I am Australian, and my ancestors are mainly Irish. I hear this song in 2022 and I grieve for my ancestors. They didn't all come out here like this song; but I understand a lot of history through this song. I live each day knowing the First Nations people of this land were treated no differently than the Irish. I am a rebel.
Like lots of us in Ireland, I moved to Australia during the 2008-2014 recession and was proud to meet Australian-Irish lads like yourself. Our cousins.
They gave us the best sailor in the world, William Brown, Admiral, creator of the Argentine Navy, father of the country, God bless you Irish, greetings from Argentina
Livebonbfo4 èvervandvever a great manbonebto by proud of hevgot theb4awvdeal but he wasvabthrough manbhe never broke ingoughtbtobthe ladtcseckondvge had noting left to fightvwith so he used the ladt thing he had sadly it costbhembhesblife
It's great that he died of hunger. it must have been fucking agony to commit suicide like that. And for nothing! Ireland is still Ireland and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is still that. He was a bit dim-witted, wasn't he? Like a silly Japanese kamikaze. What a silly boy.
I’m ashamed to say I’ve known this song for years, for most of my life but I’ve only just learned that Bobby Sands wrote it. Talk about a whole new meaning 👏👏👏 🇮🇪
no shame mate, but what a coincidence that while he suffered and starved himself he created something so strong and expressive. a real talent. Much respect..
Just found out from your comment. I used to live next door to the plough pub in Dublin and all rebel music would keep me awake all night as have lock ins next door. Didn't know it was boby sands that wrote it
Iv heard that songvavfuevtimesbovervthevyears on mebtravels imnonlyv40 now but have a lot of road covered I I heard great great menbsingbthat song but mot any of them could come nearvvhristybyevus
Not a revolution, a rebellion, totally different! We never needed a revolution, we know who we are. Revolutions are for people still trying to figure that out.
I think Bobby Sands used the classic folk process when he wrote it, and nicked the melody from what we now call a 'banger" of a tune. RIP both himself and Gordon
Love Christy Moore. My grandmother was Irish and although we are Australian my family has a saying when someone is being a victim or being badly treated and putting up with it. We say with passion. “They don’t have enough Irish in them”.
@@liammellows-hz3pf Haha, a song consists of a lyric and/or music, i.e. a tune so, technically, he is right . I get your point though and the advice is sound - Ride on, Trevor, Ride on!! ;)
We let a good man go- way too early- in the form of Bobby Sands (RIP) This song is a true legacy of his, Christy sings it, and I always see Bobby Sands face...epic stuff!
My dad born 100 years ago today West Coast South Australia ,our kin from West Coast Ireland,emigrated after the old man died in TheFamine,LongLiveTheIrish,ThsSpirit and the Music
Im in South Australia for 35 years but always a proud West Cork man , have connections on the west coast around Streaky Bay , and west coast of Cork , Kerry , Clare, California , Australia, Brittany , Spain. Guess I'm west coast man !!!
@@biffa1234100 Thanks man! I lived in Ireland for 10 years working my arse off during the day and learning to play jigs reels and rebel songs in pubs during the night.
Christy, your some man, you gave so much enjoyment in Ireland and around the world,, a credit to you,, you made history in my life.. Also thanks Bobby Sands ☘️☘️🇮🇪🇮🇪
Esta es una canción q a estas alturas se convirtió en el himno de Irlanda y x lo q veo hay cada vez mas amantes de este bellésima canción alrededor del mundo.La versión q mas me gusta el la de los: The Young Wolfe Tones.Tratá de escucharla,tiene mucha mas polenta.Espero ecnontrar una versión hecha x una banda militar.Hace poco sugerí,en un canal donde mostraba la fragata Libertad llegando a Irlanda,q tocaran esa canción,te asegura q sorprendería mucho a los irlandeses.No sé si conocés la canción homenaje hecha x los Wolfe Tones a Guillermo Brown.si no la conocés,la encontrás fácil como Homenaje a Guillermo Brown o Tribute to Admiral William Brown.Saludos y Erin go bragh!!!
Did not realize myself that Irish Patriot Bobby Sands wrote this fine Song 🌿🙏🌿 he and the other more than Brave young Men who give their Lives rather than give in to War Criminals Thatcher & Co 🙏💯🙏
This song is beautifully sublime and makes me pleasantly proud of my Da's history from Indiana, Illinois where resides the great college of Notre Dame. May God bless you always you lads and lassies, I love you to the tears that are filled with the salt that keeps our people from seein' as the very angels in Heaven do.
