The whole fault lies with the incompetent central leadership at that time. Everyone understands that. Bureaucrats can't act on their own they follow orders of elected ppl.
Just listening to MR dulat answers one can feel how incompetent he is and this 🕵️ guy doesn’t even know that they had arms when the plane landed in Amritsar and to contradict his own answer he says it wud have been a blood bath in Amritsar airport even before this guy know whether hijackers have arms or knife with them and he whitewashes by saying its far better to release and get a negotiated settlement than a Amritsar storming without even realizing that the guy they released had killed 10x the number of indians than the ones in the hijacked flight
This mf Dulat was heading the intelligence but didn't have anything before this terrible thing happened. What this mf was doing? In our country there is no accountability. This guy should be sacked. Intel failure . 😊
I wont even allow this guy to walk my dog.....forget about being intelligence Chief of India.....What caliber of people we appoint for our Intelligence agencies....
Barkha - Why don’t you do a candid episode on 26/11 covering (1) why it happened, (2) what were the lapses by Govt in handling it (3) Could it have been averted and (4) what is the role of media who are alleged to have given away vital information concerning NSG Commondos under the guise of investigative journalism. Be truthful without trying to defend your role also. It had inadvertently given away vital clues to the terrorists and their command control at Karachi. I know that wasn't your intention but you need to come out clear by admitting lapses of you and few other hyper journalistson that day. I remember Shoba De screaming on the tv asking politicians not to indulge in showing make- belief concerns but to stay away and allow NSG and police to tackle without hindrance
Barkha doesn't let Dulat complete sentences. She assumes what he is going to say, and frames the next question which is tangential to what Dulat was going to say. Any other interviewer would have teased out a more complete and satisfying interview from Mr Dulat. Such a waste!
Quite ironical that the person responsible for letting the handlers of 26/11 know locations of the terrorists is now asking questions about national security in an interview!
You can easily see if these guys are in chief position, nothing more can be expected. And the show is done without watching the series....its basic. Only God have saved India from these guys.
No need to watch a hogwash series to discuss the real hijacking’s from the people who were dealing with it. This show was not so much about the crappy series that nutcase abubhav sinha made. It’s about what really happened at that time straight from the men in charge. What do you don’t understand ??
Really, he was R&W chief 🥺🥺 and doesn't know what kind of weapon terrorist carried. Shame on you sir daulat. If this similar incident happened in any other part of the world their intelligence agency had figured out the number of bullet .
@@Mehwish-bringsTruth Look , I don't think it's about person. I don't even considered who is saying. I have just raise a legitimate question being R&W chief he had obliged to figured out all those stuff. Doesn't matter if doval was in his shoes I too have raised it. Especially, In that period of time our R&W had a flop show they didn't succeed to take out crucial Intel.
The RAW chief appeared incompetent and unaware of the situation. How could he fail to communicate with the pilot and remain uncertain about whether the hijacker had a weapon? He seemed to be merely following procedures while the pilot communicated with ATC. A commission of inquiry should be established to investigate this mishap thoroughly. I don't understand why the fellow is either so overwhelmed or overly supportive of Pakistan, always using "Insha'Allah" in every communication.I initially had a good opinion of Mr. Vajpayee's government, but it seems they were just part of the typical indecisive Indian system.I can confidently say that if this had happened under Modi, the outcome would have been different. Mark my words, the people of India will remember and deeply appreciate Modi's courage and decisiveness after his retirement.
The REAL QUESTION which needs debate is how a spate of terrorist attacks & bomb blasts in India continued for a long time and HOW it has now almost completely stopped [except in Kashmir] ALMOST AS IF A TAP WAS SHUT! What was enabling it earlier? What has stopped it now since 2014? What has the NDA done that the UPA didn't?
Major terrorist attack has stopped after 26/11. After 26/11, we have handled border situation in East very well without any PR Our forces are smart enough to handle situations. Yes, it's true top leadership at both political & bureaucracy class hesitate a lot in taking up a decision. Either it's not taken or taken after a good amount of delay The latest example is of the Puja Khedkar case where the DoPT took the entire 4 months to expel her from service while being an open & shut case
Terrorism in general was at its peak from 2000s to 2010 .... world intelligence exchange has improved significantly and world over successful terrorism attacks have stopped! Everything is not about NDA vs UPA On the other hand why are gangsters like Lawrence Bishnoi able to operate openly from jails ?
