuanced voices in music. Last time I heard him live, he was spectacular. As a singer, Johnny is pedestrian at best and would go unoticed if he were not the guitarist in The Smiths.
@@CatherineNeal It's based on documentries I've watched and interviews I've read. Of course, it's probably an unfair judgment since I don't know the man personally. 😊
I was there! ❤❤❤❤ Johnny F**King Marr Amazing!!!!!
Me too ! He was amazing!❤
Me too! Fabulous! ❤
Me too!! Amazing night!!
Turned 59 last month. Man I miss the 80’s. 😊
Same 56
Same
@@EndoftheTownProductions same
I am a heavy rock fiend, but gotta say it, Marr is a riff meister.
nicely put
Metal fan here. Marr is mind blowing. He's our generation's George Harrison, the man who everyone who knows how to play guitar looks up to because he's not showy, but he does things that make you go "what just happened there?!"
@@peterclarke7240 mad you saying that I’m just watching the back ent of concert for George
Fair play to Jonny marr he wrote the music , morrissey wrote the lyrics and bless them I've a great tattoo of this charming man ❤
That's a tough one to play and sing at the same time. He hands it off to Doviak once the vocals start.
Yeah, it kind of seems to me that the original was all about Johnny Mars guitar lead and he hands it off here. Nothing against them or him, but it’s like a tribute band and I’m thinking it really shouldn’t be that way.
@@cheap25cos all they really need is a vocalist, with some character.
He's not playing the tough parts.
....you can see why Morrissey was on vocal duties in the Smiths !
2024 🎉
This is so much better than Morrissey's self-obsessed American gigs. Johnny is the Smiths!
This kicks ass. And the lack of racism between the songs is always a plus.
Idiot comment.
Now all you need is Morrissey
What?
JM smiling?
I'm alarmed.
It's good... but it's sorely missing Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce.
tHE SMITHS PODERIAM VOLTAR PARA UMA TURNÊ ....DEIXAR A VAIDADE DE LADO...SÃO MOSNTROS DA MÚSICA MUNDIAL... TRAZER A ALEGRIA DE VOLTA DO ROCK
Sem o andy fica mais dificil ainda! É mwlhor deixar como está!
The Smiths já é uma lenda um Mito. Umas das bandas que mais influenciaram outras. Se não for A Primeira?! Superando até os Beatles !
If I had to pick between Marr playing / singing this song and Morrissey singing / his guitarrist destroying the song... sorry Moz!!
It's not the same without Morrisey.
If Johnny sang like he played, he’d sound like morrissey 😂
I wonder if Americans would sing along like the British.
Of course, Moz is superior. This song meant so much to me in 1984 as teenager.
A Karaoke Version of This Charming Man 🥹
Nobody who's remotely sensible turns up to a Johnny Marr gig for anything other than the guitar.
If you're going to a Marr gig expecting stellar vocals, you've missed the point entirely.
Good, but let's not kid ourselves, Morrisey's vocals are superior.
This was good enough that I'd not come away remotely disappointed, plus Morrissey is a wanker
Dude, look up Morrissey's version of this, it totally sucks, his guitarists don't even attempt to play the famous riff. Johnny does it the way it was meant to sound.
Yeh but, Johnny is a better guitarist than Morrissey. Swings n roundabouts
Honestly I think Johnny's are better. Never liked the way morrisey sings.
@@Malto_Dextrin Alain Whyte is a great guitarist. But he was recently pushed out (again) Alain is probably better than Marr in many ways especially in his solo pursuits. I'll always love Johnny's playing forever and always.
This song just needs Morrissey's voice.
Shame Morrissey has revealed himself to be a monumental tw*t.
Thankfully, the Smiths was always about Marr, once you realise the sheer complexity of his playing.
It’s a shame that’s not true. Johnny sounds better
@@sammealor4564 I don't even think Johnny would agree with that. Morrissey may be an arse as a person, but he is one of the most distinct and nuanced voices in music. Last time I heard him live, he was spectacular. As a singer, Johnny is pedestrian at best and would go unoticed if he were not the guitarist in The Smiths.
@@stevenhartlaub4557 I agree with everything except that M is an arse. What even makes you say that?!
@@CatherineNeal It's based on documentries I've watched and interviews I've read. Of course, it's probably an unfair judgment since I don't know the man personally. 😊
lol... only Morrissey can do that tbh. and I hate Morrissey
Better than Morrissey !
Anyone is a better singer than Morrissey!
Marr worked with Morrissey because Morrissey had a good voice. Marr does not and I'm sure he is aware.
Sorry he is not a frontman. Love him but NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Could be my nephew who's in show choir singing.
Jonhnny don’t Sing” it’s dreadful. Keep to your guitar riffs pal.
He's no Morrissey. And I know Morrissey. 🙄
Well, he’s no bigot either. So there’s that.
I'll take a supremely talented guitarist who can't sing but isn't a fascist over sad old "angry man down the pub" Morrissey any day of the year.
@@peterclarke7240Childish comment.