Bobby Sands wrote the lyrics for this based off the tune of Gordon Lightfoot's song The Edmund Fitzgerald. What you're seeing here is Christie Moore's rendition.
Of my 8 Great Grandparents 5 of them were Irish. At least of 2 of them were covints; as was one of my Scottish ancestors. We have a big problem in Australia with the circumstances of our First Nations people. Our country, mostly doesn't understand colonization. Our recent referendum about our First Nations people having a voice to Parliament made me feel so ashamed. I guess I will continue to be the rebel my ancestors came with.😡
@@Sionnach1601 Incorrect, Bobby Sands would be looking down with a massive smile on his face as we come closer to achieving our final goal as a progressive island which will include everyone, all religions and races United together. Onwards to a Socialist Republic! 🇮🇪🚩
I met this man called Cameron last week and thought I had nothing in common with him and the conversation went something like this Derry ,Christy Moore ,and Glasgow Celtic 🤗🇮🇪
I m a french but irish hearth too. Going in Eire every fucking hollidays. Irish are ours Republican friends. We, french, knowing what to do with monarchy.
Ireland had a monarchy. The Normans violently destroyed it. Yes, the French did have a habit of that sort of thing. I don’t think the Revolution, a bloody affair which consisted of removing the heads at a rate which would make an Islamist blush, was quite as glorious as modern France supposes.
A beautiful song I’m not surprised Bobby wrote it he was a ordinary lad happy go lucky loved football his people community came under attack what choice did he have unemployment the scrap heap or fight back.He was a working class lad against a Tory government sound familiar.Why is it every time they offer a solution to a political economic problem they get stinking rich you sell your house for next to nothing no matter if your Irish/British the facts speak for themselves.Anyone interested in purchasing worthless PPE gear I only want 30 million offshore of course.
God bless Bobby and his 9 brave comrades. Unbowed, unbroken, unrepentant! Tiocfaidh ar la 🇮🇪✊🏻
Adams is now A multimillionaire 🎉🎉🎉 follow the MONEY 🎉🎉🎉
Love this song with all my heart!!! Greetings from Mexico, irish brothers 🇮🇪🇮🇪☘️
Mexico amigos..Pancho Villa😉
Not forgetting St patricio's👍
Hello from Ireland 🇮🇪 💚
R.I.P. BOBBY SANDS T.A.L. FROM CANADA 🇮🇪☘️🇮🇪☘️
I am Australian, and my ancestors are mainly Irish. I hear this song in 2022 and I grieve for my ancestors. They didn't all come out here like this song; but I understand a lot of history through this song. I live each day knowing the First Nations people of this land were treated no differently than the Irish. I am a rebel.
Like lots of us in Ireland, I moved to Australia during the 2008-2014 recession and was proud to meet Australian-Irish lads like yourself. Our cousins.
The blood and heart runs strongly in you 👍☘💯
A rebel we came and we're still the same!
God bless ye lad
Today is the day....Not just a song..St. Patrick blesses us all. WALK with peace today!!!
They gave us the best sailor in the world, William Brown, Admiral, creator of the Argentine Navy, father of the country, God bless you Irish, greetings from Argentina
Awesome ❤
Thank u my argentine brother ❤ 🇮🇪 🇦🇷
The second Admiral. Yi Sun-sin was the best.
The Wolfe Tones Admiral William Brown is a great song too
Para nosotros Guillermo Brown es el primero, fue él quien creo la Armada Argentina y luchó por nuestra Independencia. @@StefanoDallAgata
RIP Bobby !!! You will forever live on and we are still listening in 2021!!! Respect to Christy Moore!!
Livebonbfo4 èvervandvever a great manbonebto by proud of hevgot theb4awvdeal but he wasvabthrough manbhe never broke ingoughtbtobthe ladtcseckondvge had noting left to fightvwith so he used the ladt thing he had sadly it costbhembhesblife
2023
It's great that he died of hunger. it must have been fucking agony to commit suicide like that. And for nothing! Ireland is still Ireland and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is still that. He was a bit dim-witted, wasn't he? Like a silly Japanese kamikaze. What a silly boy.