The security system underwent complete overhaul after 29/11. Chithamparum took over as the Home minister ( from his usual portfolios of finance and commerce, in which he used to be ultra efficient). A new security system under the lines of US interior security was developed, with quite a lot hand holding from the US government. This was a game changer. One has to know history before bluffing on ‘seeming’ correlation. The US security system after the 9/11 was quite proactive - this was documented by scholar like Amitava Kumar. Indian security system after 29/11 is modelled on this.
Kitna dhakkan hain be tu? Pulawama kya tha? 2019 comes after 2014. Another shameless andjha-bhakt aka 2-rupees troll. challl, godi-media dekh jake. Aur school-me admission le phir.
Can’t remember a more incompetent spy chief. His performance in Kashmir, Punjab, Sri Lanka were abysmal failures. ‘I still don’t know whether they had arms’ what a claim to make.
I think these guys were pretending to bribe the Kashmiris, without any evidence that radicalism, separatism & violence went down by a notch. They may all have been in cahoots with the Kashmiris & Pakistanis for all you know.
He is being honest. And it’s ok for you commenting in social media on hindsight after 20 years ? I would love to see what arm chair critics would if you were in their shoes at that difficult moment ? Pls stop being immature and childish. These are best of the best professionals and you just have to hear them out. You don’t have the competence nor the skills to criticize these men who have gone through so much and have served India with full commitment. You should be ashamed.
If you are running an interview at least see the series and then you would have asked more pertinent questions which were very important. Missed opportunity I think. So frustrating from viewers point of view…..
Indian citizens should remember face of this guy, Mr dullat. He is the man who convinced Delhi that peace cab be brought to kashmir by negotiations. His policies brought Mumbai 2008 attack. All patriotic Indians should make sure that people like him do not reach in meaningful positions.
You mean to say none of these guys interacted with the passengers once they returned.. Moreover with one of their own in the aircraft.. Such a Shame.. Why is Dulat doing this interview.. Why is Barkha not asking him tough questions as she does to the opposition politicians..
Barkha is one of the dulat gang.they share the same ideology which is border line treason..spouting wokeism while Hindus pay the price with their lives.at best they are useful idiots of the left/jihadi combine or they are so selfish that they will sell the country for self gain.
On page 7 of Chapter 1 of Capt. Devi Sharan's book, he describes his first impression when a hijacker entered the cockpit, writing, "What I noticed immediately were the pistol and hand grenade he was carrying." It is shocking to hear Mr. Dulat express uncertainty about whether the hijackers had any weapons on them, suggesting they might have obtained them in Lahore.
This senior official who was in the negotiating team, never read the book written by the pilot and to this day doesn’t know if gins were on board in Amritsar! Amazing how ignorant and non curious this person is! My God
When you haven’t watched the series hosting multiple interviews doesn’t make sense. Someone in the team should probably watch the series and give Barkha Ma’am the jist of the series. Really disappointed that both the host and guests have been debating a series they haven’t watched COMPLETELY. The point of the whole show is defeated. We appreciate the information but the basis of the program is on loose foundation.
The paralysis in the control room which was responsible for the goof up at Amritsar airport was most likely due to the fact that the brother-in-law of N K Singh was on board. This is the professional caliber of the people in power in India, As far as killings in the plane are concerned, well how many have the three terrorists killed in India since they were released? I'm amazed at the unprofessionalism of Dulat.
Barkha, the least you can do is to watch the series before doing these shows on on this subject matter. You jump into so many conclusions without having the basic information.
This fiasco should lead to declassifying all the Minutes of meeting, documents, classified ones after a certain period.. The people of this country have every right to know what transpired at RAW , IB, PMO, south block, north block, etc etc. Or else we will just need to believe such guys who wiill write some books at retirement.
what appalls me is that such a veteran does not know even today that they had guns or not. Did they not debrief the passengers, the pilot? this is the reason why such things happen to this country. We entrust our security to people who even today don't learn from their mistakes
Question: "Is it a complete whitewashing?" Answer: "No, No. But I haven't seen the whole series but I don't think so..." If you didn't see the series, why say No it's not a whitewashing?
That's why I have dislike for coalition Govt. They are not strong and also so full of contradiction. I can digest the fact that those prisoners were released, but its difficult for me to comprehend that these who were planned this were not taken down later...
7:33 : If Taliban was neutral, why did they put up anti aircraft guns to foil an NSG attempt ro carry out an Entebbe - like ope ration? They could have actually helped the NSG.
Barkha I have followed u from kargil days & I tell these all high profile political people want to rub each other back and don't want to set a precedence for themselves to be caught in a catch 22 situation just like Rubaiya. Till 2014 no one wanted to hit the nail on its head
@@anshuraj4277 Sood was Raw chief not dulat. I'm talking about late nineties when dulat had contacts with militants of j&k. When kandhar happened he is just an advisor of pm.
@@vikku_19 so having contact with militant was his job All I am saying is if he was so bad and evil Why didn't vajpayee Fire him from whatever post he was on and have him arrested
How one does an interview without even watching the show. It's pathetic when even serious journalists do this. Please don't downgrade your standards. You were widely respected for your work at one point in time!
That's why it's imperative for countries to have clear cut policies on terrorism. India paid for having infirm minds and confusion. I'm not a fan of Dulat.
Barkha please don't expose indian incompetence by interviewing such people who don't no details after so long. He doesn't have the need to case study for future mishaps. This person is not the one who's blood will boil.
I appreciate his honesty to acknowledge how inefficient and lazy these officials were who just got frozen when the time demanded them to show their grit to save their nation :(
You mean after it was all over, Captain Devi Sharan/the passengers were never asked by the investigators if the terrorists had ammunition? Is this really the RAW chief speaking?
Barkha is doing back to back programs on this ic814 issue…. Without watching the series…. I find that strange… aren’t you supposed to study the subject before you discuss it …. I also find it strange that the survivors who witnessed everything… aren’t being called … or why nobody wants to say what the truth was…!!
She was a very famous reporter then so she knows more about the incident than the series. Plus I'm sure she's read the book the series is based on and other available literature
I think to protect one highly connected officer (tomar)the whole IPS ,IAS lobby played with innocent people in the flight and gave away easy chances like stopping the flight from taking off in Amritsar and in-fact they exchanged a dreaded terrorist who came back and wreak havoc in india and still dng it Its just the IPS-IAS lobby and all the rulers bend for this lobby
IB and he doesn't have the feed from the pilot to ATC if the hijackers had automatic weapons from Nepal to Amritsar.... really scary...when he says he doesn't even know this day ...after the multiple debriefs they would have done of all on board including his elderly friend who got off in Dubai.... really incompetent people at the realm of affairs...as he said himself "good friends who get positions not competence"..
Wonderful program Barkha!! The releases of dreaded terrorist as deal always puzzling my mind. Whether the civilians life is more precious than our security forces? Being a civilian I wonder when it come to sacrificing for your nation seems it’s only for citizens who joined security forces!!! Barkha rightly pointed out we’re afraid about the casualties that time and there after these terrorists gave us more casualties than then would have. I personally consider the decision of our government and not taking timely action was weak and lethargic systems. Mr. Dullat looks me a man at job as kk Menon was in 1962 China war
Musharaf cheated BJP government that time . Because their agenda Ram mandir. No matter Pulwama happend, Cargill happend many army personnel died due these two major and same time Bombay blast etc. I am worrying in future if BJP will continue in power.
Netflix should have made a webseries on united flight 93. Although situations can't help, it would have been truly inspiring for all of us specifically... instead of reminding bittersweet past of IC814.
I really liked this interview 😅.. He seems honest. Also, I agree with him about the movie. I watched it and i feel this movie is about the passengers 😅
I stopped watching the series after 1.5 episodes out of humiliation. So incompetent, indecisive government intelligence authorities. After seeing so many big shots involved handling the situation, it was like 'Too many cooks spoil the broth'.
You have a waiter like Dulat this is the outcome. He doesn't know whether they had guns...he "escorts" Azhar without even seeing him. What, if the wrong man had been released from jail? This cartoon was not just a delivery boy..he was a dumb & incompetent delivery boy.
But in interview with Richa the captain clearly said that the hijacker had put a gun on neck when he asked him to fly to Kabul before landing in Amritsar.
Barkha Dutt has not seen the series but conducts an interview with Duval on the Netflix serial the plane hijack !!! That's Barkha Dutt type of journalism!!!! That's the type of journalism today's journalists are practicing!!
If that time Congress was in power. I am telling you today BJP loudly blame Gandhi family belongs to Pakistan not Indian. Inspiet and fact Congree regime these hard core terrorist realised. Thankfull to God today Gandhi family safe and humiliation.
Bharkha ji, Hijacking of IC814 in 1999 & kargil war reflected the failure of intelligence & security system at that time.The political indecisiveness and immaturity was the root cause. Not stopping, storming the plane at Amritsar & release of big terrorists was a damaging political decision. Had it been taken by Congress or other government, the RSS and BJP would have made it a very big and long lasting issue like kashmir.
How ridiculous! Dulat ji! You were responsible for such a serious decision making and even after the event, you never met the pilots, crew, and passengers? You did not read any of the books written by Pilot Devi Sharan, book by Flight engineer Anil Jaggia and Saurabh Shukla, and book by flight purser Anil Sharma and official Ajit Doval? Not one of them? Where is your conscience? Your intelligence failed, at least to know how hostages suffered and to avoid such mishaps in the future you could have got useful insights?