Bobby rubs shit on his walls
@@James-zt7nf Bobby Sands rubs shit in the face of his unionist enemies for ETERNITY..Hear it ring Sinn Fein 🤗
When the whole crowd just says together ‘ a rebel I came, I’m still the same’. Beautiful
And I’ll die the same
@@MulryanCarpentry89 and me comrades ghosts walk besides me
Christy Moore is an absolute legend, I wish he'd come to Canada so I can see him. Im tempted to jump on a plane to anywhere though.
"A rebel I came and I'm still the same" 🇮🇪💪
I’m ashamed to say I’ve known this song for years, for most of my life but I’ve only just learned that Bobby Sands wrote it. Talk about a whole new meaning 👏👏👏 🇮🇪
no shame mate, but what a coincidence that while he suffered and starved himself he created something so strong and expressive. a real talent. Much respect..
Christy has sung afew of bobby's songs
No Shame
Please don't feel bad, I lost my brother in October and learned so much about him from this song.😭 We learn about life every day😊
Just found out from your comment. I used to live next door to the plough pub in Dublin and all rebel music would keep me awake all night as have lock ins next door. Didn't know it was boby sands that wrote it
Kurd from Kurdistan salute you,
Biji Kurdistan!
A powerful song written by a man who died on hunger strike for his country..the ultimate sacrifice
Jesus Christ I’ve never seen a man sing a song with so much passion, powerful stuff!
Only discovering Christy now!?? Welcome to The Bard of Ireland!!
Iv heard that songvavfuevtimesbovervthevyears on mebtravels imnonlyv40 now but have a lot of road covered I I heard great great menbsingbthat song but mot any of them could come nearvvhristybyevus
❤
Christy Moore sang the song at the Marty McGuinness Funeral.
They have nothing to break the Irish rebels spirit Tiacfaidh ar la 🇮🇪
Long live the brave men and women of the Irish freedom movement, long live the revolution
I'm not sure if this song belongs to Australians or Irish. Its awesome either way.
Not a revolution, a rebellion, totally different!
We never needed a revolution, we know who we are. Revolutions are for people still trying to figure that out.
I'm Irish, but I'm also a Michigander, and this tune is the Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald
I certainly recognise strains of that exceptional track.
RIP Gordon.
You gave us some fantastic songs.
I think Bobby Sands used the classic folk process when he wrote it, and nicked the melody from what we now call a 'banger" of a tune. RIP both himself and Gordon
@@poorpaddy7803Based on what I read on wikipedia the Christy Moore Version is the first one to do it to the tune of The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald
When asked about it, Gordon Lightfoot said 'I always knew that was an old Irish tune'.
@@DM-GRPRTChristy has said recently that Bobby used to melody of wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald, two legends Bobby and Gordon
Gloria a Boby Danés y otros nueve camaradas que fallecieron en la segunda huelga de hambre😢😢😢😢😢
RIP Bobby , a nation salutes YOU , Tiocfaidh ar la !
Well done Bobby shit smear
Love Christy Moore. My grandmother was Irish and although we are Australian my family has a saying when someone is being a victim or being badly treated and putting up with it. We say with passion. “They don’t have enough Irish in them”.
We're all the same people! We've been split up, divided, forced to hate and kill each other for 2000 years! We're all over the world! All my love 🙏♥️🙋
Bobby Sands will never be forgotten
Rip Bobby sands you wrote some tune
You write a song,not a tune..Ride on Trevor..
@@liammellows-hz3pf Haha, a song consists of a lyric and/or music, i.e. a tune so, technically, he is right . I get your point though and the advice is sound - Ride on, Trevor, Ride on!! ;)
he didn't write the melody that was written by Gordon Lightfoot
LOL !! Music by Gordon Lightfoot - The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.
@@brendanpage3369 Lightfoot gave permission to Sands.
We let a good man go- way too early- in the form of Bobby Sands (RIP)
This song is a true legacy of his, Christy sings it, and I always see Bobby Sands face...epic stuff!
Agree Bobby was my mates cousin still heart broken never forget the sacrifice those 10 men made free Ireland 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪
Im from Derry but live in London.... God I miss it.... Beautiful place
Fuck off back then, we wont miss you
I love this song forever! R.I.P. Bobby Sands 🇮🇪💚☘️✨🙏
My dad born 100 years ago today West Coast South Australia ,our kin from West Coast Ireland,emigrated after the old man died in TheFamine,LongLiveTheIrish,ThsSpirit and the Music
Im in South Australia for 35 years but always a proud West Cork man , have connections on the west coast around Streaky Bay , and west coast of Cork , Kerry , Clare, California , Australia, Brittany , Spain. Guess I'm west coast man !!!