Something very fishy i smell after this interview They can’t even know now if there were guns or not???? They don’t know if money was demanded What lies and rumors go around??? And people will believe the lies and drama in the film
I think barkha has lost mind as she is doing the show w/o seeing the series which has been made with fantastically accurate and very professionally directed.Every time we all get a paralytic attack when it’s time to take decisions.
I am quite surprised that Farooq resisted releasing the terrorists. I thought he was one among the Pak ISI internal circle. If he really meant it, he seemed to be the wisest of all the incompetent people who handled this case.
Cheap media is nobodies' friend. If some of the hostages had died if the plane was stormed by Punjab police commandoes, then same Barkha Dutt would have questioned the operation. The role of Punjab CM was deplorable. Such decisions should entirely be with the professionals of NSG who should take over the command of such emergencies.
![If [Pannun plot] Happened Ajit [Doval] May've Been in the Know of it: Former R&AW chief AS Dulat](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gdeQ6vwii0U/mqdefault.jpg)
![⭐ฮิตในTikTok!! ( หมูเด้ง MooDeng ) Ver. แดนซ์โจ๊ะๆ ReMix BY [ ดีเจกิต รีมิกซ์ ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3krsyfWUeHU/mqdefault.jpg)
This Guy is like a typical sarkari Babu who knows all but does nothing.
Kiya Matlab
He inly knows to bribe terrorists
Offcourse u become pm n take a call he can only do wht gov does
It wasn't his call to make
Most incompetent spy master.
How
I can smell that too
Daulat should be in jail, not giving interviews to everyone. Shame on those who are offering this man a platform.
Then why ceasefire at LoC from 2021. 😂
Mfer should have been sacked after the hostages came home. Absolutely incompetent idiot.
@@MarvelousTitanZimmi spotted 🤮
The whole fault lies with the incompetent central leadership at that time. Everyone understands that. Bureaucrats can't act on their own they follow orders of elected ppl.
Sala after so many years, this former R&AW chief doesn't know anything.
Just listening to MR dulat answers one can feel how incompetent he is and this 🕵️ guy doesn’t even know that they had arms when the plane landed in Amritsar and to contradict his own answer he says it wud have been a blood bath in Amritsar airport even before this guy know whether hijackers have arms or knife with them and he whitewashes by saying its far better to release and get a negotiated settlement than a Amritsar storming without even realizing that the guy they released had killed 10x the number of indians than the ones in the hijacked flight
This mf Dulat was heading the intelligence but didn't have anything before this terrible thing happened. What this mf was doing? In our country there is no accountability. This guy should be sacked. Intel failure . 😊
He is such cowherd not taking any responsibility India will never be safe till we have such a diplomat
I wont even allow this guy to walk my dog.....forget about being intelligence Chief of India.....What caliber of people we appoint for our Intelligence agencies....
Agree
Barkha - Why don’t you do a candid episode on 26/11 covering (1) why it happened, (2) what were the lapses by Govt in handling it (3) Could it have been averted and (4) what is the role of media who are alleged to have given away vital information concerning NSG Commondos under the guise of investigative journalism. Be truthful without trying to defend your role also. It had inadvertently given away vital clues to the terrorists and their command control at Karachi. I know that wasn't your intention but you need to come out clear by admitting lapses of you and few other hyper journalistson that day. I remember Shoba De screaming on the tv asking politicians not to indulge in showing make- belief concerns but to stay away and allow NSG and police to tackle without hindrance
True that
He is "aman ki asha" type and sympathetic to kashmiri terrorists.
What was the BJP doing?
Because of Masood Azhar we faced 26/11
@@anujsethi7845 I just stated what I know about Dulat. Your question is good one too.
@@gsge who left Azhar not daulat it was BJP
@@anujsethi7845abe brain washed child 26/11 is also pakistani plot masood azhar is only mukota if he was not there also they will do.
@@sunilshetty1533abe danghar kya tere bai plain me hota to to yahi bolta.
If such people are at the helm of affairs, you can easily predict the outcome of the negotiations.
Barkha doesn't let Dulat complete sentences. She assumes what he is going to say, and frames the next question which is tangential to what Dulat was going to say. Any other interviewer would have teased out a more complete and satisfying interview from Mr Dulat. Such a waste!
@@Lets_Be_Real_UK that's because she has prepared set of questions like Rahul Gandhy who has prepared set of answered whatever be the question 😂😂
Quite ironical that the person responsible for letting the handlers of 26/11 know locations of the terrorists is now asking questions about national security in an interview!
@@pmurthy431 Like Narendra Modi bol, jo reharse karke atan hain. Ja, tu thoda break le-le gomutra pine-se, bloody gawar, 2 rupees troll, aka andha-bhakt
You can easily see if these guys are in chief position, nothing more can be expected. And the show is done without watching the series....its basic. Only God have saved India from these guys.
No need to watch a hogwash series to discuss the real hijacking’s from the people who were dealing with it. This show was not so much about the crappy series that nutcase abubhav sinha made. It’s about what really happened at that time straight from the men in charge. What do you don’t understand ??
Ah Mr.DULAT , the ISI Mole in India
Then why ceasefire at LoC from 2021. 😂
He made vajayee fool all the time
May be vaajpay was the spy. You do know he was born in Pakistan right?
@@anziff Maybe you were born there too
@@neutral456 I was not but I know you were.
Useless officer, after so many years he still has not gone into details and he is given instansaes of a net flix series, shameful
Really, he was R&W chief 🥺🥺 and doesn't know what kind of weapon terrorist carried.
Shame on you sir daulat.
If this similar incident happened in any other part of the world their intelligence agency had figured out the number of bullet .
If Ajit Doval had said the same you would have praised it
@@Mehwish-bringsTruth
Look , I don't think it's about person. I don't even considered who is saying.
I have just raise a legitimate question being R&W chief he had obliged to figured out all those stuff. Doesn't matter if doval was in his shoes I too have raised it. Especially, In that period of time our R&W had a flop show they didn't succeed to take out crucial Intel.
He was IB chief not RAW chief that time. Brijest Mishra was RAQ chief.
@@ashfaqrather6781
He was r&w chief at that time.
His tenure started in 1999 and lasted to 2000.
The RAW chief appeared incompetent and unaware of the situation. How could he fail to communicate with the pilot and remain uncertain about whether the hijacker had a weapon? He seemed to be merely following procedures while the pilot communicated with ATC. A commission of inquiry should be established to investigate this mishap thoroughly.
I don't understand why the fellow is either so overwhelmed or overly supportive of Pakistan, always using "Insha'Allah" in every communication.I initially had a good opinion of Mr. Vajpayee's government, but it seems they were just part of the typical indecisive Indian system.I can confidently say that if this had happened under Modi, the outcome would have been different. Mark my words, the people of India will remember and deeply appreciate Modi's courage and decisiveness after his retirement.
Even the prime minister at that time was an idiot.
The REAL QUESTION which needs debate is how a spate of terrorist attacks & bomb blasts in India continued for a long time and HOW it has now almost completely stopped [except in Kashmir] ALMOST AS IF A TAP WAS SHUT!
What was enabling it earlier? What has stopped it now since 2014?
What has the NDA done that the UPA didn't?
Major terrorist attack has stopped after 26/11. After 26/11, we have handled border situation in East very well without any PR
Our forces are smart enough to handle situations. Yes, it's true top leadership at both political & bureaucracy class hesitate a lot in taking up a decision. Either it's not taken or taken after a good amount of delay
The latest example is of the Puja Khedkar case where the DoPT took the entire 4 months to expel her from service while being an open & shut case
Terrorism in general was at its peak from 2000s to 2010 .... world intelligence exchange has improved significantly and world over successful terrorism attacks have stopped! Everything is not about NDA vs UPA
On the other hand why are gangsters like Lawrence Bishnoi able to operate openly from jails ?
The security system underwent complete overhaul after 29/11. Chithamparum took over as the Home minister ( from his usual portfolios of finance and commerce, in which he used to be ultra efficient). A new security system under the lines of US interior security was developed, with quite a lot hand holding from the US government. This was a game changer. One has to know history before bluffing on ‘seeming’ correlation. The US security system after the 9/11 was quite proactive - this was documented by scholar like Amitava Kumar. Indian security system after 29/11 is modelled on this.
Kitna dhakkan hain be tu? Pulawama kya tha? 2019 comes after 2014. Another shameless andjha-bhakt aka 2-rupees troll. challl, godi-media dekh jake. Aur school-me admission le phir.
Fools were there leading the our security agencies like dulat
Can’t remember a more incompetent spy chief. His performance in Kashmir, Punjab, Sri Lanka were abysmal failures. ‘I still don’t know whether they had arms’ what a claim to make.
the life of spy chief is not open in public to warrant a judgement .. unless u r an exceptions..
Please don't blame the bureaucracy when you have incompetent political bosses. They can't even talk openly about politicians of then even now!