@@patrickmanning3118how does being away for so long affect how you feel about Ireland?
Top class, I'm home in Derry now. Feels great listening to this. Send it on! Rebel I came, I'm still the same!
God Bless you Bobby Sands MP 🇮🇪✊🏻
When I hear this song I am proud to be Irish even though I'm from Poland.
thats the best comment on here Kamil, and I know what you mean brother.x
@@biffa1234100 Thanks man! I lived in Ireland for 10 years working my arse off during the day and learning to play jigs reels and rebel songs in pubs during the night.
@@kamilfiryndo yo play gaa
@@Uptheroyals80 bollocks! You got me there, im not Irish 😐
Up the Deise!
@@kamilfiryn you live in Waterford?
Christy, your some man, you gave so much enjoyment in Ireland and around the world,, a credit to you,, you made history in my life.. Also thanks Bobby Sands ☘️☘️🇮🇪🇮🇪
Erin go bragh!! Up de Ra! Greetings for Argentina!! Amazing song!
Esta es una canción q a estas alturas se convirtió en el himno de Irlanda y x lo q veo hay cada vez mas amantes de este bellésima canción alrededor del mundo.La versión q mas me gusta el la de los: The Young Wolfe Tones.Tratá de escucharla,tiene mucha mas polenta.Espero ecnontrar una versión hecha x una banda militar.Hace poco sugerí,en un canal donde mostraba la fragata Libertad llegando a Irlanda,q tocaran esa canción,te asegura q sorprendería mucho a los irlandeses.No sé si conocés la canción homenaje hecha x los Wolfe Tones a Guillermo Brown.si no la conocés,la encontrás fácil como Homenaje a Guillermo Brown o Tribute to Admiral William Brown.Saludos y Erin go bragh!!!
Erin go bragh!! All my love from Occitania!
😊 the 410 😮 xxxx
This song brings tears to my eyes, a great song , sung by a great musician.
I am praying today!!! Good old 🇮🇪!!!!! We won. God is on our side!!!!!
I am not irish but I feel broken my heart when hear this song...Eire go Bragh
Sang at my mum’s funeral a woman of Derry ❤
Downy
10 months later and I am still listening . One of the best songs ever written and so powerful lyrically.
rest in power bobby sands. the true hero of the troubles!
Did not realize myself that Irish Patriot Bobby Sands wrote this fine Song 🌿🙏🌿 he and the other more than Brave young Men who give their Lives rather than give in to War Criminals Thatcher & Co 🙏💯🙏
Good man Christy. RIP Bobby Sands. You were some man for one man.
A beautiful song that manages to capture a rare combination of rebellion and homesickness.
This song is beautifully sublime and makes me pleasantly proud of my Da's history from Indiana, Illinois where resides the great college of Notre Dame. May God bless you always you lads and lassies, I love you to the tears that are filled with the salt that keeps our people from seein' as the very angels in Heaven do.
Love from America 🙏🇺🇸
What a genius of a songwriter and performer. Takes me back years . May he continue to grace the stages of Ireland for many more years
Bobby Sands wrote the lyrics for this based off the tune of Gordon Lightfoot's song The Edmund Fitzgerald. What you're seeing here is Christie Moore's rendition.
2022 and you know what you have to do. Love this song so much. Bobby is a legend in history.
Love this live version 🇮🇪
Love this song. it makes me cry.
All the best from Western Australia.
Christy Moore always sings with great passion
Of my 8 Great Grandparents 5 of them were Irish. At least of 2 of them were covints; as was one of my Scottish ancestors. We have a big problem in Australia with the circumstances of our First Nations people. Our country, mostly doesn't understand colonization. Our recent referendum about our First Nations people having a voice to Parliament made me feel so ashamed. I guess I will continue to be the rebel my ancestors came with.😡
A rebel I came I'm still the same 🇮🇪
RIP Bobby Sands a hero who stood up to the bastards.
And who would turn in his grave to know that Christy is now against the free speech of the Irish and those who want to keep Ireland Irish.