YOU SAID IT!
I think these guys were pretending to bribe the Kashmiris, without any evidence that radicalism, separatism & violence went down by a notch. They may all have been in cahoots with the Kashmiris & Pakistanis for all you know.
He is being honest. And it’s ok for you commenting in social media on hindsight after 20 years ? I would love to see what arm chair critics would if you were in their shoes at that difficult moment ? Pls stop being immature and childish. These are best of the best professionals and you just have to hear them out. You don’t have the competence nor the skills to criticize these men who have gone through so much and have served India with full commitment. You should be ashamed.
When a "WOKE KING" become R&AW chief
The anchor has not seen the series and is discussing it. What arrogance to discuss the issue without seeing it.
She was reporting this incident in 1999. Had inside stories then. Those days journalists were really having inside info.
She knew nothing. Very clear from the interview
@@shubchattKnows much more than you for sure. BTW why worry as you have boycotted Metflix 😅
@@shubchatt Her questions were very good, why the fuck you criticize
If you are running an interview at least see the series and then you would have asked more pertinent questions which were very important. Missed opportunity I think. So frustrating from viewers point of view…..
There is no second thought, once plane landed in Amritsar it should not have been let to take off no matter what!!
would you let your mother , father die in that plane , once commandos start attacking it in amritsar ??
Indian citizens should remember face of this guy, Mr dullat. He is the man who convinced Delhi that peace cab be brought to kashmir by negotiations. His policies brought Mumbai 2008 attack. All patriotic Indians should make sure that people like him do not reach in meaningful positions.
You mean to say none of these guys interacted with the passengers once they returned.. Moreover with one of their own in the aircraft.. Such a Shame.. Why is Dulat doing this interview.. Why is Barkha not asking him tough questions as she does to the opposition politicians..
Barkha is one of the dulat gang.they share the same ideology which is border line treason..spouting wokeism while Hindus pay the price with their lives.at best they are useful idiots of the left/jihadi combine or they are so selfish that they will sell the country for self gain.
On page 7 of Chapter 1 of Capt. Devi Sharan's book, he describes his first impression when a hijacker entered the cockpit, writing, "What I noticed immediately were the pistol and hand grenade he was carrying." It is shocking to hear Mr. Dulat express uncertainty about whether the hijackers had any weapons on them, suggesting they might have obtained them in Lahore.
He thinks Musharaf was our real friend OMG tomorrow he is going to say Haffez sayyed is our best friend
He was vajpayee's special advisor. Post SAARC Kathmandu, vajpayee and Musharraf started talking again and there was some peace at the borders.
This senior official who was in the negotiating team, never read the book written by the pilot and to this day doesn’t know if gins were on board in Amritsar! Amazing how ignorant and non curious this person is! My God
Fail to understand why Barkha is swol having not even seen the series. She is doing programs each day. Strange days of journalism..
When you haven’t watched the series hosting multiple interviews doesn’t make sense. Someone in the team should probably watch the series and give Barkha Ma’am the jist of the series.
Really disappointed that both the host and guests have been debating a series they haven’t watched COMPLETELY. The point of the whole show is defeated. We appreciate the information but the basis of the program is on loose foundation.
Totally agree! One panelist only had watched the entire series and made most sense.
He was the RAW chief..ask him why he failed ???
The paralysis in the control room which was responsible for the goof up at Amritsar airport was most likely due to the fact that the brother-in-law of N K Singh was on board. This is the professional caliber of the people in power in India, As far as killings in the plane are concerned, well how many have the three terrorists killed in India since they were released? I'm amazed at the unprofessionalism of Dulat.
I thought so too.😢
Barkha, the least you can do is to watch the series before doing these shows on on this subject matter. You jump into so many conclusions without having the basic information.
This fiasco should lead to declassifying all the Minutes of meeting, documents, classified ones after a certain period.. The people of this country have every right to know what transpired at RAW , IB, PMO, south block, north block, etc etc. Or else we will just need to believe such guys who wiill write some books at retirement.
what appalls me is that such a veteran does not know even today that they had guns or not. Did they not debrief the passengers, the pilot? this is the reason why such things happen to this country. We entrust our security to people who even today don't learn from their mistakes
Since vaajpay and BJP did not have a spine at that time we had suffer on 26/11
How are such people allowed in RAW? Look at his body language; he doesn't meet the standard at all.
Dulat doctrine is all about appeasement... And is one reason why Kashmir became such a big problem😢😢
Question: "Is it a complete whitewashing?" Answer: "No, No. But I haven't seen the whole series but I don't think so..." If you didn't see the series, why say No it's not a whitewashing?
And he wrote a book in collaboration with ISI chief
If you are still not sure there were weapons in plane what was tomar doing there???
The one thing we must be grateful for to the makers of the OTT “IC 814” is that a forgotten incident is evoking such analyses and discussion!
Incompitence !!!!! Reson why India is still poor.
That's why I have dislike for coalition Govt. They are not strong and also so full of contradiction. I can digest the fact that those prisoners were released, but its difficult for me to comprehend that these who were planned this were not taken down later...
7:33 : If Taliban was neutral, why did they put up anti aircraft guns to foil an NSG attempt ro carry out an Entebbe - like ope ration? They could have actually helped the NSG.
two people who have not watched the movie/series discussing about it:)
Barkha I have followed u from kargil days & I tell these all high profile political people want to rub each other back and don't want to set a precedence for themselves to be caught in a catch 22 situation just like Rubaiya. Till 2014 no one wanted to hit the nail on its head
This Gentle Man has written a book with ISI Chief..😡.
So?
It's not personal
@@anshuraj4277 You should watch other interview. This guy kept Kashmir on fire for decades.
@@vikku_19 why didn't vajpayee fire him then
@@anshuraj4277 Sood was Raw chief not dulat. I'm talking about late nineties when dulat had contacts with militants of j&k. When kandhar happened he is just an advisor of pm.
@@vikku_19 so having contact with militant was his job
All I am saying is if he was so bad and evil
Why didn't vajpayee Fire him from whatever post he was on and have him arrested
How one does an interview without even watching the show. It's pathetic when even serious journalists do this. Please don't downgrade your standards. You were widely respected for your work at one point in time!
She is going through the motions....
That's why it's imperative for countries to have clear cut policies on terrorism. India paid for having infirm minds and confusion. I'm not a fan of Dulat.
Barkha please don't expose indian incompetence by interviewing such people who don't no details after so long. He doesn't have the need to case study for future mishaps. This person is not the one who's blood will boil.
I appreciate his honesty to acknowledge how inefficient and lazy these officials were who just got frozen when the time demanded them to show their grit to save their nation :(
God save india. With such fools in important position
He seems so shockingly indifferent. Such a useless discussion though liked barkha's line of questioning.
This Dulat is sickeningly vicious. Cant be trusted.....this guys shouldnt never been NSA
You mean after it was all over, Captain Devi Sharan/the passengers were never asked by the investigators if the terrorists had ammunition? Is this really the RAW chief speaking?
Barkha is doing back to back programs on this ic814 issue…. Without watching the series…. I find that strange… aren’t you supposed to study the subject before you discuss it …. I also find it strange that the survivors who witnessed everything… aren’t being called … or why nobody wants to say what the truth was…!!
She was a very famous reporter then so she knows more about the incident than the series. Plus I'm sure she's read the book the series is based on and other available literature
@@Benaam007-z5s ya sure then she should say so … instead on mentioning in every program she does .. that I hv not seen the series yet ..!
I think to protect one highly connected officer (tomar)the whole IPS ,IAS lobby played with innocent people in the flight and gave away easy chances like stopping the flight from taking off in Amritsar and in-fact they exchanged a dreaded terrorist who came back and wreak havoc in india and still dng it
Its just the IPS-IAS lobby and all the rulers bend for this lobby
Once upon a time there was pet who’s name was GOOFY 🙈✌️
He has been on the helm of affairs and if he doesnt know even now whether they had arms or not then clearly he shouldnt be in the position he was in.
RAW is no comparison to ISI
If the same episode happens today how ready is our system ? Have we learnt from this episode ?
Both anti nationals so happy. 😂 vande Mataram
If Punjab police was ready to stromed, Vajpayee is to be blamed to allowed the plane out of Amritsar.
IB and he doesn't have the feed from the pilot to ATC if the hijackers had automatic weapons from Nepal to Amritsar.... really scary...when he says he doesn't even know this day ...after the multiple debriefs they would have done of all on board including his elderly friend who got off in Dubai.... really incompetent people at the realm of affairs...as he said himself "good friends who get positions not competence"..
Barkha you should watch the series first and then conduct these series of interviews.
Strange how a professional like you is doing this.
Wonderful program Barkha!!
The releases of dreaded terrorist as deal always puzzling my mind.
Whether the civilians life is more precious than our security forces?
Being a civilian I wonder when it come to sacrificing for your nation seems it’s only for citizens who joined security forces!!!
Barkha rightly pointed out we’re afraid about the casualties that time and there after these terrorists gave us more casualties than then would have.