@@Sionnach1601 Incorrect, Bobby Sands would be looking down with a massive smile on his face as we come closer to achieving our final goal as a progressive island which will include everyone, all religions and races United together. Onwards to a Socialist Republic! 🇮🇪🚩
He’s deed not for the Greed.
@@eoin3853 Only a fully vaxxed c**t could put on a comment like that .Straight out of the globalist handbook.
What a beautiful song. Well sung and played.
Back again. This is my anthem!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I met this man called Cameron last week and thought I had nothing in common with him and the conversation went something like this Derry ,Christy Moore ,and Glasgow Celtic 🤗🇮🇪
By choice or not the Irish made it to every corner of the World and even the Moon 🙂
This Ones for my special friend....ancestors left their native shore for a better life in the United States 🇺🇸 an that was a love song..........❤❤❤
God this brings tears to my eyes. Love ya Christy.
Bobby Sands your a Legend.
05/05/1981
05/05/2021
40 years gone
RIP Bobby
The Bravest of the Brave 🇮🇪✊
I love this song 💚
Hail Hail from Glasgow ..Celtic
Grew up in Derry, Pennsylvania. That other Derry across the pond seems a lot cooler 🤙
Went there in 2018.
Back this year.
Back home.
R.I.P BOBBY, loved for eternity unlike the modern day cromwell Thatcher. TAL
I was up there on a tour before it was my first time there nice city
Famous song sang, with meaning and history,,, beautiful
God bless MP Bobby Sands 🇮🇪☘️🇮🇪
RIP Bobby
class song thanks Bobby a true hero RIP
What a song 🇮🇪
Bobby sands true Irish hero 💚🤍🧡☘☘
OUTSTANDING 🇺🇲🐸☘️🇮🇪
beautiful, derry
Great song. Up South armagh
funfeckingtastic!! Greetings from St.Pauli!!
RIP, Bobby Sands. Tiocfaidh ár lá!
Proud Derry man 👌🍀
God bless u bobby sand🍀
Saw when they played this at Martin McGuinness' funeral. Unforgettable.
Can't mistake the Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald influence. What a good song.
Great melody. Great choice.
IRELAND how à so little Land May incluse a so great nation....
Greetings from Italy.
I m a french but irish hearth too. Going in Eire every fucking hollidays. Irish are ours Republican friends. We, french, knowing what to do with monarchy.
Mussolini didn't say that did he
Ireland had a monarchy. The Normans violently destroyed it.
Yes, the French did have a habit of that sort of thing.
I don’t think the Revolution, a bloody affair which consisted of removing the heads at a rate which would make an Islamist blush, was quite as glorious as modern France supposes.
@@claremargarettherese you are watching Revolution things with your 21 centuries glasses
To the Hunger Strikers who never surrendered.....may you all rest in peace
Oooohhhh oohhhh oooh oooooh I wish I was back home in Derry!!!!
This song reminds me of some one previous to me
Love your music
💗✌💙💙💙💙✌✌✌✌
legend
Yes, Bobby,,,,,God rest your soul,,,
My eyes are walking up to alot!! Wow! Jesus is my LORD and saviour! 🙏♥️😭
A beautiful song I’m not surprised Bobby wrote it he was a ordinary lad happy go lucky loved football his people community came under attack what choice did he have unemployment the scrap heap or fight back.He was a working class lad against a Tory government sound familiar.Why is it every time they offer a solution to a political economic problem they get stinking rich you sell your house for next to nothing no matter if your Irish/British the facts speak for themselves.Anyone interested in purchasing worthless PPE gear I only want 30 million offshore of course.
One of the best songs ever written about transpiration or Australia.
God bless you Bobby Sands
I was listening to Gordon Lightfoot singing the wreck of the Edward Fitzgerald, and the air is almost identical to this song.
True, it is.
Bobby sands is from rathcoul ?
Wish I was back home in Bangor
big respect!!!
Long live Free Ireland!
remember this in these times
Still listening christy in 2023
This is a Gordon Lightfoot Melody!🤓
Yup
@@thephantomeagle2The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald.
This is sang in the melody of Gordon Lightfoot - The Wreck of The Edmund Fitzgerald
Isn't this the melody of "Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" by Gordon Lightfoot?!?
Certainly seems like it.
Yes, it is.
Yes, used with permission