I personally consider the decision of our government and not taking timely action was weak and lethargic systems. Mr. Dullat looks me a man at job as kk Menon was in 1962 China war
Pls read it as V k Menon
Musharaf cheated BJP government that time . Because their agenda Ram mandir. No matter Pulwama happend, Cargill happend many army personnel died due these two major and same time Bombay blast etc. I am worrying in future if BJP will continue in power.
Netflix should have made a webseries on united flight 93. Although situations can't help, it would have been truly inspiring for all of us specifically... instead of reminding bittersweet past of IC814.
This guy was unfit to be in the service. And it was a total failure of vajpayee government, azar created havoc since his release
An incompetent drunk.
I really liked this interview 😅.. He seems honest. Also, I agree with him about the movie. I watched it and i feel this movie is about the passengers 😅
Incapable officer
Poor Rupin! And a heartfelt salute to his parents 🙏
He did nit even think of meeting Devi Sharan to understand whether hijackers were armed or not. Totally useless man.
Why do you make a 1 hr video without seeing the series
Excellent program Barkha. You have a real class especially when you are neutral.
If you think Taliban were not involved then you are the biggest fool.
I stopped watching the series after 1.5 episodes out of humiliation. So incompetent, indecisive government intelligence authorities. After seeing so many big shots involved handling the situation, it was like 'Too many cooks spoil the broth'.
You have a waiter like Dulat this is the outcome. He doesn't know whether they had guns...he "escorts" Azhar without even seeing him. What, if the wrong man had been released from jail? This cartoon was not just a delivery boy..he was a dumb & incompetent delivery boy.
But in interview with Richa the captain clearly said that the hijacker had put a gun on neck when he asked him to fly to Kabul before landing in Amritsar.
What a combination? Doval and Barkha....Both are known for their soft glove on Pak.
Watch the damn thing barkha, before you go on about it
Barkha Dutt has not seen the series but conducts an interview with Duval on the Netflix serial the plane hijack !!! That's Barkha Dutt type of journalism!!!! That's the type of journalism today's journalists are practicing!!
the conversation is about real life, not reel life.
@@mojostory Then why even mention Netflix in thumb nail ???
He was not in ic814 .so how can he know .😊
If that time Congress was in power. I am telling you today BJP loudly blame Gandhi family belongs to Pakistan not Indian. Inspiet and fact Congree regime these hard core terrorist realised. Thankfull to God today Gandhi family safe and humiliation.
Bharkha ji,
Hijacking of IC814 in 1999 & kargil war reflected the failure of intelligence & security system at that time.The political indecisiveness and immaturity was the root cause. Not stopping, storming the plane at Amritsar & release of big terrorists was a damaging political decision. Had it been taken by Congress or other government, the RSS and BJP would have made it a very big and long lasting issue like kashmir.
Any question she asked this ex RAW chief he says i dont know, i am not sure etc etc. Benched to RAW chief bana tha mujra karne ke liye????
What a shame ! It shows that we didn’t have a clear authority to take decisions
How ridiculous! Dulat ji! You were responsible for such a serious decision making and even after the event, you never met the pilots, crew, and passengers? You did not read any of the books written by Pilot Devi Sharan, book by Flight engineer Anil Jaggia and Saurabh Shukla, and book by flight purser Anil Sharma and official Ajit Doval? Not one of them? Where is your conscience? Your intelligence failed, at least to know how hostages suffered and to avoid such mishaps in the future you could have got useful insights?
They did not conduct a debrief???? This is a basic requirement after such event
Something very fishy i smell after this interview
They can’t even know now if there were guns or not????
They don’t know if money was demanded
What lies and rumors go around???
And people will believe the lies and drama in the film
Why are people reluctant to admit watching the series? Where even people who have watched it seem to known what was depicted don’t want to admit it?
I think barkha has lost mind as she is doing the show w/o seeing the series which has been made with fantastically accurate and very professionally directed.Every time we all get a paralytic attack when it’s time to take decisions.
Let him complete...there is question after question.....
I am quite surprised that Farooq resisted releasing the terrorists. I thought he was one among the Pak ISI internal circle. If he really meant it, he seemed to be the wisest of all the incompetent people who handled this case.
Cheap media is nobodies' friend. If some of the hostages had died if the plane was stormed by Punjab police commandoes, then same Barkha Dutt would have questioned the operation. The role of Punjab CM was deplorable. Such decisions should entirely be with the professionals of NSG who should take over the command of such emergencies.
Truth of Amritsar will never be known.
Please don’t do an interview without seeing the series and your guest as well should as well !
This man is really difficult to be trusted... I had seen his view on 370...
Compromised person
Interesting... Thanks